• The real story of "confirming" The Shit

    From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 10:07:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    1) The idiot has imagined some desynchronizing
    according to his symmetric idiocies clocks. He
    asserted them to be perfect and ideal clocks.

    2)His minions invented and constructed clocks
    fitting that. They said "Look! These clocks are
    PERFECT!!! Because they perfectly fit the idiot's
    delusions!!!"

    3) Fitting the idiot's delusions clocks fitted
    the idiot's delusions and "confirmed" the prophecy
    that fitting the idiot's delusions clocks will fit
    the idiot's delusions.

    4)the assertion that it's perfect remains as
    baseless as it is idiotic
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 10:32:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    The real story of "confirming" The Shit

    Oh, wonderful.

    Maciej Wo+|niak has finally decided to rewrite the history of experimental physics.

    Unfortunately, he forgot to check what actually happened.

    1) The idiot has imagined some desynchronizing
    according to his symmetric idiocies clocks.
    He asserted them to be perfect and ideal clocks.

    No, Maciej.

    An ideal clock is one that measures the proper time along its worldline.

    Relativity predicts that clocks following different worldlines can
    accumulate different amounts of proper time.

    There is nothing contradictory about that.

    And the predicted difference is QUANTITATIVE.

    Not a label.

    Not a religious belief.

    A NUMBER.

    2) His minions invented and constructed clocks
    fitting that.

    Ah, yes!

    The great conspiracy of atomic clock manufacturers!

    Apparently, they secretly designed cesium atoms to obey Einstein.

    Quite an achievement, considering that the relevant atomic transition frequencies are properties of nature, not inventions of clock
    manufacturers.

    And now for the part you conveniently left out.

    In 1977, the NTS-2 satellite carried a cesium atomic clock.

    Its relativistic frequency offset was predicted BEFORE the measurement.

    The correction was initially left unapplied.

    The measured offset was:

    +443.1 x 10^-12.

    The predicted offset was:

    +445.0 x 10^-12.

    Agreement within approximately 0.43%.

    Only AFTER this measurement was the correction applied.

    Source:

    Easton, Buisson and McCaskill,
    NRL Report 8232 (1978),
    "Initial Results of the NAVSTAR GPS NTS-2 Satellite".

    https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA058591.pdf

    So explain something, Maciej.

    How did a clock that had NOT YET BEEN CORRECTED produce almost exactly the frequency difference predicted by relativity?

    Did the cesium atoms read Einstein's papers?

    Were they brainwashed?

    Perhaps they attended secret meetings of the Church of Proper Time?

    3) Fitting the idiot's delusions clocks fitted
    the idiot's delusions and "confirmed" the prophecy

    No.

    A theory predicted a numerical effect.

    An experiment measured that effect.

    The prediction agreed with the measurement.

    That is what experimental confirmation means.

    And your attempt to describe this as circular reasoning is particularly hilarious because the experimental measurement was made BEFORE the
    correction was applied.

    4) the assertion that it's perfect remains as
    baseless as it is idiotic

    And there you go again.

    PERFECT.

    IDEAL.

    PROPER.

    REAL.

    You are still obsessing over adjectives.

    Meanwhile, physicists and engineers are comparing numerical predictions
    with measurements.

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Your old nemesis.

    You have now produced four paragraphs of insults, a conspiracy theory
    about atomic clocks, and precisely ZERO numerical predictions of your own.

    So here's a simple challenge.

    Forget Einstein.

    Forget the words "proper time".

    Forget whether you like the adjective "ideal".

    Take an atomic clock on Earth and another aboard a GPS satellite.

    What difference in their rates does YOUR theory predict, before
    compensation?

    Give us a number.

    With units.

    And show us how you calculated it.

    The relativistic prediction is approximately +38.5 microseconds per day
    for the satellite clock.

    The experiment confirmed the effect.

    Now it's your turn.

    Or will you once again explain that numbers are irrelevant because the
    clocks have the wrong NAME?

    Praise REAL TIME!

    And may the sacred cesium atoms never betray you. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 11:50:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 11:32 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    The real story of "confirming" The Shit

    Oh, wonderful.

    Maciej Wo+|niak has finally decided to rewrite the history of
    experimental physics.

    Unfortunately, he forgot to check what actually happened.

    1) The idiot has imagined some desynchronizing
    according to his symmetric idiocies clocks.
    He asserted them to be perfect and ideal clocks.

    No, Maciej.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.




    An ideal clock is one that measures the proper time along its worldline.

    Relativity predicts that clocks following different worldlines can accumulate different amounts of proper time.

    That's right, The Shit is prophecing that
    the clocks fitting it will fit it.

    There is nothing contradictory about that.

    Indeed.


    2) His minions invented and constructed clocks
    fitting that.

    Ah, yes!

    The great conspiracy of atomic clock manufacturers!

    Python you're too stupid for any conspiracy and it's
    a mere fact that atomic clocks were invented and
    announced perfect after the idiot mumbled his
    idiocies.


    In 1977, the NTS-2 satellite carried a cesium atomic clock.
    Its relativistic frequency offset was predicted BEFORE the measurement.

    To predict that the clocks fitting the idiot's
    idiocies will fit the idiot's idiocies requires
    indeed magnificent skills.

    And the assertion that it's perfect remains
    as baseless as it is idiotic.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 11:02:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 11:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:32 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    The real story of "confirming" The Shit

    Oh, wonderful.

    Maciej Wo+|niak has finally decided to rewrite the history of
    experimental physics.

    Unfortunately, he forgot to check what actually happened.

    1) The idiot has imagined some desynchronizing
    according to his symmetric idiocies clocks.
    He asserted them to be perfect and ideal clocks.

    No, Maciej.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.




    An ideal clock is one that measures the proper time along its worldline.

    Relativity predicts that clocks following different worldlines can
    accumulate different amounts of proper time.

    That's right, The Shit is prophecing that
    the clocks fitting it will fit it.

    There is nothing contradictory about that.

    Indeed.


    2) His minions invented and constructed clocks
    fitting that.

    Ah, yes!

    The great conspiracy of atomic clock manufacturers!

    Python you're too stupid for any conspiracy and it's
    a mere fact that atomic clocks were invented and
    announced perfect after the idiot mumbled his
    idiocies.


    In 1977, the NTS-2 satellite carried a cesium atomic clock.
    Its relativistic frequency offset was predicted BEFORE the measurement.

    To predict that the clocks fitting the idiot's
    idiocies will fit the idiot's idiocies requires
    indeed magnificent skills.

    And the assertion that it's perfect remains
    as baseless as it is idiotic.

    https://ibb.co/HT3CqjBB
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From x3@x@x.net to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 15:17:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/26 01:07, Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:
    1) The idiot ...

    When did the word 'idiot' come into existence?

    Were these all based upon theories of development
    in the later 1800s? Like 'idiot', 'imbecile', and
    'moron'?

    If you were to call someone an 'idiot' in the year
    1850, would they have no idea what you were talking
    about?

    Would this word nave meaning if there was no
    knowledge of its meaning? Did a meaning to
    the word exist at the time?



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2