• The Spring

    From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Sun Nov 8 14:34:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    At the center of a spring AB--which is free to move--lies point C, its
    center of mass.

    If we compress only the half AC of the spring, we end up with half AC in
    a compressed state, while the other half, CB, remains uncompressed.

    When we suddenly release the compression of AC, allowing it to expand
    freely, does point C remain stationary in its original position, or does
    it move away in the direction of end B?

    Luigi Fortunati


    [[Mod. note -- The answer to your question depends on just what we
    mean by "point C". I can see three plausible interpretations of the description "At the center of a spring AB--which is free to move--lies
    point C, its center of mass":
    (i) C is the geometrical center of the spring
    (ii) C is the place on the spring which was at the geometrical center
    before AC was compressed, i.e., C is the place on the spring such
    that (assuming the spring to be uniform before the compression)
    half the spring's mass to the left of C and half the spring's mass
    is to the right of C
    (iii) C is the spring's center of mass.
    Let's call these points C(i), C(ii), and C(iii), respectively.

    In the initial uncompressed state, C(i), C(ii), and C(iii) all coincide.
    But, once the spring is compressed, and after that compression is released, these three points may differ. Which point or points were you asking
    about?
    -- jt]]
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Mon Nov 9 11:16:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 08/11/2026 22:34, Luigi Fortunati ha scritto:
    At the center of a spring AB--which is free to move--lies point C, its
    center of mass.

    If we compress only the half AC of the spring, we end up with half AC in
    a compressed state, while the other half, CB, remains uncompressed.

    When we suddenly release the compression of AC, allowing it to expand
    freely, does point C remain stationary in its original position, or does
    it move away in the direction of end B?

    Luigi Fortunati


    [[Mod. note -- The answer to your question depends on just what we
    mean by "point C". I can see three plausible interpretations of the description "At the center of a spring AB--which is free to move--lies
    point C, its center of mass":
    (i) C is the geometrical center of the spring
    (ii) C is the place on the spring which was at the geometrical center
    before AC was compressed, i.e., C is the place on the spring such
    that (assuming the spring to be uniform before the compression)
    half the spring's mass to the left of C and half the spring's mass
    is to the right of C
    (iii) C is the spring's center of mass.
    Let's call these points C(i), C(ii), and C(iii), respectively.

    In the initial uncompressed state, C(i), C(ii), and C(iii) all coincide.
    But, once the spring is compressed, and after that compression is released, these three points may differ. Which point or points were you asking
    about?
    -- jt]]

    I am referring to point C(iii).
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Wed Nov 11 00:18:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 09/11/2026 19:16, Luigi Fortunati ha scritto:
    Il 08/11/2026 22:34, Luigi Fortunati ha scritto:
    At the center of a spring AB--which is free to move--lies point C, its
    center of mass.

    If we compress only the half AC of the spring, we end up with half AC in
    a compressed state, while the other half, CB, remains uncompressed.

    When we suddenly release the compression of AC, allowing it to expand
    freely, does point C remain stationary in its original position, or does
    it move away in the direction of end B?

    Luigi Fortunati


    [[Mod. note -- The answer to your question depends on just what we
    mean by "point C". I can see three plausible interpretations of the
    description "At the center of a spring AB--which is free to move--lies
    point C, its center of mass":
    (i) C is the geometrical center of the spring
    (ii) C is the place on the spring which was at the geometrical center
    before AC was compressed, i.e., C is the place on the spring such
    that (assuming the spring to be uniform before the compression)
    half the spring's mass to the left of C and half the spring's mass
    is to the right of C
    (iii) C is the spring's center of mass.
    Let's call these points C(i), C(ii), and C(iii), respectively.

    In the initial uncompressed state, C(i), C(ii), and C(iii) all coincide.
    But, once the spring is compressed, and after that compression is released, >> these three points may differ. Which point or points were you asking
    about?
    -- jt]]

    I am referring to point C(iii).

    I would like to clarify the following.

    To compress the spring, we grasp particle C, which, at that moment, is
    the center of mass.

    I want to know how that particle C--which I grasped and then
    released--will move, rather than how the center of mass of the spring moves.

    Luigi Fortunati

    [[Mod. note -- Ok. "particle C" is what I called C(ii).

    For convenience of discussion, let's take the spring to be oriented horizontally, with point A on the left and B on the right. And let's
    take the spring to be initially at rest in an inertial coordinate system.

    In the compressed state (before the compression is released):
    * Spring AC is compressed relative to its equlibrium length,
    so it exerts outward forces on its two ends (particles A and C),
    i.e., it exerts a leftward force on A and a rightward force on C.
    * Spring CB is at its equilibrium length, so it exerts no forces
    on its two ends (particles C and B).

    Therefore, there is a net force rightward force on C.
    Therefore, when we allow everything to move freely, C will initially
    accelerate to the right.
    -- jt]]
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Thu Nov 12 21:10:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 11/11/2026 08:18, Luigi Fortunati ha scritto:
    I want to know how that particle C--which I grasped and then
    released--will move, rather than how the center of mass of the spring
    moves.

    Luigi Fortunati

    [[Mod. note -- Ok. "particle C" is what I called C(ii).

    For convenience of discussion, let's take the spring to be oriented horizontally, with point A on the left and B on the right. And let's
    take the spring to be initially at rest in an inertial coordinate system.

    In the compressed state (before the compression is released):
    * Spring AC is compressed relative to its equlibrium length,
    so it exerts outward forces on its two ends (particles A and C),
    i.e., it exerts a leftward force on A and a rightward force on C.
    * Spring CB is at its equilibrium length, so it exerts no forces
    on its two ends (particles C and B).
    Therefore, there is a net force rightward force on C.

    Exactly. That is what you can see in my animation https://www.geogebra.org/classic/kpxw3reu
    by clicking on the "Compression" button.

    Therefore, when we allow everything to move freely, C will initially accelerate to the right.
    -- jt]]

    This is the final part ("Final position") about which I have many doubts.

    Once the compressed half-spring is left free to expand, it oscillates
    and then:
    -(a) comes to a stop;
    -(b) moves at a constant and linear velocity?

    In case (a), does it come to a stop at the original starting
    position--that is, with particle C at point x=0--or at a position further ahead or further back?

    In case (b), does the spring move to the right or to the left?

    Luigi Fortunati

    [[Mod. note --

    Any real spring will have some internal friction, which will eventually
    damp out the oscillations (converting them into heat).

    In the starting condition (AC held compressed, CB uncompressed) the
    entire spring was at rest in an inertial coordinate system, so its
    total linear momentum in the horizontal direction was zero. Since
    (we assume) there are no external forces acting on the spring, the
    spring's total linear momentum in the horizontal direction remains
    zero at all times. Thus, once the oscillations damp out, the spring
    is at rest (in our same inertial coordinate system).
    -- jt]]
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Fri Nov 13 23:10:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 13/11/2026 05:10, Luigi Fortunati ha scritto:
    ...
    Exactly. That is what you can see in my animation https://www.geogebra.org/classic/kpxw3reu
    by clicking on the "Compression" button.

    > Therefore, when we allow everything to move freely, C will initially
    > accelerate to the right.
    > -- jt]]

    This is the final part ("Final position") about which I have many doubts.

    Once the compressed half-spring is left free to expand, it oscillates
    and then:
    -(a) comes to a stop;
    -(b) moves at a constant and linear velocity?

    In case (a), does it come to a stop at the original starting
    position--that is, with particle C at point x=0--or at a position further ahead or further back?

    In case (b), does the spring move to the right or to the left?

    Luigi Fortunati

    [[Mod. note --

    Any real spring will have some internal friction, which will eventually
    damp out the oscillations (converting them into heat).

    In the starting condition (AC held compressed, CB uncompressed) the
    entire spring was at rest in an inertial coordinate system, so its
    total linear momentum in the horizontal direction was zero. Since
    (we assume) there are no external forces acting on the spring, the
    spring's total linear momentum in the horizontal direction remains
    zero at all times. Thus, once the oscillations damp out, the spring
    is at rest (in our same inertial coordinate system).
    -- jt]]

    After its oscillations, does particle C come to a stop at point x=0, or
    at a position further ahead or further back?

    Luigi Fortunati

    [[Mod. note --

    Let's assume that the spring was uniform before the compression, with
    total mass M (i.e., AC has mass M/2 and CB has mass M/2), and that before
    the compression, the points are at coordinates (in the inertial reference
    frame in which the spring is initially stationary):
    A: x=-d
    C: x=0
    B: x=+d

    Then in the compressed pre-release state, we have
    A: x=-d/2
    C: x=0
    B: x=+d
    so spring AC has COM x=-d/4 and mass M/2
    and spring CB has COM x=+d/2 and mass M/2.
    Thus the overall system's COM in the compressed pre-release state is x=+d/8.

    We are assuming that there are no (horizontal) external forces acting on
    the spring, so the overall COM center must have zero (horizontal) acceleration (in our same inertial reference frame). Since the COM was at rest before
    the spring was released, it must in fact stay stationary.

    Therefore the final end state when all the oscillations have damped out
    must also have it's COM at x=+d8.

    Since the final end state has the spring uncompressed again, that means
    the final length of the spring is the same as its initial length (i.e., 2d), with C at the spring's geometrical center. This means that
    final A: x=-3/8 d
    final C: x=+1/8 d
    final B: x=+5/8 d

    -- jt]]
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2