On 3/10/2026 2:25 am, RonO wrote:
On 10/1/2026 8:49 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 2/10/2026 11:13 am, RonO wrote:
On 10/1/2026 3:42 PM, RonO wrote:
You're playing the man and not the ball.
Whatever the case may be with ID, the origin of life presents real and growing challenges for materialism [...]
On 10/5/26 4:31 AM, MarkE wrote:
On 3/10/2026 2:25 am, RonO wrote:
On 10/1/2026 8:49 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 2/10/2026 11:13 am, RonO wrote:
On 10/1/2026 3:42 PM, RonO wrote:
You're playing the man and not the ball.
Whatever the case may be with ID, the origin of life presents real and
growing challenges for materialism [...]
You keep using that phrase. I do not think it means what you think it
means.
A millennium ago, people had not the foggiest idea that a materialist
origin of life was possible, much less how to accomplish it. A century
ago, a materialist mechanism of shaping and diversifying life was know,
and enough of chemistry and biology were known to make a materialist
origin of life plausible, even if the mechanism was still unknown. A
decade ago, chemical mechanisms for forming the components of life were known, even if we don't know how all of them could happen in nature.
Clearly, the origin of life presents a real and *shrinking* challenge
for materialism.
On 26/10/2026 6:11 am, Mark Isaak wrote:
A millennium ago, people had not the foggiest idea that a materialist
origin of life was possible, much less how to accomplish it. A century
ago, a materialist mechanism of shaping and diversifying life was
know, and enough of chemistry and biology were known to make a
materialist origin of life plausible, even if the mechanism was still
unknown. A decade ago, chemical mechanisms for forming the components
of life were known, even if we don't know how all of them could happen
in nature.
Clearly, the origin of life presents a real and *shrinking* challenge
for materialism.
My invitation from 18 October stands: Feel free to respond to the
science in my post "Hats off to DD (2026)".
On 26/10/2026 6:11 am, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/5/26 4:31 AM, MarkE wrote:
On 3/10/2026 2:25 am, RonO wrote:
On 10/1/2026 8:49 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 2/10/2026 11:13 am, RonO wrote:
On 10/1/2026 3:42 PM, RonO wrote:
You're playing the man and not the ball.
Whatever the case may be with ID, the origin of life presents real
and growing challenges for materialism [...]
You keep using that phrase. I do not think it means what you think it
means.
A millennium ago, people had not the foggiest idea that a materialist
origin of life was possible, much less how to accomplish it. A century
ago, a materialist mechanism of shaping and diversifying life was
know, and enough of chemistry and biology were known to make a
materialist origin of life plausible, even if the mechanism was still
unknown. A decade ago, chemical mechanisms for forming the components
of life were known, even if we don't know how all of them could happen
in nature.
Clearly, the origin of life presents a real and *shrinking* challenge
for materialism.
My invitation from 18 October stands: Feel free to respond to the
science in my post "Hats off to DD (2026)".
W Saint Augustine was
not a flat earther, but he was one of the Church Fathers who used the
Bible to support geocentrism.
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 07:29:28 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
W Saint Augustine was
not a flat earther, but he was one of the Church Fathers who used the
Bible to support geocentrism.
No, he didn't. You really need to learn to check things out before
posting utter rubbish based on your own imbedded biases. Your beloved
Google AI would have told you:
<quote>
Saint Augustine of Hippo showed indifference toward the shape and
mechanics of the physical cosmos, famously asking: "What concern is it
to me whether the heavens as a sphere enclose the earth in the middle
of the world or overhang it on either side?"
Augustine's Approach to Astronomy and Science
o Indifference to Cosmology: Augustine did not treat astronomical
models (such as geocentrism versus alternative arrangements) as a core
matter of Christian faith.
o Prioritizing Scripture Without Dogmatizing Science: He warned
Christians against making rash, unscientific claims based on a
literalist reading of the Bible that could embarrass the faith when contradicted by clear reason or observation. In The Literal Meaning of Genesis, he argued that non-believers should not hear Christians
talking nonsense about physical science while citing Scripture.
o Humility in Interpretation: Later theologians, such as John Calvin,
drew directly on Augustine's hermeneutics to note that Scripture uses everyday, phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun
"rising"-to accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid
technical science.
</quote>
On 10/29/2026 11:06 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 07:29:28 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>You need to quit lying about reality. I noted that Saint Augustine
wrote:
W Saint Augustine was
not a flat earther, but he was one of the Church Fathers who used the
Bible to support geocentrism.
No, he didn't. You really need to learn to check things out before
posting utter rubbish based on your own imbedded biases. Your beloved
Google AI would have told you:
<quote>
Saint Augustine of Hippo showed indifference toward the shape and
mechanics of the physical cosmos, famously asking: "What concern is it
to me whether the heavens as a sphere enclose the earth in the middle
of the world or overhang it on either side?"
Augustine's Approach to Astronomy and Science
o Indifference to Cosmology: Augustine did not treat astronomical
models (such as geocentrism versus alternative arrangements) as a core
matter of Christian faith.
o Prioritizing Scripture Without Dogmatizing Science: He warned
Christians against making rash, unscientific claims based on a
literalist reading of the Bible that could embarrass the faith when
contradicted by clear reason or observation. In The Literal Meaning of
Genesis, he argued that non-believers should not hear Christians
talking nonsense about physical science while citing Scripture.
o Humility in Interpretation: Later theologians, such as John Calvin,
drew directly on Augustine's hermeneutics to note that Scripture uses
everyday, phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun
"rising"-to accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid
technical science.
</quote>
warned against using the Bible to deny what we could determine for our >selves, but he is one of the Church fathers noted for using the Bible to >support his geocentric views.
Google cites the references.
Google Quote:
You are correct.
To clarify, Saint Augustine did write within a
fundamentally geocentric worldview
and relied directly on Biblical
descriptions to outline how he believed the physical cosmos operated.
While he warned against making foolish claims that defied proven logic,
his actual commentaries on the text explicitly treated the Earth as >stationary and central, using Scripture to address astronomical mechanics.
Where Augustine Uses Scripture to Address Geocentric Concepts
o The Movement of the Heavens vs. a Stationary Earth: In De Genesi ad >litteram (The Literal Meaning of Genesis), Augustine grappled with the >prevailing scientific questions of his day. When discussing the creation
of celestial bodies in Genesis 1:14-16, he assumed a geocentric
architecture where the sun, moon, and stars orbited a fixed center.
o The Nature of the Firmament: In Book 2 of the same work, Augustine >meticulously analyzed Genesis 1:6 ("Let there be a firmament in the
midst of the waters"). He used this verse to debate the physical
properties of the heavens, addressing how the dome of the sky moves and
how water could be held above a spherical, central Earth without falling.
o Accommodating Earth's Immobility: Like other Scripture Catholic
historical figures, Augustine read references to the earth being >"established" (such as in the Psalms) as physical realities of its >immobility, even if he simultaneously argued that some descriptions of
size or light were tailored to human observation rather than absolute >spatial dimensions.
END Google Quote:
Google references:
Warning against foolish claims and the earth's immobility: >https://catholicscientists.org/articles/augustine-aquinas-and-calvin-on-the-size-of-the-moon-scripture-and-following-the-science/
Movement of the heavens:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Genesi_ad_litteram
He used the Bible to support his geocentric views of the cosmos. End of >that story. Like all the other Church fathers Augustine was a
geocentrist, and he is one of the Church fathers that used Bible verses
to support geocentrism. He knew that it was a stupid thing to do, but
he did it anyway.
Your lame stupidity about the Council of Trent requiring that the Church >fathers teach geocentrism is just lying to yourself because all the
Council of Trent required was unanimous consensus, and Augustine was one
of the Church fathers that actually could be considered to have used >scripture to teach geocentrism.
Like the historical Rabbis, Augustine also believed that the Biblical >firmament existed. He did not believe that the authors of the Bible had >presented the correct order of the 6 day creation in Genesis, but his >alternative would have also been found to be incorrect today.
On Thu, 29 Oct 2026 12:23:31 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 10/29/2026 11:06 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 07:29:28 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>You need to quit lying about reality. I noted that Saint Augustine
wrote:
W Saint Augustine was
not a flat earther, but he was one of the Church Fathers who used the
Bible to support geocentrism.
No, he didn't. You really need to learn to check things out before
posting utter rubbish based on your own imbedded biases. Your beloved
Google AI would have told you:
<quote>
Saint Augustine of Hippo showed indifference toward the shape and
mechanics of the physical cosmos, famously asking: "What concern is it
to me whether the heavens as a sphere enclose the earth in the middle
of the world or overhang it on either side?"
Augustine's Approach to Astronomy and Science
o Indifference to Cosmology: Augustine did not treat astronomical
models (such as geocentrism versus alternative arrangements) as a core
matter of Christian faith.
o Prioritizing Scripture Without Dogmatizing Science: He warned
Christians against making rash, unscientific claims based on a
literalist reading of the Bible that could embarrass the faith when
contradicted by clear reason or observation. In The Literal Meaning of
Genesis, he argued that non-believers should not hear Christians
talking nonsense about physical science while citing Scripture.
o Humility in Interpretation: Later theologians, such as John Calvin,
drew directly on Augustine's hermeneutics to note that Scripture uses
everyday, phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun
"rising"-to accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid
technical science.
</quote>
warned against using the Bible to deny what we could determine for our
selves, but he is one of the Church fathers noted for using the Bible to
support his geocentric views.
Google cites the references.
Google Quote:
You are correct.
A good example of asking a loaded question to get the answer you want.
To clarify, Saint Augustine did write within a
fundamentally geocentric worldview
Of course he did as geocentrism was the accepted paradigm of the time
by everyone, Christian and non-Christian, religious and non-religious.
Nobody had anything different to suggest since the Philolaus eight
centuries earlier and nobody would suggest anything different until Copernicus 12 centuries later. Why would Augustine have written in any
other context?
and relied directly on Biblical
descriptions to outline how he believed the physical cosmos operated.
As Calvin and other theologians pointed out, he was using everyday, phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun "rising"-to accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid technical
science.
While he warned against making foolish claims that defied proven logic,
his actual commentaries on the text explicitly treated the Earth as
stationary and central, using Scripture to address astronomical mechanics. >>
Where Augustine Uses Scripture to Address Geocentric Concepts
o The Movement of the Heavens vs. a Stationary Earth: In De Genesi ad
litteram (The Literal Meaning of Genesis), Augustine grappled with the
prevailing scientific questions of his day. When discussing the creation
of celestial bodies in Genesis 1:14-16, he assumed a geocentric
architecture where the sun, moon, and stars orbited a fixed center.
o The Nature of the Firmament: In Book 2 of the same work, Augustine
meticulously analyzed Genesis 1:6 ("Let there be a firmament in the
midst of the waters"). He used this verse to debate the physical
properties of the heavens, addressing how the dome of the sky moves and
how water could be held above a spherical, central Earth without falling.
o Accommodating Earth's Immobility: Like other Scripture Catholic
historical figures, Augustine read references to the earth being
"established" (such as in the Psalms) as physical realities of its
immobility, even if he simultaneously argued that some descriptions of
size or light were tailored to human observation rather than absolute
spatial dimensions.
END Google Quote:
Google references:
Warning against foolish claims and the earth's immobility:
https://catholicscientists.org/articles/augustine-aquinas-and-calvin-on-the-size-of-the-moon-scripture-and-following-the-science/
Movement of the heavens:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Genesi_ad_litteram
Allof which was written within the prevailing paradigm of the time and
none of which was intended to support geocentrism or had anything
whatsoever to do with faith or morals.
He used the Bible to support his geocentric views of the cosmos. End of
that story. Like all the other Church fathers Augustine was a
geocentrist, and he is one of the Church fathers that used Bible verses
to support geocentrism. He knew that it was a stupid thing to do, but
he did it anyway.
Your lame stupidity about the Council of Trent requiring that the Church
fathers teach geocentrism is just lying to yourself because all the
Council of Trent required was unanimous consensus, and Augustine was one
of the Church fathers that actually could be considered to have used
scripture to teach geocentrism.
Like the historical Rabbis, Augustine also believed that the Biblical
firmament existed. He did not believe that the authors of the Bible had
presented the correct order of the 6 day creation in Genesis, but his
alternative would have also been found to be incorrect today.
I really, really thought by now you would have wakened up to the fact
that your ideas about the Church Fathers and the Council of Trent were
formed by a crazy kook promoting geocentrism. Are you seriously not
bothered by the fact that you have still never been able to find a
reputable historian or scholar who agrees with him?
On 10/30/2026 5:46 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 29 Oct 2026 12:23:31 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 10/29/2026 11:06 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 07:29:28 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>You need to quit lying about reality. I noted that Saint Augustine
wrote:
W Saint Augustine was
not a flat earther, but he was one of the Church Fathers who used the >>>>> Bible to support geocentrism.
No, he didn't. You really need to learn to check things out before
posting utter rubbish based on your own imbedded biases. Your beloved
Google AI would have told you:
<quote>
Saint Augustine of Hippo showed indifference toward the shape and
mechanics of the physical cosmos, famously asking: "What concern is it >>>> to me whether the heavens as a sphere enclose the earth in the middle
of the world or overhang it on either side?"
Augustine's Approach to Astronomy and Science
o Indifference to Cosmology: Augustine did not treat astronomical
models (such as geocentrism versus alternative arrangements) as a core >>>> matter of Christian faith.
o Prioritizing Scripture Without Dogmatizing Science: He warned
Christians against making rash, unscientific claims based on a
literalist reading of the Bible that could embarrass the faith when
contradicted by clear reason or observation. In The Literal Meaning of >>>> Genesis, he argued that non-believers should not hear Christians
talking nonsense about physical science while citing Scripture.
o Humility in Interpretation: Later theologians, such as John Calvin,
drew directly on Augustine's hermeneutics to note that Scripture uses
everyday, phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun
"rising"-to accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid
technical science.
</quote>
warned against using the Bible to deny what we could determine for our
selves, but he is one of the Church fathers noted for using the Bible to >>> support his geocentric views.
Google cites the references.
Google Quote:
You are correct.
A good example of asking a loaded question to get the answer you want.
Why keep lying about the situation? The facts are just what they are.
Saint Augustine is known to be one of the Church fathers that used Bible >verses to support geocentrism. He was not only a geocentrist like all
the other Church fathers, but he taught geocentrism using the Bible, so
he qualifies as your lame excuse of the Church fathers needing to teach >instead of just agree with geocentrism. You lose with Augustine either way.
To clarify, Saint Augustine did write within a
fundamentally geocentric worldview
Of course he did as geocentrism was the accepted paradigm of the time
by everyone, Christian and non-Christian, religious and non-religious.
Nobody had anything different to suggest since the Philolaus eight
centuries earlier and nobody would suggest anything different until
Copernicus 12 centuries later. Why would Augustine have written in any
other context?
All the Council of Trent required was consensus. That is why the >Inquisition was able to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy, and why
the pope agreed with the inquisition in 1616 and condemned heliocentrism
and added heliocentric writings to the Index.
and relied directly on Biblical
descriptions to outline how he believed the physical cosmos operated.
As Calvin and other theologians pointed out, he was using everyday,
phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun "rising"-to
accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid technical
science.
It doesn't matter how others have tried to lie about the situation. >Augustine did what he did, end of that story. Augustine used the Bible
to support his geocentric beliefs. He understood that it was a stupid
thing to do, but he did it because he did not think that the Bible was
wrong about that aspect of nature.
While he warned against making foolish claims that defied proven logic,
his actual commentaries on the text explicitly treated the Earth as
stationary and central, using Scripture to address astronomical mechanics. >>>
Where Augustine Uses Scripture to Address Geocentric Concepts
o The Movement of the Heavens vs. a Stationary Earth: In De Genesi ad
litteram (The Literal Meaning of Genesis), Augustine grappled with the
prevailing scientific questions of his day. When discussing the creation >>> of celestial bodies in Genesis 1:14-16, he assumed a geocentric
architecture where the sun, moon, and stars orbited a fixed center.
o The Nature of the Firmament: In Book 2 of the same work, Augustine
meticulously analyzed Genesis 1:6 ("Let there be a firmament in the
midst of the waters"). He used this verse to debate the physical
properties of the heavens, addressing how the dome of the sky moves and
how water could be held above a spherical, central Earth without falling. >>>
o Accommodating Earth's Immobility: Like other Scripture Catholic
historical figures, Augustine read references to the earth being
"established" (such as in the Psalms) as physical realities of its
immobility, even if he simultaneously argued that some descriptions of
size or light were tailored to human observation rather than absolute
spatial dimensions.
END Google Quote:
Google references:
Warning against foolish claims and the earth's immobility:
https://catholicscientists.org/articles/augustine-aquinas-and-calvin-on-the-size-of-the-moon-scripture-and-following-the-science/
Movement of the heavens:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Genesi_ad_litteram
Allof which was written within the prevailing paradigm of the time and
none of which was intended to support geocentrism or had anything
whatsoever to do with faith or morals.
It is what the Church fathers believed that mattered, end of any stupid >excuses about why they believed it. The Council of Trent was trying to >figure out a means to determine what scriptural interpretations mattered
to the faith and morals of the Church. They decided to rely on the
initial interpretations of the early church intellectuals known as the >Church Fathers. There were likely over a hundred individuals that were
well known enough to qualify, by their writings and what had been
written about them. Some of the church fathers were already old earth >creationists, and some, like Augustine, did not think that the authors
of the Bible had gotten the 6 day creation right.
The stupid thing is that the Council of Trent findings still hold.
Years ago you and I found out that several hundred years after Galileo
that some Pope removed heliocentric writing from the Index and lifted
the ban on publication of helicentric notions for the purposes of
telling time and tracking planetary motions, but the geocentrist site >claimed that restrictions against going against the Council of Trent
still held and were not lifted because the Pope claimed that there
remained restrictions, and that any authors that wanted to publish >heliocentric material had to consult the church offices to see if those >restrictions applied to them. The geocentrist site believed that >heliocentrism could not be used to challenge the Council of Trent's
findings on scriptural interpretation. The anti geocentrists agreed
with the geocentrists that some restrictions still held, but they quoted
the entire Papal decree and noted that the remaining restrictions were
not stated, and that they did not know what the restrictions were. The
Pope knew, and someone in the Church offices knew.
In the end the Bible was just wrong about geocentrism, and until
Copernican times the Hebrew also understood what the Bible was telling
them. The authors of the Bible were geocentrists, flat earthers, and
their cosmology only went back in time to their oral history of their >ancestors. Because of that the Bible is just not a very good science >textbook. Nature has never been Biblical. The early church fathers all >understood this because, likely, none of them were flat earth Biblical >creationists even though flat earth Biblical Christians and Jews still
exist today.
He used the Bible to support his geocentric views of the cosmos. End of >>> that story. Like all the other Church fathers Augustine was a
geocentrist, and he is one of the Church fathers that used Bible verses
to support geocentrism. He knew that it was a stupid thing to do, but
he did it anyway.
Your lame stupidity about the Council of Trent requiring that the Church >>> fathers teach geocentrism is just lying to yourself because all the
Council of Trent required was unanimous consensus, and Augustine was one >>> of the Church fathers that actually could be considered to have used
scripture to teach geocentrism.
Like the historical Rabbis, Augustine also believed that the Biblical
firmament existed. He did not believe that the authors of the Bible had >>> presented the correct order of the 6 day creation in Genesis, but his
alternative would have also been found to be incorrect today.
I really, really thought by now you would have wakened up to the fact
that your ideas about the Church Fathers and the Council of Trent were
formed by a crazy kook promoting geocentrism. Are you seriously not
bothered by the fact that you have still never been able to find a
reputable historian or scholar who agrees with him?
You need to just accept reality for what it is. The Bible has just been >wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves. That
has been true from the start of Christianity. Guys like you have lied
to yourselves and made excuses about the situation, but the simple fact
is that the authors of the Bible believed an ancient cosmology that they
had likely assimilated from cultures that had been civilized for a
longer period of time. It was a young, flat earth, geocentric
cosmology, and I recently put up an Orthodox Jewish account of the
Biblical firmament demonstrating that the ancient historical Rabbis had >understood the flat earth geocentric cosmology with a solid dome
firmament above the earth, and that the historical Rabbis had supported
the existence of the solid firmament until Copernican times and the
failure of geocentrism. That account even had an example of a
historical Rabbi trying to make the solid firmament consistent with what
had become known about the independent motions of the sun and moon. The >Bible claimed that the sun and moon were made on the 4th day and placed
into the firmament, but the firmament was supposed to be solid and in
motion above the earth. To allow for the independent motion of the sun
and moon the Rabbi proposed that the firmament had two layers and that
the sun and moon were in between the two layers, and could move
independent of each other.
The authors of the Bible just had the wrong cosmology that they were
writing about. Their idea of the creation never existed. The Orthodox >jewish author understood that they had the wrong cosmology, but he took >comfort in the notion that they wrote about what they believed, and that >applied to what we can't cross check and find to be wrong.
Christians like you should probably not be Christians because you lack
the faith that you need. Trying to make lame excuses about Biblical >"interpretations" is just stupid when the early church intellectuals >understood that the Bible was just wrong about a lot of things that we
can determine for ourselves. They knew that the authors of the Bible
were not perfect angels. Faith was always more important to the
individuals that understood the limitations of the written word.
Science is never going to support the religious beliefs that are most >important to most Christians. God as the creator, the holy trinity, and >Jesus Christ are never going to be supported by science. The existing >cosmology, and the fact that life has been evolving on this planet for >billions of years is never going to support your Biblical beliefs,
because the Bible was just wrong about those aspects of nature. The
authors of the Bible knew nothing about the origin of life and its >subsequent evolution, nor did they understand much about the universe we >exist in. They did not know that our planet exists on the edge of one >spiral arm of one of billions of other galaxies. If your faith is not >strong enough to survive in the current reality, you should consider
what that means to your beliefs. The early Church Fathers already >understood that they did not have to believe everything in the Bible to >believe what they wanted to believe about Christianity. How many
Biblical laws and commands, did the early Christians not adhere to?
You just put up the Pope Francis quote about not having to believe that
the creator did everything in six magic acts, and that the Big Bang >cosmology was a creation that he could understand as being consistent
with his Biblical creator. Saint Augustine was making claims against
the 6 day creation over 1500 years ago. He did not think that the Bible >being wrong about that aspect of nature canceled what he wanted to
believe about his designer.
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:05:12 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 10/30/2026 5:46 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 29 Oct 2026 12:23:31 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 10/29/2026 11:06 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 07:29:28 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>You need to quit lying about reality. I noted that Saint Augustine
wrote:
W Saint Augustine was
not a flat earther, but he was one of the Church Fathers who used the >>>>>> Bible to support geocentrism.
No, he didn't. You really need to learn to check things out before
posting utter rubbish based on your own imbedded biases. Your beloved >>>>> Google AI would have told you:
<quote>
Saint Augustine of Hippo showed indifference toward the shape and
mechanics of the physical cosmos, famously asking: "What concern is it >>>>> to me whether the heavens as a sphere enclose the earth in the middle >>>>> of the world or overhang it on either side?"
Augustine's Approach to Astronomy and Science
o Indifference to Cosmology: Augustine did not treat astronomical
models (such as geocentrism versus alternative arrangements) as a core >>>>> matter of Christian faith.
o Prioritizing Scripture Without Dogmatizing Science: He warned
Christians against making rash, unscientific claims based on a
literalist reading of the Bible that could embarrass the faith when
contradicted by clear reason or observation. In The Literal Meaning of >>>>> Genesis, he argued that non-believers should not hear Christians
talking nonsense about physical science while citing Scripture.
o Humility in Interpretation: Later theologians, such as John Calvin, >>>>> drew directly on Augustine's hermeneutics to note that Scripture uses >>>>> everyday, phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun
"rising"-to accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid
technical science.
</quote>
warned against using the Bible to deny what we could determine for our >>>> selves, but he is one of the Church fathers noted for using the Bible to >>>> support his geocentric views.
Google cites the references.
Google Quote:
You are correct.
A good example of asking a loaded question to get the answer you want.
Why keep lying about the situation? The facts are just what they are.
Saint Augustine is known to be one of the Church fathers that used Bible
verses to support geocentrism. He was not only a geocentrist like all
the other Church fathers, but he taught geocentrism using the Bible, so
he qualifies as your lame excuse of the Church fathers needing to teach
instead of just agree with geocentrism. You lose with Augustine either way. >>
To clarify, Saint Augustine did write within a
fundamentally geocentric worldview
Of course he did as geocentrism was the accepted paradigm of the time
by everyone, Christian and non-Christian, religious and non-religious.
Nobody had anything different to suggest since the Philolaus eight
centuries earlier and nobody would suggest anything different until
Copernicus 12 centuries later. Why would Augustine have written in any
other context?
All the Council of Trent required was consensus. That is why the
Inquisition was able to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy, and why
the pope agreed with the inquisition in 1616 and condemned heliocentrism
and added heliocentric writings to the Index.
and relied directly on Biblical
descriptions to outline how he believed the physical cosmos operated.
As Calvin and other theologians pointed out, he was using everyday,
phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun "rising"-to
accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid technical
science.
It doesn't matter how others have tried to lie about the situation.
Augustine did what he did, end of that story. Augustine used the Bible
to support his geocentric beliefs. He understood that it was a stupid
thing to do, but he did it because he did not think that the Bible was
wrong about that aspect of nature.
While he warned against making foolish claims that defied proven logic, >>>> his actual commentaries on the text explicitly treated the Earth as
stationary and central, using Scripture to address astronomical mechanics. >>>>
Where Augustine Uses Scripture to Address Geocentric Concepts
o The Movement of the Heavens vs. a Stationary Earth: In De Genesi ad
litteram (The Literal Meaning of Genesis), Augustine grappled with the >>>> prevailing scientific questions of his day. When discussing the creation >>>> of celestial bodies in Genesis 1:14-16, he assumed a geocentric
architecture where the sun, moon, and stars orbited a fixed center.
o The Nature of the Firmament: In Book 2 of the same work, Augustine
meticulously analyzed Genesis 1:6 ("Let there be a firmament in the
midst of the waters"). He used this verse to debate the physical
properties of the heavens, addressing how the dome of the sky moves and >>>> how water could be held above a spherical, central Earth without falling. >>>>
o Accommodating Earth's Immobility: Like other Scripture Catholic
historical figures, Augustine read references to the earth being
"established" (such as in the Psalms) as physical realities of its
immobility, even if he simultaneously argued that some descriptions of >>>> size or light were tailored to human observation rather than absolute
spatial dimensions.
END Google Quote:
Google references:
Warning against foolish claims and the earth's immobility:
https://catholicscientists.org/articles/augustine-aquinas-and-calvin-on-the-size-of-the-moon-scripture-and-following-the-science/
Movement of the heavens:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Genesi_ad_litteram
Allof which was written within the prevailing paradigm of the time and
none of which was intended to support geocentrism or had anything
whatsoever to do with faith or morals.
It is what the Church fathers believed that mattered, end of any stupid
excuses about why they believed it. The Council of Trent was trying to
figure out a means to determine what scriptural interpretations mattered
to the faith and morals of the Church. They decided to rely on the
initial interpretations of the early church intellectuals known as the
Church Fathers. There were likely over a hundred individuals that were
well known enough to qualify, by their writings and what had been
written about them. Some of the church fathers were already old earth
creationists, and some, like Augustine, did not think that the authors
of the Bible had gotten the 6 day creation right.
The stupid thing is that the Council of Trent findings still hold.
Years ago you and I found out that several hundred years after Galileo
that some Pope removed heliocentric writing from the Index and lifted
the ban on publication of helicentric notions for the purposes of
telling time and tracking planetary motions, but the geocentrist site
claimed that restrictions against going against the Council of Trent
still held and were not lifted because the Pope claimed that there
remained restrictions, and that any authors that wanted to publish
heliocentric material had to consult the church offices to see if those
restrictions applied to them. The geocentrist site believed that
heliocentrism could not be used to challenge the Council of Trent's
findings on scriptural interpretation. The anti geocentrists agreed
with the geocentrists that some restrictions still held, but they quoted
the entire Papal decree and noted that the remaining restrictions were
not stated, and that they did not know what the restrictions were. The
Pope knew, and someone in the Church offices knew.
In the end the Bible was just wrong about geocentrism, and until
Copernican times the Hebrew also understood what the Bible was telling
them. The authors of the Bible were geocentrists, flat earthers, and
their cosmology only went back in time to their oral history of their
ancestors. Because of that the Bible is just not a very good science
textbook. Nature has never been Biblical. The early church fathers all
understood this because, likely, none of them were flat earth Biblical
creationists even though flat earth Biblical Christians and Jews still
exist today.
He used the Bible to support his geocentric views of the cosmos. End of >>>> that story. Like all the other Church fathers Augustine was a
geocentrist, and he is one of the Church fathers that used Bible verses >>>> to support geocentrism. He knew that it was a stupid thing to do, but >>>> he did it anyway.
Your lame stupidity about the Council of Trent requiring that the Church >>>> fathers teach geocentrism is just lying to yourself because all the
Council of Trent required was unanimous consensus, and Augustine was one >>>> of the Church fathers that actually could be considered to have used
scripture to teach geocentrism.
Like the historical Rabbis, Augustine also believed that the Biblical
firmament existed. He did not believe that the authors of the Bible had >>>> presented the correct order of the 6 day creation in Genesis, but his
alternative would have also been found to be incorrect today.
I really, really thought by now you would have wakened up to the fact
that your ideas about the Church Fathers and the Council of Trent were
formed by a crazy kook promoting geocentrism. Are you seriously not
bothered by the fact that you have still never been able to find a
reputable historian or scholar who agrees with him?
You need to just accept reality for what it is. The Bible has just been
wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves. That
has been true from the start of Christianity. Guys like you have lied
to yourselves and made excuses about the situation, but the simple fact
is that the authors of the Bible believed an ancient cosmology that they
had likely assimilated from cultures that had been civilized for a
longer period of time. It was a young, flat earth, geocentric
cosmology, and I recently put up an Orthodox Jewish account of the
Biblical firmament demonstrating that the ancient historical Rabbis had
understood the flat earth geocentric cosmology with a solid dome
firmament above the earth, and that the historical Rabbis had supported
the existence of the solid firmament until Copernican times and the
failure of geocentrism. That account even had an example of a
historical Rabbi trying to make the solid firmament consistent with what
had become known about the independent motions of the sun and moon. The
Bible claimed that the sun and moon were made on the 4th day and placed
into the firmament, but the firmament was supposed to be solid and in
motion above the earth. To allow for the independent motion of the sun
and moon the Rabbi proposed that the firmament had two layers and that
the sun and moon were in between the two layers, and could move
independent of each other.
The authors of the Bible just had the wrong cosmology that they were
writing about. Their idea of the creation never existed. The Orthodox
jewish author understood that they had the wrong cosmology, but he took
comfort in the notion that they wrote about what they believed, and that
applied to what we can't cross check and find to be wrong.
Christians like you should probably not be Christians because you lack
the faith that you need. Trying to make lame excuses about Biblical
"interpretations" is just stupid when the early church intellectuals
understood that the Bible was just wrong about a lot of things that we
can determine for ourselves. They knew that the authors of the Bible
were not perfect angels. Faith was always more important to the
individuals that understood the limitations of the written word.
Science is never going to support the religious beliefs that are most
important to most Christians. God as the creator, the holy trinity, and
Jesus Christ are never going to be supported by science. The existing
cosmology, and the fact that life has been evolving on this planet for
billions of years is never going to support your Biblical beliefs,
because the Bible was just wrong about those aspects of nature. The
authors of the Bible knew nothing about the origin of life and its
subsequent evolution, nor did they understand much about the universe we
exist in. They did not know that our planet exists on the edge of one
spiral arm of one of billions of other galaxies. If your faith is not
strong enough to survive in the current reality, you should consider
what that means to your beliefs. The early Church Fathers already
understood that they did not have to believe everything in the Bible to
believe what they wanted to believe about Christianity. How many
Biblical laws and commands, did the early Christians not adhere to?
You just put up the Pope Francis quote about not having to believe that
the creator did everything in six magic acts, and that the Big Bang
cosmology was a creation that he could understand as being consistent
with his Biblical creator. Saint Augustine was making claims against
the 6 day creation over 1500 years ago. He did not think that the Bible
being wrong about that aspect of nature canceled what he wanted to
believe about his designer.
What a long and rambling attempt to divert attention away from the
fact that you cannot produce a single reputable source that supports
your claims about Augustin, the Church Fathers in general and the
Council of Trent. Sorry, Ron, it doesn't work. I reckon you must be
trying to convince yourself of this stuff; you can't seriously think
you're going to convince anyone else to accept the arguments put
forward by a kook trying to make a case for geocentrism.
On 10/31/2026 11:55 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:05:12 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>Why keep lying about the situation. It is well known what Augustine
wrote:
On 10/30/2026 5:46 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 29 Oct 2026 12:23:31 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 10/29/2026 11:06 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 07:29:28 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>You need to quit lying about reality. I noted that Saint Augustine
wrote:
W Saint Augustine was
not a flat earther, but he was one of the Church Fathers who used the >>>>>>> Bible to support geocentrism.
No, he didn't. You really need to learn to check things out before >>>>>> posting utter rubbish based on your own imbedded biases. Your beloved >>>>>> Google AI would have told you:
<quote>
Saint Augustine of Hippo showed indifference toward the shape and
mechanics of the physical cosmos, famously asking: "What concern is it >>>>>> to me whether the heavens as a sphere enclose the earth in the middle >>>>>> of the world or overhang it on either side?"
Augustine's Approach to Astronomy and Science
o Indifference to Cosmology: Augustine did not treat astronomical
models (such as geocentrism versus alternative arrangements) as a core >>>>>> matter of Christian faith.
o Prioritizing Scripture Without Dogmatizing Science: He warned
Christians against making rash, unscientific claims based on a
literalist reading of the Bible that could embarrass the faith when >>>>>> contradicted by clear reason or observation. In The Literal Meaning of >>>>>> Genesis, he argued that non-believers should not hear Christians
talking nonsense about physical science while citing Scripture.
o Humility in Interpretation: Later theologians, such as John Calvin, >>>>>> drew directly on Augustine's hermeneutics to note that Scripture uses >>>>>> everyday, phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun
"rising"-to accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid >>>>>> technical science.
</quote>
warned against using the Bible to deny what we could determine for our >>>>> selves, but he is one of the Church fathers noted for using the Bible to >>>>> support his geocentric views.
Google cites the references.
Google Quote:
You are correct.
A good example of asking a loaded question to get the answer you want.
Why keep lying about the situation? The facts are just what they are.
Saint Augustine is known to be one of the Church fathers that used Bible >>> verses to support geocentrism. He was not only a geocentrist like all
the other Church fathers, but he taught geocentrism using the Bible, so
he qualifies as your lame excuse of the Church fathers needing to teach
instead of just agree with geocentrism. You lose with Augustine either way.
To clarify, Saint Augustine did write within a
fundamentally geocentric worldview
Of course he did as geocentrism was the accepted paradigm of the time
by everyone, Christian and non-Christian, religious and non-religious. >>>> Nobody had anything different to suggest since the Philolaus eight
centuries earlier and nobody would suggest anything different until
Copernicus 12 centuries later. Why would Augustine have written in any >>>> other context?
All the Council of Trent required was consensus. That is why the
Inquisition was able to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy, and why >>> the pope agreed with the inquisition in 1616 and condemned heliocentrism >>> and added heliocentric writings to the Index.
and relied directly on BiblicalAs Calvin and other theologians pointed out, he was using everyday,
descriptions to outline how he believed the physical cosmos operated. >>>>
phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun "rising"-to
accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid technical
science.
It doesn't matter how others have tried to lie about the situation.
Augustine did what he did, end of that story. Augustine used the Bible
to support his geocentric beliefs. He understood that it was a stupid
thing to do, but he did it because he did not think that the Bible was
wrong about that aspect of nature.
While he warned against making foolish claims that defied proven logic, >>>>> his actual commentaries on the text explicitly treated the Earth as
stationary and central, using Scripture to address astronomical mechanics.
Where Augustine Uses Scripture to Address Geocentric Concepts
o The Movement of the Heavens vs. a Stationary Earth: In De Genesi ad >>>>> litteram (The Literal Meaning of Genesis), Augustine grappled with the >>>>> prevailing scientific questions of his day. When discussing the creation >>>>> of celestial bodies in Genesis 1:14-16, he assumed a geocentric
architecture where the sun, moon, and stars orbited a fixed center.
o The Nature of the Firmament: In Book 2 of the same work, Augustine >>>>> meticulously analyzed Genesis 1:6 ("Let there be a firmament in the
midst of the waters"). He used this verse to debate the physical
properties of the heavens, addressing how the dome of the sky moves and >>>>> how water could be held above a spherical, central Earth without falling. >>>>>
o Accommodating Earth's Immobility: Like other Scripture Catholic
historical figures, Augustine read references to the earth being
"established" (such as in the Psalms) as physical realities of its
immobility, even if he simultaneously argued that some descriptions of >>>>> size or light were tailored to human observation rather than absolute >>>>> spatial dimensions.
END Google Quote:
Google references:
Warning against foolish claims and the earth's immobility:
https://catholicscientists.org/articles/augustine-aquinas-and-calvin-on-the-size-of-the-moon-scripture-and-following-the-science/
Movement of the heavens:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Genesi_ad_litteram
Allof which was written within the prevailing paradigm of the time and >>>> none of which was intended to support geocentrism or had anything
whatsoever to do with faith or morals.
It is what the Church fathers believed that mattered, end of any stupid
excuses about why they believed it. The Council of Trent was trying to
figure out a means to determine what scriptural interpretations mattered >>> to the faith and morals of the Church. They decided to rely on the
initial interpretations of the early church intellectuals known as the
Church Fathers. There were likely over a hundred individuals that were
well known enough to qualify, by their writings and what had been
written about them. Some of the church fathers were already old earth
creationists, and some, like Augustine, did not think that the authors
of the Bible had gotten the 6 day creation right.
The stupid thing is that the Council of Trent findings still hold.
Years ago you and I found out that several hundred years after Galileo
that some Pope removed heliocentric writing from the Index and lifted
the ban on publication of helicentric notions for the purposes of
telling time and tracking planetary motions, but the geocentrist site
claimed that restrictions against going against the Council of Trent
still held and were not lifted because the Pope claimed that there
remained restrictions, and that any authors that wanted to publish
heliocentric material had to consult the church offices to see if those
restrictions applied to them. The geocentrist site believed that
heliocentrism could not be used to challenge the Council of Trent's
findings on scriptural interpretation. The anti geocentrists agreed
with the geocentrists that some restrictions still held, but they quoted >>> the entire Papal decree and noted that the remaining restrictions were
not stated, and that they did not know what the restrictions were. The
Pope knew, and someone in the Church offices knew.
In the end the Bible was just wrong about geocentrism, and until
Copernican times the Hebrew also understood what the Bible was telling
them. The authors of the Bible were geocentrists, flat earthers, and
their cosmology only went back in time to their oral history of their
ancestors. Because of that the Bible is just not a very good science
textbook. Nature has never been Biblical. The early church fathers all >>> understood this because, likely, none of them were flat earth Biblical
creationists even though flat earth Biblical Christians and Jews still
exist today.
He used the Bible to support his geocentric views of the cosmos. End of >>>>> that story. Like all the other Church fathers Augustine was a
geocentrist, and he is one of the Church fathers that used Bible verses >>>>> to support geocentrism. He knew that it was a stupid thing to do, but >>>>> he did it anyway.
Your lame stupidity about the Council of Trent requiring that the Church >>>>> fathers teach geocentrism is just lying to yourself because all the
Council of Trent required was unanimous consensus, and Augustine was one >>>>> of the Church fathers that actually could be considered to have used >>>>> scripture to teach geocentrism.
Like the historical Rabbis, Augustine also believed that the Biblical >>>>> firmament existed. He did not believe that the authors of the Bible had >>>>> presented the correct order of the 6 day creation in Genesis, but his >>>>> alternative would have also been found to be incorrect today.
I really, really thought by now you would have wakened up to the fact
that your ideas about the Church Fathers and the Council of Trent were >>>> formed by a crazy kook promoting geocentrism. Are you seriously not
bothered by the fact that you have still never been able to find a
reputable historian or scholar who agrees with him?
You need to just accept reality for what it is. The Bible has just been >>> wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves. That
has been true from the start of Christianity. Guys like you have lied
to yourselves and made excuses about the situation, but the simple fact
is that the authors of the Bible believed an ancient cosmology that they >>> had likely assimilated from cultures that had been civilized for a
longer period of time. It was a young, flat earth, geocentric
cosmology, and I recently put up an Orthodox Jewish account of the
Biblical firmament demonstrating that the ancient historical Rabbis had
understood the flat earth geocentric cosmology with a solid dome
firmament above the earth, and that the historical Rabbis had supported
the existence of the solid firmament until Copernican times and the
failure of geocentrism. That account even had an example of a
historical Rabbi trying to make the solid firmament consistent with what >>> had become known about the independent motions of the sun and moon. The >>> Bible claimed that the sun and moon were made on the 4th day and placed
into the firmament, but the firmament was supposed to be solid and in
motion above the earth. To allow for the independent motion of the sun
and moon the Rabbi proposed that the firmament had two layers and that
the sun and moon were in between the two layers, and could move
independent of each other.
The authors of the Bible just had the wrong cosmology that they were
writing about. Their idea of the creation never existed. The Orthodox
jewish author understood that they had the wrong cosmology, but he took
comfort in the notion that they wrote about what they believed, and that >>> applied to what we can't cross check and find to be wrong.
Christians like you should probably not be Christians because you lack
the faith that you need. Trying to make lame excuses about Biblical
"interpretations" is just stupid when the early church intellectuals
understood that the Bible was just wrong about a lot of things that we
can determine for ourselves. They knew that the authors of the Bible
were not perfect angels. Faith was always more important to the
individuals that understood the limitations of the written word.
Science is never going to support the religious beliefs that are most
important to most Christians. God as the creator, the holy trinity, and >>> Jesus Christ are never going to be supported by science. The existing
cosmology, and the fact that life has been evolving on this planet for
billions of years is never going to support your Biblical beliefs,
because the Bible was just wrong about those aspects of nature. The
authors of the Bible knew nothing about the origin of life and its
subsequent evolution, nor did they understand much about the universe we >>> exist in. They did not know that our planet exists on the edge of one
spiral arm of one of billions of other galaxies. If your faith is not
strong enough to survive in the current reality, you should consider
what that means to your beliefs. The early Church Fathers already
understood that they did not have to believe everything in the Bible to
believe what they wanted to believe about Christianity. How many
Biblical laws and commands, did the early Christians not adhere to?
You just put up the Pope Francis quote about not having to believe that
the creator did everything in six magic acts, and that the Big Bang
cosmology was a creation that he could understand as being consistent
with his Biblical creator. Saint Augustine was making claims against
the 6 day creation over 1500 years ago. He did not think that the Bible >>> being wrong about that aspect of nature canceled what he wanted to
believe about his designer.
What a long and rambling attempt to divert attention away from the
fact that you cannot produce a single reputable source that supports
your claims about Augustin, the Church Fathers in general and the
Council of Trent. Sorry, Ron, it doesn't work. I reckon you must be
trying to convince yourself of this stuff; you can't seriously think
you're going to convince anyone else to accept the arguments put
forward by a kook trying to make a case for geocentrism.
did, and two references were given.
them, does not mean that they do not represent what has been understood
for centuries. Augustine did what he did. You can't keep lying about
that just because you don't want it to be true. Augustine warned
Christians that they should not use the Bible to deny what we could
figure out for ourselves. He did not believe that the order of the 6
day creation was what actually happened, but the Bible being wrong about >that did not matter to him. He was not a flat earth creationist, but he
was a geocentrist, and even though it was a stupid thing to do, he used
the Bible to support his geocentric beliefs. He likely did that because
he did not think that the Bible was wrong about the geocentric Hebrew >cosmology.
One of the sources that you do not find reputable is
catholicscientists.org. This is supposed to be an international >organization of Catholic scientists. You need to demonstrate that the >author was wrong about Augustine's use of Bible verses to support >geocentrism.
You can't change reality by trying to cover up what you do not want to >believe.
Your lame lie about reputable sources, is just as lame as your dishonest >quote mining of the papal document demonstrating that the pope had >heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric writings added to the Index.
Your source had been found to have lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism. You can't demonstrate >that the Augustine Google cited sources are not reputable,
you can only
lie about it in your delusional state of not wanting reality to be what
it is. Really, you can lie about "reputable" sources when you know that
it is a well known fact that Augustine used Bible verses to support >geocentrism. It is insane to try to lie about something like this.
When I took Christian history as an undergraduate, Berkeley was on a 10
week quarter system, and the prof. spent over a week on Augustine, and
had a book on Augustine as one of the 3 books that we had to buy for the >class. That was 50 years ago, and Google doesn't think that anything
has changed. Google just gave some more recent references that noted
what Augustine had done.
Ron Okimoto
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 13:46:36 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 10/31/2026 11:55 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:05:12 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>Why keep lying about the situation. It is well known what Augustine
wrote:
On 10/30/2026 5:46 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 29 Oct 2026 12:23:31 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>Why keep lying about the situation? The facts are just what they are. >>>> Saint Augustine is known to be one of the Church fathers that used Bible >>>> verses to support geocentrism. He was not only a geocentrist like all >>>> the other Church fathers, but he taught geocentrism using the Bible, so >>>> he qualifies as your lame excuse of the Church fathers needing to teach >>>> instead of just agree with geocentrism. You lose with Augustine either way.
wrote:
On 10/29/2026 11:06 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 07:29:28 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> >>>>>>> wrote:You need to quit lying about reality. I noted that Saint Augustine >>>>>> warned against using the Bible to deny what we could determine for our >>>>>> selves, but he is one of the Church fathers noted for using the Bible to >>>>>> support his geocentric views.
W Saint Augustine was
not a flat earther, but he was one of the Church Fathers who used the >>>>>>>> Bible to support geocentrism.
No, he didn't. You really need to learn to check things out before >>>>>>> posting utter rubbish based on your own imbedded biases. Your beloved >>>>>>> Google AI would have told you:
<quote>
Saint Augustine of Hippo showed indifference toward the shape and >>>>>>> mechanics of the physical cosmos, famously asking: "What concern is it >>>>>>> to me whether the heavens as a sphere enclose the earth in the middle >>>>>>> of the world or overhang it on either side?"
Augustine's Approach to Astronomy and Science
o Indifference to Cosmology: Augustine did not treat astronomical >>>>>>> models (such as geocentrism versus alternative arrangements) as a core >>>>>>> matter of Christian faith.
o Prioritizing Scripture Without Dogmatizing Science: He warned
Christians against making rash, unscientific claims based on a
literalist reading of the Bible that could embarrass the faith when >>>>>>> contradicted by clear reason or observation. In The Literal Meaning of >>>>>>> Genesis, he argued that non-believers should not hear Christians >>>>>>> talking nonsense about physical science while citing Scripture.
o Humility in Interpretation: Later theologians, such as John Calvin, >>>>>>> drew directly on Augustine's hermeneutics to note that Scripture uses >>>>>>> everyday, phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun >>>>>>> "rising"-to accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid >>>>>>> technical science.
</quote>
Google cites the references.
Google Quote:
You are correct.
A good example of asking a loaded question to get the answer you want. >>>>
To clarify, Saint Augustine did write within a
fundamentally geocentric worldview
Of course he did as geocentrism was the accepted paradigm of the time >>>>> by everyone, Christian and non-Christian, religious and non-religious. >>>>> Nobody had anything different to suggest since the Philolaus eight
centuries earlier and nobody would suggest anything different until
Copernicus 12 centuries later. Why would Augustine have written in any >>>>> other context?
All the Council of Trent required was consensus. That is why the
Inquisition was able to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy, and why >>>> the pope agreed with the inquisition in 1616 and condemned heliocentrism >>>> and added heliocentric writings to the Index.
and relied directly on BiblicalAs Calvin and other theologians pointed out, he was using everyday,
descriptions to outline how he believed the physical cosmos operated. >>>>>
phenomenological (observational) language-like the sun "rising"-to
accommodate human weakness rather than to teach a rigid technical
science.
It doesn't matter how others have tried to lie about the situation.
Augustine did what he did, end of that story. Augustine used the Bible >>>> to support his geocentric beliefs. He understood that it was a stupid >>>> thing to do, but he did it because he did not think that the Bible was >>>> wrong about that aspect of nature.
While he warned against making foolish claims that defied proven logic, >>>>>> his actual commentaries on the text explicitly treated the Earth as >>>>>> stationary and central, using Scripture to address astronomical mechanics.
Where Augustine Uses Scripture to Address Geocentric Concepts
o The Movement of the Heavens vs. a Stationary Earth: In De Genesi ad >>>>>> litteram (The Literal Meaning of Genesis), Augustine grappled with the >>>>>> prevailing scientific questions of his day. When discussing the creation >>>>>> of celestial bodies in Genesis 1:14-16, he assumed a geocentric
architecture where the sun, moon, and stars orbited a fixed center. >>>>>>
o The Nature of the Firmament: In Book 2 of the same work, Augustine >>>>>> meticulously analyzed Genesis 1:6 ("Let there be a firmament in the >>>>>> midst of the waters"). He used this verse to debate the physical
properties of the heavens, addressing how the dome of the sky moves and >>>>>> how water could be held above a spherical, central Earth without falling.
o Accommodating Earth's Immobility: Like other Scripture Catholic
historical figures, Augustine read references to the earth being
"established" (such as in the Psalms) as physical realities of its >>>>>> immobility, even if he simultaneously argued that some descriptions of >>>>>> size or light were tailored to human observation rather than absolute >>>>>> spatial dimensions.
END Google Quote:
Google references:
Warning against foolish claims and the earth's immobility:
https://catholicscientists.org/articles/augustine-aquinas-and-calvin-on-the-size-of-the-moon-scripture-and-following-the-science/
Movement of the heavens:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Genesi_ad_litteram
Allof which was written within the prevailing paradigm of the time and >>>>> none of which was intended to support geocentrism or had anything
whatsoever to do with faith or morals.
It is what the Church fathers believed that mattered, end of any stupid >>>> excuses about why they believed it. The Council of Trent was trying to >>>> figure out a means to determine what scriptural interpretations mattered >>>> to the faith and morals of the Church. They decided to rely on the
initial interpretations of the early church intellectuals known as the >>>> Church Fathers. There were likely over a hundred individuals that were >>>> well known enough to qualify, by their writings and what had been
written about them. Some of the church fathers were already old earth >>>> creationists, and some, like Augustine, did not think that the authors >>>> of the Bible had gotten the 6 day creation right.
The stupid thing is that the Council of Trent findings still hold.
Years ago you and I found out that several hundred years after Galileo >>>> that some Pope removed heliocentric writing from the Index and lifted
the ban on publication of helicentric notions for the purposes of
telling time and tracking planetary motions, but the geocentrist site
claimed that restrictions against going against the Council of Trent
still held and were not lifted because the Pope claimed that there
remained restrictions, and that any authors that wanted to publish
heliocentric material had to consult the church offices to see if those >>>> restrictions applied to them. The geocentrist site believed that
heliocentrism could not be used to challenge the Council of Trent's
findings on scriptural interpretation. The anti geocentrists agreed
with the geocentrists that some restrictions still held, but they quoted >>>> the entire Papal decree and noted that the remaining restrictions were >>>> not stated, and that they did not know what the restrictions were. The >>>> Pope knew, and someone in the Church offices knew.
In the end the Bible was just wrong about geocentrism, and until
Copernican times the Hebrew also understood what the Bible was telling >>>> them. The authors of the Bible were geocentrists, flat earthers, and
their cosmology only went back in time to their oral history of their
ancestors. Because of that the Bible is just not a very good science
textbook. Nature has never been Biblical. The early church fathers all >>>> understood this because, likely, none of them were flat earth Biblical >>>> creationists even though flat earth Biblical Christians and Jews still >>>> exist today.
He used the Bible to support his geocentric views of the cosmos. End of >>>>>> that story. Like all the other Church fathers Augustine was a
geocentrist, and he is one of the Church fathers that used Bible verses >>>>>> to support geocentrism. He knew that it was a stupid thing to do, but >>>>>> he did it anyway.
Your lame stupidity about the Council of Trent requiring that the Church >>>>>> fathers teach geocentrism is just lying to yourself because all the >>>>>> Council of Trent required was unanimous consensus, and Augustine was one >>>>>> of the Church fathers that actually could be considered to have used >>>>>> scripture to teach geocentrism.
Like the historical Rabbis, Augustine also believed that the Biblical >>>>>> firmament existed. He did not believe that the authors of the Bible had >>>>>> presented the correct order of the 6 day creation in Genesis, but his >>>>>> alternative would have also been found to be incorrect today.
I really, really thought by now you would have wakened up to the fact >>>>> that your ideas about the Church Fathers and the Council of Trent were >>>>> formed by a crazy kook promoting geocentrism. Are you seriously not >>>>> bothered by the fact that you have still never been able to find a
reputable historian or scholar who agrees with him?
You need to just accept reality for what it is. The Bible has just been >>>> wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves. That >>>> has been true from the start of Christianity. Guys like you have lied >>>> to yourselves and made excuses about the situation, but the simple fact >>>> is that the authors of the Bible believed an ancient cosmology that they >>>> had likely assimilated from cultures that had been civilized for a
longer period of time. It was a young, flat earth, geocentric
cosmology, and I recently put up an Orthodox Jewish account of the
Biblical firmament demonstrating that the ancient historical Rabbis had >>>> understood the flat earth geocentric cosmology with a solid dome
firmament above the earth, and that the historical Rabbis had supported >>>> the existence of the solid firmament until Copernican times and the
failure of geocentrism. That account even had an example of a
historical Rabbi trying to make the solid firmament consistent with what >>>> had become known about the independent motions of the sun and moon. The >>>> Bible claimed that the sun and moon were made on the 4th day and placed >>>> into the firmament, but the firmament was supposed to be solid and in
motion above the earth. To allow for the independent motion of the sun >>>> and moon the Rabbi proposed that the firmament had two layers and that >>>> the sun and moon were in between the two layers, and could move
independent of each other.
The authors of the Bible just had the wrong cosmology that they were
writing about. Their idea of the creation never existed. The Orthodox >>>> jewish author understood that they had the wrong cosmology, but he took >>>> comfort in the notion that they wrote about what they believed, and that >>>> applied to what we can't cross check and find to be wrong.
Christians like you should probably not be Christians because you lack >>>> the faith that you need. Trying to make lame excuses about Biblical
"interpretations" is just stupid when the early church intellectuals
understood that the Bible was just wrong about a lot of things that we >>>> can determine for ourselves. They knew that the authors of the Bible
were not perfect angels. Faith was always more important to the
individuals that understood the limitations of the written word.
Science is never going to support the religious beliefs that are most
important to most Christians. God as the creator, the holy trinity, and >>>> Jesus Christ are never going to be supported by science. The existing >>>> cosmology, and the fact that life has been evolving on this planet for >>>> billions of years is never going to support your Biblical beliefs,
because the Bible was just wrong about those aspects of nature. The
authors of the Bible knew nothing about the origin of life and its
subsequent evolution, nor did they understand much about the universe we >>>> exist in. They did not know that our planet exists on the edge of one >>>> spiral arm of one of billions of other galaxies. If your faith is not >>>> strong enough to survive in the current reality, you should consider
what that means to your beliefs. The early Church Fathers already
understood that they did not have to believe everything in the Bible to >>>> believe what they wanted to believe about Christianity. How many
Biblical laws and commands, did the early Christians not adhere to?
You just put up the Pope Francis quote about not having to believe that >>>> the creator did everything in six magic acts, and that the Big Bang
cosmology was a creation that he could understand as being consistent
with his Biblical creator. Saint Augustine was making claims against
the 6 day creation over 1500 years ago. He did not think that the Bible >>>> being wrong about that aspect of nature canceled what he wanted to
believe about his designer.
What a long and rambling attempt to divert attention away from the
fact that you cannot produce a single reputable source that supports
your claims about Augustin, the Church Fathers in general and the
Council of Trent. Sorry, Ron, it doesn't work. I reckon you must be
trying to convince yourself of this stuff; you can't seriously think
you're going to convince anyone else to accept the arguments put
forward by a kook trying to make a case for geocentrism.
did, and two references were given.
No they weren't - an Ai summary of a Wikipedia summary does not
qualify as a references. As a professional scientist with multiple publications, you clearly understand that and are simply waffling to
try to hide the fact that you don't have a reputable source.
Just because you want to lie about
them, does not mean that they do not represent what has been understood
for centuries. Augustine did what he did. You can't keep lying about
that just because you don't want it to be true. Augustine warned
Christians that they should not use the Bible to deny what we could
figure out for ourselves. He did not believe that the order of the 6
day creation was what actually happened, but the Bible being wrong about
that did not matter to him. He was not a flat earth creationist, but he
was a geocentrist, and even though it was a stupid thing to do, he used
the Bible to support his geocentric beliefs. He likely did that because
he did not think that the Bible was wrong about the geocentric Hebrew
cosmology.
One of the sources that you do not find reputable is
catholicscientists.org. This is supposed to be an international
organization of Catholic scientists. You need to demonstrate that the
author was wrong about Augustine's use of Bible verses to support
geocentrism.
Where does the author state that St Augustine related geocentrism to
Faith and Morals which are the only areas where the opinions of the
Church Fathers matter?
You can't change reality by trying to cover up what you do not want to
believe.
Your lame lie about reputable sources, is just as lame as your dishonest
quote mining of the papal document demonstrating that the pope had
heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric writings added to the Index.
Your source had been found to have lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism. You can't demonstrate
that the Augustine Google cited sources are not reputable,
It's not up to me to do that - you are the one relying on them, it is
up to you to show they are reputable. Again, you know that, you're
just trying to wriggle your way out of it.
you can only
lie about it in your delusional state of not wanting reality to be what
it is. Really, you can lie about "reputable" sources when you know that
it is a well known fact that Augustine used Bible verses to support
geocentrism. It is insane to try to lie about something like this.
When I took Christian history as an undergraduate, Berkeley was on a 10
week quarter system, and the prof. spent over a week on Augustine, and
had a book on Augustine as one of the 3 books that we had to buy for the
class. That was 50 years ago, and Google doesn't think that anything
has changed. Google just gave some more recent references that noted
what Augustine had done.
Ron Okimoto
On 11/1/2026 12:48 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the sources that you do not find reputable is
catholicscientists.org.
This is supposed to be an international
organization of Catholic scientists.
You need to demonstrate that the
author was wrong about Augustine's use of Bible verses to support
geocentrism.
Where does the author state that St Augustine related geocentrism to
Faith and Morals which are the only areas where the opinions of the
Church Fathers matter?
What a nut job. All that you required before was that Augustine "teach" >geocentrism, and that is exactly what he was doing. All the Council of >Trent required was concensus. All the church fathers were geocentrists.
Why keep lying about the situation? The Pope agreed with the
inquisition findings and had heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric >writings added to the Index in 1616.
Augustine used Bible verses to support his geocentric beliefs. That is
all the article needed to demonstrate. That is what you contested, and >moving the goal posts after finding out that you were wrong is stupid
and dishonest and doesn't change the fact of what Augustine did.
You can't change reality by trying to cover up what you do not want to
believe.
Your lame lie about reputable sources, is just as lame as your dishonest >>> quote mining of the papal document demonstrating that the pope had
heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric writings added to the Index.
Your source had been found to have lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism. You can't demonstrate >>> that the Augustine Google cited sources are not reputable,
It's not up to me to do that - you are the one relying on them, it is
up to you to show they are reputable. Again, you know that, you're
just trying to wriggle your way out of it.
What a liar. You made the claim that the sources were not reputable,
you need to back up that lie or retract it.
The sources are just
repeating what has been known for centuries. They are just recent
examples where someone is noting what Augustine did. You need to >demonstrate that Augustine never did what everyone that understands the >situation knows that he did it.
I was going off my memory of
Augustine's foible from what I learned 50 years ago, and things
obviously have not changed, since the Catholic reference was from 2022.
What is not reputable about an article written by an Adjunct Scholar at
the Vatican Observatory? You can't just lie about the source not being >reputable and then run from the lie and expect the lie to hold up.
Ron Okimoto
you can only
lie about it in your delusional state of not wanting reality to be what
it is. Really, you can lie about "reputable" sources when you know that >>> it is a well known fact that Augustine used Bible verses to support
geocentrism. It is insane to try to lie about something like this.
When I took Christian history as an undergraduate, Berkeley was on a 10
week quarter system, and the prof. spent over a week on Augustine, and
had a book on Augustine as one of the 3 books that we had to buy for the >>> class. That was 50 years ago, and Google doesn't think that anything
has changed. Google just gave some more recent references that noted
what Augustine had done.
Ron Okimoto
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 21:19:35 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/2026 12:48 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
[mercy snip]
*Note to Ron* - mercy snip does NOT mean someone is agreeing with what
you posted or running from it; just that they are tired with your
endless repetition.
One of the sources that you do not find reputable is
catholicscientists.org.
To the best of my recollection and doing a search on TO for it, this
is the first time you have ever referred to that site so once again,
you invent a claim about me that simply isn't true - I consider it a
very reputable site.
This is supposed to be an international
organization of Catholic scientists.
No "supposed" about it, it is an international organisation of
Catholic scientists.
You need to demonstrate that the
author was wrong about Augustine's use of Bible verses to support
geocentrism.
Where does the author state that St Augustine related geocentrism to
Faith and Morals which are the only areas where the opinions of the
Church Fathers matter?
What a nut job. All that you required before was that Augustine "teach"
geocentrism, and that is exactly what he was doing. All the Council of
Trent required was concensus. All the church fathers were geocentrists.
Why keep lying about the situation? The Pope agreed with the
inquisition findings and had heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric
writings added to the Index in 1616.
Augustine used Bible verses to support his geocentric beliefs. That is
all the article needed to demonstrate. That is what you contested, and
moving the goal posts after finding out that you were wrong is stupid
and dishonest and doesn't change the fact of what Augustine did.
So the article doesn't say what you claimed it says. Plus |oa change.
You can't change reality by trying to cover up what you do not want to >>>> believe.
Your lame lie about reputable sources, is just as lame as your dishonest >>>> quote mining of the papal document demonstrating that the pope had
heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric writings added to the Index.
Your source had been found to have lied about the Inquisition being the >>>> only church body to have condemned heliocentrism. You can't demonstrate >>>> that the Augustine Google cited sources are not reputable,
It's not up to me to do that - you are the one relying on them, it is
up to you to show they are reputable. Again, you know that, you're
just trying to wriggle your way out of it.
What a liar. You made the claim that the sources were not reputable,
you need to back up that lie or retract it.
The only source you have given that supports you is the guy promoting geocentrism. I'm pretty sure that nobody here except you would regard
that as a reputable source, especially when qualified historians
directly contradict him.
The sources are just
repeating what has been known for centuries. They are just recent
examples where someone is noting what Augustine did. You need to
demonstrate that Augustine never did what everyone that understands the
situation knows that he did it.
It's not up to me or anyone to prove a negative; it's always up to the
person making a claim to prove it. You know that principle well;
asking me to prove a negative just highlights how far up your asshole
you have got about this.
I was going off my memory of
Augustine's foible from what I learned 50 years ago, and things
obviously have not changed, since the Catholic reference was from 2022.
What is not reputable about an article written by an Adjunct Scholar at
the Vatican Observatory? You can't just lie about the source not being
reputable and then run from the lie and expect the lie to hold up.
Ron Okimoto
you can only
lie about it in your delusional state of not wanting reality to be what >>>> it is. Really, you can lie about "reputable" sources when you know that >>>> it is a well known fact that Augustine used Bible verses to support
geocentrism. It is insane to try to lie about something like this.
When I took Christian history as an undergraduate, Berkeley was on a 10 >>>> week quarter system, and the prof. spent over a week on Augustine, and >>>> had a book on Augustine as one of the 3 books that we had to buy for the >>>> class. That was 50 years ago, and Google doesn't think that anything
has changed. Google just gave some more recent references that noted
what Augustine had done.
Ron Okimoto
On 11/2/2026 9:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 21:19:35 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/2026 12:48 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
[mercy snip]
*Note to Ron* - mercy snip does NOT mean someone is agreeing with what
you posted or running from it; just that they are tired with your
endless repetition.
You are just lying, and you are snipping and running from your past >dishonest foibles.
One of the sources that you do not find reputable is
catholicscientists.org.
To the best of my recollection and doing a search on TO for it, this
is the first time you have ever referred to that site so once again,
you invent a claim about me that simply isn't true - I consider it a
very reputable site.
You are just prevaricating because it was Google that put up that
reference as support for it's acknowledgement that Augustine had used
Bible verses to support geocentrism. Google not only puts up a summary,
but it puts up references that can be used to confirm what it is
claiming. It was not my reference. It is just a citation that can be
used to support what was claimed. As you know in the part that you have >snipped out I state that they are the Google references.
This is supposed to be an international
organization of Catholic scientists.
No "supposed" about it, it is an international organisation of
Catholic scientists.
So what is not reputable about them? Why did you lie about the source
not being reputable?
The claim that you contested was that Augustine used Bible verses to
You need to demonstrate that the
author was wrong about Augustine's use of Bible verses to support
geocentrism.
Where does the author state that St Augustine related geocentrism to
Faith and Morals which are the only areas where the opinions of the
Church Fathers matter?
What a nut job. All that you required before was that Augustine "teach" >>> geocentrism, and that is exactly what he was doing. All the Council of
Trent required was concensus. All the church fathers were geocentrists. >>> Why keep lying about the situation? The Pope agreed with the
inquisition findings and had heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric
writings added to the Index in 1616.
Augustine used Bible verses to support his geocentric beliefs. That is
all the article needed to demonstrate. That is what you contested, and
moving the goal posts after finding out that you were wrong is stupid
and dishonest and doesn't change the fact of what Augustine did.
So the article doesn't say what you claimed it says. Plus |oa change.
support geocentrism.
That is the claim that I had made, that you said
was not true. You are the one that moved the goal posts to something
that I never claimed. Augustine did use Bible verses to "teach" >geocentrism.
Your previous claim about having had to teach the junk did
not contain anything about the spiritual or moral implications of
teaching geocentrism. Like all the other Church fathers Augustine >understood that the Biblical cosmology was geocentric, but he was OK
with that aspect of the creation.
He did have issues with other aspects
of Biblical creationism, but geocentrism was not one of them. Moving
the goal posts, does not change the fact that it is well understood that >Augustine used Bible verses to support Biblical geocentrism.
You can't change reality by trying to cover up what you do not want to >>>>> believe.
Your lame lie about reputable sources, is just as lame as your dishonest >>>>> quote mining of the papal document demonstrating that the pope had
heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric writings added to the Index. >>>>> Your source had been found to have lied about the Inquisition being the >>>>> only church body to have condemned heliocentrism. You can't demonstrate >>>>> that the Augustine Google cited sources are not reputable,
It's not up to me to do that - you are the one relying on them, it is
up to you to show they are reputable. Again, you know that, you're
just trying to wriggle your way out of it.
What a liar. You made the claim that the sources were not reputable,
you need to back up that lie or retract it.
The only source you have given that supports you is the guy promoting
geocentrism. I'm pretty sure that nobody here except you would regard
that as a reputable source, especially when qualified historians
directly contradict him.
Why keep lying. The sources that you claimed were not reputable were
cited by Google. You even claimed that the Wiki entry was not reputable >without demonstrating that the wiki was wrong about anything. I even
listed them as Google references. You need to support your bogus lie or >retract it.
The sources are just
repeating what has been known for centuries. They are just recent
examples where someone is noting what Augustine did. You need to
demonstrate that Augustine never did what everyone that understands the
situation knows that he did it.
It's not up to me or anyone to prove a negative; it's always up to the
person making a claim to prove it. You know that principle well;
asking me to prove a negative just highlights how far up your asshole
you have got about this.
It is the liar that needs to demonstrate that he is not lying, when all
that I had to do was demonstrate that the Catholic source cited by
Google was supposed to be a group of Catholic scientists as a counter to >your stupid lie. You need to demonstrate that Catholic scientists are
not reputable. The author of the article was an adjunct scientist at
the Vatican observatory. All that they were confirming was something
that other historians had already known about Augustine and geocentrism.
Augustine believed that the sun and moon were in motion, and not the
earth, and he used Bible verses to support his geocentric notions. At
that time in the early church there was no opposition to geocentrism,
and it was an acceptable aspect of the flat earth Hebrew cosmology.
Likely all the Church fathers understood that the earth was not flat
because the Greeks had used physical measurements to estimate the >circumference of the earth a couple of centuries before Christ was born.
Some of the authors of the New Testament books may have been flat
earth creationists, but there doesn't seem to be any evidence that the >intellectuals considered to be the Church Fathers were flat earth >creationists. They all understood that, that aspect of the Hebrew
Cosmology was wrong.
You just have to accept that the Bible was written by people that had an >incorrect cosmology.
Their young, flat earth geocentric cosmology never
existed, but it is the cosmology the Hebrew believed that their creator
had created. That is why Nature is not Biblical. The authors of the
Bible were describing a cosmology that they believed existed, not the
one that actually existed. Even if we wrote the Bible today we could
still be wrong about somethings because we lack a full understanding of >Nature. MarkE is wallowing in gap denial in order to keep believing a >Biblical scenario that only existed in the minds of the Hebrew authors
of the Bible.
Ron Okimoto
I was going off my memory of
Augustine's foible from what I learned 50 years ago, and things
obviously have not changed, since the Catholic reference was from 2022.
What is not reputable about an article written by an Adjunct Scholar at
the Vatican Observatory? You can't just lie about the source not being
reputable and then run from the lie and expect the lie to hold up.
Ron Okimoto
you can only
lie about it in your delusional state of not wanting reality to be what >>>>> it is. Really, you can lie about "reputable" sources when you know that >>>>> it is a well known fact that Augustine used Bible verses to support
geocentrism. It is insane to try to lie about something like this.
When I took Christian history as an undergraduate, Berkeley was on a 10 >>>>> week quarter system, and the prof. spent over a week on Augustine, and >>>>> had a book on Augustine as one of the 3 books that we had to buy for the >>>>> class. That was 50 years ago, and Google doesn't think that anything >>>>> has changed. Google just gave some more recent references that noted >>>>> what Augustine had done.
Ron Okimoto
The claim that you contested was that Augustine used Bible verses to
support geocentrism. That is the claim that I had made, that you said
was not true. You are the one that moved the goal posts to something
that I never claimed.
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 10:47:35 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
[snip for focus]
The claim that you contested was that Augustine used Bible verses to >>support geocentrism. That is the claim that I had made, that you said
was not true. You are the one that moved the goal posts to something
that I never claimed.
You are the one who keeps calling upon the Council of Trent for
support. Here is exactly what the Council said:
https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Canons_and_Decrees_of_the_Council_of_Trent/Session_IV/Sacred_Books
"Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, It decrees, that
no one, relying on his own skill, shall, in matters of faith, and of
morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, wresting
the sacred Scripture to his own senses, dare to interpret the said
sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,
whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy >Scriptures, hath held and doth hold; or even contrary to the unanimous >consent of the Fathers; even though suchlike interpretations were
never [intended] to be at any time published. They who shall
contravene shall be made known by their ordinaries, and be punished
with the penalties by law established."
It was the Council itself who stated the qualifier "in matters of
faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian
doctrine"
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 10:47:35 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/2/2026 9:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 21:19:35 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/2026 12:48 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
[mercy snip]
*Note to Ron* - mercy snip does NOT mean someone is agreeing with what
you posted or running from it; just that they are tired with your
endless repetition.
You are just lying, and you are snipping and running from your past
dishonest foibles.
One of the sources that you do not find reputable is
catholicscientists.org.
To the best of my recollection and doing a search on TO for it, this
is the first time you have ever referred to that site so once again,
you invent a claim about me that simply isn't true - I consider it a
very reputable site.
You are just prevaricating because it was Google that put up that
reference as support for it's acknowledgement that Augustine had used
Bible verses to support geocentrism. Google not only puts up a summary,
but it puts up references that can be used to confirm what it is
claiming. It was not my reference. It is just a citation that can be
used to support what was claimed. As you know in the part that you have
snipped out I state that they are the Google references.
This is supposed to be an international
organization of Catholic scientists.
No "supposed" about it, it is an international organisation of
Catholic scientists.
So what is not reputable about them? Why did you lie about the source
not being reputable?
I never said anything about them not being reputable. You made up a
lie about me saying they weren't reputable.
What a long and rambling attempt to divert attention away from the
fact that you cannot produce a single reputable source that supports
your claims about Augustin, the Church Fathers in general and the
Council of Trent. Sorry, Ron, it doesn't work. I reckon you must be
trying to convince yourself of this stuff; you can't seriously think
you're going to convince anyone else to accept the arguments put
forward by a kook trying to make a case for geocentrism.
The claim that you contested was that Augustine used Bible verses to
You need to demonstrate that the
author was wrong about Augustine's use of Bible verses to support
geocentrism.
Where does the author state that St Augustine related geocentrism to >>>>> Faith and Morals which are the only areas where the opinions of the
Church Fathers matter?
What a nut job. All that you required before was that Augustine "teach" >>>> geocentrism, and that is exactly what he was doing. All the Council of >>>> Trent required was concensus. All the church fathers were geocentrists. >>>> Why keep lying about the situation? The Pope agreed with the
inquisition findings and had heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric
writings added to the Index in 1616.
Augustine used Bible verses to support his geocentric beliefs. That is >>>> all the article needed to demonstrate. That is what you contested, and >>>> moving the goal posts after finding out that you were wrong is stupid
and dishonest and doesn't change the fact of what Augustine did.
So the article doesn't say what you claimed it says. Plus |oa change.
support geocentrism.
He didn't *support* geocentism; he accepted it as the scientific
paradigm of his time. You want to have it both ways. You want to
accuse the Church of not accept ingscience and then attack them for
accepting geocentrism when it was the scientific opinion.
That is the claim that I had made, that you said
was not true. You are the one that moved the goal posts to something
that I never claimed. Augustine did use Bible verses to "teach"
geocentrism.
Pity you can't give a cite from Augustine where he taught geocentrism.
Your previous claim about having had to teach the junk did
not contain anything about the spiritual or moral implications of
teaching geocentrism. Like all the other Church fathers Augustine
understood that the Biblical cosmology was geocentric, but he was OK
with that aspect of the creation.
He didn't give a toss about it. As he said himself:
"What concern is it to me whether the heavens as a sphere enclose the
earth in the middle of the world or overhang it on either side?"
He did have issues with other aspects
of Biblical creationism, but geocentrism was not one of them. Moving
the goal posts, does not change the fact that it is well understood that
Augustine used Bible verses to support Biblical geocentrism.
You can't change reality by trying to cover up what you do not want to >>>>>> believe.
Your lame lie about reputable sources, is just as lame as your dishonest >>>>>> quote mining of the papal document demonstrating that the pope had >>>>>> heliocentrism condemned and heliocentric writings added to the Index. >>>>>> Your source had been found to have lied about the Inquisition being the >>>>>> only church body to have condemned heliocentrism. You can't demonstrate >>>>>> that the Augustine Google cited sources are not reputable,
It's not up to me to do that - you are the one relying on them, it is >>>>> up to you to show they are reputable. Again, you know that, you're
just trying to wriggle your way out of it.
What a liar. You made the claim that the sources were not reputable,
you need to back up that lie or retract it.
The only source you have given that supports you is the guy promoting
geocentrism. I'm pretty sure that nobody here except you would regard
that as a reputable source, especially when qualified historians
directly contradict him.
Why keep lying. The sources that you claimed were not reputable were
cited by Google. You even claimed that the Wiki entry was not reputable
without demonstrating that the wiki was wrong about anything. I even
listed them as Google references. You need to support your bogus lie or
retract it.
The sources are just
repeating what has been known for centuries. They are just recent
examples where someone is noting what Augustine did. You need to
demonstrate that Augustine never did what everyone that understands the >>>> situation knows that he did it.
It's not up to me or anyone to prove a negative; it's always up to the
person making a claim to prove it. You know that principle well;
asking me to prove a negative just highlights how far up your asshole
you have got about this.
It is the liar that needs to demonstrate that he is not lying, when all
that I had to do was demonstrate that the Catholic source cited by
Google was supposed to be a group of Catholic scientists as a counter to
your stupid lie. You need to demonstrate that Catholic scientists are
not reputable. The author of the article was an adjunct scientist at
the Vatican observatory. All that they were confirming was something
that other historians had already known about Augustine and geocentrism.
Augustine believed that the sun and moon were in motion, and not the
earth, and he used Bible verses to support his geocentric notions. At
that time in the early church there was no opposition to geocentrism,
and it was an acceptable aspect of the flat earth Hebrew cosmology.
Likely all the Church fathers understood that the earth was not flat
because the Greeks had used physical measurements to estimate the
circumference of the earth a couple of centuries before Christ was born.
Some of the authors of the New Testament books may have been flat
earth creationists, but there doesn't seem to be any evidence that the
intellectuals considered to be the Church Fathers were flat earth
creationists. They all understood that, that aspect of the Hebrew
Cosmology was wrong.
You just have to accept that the Bible was written by people that had an
incorrect cosmology.
The Bible was not written as a cosmological treatise. Again, as
Augustine put it:
" 'Nowhere in the Gospel do we read that the Lord said: 'I am sending
you a Paraclete who will teach you about the course of the sun and
moon.' For He wanted to make Christians, not mathematicians.'
Their young, flat earth geocentric cosmology never
existed, but it is the cosmology the Hebrew believed that their creator
had created. That is why Nature is not Biblical. The authors of the
Bible were describing a cosmology that they believed existed, not the
one that actually existed. Even if we wrote the Bible today we could
still be wrong about somethings because we lack a full understanding of
Nature. MarkE is wallowing in gap denial in order to keep believing a
Biblical scenario that only existed in the minds of the Hebrew authors
of the Bible.
Ron Okimoto
I was going off my memory of
Augustine's foible from what I learned 50 years ago, and things
obviously have not changed, since the Catholic reference was from 2022. >>>> What is not reputable about an article written by an Adjunct Scholar at >>>> the Vatican Observatory? You can't just lie about the source not being >>>> reputable and then run from the lie and expect the lie to hold up.
Ron Okimoto
you can only
lie about it in your delusional state of not wanting reality to be what >>>>>> it is. Really, you can lie about "reputable" sources when you know that >>>>>> it is a well known fact that Augustine used Bible verses to support >>>>>> geocentrism. It is insane to try to lie about something like this. >>>>>> When I took Christian history as an undergraduate, Berkeley was on a 10 >>>>>> week quarter system, and the prof. spent over a week on Augustine, and >>>>>> had a book on Augustine as one of the 3 books that we had to buy for the >>>>>> class. That was 50 years ago, and Google doesn't think that anything >>>>>> has changed. Google just gave some more recent references that noted >>>>>> what Augustine had done.
Ron Okimoto
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 10:47:35 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
[snip for focus]
The claim that you contested was that Augustine used Bible verses to
support geocentrism. That is the claim that I had made, that you said
was not true. You are the one that moved the goal posts to something
that I never claimed.
You are the one who keeps calling upon the Council of Trent for
support. Here is exactly what the Council said:
https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Canons_and_Decrees_of_the_Council_of_Trent/Session_IV/Sacred_Books
"Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, It decrees, that
no one, relying on his own skill, shall, in matters of faith, and of
morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, wresting
the sacred Scripture to his own senses, dare to interpret the said
sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,
whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures, hath held and doth hold; or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though suchlike interpretations were
never [intended] to be at any time published. They who shall
contravene shall be made known by their ordinaries, and be punished
with the penalties by law established."
It was the Council itself who stated the qualifier "in matters of
faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian
doctrine"
On Mon, 02 Nov 2026 17:32:43 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 10:47:35 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
[snip for focus]
The claim that you contested was that Augustine used Bible verses to
support geocentrism. That is the claim that I had made, that you said
was not true. You are the one that moved the goal posts to something
that I never claimed.
You are the one who keeps calling upon the Council of Trent for
support. Here is exactly what the Council said:
https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Canons_and_Decrees_of_the_Council_of_Trent/Session_IV/Sacred_Books
"Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, It decrees, that
no one, relying on his own skill, shall, in matters of faith, and of
morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, wresting
the sacred Scripture to his own senses, dare to interpret the said
sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,
whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy
Scriptures, hath held and doth hold; or even contrary to the unanimous
consent of the Fathers; even though suchlike interpretations were
never [intended] to be at any time published. They who shall
contravene shall be made known by their ordinaries, and be punished
with the penalties by law established."
It was the Council itself who stated the qualifier "in matters of
faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian
doctrine"
I meant to add that your geocentrist mentor, in contradicting the
Church's interpretation of scripture, is himself the one who is
offending against Trent.
On 11/2/2026 11:14 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
This is supposed to be an international
organization of Catholic scientists.
No "supposed" about it, it is an international organisation of
Catholic scientists.
So what is not reputable about them? Why did you lie about the source
not being reputable?
I never said anything about them not being reputable. You made up a
lie about me saying they weren't reputable.
Your recollection is a lie. Quote from above and my response that you
have been prevaricating about for the last several posts. Where do you >think that I got "reputable" from?
QUOTE:
What a long and rambling attempt to divert attention away from the
fact that you cannot produce a single reputable source that supports
your claims about Augustin, the Church Fathers in general and the
Council of Trent. Sorry, Ron, it doesn't work. I reckon you must be
trying to convince yourself of this stuff; you can't seriously think
you're going to convince anyone else to accept the arguments put
forward by a kook trying to make a case for geocentrism.
Why keep lying about the situation. It is well known what Augustine
did, and two references were given.
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
Heliocentrism
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616.
The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of
the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy.
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 13:46:06 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/2/2026 11:14 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[...]
This is supposed to be an international
organization of Catholic scientists.
No "supposed" about it, it is an international organisation of
Catholic scientists.
So what is not reputable about them? Why did you lie about the source >>>> not being reputable?
I never said anything about them not being reputable. You made up a
lie about me saying they weren't reputable.
Your recollection is a lie. Quote from above and my response that you
have been prevaricating about for the last several posts. Where do you
think that I got "reputable" from?
QUOTE:
What a long and rambling attempt to divert attention away from theWhy keep lying about the situation. It is well known what Augustine
fact that you cannot produce a single reputable source that supports
your claims about Augustin, the Church Fathers in general and the
Council of Trent. Sorry, Ron, it doesn't work. I reckon you must be
trying to convince yourself of this stuff; you can't seriously think
you're going to convince anyone else to accept the arguments put
forward by a kook trying to make a case for geocentrism.
did, and two references were given.
OK, I missed out those two quotes buried in your long, rambling rant.
Not seeking to make excuses but my eyes are inclined to glaze over
when one of your endless diatribes is repeated for the umpteenth time
and I can easily miss something new that is buried in it.
Anyway, once again you rerence sites that do not support you, on the
contrary they contradict you
I cannot see any reference of any kind to geocentrism in the Catholic Scientists you referenced. On the contrary it says:
"St. Augustine, St. Thomas Aquinas, and John Calvin all took the words
of astronomers over a plain reading of Genesis 1:14-16. All three
argued for interpreting these scriptural verses in light of what
science had discovered and therefore held those verses to be
describing celestial bodies not as they are in themselves, but as they
appear to human eyes."
It was actually far-reaching of Augustine to recognise that the
structure of the universe could be very different from what it
appeared.
The second link again makes no reference to geocentrism. It states out
that
"Augustine recommends prudence when multiple interpretations of a
passage are possible, and warns against presenting specific readings
as if they are absolute and unquestionable"
and goes on to highlight Augustine's warning about the foolishness of
trying to use scripture to deal with things found by science. It
beats me how you see that supporting your claims.
[...]
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
Heliocentrism
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616.
The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of
the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy.
The Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You
have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to
declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim
support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church.
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism
was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What
they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it
was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time.
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document
that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be
true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's
how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly
with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing
the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible.
That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's
wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have
never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how
Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be
true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent
that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church
and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of
passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to
be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific
aspects.
On 11/5/2026 4:12 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
Heliocentrism
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616.
The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of
the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy.
The Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You
have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to
declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim
support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church.
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an
opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism
was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What
they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it
was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time.
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a
hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document
that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be
true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's
how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly
with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing
the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible.
That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's
wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have
never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as
hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how
Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be
true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent
that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church
and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of
passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to
be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific
aspects.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/inquisition-copernicus-february-24-1616-little-story-punctuation-re-run/
QUOTE:
rCLScientifically untenable and theologically heretical.rCY That is how a >committee of consultants for the Roman Inquisition assessed the
heliocentric theory four hundred years ago today, on February 24,
1616rCoor, that is how the historian Maurice Finocchiaro paraphrases their >assessment. Well, there is an interesting story about exactly what it
was the consultants said.
END QUOTE:
Two different translations:
QUOTE:
All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and >formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the
sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words
and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy >Fathers and the doctors of theology.
But another highly regarded historian, Albert van Helden, translates this as
All declared the said proposition to be foolish and absurd in philosophy
and formally heretical, because it expressly contradicts the doctrine of
the Holy Scripture in many passages, both in their literal meaning and >according to the general interpretation of the Fathers and the Doctors
of the Church.
END QUOTE:
Both translations claim "formally heretical" as the Wiki judgement
section claimed.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 10:58:44 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/5/2026 4:12 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
Heliocentrism
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616.
The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of >>>> the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy.
The Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You
have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to
declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim
support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church.
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an
opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism
was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What
they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it
was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time.
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a
hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document
that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be
true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's
how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly
with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing
the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible.
That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's
wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have
never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as
hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how
Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be
true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent
that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church
and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of
passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to
be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific
aspects.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/inquisition-copernicus-february-24-1616-little-story-punctuation-re-run/
QUOTE:
rCLScientifically untenable and theologically heretical.rCY That is how a
committee of consultants for the Roman Inquisition assessed the
heliocentric theory four hundred years ago today, on February 24,
1616rCoor, that is how the historian Maurice Finocchiaro paraphrases their >> assessment. Well, there is an interesting story about exactly what it
was the consultants said.
END QUOTE:
Two different translations:
QUOTE:
All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and
formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the
sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words
and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy
Fathers and the doctors of theology.
But another highly regarded historian, Albert van Helden, translates this as >>
All declared the said proposition to be foolish and absurd in philosophy
and formally heretical, because it expressly contradicts the doctrine of
the Holy Scripture in many passages, both in their literal meaning and
according to the general interpretation of the Fathers and the Doctors
of the Church.
END QUOTE:
Both translations claim "formally heretical" as the Wiki judgement
section claimed.
So what? As your Wiki points out, their opinion was not binding. The
people in charge were the Inquisition, and they decided to ignore the conclusion, whatever way it was worded is irrelevant. Theye were the
only ones with authority to declare a heresy and they did NOT do so.
Why do you keep insisting that they did so when the decree is readily available for checking and anyone can see that it doesn't mention
heresy anywhere in regard to heliocentrism.
On 11/5/2026 3:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 10:58:44 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:So what? Heliocentrism was considered to be formal heresy when Galileo >faced the issue in 1616.
On 11/5/2026 4:12 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
Heliocentrism
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616. >>>>> The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of >>>>> the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy.
The Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You
have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to
declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim
support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church.
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an >>>> opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism
was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What
they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it >>>> was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time.
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a
hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document
that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be
true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's
how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly
with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing
the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible.
That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's
wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have
never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as
hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how
Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be
true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent
that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church
and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of
passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to
be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific
aspects.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/inquisition-copernicus-february-24-1616-little-story-punctuation-re-run/
QUOTE:
rCLScientifically untenable and theologically heretical.rCY That is how a >>> committee of consultants for the Roman Inquisition assessed the
heliocentric theory four hundred years ago today, on February 24,
1616rCoor, that is how the historian Maurice Finocchiaro paraphrases their >>> assessment. Well, there is an interesting story about exactly what it
was the consultants said.
END QUOTE:
Two different translations:
QUOTE:
All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and
formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the
sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words
and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy >>> Fathers and the doctors of theology.
But another highly regarded historian, Albert van Helden, translates this as
All declared the said proposition to be foolish and absurd in philosophy >>> and formally heretical, because it expressly contradicts the doctrine of >>> the Holy Scripture in many passages, both in their literal meaning and
according to the general interpretation of the Fathers and the Doctors
of the Church.
END QUOTE:
Both translations claim "formally heretical" as the Wiki judgement
section claimed.
So what? As your Wiki points out, their opinion was not binding. The
people in charge were the Inquisition, and they decided to ignore the
conclusion, whatever way it was worded is irrelevant. Theye were the
only ones with authority to declare a heresy and they did NOT do so.
Why do you keep insisting that they did so when the decree is readily
available for checking and anyone can see that it doesn't mention
heresy anywhere in regard to heliocentrism.
It is what it was considered to be. The Pope
agreed with the Inquisition and condemned heliocentrism (you know what >condemned means) and added heliocentric writings to the Index (and you
know what that means).
Ron Okimoto
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 17:21:16 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/5/2026 3:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 10:58:44 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:So what? Heliocentrism was considered to be formal heresy when Galileo
On 11/5/2026 4:12 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
Heliocentrism
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616. >>>>>> The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of >>>>>> the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy.
The Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You >>>>> have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to
declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim
support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church. >>>>>
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an >>>>> opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism >>>>> was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What >>>>> they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it >>>>> was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time.
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a >>>>> hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document
that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be
true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's >>>>> how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly
with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing >>>>> the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible.
That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's
wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have
never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as
hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how
Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be
true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent >>>>> that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church >>>>> and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of
passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to >>>>> be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific
aspects.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/inquisition-copernicus-february-24-1616-little-story-punctuation-re-run/
QUOTE:
rCLScientifically untenable and theologically heretical.rCY That is how a >>>> committee of consultants for the Roman Inquisition assessed the
heliocentric theory four hundred years ago today, on February 24,
1616rCoor, that is how the historian Maurice Finocchiaro paraphrases their >>>> assessment. Well, there is an interesting story about exactly what it >>>> was the consultants said.
END QUOTE:
Two different translations:
QUOTE:
All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and >>>> formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the
sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words >>>> and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy >>>> Fathers and the doctors of theology.
But another highly regarded historian, Albert van Helden, translates this as
All declared the said proposition to be foolish and absurd in philosophy >>>> and formally heretical, because it expressly contradicts the doctrine of >>>> the Holy Scripture in many passages, both in their literal meaning and >>>> according to the general interpretation of the Fathers and the Doctors >>>> of the Church.
END QUOTE:
Both translations claim "formally heretical" as the Wiki judgement
section claimed.
So what? As your Wiki points out, their opinion was not binding. The
people in charge were the Inquisition, and they decided to ignore the
conclusion, whatever way it was worded is irrelevant. Theye were the
only ones with authority to declare a heresy and they did NOT do so.
Why do you keep insisting that they did so when the decree is readily
available for checking and anyone can see that it doesn't mention
heresy anywhere in regard to heliocentrism.
faced the issue in 1616.
You have been insisting all along that the Inquisition declared
heliocentrism a heresy in 1616. Now you are claiming it already was a
heresy. Just when I thought you couldn't dig your hole any deeper, you
turn round and do so.
It is what it was considered to be. The Pope
agreed with the Inquisition and condemned heliocentrism (you know what
condemned means) and added heliocentric writings to the Index (and you
know what that means).
Ron Okimoto
On 11/6/2026 2:25 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 17:21:16 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/5/2026 3:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 10:58:44 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>So what? Heliocentrism was considered to be formal heresy when Galileo
On 11/5/2026 4:12 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
Heliocentrism
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616. >>>>>>> The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of >>>>>>> the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy.
The Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You >>>>>> have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to
declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim
support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church. >>>>>>
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an >>>>>> opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism >>>>>> was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What >>>>>> they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it >>>>>> was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time. >>>>>>
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a >>>>>> hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document >>>>>> that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be >>>>>> true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's >>>>>> how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly >>>>>> with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing >>>>>> the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible.
That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's
wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have
never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as
hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how >>>>>> Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be >>>>>> true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent >>>>>> that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church >>>>>> and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of >>>>>> passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to >>>>>> be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific
aspects.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/inquisition-copernicus-february-24-1616-little-story-punctuation-re-run/
QUOTE:
"Scientifically untenable and theologically heretical." That is how a >>>>> committee of consultants for the Roman Inquisition assessed the
heliocentric theory four hundred years ago today, on February 24,
1616-or, that is how the historian Maurice Finocchiaro paraphrases their >>>>> assessment. Well, there is an interesting story about exactly what it >>>>> was the consultants said.
END QUOTE:
Two different translations:
QUOTE:
All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and >>>>> formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the >>>>> sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words >>>>> and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy >>>>> Fathers and the doctors of theology.
But another highly regarded historian, Albert van Helden, translates this as
All declared the said proposition to be foolish and absurd in philosophy >>>>> and formally heretical, because it expressly contradicts the doctrine of >>>>> the Holy Scripture in many passages, both in their literal meaning and >>>>> according to the general interpretation of the Fathers and the Doctors >>>>> of the Church.
END QUOTE:
Both translations claim "formally heretical" as the Wiki judgement
section claimed.
So what? As your Wiki points out, their opinion was not binding. The
people in charge were the Inquisition, and they decided to ignore the
conclusion, whatever way it was worded is irrelevant. Theye were the
only ones with authority to declare a heresy and they did NOT do so.
Why do you keep insisting that they did so when the decree is readily
available for checking and anyone can see that it doesn't mention
heresy anywhere in regard to heliocentrism.
faced the issue in 1616.
You have been insisting all along that the Inquisition declared
heliocentrism a heresy in 1616. Now you are claiming it already was a
heresy. Just when I thought you couldn't dig your hole any deeper, you
turn round and do so.
Why keep prevaricating about the issue.
Galileo first faced the issue
in 1616. You have lied about the situation for years. He was not
charged with heresy, he went to Rome to defend his actions.
When was it
established that heliocentrism was a formal heresy?
He likely made the
Inquistion initiate their confirmation of heresy for heliocentrism.
Cardinal Bellarmine made his warning to Galileo and Galileo accepted it >after the Inquisition had determined that heliocentrism was a formal heresy.
As you can't deal with the reality stated below that the Pope agreed
with the Inquisition in 1616 and had heliocentrism condemned and >heliocentric writings added to the index.
Ron Okimoto
It is what it was considered to be. The Pope
agreed with the Inquisition and condemned heliocentrism (you know what
condemned means) and added heliocentric writings to the Index (and you
know what that means).
Ron Okimoto
On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 09:54:36 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/6/2026 2:25 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 17:21:16 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/5/2026 3:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 10:58:44 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>So what? Heliocentrism was considered to be formal heresy when Galileo >>>> faced the issue in 1616.
On 11/5/2026 4:12 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
Heliocentrism
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616. >>>>>>>> The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of >>>>>>>> the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy.
The Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You >>>>>>> have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to >>>>>>> declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim
support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church. >>>>>>>
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an >>>>>>> opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism >>>>>>> was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What >>>>>>> they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it >>>>>>> was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time. >>>>>>>
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a >>>>>>> hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document >>>>>>> that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be >>>>>>> true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's >>>>>>> how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly >>>>>>> with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing >>>>>>> the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible. >>>>>>> That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's >>>>>>> wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have >>>>>>> never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as >>>>>>> hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how >>>>>>> Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be >>>>>>> true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent >>>>>>> that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church >>>>>>> and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of >>>>>>> passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to >>>>>>> be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific >>>>>>> aspects.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/inquisition-copernicus-february-24-1616-little-story-punctuation-re-run/
QUOTE:
"Scientifically untenable and theologically heretical." That is how a >>>>>> committee of consultants for the Roman Inquisition assessed the
heliocentric theory four hundred years ago today, on February 24,
1616-or, that is how the historian Maurice Finocchiaro paraphrases their >>>>>> assessment. Well, there is an interesting story about exactly what it >>>>>> was the consultants said.
END QUOTE:
Two different translations:
QUOTE:
All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and >>>>>> formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the >>>>>> sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words >>>>>> and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy >>>>>> Fathers and the doctors of theology.
But another highly regarded historian, Albert van Helden, translates this as
All declared the said proposition to be foolish and absurd in philosophy >>>>>> and formally heretical, because it expressly contradicts the doctrine of >>>>>> the Holy Scripture in many passages, both in their literal meaning and >>>>>> according to the general interpretation of the Fathers and the Doctors >>>>>> of the Church.
END QUOTE:
Both translations claim "formally heretical" as the Wiki judgement >>>>>> section claimed.
So what? As your Wiki points out, their opinion was not binding. The >>>>> people in charge were the Inquisition, and they decided to ignore the >>>>> conclusion, whatever way it was worded is irrelevant. Theye were the >>>>> only ones with authority to declare a heresy and they did NOT do so. >>>>>
Why do you keep insisting that they did so when the decree is readily >>>>> available for checking and anyone can see that it doesn't mention
heresy anywhere in regard to heliocentrism.
You have been insisting all along that the Inquisition declared
heliocentrism a heresy in 1616. Now you are claiming it already was a
heresy. Just when I thought you couldn't dig your hole any deeper, you
turn round and do so.
Why keep prevaricating about the issue.
You are the one prevaricating. First you claim the Inquisition
declared heliocentrism a heresy in 1616; then you claim already was a
heresy.
Galileo first faced the issue
in 1616. You have lied about the situation for years. He was not
charged with heresy, he went to Rome to defend his actions.
The last time round, you persistently insisted I was wrong and that he
was charged with heresy in 1616, I guess it is some progress that you
now recognise you got at least that bit wrong. It would have been nice
of you to admit that you got it wrong but I guess that's too much to
expect.
Unfortunately, you still haven't got it quite right. Galileo did not
have to "defend his actions" in 1616, his actions have already been investigated and he had been cleared. That was back in the previous
year when two Dominicans complained about him to the Inquisition
claiming that his Letter to Castelli was heretical and reporting
various rumours that were circulating in Florence about Galileo and
his supporters. [1] In regard to the Letter to Castelli, the
Inquisition found that "it does not diverge from the pathways of
Catholic expression" and they dismissed the stories from Florence as
baseless hearsay. [2]
When was it
established that heliocentrism was a formal heresy?
Never. I've also told you multiple times that there isn't even such a
thing as a belief being a "formal heresy" - the word "formal" applies
to the awareness of the person committing heresy and is "the wilful
and persistent adherence to an error in matters of faith" on the part
of a baptised person. [3]
He likely made the
Inquistion initiate their confirmation of heresy for heliocentrism.
Cardinal Bellarmine made his warning to Galileo and Galileo accepted it
after the Inquisition had determined that heliocentrism was a formal heresy.
Bellarmine's warning was to not promote heliocentrism as conclusive
and to stay away from scripture. Galileo agreed to do so and that's
why he was able to continue with his work on it. False rumours were
spread afterwards about what happened between Galileo and Bellarmine
and in order to clear the air, Bellarmine wrote out a signed statement
that Galileo had neither abjured nor done penance, but had merely been informed of the general edict governing all Catholics.
As you can't deal with the reality stated below that the Pope agreed
with the Inquisition in 1616 and had heliocentrism condemned and
heliocentric writings added to the index.
The Pope not only agreed with the Inquisition, he approved their final
decree and ordered it to be published. That decree, which you have persistently claimed declared heliocentrism a heresy, makes no mention whatsoever of heresy in regard to heliocentrism. What it does is what
I summarised above: it declared heliocentrism to be false (the
scientific consensus at the time); it banned the promotion of
heliocentrism as anything other than hypothesis (but did not ban work continuing on it); it banned heliocentrism being used to reinterpret Scripture by people not authorised to do so.
Just 5 days after the decree was published, Galileo had an audience
with the Pope in which the Pope assured him that he knew Galileo's
integrity and sincerity, told him not to worry, said that not only he
but the entire Congregation of the Holy Office knew about his unjust persecutions, and added the unusual remark that so long as he, Paul V,
lived, Galileo remained secure. [4]
=========================================
[1] The two Dominicans, Niccol|# Lorini and Tommaso Caccini were acting
at their own instigation, not on behalf of the Dominican order.
Following a sermon from Caccini the previous December where he
attacked heliocentrism and mocked Galileo, Father Luigi Maraffi, the Preacher-General and highest administrative authority of the Dominican
Order, sent Galileo a written letter of apology expressing bitter
regret for Caccini's behavior, saying "unfortunately I have to answer
for all the idiocies that thirty or forty thousand brothers may or
actually do commit" and described Caccini's action as madness and
ignorance. [Drake, Stillman. 'Galileo at work: His scientific
biography'. The University of Chicago Press,1978, p239]
[2] Finocchiaro, Maurice A. 'Defending Copernicus and Galileo:
Critical reasoning in the two affairs.' Springer Science & Business
Media, 2010, p140
[3]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_heresies_in_the_Catholic_Church
[4] Drake, Stillman. 'Galileo at work: His scientific biography'. The University of Chicago Press,1978, p256
Ron Okimoto
It is what it was considered to be. The Pope
agreed with the Inquisition and condemned heliocentrism (you know what >>>> condemned means) and added heliocentric writings to the Index (and you >>>> know what that means).
Ron Okimoto
On 11/7/2026 6:43 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 09:54:36 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/6/2026 2:25 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 17:21:16 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>
On 11/5/2026 3:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 10:58:44 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>So what? Heliocentrism was considered to be formal heresy when Galileo >>>>> faced the issue in 1616.
On 11/5/2026 4:12 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>>
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
HeliocentrismThe Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You >>>>>>>> have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to >>>>>>>> declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim >>>>>>>> support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church. >>>>>>>>
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616. >>>>>>>>> The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of
the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy. >>>>>>>>
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an >>>>>>>> opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism >>>>>>>> was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What >>>>>>>> they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it >>>>>>>> was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time. >>>>>>>>
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a >>>>>>>> hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document >>>>>>>> that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be >>>>>>>> true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's >>>>>>>> how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly >>>>>>>> with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing >>>>>>>> the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible. >>>>>>>> That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's >>>>>>>> wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have >>>>>>>> never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as >>>>>>>> hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how >>>>>>>> Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be >>>>>>>> true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent >>>>>>>> that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church >>>>>>>> and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of >>>>>>>> passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to >>>>>>>> be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific >>>>>>>> aspects.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/inquisition-copernicus-february-24-1616-little-story-punctuation-re-run/
QUOTE:
"Scientifically untenable and theologically heretical." That is how a >>>>>>> committee of consultants for the Roman Inquisition assessed the
heliocentric theory four hundred years ago today, on February 24, >>>>>>> 1616-or, that is how the historian Maurice Finocchiaro paraphrases their
assessment. Well, there is an interesting story about exactly what it >>>>>>> was the consultants said.
END QUOTE:
Two different translations:
QUOTE:
All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and >>>>>>> formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the >>>>>>> sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words >>>>>>> and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy
Fathers and the doctors of theology.
But another highly regarded historian, Albert van Helden, translates this as
All declared the said proposition to be foolish and absurd in philosophy
and formally heretical, because it expressly contradicts the doctrine of
the Holy Scripture in many passages, both in their literal meaning and >>>>>>> according to the general interpretation of the Fathers and the Doctors >>>>>>> of the Church.
END QUOTE:
Both translations claim "formally heretical" as the Wiki judgement >>>>>>> section claimed.
So what? As your Wiki points out, their opinion was not binding. The >>>>>> people in charge were the Inquisition, and they decided to ignore the >>>>>> conclusion, whatever way it was worded is irrelevant. Theye were the >>>>>> only ones with authority to declare a heresy and they did NOT do so. >>>>>>
Why do you keep insisting that they did so when the decree is readily >>>>>> available for checking and anyone can see that it doesn't mention
heresy anywhere in regard to heliocentrism.
You have been insisting all along that the Inquisition declared
heliocentrism a heresy in 1616. Now you are claiming it already was a
heresy. Just when I thought you couldn't dig your hole any deeper, you >>>> turn round and do so.
Why keep prevaricating about the issue.
You are the one prevaricating. First you claim the Inquisition
declared heliocentrism a heresy in 1616; then you claim already was a
heresy.
Why keep lying about the past. I have always claimed that heliocentrism
was considered to be heresy both times that Galileo faced the issue in
1616 and 1633. My sources had demonstrated that heliocentrism was >considered to be formal heresy in 1616, and it was only written up as
heresy in the sentencing of Galileo in 1633. That was years ago. You
are the one that denied that reality. You lied about my sources not
being reliable when you could not demonstrate that they were wrong about >heliocentrism. You now know that your own trusted source supported my >sources and claimed that heliocentrism was considered to be a heresy
both times that Galileo faced the issue. Your source did not make the >distinction between formal heresy and heresy. In order to prevaricate
about your own source you put up the sentencing where the word "formal"
had been left out, but the sentencing still claimed heliocentrism was
heresy and clearly defined the heresy. You tried to quote mine the wiki >when the wiki continued to claim that heliocentrism was a formal heresy
in 1616 in the Judgement section of the wiki. You know that the Pope
agreed with the Inquisition in 1616 and condemned heliocentrism and
added heliocentric writings to the index. Your quote mining the >condemnation did not change what the Pope had done. It was your source
that came up short and had lied about the situation in 1616. Your
stupid dishonest antics trying to support the lie that your source had
tried to get away with was just tragically lame and stupid. It
Inquistion was not the only church body to have condemned heliocentrism.
The Vatican Observatory was very matter of fact that the Pope had
condemned heliocentrism in 1616, and even quoted the condemnation. Your >quote mining of what they quoted did not change what the Pope had done.
You just need to stop lying about the past and accept reality. You need
to apologize for harassing me with your lies.
Galileo first faced the issue
in 1616. You have lied about the situation for years. He was not
charged with heresy, he went to Rome to defend his actions.
The last time round, you persistently insisted I was wrong and that he
was charged with heresy in 1616, I guess it is some progress that you
now recognise you got at least that bit wrong. It would have been nice
of you to admit that you got it wrong but I guess that's too much to
expect.
I said he faced the charge of heresy. I acknowledged that he was never >formally charged in 1616, but the Inquisition rejected his arguments,
and believed that Galileo believed the heresy, but they did not have a
case because Galileo claimed that he did not believe in heliocentrism
and that putting up data supporting the notion did not mean belief. My
take is that Galileo did not believe that heliocentrism to be heresy,
but the Inquisition required proof that heliocentrism was true, and
Galileo did not have "proof". Galileo was unable to keep the
Inquisition from concluding that heliocentrism was formally heretical.
In 1633 Galileo tried the same defense by claiming that he did not
believe in the heliocentrism, but the compromise document from 1616 was >produced that had Galileo stop teaching, defending, or discussing >heliocentrism. Google claims that the document is controversial, and
may have been a forgery, but Galileo did not deny the document. It
doesn't matter because violating the instructions would mean that
Galileo was guilty of heresy in 1616.
Google Quote:
1. The Context of the 1616 "Injunction"
In February 1616, the Catholic Church's Theological Advisory Committee >formally declared heliocentrism to be "philosophically foolish" and >"formally heretical". Pope Paul V ordered Cardinal Robert Bellarmine to >summon Galileo and privately warn him to abandon Copernicanism.
The Pope's explicit instructions were:
1. Cardinal Bellarmine must warn Galileo to abandon heliocentrism.
2. If Galileo refused, the Father Commissary of the Inquisition was to
step forward in front of a notary and witnesses to issue a strict legal >injunction commanding Galileo to abstain completely from teaching, >defending, or even discussing it.
3. If Galileo still did not comply, he was to be imprisoned.
END Google quote:
It doesn't matter if the document was a forgery. Heliocentrism would >continue to be considered to be heresy both times that Galileo faced the >issue.
Unfortunately, you still haven't got it quite right. Galileo did not
have to "defend his actions" in 1616, his actions have already been
investigated and he had been cleared. That was back in the previous
year when two Dominicans complained about him to the Inquisition
claiming that his Letter to Castelli was heretical and reporting
various rumours that were circulating in Florence about Galileo and
his supporters. [1] In regard to the Letter to Castelli, the
Inquisition found that "it does not diverge from the pathways of
Catholic expression" and they dismissed the stories from Florence as
baseless hearsay. [2]
He had obviously not been cleared because when he went to Rome to defend
his writings the Inquisition wanted to charge him, but Galileo had never >confessed to believing in the heresy, and he consistently claimed that
he did not believe in the heresy. They did not have a case. The Pope >agreed with Galileo that just writing about evidence that would support >heliocentrism was not the same as believing the heresy, but the Google
quote would indicate that he did not want Galileo to continue to support
the heresy in any way.
When was it
established that heliocentrism was a formal heresy?
Never. I've also told you multiple times that there isn't even such a
thing as a belief being a "formal heresy" - the word "formal" applies
to the awareness of the person committing heresy and is "the wilful
and persistent adherence to an error in matters of faith" on the part
of a baptised person. [3]
It is the anti geocentric Catholics that think that "formal" means >something. Just as your source trying to use the sentencing in order to >deny "formal heresy" in the 1633 case. Why lie about the situation.
What was the conclusion of the Inquisition in 1616 and was a conclusion
that the Pope agreed with? Just because everyone wants to lie about the >situation and prevaricate about what went down does not matter. >Heliocentrism was still considered to be heresy in 1633. The anti >geocentric web site admitted that it was an issue within the church and
that the Pope had the 1633 case and sentencing published and distributed >throughout the church in order to quash heliocentric supporters within
the Church. They only claimed that, that act was not an official Papal >action because they wanted to preserve Papal infallibility, which is
just stupid in this day and age. It is what the Pope did and why he did
it that matters.
He likely made the
Inquistion initiate their confirmation of heresy for heliocentrism.
Cardinal Bellarmine made his warning to Galileo and Galileo accepted it
after the Inquisition had determined that heliocentrism was a formal heresy.
Bellarmine's warning was to not promote heliocentrism as conclusive
and to stay away from scripture. Galileo agreed to do so and that's
why he was able to continue with his work on it. False rumours were
spread afterwards about what happened between Galileo and Bellarmine
and in order to clear the air, Bellarmine wrote out a signed statement
that Galileo had neither abjured nor done penance, but had merely been
informed of the general edict governing all Catholics.
That is the letter that Galileo brought to the court, not the document
that was used to convict him. The Inquisition contended that Galileo had >agreed to something that he had disregarded.
All of this does not matter. What matters is that heliocentrism was >considered to be heresy both times that Galileo faced the issue, and the >Pope agreed with the Inquisition in 1616 had condemned heliocentrism and >added heliocentric writings to the index.
As you can't deal with the reality stated below that the Pope agreed
with the Inquisition in 1616 and had heliocentrism condemned and
heliocentric writings added to the index.
The Pope not only agreed with the Inquisition, he approved their final
decree and ordered it to be published. That decree, which you have
persistently claimed declared heliocentrism a heresy, makes no mention
whatsoever of heresy in regard to heliocentrism. What it does is what
I summarised above: it declared heliocentrism to be false (the
scientific consensus at the time); it banned the promotion of
heliocentrism as anything other than hypothesis (but did not ban work
continuing on it); it banned heliocentrism being used to reinterpret
Scripture by people not authorised to do so.
Just 5 days after the decree was published, Galileo had an audience
with the Pope in which the Pope assured him that he knew Galileo's
integrity and sincerity, told him not to worry, said that not only he
but the entire Congregation of the Holy Office knew about his unjust
persecutions, and added the unusual remark that so long as he, Paul V,
lived, Galileo remained secure. [4]
Too bad, but what has always been claimed is that the qualifiers made
the determination and a summary of their conclusions has always been
used to demonstrate that they made that conclusion. I put up two >translations that the Vatican observatory put up for the document. Both >translations call heliocentrism formally heretical. Even the wiki had
cited that document.
=========================================
[1] The two Dominicans, Niccol|# Lorini and Tommaso Caccini were acting
at their own instigation, not on behalf of the Dominican order.
Following a sermon from Caccini the previous December where he
attacked heliocentrism and mocked Galileo, Father Luigi Maraffi, the
Preacher-General and highest administrative authority of the Dominican
Order, sent Galileo a written letter of apology expressing bitter
regret for Caccini's behavior, saying "unfortunately I have to answer
for all the idiocies that thirty or forty thousand brothers may or
actually do commit" and described Caccini's action as madness and
ignorance. [Drake, Stillman. 'Galileo at work: His scientific
biography'. The University of Chicago Press,1978, p239]
[2] Finocchiaro, Maurice A. 'Defending Copernicus and Galileo:
Critical reasoning in the two affairs.' Springer Science & Business
Media, 2010, p140
[3]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_heresies_in_the_Catholic_Church
[4] Drake, Stillman. 'Galileo at work: His scientific biography'. The
University of Chicago Press,1978, p256
In the 1633 sentencing it was called heresy, the heresy was clearly
defined, and Galileo was found to be guilty. Prevaricating about the
issue is just stupid and dishonest. You have been wrong for years, and
have lied about the issue for years. Nothing will ever change the fact
that heliocentrism was considered to be heresy both times that Galileo
faced the issue in 1616, and 1633.
The authors of the Bible believed in an ancient flat earth geocentric >cosmology that never existed. Interpretation of the Bible has always
had to be incorrect because Nature is not Biblical. The Church
understood this, but they believed that the Bible was correct about >geocentrism. They did not believe that the Bible was correct about a
flat earth (the majority, there are still flat earth geocentric
Christians and Jews that exist today). The Inquisition understood that
if Galileo had proof that heliocentrism was true that heliocentrism
would not be considered to be heretical, but Galileo did not have that >proof, and the Church Fathers may not have been flat earthers, but they >remained geocentrists.
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 10:18:44 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/7/2026 6:43 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 09:54:36 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/6/2026 2:25 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 17:21:16 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 11/5/2026 3:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 10:58:44 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>So what? Heliocentrism was considered to be formal heresy when Galileo >>>>>> faced the issue in 1616.
On 11/5/2026 4:12 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 14:26:01 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/2/2026 11:32 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[rCa]
HeliocentrismThe Inquisition did NOT make it into any kind of heresy in 1616. You >>>>>>>>> have been told ad nauseum that the Inquirers had no authority to >>>>>>>>> declare a heresy. Even the Wiki article that you tried to claim >>>>>>>>> support you states that their opinion was not binding on the Church. >>>>>>>>>
did not become a formal heresy until Galileo faced the issue in 1616.
The Inquisition used the Council of Trent and the unanimous consent of
the Church Fathers to make heliocentrism into a formal heresy. >>>>>>>>>
The Inquirers were consultants appointed by the Inquisition to give an
opinion on heliocentrism; they gave their opinion that heliocentrism >>>>>>>>> was heretical but the Inquisition chose to ignore that opinion. What >>>>>>>>> they said in their final; decree was:
1) Heliocentrism was false. That was not a theological conclusion, it
was simply the acceptance of the scientific consensus at that time. >>>>>>>>>
2) They banned any promotion of heliocentrism as anything more than a >>>>>>>>> hypothetical; Cardinal Bellarmine made clear in a separate document >>>>>>>>> that that would change if it heliocentrism to be demonstrated to be >>>>>>>>> true. They did not prohibit any further investigation into
heliocentrism provided its hypothetical status was recognised; that's >>>>>>>>> how Galileo was able to carry on with his work, debating it openly >>>>>>>>> with the Pope and being given authorisation to publish a book arguing >>>>>>>>> the pros and cons of heliocentrism.
2) They banned the use of heliocentrism to reinterpret the Bible. >>>>>>>>> That's why Foscarini's book was banned outright but Copernicus's >>>>>>>>> wasn't, one of the contradictions in your arguments that you have >>>>>>>>> never been able to explain. Both authors treated heliocentrism as >>>>>>>>> hypothetical but Foscarini went into a detailed description of how >>>>>>>>> Scripture could be reinterpreted if heliocentrism were shown to be >>>>>>>>> true; that was contrary to church teaching from the Council of Trent >>>>>>>>> that interpretation of Scripture was strictly reserved to the Church >>>>>>>>> and its appointed authorities. Copernicus had only made a couple of >>>>>>>>> passing references to Scripture and the Inquisition ordered those to >>>>>>>>> be deleted; they did not modify or restrict any of the scientific >>>>>>>>> aspects.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/inquisition-copernicus-february-24-1616-little-story-punctuation-re-run/
QUOTE:
"Scientifically untenable and theologically heretical." That is how a >>>>>>>> committee of consultants for the Roman Inquisition assessed the >>>>>>>> heliocentric theory four hundred years ago today, on February 24, >>>>>>>> 1616-or, that is how the historian Maurice Finocchiaro paraphrases their
assessment. Well, there is an interesting story about exactly what it >>>>>>>> was the consultants said.
END QUOTE:
Two different translations:
QUOTE:
All said that this proposition is foolish and absurd in philosophy, and
formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the >>>>>>>> sense of Holy Scripture, according to the literal meaning of the words >>>>>>>> and according to the common interpretation and understanding of the Holy
Fathers and the doctors of theology.
But another highly regarded historian, Albert van Helden, translates this as
All declared the said proposition to be foolish and absurd in philosophy
and formally heretical, because it expressly contradicts the doctrine of
the Holy Scripture in many passages, both in their literal meaning and >>>>>>>> according to the general interpretation of the Fathers and the Doctors >>>>>>>> of the Church.
END QUOTE:
Both translations claim "formally heretical" as the Wiki judgement >>>>>>>> section claimed.
So what? As your Wiki points out, their opinion was not binding. The >>>>>>> people in charge were the Inquisition, and they decided to ignore the >>>>>>> conclusion, whatever way it was worded is irrelevant. Theye were the >>>>>>> only ones with authority to declare a heresy and they did NOT do so. >>>>>>>
Why do you keep insisting that they did so when the decree is readily >>>>>>> available for checking and anyone can see that it doesn't mention >>>>>>> heresy anywhere in regard to heliocentrism.
You have been insisting all along that the Inquisition declared
heliocentrism a heresy in 1616. Now you are claiming it already was a >>>>> heresy. Just when I thought you couldn't dig your hole any deeper, you >>>>> turn round and do so.
Why keep prevaricating about the issue.
You are the one prevaricating. First you claim the Inquisition
declared heliocentrism a heresy in 1616; then you claim already was a
heresy.
Why keep lying about the past. I have always claimed that heliocentrism
was considered to be heresy both times that Galileo faced the issue in
1616 and 1633. My sources had demonstrated that heliocentrism was
considered to be formal heresy in 1616, and it was only written up as
heresy in the sentencing of Galileo in 1633. That was years ago. You
are the one that denied that reality. You lied about my sources not
being reliable when you could not demonstrate that they were wrong about
heliocentrism. You now know that your own trusted source supported my
sources and claimed that heliocentrism was considered to be a heresy
both times that Galileo faced the issue. Your source did not make the
distinction between formal heresy and heresy. In order to prevaricate
about your own source you put up the sentencing where the word "formal"
had been left out, but the sentencing still claimed heliocentrism was
heresy and clearly defined the heresy. You tried to quote mine the wiki
when the wiki continued to claim that heliocentrism was a formal heresy
in 1616 in the Judgement section of the wiki. You know that the Pope
agreed with the Inquisition in 1616 and condemned heliocentrism and
added heliocentric writings to the index. Your quote mining the
condemnation did not change what the Pope had done. It was your source
that came up short and had lied about the situation in 1616. Your
stupid dishonest antics trying to support the lie that your source had
tried to get away with was just tragically lame and stupid. It
Inquistion was not the only church body to have condemned heliocentrism.
The Vatican Observatory was very matter of fact that the Pope had
condemned heliocentrism in 1616, and even quoted the condemnation. Your
quote mining of what they quoted did not change what the Pope had done.
You just need to stop lying about the past and accept reality. You need
to apologize for harassing me with your lies.
Galileo first faced the issue
in 1616. You have lied about the situation for years. He was not
charged with heresy, he went to Rome to defend his actions.
The last time round, you persistently insisted I was wrong and that he
was charged with heresy in 1616, I guess it is some progress that you
now recognise you got at least that bit wrong. It would have been nice
of you to admit that you got it wrong but I guess that's too much to
expect.
I said he faced the charge of heresy. I acknowledged that he was never
formally charged in 1616, but the Inquisition rejected his arguments,
and believed that Galileo believed the heresy, but they did not have a
case because Galileo claimed that he did not believe in heliocentrism
and that putting up data supporting the notion did not mean belief. My
take is that Galileo did not believe that heliocentrism to be heresy,
but the Inquisition required proof that heliocentrism was true, and
Galileo did not have "proof". Galileo was unable to keep the
Inquisition from concluding that heliocentrism was formally heretical.
In 1633 Galileo tried the same defense by claiming that he did not
believe in the heliocentrism, but the compromise document from 1616 was
produced that had Galileo stop teaching, defending, or discussing
heliocentrism. Google claims that the document is controversial, and
may have been a forgery, but Galileo did not deny the document. It
doesn't matter because violating the instructions would mean that
Galileo was guilty of heresy in 1616.
Google Quote:
1. The Context of the 1616 "Injunction"
In February 1616, the Catholic Church's Theological Advisory Committee
formally declared heliocentrism to be "philosophically foolish" and
"formally heretical". Pope Paul V ordered Cardinal Robert Bellarmine to
summon Galileo and privately warn him to abandon Copernicanism.
The Pope's explicit instructions were:
1. Cardinal Bellarmine must warn Galileo to abandon heliocentrism.
2. If Galileo refused, the Father Commissary of the Inquisition was to
step forward in front of a notary and witnesses to issue a strict legal
injunction commanding Galileo to abstain completely from teaching,
defending, or even discussing it.
3. If Galileo still did not comply, he was to be imprisoned.
END Google quote:
It doesn't matter if the document was a forgery. Heliocentrism would
continue to be considered to be heresy both times that Galileo faced the
issue.
Unfortunately, you still haven't got it quite right. Galileo did not
have to "defend his actions" in 1616, his actions have already been
investigated and he had been cleared. That was back in the previous
year when two Dominicans complained about him to the Inquisition
claiming that his Letter to Castelli was heretical and reporting
various rumours that were circulating in Florence about Galileo and
his supporters. [1] In regard to the Letter to Castelli, the
Inquisition found that "it does not diverge from the pathways of
Catholic expression" and they dismissed the stories from Florence as
baseless hearsay. [2]
He had obviously not been cleared because when he went to Rome to defend
his writings the Inquisition wanted to charge him, but Galileo had never
confessed to believing in the heresy, and he consistently claimed that
he did not believe in the heresy. They did not have a case. The Pope
agreed with Galileo that just writing about evidence that would support
heliocentrism was not the same as believing the heresy, but the Google
quote would indicate that he did not want Galileo to continue to support
the heresy in any way.
When was it
established that heliocentrism was a formal heresy?
Never. I've also told you multiple times that there isn't even such a
thing as a belief being a "formal heresy" - the word "formal" applies
to the awareness of the person committing heresy and is "the wilful
and persistent adherence to an error in matters of faith" on the part
of a baptised person. [3]
It is the anti geocentric Catholics that think that "formal" means
something. Just as your source trying to use the sentencing in order to
deny "formal heresy" in the 1633 case. Why lie about the situation.
What was the conclusion of the Inquisition in 1616 and was a conclusion
that the Pope agreed with? Just because everyone wants to lie about the
situation and prevaricate about what went down does not matter.
Heliocentrism was still considered to be heresy in 1633. The anti
geocentric web site admitted that it was an issue within the church and
that the Pope had the 1633 case and sentencing published and distributed
throughout the church in order to quash heliocentric supporters within
the Church. They only claimed that, that act was not an official Papal
action because they wanted to preserve Papal infallibility, which is
just stupid in this day and age. It is what the Pope did and why he did
it that matters.
He likely made the
Inquistion initiate their confirmation of heresy for heliocentrism.
Cardinal Bellarmine made his warning to Galileo and Galileo accepted it >>>> after the Inquisition had determined that heliocentrism was a formal heresy.
Bellarmine's warning was to not promote heliocentrism as conclusive
and to stay away from scripture. Galileo agreed to do so and that's
why he was able to continue with his work on it. False rumours were
spread afterwards about what happened between Galileo and Bellarmine
and in order to clear the air, Bellarmine wrote out a signed statement
that Galileo had neither abjured nor done penance, but had merely been
informed of the general edict governing all Catholics.
That is the letter that Galileo brought to the court, not the document
that was used to convict him. The Inquisition contended that Galileo had
agreed to something that he had disregarded.
All of this does not matter. What matters is that heliocentrism was
considered to be heresy both times that Galileo faced the issue, and the
Pope agreed with the Inquisition in 1616 had condemned heliocentrism and
added heliocentric writings to the index.
As you can't deal with the reality stated below that the Pope agreed
with the Inquisition in 1616 and had heliocentrism condemned and
heliocentric writings added to the index.
The Pope not only agreed with the Inquisition, he approved their final
decree and ordered it to be published. That decree, which you have
persistently claimed declared heliocentrism a heresy, makes no mention
whatsoever of heresy in regard to heliocentrism. What it does is what
I summarised above: it declared heliocentrism to be false (the
scientific consensus at the time); it banned the promotion of
heliocentrism as anything other than hypothesis (but did not ban work
continuing on it); it banned heliocentrism being used to reinterpret
Scripture by people not authorised to do so.
Just 5 days after the decree was published, Galileo had an audience
with the Pope in which the Pope assured him that he knew Galileo's
integrity and sincerity, told him not to worry, said that not only he
but the entire Congregation of the Holy Office knew about his unjust
persecutions, and added the unusual remark that so long as he, Paul V,
lived, Galileo remained secure. [4]
Too bad, but what has always been claimed is that the qualifiers made
the determination and a summary of their conclusions has always been
used to demonstrate that they made that conclusion. I put up two
translations that the Vatican observatory put up for the document. Both
translations call heliocentrism formally heretical. Even the wiki had
cited that document.
=========================================
[1] The two Dominicans, Niccol|# Lorini and Tommaso Caccini were acting
at their own instigation, not on behalf of the Dominican order.
Following a sermon from Caccini the previous December where he
attacked heliocentrism and mocked Galileo, Father Luigi Maraffi, the
Preacher-General and highest administrative authority of the Dominican
Order, sent Galileo a written letter of apology expressing bitter
regret for Caccini's behavior, saying "unfortunately I have to answer
for all the idiocies that thirty or forty thousand brothers may or
actually do commit" and described Caccini's action as madness and
ignorance. [Drake, Stillman. 'Galileo at work: His scientific
biography'. The University of Chicago Press,1978, p239]
[2] Finocchiaro, Maurice A. 'Defending Copernicus and Galileo:
Critical reasoning in the two affairs.' Springer Science & Business
Media, 2010, p140
[3]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_heresies_in_the_Catholic_Church
[4] Drake, Stillman. 'Galileo at work: His scientific biography'. The
University of Chicago Press,1978, p256
In the 1633 sentencing it was called heresy, the heresy was clearly
defined, and Galileo was found to be guilty. Prevaricating about the
issue is just stupid and dishonest. You have been wrong for years, and
have lied about the issue for years. Nothing will ever change the fact
that heliocentrism was considered to be heresy both times that Galileo
faced the issue in 1616, and 1633.
The authors of the Bible believed in an ancient flat earth geocentric
cosmology that never existed. Interpretation of the Bible has always
had to be incorrect because Nature is not Biblical. The Church
understood this, but they believed that the Bible was correct about
geocentrism. They did not believe that the Bible was correct about a
flat earth (the majority, there are still flat earth geocentric
Christians and Jews that exist today). The Inquisition understood that
if Galileo had proof that heliocentrism was true that heliocentrism
would not be considered to be heretical, but Galileo did not have that
proof, and the Church Fathers may not have been flat earthers, but they
remained geocentrists.
You know, Ron, historians like Drake and Favaro and Finocchiaro and
many others really should not have wasted so many years ploughing
through archives, poring over old documents, some of them in Italian,
many of them in Latin, writing so many papers and books that got it
all wrong. They could have left it until you and your geocentrist
mentor came along to figure it all out properly.
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the
type of sources that you rely on.
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the
type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so
easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said:
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia,
1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the
type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so
easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said:
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the
Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia,
1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
You have done a pretty poor job of lying about the situation for years.
You never demonstrated that my sources were deficient, but your own
sources kept coming up short. Lying about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism came up pretty short.
Quote mining the documents is never going to change reality
The Jesuits were pretty matter of fact about what the Pope had done when
he agreed with the Inquisition and condemned heliocentrism and had >heliocentric writing added to the index. It doesn't matter what you
want to prevaricate about. Reality is just what it is. The Bible was
just wrong about geocentrism. The ancient Hebrew cosmology that the
authors of the Bible believed did not exist. The earth was not flat and
was not the center of the universe. There was no firmament for some god
to open to let the rain fall through. The Church understood that the
Bible was wrong about the earth being flat from the start of
Christianity. The Greeks had used physical measurements to estimate the >circumference of the earth a couple hundred years before Christ was
born. The Biblical Hebrew cosmology had already been found to be
wanting. Geocentrism just remained an issue because it was something
that the early Christians accepted and agreed with. It turned out to be >just more that the Bible was wrong about.
There were issues with the 6 day creation from the start of the Church.
The literal 6 day creation was never taken as something that needed to
be required to be believed by the church, and yet we still have anti >evolution creationists like MarkE and Sticks, and the creationists at
Reason to Believe. It is all just the foibles of Biblical literalism.
You put up the Pope Francis Quote on how he dealt with the 6 magic acts
of Genesis. Google calls it the "Framework" interpretation that holds
that the 6 day creation is not intended to convey anything in particular >about the time or sequence in which God created things. Instead they >represent a literary framework into which the Biblical events of
creation are portrayed. Pope Francis was just acknowledging that the
Big Bang cosmology was consistent with how his God created.
Ron Okimoto
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:43:41 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the
type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so
easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said:
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the
Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia,
1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
So why do you run from the reality that what you said about my source
was demonstrably false?
I can't figure out whether you are one of these people who likes to
accuse other people of lies to take attention away from your own
persistent lies; or whether you are living in a land of make-believe
where things become true just because you would like them to be true.
The rubbish repeated below suggests the latter.
You have done a pretty poor job of lying about the situation for years.
You never demonstrated that my sources were deficient, but your own
sources kept coming up short. Lying about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism came up pretty short.
Quote mining the documents is never going to change reality
The Jesuits were pretty matter of fact about what the Pope had done when
he agreed with the Inquisition and condemned heliocentrism and had
heliocentric writing added to the index. It doesn't matter what you
want to prevaricate about. Reality is just what it is. The Bible was
just wrong about geocentrism. The ancient Hebrew cosmology that the
authors of the Bible believed did not exist. The earth was not flat and
was not the center of the universe. There was no firmament for some god
to open to let the rain fall through. The Church understood that the
Bible was wrong about the earth being flat from the start of
Christianity. The Greeks had used physical measurements to estimate the
circumference of the earth a couple hundred years before Christ was
born. The Biblical Hebrew cosmology had already been found to be
wanting. Geocentrism just remained an issue because it was something
that the early Christians accepted and agreed with. It turned out to be
just more that the Bible was wrong about.
There were issues with the 6 day creation from the start of the Church.
The literal 6 day creation was never taken as something that needed to
be required to be believed by the church, and yet we still have anti
evolution creationists like MarkE and Sticks, and the creationists at
Reason to Believe. It is all just the foibles of Biblical literalism.
You put up the Pope Francis Quote on how he dealt with the 6 magic acts
of Genesis. Google calls it the "Framework" interpretation that holds
that the 6 day creation is not intended to convey anything in particular
about the time or sequence in which God created things. Instead they
represent a literary framework into which the Biblical events of
creation are portrayed. Pope Francis was just acknowledging that the
Big Bang cosmology was consistent with how his God created.
Ron Okimoto
On 11/9/2026 7:10 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:43:41 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the >>>>> type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so
easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said:
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the >>>> Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia,
1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
So why do you run from the reality that what you said about my source
was demonstrably false?
Your source had lied. You quoted the claim that the Inquisition was the >only Church body to have condemned heliocentrism. Just one Google
search turned up the Jesuit account that was matter of fact about what
the Pope had done in 1616. The Pope had agreed with the Inquisition and >condemned heliocentrism, and had heliocentric writings added to the
Index. Your source had lied, and in order to try to support the liar
you tried to quote mine the condemnation. That is how tragically lame
you have been.
I can't figure out whether you are one of these people who likes to
accuse other people of lies to take attention away from your own
persistent lies; or whether you are living in a land of make-believe
where things become true just because you would like them to be true.
The rubbish repeated below suggests the latter.
You are the delusional one. Quote mining the condemnation and the Wiki
was never going to change reality. The Wiki continued to claim that >heliocentrism was a formal heresy when Galileo faced the issue in 1616
in the Judgement section of the Wiki.
You need to stop harassing me about this junk and accept reality. You
are the one that had to resort to lying about running from the Papal >condemnation, and you are the one that had to try to quote mine the
Papal document in order to justify your stupid lie, and continue to
support your source that had been demonstrated to have lied about the issue.
Ron Okimoto
You have done a pretty poor job of lying about the situation for years.
You never demonstrated that my sources were deficient, but your own
sources kept coming up short. Lying about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism came up pretty short.
Quote mining the documents is never going to change reality
The Jesuits were pretty matter of fact about what the Pope had done when >>> he agreed with the Inquisition and condemned heliocentrism and had
heliocentric writing added to the index. It doesn't matter what you
want to prevaricate about. Reality is just what it is. The Bible was
just wrong about geocentrism. The ancient Hebrew cosmology that the
authors of the Bible believed did not exist. The earth was not flat and >>> was not the center of the universe. There was no firmament for some god >>> to open to let the rain fall through. The Church understood that the
Bible was wrong about the earth being flat from the start of
Christianity. The Greeks had used physical measurements to estimate the >>> circumference of the earth a couple hundred years before Christ was
born. The Biblical Hebrew cosmology had already been found to be
wanting. Geocentrism just remained an issue because it was something
that the early Christians accepted and agreed with. It turned out to be >>> just more that the Bible was wrong about.
There were issues with the 6 day creation from the start of the Church.
The literal 6 day creation was never taken as something that needed to
be required to be believed by the church, and yet we still have anti
evolution creationists like MarkE and Sticks, and the creationists at
Reason to Believe. It is all just the foibles of Biblical literalism.
You put up the Pope Francis Quote on how he dealt with the 6 magic acts
of Genesis. Google calls it the "Framework" interpretation that holds
that the 6 day creation is not intended to convey anything in particular >>> about the time or sequence in which God created things. Instead they
represent a literary framework into which the Biblical events of
creation are portrayed. Pope Francis was just acknowledging that the
Big Bang cosmology was consistent with how his God created.
Ron Okimoto
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 11:57:02 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 7:10 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:43:41 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the >>>>>> type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so
easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said:
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the >>>>> Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia, >>>>> 1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
So why do you run from the reality that what you said about my source
was demonstrably false?
Your source had lied. You quoted the claim that the Inquisition was the
only Church body to have condemned heliocentrism. Just one Google
search turned up the Jesuit account that was matter of fact about what
the Pope had done in 1616. The Pope had agreed with the Inquisition and
condemned heliocentrism, and had heliocentric writings added to the
Index. Your source had lied, and in order to try to support the liar
you tried to quote mine the condemnation. That is how tragically lame
you have been.
Can you not grasp that by continually insisting I said stuff when you
can't produce a single example of me doing so makes you look like an
idiot? Or do you simply not care about looking like an idiot?
I can't figure out whether you are one of these people who likes to
accuse other people of lies to take attention away from your own
persistent lies; or whether you are living in a land of make-believe
where things become true just because you would like them to be true.
The rubbish repeated below suggests the latter.
You are the delusional one. Quote mining the condemnation and the Wiki
was never going to change reality. The Wiki continued to claim that
heliocentrism was a formal heresy when Galileo faced the issue in 1616
in the Judgement section of the Wiki.
You need to stop harassing me about this junk and accept reality. You
are the one that had to resort to lying about running from the Papal
condemnation, and you are the one that had to try to quote mine the
Papal document in order to justify your stupid lie, and continue to
support your source that had been demonstrated to have lied about the issue. >>
Ron Okimoto
You have done a pretty poor job of lying about the situation for years. >>>> You never demonstrated that my sources were deficient, but your own
sources kept coming up short. Lying about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism came up pretty short. >>>> Quote mining the documents is never going to change reality
The Jesuits were pretty matter of fact about what the Pope had done when >>>> he agreed with the Inquisition and condemned heliocentrism and had
heliocentric writing added to the index. It doesn't matter what you
want to prevaricate about. Reality is just what it is. The Bible was >>>> just wrong about geocentrism. The ancient Hebrew cosmology that the
authors of the Bible believed did not exist. The earth was not flat and >>>> was not the center of the universe. There was no firmament for some god >>>> to open to let the rain fall through. The Church understood that the
Bible was wrong about the earth being flat from the start of
Christianity. The Greeks had used physical measurements to estimate the >>>> circumference of the earth a couple hundred years before Christ was
born. The Biblical Hebrew cosmology had already been found to be
wanting. Geocentrism just remained an issue because it was something
that the early Christians accepted and agreed with. It turned out to be >>>> just more that the Bible was wrong about.
There were issues with the 6 day creation from the start of the Church. >>>> The literal 6 day creation was never taken as something that needed to >>>> be required to be believed by the church, and yet we still have anti
evolution creationists like MarkE and Sticks, and the creationists at
Reason to Believe. It is all just the foibles of Biblical literalism. >>>> You put up the Pope Francis Quote on how he dealt with the 6 magic acts >>>> of Genesis. Google calls it the "Framework" interpretation that holds >>>> that the 6 day creation is not intended to convey anything in particular >>>> about the time or sequence in which God created things. Instead they
represent a literary framework into which the Biblical events of
creation are portrayed. Pope Francis was just acknowledging that the
Big Bang cosmology was consistent with how his God created.
Ron Okimoto
On 11/9/2026 4:24 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 11:57:02 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 7:10 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:43:41 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the >>>>>>> type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so >>>>>> easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said:
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the >>>>>> Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia, >>>>>> 1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
So why do you run from the reality that what you said about my source
was demonstrably false?
Your source had lied. You quoted the claim that the Inquisition was the >>> only Church body to have condemned heliocentrism. Just one Google
search turned up the Jesuit account that was matter of fact about what
the Pope had done in 1616. The Pope had agreed with the Inquisition and >>> condemned heliocentrism, and had heliocentric writings added to the
Index. Your source had lied, and in order to try to support the liar
you tried to quote mine the condemnation. That is how tragically lame
you have been.
Can you not grasp that by continually insisting I said stuff when you
can't produce a single example of me doing so makes you look like an
idiot? Or do you simply not care about looking like an idiot?
What happened when you denied that you lied about running from the >condemnation? How many times did you snip and run from the REPOST
evidence that you had lied? Go to the thread and count them for
yourself. I have put up the post where I had put up the Papal
condemnation and you ran. I then reposted the same material and you
snipped it out and ran. You then started lying about running from it,
but all that I had to do was put up the posts of you doing just that.
In order to claim that you did not have to snip and run from the
evidence, you tried to quote mine the Papal condemnation, but how did
that turn out. What followed the quote that you put up?
Why keep lying about what you have been doing for years? Do you want me
to start REPOSTing the evidence again? All that you have ever done is
snip it out and run from it.
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 18:11:14 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 4:24 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 11:57:02 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 7:10 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:43:41 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the >>>>>>>> type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so >>>>>>> easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said:
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the >>>>>>> Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia, >>>>>>> 1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
So why do you run from the reality that what you said about my source >>>>> was demonstrably false?
Your source had lied. You quoted the claim that the Inquisition was the >>>> only Church body to have condemned heliocentrism. Just one Google
search turned up the Jesuit account that was matter of fact about what >>>> the Pope had done in 1616. The Pope had agreed with the Inquisition and >>>> condemned heliocentrism, and had heliocentric writings added to the
Index. Your source had lied, and in order to try to support the liar
you tried to quote mine the condemnation. That is how tragically lame >>>> you have been.
Can you not grasp that by continually insisting I said stuff when you
can't produce a single example of me doing so makes you look like an
idiot? Or do you simply not care about looking like an idiot?
What happened when you denied that you lied about running from the
condemnation? How many times did you snip and run from the REPOST
evidence that you had lied? Go to the thread and count them for
yourself. I have put up the post where I had put up the Papal
condemnation and you ran. I then reposted the same material and you
snipped it out and ran. You then started lying about running from it,
but all that I had to do was put up the posts of you doing just that.
In order to claim that you did not have to snip and run from the
evidence, you tried to quote mine the Papal condemnation, but how did
that turn out. What followed the quote that you put up?
Telling people to "go to the thread" is a feeble attempt to try to get
away from the fact that you cannot quote a single example of a lie or
quote mine from me.
On Thu, 30 Apr 2026 08:49:48 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>insane.
wrote:
On 4/30/2026 5:44 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 29 Apr 2026 19:41:58 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/29/2026 1:13 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 29 Apr 2026 12:43:53 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[...]
Snipping and lying about what you have done is just stupid and
snipped and
Not as stupid and insane as making a claim you can't support. C'mon,
Ron, give the link to the Wiki article that says Galileo faced a
heresy charge in 1616 rCa surely it can't be that difficult.
[snip desperation attempt to avoid issue]
What a lying asshole. This is the second time that you have
run from what you have lied about as being handwaving.
C'mon Ron, no need to repost 7000 words that nobody wants to read. All
that's needed to show me to be the lying asshole, not you, is a simple
quote from the Wiki article that says what you insist it says. A dozen
or so words should cover it or even a simple URL. Can't be that hard
can it?
[...]
You need to stop harassing me with your stupid lies about the past.
I'll gladly stop harassing you when you either give a specific example
of a lie told by either me or those I cited in support. Or else
withdraw your own stupid lies.
On Mon, 20 Apr 2026 13:40:43 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>are lying".
wrote:
On 4/20/2026 4:08 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 18 Apr 2026 12:06:53 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/18/2026 6:24 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:31:27 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/15/2026 11:36 AM, Martin Harran wrote:[rCa]
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 16:59:56 +0100, "Kerr-Mudd, John"
No one is going to convince an opponent by stating that "they
(no matterand probably not by constant repetition of the same arguments
reality,how valid) that failed to get through the first 50 times.
Tell that to RonO, he's the one who keeps calling everyone who
disagrees with him a liar.
Who got caught lying and quote mining? You need to deal with
short?and quit lying about it. Lying about me is just so stupid that it is
pretty much insane. You have always lied about the sources that you
could not deal honestly with. Who's sources have always come up
matched byLook at what you are doing now. Is there any excuse for you not dealing
with your own stupid dishonest behavior?
The tiresomeness of you continually claiming that my sources were
caught lying and that I have been lying and quote mining is
beenthe tiresomeness of your inability to ever identify what lie my
sources were caught in, what lies I have told or where I have quote
mined.
[... more big snip ...]
Why keep lying about what your sources did and what you did? That is
just stupid and dishonest. Just look up your past posts to determine
for yourself what went down. You tried to lie about my sources being
deficient when your sources had always come up short or even supported
my sources by putting up the lame lie that heliocentrism had never
samecondemned other then by the inquisition. It was stupid because it did
not negate what you and your sources had been wrong about. It turned
out that your source was lying and you ran. You ran twice from the
whatevidence that your source was lying. You tried to come back with your
lame quote mining efforts and trying to distract the argument from
it had been. You did that, and your source was demonstrated to have
lied about the issue. You need to go back and deal with what you did.
An appology for your disgraceful behavior would be in order. Just try
not to do it again. Continuing to lie about what happened is just
adding to how low you needed to go.
Yet again, you make all sorts of accusations without a single example
of something to support them.
What I cannot figure out is whether you just can't grasp that your
failure to produce a single example of supporting evidence portrays
*you* as the one telling lies; or whether you do grasp it and just
don't care; or whether, like a certain President, you think that if
you repeat a lie enough times that someone will eventually believe it.
You should apologize for what you have been doing and stop doing it. I
found the posts where you ran from your source having been caught lying,
you then snipped the evidence out of your response to your running.
The thread: There is no legitimate scientific support for the ID scam.
I can post your quote mining attempts and other stupid behavior that you
resorted to to defend your running and defense of your bogus source.
So why don't you instead of talking about it?
Specific examples, please, not reams and reams of obfuscatory cut'n
paste.
On Sun, 16 Nov 2025 18:25:18 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>claiming you
wrote:
On 11/16/2025 4:40 PM, Martin Harran wrote:[rCa]
The links that I put up were from the Catholics that continue to be
geocentric creationists, and the Catholics that are trying to refute
them. Both sides do not agree with you. What does your continued
denial of reality tell you?
You gave no such links. All you have to do to prove me wrong is give
them again.
Do you not see how stupid you are making yourself look by
gave links but cannot repeat them?
Why lie about something so stupid. One of the links was your own
trusted Catholic site, and you initially gave that link.
That was this site:
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
The one where the Catholic Church states:
" In thus acting, it is undeniable that the ecclesiastical authorities
committed a grave and deplorable error, and sanctioned an altogether
false principle as to the proper use of Scripture."
The one that cites Professor Augustus De Morgan (Budget of Paradoxes)
declaring
"It is clear that the absurdity was the act of the Italian
Inquisition, for the private and personal pleasure of the pope - who
knew that the course he took could not convict him as pope - and not
of the body which calls itself the Church."
The one that cites von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei"):
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the
Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
It beats me how you figure out that site and the people referred to in
it somehow back your claim that heliocentrism really was a heresy. I
guess you have to convince yourself in order to maintain your delusion
as you clearly can't find a reputable source that actually does back
you up.
Yes, everyone admits that they were wrong about geocentrism except for
the Catholics that are still geocentrics. This source called what
Galileo faced both times a charge of heresy. They did not make a
distinction between formal heresy and heresy like the anti geocentric
site, but it was still a heresy.
What part of "The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at
all" did you not understand?
The only place that formal comes into all this is in the judgement
issued after Galileo's first trial where the verdict stated that the proposition that the Sun is stationary at the centre of the universe
is "foolish and absurd in philosophy, and formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the sense of Holy Scripture".
That, however, is t the Catholic Encyclopaedia refers to where it
says:
"it is undeniable that the ecclesiastical authorities committed a
grave and deplorable error, and sanctioned an altogether false
principle as to the proper use of Scripture."
Note also that the words "formally heretical" are wrong - I'm not sure whether it was the Inquisition using weasel words or whether it was a
bad translation from the Latin.
The word "heresy" can be used in two ways; it can apply to the
rejection of a specific doctrine of the Church or it can refer to the
act of committing heresy. The word "formal" applies to the latter -
the act of committing heresy - and is used to categorise the degree of
guilt of the person committing the heresy. "Formal heresy" means they
knew they were going against doctrine and are therefore guilty of
mortal sin; "material heresy" means they did not know they were going against doctrine so they are not guilty sin.
It's a bit like first degree versus second degree murder and Galileo's
trial was like him being charged with first-degree murder without a
murder being established in the first place.
The Inquisition made it into a formal heresy after the Council of Trent.
They were supposedly wrong, and a couple centuries later things got
reversed to what they had been at the time that the findings of the
Council of Trent were published.
The holy office (the inquisition) had Galileo facing a formal heresy
charge in his first encounter. When the pope got involved they just did
not call it a formal heresy in the sentencing. Galileo's views were
still condemned. They claimed that Galileo was facing a charge of
heresy. His heliocentric notions were still considered to be heresy and
the heresy that he was guilty of was clearly defined in the sentencing.
The anti geocentrics admitted that the pope had the Galileo case
published and disseminated throughout the church in order to quash the
heliocentric notions that were becoming an issue for the church. They
just want to claim that, that was not an official act. That is just
stupid. The pope did it for known reasons, and who cares if they want
to plead that he was not acting as pope?
There is no doubt that the actors were wrong, and that is the issue.
They do not want it to reflect on papal infallibility. That in itself
should be considered to be a non scriptural unjustifiable claim.
The Inquisition had Copernican writings banned and made heliocentrism
into a formal heresy because all the church fathers were geocentrics,
and that meant that Copernicans were in conflict with the beliefs of the
church fathers. Both the geocentric Catholics and the anti geocentric
Catholics claim that the Inquisition did this because of what the church
came up with at the Council of Trent where they made the beliefs of the
church fathers as a legitimate and necessary authority for interpreting
scripture. Both Catholic sides of the geocentric issue understand this
to be true.
QUOTE:
Council of Trent
Session IV, April 8, 1546, Decree Concerning the Edition and the Use of
the Sacred Books:
... "Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, it [the Council
of Trent] decrees that no one, relying on his own skill, shall,-in
matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of
Christian doctrine,-wresting the sacred Scriptures to his own senses,
presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense
which holy Mother Church-to whom it belongs to judge of the true sense
and interpretation of the Holy Scriptures-hath held and doth hold; or
even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such
interpretations were never (intended) to be at any time published.
Contraveners shall be made known by their Ordinaries and be punished
with the penalties by law established."
END QUOTE:
https://www.biblelightinfo.com/unanimous-consent.htm
Both Catholic sides of the issue claim that the Council of Trent caused
the Inquisition to ban Copernican writings and start treating
heliocentrism as a formal heresy because it went against the geocentric
beliefs of the church fathers.
You are taking all that crap from your geocentric hero; if you want to persist in taking his opinion against that of the Church's own
theologians then that is you just acting like Spikes rejecting the
opinion of scientists in favour of people who play to his confirmation
bias.
It was a mistake and the actors were in error only because of our
current understanding of nature. The Pope was wrong about it. He was
one of the mistaken actors.
The Pope was not a "mistaken actor", he was pissed off with Galileo presenting the Pope's views as those of a simpleton and misused his
powers to hit back at Galileo. Again, the Catholic Encyclopaedia
spells that explicitly:
"It is clear that the absurdity was the act of the Italian
Inquisition, for the private and personal pleasure of the pope - who
knew that the course he took could not convict him as pope - and not
of the body which calls itself the Church."
The Galileo affair was a shameful episode in the Church's history but
was all about the animosity between the Pope and Galileo, it had
nothing to do with heliocentrism being a heresy, that was just the
vehicle that the Pope used to attack Galileo.
On Mon, 17 Nov 2025 14:40:05 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/17/2025 11:45 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 17 Nov 2025 09:57:31 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[...]
Oops, the Pope was not infallible.
So papal infallibility is another thing you don't understand.
I am just repeating what the anti geocentrist want to claim about it.
The "anti-geocentrists" of whom you cannot identify even one. Mind
you, when you first brought in the website of your geocentrist mentor,
it was anonymous and you didn't even know who the author was until I
figured out; the fact that he is a declared geocentrist and you knew
nothing about him didn't stop you placing high value on his opinions
and continuing to do so.
Weird to say the least.
[...]
On Wed, 19 Nov 2025 14:55:52 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/19/2025 12:01 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 17 Nov 2025 14:40:05 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/17/2025 11:45 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 17 Nov 2025 09:57:31 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[...]
Oops, the Pope was not infallible.
So papal infallibility is another thing you don't understand.
I am just repeating what the anti geocentrist want to claim about it.
The "anti-geocentrists" of whom you cannot identify even one. Mind
you, when you first brought in the website of your geocentrist mentor,
it was anonymous and you didn't even know who the author was until I
figured out; the fact that he is a declared geocentrist and you knew
nothing about him didn't stop you placing high value on his opinions
and continuing to do so.
Weird to say the least.
[...]
You were given the links before,
Nope
so stop lying about it. Why should I
look up that junk again.
So you can prove I'm lying. But you can't because I'm not lying, you
gave no links except to the geocentrist idiot whose opinion you value
so highly.
You just denied that it was valid and kept
lying. Even your own trusted source backed up the anti geocentric site.
The anti geocentrists were on your side in terms of denying that it
was a formal heresy that Galileo faced the second time, but they agreed
with the geocentrists that the Inquisition had made it a formal heresy
charge the first time Galileo faced it and agreed with the Wiki. The
Vatican Observatory article that you have run from and snipped out of
this post backs up the geocentrists and anti geocentrists.
Just stop lying about the issue.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/heliocentrism-condemned-400-years-ago-on-march-5-2/
They admit that helicentrism was condemned 400 years ago. 1616 is when
Galileo faced the formal heresy charge.
They do not consider the heresy cases, but they were based upon the
Inquisitions opinion of the topic.
Your claim of "never" having been condemned seems to be a lie.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo_Galilei
QUOTE:
In February 1616, an Inquisitorial commission declared heliocentrism to
be "foolish and absurd in philosophy, and formally heretical since it
explicitly contradicts in many places the sense of Holy Scripture".
END QUOTE:
Now YOU are the one lying about me. I never said it was never
condemned; on the contrary, I gave that exact same quote. What I did
was to point out that what it said was a FALSE CLAIM and it wasn't me
who came to that conclusion, it was the Catholic Church who came to
it, supported by every historian I know of who investigated it, people
like De Morgan and von Gebler. The only person I have ever known to
say there actually was a heresy is the geocentrist idiot whose opinion
you value so highly.
Both the geocentrists that you don't like, and the anti geocentric
catholics that do not agree with geocentric beliefs agreed that it was a
formal heresy charge the first time that Galileo faced the issue.
Now you seem to be trying to worm your way out of it by admitting
there was a *charge* without retracting that there was an actual
heresy which is what you have been claiming all long.
You can't just keep refusing to deal with reality and expect anything to
change.
You can't keep claiming support from "anti-geocentrists" about
heliocentrism having been an actual heresy without being able to
identify even one and expect people to take you seriously.
On Thu, 20 Nov 2025 09:38:56 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>heliocentrism to
wrote:
On 11/20/2025 4:47 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 19 Nov 2025 14:55:52 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[snip for focus]
Your claim of "never" having been condemned seems to be a lie.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo_Galilei
QUOTE:
In February 1616, an Inquisitorial commission declared
be "foolish and absurd in philosophy, and formally heretical since it
explicitly contradicts in many places the sense of Holy Scripture".
END QUOTE:
Now YOU are the one lying about me. I never said it was never
condemned; on the contrary, I gave that exact same quote. What I did
was to point out that what it said was a FALSE CLAIM and it wasn't me
who came to that conclusion, it was the Catholic Church who came to
it, supported by every historian I know of who investigated it, people
like De Morgan and von Gebler. The only person I have ever known to
say there actually was a heresy is the geocentrist idiot whose opinion
you value so highly.
You put up the quote that said it had never been condemned. Go back up
and check. It was your quote.
Here is verbatim what I quoted:
Message-ID: 2gkkhk9bvctolude5jf6b6e0kothd5723d@4ax.com ========================================
<quote>
The [site] that cites von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei"):
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
==========================================
#1: it was von Gebler who said rCLnever condemnedrCY, not me as you
claimed two posts ago.
#2 he did not say it was never condemned, he said *the Church* never condemned it.
Why do you post lies that are so easily shown to be lies?
On Fri, 21 Nov 2025 17:33:49 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/21/2025 12:29 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 21 Nov 2025 09:04:37 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[rCa]
Let's cut to the chase here.
No lies to retract. You lied.
What lie are you claiming I told? Please quote exactly what I said
that you regard as a lie.
The ones that you keep telling.
"Never condemned"
I'm out of here. George Bernard Shaw warned that you shouldn't wrestle
with a pig as you get dirty and the pig enjoys it. I'm not going to
waste any more time trying to have a sensible discussion with someone
who thinks it's ok to take two words out of what somebody else said to
give a completely different meaning and then attribute those two words
to me. It doesn't even reach the level of quote-mining.
What beggars belief is that you do it where the exact quote from von
Gerber [1] and what I said about it are preserved just a couple of
posts above for all to see. As I noted earlier, it is really sad to
see this sort of behaviour from someone whose ability as a scientist I respect so much EfOU
===========================================
[1] "The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for
the Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei")]
[..]
Why keep lying about what you have been doing for years? Do you want me
to start REPOSTing the evidence again? All that you have ever done is
snip it out and run from it.
All you have to do is quote a single lie or quote mine from me but you
cannot do so because they are all in your land of make-believe.
Threatening to go back to dumping 50K+ of garbage is just another
feeble way of trying to run away from that simple truth.
[rCa]
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 18:11:14 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 4:24 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 11:57:02 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 7:10 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:43:41 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the >>>>>>>> type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so >>>>>>> easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said:
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the >>>>>>> Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia, >>>>>>> 1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
So why do you run from the reality that what you said about my source >>>>> was demonstrably false?
Your source had lied. You quoted the claim that the Inquisition was the >>>> only Church body to have condemned heliocentrism. Just one Google
search turned up the Jesuit account that was matter of fact about what >>>> the Pope had done in 1616. The Pope had agreed with the Inquisition and >>>> condemned heliocentrism, and had heliocentric writings added to the
Index. Your source had lied, and in order to try to support the liar
you tried to quote mine the condemnation. That is how tragically lame >>>> you have been.
Can you not grasp that by continually insisting I said stuff when you
can't produce a single example of me doing so makes you look like an
idiot? Or do you simply not care about looking like an idiot?
What happened when you denied that you lied about running from the
condemnation? How many times did you snip and run from the REPOST
evidence that you had lied? Go to the thread and count them for
yourself. I have put up the post where I had put up the Papal
condemnation and you ran. I then reposted the same material and you
snipped it out and ran. You then started lying about running from it,
but all that I had to do was put up the posts of you doing just that.
In order to claim that you did not have to snip and run from the
evidence, you tried to quote mine the Papal condemnation, but how did
that turn out. What followed the quote that you put up?
Telling people to "go to the thread" is a feeble attempt to try to get
away from the fact that you cannot quote a single example of a lie or
quote mine from me.
On Sun, 22 Feb 2026 13:40:10 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>Jesuits
wrote:
On 2/22/2026 10:18 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 21 Feb 2026 12:44:57 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 2/21/2026 11:59 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
What documents are you talking about that you keep saying the
what youput up?
You can keep lying about what has been discussed, but you know
condemneddid. You need to be the one that finds it and satisfy yourself with
what you did.
You put up your source lying about heliocentrism never being
was notby anyone but the Inquisition. You claimed that the Inquisition
ordered bythe Church. I put up the Jesuit Observatory claim that the Papal
offices had condemned heliocentrism and this condemnation was
sources havethe Pope. They put up the relevant document and stated what the Pope
did. Your source was caught lying and you ran. Go find it. It is
something that you should do because you will uncover all your other
evasions on this issue while doing it. Your quotes of your
havealways come up short. The sources that you claim are unreliable,
repeatedly been shown to be more reliable than what you come up with.
Oh, you mean the link you gave back in November, this one:
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/heliocentrism-condemned-400-years-ago-on-march-5-2/
The one where they posted the full 1616 decree on it's 400th
anniversary and commented:
<quote>
The formulation here is much milder than the one found in the working
document of February 24. The Decree talks about the "false Pythagorean
doctrine" and declare it "altogether contrary to the Holy Scripture".
This is not nearly as harsh as "foolish and absurd" philosophically,
and "formally heretical" because contrary to Scripture.
</quote>
How fucking dense can you be? It doesn't get much stupider than
posting something that contradicts what you are claiming.
If I am the dense one why did you run from what they admitted about the
document?
LOL, you post something that you think supports your claim but
actually rejects it and the best defence you can offer is to accuse me
of running away from it.
The Pope did condemn heliocentrism.
Beats me why you keep repeating this. The Pope did not personally
condemn heliocentrism, he allowed the Inquisition's condemnation of it
to be made public - that did not make it a heresy.
That is what your side was lying
about.
The only one telling lies here is you. For example, when you keep
insisting that all the "anti-geocentrists" in the Catholic
Encyclopaedia article agree with you that heliocentrism was a heresy
when they all say explicitly that it wasn't. Your lie is underlined by
the fact that you can't produce identify any source that agrees that heliocentrism was a heresy except your geocentrist mentors.
condemnedIt doesn't matter that the final wording was milder than the
initial draft. They admit that the Pope condemned heliocentrism, and
supported using the Council of Trent's scriptural interpretation on the
matter. It doesn't matter what it was called because the authors and
books are named. You ran from this link because your source was found
to have lied about heliocentrism never having been condemned except by
the Inquisition. The Pope obviously represents the Church and
to beheliocentrism. He supported the Inquisition in 1616, and their
additions to the Index in order to protect against heresy. The books
would not have been added to the Index if they were not considered
reality.heretical. The document even talks about the heretical parts of the
books, and indicates that after one of them is rewritten, so that it is
not against scripture, that it can be removed from the Index.
Keep lying to yourself about the issue. It isn't going to change
The Inquisition made heliocentrism a formal heresy in 1615-1616.
The decree is given in full on the Vatican Observatory site that you
tried to claim supports you and the word 'heresy' or 'heretical' does
not even appear in it.
They
did this because of their interpretation of scripture as the Council of
Trent had decided.
The decree doesn't make any reference whatsoever to Trent regarding interpretation of scripture; the one and only reference is to the *punishment* under Trent for disobeying the decree.
They added heliocentric writings to the Index,
They declare that "the books by Nicolaus Copernicus (On the
Revolutions of Spheres) and by Diego de Zu|#iga (On Job) be suspended
until corrected".
I've given details of the required corrections to Revolutions in a
different post to Harshman and they are all minor edits - not one of
them makes any change to the core principle of heliocentrism. A rather
weird declaration of heresy that allows Copernicus's book supporting
it to be published with minor edits that don't undermine his
proposition.
Index ofand
had their first encounter with Galileo. The Pope agreed with them and
condemned heliocentrism, and agreed with their additions to the
banned writings.
Before your source lied about "never being condemned" the Pope's
involvement in 1616 was not an issue between the geocentric and
anti-geocentric Catholics in terms of what you were lying about at the
time. Both sides agreed that it was a formal heresy charge faced by
Galileo in 1615-1616. They disagreed about it being a formal heresy
charge the second time because it was only written up as "heresy" and
not formal heresy in the sentencing. It remained a heresy charge.
You obviously struggle with grasping that a *charge* does not make
someone guilty. I hope I'm never on trial for something I didn't do
with you on the jury.
The
Pope had the Galileo case, sentencing, and punishment published and
distributed throughout the Church in order to quash the heliocentric
heresy, but the guys that want to maintain Papal infallibility claim
that that was not an official Papal action. They admitted that there
was an issue with helicentrism at the time, but they do not want the
Pope to have been on the wrong side of the issue.
You need to deal with reality.
I think it's very clear who has the problem with accepting reality and
it's not me.
It is well understood that the Bible is
just wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves.
Your own quotes from Pope Francis makes that claim. The Bible can be
misinterpreted because the author's understanding of the creation was
faulty. Francis knows that the universe was not created in 6 magic
episodes. Only those in complete denial do not understand that the
order of creation described in the Bible is wrong. There are still
young earth, old earth day for agers, geocentric, and flat earth
Biblical creationists because they are in the same type of denial that
you are in. There are just different levels of denial.
Ron Okimoto
On 11/10/2026 3:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 18:11:14 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 4:24 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 11:57:02 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>
On 11/9/2026 7:10 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:43:41 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>>
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the >>>>>>>>> type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so >>>>>>>> easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said: >>>>>>>>
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the >>>>>>>> Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia, >>>>>>>> 1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
So why do you run from the reality that what you said about my source >>>>>> was demonstrably false?
Your source had lied. You quoted the claim that the Inquisition was the >>>>> only Church body to have condemned heliocentrism. Just one Google
search turned up the Jesuit account that was matter of fact about what >>>>> the Pope had done in 1616. The Pope had agreed with the Inquisition and >>>>> condemned heliocentrism, and had heliocentric writings added to the
Index. Your source had lied, and in order to try to support the liar >>>>> you tried to quote mine the condemnation. That is how tragically lame >>>>> you have been.
Can you not grasp that by continually insisting I said stuff when you
can't produce a single example of me doing so makes you look like an
idiot? Or do you simply not care about looking like an idiot?
What happened when you denied that you lied about running from the
condemnation? How many times did you snip and run from the REPOST
evidence that you had lied? Go to the thread and count them for
yourself. I have put up the post where I had put up the Papal
condemnation and you ran. I then reposted the same material and you
snipped it out and ran. You then started lying about running from it,
but all that I had to do was put up the posts of you doing just that.
In order to claim that you did not have to snip and run from the
evidence, you tried to quote mine the Papal condemnation, but how did
that turn out. What followed the quote that you put up?
Telling people to "go to the thread" is a feeble attempt to try to get
away from the fact that you cannot quote a single example of a lie or
quote mine from me.
Why keep trolling the issue?
You got caught lying about running from
the Papal condemnation that demonstrated that your source had lied about
the issue.
REPOSTS from the thread that you are lying about.
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 09:54:27 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/10/2026 3:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 18:11:14 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 4:24 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 11:57:02 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 11/9/2026 7:10 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:43:41 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>
On 11/8/2026 5:51 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:06:30 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
Your source that lied about the Inquisition being the
only church body to have condemned heliocentrism is an example of the
type of sources that you rely on.
Why do you think you can get away with saying stuff that can be so >>>>>>>>> easily shown to be totally false? Here is what my source said: >>>>>>>>>
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the
Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[Von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei") cited in The Catholic Encyclopaedia, >>>>>>>>> 1909]
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
[...]
Snipping and running from reality will never change reality.
So why do you run from the reality that what you said about my source >>>>>>> was demonstrably false?
Your source had lied. You quoted the claim that the Inquisition was the >>>>>> only Church body to have condemned heliocentrism. Just one Google >>>>>> search turned up the Jesuit account that was matter of fact about what >>>>>> the Pope had done in 1616. The Pope had agreed with the Inquisition and >>>>>> condemned heliocentrism, and had heliocentric writings added to the >>>>>> Index. Your source had lied, and in order to try to support the liar >>>>>> you tried to quote mine the condemnation. That is how tragically lame >>>>>> you have been.
Can you not grasp that by continually insisting I said stuff when you >>>>> can't produce a single example of me doing so makes you look like an >>>>> idiot? Or do you simply not care about looking like an idiot?
What happened when you denied that you lied about running from the
condemnation? How many times did you snip and run from the REPOST
evidence that you had lied? Go to the thread and count them for
yourself. I have put up the post where I had put up the Papal
condemnation and you ran. I then reposted the same material and you
snipped it out and ran. You then started lying about running from it, >>>> but all that I had to do was put up the posts of you doing just that.
In order to claim that you did not have to snip and run from the
evidence, you tried to quote mine the Papal condemnation, but how did
that turn out. What followed the quote that you put up?
Telling people to "go to the thread" is a feeble attempt to try to get
away from the fact that you cannot quote a single example of a lie or
quote mine from me.
Why keep trolling the issue?
You really should ask yourself that question.
You got caught lying about running from
the Papal condemnation that demonstrated that your source had lied about
the issue.
LOL, you claimed that my source said the Inquisition was the only
church body to have condemned heliocentrism. I quoted the source
verbatim which showed that Von Gebler said no such thing. Then you
make up accusations that Von Gebler - a highly regarded historian and
Galileo expert - was telling lies. Talk about wriggling!
REPOSTS from the thread that you are lying about.
As predicted, you cannot point to a single lie or quote mine from me,
so you dump a load of garbage to try to cause a distraction whilst you
run away.
[snip garbage]
On Thu, 30 Apr 2026 08:49:48 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>insane.
wrote:
On 4/30/2026 5:44 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 29 Apr 2026 19:41:58 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/29/2026 1:13 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 29 Apr 2026 12:43:53 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[...]
Snipping and lying about what you have done is just stupid and
snipped and
Not as stupid and insane as making a claim you can't support. C'mon,
Ron, give the link to the Wiki article that says Galileo faced a
heresy charge in 1616 rCa surely it can't be that difficult.
[snip desperation attempt to avoid issue]
What a lying asshole. This is the second time that you have
run from what you have lied about as being handwaving.
C'mon Ron, no need to repost 7000 words that nobody wants to read. All
that's needed to show me to be the lying asshole, not you, is a simple
quote from the Wiki article that says what you insist it says. A dozen
or so words should cover it or even a simple URL. Can't be that hard
can it?
[...]
You need to stop harassing me with your stupid lies about the past.
I'll gladly stop harassing you when you either give a specific example
of a lie told by either me or those I cited in support. Or else
withdraw your own stupid lies.
On Mon, 20 Apr 2026 13:40:43 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>are lying".
wrote:
On 4/20/2026 4:08 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 18 Apr 2026 12:06:53 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/18/2026 6:24 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:31:27 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/15/2026 11:36 AM, Martin Harran wrote:[rCa]
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 16:59:56 +0100, "Kerr-Mudd, John"
No one is going to convince an opponent by stating that "they
(no matterand probably not by constant repetition of the same arguments
reality,how valid) that failed to get through the first 50 times.
Tell that to RonO, he's the one who keeps calling everyone who
disagrees with him a liar.
Who got caught lying and quote mining? You need to deal with
short?and quit lying about it. Lying about me is just so stupid that it is
pretty much insane. You have always lied about the sources that you
could not deal honestly with. Who's sources have always come up
matched byLook at what you are doing now. Is there any excuse for you not dealing
with your own stupid dishonest behavior?
The tiresomeness of you continually claiming that my sources were
caught lying and that I have been lying and quote mining is
beenthe tiresomeness of your inability to ever identify what lie my
sources were caught in, what lies I have told or where I have quote
mined.
[... more big snip ...]
Why keep lying about what your sources did and what you did? That is
just stupid and dishonest. Just look up your past posts to determine
for yourself what went down. You tried to lie about my sources being
deficient when your sources had always come up short or even supported
my sources by putting up the lame lie that heliocentrism had never
samecondemned other then by the inquisition. It was stupid because it did
not negate what you and your sources had been wrong about. It turned
out that your source was lying and you ran. You ran twice from the
whatevidence that your source was lying. You tried to come back with your
lame quote mining efforts and trying to distract the argument from
it had been. You did that, and your source was demonstrated to have
lied about the issue. You need to go back and deal with what you did.
An appology for your disgraceful behavior would be in order. Just try
not to do it again. Continuing to lie about what happened is just
adding to how low you needed to go.
Yet again, you make all sorts of accusations without a single example
of something to support them.
What I cannot figure out is whether you just can't grasp that your
failure to produce a single example of supporting evidence portrays
*you* as the one telling lies; or whether you do grasp it and just
don't care; or whether, like a certain President, you think that if
you repeat a lie enough times that someone will eventually believe it.
You should apologize for what you have been doing and stop doing it. I
found the posts where you ran from your source having been caught lying,
you then snipped the evidence out of your response to your running.
The thread: There is no legitimate scientific support for the ID scam.
I can post your quote mining attempts and other stupid behavior that you
resorted to to defend your running and defense of your bogus source.
So why don't you instead of talking about it?
Specific examples, please, not reams and reams of obfuscatory cut'n
paste.
On Sun, 16 Nov 2025 18:25:18 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>claiming you
wrote:
On 11/16/2025 4:40 PM, Martin Harran wrote:[rCa]
The links that I put up were from the Catholics that continue to be
geocentric creationists, and the Catholics that are trying to refute
them. Both sides do not agree with you. What does your continued
denial of reality tell you?
You gave no such links. All you have to do to prove me wrong is give
them again.
Do you not see how stupid you are making yourself look by
gave links but cannot repeat them?
Why lie about something so stupid. One of the links was your own
trusted Catholic site, and you initially gave that link.
That was this site:
https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06342b.htm
The one where the Catholic Church states:
" In thus acting, it is undeniable that the ecclesiastical authorities
committed a grave and deplorable error, and sanctioned an altogether
false principle as to the proper use of Scripture."
The one that cites Professor Augustus De Morgan (Budget of Paradoxes)
declaring
"It is clear that the absurdity was the act of the Italian
Inquisition, for the private and personal pleasure of the pope - who
knew that the course he took could not convict him as pope - and not
of the body which calls itself the Church."
The one that cites von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei"):
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the
Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
It beats me how you figure out that site and the people referred to in
it somehow back your claim that heliocentrism really was a heresy. I
guess you have to convince yourself in order to maintain your delusion
as you clearly can't find a reputable source that actually does back
you up.
Yes, everyone admits that they were wrong about geocentrism except for
the Catholics that are still geocentrics. This source called what
Galileo faced both times a charge of heresy. They did not make a
distinction between formal heresy and heresy like the anti geocentric
site, but it was still a heresy.
What part of "The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at
all" did you not understand?
The only place that formal comes into all this is in the judgement
issued after Galileo's first trial where the verdict stated that the proposition that the Sun is stationary at the centre of the universe
is "foolish and absurd in philosophy, and formally heretical since it explicitly contradicts in many places the sense of Holy Scripture".
That, however, is t the Catholic Encyclopaedia refers to where it
says:
"it is undeniable that the ecclesiastical authorities committed a
grave and deplorable error, and sanctioned an altogether false
principle as to the proper use of Scripture."
Note also that the words "formally heretical" are wrong - I'm not sure whether it was the Inquisition using weasel words or whether it was a
bad translation from the Latin.
The word "heresy" can be used in two ways; it can apply to the
rejection of a specific doctrine of the Church or it can refer to the
act of committing heresy. The word "formal" applies to the latter -
the act of committing heresy - and is used to categorise the degree of
guilt of the person committing the heresy. "Formal heresy" means they
knew they were going against doctrine and are therefore guilty of
mortal sin; "material heresy" means they did not know they were going against doctrine so they are not guilty sin.
It's a bit like first degree versus second degree murder and Galileo's
trial was like him being charged with first-degree murder without a
murder being established in the first place.
The Inquisition made it into a formal heresy after the Council of Trent.
They were supposedly wrong, and a couple centuries later things got
reversed to what they had been at the time that the findings of the
Council of Trent were published.
The holy office (the inquisition) had Galileo facing a formal heresy
charge in his first encounter. When the pope got involved they just did
not call it a formal heresy in the sentencing. Galileo's views were
still condemned. They claimed that Galileo was facing a charge of
heresy. His heliocentric notions were still considered to be heresy and
the heresy that he was guilty of was clearly defined in the sentencing.
The anti geocentrics admitted that the pope had the Galileo case
published and disseminated throughout the church in order to quash the
heliocentric notions that were becoming an issue for the church. They
just want to claim that, that was not an official act. That is just
stupid. The pope did it for known reasons, and who cares if they want
to plead that he was not acting as pope?
There is no doubt that the actors were wrong, and that is the issue.
They do not want it to reflect on papal infallibility. That in itself
should be considered to be a non scriptural unjustifiable claim.
The Inquisition had Copernican writings banned and made heliocentrism
into a formal heresy because all the church fathers were geocentrics,
and that meant that Copernicans were in conflict with the beliefs of the
church fathers. Both the geocentric Catholics and the anti geocentric
Catholics claim that the Inquisition did this because of what the church
came up with at the Council of Trent where they made the beliefs of the
church fathers as a legitimate and necessary authority for interpreting
scripture. Both Catholic sides of the geocentric issue understand this
to be true.
QUOTE:
Council of Trent
Session IV, April 8, 1546, Decree Concerning the Edition and the Use of
the Sacred Books:
... "Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, it [the Council
of Trent] decrees that no one, relying on his own skill, shall,-in
matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of
Christian doctrine,-wresting the sacred Scriptures to his own senses,
presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense
which holy Mother Church-to whom it belongs to judge of the true sense
and interpretation of the Holy Scriptures-hath held and doth hold; or
even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such
interpretations were never (intended) to be at any time published.
Contraveners shall be made known by their Ordinaries and be punished
with the penalties by law established."
END QUOTE:
https://www.biblelightinfo.com/unanimous-consent.htm
Both Catholic sides of the issue claim that the Council of Trent caused
the Inquisition to ban Copernican writings and start treating
heliocentrism as a formal heresy because it went against the geocentric
beliefs of the church fathers.
You are taking all that crap from your geocentric hero; if you want to persist in taking his opinion against that of the Church's own
theologians then that is you just acting like Spikes rejecting the
opinion of scientists in favour of people who play to his confirmation
bias.
It was a mistake and the actors were in error only because of our
current understanding of nature. The Pope was wrong about it. He was
one of the mistaken actors.
The Pope was not a "mistaken actor", he was pissed off with Galileo presenting the Pope's views as those of a simpleton and misused his
powers to hit back at Galileo. Again, the Catholic Encyclopaedia
spells that explicitly:
"It is clear that the absurdity was the act of the Italian
Inquisition, for the private and personal pleasure of the pope - who
knew that the course he took could not convict him as pope - and not
of the body which calls itself the Church."
The Galileo affair was a shameful episode in the Church's history but
was all about the animosity between the Pope and Galileo, it had
nothing to do with heliocentrism being a heresy, that was just the
vehicle that the Pope used to attack Galileo.
On Mon, 17 Nov 2025 14:40:05 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/17/2025 11:45 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 17 Nov 2025 09:57:31 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[...]
Oops, the Pope was not infallible.
So papal infallibility is another thing you don't understand.
I am just repeating what the anti geocentrist want to claim about it.
The "anti-geocentrists" of whom you cannot identify even one. Mind
you, when you first brought in the website of your geocentrist mentor,
it was anonymous and you didn't even know who the author was until I
figured out; the fact that he is a declared geocentrist and you knew
nothing about him didn't stop you placing high value on his opinions
and continuing to do so.
Weird to say the least.
[...]
On Wed, 19 Nov 2025 14:55:52 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/19/2025 12:01 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 17 Nov 2025 14:40:05 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/17/2025 11:45 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 17 Nov 2025 09:57:31 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[...]
Oops, the Pope was not infallible.
So papal infallibility is another thing you don't understand.
I am just repeating what the anti geocentrist want to claim about it.
The "anti-geocentrists" of whom you cannot identify even one. Mind
you, when you first brought in the website of your geocentrist mentor,
it was anonymous and you didn't even know who the author was until I
figured out; the fact that he is a declared geocentrist and you knew
nothing about him didn't stop you placing high value on his opinions
and continuing to do so.
Weird to say the least.
[...]
You were given the links before,
Nope
so stop lying about it. Why should I
look up that junk again.
So you can prove I'm lying. But you can't because I'm not lying, you
gave no links except to the geocentrist idiot whose opinion you value
so highly.
You just denied that it was valid and kept
lying. Even your own trusted source backed up the anti geocentric site.
The anti geocentrists were on your side in terms of denying that it
was a formal heresy that Galileo faced the second time, but they agreed
with the geocentrists that the Inquisition had made it a formal heresy
charge the first time Galileo faced it and agreed with the Wiki. The
Vatican Observatory article that you have run from and snipped out of
this post backs up the geocentrists and anti geocentrists.
Just stop lying about the issue.
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/heliocentrism-condemned-400-years-ago-on-march-5-2/
They admit that helicentrism was condemned 400 years ago. 1616 is when
Galileo faced the formal heresy charge.
They do not consider the heresy cases, but they were based upon the
Inquisitions opinion of the topic.
Your claim of "never" having been condemned seems to be a lie.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo_Galilei
QUOTE:
In February 1616, an Inquisitorial commission declared heliocentrism to
be "foolish and absurd in philosophy, and formally heretical since it
explicitly contradicts in many places the sense of Holy Scripture".
END QUOTE:
Now YOU are the one lying about me. I never said it was never
condemned; on the contrary, I gave that exact same quote. What I did
was to point out that what it said was a FALSE CLAIM and it wasn't me
who came to that conclusion, it was the Catholic Church who came to
it, supported by every historian I know of who investigated it, people
like De Morgan and von Gebler. The only person I have ever known to
say there actually was a heresy is the geocentrist idiot whose opinion
you value so highly.
Both the geocentrists that you don't like, and the anti geocentric
catholics that do not agree with geocentric beliefs agreed that it was a
formal heresy charge the first time that Galileo faced the issue.
Now you seem to be trying to worm your way out of it by admitting
there was a *charge* without retracting that there was an actual
heresy which is what you have been claiming all long.
You can't just keep refusing to deal with reality and expect anything to
change.
You can't keep claiming support from "anti-geocentrists" about
heliocentrism having been an actual heresy without being able to
identify even one and expect people to take you seriously.
On Thu, 20 Nov 2025 09:38:56 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>heliocentrism to
wrote:
On 11/20/2025 4:47 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 19 Nov 2025 14:55:52 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[snip for focus]
Your claim of "never" having been condemned seems to be a lie.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo_Galilei
QUOTE:
In February 1616, an Inquisitorial commission declared
be "foolish and absurd in philosophy, and formally heretical since it
explicitly contradicts in many places the sense of Holy Scripture".
END QUOTE:
Now YOU are the one lying about me. I never said it was never
condemned; on the contrary, I gave that exact same quote. What I did
was to point out that what it said was a FALSE CLAIM and it wasn't me
who came to that conclusion, it was the Catholic Church who came to
it, supported by every historian I know of who investigated it, people
like De Morgan and von Gebler. The only person I have ever known to
say there actually was a heresy is the geocentrist idiot whose opinion
you value so highly.
You put up the quote that said it had never been condemned. Go back up
and check. It was your quote.
Here is verbatim what I quoted:
Message-ID: 2gkkhk9bvctolude5jf6b6e0kothd5723d@4ax.com ========================================
<quote>
The [site] that cites von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei"):
"The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for the Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
==========================================
#1: it was von Gebler who said rCLnever condemnedrCY, not me as you
claimed two posts ago.
#2 he did not say it was never condemned, he said *the Church* never condemned it.
Why do you post lies that are so easily shown to be lies?
On Fri, 21 Nov 2025 17:33:49 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/21/2025 12:29 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 21 Nov 2025 09:04:37 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[rCa]
Let's cut to the chase here.
No lies to retract. You lied.
What lie are you claiming I told? Please quote exactly what I said
that you regard as a lie.
The ones that you keep telling.
"Never condemned"
I'm out of here. George Bernard Shaw warned that you shouldn't wrestle
with a pig as you get dirty and the pig enjoys it. I'm not going to
waste any more time trying to have a sensible discussion with someone
who thinks it's ok to take two words out of what somebody else said to
give a completely different meaning and then attribute those two words
to me. It doesn't even reach the level of quote-mining.
What beggars belief is that you do it where the exact quote from von
Gerber [1] and what I said about it are preserved just a couple of
posts above for all to see. As I noted earlier, it is really sad to
see this sort of behaviour from someone whose ability as a scientist I respect so much EfOU
===========================================
[1] "The Church never condemned it (the Copernican system) at all, for
the Qualifiers of the Holy Office never mean the Church."
[von Gebler ("Galileo Galilei")]
[..]
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 10:13:33 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
Now over 70K garbage. Have you really no clue how childish you are
making yourself look, disregarding one of the most fundamental,
longstanding principles of Usenet?
On Sun, 22 Feb 2026 13:40:10 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>what you
wrote:
On 2/22/2026 10:18 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 21 Feb 2026 12:44:57 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 2/21/2026 11:59 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
What documents are you talking about that you keep saying the Jesuits
put up?
You can keep lying about what has been discussed, but you know
was notdid. You need to be the one that finds it and satisfy yourself with
what you did.
You put up your source lying about heliocentrism never being condemned
by anyone but the Inquisition. You claimed that the Inquisition
ordered bythe Church. I put up the Jesuit Observatory claim that the Papal
offices had condemned heliocentrism and this condemnation was
sources havethe Pope. They put up the relevant document and stated what the Pope
did. Your source was caught lying and you ran. Go find it. It is
something that you should do because you will uncover all your other
evasions on this issue while doing it. Your quotes of your
always come up short. The sources that you claim are unreliable, have
repeatedly been shown to be more reliable than what you come up with.
Oh, you mean the link you gave back in November, this one:
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/heliocentrism-condemned-400-years-ago-on-march-5-2/
The one where they posted the full 1616 decree on it's 400th
anniversary and commented:
<quote>
The formulation here is much milder than the one found in the working
document of February 24. The Decree talks about the "false Pythagorean
doctrine" and declare it "altogether contrary to the Holy Scripture".
This is not nearly as harsh as "foolish and absurd" philosophically,
and "formally heretical" because contrary to Scripture.
</quote>
How fucking dense can you be? It doesn't get much stupider than
posting something that contradicts what you are claiming.
If I am the dense one why did you run from what they admitted about the
document?
LOL, you post something that you think supports your claim but
actually rejects it and the best defence you can offer is to accuse me
of running away from it.
The Pope did condemn heliocentrism.
Beats me why you keep repeating this. The Pope did not personally
condemn heliocentrism, he allowed the Inquisition's condemnation of it
to be made public - that did not make it a heresy.
That is what your side was lying
about.
The only one telling lies here is you. For example, when you keep
insisting that all the "anti-geocentrists" in the Catholic
Encyclopaedia article agree with you that heliocentrism was a heresy
when they all say explicitly that it wasn't. Your lie is underlined by
the fact that you can't produce identify any source that agrees that heliocentrism was a heresy except your geocentrist mentors.
reality.It doesn't matter that the final wording was milder than the
initial draft. They admit that the Pope condemned heliocentrism, and
supported using the Council of Trent's scriptural interpretation on the
matter. It doesn't matter what it was called because the authors and
books are named. You ran from this link because your source was found
to have lied about heliocentrism never having been condemned except by
the Inquisition. The Pope obviously represents the Church and condemned
heliocentrism. He supported the Inquisition in 1616, and their
additions to the Index in order to protect against heresy. The books
would not have been added to the Index if they were not considered to be
heretical. The document even talks about the heretical parts of the
books, and indicates that after one of them is rewritten, so that it is
not against scripture, that it can be removed from the Index.
Keep lying to yourself about the issue. It isn't going to change
The Inquisition made heliocentrism a formal heresy in 1615-1616.
The decree is given in full on the Vatican Observatory site that you
tried to claim supports you and the word 'heresy' or 'heretical' does
not even appear in it.
They
did this because of their interpretation of scripture as the Council of
Trent had decided.
The decree doesn't make any reference whatsoever to Trent regarding interpretation of scripture; the one and only reference is to the *punishment* under Trent for disobeying the decree.
They added heliocentric writings to the Index,
They declare that "the books by Nicolaus Copernicus (On the
Revolutions of Spheres) and by Diego de Zu|#iga (On Job) be suspended
until corrected".
I've given details of the required corrections to Revolutions in a
different post to Harshman and they are all minor edits - not one of
them makes any change to the core principle of heliocentrism. A rather
weird declaration of heresy that allows Copernicus's book supporting
it to be published with minor edits that don't undermine his
proposition.
and
had their first encounter with Galileo. The Pope agreed with them and
condemned heliocentrism, and agreed with their additions to the Index of
banned writings.
Before your source lied about "never being condemned" the Pope's
involvement in 1616 was not an issue between the geocentric and
anti-geocentric Catholics in terms of what you were lying about at the
time. Both sides agreed that it was a formal heresy charge faced by
Galileo in 1615-1616. They disagreed about it being a formal heresy
charge the second time because it was only written up as "heresy" and
not formal heresy in the sentencing. It remained a heresy charge.
You obviously struggle with grasping that a *charge* does not make
someone guilty. I hope I'm never on trial for something I didn't do
with you on the jury.
The
Pope had the Galileo case, sentencing, and punishment published and
distributed throughout the Church in order to quash the heliocentric
heresy, but the guys that want to maintain Papal infallibility claim
that that was not an official Papal action. They admitted that there
was an issue with helicentrism at the time, but they do not want the
Pope to have been on the wrong side of the issue.
You need to deal with reality.
I think it's very clear who has the problem with accepting reality and
it's not me.
It is well understood that the Bible is
just wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves.
Your own quotes from Pope Francis makes that claim. The Bible can be
misinterpreted because the author's understanding of the creation was
faulty. Francis knows that the universe was not created in 6 magic
episodes. Only those in complete denial do not understand that the
order of creation described in the Bible is wrong. There are still
young earth, old earth day for agers, geocentric, and flat earth
Biblical creationists because they are in the same type of denial that
you are in. There are just different levels of denial.
Ron Okimoto
On 11/10/2026 11:28 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 10:13:33 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
Now over 70K garbage. Have you really no clue how childish you are
making yourself look, disregarding one of the most fundamental,
longstanding principles of Usenet?
True to form. For some stupid reason Harran can't deal honestly with
the second REPOST where he is demonstrated to have tried to quote mine
the Papal condemnation in order to support his source that lied about
the situation.
This is the material that Harran was lying about, and now he can't deal
with it's existence.
What is so terrible about this second REPOST that Harran has to lie to >himself about snipping and running? It is actually much shorter than
the first REPOST. That is how stupid Harran's delusions have to be. In
the original thread Harran would just run from this REPOST without >acknowledging that it existed, but he screwed up and accidently snipped
and ran from it a couple of times, and each time he ran from what he did >instead of continuing to do it. It somehow crosses Harran's delusional
line of how dishonest and stupid he is allowed to be.
Second Harran repost:
On 4/21/2026 10:38 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 20 Apr 2026 13:40:43 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/20/2026 4:08 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 18 Apr 2026 12:06:53 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/18/2026 6:24 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:31:27 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/15/2026 11:36 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 16:59:56 +0100, "Kerr-Mudd, John"
[rCa]
No one is going to convince an opponent by stating that "they are lying".
and probably not by constant repetition of the same arguments (no matter
how valid) that failed to get through the first 50 times.
Tell that to RonO, he's the one who keeps calling everyone who
disagrees with him a liar.
Who got caught lying and quote mining? You need to deal with reality,
and quit lying about it. Lying about me is just so stupid that it is
pretty much insane. You have always lied about the sources that you
could not deal honestly with. Who's sources have always come up short?
Look at what you are doing now. Is there any excuse for you not dealing
with your own stupid dishonest behavior?
The tiresomeness of you continually claiming that my sources were
caught lying and that I have been lying and quote mining is matched by
the tiresomeness of your inability to ever identify what lie my
sources were caught in, what lies I have told or where I have quote
mined.
[... more big snip ...]
Why keep lying about what your sources did and what you did? That is
just stupid and dishonest. Just look up your past posts to determine
for yourself what went down. You tried to lie about my sources being >deficient when your sources had always come up short or even supported
my sources by putting up the lame lie that heliocentrism had never been >condemned other then by the inquisition. It was stupid because it did
not negate what you and your sources had been wrong about. It turned
out that your source was lying and you ran. You ran twice from the same >evidence that your source was lying. You tried to come back with your
lame quote mining efforts and trying to distract the argument from what
it had been. You did that, and your source was demonstrated to have
lied about the issue. You need to go back and deal with what you did.
An appology for your disgraceful behavior would be in order. Just try
not to do it again. Continuing to lie about what happened is just
adding to how low you needed to go.
Yet again, you make all sorts of accusations without a single example
of something to support them.
What I cannot figure out is whether you just can't grasp that your
failure to produce a single example of supporting evidence portrays
*you* as the one telling lies; or whether you do grasp it and just
don't care; or whether, like a certain President, you think that if
you repeat a lie enough times that someone will eventually believe it.
You should apologize for what you have been doing and stop doing it. I
found the posts where you ran from your source having been caught lying,
you then snipped the evidence out of your response to your running.
The thread: There is no legitimate scientific support for the ID scam.
I can post your quote mining attempts and other stupid behavior that you >resorted to to defend your running and defense of your bogus source.
So why don't you instead of talking about it?
Specific examples, please, not reams and reams of obfuscatory cut'n
paste.
You should not continue to add to your own dishonest stupidity.
Trusting your source was obviously a stupid thing to do, and trying to >continue to support that source was just stupid and dishonest.
Ron Okimoto
This the other thread string that was in the "Chimp to human >evolution-Sandwalk perspective" thread. This posts demonstrates that
Harran tried to quote mine the condemnation. If you go to other posts
in this thread string you will find Harran having memory lapse of his >running from the Vatican observatory link. This was his attempt to try
to claim that he did not have to run. He literally tried to quote mine
the document so that it would not have been considered to be a
condemnation of heliocentrism by only quoting a bit of what was being >condemned.
REPOST:
On 2/23/2026 7:03 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 22 Feb 2026 13:40:10 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
what youOn 2/22/2026 10:18 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 21 Feb 2026 12:44:57 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 2/21/2026 11:59 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
What documents are you talking about that you keep saying the Jesuits >>>>> put up?
You can keep lying about what has been discussed, but you know
was notdid. You need to be the one that finds it and satisfy yourself with >>>> what you did.
You put up your source lying about heliocentrism never being condemned >>>> by anyone but the Inquisition. You claimed that the Inquisition
ordered bythe Church. I put up the Jesuit Observatory claim that the Papal
offices had condemned heliocentrism and this condemnation was
sources havethe Pope. They put up the relevant document and stated what the Pope >>>> did. Your source was caught lying and you ran. Go find it. It is
something that you should do because you will uncover all your other >>>> evasions on this issue while doing it. Your quotes of your
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/heliocentrism-condemned-400-years-ago-on-march-5-2/always come up short. The sources that you claim are unreliable, have >>>> repeatedly been shown to be more reliable than what you come up with. >>>Oh, you mean the link you gave back in November, this one:
The one where they posted the full 1616 decree on it's 400th
anniversary and commented:
<quote>
The formulation here is much milder than the one found in the working
document of February 24. The Decree talks about the "false Pythagorean >>> doctrine" and declare it "altogether contrary to the Holy Scripture".
This is not nearly as harsh as "foolish and absurd" philosophically,
and "formally heretical" because contrary to Scripture.
</quote>
How fucking dense can you be? It doesn't get much stupider than
posting something that contradicts what you are claiming.
If I am the dense one why did you run from what they admitted about the
document?
LOL, you post something that you think supports your claim but
actually rejects it and the best defence you can offer is to accuse me
of running away from it.
You did run, twice in that thread. You would not address your source >getting caught lying.
The Pope did condemn heliocentrism.
Beats me why you keep repeating this. The Pope did not personally
condemn heliocentrism, he allowed the Inquisition's condemnation of it
to be made public - that did not make it a heresy.
He did more than allow, he directed that it should be published. Why
deny what the source claimed? The source admits that it was a Papal >condemnation. They just claim that it was a toned down condemnation >compared to the first draft of the document that still exists.
There is no reason to try to weasel out of the fact that you ran and
would not even try to lie about the situation the first time you were
given this link. It did just what I claimed at the time. Your source
was found to have lied about the situation, and could not be trusted.
You can't say that about any of my sources. You just keep lying about
those sources being unreliable when it has always been your sources that >came up short.
That is what your side was lying
about.
The only one telling lies here is you. For example, when you keep
insisting that all the "anti-geocentrists" in the Catholic
Encyclopaedia article agree with you that heliocentrism was a heresy
when they all say explicitly that it wasn't. Your lie is underlined by
the fact that you can't produce identify any source that agrees that heliocentrism was a heresy except your geocentrist mentors.
Your source lied about the Inquisition being the only church arm to have >condemned heliocentrism. It was a false statement and should have been >known to be a false statement. Lying about the Pope only allowing the >publication when he wanted it to be published, and directed that it
should be written up and published. The Jesuits are pretty matter of
fact that it was a Papal condemnation of heliocentrism. They note that
it is the only instance of any Pope directly condemning heliocentrism.
reality.It doesn't matter that the final wording was milder than the
initial draft. They admit that the Pope condemned heliocentrism, and
supported using the Council of Trent's scriptural interpretation on the
matter. It doesn't matter what it was called because the authors and
books are named. You ran from this link because your source was found
to have lied about heliocentrism never having been condemned except by
the Inquisition. The Pope obviously represents the Church and condemned >> heliocentrism. He supported the Inquisition in 1616, and their
additions to the Index in order to protect against heresy. The books
would not have been added to the Index if they were not considered to be >> heretical. The document even talks about the heretical parts of the
books, and indicates that after one of them is rewritten, so that it is
not against scripture, that it can be removed from the Index.
Keep lying to yourself about the issue. It isn't going to change
The Inquisition made heliocentrism a formal heresy in 1615-1616.
The decree is given in full on the Vatican Observatory site that you
tried to claim supports you and the word 'heresy' or 'heretical' does
not even appear in it.
It was not put up to claim heresy even though that is what it did. That >document condemned heliocentrism and supported heliocentric writings
being added to the Index. Those writings were deemed to be heretical
and against scripture. Lying about something else does not change the
fact that your source was caught lying. You know what condemning means
so why try to lie about the situation in this way? What was your source >trying to lie about by claiming that heliocentrism had only been
condemned by the Inquisition? You know why your source told that lie,
so why try to weasel out of the fact that they lied?
They
did this because of their interpretation of scripture as the Council of
Trent had decided.
The decree doesn't make any reference whatsoever to Trent regarding interpretation of scripture; the one and only reference is to the *punishment* under Trent for disobeying the decree.
The decree doesn't need to reference Trent in terms of scriptural >interpretation because that had already been decided by the Inquisition
when it added the writings to the Index. Those writings would not have
been added to the Index if it were not for the Council of Trents >determination about scriptural interpretation. The Pope agreed with
those additions to the Index, so he must have agreed with the
Inquisitions scriptural interpretation.
They added heliocentric writings to the Index,
They declare that "the books by Nicolaus Copernicus (On the
Revolutions of Spheres) and by Diego de Zu|#iga (On Job) be suspended
until corrected".
The Books by Copernicus were never corrected and republished, so his >writings were banned until removed from the index centuries later. I
see that you left out the book that could not be corrected and would be >permanently banned. Why did you do that? Isn't this quote mining? >Heliocentrism was condemned and heliocentric writings were added to the >Index. End of that story.
QUOTE:
Decree
of the Sacred Congregation of the Most Illustrious Cardinals of the Holy >Roman Church especially charged by Our Holy Lord Pope Paul V and by the
Holy Apostolic See with the Index of books and their licensing,
prohibition, correction, and printing in all of Christendom, to be
published everywhere.
In regard to several books containing various heresies and errors, to >prevent the emergence of more serious harm throughout Christendom, the >Sacred Congregation of the Most Illustrious Cardinals of the Holy Roman >Church in charge of the Index has decided that they should be altogether >condemned and prohibited, as indeed with the present decree it condemns
and prohibits them, wherever and in whatever language they are printed
or about to be printed.
END QUOTE:
This is no quote mine, but you can find your quote in the following >paragraph:
QUOTE:
This Holy Congregation has also learned about the spreading and
acceptance by many of the false Pythagorean doctrine, altogether
contrary to the Holy Scripture, that the earth moves and the sun is >motionless, which is also taught by Nicolaus CopernicusrCOs On the >Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres and by Diego de Zu|#igarCOs On Job.
This may be seen from a certain letter published by a certain Carmelite >Father whose title is Letter of the Reverend Father Paolo Antonio
Foscarini on the Pythagorean and Copernican Opinion of the EarthrCOs
Motion and SunrCOs Rest and on the New Pythagorean World System (Naples: >Lazzaro Scoriggio, 1615), in which the said Father tries to show that
the above-4mentioned doctrine of the sunrCOs rest at the center of the
world and of the earthrCOs motion is consonant with the truth and does not >contradict Holy Scripture. Therefore, in order that this opinion may not >advance any further to the prejudice of Catholic truth, the Congregation
has decided that the books by Nicolaus Copernicus (On the Revolutions of >Spheres) and by Diego de Zu|#iga (On Job) be suspended until corrected;
but that the book of the Carmelite Father Paolo Antonio Foscarini be >completely prohibited and condemned; and that all other books which
teach the same be likewise prohibited, according to whether with the
present Decree it prohibits, condemns, and suspends them respectively.
END QUOTE:
It looks like you tried to quote mine what had been quoted on the site.
There is no reason to try to weasel out of why you ran from this link >before.
I've given details of the required corrections to Revolutions in a different post to Harshman and they are all minor edits - not one of
them makes any change to the core principle of heliocentrism. A rather weird declaration of heresy that allows Copernicus's book supporting
it to be published with minor edits that don't undermine his
proposition.
So what? Copernicus' writings remained on the Index for centuries, and
the heliocentric writings of Father Paolo Antonio Foscarini was
"completely prohibited and condemned" for the same period of time.
and
had their first encounter with Galileo. The Pope agreed with them and
condemned heliocentrism, and agreed with their additions to the Index of >> banned writings.
Before your source lied about "never being condemned" the Pope's
involvement in 1616 was not an issue between the geocentric and
anti-geocentric Catholics in terms of what you were lying about at the
time. Both sides agreed that it was a formal heresy charge faced by
Galileo in 1615-1616. They disagreed about it being a formal heresy
charge the second time because it was only written up as "heresy" and
not formal heresy in the sentencing. It remained a heresy charge.
You obviously struggle with grasping that a *charge* does not make
someone guilty. I hope I'm never on trial for something I didn't do
with you on the jury.
Galileo was not found guilty in 1616, but he was facing a formal heresy >charge. The Inquisition's condemnation was backed up by the Pope in
1616. That is what you are currently waffling about. Your source lied.
The
Pope had the Galileo case, sentencing, and punishment published and
distributed throughout the Church in order to quash the heliocentric
heresy, but the guys that want to maintain Papal infallibility claim
that that was not an official Papal action. They admitted that there
was an issue with helicentrism at the time, but they do not want the
Pope to have been on the wrong side of the issue.
You need to deal with reality.
I think it's very clear who has the problem with accepting reality and
it's not me.
I think that it is clear that your sources are as unreliable as you are.
You clearly quote mined above, so why lie about who has an issue with
dealing with reality?
Ron Okimoto
It is well understood that the Bible is
just wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves.
Your own quotes from Pope Francis makes that claim. The Bible can be
misinterpreted because the author's understanding of the creation was
faulty. Francis knows that the universe was not created in 6 magic
episodes. Only those in complete denial do not understand that the
order of creation described in the Bible is wrong. There are still
young earth, old earth day for agers, geocentric, and flat earth
Biblical creationists because they are in the same type of denial that
you are in. There are just different levels of denial.
Ron Okimoto
END REPOST:
Harran should apologize and stop lying about the past.
Ron Okimoto
You should appologize and stop lying about the past.
Ron Okimoto
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 12:24:39 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/10/2026 11:28 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 10:13:33 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
Now over 70K garbage. Have you really no clue how childish you are
making yourself look, disregarding one of the most fundamental,
longstanding principles of Usenet?
True to form. For some stupid reason Harran can't deal honestly with
the second REPOST where he is demonstrated to have tried to quote mine
the Papal condemnation in order to support his source that lied about
the situation.
This is the material that Harran was lying about, and now he can't deal
with it's existence.
What is so terrible about this second REPOST that Harran has to lie to
himself about snipping and running? It is actually much shorter than
the first REPOST. That is how stupid Harran's delusions have to be. In
the original thread Harran would just run from this REPOST without
acknowledging that it existed, but he screwed up and accidently snipped
and ran from it a couple of times, and each time he ran from what he did
instead of continuing to do it. It somehow crosses Harran's delusional
line of how dishonest and stupid he is allowed to be.
Second Harran repost:
Just to show how utterly imbecilic these reposts are, how is anyone
supposed to know who said what below. Catch yourself on, Ron.
This is Kerr-mud
On 4/21/2026 10:38 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 20 Apr 2026 13:40:43 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/20/2026 4:08 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 18 Apr 2026 12:06:53 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/18/2026 6:24 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:31:27 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/15/2026 11:36 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 16:59:56 +0100, "Kerr-Mudd, John"
[rCa]
No one is going to convince an opponent by stating that "they are lying".
and probably not by constant repetition of the same arguments (no matter
how valid) that failed to get through the first 50 times.
This is me:
Tell that to RonO, he's the one who keeps calling everyone who
disagrees with him a liar.
Who got caught lying and quote mining? You need to deal with reality,
and quit lying about it. Lying about me is just so stupid that it is
pretty much insane. You have always lied about the sources that you
could not deal honestly with. Who's sources have always come up short?
Look at what you are doing now. Is there any excuse for you not dealing
with your own stupid dishonest behavior?
your snip:The tiresomeness of you continually claiming that my sources were
caught lying and that I have been lying and quote mining is matched by
the tiresomeness of your inability to ever identify what lie my
sources were caught in, what lies I have told or where I have quote
mined.
[... more big snip ...]
This is me:
This is you wanting evidence that you have been lying:Why keep lying about what your sources did and what you did? That is
just stupid and dishonest. Just look up your past posts to determine
for yourself what went down. You tried to lie about my sources being
deficient when your sources had always come up short or even supported
my sources by putting up the lame lie that heliocentrism had never been
condemned other then by the inquisition. It was stupid because it did
not negate what you and your sources had been wrong about. It turned
out that your source was lying and you ran. You ran twice from the same
evidence that your source was lying. You tried to come back with your
lame quote mining efforts and trying to distract the argument from what
it had been. You did that, and your source was demonstrated to have
lied about the issue. You need to go back and deal with what you did.
An appology for your disgraceful behavior would be in order. Just try
not to do it again. Continuing to lie about what happened is just
adding to how low you needed to go.
This is me responding to your stupid lies:Yet again, you make all sorts of accusations without a single example
of something to support them.
What I cannot figure out is whether you just can't grasp that your
failure to produce a single example of supporting evidence portrays
*you* as the one telling lies; or whether you do grasp it and just
don't care; or whether, like a certain President, you think that if
you repeat a lie enough times that someone will eventually believe it.
You should apologize for what you have been doing and stop doing it. I
found the posts where you ran from your source having been caught lying,
you then snipped the evidence out of your response to your running.
The thread: There is no legitimate scientific support for the ID scam.
I can post your quote mining attempts and other stupid behavior that you
resorted to to defend your running and defense of your bogus source.
This is me:So why don't you instead of talking about it?
Specific examples, please, not reams and reams of obfuscatory cut'n
paste.
This is me providing the evidence that you lied about existing. All the subsequent attributions are intact. You can not deal with the evidenceYou should not continue to add to your own dishonest stupidity.
Trusting your source was obviously a stupid thing to do, and trying to
continue to support that source was just stupid and dishonest.
Ron Okimoto
This the other thread string that was in the "Chimp to human
evolution-Sandwalk perspective" thread. This posts demonstrates that
Harran tried to quote mine the condemnation. If you go to other posts
in this thread string you will find Harran having memory lapse of his
running from the Vatican observatory link. This was his attempt to try
to claim that he did not have to run. He literally tried to quote mine
the document so that it would not have been considered to be a
condemnation of heliocentrism by only quoting a bit of what was being
condemned.
REPOST:
On 2/23/2026 7:03 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 22 Feb 2026 13:40:10 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>what you
wrote:
On 2/22/2026 10:18 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 21 Feb 2026 12:44:57 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 2/21/2026 11:59 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
What documents are you talking about that you keep saying the Jesuits >>>>>>> put up?
You can keep lying about what has been discussed, but you know
was notdid. You need to be the one that finds it and satisfy yourself with >>>>>> what you did.
You put up your source lying about heliocentrism never being condemned >>>>>> by anyone but the Inquisition. You claimed that the Inquisition
ordered bythe Church. I put up the Jesuit Observatory claim that the Papal
offices had condemned heliocentrism and this condemnation was
sources havethe Pope. They put up the relevant document and stated what the Pope >>>>>> did. Your source was caught lying and you ran. Go find it. It is >>>>>> something that you should do because you will uncover all your other >>>>>> evasions on this issue while doing it. Your quotes of your
https://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/heliocentrism-condemned-400-years-ago-on-march-5-2/always come up short. The sources that you claim are unreliable, have >>>>>> repeatedly been shown to be more reliable than what you come up with. >>>>>Oh, you mean the link you gave back in November, this one:
The one where they posted the full 1616 decree on it's 400th
anniversary and commented:
<quote>
The formulation here is much milder than the one found in the working >>>>> document of February 24. The Decree talks about the "false Pythagorean >>>>> doctrine" and declare it "altogether contrary to the Holy Scripture". >>>>> This is not nearly as harsh as "foolish and absurd" philosophically, >>>>> and "formally heretical" because contrary to Scripture.
</quote>
How fucking dense can you be? It doesn't get much stupider than
posting something that contradicts what you are claiming.
If I am the dense one why did you run from what they admitted about the >>>> document?
LOL, you post something that you think supports your claim but
actually rejects it and the best defence you can offer is to accuse me
of running away from it.
You did run, twice in that thread. You would not address your source
getting caught lying.
The Pope did condemn heliocentrism.
Beats me why you keep repeating this. The Pope did not personally
condemn heliocentrism, he allowed the Inquisition's condemnation of it
to be made public - that did not make it a heresy.
He did more than allow, he directed that it should be published. Why
deny what the source claimed? The source admits that it was a Papal
condemnation. They just claim that it was a toned down condemnation
compared to the first draft of the document that still exists.
There is no reason to try to weasel out of the fact that you ran and
would not even try to lie about the situation the first time you were
given this link. It did just what I claimed at the time. Your source
was found to have lied about the situation, and could not be trusted.
You can't say that about any of my sources. You just keep lying about
those sources being unreliable when it has always been your sources that
came up short.
That is what your side was lying
about.
The only one telling lies here is you. For example, when you keep
insisting that all the "anti-geocentrists" in the Catholic
Encyclopaedia article agree with you that heliocentrism was a heresy
when they all say explicitly that it wasn't. Your lie is underlined by
the fact that you can't produce identify any source that agrees that
heliocentrism was a heresy except your geocentrist mentors.
Your source lied about the Inquisition being the only church arm to have
condemned heliocentrism. It was a false statement and should have been
known to be a false statement. Lying about the Pope only allowing the
publication when he wanted it to be published, and directed that it
should be written up and published. The Jesuits are pretty matter of
fact that it was a Papal condemnation of heliocentrism. They note that
it is the only instance of any Pope directly condemning heliocentrism.
reality.
It doesn't matter that the final wording was milder than the
initial draft. They admit that the Pope condemned heliocentrism, and
supported using the Council of Trent's scriptural interpretation on the >>>> matter. It doesn't matter what it was called because the authors and
books are named. You ran from this link because your source was found >>>> to have lied about heliocentrism never having been condemned except by >>>> the Inquisition. The Pope obviously represents the Church and condemned >>>> heliocentrism. He supported the Inquisition in 1616, and their
additions to the Index in order to protect against heresy. The books
would not have been added to the Index if they were not considered to be >>>> heretical. The document even talks about the heretical parts of the
books, and indicates that after one of them is rewritten, so that it is >>>> not against scripture, that it can be removed from the Index.
Keep lying to yourself about the issue. It isn't going to change
The Inquisition made heliocentrism a formal heresy in 1615-1616.
The decree is given in full on the Vatican Observatory site that you
tried to claim supports you and the word 'heresy' or 'heretical' does
not even appear in it.
It was not put up to claim heresy even though that is what it did. That
document condemned heliocentrism and supported heliocentric writings
being added to the Index. Those writings were deemed to be heretical
and against scripture. Lying about something else does not change the
fact that your source was caught lying. You know what condemning means
so why try to lie about the situation in this way? What was your source
trying to lie about by claiming that heliocentrism had only been
condemned by the Inquisition? You know why your source told that lie,
so why try to weasel out of the fact that they lied?
They
did this because of their interpretation of scripture as the Council of >>>> Trent had decided.
The decree doesn't make any reference whatsoever to Trent regarding
interpretation of scripture; the one and only reference is to the
*punishment* under Trent for disobeying the decree.
The decree doesn't need to reference Trent in terms of scriptural
interpretation because that had already been decided by the Inquisition
when it added the writings to the Index. Those writings would not have
been added to the Index if it were not for the Council of Trents
determination about scriptural interpretation. The Pope agreed with
those additions to the Index, so he must have agreed with the
Inquisitions scriptural interpretation.
They added heliocentric writings to the Index,
They declare that "the books by Nicolaus Copernicus (On the
Revolutions of Spheres) and by Diego de Zu|#iga (On Job) be suspended
until corrected".
The Books by Copernicus were never corrected and republished, so his
writings were banned until removed from the index centuries later. I
see that you left out the book that could not be corrected and would be
permanently banned. Why did you do that? Isn't this quote mining?
Heliocentrism was condemned and heliocentric writings were added to the
Index. End of that story.
QUOTE:
Decree
of the Sacred Congregation of the Most Illustrious Cardinals of the Holy
Roman Church especially charged by Our Holy Lord Pope Paul V and by the
Holy Apostolic See with the Index of books and their licensing,
prohibition, correction, and printing in all of Christendom, to be
published everywhere.
In regard to several books containing various heresies and errors, to
prevent the emergence of more serious harm throughout Christendom, the
Sacred Congregation of the Most Illustrious Cardinals of the Holy Roman
Church in charge of the Index has decided that they should be altogether
condemned and prohibited, as indeed with the present decree it condemns
and prohibits them, wherever and in whatever language they are printed
or about to be printed.
END QUOTE:
This is no quote mine, but you can find your quote in the following
paragraph:
QUOTE:
This Holy Congregation has also learned about the spreading and
acceptance by many of the false Pythagorean doctrine, altogether
contrary to the Holy Scripture, that the earth moves and the sun is
motionless, which is also taught by Nicolaus CopernicusrCOs On the
Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres and by Diego de Zu|#igarCOs On Job.
This may be seen from a certain letter published by a certain Carmelite
Father whose title is Letter of the Reverend Father Paolo Antonio
Foscarini on the Pythagorean and Copernican Opinion of the EarthrCOs
Motion and SunrCOs Rest and on the New Pythagorean World System (Naples:
Lazzaro Scoriggio, 1615), in which the said Father tries to show that
the above-4mentioned doctrine of the sunrCOs rest at the center of the
world and of the earthrCOs motion is consonant with the truth and does not >> contradict Holy Scripture. Therefore, in order that this opinion may not
advance any further to the prejudice of Catholic truth, the Congregation
has decided that the books by Nicolaus Copernicus (On the Revolutions of
Spheres) and by Diego de Zu|#iga (On Job) be suspended until corrected;
but that the book of the Carmelite Father Paolo Antonio Foscarini be
completely prohibited and condemned; and that all other books which
teach the same be likewise prohibited, according to whether with the
present Decree it prohibits, condemns, and suspends them respectively.
END QUOTE:
It looks like you tried to quote mine what had been quoted on the site.
There is no reason to try to weasel out of why you ran from this link
before.
I've given details of the required corrections to Revolutions in a
different post to Harshman and they are all minor edits - not one of
them makes any change to the core principle of heliocentrism. A rather
weird declaration of heresy that allows Copernicus's book supporting
it to be published with minor edits that don't undermine his
proposition.
So what? Copernicus' writings remained on the Index for centuries, and
the heliocentric writings of Father Paolo Antonio Foscarini was
"completely prohibited and condemned" for the same period of time.
and
had their first encounter with Galileo. The Pope agreed with them and >>>> condemned heliocentrism, and agreed with their additions to the Index of >>>> banned writings.
Before your source lied about "never being condemned" the Pope's
involvement in 1616 was not an issue between the geocentric and
anti-geocentric Catholics in terms of what you were lying about at the >>>> time. Both sides agreed that it was a formal heresy charge faced by
Galileo in 1615-1616. They disagreed about it being a formal heresy
charge the second time because it was only written up as "heresy" and
not formal heresy in the sentencing. It remained a heresy charge.
You obviously struggle with grasping that a *charge* does not make
someone guilty. I hope I'm never on trial for something I didn't do
with you on the jury.
Galileo was not found guilty in 1616, but he was facing a formal heresy
charge. The Inquisition's condemnation was backed up by the Pope in
1616. That is what you are currently waffling about. Your source lied.
The
Pope had the Galileo case, sentencing, and punishment published and
distributed throughout the Church in order to quash the heliocentric
heresy, but the guys that want to maintain Papal infallibility claim
that that was not an official Papal action. They admitted that there
was an issue with helicentrism at the time, but they do not want the
Pope to have been on the wrong side of the issue.
You need to deal with reality.
I think it's very clear who has the problem with accepting reality and
it's not me.
I think that it is clear that your sources are as unreliable as you are.
You clearly quote mined above, so why lie about who has an issue with
dealing with reality?
Ron Okimoto
END REPOST:
It is well understood that the Bible is
just wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves. >>>> Your own quotes from Pope Francis makes that claim. The Bible can be
misinterpreted because the author's understanding of the creation was
faulty. Francis knows that the universe was not created in 6 magic
episodes. Only those in complete denial do not understand that the
order of creation described in the Bible is wrong. There are still
young earth, old earth day for agers, geocentric, and flat earth
Biblical creationists because they are in the same type of denial that >>>> you are in. There are just different levels of denial.
Ron Okimoto
Harran should apologize and stop lying about the past.
Ron Okimoto
You should appologize and stop lying about the past.
Ron Okimoto
The attributions are only messed up in the post spawned reposting what
you did in another thread.
On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 11:47:00 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
[...]
The attributions are only messed up in the post spawned reposting what
you did in another thread.
It's YOU that is messed up!
[...]
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 12:24:39 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/10/2026 11:28 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 10:13:33 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
Now over 70K garbage. Have you really no clue how childish you are
making yourself look, disregarding one of the most fundamental,
longstanding principles of Usenet?
True to form. For some stupid reason Harran can't deal honestly with
the second REPOST where he is demonstrated to have tried to quote mine
the Papal condemnation in order to support his source that lied about
the situation.
This is the material that Harran was lying about, and now he can't deal
with it's existence.
What is so terrible about this second REPOST that Harran has to lie to
himself about snipping and running? It is actually much shorter than
the first REPOST. That is how stupid Harran's delusions have to be. In
the original thread Harran would just run from this REPOST without
acknowledging that it existed, but he screwed up and accidently snipped
and ran from it a couple of times, and each time he ran from what he did
instead of continuing to do it. It somehow crosses Harran's delusional
line of how dishonest and stupid he is allowed to be.
Second Harran repost:
Just to show how utterly imbecilic these reposts are, how is anyone
supposed to know who said what below. Catch yourself on, Ron.
This is Kerr-mud
On 4/21/2026 10:38 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Mon, 20 Apr 2026 13:40:43 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/20/2026 4:08 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 18 Apr 2026 12:06:53 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/18/2026 6:24 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 14:31:27 -0500, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 4/15/2026 11:36 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Wed, 15 Apr 2026 16:59:56 +0100, "Kerr-Mudd, John"
[rCa]
lying".No one is going to convince an opponent by stating that "they are
and probably not by constant repetition of the same arguments (no matter
how valid) that failed to get through the first 50 times.
This is me:
Tell that to RonO, he's the one who keeps calling everyone who
disagrees with him a liar.
Who got caught lying and quote mining? You need to deal with reality,
and quit lying about it. Lying about me is just so stupid that it is
pretty much insane. You have always lied about the sources that you
could not deal honestly with. Who's sources have always come up short?
Look at what you are doing now. Is there any excuse for you not dealing
with your own stupid dishonest behavior?
your snip:The tiresomeness of you continually claiming that my sources were
caught lying and that I have been lying and quote mining is matched by
the tiresomeness of your inability to ever identify what lie my
sources were caught in, what lies I have told or where I have quote
mined.
[... more big snip ...]
This is me:
This is you wanting evidence that you have been lying:Why keep lying about what your sources did and what you did? That is
just stupid and dishonest. Just look up your past posts to determine
for yourself what went down. You tried to lie about my sources being
deficient when your sources had always come up short or even supported
my sources by putting up the lame lie that heliocentrism had never been
condemned other then by the inquisition. It was stupid because it did
not negate what you and your sources had been wrong about. It turned
out that your source was lying and you ran. You ran twice from the same
evidence that your source was lying. You tried to come back with your
lame quote mining efforts and trying to distract the argument from what
it had been. You did that, and your source was demonstrated to have
lied about the issue. You need to go back and deal with what you did.
An appology for your disgraceful behavior would be in order. Just try
not to do it again. Continuing to lie about what happened is just
adding to how low you needed to go.
This is me responding to your stupid lies:Yet again, you make all sorts of accusations without a single example
of something to support them.
What I cannot figure out is whether you just can't grasp that your
failure to produce a single example of supporting evidence portrays
*you* as the one telling lies; or whether you do grasp it and just
don't care; or whether, like a certain President, you think that if
you repeat a lie enough times that someone will eventually believe it.
You should apologize for what you have been doing and stop doing it. I
found the posts where you ran from your source having been caught lying,
you then snipped the evidence out of your response to your running.
The thread: There is no legitimate scientific support for the ID scam.
I can post your quote mining attempts and other stupid behavior that you
resorted to to defend your running and defense of your bogus source.
This is me:So why don't you instead of talking about it?
Specific examples, please, not reams and reams of obfuscatory cut'n
paste.
This is me providing the evidence that you lied about existing. All the subsequent attributions are intact. You can not deal with the evidenceYou should not continue to add to your own dishonest stupidity.
Trusting your source was obviously a stupid thing to do, and trying to
continue to support that source was just stupid and dishonest.
Ron Okimoto
JesuitsThis the other thread string that was in the "Chimp to human
evolution-Sandwalk perspective" thread. This posts demonstrates that
Harran tried to quote mine the condemnation. If you go to other posts
in this thread string you will find Harran having memory lapse of his
running from the Vatican observatory link. This was his attempt to try
to claim that he did not have to run. He literally tried to quote mine
the document so that it would not have been considered to be a
condemnation of heliocentrism by only quoting a bit of what was being
condemned.
REPOST:
On 2/23/2026 7:03 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 22 Feb 2026 13:40:10 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 2/22/2026 10:18 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 21 Feb 2026 12:44:57 -0600, RonO <rokimoto557@gmail.com>
wrote:
On 2/21/2026 11:59 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
What documents are you talking about that you keep saying the
condemnedwhat youput up?
You can keep lying about what has been discussed, but you know
did. You need to be the one that finds it and satisfy yourself with
what you did.
You put up your source lying about heliocentrism never being
Popewas notby anyone but the Inquisition. You claimed that the Inquisition
ordered bythe Church. I put up the Jesuit Observatory claim that the Papal
offices had condemned heliocentrism and this condemnation was
the Pope. They put up the relevant document and stated what the
unreliable, havesources havedid. Your source was caught lying and you ran. Go find it. It is
something that you should do because you will uncover all your other
evasions on this issue while doing it. Your quotes of your
always come up short. The sources that you claim are
with.repeatedly been shown to be more reliable than what you come up
Pythagoreanhttps://www.vaticanobservatory.org/sacred-space-astronomy/heliocentrism-condemned-400-years-ago-on-march-5-2/
Oh, you mean the link you gave back in November, this one:
The one where they posted the full 1616 decree on it's 400th
anniversary and commented:
<quote>
The formulation here is much milder than the one found in the working
document of February 24. The Decree talks about the "false
about thedoctrine" and declare it "altogether contrary to the Holy Scripture".
This is not nearly as harsh as "foolish and absurd" philosophically,
and "formally heretical" because contrary to Scripture.
</quote>
How fucking dense can you be? It doesn't get much stupider than
posting something that contradicts what you are claiming.
If I am the dense one why did you run from what they admitted
on thedocument?
LOL, you post something that you think supports your claim but
actually rejects it and the best defence you can offer is to accuse me
of running away from it.
You did run, twice in that thread. You would not address your source
getting caught lying.
The Pope did condemn heliocentrism.
Beats me why you keep repeating this. The Pope did not personally
condemn heliocentrism, he allowed the Inquisition's condemnation of it
to be made public - that did not make it a heresy.
He did more than allow, he directed that it should be published. Why
deny what the source claimed? The source admits that it was a Papal
condemnation. They just claim that it was a toned down condemnation
compared to the first draft of the document that still exists.
There is no reason to try to weasel out of the fact that you ran and
would not even try to lie about the situation the first time you were
given this link. It did just what I claimed at the time. Your source
was found to have lied about the situation, and could not be trusted.
You can't say that about any of my sources. You just keep lying about
those sources being unreliable when it has always been your sources that
came up short.
That is what your side was lying
about.
The only one telling lies here is you. For example, when you keep
insisting that all the "anti-geocentrists" in the Catholic
Encyclopaedia article agree with you that heliocentrism was a heresy
when they all say explicitly that it wasn't. Your lie is underlined by
the fact that you can't produce identify any source that agrees that
heliocentrism was a heresy except your geocentrist mentors.
Your source lied about the Inquisition being the only church arm to have
condemned heliocentrism. It was a false statement and should have been
known to be a false statement. Lying about the Pope only allowing the
publication when he wanted it to be published, and directed that it
should be written up and published. The Jesuits are pretty matter of
fact that it was a Papal condemnation of heliocentrism. They note that
it is the only instance of any Pope directly condemning heliocentrism.
It doesn't matter that the final wording was milder than the
initial draft. They admit that the Pope condemned heliocentrism, and
supported using the Council of Trent's scriptural interpretation
condemnedmatter. It doesn't matter what it was called because the authors and
books are named. You ran from this link because your source was found
to have lied about heliocentrism never having been condemned except by
the Inquisition. The Pope obviously represents the Church and
to beheliocentrism. He supported the Inquisition in 1616, and their
additions to the Index in order to protect against heresy. The books
would not have been added to the Index if they were not considered
it isheretical. The document even talks about the heretical parts of the
books, and indicates that after one of them is rewritten, so that
Council ofreality.not against scripture, that it can be removed from the Index.
Keep lying to yourself about the issue. It isn't going to change
The Inquisition made heliocentrism a formal heresy in 1615-1616.
The decree is given in full on the Vatican Observatory site that you
tried to claim supports you and the word 'heresy' or 'heretical' does
not even appear in it.
It was not put up to claim heresy even though that is what it did. That
document condemned heliocentrism and supported heliocentric writings
being added to the Index. Those writings were deemed to be heretical
and against scripture. Lying about something else does not change the
fact that your source was caught lying. You know what condemning means
so why try to lie about the situation in this way? What was your source
trying to lie about by claiming that heliocentrism had only been
condemned by the Inquisition? You know why your source told that lie,
so why try to weasel out of the fact that they lied?
They
did this because of their interpretation of scripture as the
Index ofTrent had decided.
The decree doesn't make any reference whatsoever to Trent regarding
interpretation of scripture; the one and only reference is to the
*punishment* under Trent for disobeying the decree.
The decree doesn't need to reference Trent in terms of scriptural
interpretation because that had already been decided by the Inquisition
when it added the writings to the Index. Those writings would not have
been added to the Index if it were not for the Council of Trents
determination about scriptural interpretation. The Pope agreed with
those additions to the Index, so he must have agreed with the
Inquisitions scriptural interpretation.
They added heliocentric writings to the Index,
They declare that "the books by Nicolaus Copernicus (On the
Revolutions of Spheres) and by Diego de Zu|#iga (On Job) be suspended
until corrected".
The Books by Copernicus were never corrected and republished, so his
writings were banned until removed from the index centuries later. I
see that you left out the book that could not be corrected and would be
permanently banned. Why did you do that? Isn't this quote mining?
Heliocentrism was condemned and heliocentric writings were added to the
Index. End of that story.
QUOTE:
Decree
of the Sacred Congregation of the Most Illustrious Cardinals of the Holy
Roman Church especially charged by Our Holy Lord Pope Paul V and by the
Holy Apostolic See with the Index of books and their licensing,
prohibition, correction, and printing in all of Christendom, to be
published everywhere.
In regard to several books containing various heresies and errors, to
prevent the emergence of more serious harm throughout Christendom, the
Sacred Congregation of the Most Illustrious Cardinals of the Holy Roman
Church in charge of the Index has decided that they should be altogether
condemned and prohibited, as indeed with the present decree it condemns
and prohibits them, wherever and in whatever language they are printed
or about to be printed.
END QUOTE:
This is no quote mine, but you can find your quote in the following
paragraph:
QUOTE:
This Holy Congregation has also learned about the spreading and
acceptance by many of the false Pythagorean doctrine, altogether
contrary to the Holy Scripture, that the earth moves and the sun is
motionless, which is also taught by Nicolaus CopernicusrCOs On the
Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres and by Diego de Zu|#igarCOs On Job.
This may be seen from a certain letter published by a certain Carmelite
Father whose title is Letter of the Reverend Father Paolo Antonio
Foscarini on the Pythagorean and Copernican Opinion of the EarthrCOs
Motion and SunrCOs Rest and on the New Pythagorean World System (Naples:
Lazzaro Scoriggio, 1615), in which the said Father tries to show that
the above-4mentioned doctrine of the sunrCOs rest at the center of the
world and of the earthrCOs motion is consonant with the truth and does not
contradict Holy Scripture. Therefore, in order that this opinion may not
advance any further to the prejudice of Catholic truth, the Congregation
has decided that the books by Nicolaus Copernicus (On the Revolutions of
Spheres) and by Diego de Zu|#iga (On Job) be suspended until corrected;
but that the book of the Carmelite Father Paolo Antonio Foscarini be
completely prohibited and condemned; and that all other books which
teach the same be likewise prohibited, according to whether with the
present Decree it prohibits, condemns, and suspends them respectively.
END QUOTE:
It looks like you tried to quote mine what had been quoted on the site.
There is no reason to try to weasel out of why you ran from this link
before.
I've given details of the required corrections to Revolutions in a
different post to Harshman and they are all minor edits - not one of
them makes any change to the core principle of heliocentrism. A rather
weird declaration of heresy that allows Copernicus's book supporting
it to be published with minor edits that don't undermine his
proposition.
So what? Copernicus' writings remained on the Index for centuries, and
the heliocentric writings of Father Paolo Antonio Foscarini was
"completely prohibited and condemned" for the same period of time.
and
had their first encounter with Galileo. The Pope agreed with them and
condemned heliocentrism, and agreed with their additions to the
banned writings.
Before your source lied about "never being condemned" the Pope's
involvement in 1616 was not an issue between the geocentric and
anti-geocentric Catholics in terms of what you were lying about at the
time. Both sides agreed that it was a formal heresy charge faced by
Galileo in 1615-1616. They disagreed about it being a formal heresy
charge the second time because it was only written up as "heresy" and
not formal heresy in the sentencing. It remained a heresy charge.
You obviously struggle with grasping that a *charge* does not make
someone guilty. I hope I'm never on trial for something I didn't do
with you on the jury.
Galileo was not found guilty in 1616, but he was facing a formal heresy
charge. The Inquisition's condemnation was backed up by the Pope in
1616. That is what you are currently waffling about. Your source lied.
The
Pope had the Galileo case, sentencing, and punishment published and
distributed throughout the Church in order to quash the heliocentric
heresy, but the guys that want to maintain Papal infallibility claim
that that was not an official Papal action. They admitted that there
was an issue with helicentrism at the time, but they do not want the
Pope to have been on the wrong side of the issue.
You need to deal with reality.
I think it's very clear who has the problem with accepting reality and
it's not me.
I think that it is clear that your sources are as unreliable as you are.
You clearly quote mined above, so why lie about who has an issue with
dealing with reality?
Ron Okimoto
END REPOST:
It is well understood that the Bible is
just wrong about a lot of things that we can figure out for ourselves.
Your own quotes from Pope Francis makes that claim. The Bible can be
misinterpreted because the author's understanding of the creation was
faulty. Francis knows that the universe was not created in 6 magic
episodes. Only those in complete denial do not understand that the
order of creation described in the Bible is wrong. There are still
young earth, old earth day for agers, geocentric, and flat earth
Biblical creationists because they are in the same type of denial that
you are in. There are just different levels of denial.
Ron Okimoto
Harran should apologize and stop lying about the past.
Ron Okimoto
You should appologize and stop lying about the past.
Ron Okimoto
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:25:28 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |