From Newsgroup: soc.culture.russian
Peace Proposal by Prof Jeffrey Sachs, US Economist
The war in Ukraine can be ended permanently on terms that protect
Ukraine's statehood, meet Russia's security concerns, and lay the
foundation for a durable European security order.
As another round of negotiations gears up in Norway, I propose a
settlement concluded as a single package, signed by Ukraine and
Russia, adopted by a vote of the United Nations Security Council under
Chapter VII of the Charter, and guaranteed jointly by the five
permanent members of the Council together with other states that
choose to join.
The proposal rests on the principle of indivisible security set out in
the Helsinki Final Act and the Charter of Paris.
The package would have four core commitments.
The first is Ukraine's permanent neutrality, adopted in a
constitutional law on the model of Austria's law of 1955, which would
return Ukraine to the founding choice of its Declaration of State
Sovereignty of 1990.
Ukraine would join no military alliance and host no foreign bases or
forces, whether of NATO, the European Union, their member states, or
Russia. Neutrality would not mean disarmament, and Ukraine would
retain armed forces for its own defense.
The second is that Ukraine would pursue its candidacy for membership
in the European Union as a permanently neutral state, with a
neutrality protocol in its accession treaty on the model of Ireland's,
and Russia would affirm that Ukraine's membership in the EU is
consistent with Russia's security.
The third is an armistice line drawn along the line of contact on the
date of signature. Each side would exercise de facto jurisdiction on
its side of the line, neither would recognize the other's territorial
claims, and both would renounce force in any future adjustment.
This formula is compatible with both countries' constitutions, which
bar or severely restrict the cession of territory.
The fourth is the end of NATO enlargement eastward. At signature the
North Atlantic Council would declare that NATO will not admit Ukraine
or other new members in Eastern Europe or the South Caucasus,
withdrawing the Bucharest pledge of 2008.
The settlement would take effect as a permanent end of hostilities on signature, not as a temporary ceasefire, and its provisions would be implemented in stages under international verification. No element
would be negotiated in isolation, and no party would be asked to make
a concession in advance of signature.
The territorial arrangements are designed to address the concerns and
claims of both sides. Ukrainian forces would withdraw from the part of
Donetsk region that Ukraine now controls, which would become a
demilitarized special zone. Russian forces would not enter it, the
existing local civil administration would continue to function, and
its final status would be left to negotiation. Russia would withdraw
from the areas it holds in Dnipropetrovsk region and from the Kinburn
Spit. A Northern Security Zone would be demilitarized on both sides of
the Russian-Ukrainian border, and Russian forces would leave the areas
they hold in Kharkiv and Sumy regions as Ukrainian forces withdraw
from their side. The Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant would remain
under Russian control with IAEA safety oversight and would sell an
agreed share of its electricity to Ukraine at cost.
A demilitarized belt would run along both sides of the armistice line,
with heavy weapons and long-range strike systems withdrawn to agreed
distances, and mutual ceilings on forces would apply in the border
regions on both sides. In the Black Sea and the Sea of Azov,
commercial navigation would be free for all Ukrainian and Russian
ports, and attacks on shipping and ports would be prohibited.
The settlement in Ukraine should also begin the repair of European
security as a whole. NATO and Russia would agree on a moratorium on ground-launched intermediate-range missiles in Europe, refrain from
deploying nuclear weapons in any additional state, and restore the
NATO-Russia Council. Normal diplomatic relations would be restored on
both sides. The parties would convene the first summit of the
Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe since 2010 to
entrust the OSCE with monitoring the settlement, verifying arms
limits, and overseeing the provisions on rights.
Questions of language, education, culture, and religion would be
resolved according to European standards, with the Russian language
treated on the same basis as Ukraine's other minority languages, and
Russia would accept the same obligations toward Ukrainian speakers and religious communities on its side of the line. All obligations
concerning extremism and incitement would be mutual and monitored by
the OSCE. Prisoners of war would be exchanged on an all-for-all basis,
detained civilians released, and separated children reunited with
their families.
Sanctions would be lifted during 2027. Russia's immobilized sovereign
assets would also be released, and private property seized or
immobilized on both sides would be restored. An international
reconstruction fund administered by the European Investment Bank would
finance reconstruction on both sides of the line, with contributions
from all parties, Russia included, in a common effort rather than as reparations. Gas transit through Ukraine could resume wherever there
are willing buyers, without any commitment by the European Union to
purchase Russian gas.
A report of serious violation by an OSCE monitoring mission of unarmed observers from states outside NATO would trigger consultations among
the guarantors and referral to the Security Council. Ukraine would
lift martial law and hold elections under OSCE observation, and the
newly elected Verkhovna Rada would ratify the settlement and adopt the constitutional law on neutrality, while the Russian Federal Assembly
would ratify it at the same stage.
This proposed settlement addresses the causes of the war rather than
only its symptoms.
Europe has been largely absent from the design of the peace. By
putting forward such a framework, European governments can take the
lead in building EuroperCOs indivisible security and help end a war that
has cost hundreds of thousands of lives and carries a continuing risk
of confrontation between nuclear powers.
---
Jeffrey D. Sachs is a University Professor and Director of the Center
for Sustainable Development at Columbia University, where he directed
The Earth Institute from 2002 until 2016. He is also President of the
UN Sustainable Development Solutions Network and a commissioner of the
UN Broadband Commission for Development.
He has been advisor to three United Nations Secretaries-General, and
currently serves as an SDG Advocate under Secretary-General Antonio
Guterres. Sachs is the author, most recently, of "A New Foreign
Policy: Beyond American Exceptionalism" (2020). Other books include:
"Building the New American Economy: Smart, Fair, and Sustainable"
(2017) and "The Age of Sustainable Development," (2015) with Ban
Ki-moon.
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel
free to republish and share widely.
--
Steve Hayes from Tshwane, South Africa
Web:
http://www.khanya.org.za/stevesig.htm
Blog:
http://khanya.wordpress.com
For information about why crossposting is (usually) good, and multiposting (nearly always) bad, see:
http://oakroadsystems.com/genl/unice.htm#xpost
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2