• The battering ram

    From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Thu Oct 22 08:41:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    The battering ram, once used to break through the gates of enemy
    fortresses, relied on its momentum: the more massive the ram, the
    greater its momentum, and the more force it exerted upon the obstacle (assuming equal velocity).

    Therefore, the force exerted by a battering ram on an obstacle is
    directly proportional to its momentum; a ram with greater momentum
    exerts a greater force than one with less momentum.

    This greater force arises--simply and clearly--from the larger number of particles pushing forward within the more massive ram: the more
    particles pushing forward, the greater the force applied to the obstacle.

    And if a battering ram with greater momentum collides head-on with one possessing less momentum, why should the *greater* number of particles
    in the more massive ram exert the same amount of force as the *smaller*
    number of particles pushing from the opposite side?

    Luigi Fortunati.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ram@ram@zedat.fu-berlin.de (Stefan Ram) to sci.physics.research on Fri Oct 23 12:05:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Luigi Fortunati <fortunati.luigi@gmail.com> wrote or quoted:
    And if a battering ram with greater momentum collides head-on with one >possessing less momentum, why should the *greater* number of particles
    in the more massive ram exert the same amount of force as the *smaller* >number of particles pushing from the opposite side?

    Because of the conservation of momentum.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Tue Oct 27 00:56:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 23/10/2026 21:05, Stefan Ram ha scritto:
    Luigi Fortunati <fortunati.luigi@gmail.com> wrote or quoted:
    And if a battering ram with greater momentum collides head-on with one
    possessing less momentum, why should the *greater* number of particles
    in the more massive ram exert the same amount of force as the *smaller*
    number of particles pushing from the opposite side?

    Because of the conservation of momentum.

    The conservation of momentum demonstrates something quite different.

    Let's use numbers and mathematics.

    Ram A, with mass mA=2 and velocity v=+1, collides inelastically with Ram
    B, which has mass mB=1 and velocity vB=-1.

    In the end, Ram A loses +4/3 of its momentum, while Ram B loses its
    initial momentum of -1 and gains a momentum of +1/3.

    What does the conservation of momentum say?

    It explicitly states that there is a quantity of momentum that is
    conserved (in this case, the excess momentum of +1 present in Ram A),
    and it implicitly states that there is a quantity of momentum that is
    NOT conserved (the pair of equal and opposite quantities, +1 and -1,
    which vanish by canceling each other out).

    In other words, only the quantities+1 and -1 can disappear--because they
    are equal and opposite and cancel each other out due to the equality of
    action and reaction--but the additional +1/3 momentum of Ram A does not disappear, because this quantity is part of the excess +1 that is
    conserved. So, where does this +1/3 quantity--which was present in A but
    is no longer there after the collision--actually end up?

    Clearly, it has not vanished; rather, it has been transferred from A to
    B: it was in A, and now it is in B.

    The equality between the action of A and the reaction of B accounts for
    the disappearance of the equal and opposite momenta +1 and -1; but how
    can it account for the disappearance of the +1/3 momentum from ram A
    without a corresponding disappearance of the -1/3 momentum from B?

    Luigi Fortunati
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ram@ram@zedat.fu-berlin.de (Stefan Ram) to sci.physics.research on Thu Oct 29 08:34:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Luigi Fortunati <fortunati.luigi@gmail.com> wrote or quoted:
    Ram A, with mass mA=2 and velocity v=+1, collides inelastically with Ram
    B, which has mass mB=1 and velocity vB=-1.
    In the end, Ram A loses +4/3 of its momentum, while Ram B loses its
    initial momentum of -1 and gains a momentum of +1/3.

    How do you know that in that case ram A loses +4/3 of its
    momentum, while ram B loses its initial momentum of -1 and
    gains a momentum of +1/3?

    What does the conservation of momentum say?

    It says the momentum of a system on which no external forces act does
    not change. So if no external forces act on a system, and that system
    has two parts, the momentum gained by one must be lost by the other.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Sun Nov 1 15:07:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 29/10/2026 16:34, Stefan Ram ha scritto:
    Luigi Fortunati <fortunati.luigi@gmail.com> wrote or quoted:
    Ram A, with mass mA=2 and velocity v=+1, collides inelastically with Ram
    B, which has mass mB=1 and velocity vB=-1.
    In the end, Ram A loses +4/3 of its momentum, while Ram B loses its
    initial momentum of -1 and gains a momentum of +1/3.

    How do you know that in that case ram A loses +4/3 of its
    momentum, while ram B loses its initial momentum of -1 and
    gains a momentum of +1/3?

    I will explain it right away.

    Before the collision
    ---------------------
    Body A has a momentum of +2, moving inertially to the right; it exerts
    no force on anything because bodies A and B are distant and are not
    pushing against each other (no pushing = no force).

    Similarly, body B has a momentum of -1, moving inertially to the left
    without pushing.

    During the collision
    -------------------
    The momentum of +2 of body A--which was previously just inertia moving to
    the right--transforms into a force that PUSHES body B to the right.

    Likewise, the momentum of -1 of body B ceases to be mere inertia and
    becomes a force that PUSHES body A to the left.

    All of this occurs within the unified body A+B, where these forces are internal to the system.

    Within this unified body, there is a momentum of +2 pushing to the right
    and a momentum of -1 pushing to the left.

    A portion of this (kinetic) collision is converted into heat (+1 and
    -1), while the remaining +1 persists as kinetic energy, pushing the
    entire unified body A+B and distributing itself uniformly in proportion
    to the masses that compose it.

    The distribution of the system's +1 momentum occurs "democratically":
    the +1 value is divided by 3 (since there are 3 units of mass, 2+1).
    Thus, 2/3 of that 1 remains with body A (which has a mass of 2), and 1/3
    is transferred to body B (which has a mass of 1).

    Body A has lost a total momentum of 4/3: 1 unit was converted into heat,
    and 1/3 was transferred to body B.

    Luigi Fortunati
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ram@ram@zedat.fu-berlin.de (Stefan Ram) to sci.physics.research on Mon Nov 2 11:24:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Luigi Fortunati <fortunati.luigi@gmail.com> wrote or quoted:
    Thus, 2/3 of that 1 remains with body A (which has a mass of 2), and 1/3
    is transferred to body B (which has a mass of 1).
    Body A has lost a total momentum of 4/3: 1 unit was converted into heat,
    and 1/3 was transferred to body B.

    When you say "1/3 is transferred to body B," you imply that the 1/3
    added to B is subtracted from A. Thus, A changes by -1/3 and B changes
    by +1/3. This equal and opposite exchange means the action on B is
    +1/3 and the reaction on A is -1/3. Therefore, you utilized the very
    principle of "action = reaction" that you set out to disprove.

    The process is being described in the following table.

    Body Initial Final Change in
    Momentum Momentum Momentum

    A +2 2/3 -4/3
    B -1 1/3 +4/3
    Total +1 +1 0

    Momentum is conserved (as the table shows) and can be positive or
    negative. Momentum cannot be converted into heat; instead, kinetic
    energy is converted into heat. Because the total kinetic energy after
    the collision is lower, some of it was indeed converted into heat.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2