• Re: Piast DNA

    From taf@taf.medieval@gmail.com to soc.genealogy.medieval on Mon Sep 29 13:07:47 2025
    From Newsgroup: soc.genealogy.medieval

    On 6/23/2025 9:01 PM, taf wrote:
    On 6/15/2025 10:04 PM, Stewart Baldwin wrote:

    For the moment, I guess I am willing to acknowledge the possibility
    that the Piasts and some random sixth century Pict might have had a
    common direct male-line ancestor living a few thousand years ago, but
    I remain skeptical.

    At a minimum, I am withholding judgment until I see the paper and see
    what exactly that 'Pictish' sample is, and how closely related it is.
    The author stated that the paper had been accepted for publication, but
    it has not yet appeared on the journal's web site. (It is an open-access online journal, but produced as a lower-tier sister-publication of one
    of the most respected science journals - I will drop a URL once it
    appears.)

    I promised a URL when the article on Piast DNA was published. Well,
    something squirrely is going on. I have been checking regularly, and the article has yet to appear, even though it doesn't take anywhere near
    this long for an accepted science paper to be published in an
    open-access online journal like the one named.

    Either the author was misquoted or exaggerating when he said it had been accepted, or it was 'accepted with revisions' but the demanded revisions
    were so onerous that it amounted to de facto rejection.

    Either way, I am no longer expecting imminent publication, as I was when
    I promised a URL.

    taf
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From taf@taf.medieval@gmail.com to soc.genealogy.medieval on Thu Jun 12 18:46:53 2025
    From Newsgroup: soc.genealogy.medieval

    Details are a little light on the ground at this point, but there is apparently a DNA study to be published in the coming months that
    formally reports the results of a study that was discussed at a recent scientific meeting. Until the paper comes out, we only have the various
    press releases to go by, but the gist of it is that DNA analysis was
    performed on 33 (30 male, 3 female) attributed Piast-family cathedral entombments dating from about 1100 to the 1400s. They apparently found
    the same extremely rare Y-haplotype in the males.

    The kicker is that the closest relative of that has been identified was
    a ~6th century Pict from Scotland. That seemingly is going to cause some reevaluation of the genealogical foundation legend.

    taf
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Stewart Baldwin@sbaldw@mindspring.com to soc.genealogy.medieval on Mon Jun 16 00:04:15 2025
    From Newsgroup: soc.genealogy.medieval

    On 12/06/2025 8:46 pm, taf wrote:
    Details are a little light on the ground at this point, but there is apparently a DNA study to be published in the coming months that
    formally reports the results of a study that was discussed at a recent scientific meeting. Until the paper comes out, we only have the various press releases to go by, but the gist of it is that DNA analysis was performed on 33 (30 male, 3 female) attributed Piast-family cathedral entombments dating from about 1100 to the 1400s. They apparently found
    the same extremely rare Y-haplotype in the males.

    The kicker is that the closest relative of that has been identified was
    a ~6th century Pict from Scotland. That seemingly is going to cause some reevaluation of the genealogical foundation legend.

    Now that some of reports are claiming a Scottish origin for the Piast
    dynasty, I guess that it is just a matter of time before somebody claims
    that they are direct male-line descendants of the Pictish king Bridei
    son of Maelch|| (by far the most famous sixth century Pict), to be
    followed not long after that by somebody claiming to have identified
    each intervening generation.

    For the moment, I guess I am willing to acknowledge the possibility that
    the Piasts and some random sixth century Pict might have had a common
    direct male-line ancestor living a few thousand years ago, but I remain skeptical.

    Stewart Baldwin

    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From taf@taf.medieval@gmail.com to soc.genealogy.medieval on Mon Jun 23 21:01:38 2025
    From Newsgroup: soc.genealogy.medieval

    On 6/15/2025 10:04 PM, Stewart Baldwin wrote:

    For the moment, I guess I am willing to acknowledge the possibility that
    the Piasts and some random sixth century Pict might have had a common
    direct male-line ancestor living a few thousand years ago, but I remain skeptical.

    At a minimum, I am withholding judgment until I see the paper and see
    what exactly that 'Pictish' sample is, and how closely related it is.
    The author stated that the paper had been accepted for publication, but
    it has not yet appeared on the journal's web site. (It is an open-access online journal, but produced as a lower-tier sister-publication of one
    of the most respected science journals - I will drop a URL once it
    appears.)
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From taf@taf.medieval@gmail.com to soc.genealogy.medieval on Sat Oct 31 14:18:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: soc.genealogy.medieval

    On 9/29/2025 1:07 PM, taf wrote:
    On 6/23/2025 9:01 PM, taf wrote:
    On 6/15/2025 10:04 PM, Stewart Baldwin wrote:

    For the moment, I guess I am willing to acknowledge the possibility
    that the Piasts and some random sixth century Pict might have had a
    common direct male-line ancestor living a few thousand years ago, but
    I remain skeptical.

    At a minimum, I am withholding judgment until I see the paper and see
    what exactly that 'Pictish' sample is, and how closely related it is.
    The author stated that the paper had been accepted for publication,
    but it has not yet appeared on the journal's web site. (It is an open-
    access online journal, but produced as a lower-tier sister-publication
    of one of the most respected science journals - I will drop a URL once
    it appears.)

    I promised a URL when the article on Piast DNA was published.

    As indicated previously, this paper was long-delayed, and I quit
    checking regularly. I thus missed when it finally came out. It has been available online for months.

    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13066612/pdf/41467_2026_Article_71457.pdf

    Take-home: they claim to have identified Piast burials back to Wladislav
    I Herman (ancestor of English queen Eleanore of Provence). His and other
    early Y-chromosome haplotypes are of poor quality, but is consistent
    with more detailed haplotypes generated for more recent Piast burials
    they studied, and they conclude they all would have had this haplotype,
    not seen in a broad recent survey of medieval polish burials (with no
    known Piasts). They conclude that the Piasts were not of local origin,
    and were probably vikings.

    Unfortunately, some of the genealogy referred to in their They also
    briefly address a set of Hungarian royal burials, which are relevant due
    to shared matrilineage. They do, unfortunately, treat Sigrid the Haughty
    as a historical individual in their discussion of possible origins - she wasn't, most likely being a semi-legendary chimera of multiple women.

    And one more note - when this was announced to the media last year, they
    made a big deal about the closest Y-chromosome match being a Pict
    skeleton. There is no mention of this in the paper. Either they have
    reserved this finding for a second paper, or they were forced to back
    off the claim (by their own subsequent findings or by the journal's
    editors).

    taf
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jan Wolfe@janetpcwolfe@gmail.com to soc.genealogy.medieval on Tue Nov 3 22:54:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: soc.genealogy.medieval

    On 10/31/2026 5:18 PM, taf wrote:
    On 9/29/2025 1:07 PM, taf wrote:
    On 6/23/2025 9:01 PM, taf wrote:
    On 6/15/2025 10:04 PM, Stewart Baldwin wrote:

    For the moment, I guess I am willing to acknowledge the possibility
    that the Piasts and some random sixth century Pict might have had a
    common direct male-line ancestor living a few thousand years ago,
    but I remain skeptical.

    At a minimum, I am withholding judgment until I see the paper and see
    what exactly that 'Pictish' sample is, and how closely related it is.
    The author stated that the paper had been accepted for publication,
    but it has not yet appeared on the journal's web site. (It is an
    open- access online journal, but produced as a lower-tier sister-
    publication of one of the most respected science journals - I will
    drop a URL once it appears.)

    I promised a URL when the article on Piast DNA was published.

    As indicated previously, this paper was long-delayed, and I quit
    checking regularly. I thus missed when it finally came out. It has been available online for months.

    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13066612/ pdf/41467_2026_Article_71457.pdf

    Take-home: they claim to have identified Piast burials back to Wladislav
    I Herman (ancestor of English queen Eleanore of Provence). His and other early Y-chromosome haplotypes are of poor quality, but is consistent
    with more detailed haplotypes generated for more recent Piast burials
    they studied, and they conclude they all would have had this haplotype,
    not seen in a broad recent survey of medieval polish burials (with no
    known Piasts). They conclude that the Piasts were not of local origin,
    and were probably vikings.

    Unfortunately, some of the genealogy referred to in their They also
    briefly address a set of Hungarian royal burials, which are relevant due
    to shared matrilineage. They do, unfortunately, treat Sigrid the Haughty
    as a historical individual in their discussion of possible origins - she wasn't, most likely being a semi-legendary chimera of multiple women.

    And one more note - when this was announced to the media last year, they made a big deal about the closest Y-chromosome match being a Pict
    skeleton. There is no mention of this in the paper. Either they have reserved this finding for a second paper, or they were forced to back
    off the claim (by their own subsequent findings or by the journal's editors).

    taf
    Thank you for providing this summary and url.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2