• Noble Savage Myth - vs reality and modernity

    From a425couple@a425couple@hotmail.com to soc.history.medieval,alt.economics on Wed Sep 30 15:01:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: soc.history.medieval


    from Facebook

    Students For Liberty

    -+
    Follow
    a day ago
    -+
    The field was long dominated by a myth.
    Postwar anthropology, inspired by Rousseau and Marx, held that "savages"
    were peaceful and cooperative. Violence, hierarchy, and inequality were supposed to be diseases of civilization, invented by property,
    colonization, and markets. Abolish those, and the natural harmony of man
    would return.
    Then a kid from rural Michigan went to check.
    In 1964, Napoleon Chagnon, one of twelve children from a poor family in
    Port Austin, traveled to the VenezuelarCoBrazil border. He went to live
    with the Yanomam||, roughly 20,000 people scattered across the Amazon rainforest, largely untouched by the state, by markets, or by modernity.
    He would return nearly thirty times over the next three decades. His
    1968 book, Yanomam||: The Fierce People, sold nearly a million copies and
    was translated into fifteen languages.
    But this is what he actually found:
    Raids between villages were routine. Infanticide was common. Women were regularly abducted and traded after violent conflict. Headmen, as a
    rule, were killers.
    Chagnon mapped Yanomam|| genealogies using early computer methods,
    learned the language, and lived inside the villages for months at a
    stretch. The data was not hearsay.
    A particular finding broke the field.
    In a 1988 paper in Science, Chagnon documented that the unokais, men who
    had killed in raids, had on average more wives and more surviving
    offspring than non-violent men of the same age.
    In a state of nature, violence was being reproductively selected for.
    The Rousseauian premise ran backwards.
    If violence, hierarchy, and inequality were what civilization produces,
    they should be rare where civilization is absent.
    Chagnon found the opposite.
    Where the state, the market, and modern institutions had never arrived,
    up to 30% of adult male deaths were violent. The men who killed were the
    men whose lineages survived. In the modern United States that figure is
    under 1%.
    The reaction was immediate. Marshall Sahlins, one of Chagnon's former
    graduate teachers at Michigan, turned on him.
    Terence Turner and Leslie Sponsel circulated a warning to the American Anthropological Association (AAA) describing "an anthropological heart
    of darkness beyond the imagining of even a Joseph Conrad, though not,
    perhaps, a Joseph Mengele." Salesian missionaries in the region joined
    the coalition.
    What Chagnon had found could not be answered on its merits, so the man
    who found it became the target instead.
    Then came the book that ended him.
    In 2000, journalist Patrick Tierney published Darkness in El Dorado. He accused Chagnon of triggering a measles epidemic through vaccine experimentation, arming rival factions to stage conflicts on film,
    cooking his data, and behaving as "a war criminal or even a genocidaire."
    The New Yorker ran Tierney's companion article the same month. Chagnon's career effectively ended before any serious investigation reached a
    verdict.
    But every serious charge eventually collapsed.
    The vaccine complied with WHO protocols. The measles epidemic predated Chagnon's arrival. Venezuelan physicians, the Rockefeller Foundation,
    the University of Michigan, the American Society of Human Genetics, and
    the U.S. Department of Health each investigated.
    Each reached the same verdict: no crime, no cover-up, no fraud. Jane
    Hill, who chaired the AAA's own inquiry, wrote privately that Tierney's
    book was "a piece of sleaze, that's all there is to it."
    The AAA task force issued its own report in 2002 anyway, condemning
    Chagnon for prioritizing his research over the Yanomam||.
    Raymond Hames had already resigned from the panel mid-inquiry, and Sarah Blaffer Hrdy, a National Academy of Sciences member, quit the AAA in
    protest.
    Three years later, the AAA membership voted to rescind the report.
    In 2012, Chagnon was elected to the National Academy of Sciences. The following year, Sahlins resigned from the Academy over it.
    The noble savage myth outlived the twentieth century's political movements. Today it powers the decolonial framework that dominates the humanities
    and much of political discourse. The claim is unchanged: violence,
    hierarchy, and inequality are artifacts of property, civilization, and colonization, and would vanish once those were abolished.
    Three decades of Chagnon's evidence showed the claim was wrong.
    In the absence of the institutions the utopians wanted to destroy, human beings behaved more violently than within them.
    The discipline that could not answer his data answered his character
    instead.
    That is what an intellectual monoculture does when evidence contradicts
    its premises. It goes after whoever brought the evidence. See less

    comments include

    Marcus Moellmer
    -+
    wow, common sense was discovered and then rejected.. what a shockEfyE
    Reply
    Marc L|-vesque
    -+
    You can read what the Jesuits recorded when they arrived in North
    America. They recorded the same violence centuries before Chagnon
    Reply
    Dave Pulte
    -+
    Remember when we believed chimpanzees were peaceful and whatever and
    then we found out they were brutally warlike and cannibalistic?
    Reply
    Ray Morad
    -+
    I went to school in anthropology in the 1990s. Not only did we read this
    book, amongst many others, but we were pretty clear even then that the
    noble savage myth was just that. A myth.
    Reply
    Brian McCreight
    -+
    ...I've read Chagnon's book on the Yanomamo. He profiled their society thoroughly, & one could not help compare modern society to the so-called primitive one. He proved that humanity is relatively the same
    everywhere. An interesting read...
    Reply
    K George Leaves
    -+
    In rCLThe Vision of the Anointed rCL, Thomas Sowell writes about just this topic - how the rCLanointedrCY dismiss hard evidence that contradicts their rCLenlightenedrCY vision.
    Reply
    Bingham Graham
    -+
    These rCLintellectualsrCY never read Lord of the Flies.
    Reply
    Tom Maher
    -+
    The greatest crime in academia is being right too soon.
    Reply

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2