From Newsgroup: talk.origins
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-01947-1
Nature has a news article up where AI use may be messing with medical
doctor skills. After using AI diagnostic tools a study found that
doctor's diagnostic ability was degraded a significant amount when the
the AI diagnostic tool was not available.
The sad thing is that if the study conclusions are correct the doctors misdiagnosed 6% of the colonoscopies as not having precancerous lesions
(they missed lesions that they should have detected) when they did not
have the AI available to them.
This is likely going to be the case for everything that AI is being used
for. Big companies are removing a lot of their middle managers that
would have directed employees in their everyday jobs, and now AI is
being used to have fewer managers reliant on AI to manage employees and
make sure that they are doing what the company expects them to be doing.
Calculators demonstrated that this was going to be the case. How many
kids graduate high school that can make change in their heads?
What have word processors done for hand writing skills? Students are
using AI to write their essays and do their homework. How should a
teacher assess if the students understand what the AI has produced for them?
Recently, I have used AI to assess the ID creationist scam, and so has
MarkE. It is obvious that AI doesn't do a very good job in terms of
analysis of what the ID scam actually is, and does not accurately
describe what the ID perps have been doing for decades. A user has to
already understand what the AI gets wrong in order to get the AI to
correct it's analysis. The AI can correctly reanalyze the data, and can
put up the correct references that can be used to validate the corrected answer, so it has access to what it needs, but it doesn't fully utilize
the existing data.
Things will get better in terms of AI's analytical ability, but use of
AI will likely make it less likely that the users will be able to detect
when the AI is misleading them.
It isn't a rogue AI that will take over the world and control human
behavior, but humans will likely become dependent on AI to manage their
lives because they lack the skills to manage their lives themselves.
Ron Okimoto
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2