From Newsgroup: soc.culture.irish
Judges in e.g. the U.S.A. can be held to account. Cf.
HTTP://Gloucester.Insomnia247.NL/gardai/Where_are_you_from/reprimand_against_Judge_Cary_Hays/
and
an episode of "Court Cam" about the same misadventure. Video accountability of course being a concept which judges in Europe are afraid of.
Courts in Northern Ireland say that you are not even allowed to bring
a pencil into a court without a permission! (One court in Germany is
similar.)
Patrick OrCOBrien, "INFORMAL RESPONSES TO JUDICIAL MISCONDUCT: ASSESSING CHAPTER 4 OF THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL ACT", [2022] "Irish Judicial Studies Journal" Vol 6(1),
HTTPS://JudicialStudiesJournal.Ie/assets/uploads/documents/6.%20Patrick%20O'Brien%20final.pdf
has a table about the USA. Attempting to copy
and paste entire tables to the USENET would lose formatting, so instead I show smaller excerpts.
Table 3: Judicial Complaints statistics for the United States
shows:
"Year [. . .] 2019"
"Total active[. . .] 2636"
"Remedial action (%) [. . .] 0.002%".
(It reports 0.0004% or 0.001% for a different year.)
The Republic of Ireland pretends that it is perfect. "The Irish Times" alleges: "A guide to judicial complaints: No judge to date has been removed from office Ireland was last EU state to introduce formal judicial misconduct complaints regime".
HTTPS://JudicialCouncil.Ie/assets/uploads/Annual%20Report%202025.pdf#page=46 shows that over years, the Judicial-Conduct Committee receives
almost 1 complaint per day, but that it professes that "the number of complaints determined to be admissible" for before 2026 is only 2!
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=H.JR.2023.0001424
ridiculously shows:
"Plaintiff Details:
Full Name: AGNIESZKA NOWAK
Legal Rep: LITIGANT IN PERSON
Defendant Details:
Full Name: THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: -
Full Name: THE COMPLAINTS REVIEW COMMITTEE OF THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: -
Issue Date:
08/12/2023
[. . .]
29/01/2024 Affidavit
08/12/2023 JR Originating Statement
08/12/2023 Affidavit
Order Details
Date Result Perfected on
19/02/2024 Judicial Review Ex Parte refused 20/02/2024
Appeals
Appeal Type Appeal Case Ref Date Appeal Issued
Court of Appeal 2024 59 04/03/2024
Court Lists
Date List Position Result
19/02/2024 ADV - MR JUSTICE FERRITER / For Hearing - Order 19/02/2024 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 26 Transfer
15/01/2024 Judicial Review / Ex Parte - Adjourn to Date Judgment Details
Judge Delivered Distributed
There are no judgments for this case."
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=2022%20322%20JR
ridiculously shows:
"Plaintiff Details:
Full Name: PADDY WARD [A MINOR]
Legal Rep: DAVID BURKE & COMPANY SOLICITORS
Defendant Details:
Full Name: JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: -
Issue Date:
21/04/2022
Setting Down Date:
-
Setting Down Number:
0
Filings
Date Document Type
21/04/2022 JR Originating Statement
21/04/2022 Affidavit
Order Details
Date Result Perfected on
18/06/2024 Judicial Review interim 18/06/2024
10/10/2022 Judicial Review interim 12/10/2022
Appeals
Appeal Type Appeal Case Ref Date Appeal Issued
There are no appeals for this case.
Court Lists
Date List Position Result
04/11/2025 Judicial Review / For Mention 22 Strike Out
24/07/2025 Judicial Review / For Mention 2 Adjourn to Date 26/06/2025 Judicial Review / For Mention 5 Adjourn to Date 27/03/2025 Judicial Review / For Mention - Adjourn to Date 16/10/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention - Adjourn to Date 18/06/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention - Order & Adjournment 23/04/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention 25 Order
20/02/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention 37 Adjourn to Date 28/11/2023 Judicial Review / FOR MENTION 8 Adjourn to Date 11/10/2023 Judicial Review / For Mention 5 Adjourn to Date 28/06/2023 Judicial Review / For Mention 16 Adjourn to Date 26/04/2023 Judicial Review / For Mention 16 Adjourn to Date 25/01/2023 Judicial Review / For Mention 39 Adjourn to Date 10/10/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 7 Order
18/07/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 4 Adjourn to Date 20/06/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 6 Adjourn to Date 16/05/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 8 Adjourn to Date 25/04/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 8 Adjourn to Date Judgment Details
Judge Delivered Distributed
There are no judgments for this case."
Cf.
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=2021%204706%20P
by the same law firm for a different client. This webpage does not even spell a defendant name correctly:
"Full Name: THE AYYORNEY GENERAL"!
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=H.JR.2024.0000190
ridiculously shows:
"Plaintiff Details:
Full Name: AGNIESZKA NOWAK
Legal Rep: LITIGANT IN PERSON
Defendant Details:
Full Name: THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: -
Full Name: THE COMPLAINTS REVIEW COMMITTEE OF THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: -
Issue Date:
09/02/2024
[. . .]
There are no judgments for this case."
Specifiying
JUDICIAL COUNCIL
as a defendant via a court search engine shows 16 results. Many of these are without "Legal Rep"resentatives. (Cf. "-" and "LITIGANT IN PERSON" with "pro se" and "in propria persona".)
However, many of them indicate laws firm from which I never receive a satisfactory response. Cf.
HTTP://Gloucester.Insomnia247.NL/gardai/Where_are_you_from/2025-11-03s_telephone_talk_with_Ferrys_LLP.wma
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=2021%206090%20P
ridiculously shows:
"Plaintiff Details:
Full Name: DEREK MCCABE
Legal Rep: E.M. O HANRAHAN SOLICITORS
Defendant Details:
Full Name: THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: MARIA BROWNE
Full Name: IRELAND
Legal Rep: MARIA BROWNE
Full Name: AG
Legal Rep: MARIA BROWNE
Issue Date:
01/11/2021
Setting Down Date:
-
Setting Down Number:
0
Filings
Date Document Type
01/02/2023 Notice of Intention to Proceed
08/11/2021 Memo Entry Of Appearance
Order Details
Date Result Perfected on
21/04/2026 Chancery Action Final Strike Out No Order 05/05/2026 Appeals
Appeal Type Appeal Case Ref Date Appeal Issued
There are no appeals for this case.
Court Lists
Date List Position Result
21/04/2026 Chancery Court 5 / For Mention - Order
Judgment Details
Judge Delivered Distributed
There are no judgments for this case."
Cf.
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=2021%206091%20P
and
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=2021%205542%20P
and
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=2021%205173%20P
by the same law firm for different clients.
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=2022%20113%20JR
ridiculously shows:
"Plaintiff Details:
Full Name: LIAM MCGRANE
Legal Rep: MANUS SWEENEY & CO SOLICITORS [cf.
HTTPS://StapletonSolicitors.com/about
]
Defendant Details:
Full Name: PERSONAL INJURIES ASSESSMENT BOARD
Legal Rep: -
Full Name: JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: -
Full Name: IRELAND
Legal Rep: -
Full Name: AG
Legal Rep: -
Issue Date:
10/02/2022
Setting Down Date:
-
Setting Down Number:
0
Filings
Date Document Type
10/02/2022 JR Originating Statement
10/02/2022 Affidavit
Order Details
Date Result Perfected on
27/03/2025 NON JURY INTERIM 31/03/2025
Appeals
Appeal Type Appeal Case Ref Date Appeal Issued
There are no appeals for this case.
Court Lists
Date List Position Result
26/06/2025 Judicial Review / For Mention 4 Struck out, no attendance
27/03/2025 Judicial Review / For Mention - Order & Adjournment 12/11/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention 19 Adjourn to Date 15/10/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention 61 Adjourn to Date 30/07/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention 5 Adjourn to Date 18/06/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention 11 Adjourn to Date 23/04/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention 17 Adjourn to Date 20/02/2024 Judicial Review / For Mention 46 Adjourn to Date 28/11/2023 Judicial Review / FOR MENTION 52 Adjourn to Date 11/10/2023 Judicial Review / For Mention 16 Adjourn to Date 28/06/2023 Judicial Review / For Mention 5 Adjourn to Date 26/04/2023 Judicial Review / For Mention 5 Adjourn to Date 25/01/2023 Judicial Review / For Mention 4 Adjourn to Date 12/10/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 3 Adjourn to Date 22/06/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 3 Adjourn to Date 01/06/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 3 Adjourn to Date 27/04/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 4 Adjourn to Date 23/02/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 11 Adjourn to Date 16/02/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 4 Adjourn to Date 14/02/2022 Judicial Review / Ex Parte 12 Adjourn to Date Judgment Details
Judge Delivered Distributed
There are no judgments for this case."
HTTPS://Courts.Ie/high-court-search?caseRecordId=H.JR.2026.0001318
shows:
"Plaintiff Details:
Full Name: PETER NOWAK
Legal Rep: -
Defendant Details:
Full Name: JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: -
Full Name: COMPLAINTS REVIEW COMMITTEE OF THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
Legal Rep: -
Issue Date:
02/09/2026
[. . .]
There are no court listings for this case.
[. . .]
There are no judgments for this case."
"THE HIGH COURT
JUDICIAL REVIEW
[2026] IEHC 193
Record No. 2025 279 JR
BETWEEN
DENIS RIORDAN
APPLICANT
AND
COMPLAINTS REVIEW COMMITTEE OF THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT of Ms. Justice Siobh|in Phelan delivered on the 27th day of March, 2026
INTRODUCTION
1.
This matter comes before me on an opposed application for leave to proceed by way of judicial review to challenge three determinations of the Complaints Review Committee (hereinafter rCLCRCrCY) of the Judicial Council. The impugned determinations upheld earlier decisions of the Registrar of the Judicial Conduct Committee that the ApplicantrCOs Complaints against three Supreme Court judges sitting as a panel of that court in respect of his application for leave to appeal against a decision of the Court of Appeal were inadmissible.
[. . .]
141.
I refuse this application for leave to proceed by way of judicial review. I will hear the parties in respect of any consequential matters. The matter will be listed for mention on notice to the parties following the expiry of fourteen days from the date of electronic delivery of this judgment for the purpose of finalising orders."
says
HTTPS://WW2.Courts.Ie/acc/alfresco/b04a39b6-13b6-46d7-a6e3-818579adb33f/2026_IEHC_193.pdf
"The Supreme Court
Charleton J
Hogan J
Murray J
Collins J
Whelan J
Faherty J
Haughton J
Supreme Court appeal number: S:AP:IE:2022:000100
[2024] IESC 10
High Court record number 2021/641
[2022] IEHC 321
Between
Bridget Delaney
Applicant/Appellant
- and -
The Personal Injuries Assessment Board, The Judicial Council, Ireland and the Attorney General
Respondents
Judgment of Mr Justice Peter Charleton delivered on Tuesday 9 April 2024
1. The need for guidelines assisting judges in the assessment of personal injuries, a core and everyday function of all courts in Ireland, has generated public debate over decades. With the passing of such guidelines by the Judicial Council, under s 7 of the Judicial Council Act 2019, on 6 March 2021, such guidelines are now in place: but, subject to this challenge. Of those who litigate as plaintiff or defendant in the High Court or Circuit Court or District Court, the cause is usually some kind of an accident and the claim for compensation is almost always based on a lack of care shown in a factory, warehouse, or road setting. Apparently, the result of this case as to the validity and operation of the personal injury guidelines passed by the Judicial Council will influence thousands of cases currently awaiting judicial analysis and multiples of that into the future. The case is thus of systemic importance.
[. . .]
64. Given the complexity of the issues addressed in the judgments delivered by five members of the Court, it is thus appropriate to indicate the orders which, consequent upon that analysis, the Court proposes to make. Hence, this Court will make:
1. A declaration that section 7(2)(g) of the Judicial Council Act 2019 is unconstitutional in its current form;
2. A declaration that the personal injury guidelines adopted by the Judicial Council on 6 March 2021 were given force of law by virtue of section 30 of the Family Leave and Miscellaneous Provisions Act 2021 and are consequently in force;
3. A declaration that the Personal Injuries Assessment Board, accordingly, acted properly and in accordance with law in applying the personal injuries guidelines to the appellantrCOs application to be assessed as to her pain and suffering in May 2021;
4. An order that, save for the declaration of unconstitutionality in respect of section 7(2)(g) of the 2019 Act and the order for costs, the appeal from the order of the High Court is to be dismissed; and
4. Presumptively, given those orders of the Court, an order that the appellant should be awarded costs as against Ireland and the Attorney General, with the Personal Injuries Assessment Board to abide its own costs."
says
HTTPS://WW2.Courts.Ie/view/judgments/2999037c-4eb0-4ad2-98c4-2ae44198570a/da4cec77-2056-4194-96cd-cfe96dbaf92b/2024_IESC_10_(Charleton%20J).pdf
(S.
HTTP://Gloucester.Insomnia247.NL/ fuer Kontaktdaten!)
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2