Jeff Diggins wrote:
A viral clip making the rounds this week is the kind of thing that ends a debate in under a minute, whether you want it to or not. On RomerCOs Janiculum Hill, they fire a ceremonial cannon every day at noon, a
tradition that goes back to the 1800s. ItrCOs not a battlefield. NobodyrCOs getting shot at. ItrCOs a tourist-friendly time check with a big boom at the end. And still, the video of a female soldier trying to get that thing
ready while a male counterpart casually strolls underneath the barrel has people arguing about whether women belong in combat roles.
The footage is pure slapstick if you ignore the context. The woman is
yanking on the lanyard like sherCOs trying to start a lawnmower that hates her. SherCOs digging in, adjusting her stance, putting her whole body into it. The guy next to her isnrCOt even looking at her half the time. At one point, he walks right under the barrel with the string still in her hand, like herCOs grabbing a beer from the fridge. The contrast is so stark itrCOs almost mean. One person is treating the job like a normal Tuesday. The
other is fighting the equipment itself.
This isnrCOt some obscure edge case. Combat roles, the ones people are arguing about putting more women into, involve carrying heavy loads for
long periods, dragging wounded teammates, operating heavy weapons systems, and doing all of it while someone is actively trying to kill you. Average male upper-body strength is roughly 50-60% greater than average female upper-body strength. Grip strength, the ability to generate force quickly, bone density, and oxygen-carrying capacity all tilt the same direction.
These arenrCOt opinions. TheyrCOre measurable differences that show up in every large study thatrCOs ever been done on the subject. When the military has lowered standards so more women can pass, injury rates have gone up
and performance has gone down. When theyrCOve kept standards the same, very few women qualify. Both outcomes tell you something.
The rCLbut some women can do itrCY argument is technically true and also mostly irrelevant. Some women can outlift some men. Some women run faster than some men. The military doesnrCOt select for the statistical outliers
who happen to be exceptional; it selects for people who can reliably do
the job at a high level under stress, day after day. The cannon in Rome isnrCOt even a combat weapon. ItrCOs a ceremonial howitzer that requires one person to pull a rope with consistent force. If that basic physical task
is already a visible struggle, itrCOs reasonable to ask how the same person is supposed to handle a machine gun, a wounded soldier, or a heavy pack
while taking fire.
Barstool has never pretended biology is a social construct. Men and women
are different in ways that matter for certain jobs. ThatrCOs not an insult. ItrCOs the reason we have weight classes in fighting sports, different standards in powerlifting, and separate categories in almost every
physical competition on earth. Pretending those differences disappear the moment someone puts on a uniform doesnrCOt make anyone safer. It just makes the people who have to rely on each other less honest about what theyrCOre looking at.
The video doesnrCOt rCLproverCY that no woman should ever be in the military. Plenty of women serve effectively in support roles, intelligence,
aviation, and other positions where raw strength is less decisive. What it does is illustrate, in the simplest possible terms, why combat arms have always been male-dominated across every culture that has ever fielded an army. The job is hard on the body. On average, the people best at it are
the ones whose bodies are built for it. Watching someone struggle with a
rope while another person treats the same equipment like background
furniture is funny until you remember that the real version of this job
has consequences.
https://vidmax.com/video/239957-do-women-belong-in-combat-situations-one- ceremonial-cannon-just-settled-the-argument
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 57:40:23 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,926 |