• Re: vis-viva and vis-motrix

    From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 09:22:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 10/27/2026 10:03 AM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/03/2024 01:51 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/01/2024 05:49 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 09/30/2024 11:48 PM, Thomas Heger wrote:
    Am Montag000030, 30.09.2024 um 20:55 schrieb Ross Finlayson:
    On 09/29/2024 10:20 PM, Thomas Heger wrote:
    Am Samstag000028, 28.09.2024 um 23:57 schrieb Ross Finlayson:
    On 09/28/2024 01:57 AM, Thomas Heger wrote:
    Am Donnerstag000026, 26.09.2024 um 22:41 schrieb Ross Finlayson: >>>>>>>>> On 09/26/2024 10:39 AM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 09/25/2024 01:55 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 09/22/2024 11:37 AM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 09/22/2024 09:59 AM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 09/17/2024 11:41 AM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 09/17/2024 04:34 AM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Ross Finlayson <ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Does anybody even bother to think about vis-viva versus >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> vis-
    motrix
    anymore, with regards to conservation, momentum, inertia, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and
    energy,
    and potential and impulse energy?

    Of course not. These are obsolete distinctions, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> from a time when energy and momentum conservation was not >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> corectly
    understood.
    The matter was put to rest by Christiaan Huygens >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> by showing (for particle collisions)
    that momentum conservation and energy conservation >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> are distinct conservation laws, that are both needed, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Jan


    Is it usually considered at all that momentum and inertia >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> change
    places with respect to resistance to change of motion and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> rest
    respectively sort of back and forth in the theory since >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> antiquity?

    Several times?

    Au contraire, there is yet definition up, in the air, as it >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> were.

    Find any reference to fictitious forces and for a theory >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> where the potential fields are what's real and the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> classical
    field's just a projection to a perspective in the middle, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and anything at all to do with the plainly empirical or >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> tribological with regards to our grandly theoretical, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and one may find that the definitions of "inertia" and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "momentum" with regards to resistance to changes in motion >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and resistance to changes in rest, as with regards to >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> weight and as with regards to heft, have rotated each >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> few hundred years, as with regards to the great schism >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whence Newton's vis-motrix, as with regards to the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> vis-insita
    and Leibnitz' vis-viva, as what for example can be read >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> into
    from the Wikipedia on conservation of _energy_ and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> conservation
    of _momentum_ up to today, where for example, the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "infinitely- many
    higher orders of theoretical acceleration are both formally >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> non-zero and vanishing" because "zero meters/second >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> equals infinity seconds/meter".

    So, for a true centrifugal, and quite all about the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> derivative
    and anti-derivative as with regards to momentum, inertia, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and kinetic energy, in a theory what's of course >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> sum-of-histories
    sum-of-potentials with least action and gradient, or >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> sum-of-
    potentials,
    it is so that the various under-defined concepts of the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> plain
    laws
    of after Newton, are as yet un-defined, and there are a >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> variety
    of considerations as with regards to the multiplicities, or >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> these singularities, and the reciprocities, of these >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> projections.


    So, some of these considerations as since "Mediaeval >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Times",
    help reflect that Einstein's not alone in his, 'attack on >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Newton'.



    Moment and Motion: a story of momentum

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DH-Gh-
    bBb7M&list=PLb7rLSBiE7F4eHy5vT61UYFR7_BIhwcOY



    Theories and principles, momentum and sum-of-histories >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> sum-of-potentials, conservation, momentum and inertia >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and energy, fields and forces, Einstein's mechanics, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> conservation of energy and conservation of momentum, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> potential and fictitious and causal and virtual, mv, mv^2, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ordinary and extra-ordinary in the differential and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> inverses,
    the standard curriculum and the super-standard, momentum >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> in definition, classical exposition, Bayes rule and a law of >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> large
    numbers, law(s) of large numbers and not-Bayesian >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> expectations,
    numerical methods in derivations, uniqueness results later >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> distinctness results, law(s) of large numbers and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> continuity,
    complete and replete, induction and limits, partials and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> limits,
    the paleo-classical, platforms and planks, mass and weight >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and heft, gravitational force and g-forces, measure and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> matching measure, relativity and a difference between >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> rest and motion, heft, resistance to gravity, ideals and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> billiard mechanics, wider ideals, Wallis and Huygens, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Nayfeh's nonlinear oscillations, addition of vectors, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> observables and ideals, DesCartes' and Kelvin's vortices, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> black holes and white holes, waves and optics, Euler, both >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> vis-motrix and vis-viva, d'Alembert's principle, Lagrange, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> potential as integral over space, Maupertuis and Gauss >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and least action and least constraint, Hamilton, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hamiltonians and Bayesians, Jacobi, Navier and Stokes >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> and Cauchy and Saint Venant and Maxwell, statistical >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> mechanics and entropy and least action, ideal and real, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> mechanical reduction and severe abstraction, ions and >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> fields and field theory, wave mechanics and virtual >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> particles,
    ideals and the ideal, the classical and monistic holism, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> paleo-
    nouveau.







    Much like the theories of "fall", "shadow", or
    "push" gravity, or the "shadow" or "umbral"
    gravity and for theories of real supergravity,
    as after Fatio and LeSage, as of theories of
    "pull" or "suck" gravity of Newton and the
    "rubber-sheet" or "down" gravity of Einstein,
    then the theories of vortices like DesCartes
    and Kelvin, and others, help reflect on the
    rectilinear and curvilinear, and flat and round,
    as with regards to deconstructive accounts of
    usual unstated assumptions and the severe
    abstraction and mechanical reduction, in as
    with regards to modern theories of mechanics.

    Zero meters per second is infinity seconds per meter. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>


    You know, zero meters per second is infinity seconds per >>>>>>>>>>>>> meter,
    and, any change of anything in motion has associated the >>>>>>>>>>>>> infinitely-many higher orders of acceleration, and,
    it's rather underdefined and even undefined yet very >>>>>>>>>>>>> obviously clearly is an aspect of the mathematical model, >>>>>>>>>>>>> that Galileo's and Newton's laws of motion, sort of are >>>>>>>>>>>>> only a "principal branch" as it were, and, don't quite >>>>>>>>>>>>> suffice.

    Of course anything that would add infinitely-many higher >>>>>>>>>>>>> orders of acceleration mathematically to the theory, >>>>>>>>>>>>> of mechanics, the theory, would have to result being >>>>>>>>>>>>> exactly being the same as Galilean and Newtonian,
    "in the limit", and for example with regards to
    Lorentzians and these kinds of things.

    It's sort of similar with adding more and better
    infinities and infinitesimals to mathematics.
    The continuous dynamics of continuous motion
    though and its mechanics, is a few layers above
    a plain concept of the continuum, as with regards
    to something like a strong mathematical platonism's
    mathematical universe, being that making advances
    in physics involves making advances in mathematics.

    Which pretty much means digging up and revisiting
    the "severe abstraction" the "mechanical reduction", >>>>>>>>>>>>> quite all along the way: paleo-classical, super-classical. >>>>>>>>>>>>

    "zero meters per second is infinity seconds per meter"???? >>>>>>>>>>>>
    Do you guys even have any idea whats yous talkings abouts? >>>>>>>>>>>>

    'infinity' has no time and cannot be measured. So, that means >>>>>>>>>>>> there
    are
    no 'seconds' in "infinity", and no meter/meters/inches in >>>>>>>>>>>> "infinity'!


    In "infinity" there are no meters or seconds.


    Where do you guys get your information from? Albert Einstein?? >>>>>>>>>>>>













    "Moment and Motion: infinity and large numbers"

    Oh i see, yous people live in a Mandelbox universe...


    i wasn't refering to yours 'numbers' universe..

    i was refering to the real universe.

    Einstein said he wasn't sure if the universe is infinite or not.. >>>>>>>>>>
    but I'm sure the universe is infinite...just not the one you're >>>>>>>>>> in...only it's surrounding universe that yous are expanding in. >>>>>>>>>>

    sorry to bust your bubble.












    Actually, there's an idea that one way to conceive
    the universe, is, as a mathematical continuum, that
    these days that's what's called "holograph", or "hologram",
    the idea that one mathematical continuum is big enough
    to have a number, for each thing, and relation in things.

    Then these philosophically are called "plastic numbers,
    metal numbers, concrete numbers".

    Then, for example, Euclidean space, and, maybe not
    Minkowski space, have it that there's only a ray
    of time, or 3 + 1/2, with three space dimensions,
    rolling and curled up, in the infinities and the
    infinitesimals, one continuum.

    It might even be reasonable to explain sort of why
    there are three dimensions in a mathematical universe
    of the space-like, simply courtesy properties of numbers,
    because "least action and a gradient" is about the
    easiest way to say "it is what it is, and it will
    be what it will be".


    I had the idea, that this picture is actually correct and written >>>>>>>> kind
    of 'book' about this concept.

    (you find it here:

    https://docs.google.com/presentation/
    d/1Ur3_giuk2l439fxUa8QHX4wTDxBEaM6lOlgVUa0cFU4/edit?usp=sharing >>>>>>>> )

    The idea is called 'structured spacetime'.

    The spacetime of GR is assumed to exist and being a real physical >>>>>>>> entity.

    It is a continuum build from 'pointlike elements'.

    These 'elements' are something you may call 'points with features'. >>>>>>>>
    The math behind it is quite unusal, but already known and not
    particularily difficult.

    It is so called 'Pauli algebra' applied to so called
    'bi-quaternions
    (aka 'complex four-vectors').

    ...


    TH




    It kind of is, kind of isn't.

    A "tetrad" in physics helps fill out complementary duals,
    and, their complementary duals, so that notions of

    oscillation and restitution
    dissipation and attenuation

    make for

    tendencies and propensities

    what's the consistitutive
    and reconstitutive and deconstitutive,

    why three legs is enough to hold up the table,
    then for something on it.

    So, tetrads like

    proton electron neutron photon,

    mass charge light-speed neutron-lifetime

    strong+gravity electromagnetic electro-weak optical-weak

    help establish usual sorts of setups like field theory,
    models of forces, and pretty much for theories where
    the potential fields are the real field, for example

    3 + 1 dimensions, or 3 + 1/2 "space and a ray of time",

    then there's a tetrad

    point projection perspective space

    as with regards to

    point local global total.


    We need 'three axes of space and one scalar for time' at a single
    point
    only.

    Moving to another point would require the same stuff, but not the
    same
    axes!

    Iow: the (imaginary) axis of time does not need to be parallel
    throughout the entire universe!

    Actually time MUST be local and measures some sort of rythm of
    causality.

    Other places can have actually other timelines and actually a local >>>>>> time, which runs backwards from our perspective.


    This is important, because that would allow to understand certain
    behaviours of nature.

    This would result in a double tetrahedron, where forward flowing time >>>>>> with three real axes and a backwards flow time with the axes of
    kind of
    world behind the mirror would overlap to a double tetrahedron.

    Since we belong to these results, too, we can only live in our own >>>>>> world
    and cannot look behind that mirror.

    From this we have drawn the conclusion, that our own world is all >>>>>> that
    would exist.

    But that is just an optical illusion and as wrong as 'flat Earth'. >>>>>>
    But we know already, that things can leave our own 'world' and
    disappear
    into black holes or pop out of nothing in 'white holes'.



    Then, this being usually a field theory, there's
    that the theory is always "three space dimensions",
    and, that being some "real Euclidean space".

    People make a lot of the complex, and also the
    hyper-complex like geometric algebras, then
    there are also approaches like Kodaira and Zariski,
    that include without, that the same sorts of setups
    of rotations and reflections and analyticity with
    respect to a "diagram", have that there are all sorts
    of diagrams, considered mathematical models.



    Well, my own guess was a clifford algebra with the name CL_3, also >>>>>> known
    as 'Pauli algebra'.


    This uses 'bi-quaternions' and that shall be symbolised by a double >>>>>> tetrahedron (because of the eight components of this construct).



    Then the idea that there is a numerical resource,
    a continuum, that just sort of naturally results
    three dimensions and a ray of time, and also then
    as with regards to tetrads and information in
    the space-time, the "Space-Time", with its contents,
    is a thing actually looking to equip a mathematical
    model as being a resource and book-kept in this way,
    about deriving most of the theory from least,
    and that that's a very principled approach.


    'Ray of time' is a dangerous concept.

    Time is depicted as a ray, but usually time is an imaginary
    pseudoscalar.

    TH


    It's matters of perspective and projection.

    The "time parity" has never been falsified in physics,
    so there's never any real "negative time" in physics
    as a quantity, so, it's considered a real quantity.
    When the perspective/projection is unduly rigid instead
    of optical, geometric instead of optical, then it lets out,
    yet, that is a limitation of the mathematical model not
    an ever falsified aspect of the physical model.

    'negative time' is impossible.

    You need to treet time 'relative'.

    This means:
    time is positive everywhere

    Where clocks tick at the same rate and you are able to use the same
    kind
    of clocks, that is what I call 'time domain'.

    This is on planet Earth a spherical shell around the planet of equal
    hight.

    this is the set of points, sharing the same (positive!) time.

    Now other time domains may exist, where time there is locally positive, >>>> while in our view negative.

    This is possible, because the very word 'negative' makes sense only for >>>> us as remote observers, while locally time must be positive.

    Besides of this, we have the effects of 'anti-symmetry' of spacetime.

    This causes a 'mirror world', which exists invisble 'behind the
    mirror'.

    There time runs backwards from our perspective as well as our time
    there.

    This is similar to a Moebius strip, which has only one side, but with
    two directions pointing 'up' locally.


    TH



    It's interesting, though, I encourage you.




    It's like the other day, there was an article, and it purported
    "negative time demonstrated", which of course would violate causality,
    then it looks like it's as of an Aspect-type or Aspect-like experiment,
    where Alain Aspect, makes an articulated beam array, in the photonic,
    what results that an information arrives as "at once" and, "zero time",
    as it were, that "information is free, yet metered", that though
    yet still not reflecting, "negative time". Aspect's though
    does _not_ have "negative time".

    Then it's like looking at something like that, it's like,
    "well in our model, there's never zero time, so, the way
    we see what according to that coherent frame is zero time,
    which in our theory isn't coherent and so yet a time difference
    the same experiment, results it must be _negative time_".


    And it's like, "I get what you mean that's not coherent."
    It's like "you don't even have the words in your theory
    for zero time thusly it bleeds into your numbers negative".
    Of course it never went _backwards_ in time and never
    violated what most-all have as causality or otherwise
    went about making false statements about physics.



    It's almost a universal consideration that
    physics is a universal consideration, with regards
    to that of course it's arbitrarily un-falsifiable any
    matters of "higher-orders of organization", it's also
    immaterial, as "the universal consideration is a universal
    consideration".


    Then, these ideas of symmetry, what result the notions of
    mirrors and the reflection and incidence of reflection in
    what results the optical in the optical, and also about
    the vorticial that is the non-linear part of "equal and
    opposite reaction", the law of physics, then makes for
    that indeed invariance of conservation law and Noether's
    theorem about that being an abstract what we call continuum
    law or continuity law most usually, though some most usually
    call symmetries and others conservations and others invariances,
    that here it's that conservation laws are continuity laws,
    then that what can result as symmetry-flex, is otherwise
    for the regularities of symmetries, invariances, conservation.


    Moebius is a key enrichment, as with regards to matters
    of projective and perspective, those equipping geometry
    with a context and surrounds.



    The "information is free, if metered" bit reflects on that
    usually the idea is that according to the invariances under
    the theories of relativity, that information can never go
    faster than c, which given the L-principle is a universal
    constant. So, the idea is that in the space-frame terms,
    actually the space-frame can be contrived, so that what
    happens, there's established any linearity and a guide-lode
    at the center, then that the guide-lode's motion, also
    advises the motion twice as far away.

    This is that "information is fundamentally free",
    "if metered", and specifically by the carriage
    of light otherwise, and even "asymptotically free".






    The new "negative time" bit is described as a sort
    of condensed-matter physics thing where there's
    just sort of some ultra-cold rubidium which has its
    own sort of super-fluid regime with regards to
    condensed-matter physics, so anyways it's just
    shooting photons through that, then saying that
    the photons arrive out the other side at light
    speed yet also appear to displace or "be absorbed",
    where that's assigning something that's not so.

    Nothing happens faster than "light speed" there
    the photons is what's not going on.


    That's an altogether different concept of course
    that there's a clock hypothesis and indeed that
    out past c there's c_g and it reflects the Newtonian
    and gravitational waves have immediate components
    and gravitational waves have luminous components.
    Of course the most modern ephemeris about Earth
    is Parameterized Post-Newtonian where c_g > c,
    and of course the force of gravity always points
    at the source not the image, and GR is in front of SR,
    and SR has that light is fleeting, and SR's spacial is local,
    and so on, here according to JPL and Einstein on Einstein.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2