• Newton's gravity

    From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Sun Sep 13 10:47:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bK8T-ZbcZZA
    there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    (the Earth of mass M).

    And there are two forces--gravitational ones, obviously: F1 (exerted by
    the Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on the Earth).

    The two forces F1 and F2 do not constitute a single force because they
    act on different bodies and have opposite directions.

    Therefore, they are two forces, not just one.

    Just as obviously, there are two gravitational accelerations, as
    required by Newton's second law: there is the acceleration +a1=F1/m of
    body A to the right, and there is *also* the acceleration -a2=F2/M of
    body B to the left.

    Two different forces causing two different accelerations on the two
    different bodies, within the inertial reference frame.

    But what is this inertial reference frame?

    To understand this, I have summarized the phenomenon in the figure https://www.geogebra.org/classic/wqhxgce8
    showing two generic bodies, A and B, of equal mass "m" that are gravitationally attracting each other.

    Since the bodies have the same mass, the common center of mass "CM" is
    located halfway between them.

    There is the inertial reference frame!

    Both bodies accelerate within the reference frame of the center of mass
    (CM), where only the CM remains stationary while everything else
    accelerates.

    In this reference frame, there are two distinct accelerations: that of
    body A to the right (+a1=F1/m) and that of body B to the left (-a2=F2/m).

    Conversely, in the reference frame of body A (just as in that of body
    B), there is only one acceleration: that of the other body as it approaches.

    Is the magnitude of this unique acceleration--measured in the reference
    frame of A (or B, which amounts to the same thing)--equal to
    2a=|a_1|+|a_2| or to something else?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mikko@mikko.levanto@iki.fi to sci.physics.research on Mon Sep 14 19:08:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    On 13/09/2026 20:47, Luigi Fortunati wrote:
    In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bK8T-ZbcZZA
    there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    (the Earth of mass M).

    And there are two forces--gravitational ones, obviously: F1 (exerted by
    the Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on the Earth).

    Those two forces describe the same interaction.

    The two forces F1 and F2 do not constitute a single force because they
    act on different bodies and have opposite directions.

    Therefore, they are two forces, not just one.

    Just as obviously, there are two gravitational accelerations, as
    required by Newton's second law: there is the acceleration +a1=F1/m of
    body A to the right, and there is *also* the acceleration -a2=F2/M of
    body B to the left.

    Two different forces causing two different accelerations on the two
    different bodies, within the inertial reference frame.

    But what is this inertial reference frame?

    To understand this, I have summarized the phenomenon in the figure https://www.geogebra.org/classic/wqhxgce8
    showing two generic bodies, A and B, of equal mass "m" that are gravitationally attracting each other.

    Since the bodies have the same mass, the common center of mass "CM" is located halfway between them.

    There is the inertial reference frame!

    Both bodies accelerate within the reference frame of the center of mass
    (CM), where only the CM remains stationary while everything else
    accelerates.

    In this reference frame, there are two distinct accelerations: that of
    body A to the right (+a1=F1/m) and that of body B to the left (-a2=F2/m).

    Conversely, in the reference frame of body A (just as in that of body
    B), there is only one acceleration: that of the other body as it approaches.

    No, there is another one: the accleration of the center of mass, which
    also is the acceleration of every inertial frame.

    Is the magnitude of this unique acceleration--measured in the reference
    frame of A (or B, which amounts to the same thing)--equal to
    2a=|a_1|+|a_2| or to something else?

    The asked acceleration is twice the acceleration of the other body
    in the CM frame, so its magnitude is twice the magnitude of the
    acceleration in the CM frame.

    This "twice" only applies in the special case of equal magnitued.
    Otherwise there is some other number instead.
    --
    Mikko
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Thu Sep 17 08:35:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    On 09/15/2026 at 04:08, Mikko wrote:
    On 09/13/2026 at 20:47, Luigi Fortunati wrote:
    In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3DbK8T-ZbcZZA
    there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    (the Earth of mass M).

    And there are two forces =E2=80=93 gravitational, of course: F1 (exer=
    ted by the
    Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on the Earth=
    ).

    Those two forces describe the same interaction.

    Yes, it is the gravitational interaction of the third law that provides=20
    TWO forces, that of the Earth on the satellite and that of the satellite=20
    on the Earth.

    Two forces, not just one.

    The two forces F1 and F2 do not constitute a single force because=20
    they act
    on different bodies and have opposite directions.

    Therefore, these are two forces, not just one.

    Equally obviously, there are two gravitational accelerations, as
    required by Newton's second law: there is the acceleration +a1=3DF1/m=
    of
    body A to the right, and there is *also* the acceleration -a2=3DF2/M =
    of
    body B to the left.

    Two different forces causing two different accelerations on the two
    different bodies, within the inertial reference frame.

    But what is this inertial reference frame?

    To understand this, I summarized the phenomenon in the figure
    https://www.geogebra.org/classic/wqhxgce8
    showing two generic bodies, A and B, of equal mass "m" attracting=20
    each other
    gravitationally.

    Since the bodies have the same mass, the common center of mass "CM" i=
    s
    located halfway between them.

    Here is the inertial reference frame!

    Both bodies accelerate in the center of mass (CM) reference frame,
    where only the CM remains at rest while everything else
    accelerates.

    In this reference frame, there are two distinct accelerations: that
    of body A to the right (+a1=3DF1/m) and that of body B to the left=20 (-a2=3DF2/m).

    Conversely, in the reference frame of body A (as well as in that of b=
    ody
    B), there is only one acceleration: that of the other body as it=20 approaches.

    No, there is another: the acceleration of the center of mass, which
    is also the acceleration of any inertial frame.

    This is not the acceleration of a body because the center of mass is not=20
    a body.

    Is the magnitude of this unique acceleration =E2=80=94 measured in th=
    e frame of
    reference of A (or B, which is the same) =E2=80=94 equal to
    2a=3D|a_1|+|a_2| or something else?

    The acceleration in question is double the acceleration of the other b=
    ody
    in the CM frame; therefore, its magnitude is double the magnitude of t=
    he
    acceleration in the CM frame.

    This "double" is only true in the special case where the magnitudes=20
    are equal.

    Otherwise it has a different value.

    Exactly, in this case it is double, in all other cases it is an=20
    intermediate value, i.e. between F1 and |F1|+|F2|.

    Luigi Fortunati
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mikko@mikko.levanto@iki.fi to sci.physics.research on Sat Sep 19 14:10:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    On 17/09/2026 18:35, Luigi Fortunati wrote:
    On 09/15/2026 at 04:08, Mikko wrote:
    > On 09/13/2026 at 20:47, Luigi Fortunati wrote:
    >> In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video
    >> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bK8T-ZbcZZA
    >> there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    >> (the Earth of mass M).
    >>
    >> And there are two forces =E2=80=93 gravitational, of course: F1 (exer> ted by the
    >> Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on the Earth> ).
    >
    > Those two forces describe the same interaction.

    Yes, it is the gravitational interaction of the third law that provides
    TWO forces, that of the Earth on the satellite and that of the satellite
    on the Earth.

    Two forces, not just one.

    Being two descriptions of the same interaction, if one is known then so
    is the other. More specifically, F2 = -F1;


    >> The two forces F1 and F2 do not constitute a single force because
    they act
    >> on different bodies and have opposite directions.
    >>
    >> Therefore, these are two forces, not just one.
    >>
    >> Equally obviously, there are two gravitational accelerations, as
    >> required by Newton's second law: there is the acceleration +a1=F1/m> of
    >> body A to the right, and there is *also* the acceleration -a2=F2/M > of
    >> body B to the left.
    >>
    >> Two different forces causing two different accelerations on the two
    >> different bodies, within the inertial reference frame.
    >>
    >> But what is this inertial reference frame?
    >>
    >> To understand this, I summarized the phenomenon in the figure
    >> https://www.geogebra.org/classic/wqhxgce8
    >> showing two generic bodies, A and B, of equal mass "m" attracting
    each other
    >> gravitationally.
    >>
    >> Since the bodies have the same mass, the common center of mass "CM" i> s
    >> located halfway between them.
    >>
    >> Here is the inertial reference frame!
    >>
    >> Both bodies accelerate in the center of mass (CM) reference frame,
    >> where only the CM remains at rest while everything else
    >> accelerates.
    >>
    >> In this reference frame, there are two distinct accelerations: that
    >> of body A to the right (+a1=F1/m) and that of body B to the left (-a2=F2/m).
    >>
    >> Conversely, in the reference frame of body A (as well as in that of b> ody
    >> B), there is only one acceleration: that of the other body as it approaches.
    >
    > No, there is another: the acceleration of the center of mass, which
    > is also the acceleration of any inertial frame.

    This is not the acceleration of a body because the center of mass is not
    a body.

    >> Is the magnitude of this unique acceleration -- measured in th> e frame of
    >> reference of A (or B, which is the same) -- equal to
    >> 2a=|a_1|+|a_2| or something else?
    >
    > The acceleration in question is double the acceleration of the other b> ody
    > in the CM frame; therefore, its magnitude is double the magnitude of t> he
    > acceleration in the CM frame.
    >
    > This "double" is only true in the special case where the magnitudes
    are equal.

    > Otherwise it has a different value.

    Exactly, in this case it is double, in all other cases it is an
    intermediate value, i.e. between F1 and |F1|+|F2|.

    Tht "it" means the acceleration. Whith unequal masses it can be more
    or less than twice, depending on which body is more massive.
    --
    Mikko
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Wed Sep 23 10:49:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 19/09/2026 23:10, Mikko ha scritto:
    On 17/09/2026 18:35, Luigi Fortunati wrote:
    >> In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video
    >> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bK8T-ZbcZZA
    >> there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    >> (the Earth of mass M).
    >>
    >> And there are two forces =E2=80=93 gravitational, of course:
    F1 (exer> ted by the
    >> Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on
    the Earth> ).
    >
    > Those two forces describe the same interaction.

    Yes, it is the gravitational interaction of the third law that provides
    TWO forces, that of the Earth on the satellite and that of the satellite
    on the Earth.

    Two forces, not just one.

    Being two descriptions of the same interaction...

    How can it be the same interaction if *two* entities are acting?

    One body pulls in one direction and the other in the opposite direction, exactly like in a tug-of-war.

    The rope pulls and is pulled at one end (interaction 1) and pulls and is pulled at the other (interaction 2).

    It is as if, rather than a rope, a spring were acting between bodies A
    and B, pulling them and exerting *two* interactions rather than just one.

    Luigi Fortunati
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mikko@mikko.levanto@iki.fi to sci.physics.research on Fri Sep 25 00:13:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    On 23/09/2026 20:49, Luigi Fortunati wrote:
    Il 19/09/2026 23:10, Mikko ha scritto:
    > On 17/09/2026 18:35, Luigi Fortunati wrote:
    >> >> In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video
    >> >> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bK8T-ZbcZZA
    >> >> there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    >> >> (the Earth of mass M).
    >> >>
    >> >> And there are two forces =E2=80=93 gravitational, of course:
    F1 (exer> ted by the
    >> >> Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on
    the Earth> ).
    >> >
    >> > Those two forces describe the same interaction.
    >>
    >> Yes, it is the gravitational interaction of the third law that provides
    >> TWO forces, that of the Earth on the satellite and that of the satellite
    >> on the Earth.
    >>
    >> Two forces, not just one.
    >
    > Being two descriptions of the same interaction...

    How can it be the same interaction if *two* entities are acting?

    How many doublet sets can you make of those two entities? All known interactions involve a pair. In principle there could be interactions
    that require bigger sets but none is known.

    One body pulls in one direction and the other in the opposite direction, exactly like in a tug-of-war.

    That is, the interaction is attractive.

    The rope pulls and is pulled at one end (interaction 1) and pulls and is pulled at the other (interaction 2).

    That is, there are three bodies and two interactions.

    It is as if, rather than a rope, a spring were acting between bodies A
    and B, pulling them and exerting *two* interactions rather than just one.
    Very much except that there is not spring there. Newton's gravity is a non-local interaction between two bodies.
    --
    Mikko

    [[Mod. note -- According to https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/386627/why-there-is-no-3-body-or-more-generally-n-body-fundamental-force
    there are a few 3-body interactions in physics (though not in
    Newtonian mechanics).
    -- jt]]
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Sun Oct 11 23:14:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 25/09/2026 09:13, Mikko ha scritto:
    In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bK8T-ZbcZZA
    there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    (the Earth of mass M).

    And there are two forces =E2=80=93 gravitational, of course:
    F1 (exer> ted by the
    Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on
    the Earth> ).

    Those two forces describe the same interaction.
    What is interaction? Let me put it simply...

    I pull you and you pull me--that is interaction.

    I pull you with *my* force and you pull me with *your* force; there is
    no single, autonomous force sitting between us, pulling in both
    directions with the *same* intensity.

    I decide how great my force should be, and you decide how great *your*
    force should be.

    Luigi Fortunati
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mikko@mikko.levanto@iki.fi to sci.physics.research on Thu Oct 22 08:41:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    On 12/10/2026 09:14, Luigi Fortunati wrote:
    Il 25/09/2026 09:13, Mikko ha scritto:
    In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bK8T-ZbcZZA
    there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    (the Earth of mass M).

    And there are two forces =E2=80=93 gravitational, of course:
    F1 (exer> ted by the
    Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on
    the Earth> ).

    Those two forces describe the same interaction.

    What is interaction? Let me put it simply...

    I pull you and you pull me--that is interaction.

    I pull you with *my* force and you pull me with *your* force; there is
    no single, autonomous force sitting between us, pulling in both
    directions with the *same* intensity.

    There's your mistake. There is only one interaction between us. You
    can't pull with a greater force than I pull. If you try to pull harder
    but I don't and instead apprach you you fail to pull harder. Try with
    two threads, one firmly attached to something immoble, the other
    unattached: you can pull the attached one much harder.

    I decide how great my force should be, and you decide how great *your*
    force should be.

    That does not mean that both can pull as hard as has decided.
    --
    Mikko
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Luigi Fortunati@fortunati.luigi@gmail.com to sci.physics.research on Fri Oct 23 12:06:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.research

    Il 22/10/2026 17:41, Mikko ha scritto:
    In the frame https://ibb.co/PsG2JQXK taken from the video
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bK8T-ZbcZZA
    there are two bodies: body A (the satellite of mass m) and body B
    (the Earth of mass M).

    And there are two forces -- gravitational, of course:
    F1 (exerted by the
    Earth on the satellite) and F2 (exerted by the satellite on
    the Earth> ).

    Those two forces describe the same interaction.

    What is interaction? Let me put it simply...

    I pull you and you pull me--that is interaction.

    I pull you with *my* force and you pull me with *your* force; there is
    no single, autonomous force sitting between us, pulling in both
    directions with the *same* intensity.

    There's your mistake. There is only one interaction between us. You
    can't pull with a greater force than I pull. If you try to pull harder
    but I don't and instead apprach you you fail to pull harder.

    I can demonstrate--using numbers and mathematics--that I am capable of
    pulling with greater force.

    Initial position: I pull you with a force of -1 (action), you pull me
    with a force of +1 (reaction), and both of us remain stationary.

    Where do these equal and opposite forces of +1 and -1 come from? Do they
    arise from the third law of motion? No!

    Do they depend on our physical prowess? No!

    Do they depend on our mass? No!

    They depend exclusively on our own will to increase or decrease the
    force we exert.

    I am stronger, but I choose not to exert my full strength; instead, I
    decide to apply an amount of force exactly equal to yours.

    I determine this equality (in agreement with you: +1 and -1), and we
    remain stationary.

    In summary: mass has nothing to do with it, physical prowess has nothing
    to do with it, and the third law of motion has nothing to do with it.

    The opposing forces of +1 and -1 depend solely on our own intentions.

    And as long as we choose to keep our action and reaction forces
    equal--whether +2 and -2, +100 and -100, or any other pair of EQUAL and opposite values--we will always remain stationary.

    What is the only way for you to accelerate me, or for me to accelerate
    you, other than by breaking this equality between action and reaction?

    Luigi Fortunati
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2