• Praise The Shit!!! Which PREDICTED!!!

    From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 20:57:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity


    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 21:13:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the
    satellites.

    Applied it.

    And it worked.

    What a devastating failure for relativity!

    Meanwhile, your theory still can't predict a single number.

    How ingenious indeed.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 22:37:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 21:42:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate, or any textbook :-)

    https://ibb.co/PszXSQPj


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 22:50:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.
    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?






    https://ibb.co/PszXSQPj

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 21:54:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    https://ibb.co/KjWk9SM7


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 23:02:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike worldline:

    d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?




    https://ibb.co/KjWk9SM7

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 22:14:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike worldline:

    d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions with EXPERIMENTS.

    Relativity predicts a specific, measurable difference in clock rates. GPS engineers calculated it in advance, compensated for it, and verified the result.

    That's called experimental physics.

    Your endless repetition of "idiot's formulas" isn't.

    Now, where is YOUR quantitative prediction?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 23:24:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the >>>>>>
    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike worldline:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions with EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 22:28:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the >>>>>>>
    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike worldline:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions with
    EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Maciej,

    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Nope.

    Let's take GPS clocks, for instance.

    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the
    nominal GPS frequency.

    WHY?

    Because relativity predicts that, once in orbit, an uncompensated clock
    would gain approximately 38.5 microseconds per day relative to GPS
    coordinate time.

    **AFTER LAUNCH:**

    The satellite reaches its orbit.

    Its gravitational environment and orbital velocity change, just as
    predicted.

    And the pre-adjusted clock now runs at approximately the required GPS coordinate-time rate, with additional corrections for orbital variations
    and other effects.

    The correction was calculated BEFORE launch, not invented afterward to fit
    the measurements.

    Without that relativistic frequency offset, the clock would drift by approximately 38.5 microseconds per day.

    So your celebrated t'=t is precisely the result engineers work to obtain
    by COMPENSATING for the relativistic difference.

    The clock's proper time is not defined by whether its display agrees with another clock. It is the spacetime interval accumulated along its
    worldline.

    Now, Maciej, a very simple question:

    **What frequency offset would YOU have specified before launching that satellite?**

    Relativity gives a number.

    You give insults.

    https://ibb.co/LdXXZT1W

    And the satellites keep working. :-)


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 23:31:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/9/2026 11:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the >>>>>>>>
    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike worldline: >>>> -a>
    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions with
    EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Maciej,

    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Nope.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.



    Let's take GPS clocks, for instance.

    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the nominal GPS frequency.

    WHY?


    Because nobody cares for your "proper time"
    and measuring it would be utter idiocy.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 22:51:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the >>>>>>>>>
    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike worldline: >>>>> -a>
    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions with
    EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Maciej,

    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Nope.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.



    Let's take GPS clocks, for instance.

    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the
    nominal GPS frequency.

    WHY?


    Because nobody cares for your "proper time"
    and measuring it would be utter idiocy.

    Nobody cares about proper time, Maciej? Really?

    GPS engineers, physicists and metrologists might disagree.

    But perhaps it's time to get some sleep in your hospital room.

    The night nurse will be along shortly to change your sheets again.

    https://ibb.co/Nd8rqxhp

    Sweet dreams, honey. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris M. Thomasson@chris.m.thomasson.1@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 9 17:53:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/9/2026 2:51 PM, Python wrote:
    [...]

    You are a nice person. Can roll with the likes of PO? Well done.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 07:04:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/9/2026 11:51 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-)

    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching >>>>>>>>>>> the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike worldline: >>>>>> -a>
    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions with
    EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Maciej,

    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Nope.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.



    Let's take GPS clocks, for instance.

    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the
    nominal GPS frequency.

    WHY?


    Because nobody cares for your "proper time"
    and measuring it would be utter idiocy.

    Nobody cares about proper time, Maciej? Really?

    Except some brainwashed religious idiots like
    yourself. You're not important.



    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 10:52:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 10/11/2026 |a 07:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:51 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-) >>>>>>>>>>>>
    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching >>>>>>>>>>>> the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike worldline: >>>>>>> -a>
    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions with >>>>>> EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Maciej,

    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Nope.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.



    Let's take GPS clocks, for instance.

    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the >>>> nominal GPS frequency.

    WHY?


    Because nobody cares for your "proper time"
    and measuring it would be utter idiocy.

    Nobody cares about proper time, Maciej? Really?

    Except some brainwashed religious idiots like
    yourself. You're not important.



    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.
    Maciej,

    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.

    Oh, really?

    GPS engineers compensate for the difference between proper time and GPS coordinate time.

    They calculate the correction, implement it in their hardware and
    software, and maintain an operational navigation system.

    But apparently, they don't care about proper time.

    Perhaps they just add relativistic corrections for religious reasons?

    What a magnificent engineering conspiracy! :-)

    Meanwhile, still no numerical prediction from you.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 11:57:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/10/2026 11:52 AM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 07:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:51 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :

    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-) >>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE >>>>>>>>>>>>> launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike
    worldline:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions
    with EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Maciej,

    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Nope.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.



    Let's take GPS clocks, for instance.

    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to
    the nominal GPS frequency.

    WHY?


    Because nobody cares for your "proper time"
    and measuring it would be utter idiocy.

    Nobody cares about proper time, Maciej? Really?

    Except some brainwashed religious idiots like
    yourself. You're not important.



    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.
    Maciej,

    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.

    Oh, really?

    Python,
    what are they clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time?
    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time?
    The same applies to metrologists.

    It was easy to give it a bombastic name,
    but a bombastic name was not enough to
    make it important.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 11:00:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 10/11/2026 |a 11:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 11:52 AM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 07:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:51 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE >>>>>>>>>>>>>> launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike >>>>>>>>> worldline:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing!

    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones.

    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions >>>>>>>> with EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Maciej,

    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Nope.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.



    Let's take GPS clocks, for instance.

    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is >>>>>> deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to >>>>>> the nominal GPS frequency.

    WHY?


    Because nobody cares for your "proper time"
    and measuring it would be utter idiocy.

    Nobody cares about proper time, Maciej? Really?

    Except some brainwashed religious idiots like
    yourself. You're not important.



    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.
    Maciej,

    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.

    Oh, really?

    Python,
    what are they clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time?
    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time?
    The same applies to metrologists.

    It was easy to give it a bombastic name,
    but a bombastic name was not enough to
    make it important.

    Right, Maciej.

    The name is not important.

    The numerical values are.

    You know, your old nemesis:

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Still waiting for YOUR prediction.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 12:27:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/10/2026 12:00 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 11:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 11:52 AM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 07:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:51 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 11:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 23:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 22:37, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/9/2026 10:13 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 09/11/2026 |a 20:57, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Predicted that - the clocks which are running
    in accordance with its formulas will run in
    accordance with its formulas!!!

    Oh, it is so ingenious...

    https://ibb.co/3mjpSK1D

    See? You're not that ugly. Well, not on all aspects :-) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Maciej,

    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> launching the

    Python, poor piece of shit,
    so, the idiot's prophecies were not
    intending to describe ANY clock, nonononono!
    Just some of them.
    Which ones?
    Oh, you've said already. The ones measuring
    "proper time".
    How is your "proper time" idiocy defined?

    Read previous posts mate,-a or any textbook :-)


    It is defined as the time fitting those
    idiot's formulas.

    No it is not defined this way. Check by yourself.

    Why not, poor piece of shit.

    On 11/7/2026 12:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    You ask me to define proper time. Gladly.

    In special relativity, for a clock following a timelike >>>>>>>>>> worldline:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau) = dt * sqrt(1 - v^2/c^2)

    More generally, in GR:

    -a-a-a-a d(tau)^2 = -g_mu_nu dx^mu dx^nu / c^2

    using the (-,+,+,+) metric signature.


    The prophecy you're worshiping is: the
    clocks which are running in accordance
    with idiot's formulas will run in accordance
    with idiot's formulas.
    Do you think it was hard to predict something
    like that, poor piece of shit?

    Oh dear, Maciej.

    A theory's equations agree with themselves. How astonishing! >>>>>>>>>
    That's true of EVERY theory, including completely wrong ones. >>>>>>>>>
    https://ibb.co/WWQNZ019

    The interesting part begins when you confront its predictions >>>>>>>>> with EXPERIMENTS.

    For The Shit it is: while some clocks (the
    ones fitting its idiocies) indeed fit its idiocies -
    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Maciej,

    the serious ones made for serious measurements
    keep measuring t'=t, just like they always did.

    Nope.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.



    Let's take GPS clocks, for instance.

    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is >>>>>>> deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to >>>>>>> the nominal GPS frequency.

    WHY?


    Because nobody cares for your "proper time"
    and measuring it would be utter idiocy.

    Nobody cares about proper time, Maciej? Really?

    Except some brainwashed religious idiots like
    yourself. You're not important.



    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.
    Maciej,

    GPS engineers

    No, trash. It's just you and your fellow idiots.

    Oh, really?

    Python,
    what are they clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time?
    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time?
    The same applies to metrologists.

    It was easy to give it a bombastic name,
    but a bombastic name was not enough to
    make it important.

    Right, Maciej.

    The name is not important.

    If it wasn't you wouldn't get
    brainwashed so easily.

    So, what are their clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time? No
    answer, poor piece of shit? Of course.

    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time? No answer,
    poor piece of shit? Of course.

    It was easy to give it a bombastic name,
    but a bombastic name was not enough to
    make it important.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 11:46:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 10/11/2026 |a 12:27, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    So, what are their clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time? No
    answer, poor piece of shit? Of course.

    This doesn't parse Maciej.

    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time? No answer,
    poor piece of shit? Of course.

    Both are important, Maciej.

    GPS engineers need to calculate the difference between proper time and GPS coordinate time in order to adjust their clocks to the latter.

    But... did you notice how you snipped, for the umpteenth time, the part
    about the NUMERICAL VALUE?

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Your nemesis.

    You keep arguing about words while desperately avoiding numbers.

    Some engineer you are!
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 13:47:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 12:27, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    So, what are their clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time? No
    answer, poor piece of shit? Of course.

    This doesn't parse Maciej.

    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time?-a No answer,
    poor piece of shit? Of course.

    Both are important, Maciej.

    Wrong like always, poor piece of shit.

    It was easy to give it a bombastic name,
    but a bombastic name was not enough to
    make it important.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 13:53:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:


    But... did you notice how you snipped, for the umpteenth time, the part about the NUMERICAL VALUE?

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Your nemesis.

    Maybe I should draw a picture with a
    drunken, shitty idiot screaming "NEMESSIS!!!
    38us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!THEY DELIBERATELY!!!
    CONSPIRACY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!". I'm sure you would
    like it.
    There is no 38us, however. The measured
    numbers are: 2026-11-07 16:00:00.000000000
    on one clock->2026-11-07 16:00:00.000000000
    on the other.
    Common sense had been warning the idiot.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 13:00:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 10/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:


    But... did you notice how you snipped, for the umpteenth time, the part
    about the NUMERICAL VALUE?

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Your nemesis.

    Maybe I should draw a picture with a
    drunken, shitty idiot screaming "NEMESSIS!!!
    38us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!THEY DELIBERATELY!!!
    CONSPIRACY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!". I'm sure you would
    like it.


    There is no 38us, however. The measured

    There are 38us, measured and..

    numbers are: 2026-11-07 16:00:00.000000000
    on one clock->2026-11-07 16:00:00.000000000
    on the other.

    without these 38us this would be what is displayed.

    Common sense had been warning the idiot.

    What you call "common sense" is not common and is not sense : it is a
    cult.

    https://ibb.co/rG3X7tLc




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 13:00:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 10/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:


    But... did you notice how you snipped, for the umpteenth time, the part
    about the NUMERICAL VALUE?

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Your nemesis.

    Maybe I should draw a picture with a
    drunken, shitty idiot screaming "NEMESSIS!!!
    38us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!THEY DELIBERATELY!!!
    CONSPIRACY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!". I'm sure you would
    like it.


    There is no 38us, however. The measured

    There are 38us, measured and..

    numbers are: 2026-11-07 16:00:00.000000000
    on one clock->2026-11-07 16:00:00.000000000
    on the other.

    without these 38us this would NOT be what is displayed.

    Common sense had been warning the idiot.

    What you call "common sense" is not common and is not sense : it is a
    cult.

    https://ibb.co/rG3X7tLc




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 13:06:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 10/11/2026 |a 13:47, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 12:27, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    So, what are their clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time? No
    answer, poor piece of shit? Of course.

    This doesn't parse Maciej.

    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time?-a No answer,
    poor piece of shit? Of course.

    Both are important, Maciej.

    Wrong like always, poor piece of shit.

    It was easy to give it a bombastic name,
    but a bombastic name was not enough to
    make it important.

    Again, Maciej: the name is not important.

    And "proper" is hardly a bombastic word. It certainly isn't a synonym for "perfect", as any dictionary could teach you.

    But sure, in your religion, in order to compute

    b = a +/- d

    the values of a and d are of no importance.

    Only the sacred label attached to b matters.

    Praise REAL TIME!

    Give us a break, idiot.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 14:09:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/10/2026 2:00 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:


    But... did you notice how you snipped, for the umpteenth time, the
    part about the NUMERICAL VALUE?

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Your nemesis.

    Maybe I should draw a picture with a
    drunken, shitty idiot screaming "NEMESSIS!!!
    38us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!THEY DELIBERATELY!!!
    CONSPIRACY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!". I'm sure you would
    like it.


    There is no 38us, however. The measured

    There are 38us, measured and..

    Nope, poor piece of shit. There WERE.
    50 years ago. Vanished with using the
    correct(ed) clocks.

    If your moronic religion succeeded
    with enforcing its wannabe standard,
    with brainwashing GPS engineers to
    feel your idiocy is something incredibly
    important and with some other things -
    it would win. But it's too idiotic to
    brainwash anyone having any contact with
    the reality. It can only brainwash those
    like you.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 14:11:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/10/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 13:47, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 12:27, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    So, what are their clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time? No
    answer, poor piece of shit? Of course.

    This doesn't parse Maciej.

    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time?-a No answer,
    poor piece of shit? Of course.

    Both are important, Maciej.

    Wrong like always, poor piece of shit.

    It was easy to give it a bombastic name,
    but a bombastic name was not enough to
    make it important.

    Again, Maciej: the name is not important.

    So why won't you call your "proper time"
    "the idiot's delusion" together with me,
    poor piece of shit?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 15:29:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 10/11/2026 |a 14:09, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 2:00 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:


    But... did you notice how you snipped, for the umpteenth time, the
    part about the NUMERICAL VALUE?

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Your nemesis.

    Maybe I should draw a picture with a
    drunken, shitty idiot screaming "NEMESSIS!!!
    38us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!THEY DELIBERATELY!!!
    CONSPIRACY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!". I'm sure you would
    like it.


    There is no 38us, however. The measured

    There are 38us, measured and..

    Nope, poor piece of shit. There WERE.
    50 years ago. Vanished with using the
    correct(ed) clocks.

    If your moronic religion succeeded
    with enforcing its wannabe standard,
    with brainwashing GPS engineers to
    feel your idiocy is something incredibly
    important and with some other things -
    it would win. But it's too idiotic to
    brainwash anyone having any contact with
    the reality. It can only brainwash those
    like you.

    Maciej,

    Nope, poor piece of shit. There WERE.
    50 years ago. Vanished with using the
    correct(ed) clocks.

    OH!

    You acknowledge that the difference was measured.

    And that it vanished when the clocks were corrected.

    And how much was that correction?

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    And which theory predicted that value BEFORE the measurement?

    Relativity.

    Maciej, you have just described a successful experimental confirmation of relativity.

    And you think you have refuted it.

    This is absolutely hilarious.

    By your logic, wearing glasses proves that myopia does not exist.

    After all, the blurred vision VANISHED when you put them on!

    Praise REAL TIME!
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 15:31:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 10/11/2026 |a 14:11, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 13:47, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 12:27, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    So, what are their clocks adjusted to -
    your idiocy or the real time? No
    answer, poor piece of shit? Of course.

    This doesn't parse Maciej.

    What is important for them - your
    idiocy or the real time?-a No answer,
    poor piece of shit? Of course.

    Both are important, Maciej.

    Wrong like always, poor piece of shit.

    It was easy to give it a bombastic name,
    but a bombastic name was not enough to
    make it important.

    Again, Maciej: the name is not important.

    So why won't you call your "proper time"
    "the idiot's delusion" together with me,
    poor piece of shit?

    Because I prefer the more meaningful name "proper time".

    Although "what drives a ranting Polish crank absolutely mad" would also be quite appropriate.

    A bit long for a physics textbook, though. :-)


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Tue Nov 10 18:53:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/10/2026 4:29 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 14:09, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 2:00 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 10/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/10/2026 12:46 PM, Python wrote:


    But... did you notice how you snipped, for the umpteenth time, the
    part about the NUMERICAL VALUE?

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Your nemesis.

    Maybe I should draw a picture with a
    drunken, shitty idiot screaming "NEMESSIS!!!
    38us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!THEY DELIBERATELY!!!
    CONSPIRACY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!". I'm sure you would
    like it.


    There is no 38us, however. The measured

    There are 38us, measured and..

    Nope, poor piece of shit. There WERE.
    50 years ago. Vanished with using the
    correct(ed) clocks.

    If your moronic religion succeeded
    with enforcing its wannabe standard,
    with brainwashing GPS-a engineers to
    feel your idiocy is something incredibly
    important and-a with some other things -
    it would win. But it's too idiotic to
    brainwash anyone having any contact with
    the reality. It can only brainwash those
    like you.

    Maciej,

    Nope, poor piece of shit. There WERE.
    50 years ago. Vanished with using the
    correct(ed) clocks.

    OH!

    You acknowledge that the difference was measured.

    And that it vanished when the clocks were corrected.

    And how much was that correction?

    Not predicted by The Shit 0 at all.


    And which theory predicted that value BEFORE the measurement?

    Relativity.

    That's of course a lie. Your moronic
    Shit has predicted no correction and
    a measured difference in indications.
    Too bad for it.


    Again, Maciej: the name is not important.

    So why won't you call your "proper time"
    "the idiot's delusion" together with me,
    poor piece of shit?

    Because I prefer the more meaningful name "proper time".

    Unfortunately, you're mistaken about
    which name is more meaningful, because
    you're an ignorant idiot knowing nothing
    about the word meanings. Same as you
    are mistaken that it is not important.

    You can be mistaken, can't you, poor
    piece of shit?






    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 02:04:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    That's of course a lie. Your moronic Shit has
    predicted no correction and a measured
    difference in indications.

    No, Maciej. The liar here is YOU.

    Relativity predicted a difference in clock rates.

    The engineers calculated the numerical value of that difference BEFORE the experiment.

    The difference was measured.

    The engineers compensated for it.

    And the correction worked.

    You even acknowledged it yourself:

    There WERE. 50 years ago. Vanished with using
    the correct(ed) clocks.

    So let me get this straight.

    Relativity predicts a difference of approximately 38.5 microseconds per
    day.

    The difference is measured.

    The engineers apply a correction of approximately 38.5 microseconds per
    day.

    The difference disappears.

    And according to the greatest Polish logician of all time, this REFUTES relativity because the corrected clocks no longer exhibit the difference
    that the correction was specifically designed to eliminate!

    Absolutely brilliant.

    By the same reasoning, if a physician predicts that a patient will die
    without treatment, administers the treatment, and the patient survives,
    the physician's prediction was false.

    Perhaps you should revolutionize medicine next. :-)

    You can be mistaken, can't you, poor
    piece of shit?

    Of course I can, Maciej.

    That's precisely why I check equations, numerical predictions and
    experimental results.

    You, on the other hand, simply declare yourself right, call everyone else
    a liar, and run away whenever a number appears.

    38.5.

    Still there, sweetheart. :-)

    And still no prediction from YOU.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 03:07:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the satellites.

    Applied it.

    And it worked.

    What a devastating failure for relativity!

    It did NOT happen this way.

    Instead, it was tested first. In the design of the NAVSTAR GPS NTS-2
    test satellite (Navigation System with Time and Ranging, Global
    Positioning System, Navigation Technology Satellite 2), the GPS
    _engineers_ considered the possibility that general relativity would be correct: They included a frequency synthesizer for the clock's output
    that could be tuned to a range of frequencies that included the one that
    had been calculated using general relativity by a theoretical physicist,
    Neil Ashby.

    <https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Neil_Ashby&oldid=1309863161>

    <https://web.archive.org/web/20251206154234/https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA058591.pdf>

    | NRL Report 8232
    |
    | Initial Results of the
    | NAVSTAR GPS NTS-2 Satellite
    |
    | Roger L. Easton, James A. Buisson, and Thomas B. McCaskill
    |
    | Space Applications Branch
    | Space Systems Division
    |
    | May 25, 1978
    |
    | NAVAL RESEARCH LABORATORY
    | Washington, D.C.
    |
    | Approved for public release; distribudon unlimited.
    |
    | [...]
    |
    | FREQUENCY DETERMINATION [beginning at the bottom of page 10]
    |
    | GPS requirements for the NTS-2 mission called for cesium-controlled
    | frequency operation after full power was available, following
    | solar-panel deployment. The first FTS cesium standard to be used,
    | designated as PRO-5, was locked up (Fig. 14) on the first attempt on
    | day 190, 1977, at 1418 UTC following a VCXO frequency tune to bring
    | the PRO-5 quartz oscillator frequency close to the cesium resonance
    | frequency.

    NTS-2 was operating like that for ca. 25 days, from "day 190, 1977"
    (according to my calculations-|, 1977-07-08 UTC) to "day 215, 1977"
    (1977-08-02 UTC). When the satellite clock and the ground clocks were
    compared afterwards via the satellite's signal, it was found that from
    the ground the satellite clock appeared to be ahead almost precisely by
    the amount predicted by general relativity; i.e. in its orbit it had
    measured more elapsed proper time than on the ground:

    | Figure 14 presents the values of the theoretical range minus the
    | observed range (T reA O) [131], which are calculated from measurements
    | collected at a 1-minute interval from the Panama site. These (T reA O)
    | values yield a measure of the spacecraft clock offset with respect to
    | the Panama clock. Knowledge of the station clock offset with respect
    | to the USNO master clock (MC) permits the spacecraft to be referenced
    | to USNO. Figure 15 presents a plot of (T reA O) values [13] from Panama
    | over a 6-day span. The (T reA O) slope gives the frequency offset of
    | +442.5 pp 10-|-# with respect to the Panama clock. Inclusion of the
    | Panama frequency offset of +0.6 pp 10-|-# produces an NTS measured
    | value of +443.1 pp 10-|-#. Comparison of this value to the predicted
    | value of the relativistic offset of +445.0 pp 10-|-# gives a difference
    | of reA1.9 pp 10-|-#.

    "pp" means "parts per". These figures mean fractions of the standard
    day, 86400 s. Therefore, "+443.1 pp 10-|-#" means

    +443.1 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree +38.28 ++s,

    "+445.0 pp 10-|-#" means

    +445.0 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree +38.45 ++s,

    and "reA1.9 pp 10-|-#" means

    reA1.9 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree reA164.16 ns.

    That is by how much the measured elapsed proper time differed from the
    elapsed proper time that was calculated using general relativity.
    So this difference is /tiny/, well within rounding and measurement
    error; it /strongly/ confirms general relativity.

    [According to my (GR) calculations-#, a clock in a circular orbit at an altitude above the terrestrial surface of 20000 km (approximate GPS
    orbital altitude) should be ahead of a ground clock at a latitude of
    38.9217-# N (where the USNO is) by ca. 38.4-a++s/d, provided that both
    orbit in the same direction.]

    The clock's output was then tuned accordingly, and after some further
    minor adjustments the satellite clock appeared (from the ground) to be
    in sync with the ground clocks again:

    | On day 215, 1977, the NTS-2 PRO-S output signal was offset (Fig. 16)
    | through the use of a frequency synthesizer [4].
    | Closer frequency synchronization to the UTC rate is obtainable by use
    | of cesium C-field tuning, which provides a resolution of 1.3 pp 10-|-|.
    | Before the C-field tune was applied, the NTS-2 frequency offset was
    | redetermined using the NRL Chesapeake Bay Division (CBD) station.
    | Figure 17 presents a plot of UTC(USNO MC No. 1) minus UTC(CBD), where
    | CBD denotes the clock used for the CBD receiver. The slope of this
    | line yields a frequency offset of 18.0 pp 10-|-|. Figure 18 represents
    | plot of NTS reA CBD; a frequency offset of 10.1 pp 10-|-| was measured.
    | Combining these results (Table 5) produced a frequency offset of +7.9
    | pp 10-|-|. On day 287, 1977 (14 Oct.), a C-field tune of six bits was
    | applied. Figure 19 is a plot of the (T reA O) values after the C-field
    | tune; a resultant frequency of reA6.6 pp 10-|-| was measured. The net
    | measured change was (reA10.1 reA (reA24.6)) pp 10-|-|, or 14.5 pp 10-|-|, which
    | exceeded the expected value of 7.8 pp 10-|-| by 6.7 pp 10-|-|. Table 6
    | presents the preliminary results of the C-field tune, the cause of the
    | small differences are being investigated. A frequency history of NTS-2
    | since launch is presented by Fig. 20; a split logarithmic scale is
    | used so that positive and negative values of frequency offset with
    | respect to UTC(USNO) may be included over a large range.

    After that, IIUC, for some time the atomic clocks of GPS satellites were adjusted on the ground, before they were put on the satellites on the
    rockets, to account for the discrepancy.

    But today the satellite clocks are not modified anymore, and the sending frequency is adjusted instead, compensating the "gravitational"
    blueshift, so that from the ground it appears to be the frequency that
    would be expected without relativistic effects. Also, because the orbit
    of one GPS satellite is different from that of all the others (different direction and/or altitude), and its orbit changes, too, a correction
    value that is updated as necessary is included in the signal payload (astronomical observatories worldwide work together to determine the satellites' ephemerides daily; those are also included in the GPS
    payload now). As Ashby wrote in his 2003 article on the subject:

    Ashby, N. "Relativity in the Global Positioning System." In: "Living
    Rev. Relativ." 6, 1 (2003). <https://doi.org/10.12942/lrr-2003-1>

    ___
    -| I did this using the JavaScript Console of the Chromium DevTools in
    Microsoft Edge:

    new Date(new Date(1977, 0, 1).setDate(d)).toUTCString()

    where d is the day number.

    -# 86400 s |u [reU(1 reA 3 G Mreo[c-# (R + 20000 km)])
    reA reU(1 reA 2 G Mreo[c-# R] reA [2-C R cos(38.9217reo360 |u 2-C)reoT]-#reoc-#)],

    where M ree 5.974 |u 10-#rU| kg is the mass of Terra, R ree 6371 km is her
    mean radius, and T ree 23.934472 h is her mean rotation period.

    See also:


    <https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=86400+s+*+%28sqrt%281+-+3+G+*+Earth+mass%2F%28c%5E2+*+%28Earth+radius+%2B+20000+km%29%29%29+-+sqrt%281+-+2+*+G+*+Earth+mass%2F%28c%5E2+*+Earth+radius%29+-+%282+*+pi+*+Earth+radius+*+cos%2838.9217%2F360+*+2pi%29%2F%2823.934472+h%29%29%5E2%2Fc%5E2%29%29>
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 02:14:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:07, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the
    satellites.

    Applied it.

    And it worked.

    What a devastating failure for relativity!

    It did NOT happen this way.

    Instead, it was tested first. In the design of the NAVSTAR GPS NTS-2
    test satellite (Navigation System with Time and Ranging, Global
    Positioning System, Navigation Technology Satellite 2), the GPS
    _engineers_ considered the possibility that general relativity would be correct: They included a frequency synthesizer for the clock's output
    that could be tuned to a range of frequencies that included the one that
    had been calculated using general relativity by a theoretical physicist,
    Neil Ashby.

    <https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Neil_Ashby&oldid=1309863161>


    <https://web.archive.org/web/20251206154234/https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA058591.pdf>

    | NRL Report 8232
    |
    | Initial Results of the
    | NAVSTAR GPS NTS-2 Satellite
    |
    | Roger L. Easton, James A. Buisson, and Thomas B. McCaskill
    |
    | Space Applications Branch
    | Space Systems Division
    |
    | May 25, 1978
    |
    | NAVAL RESEARCH LABORATORY
    | Washington, D.C.
    |
    | Approved for public release; distribudon unlimited.
    |
    | [...]
    |
    | FREQUENCY DETERMINATION [beginning at the bottom of page 10]
    |
    | GPS requirements for the NTS-2 mission called for cesium-controlled
    | frequency operation after full power was available, following
    | solar-panel deployment. The first FTS cesium standard to be used,
    | designated as PRO-5, was locked up (Fig. 14) on the first attempt on
    | day 190, 1977, at 1418 UTC following a VCXO frequency tune to bring
    | the PRO-5 quartz oscillator frequency close to the cesium resonance
    | frequency.

    NTS-2 was operating like that for ca. 25 days, from "day 190, 1977" (according to my calculations-|, 1977-07-08 UTC) to "day 215, 1977" (1977-08-02 UTC). When the satellite clock and the ground clocks were compared afterwards via the satellite's signal, it was found that from
    the ground the satellite clock appeared to be ahead almost precisely by
    the amount predicted by general relativity; i.e. in its orbit it had
    measured more elapsed proper time than on the ground:

    | Figure 14 presents the values of the theoretical range minus the
    | observed range (T reA O) [131], which are calculated from measurements
    | collected at a 1-minute interval from the Panama site. These (T reA O)
    | values yield a measure of the spacecraft clock offset with respect to
    | the Panama clock. Knowledge of the station clock offset with respect
    | to the USNO master clock (MC) permits the spacecraft to be referenced
    | to USNO. Figure 15 presents a plot of (T reA O) values [13] from Panama
    | over a 6-day span. The (T reA O) slope gives the frequency offset of
    | +442.5 pp 10-|-# with respect to the Panama clock. Inclusion of the
    | Panama frequency offset of +0.6 pp 10-|-# produces an NTS measured
    | value of +443.1 pp 10-|-#. Comparison of this value to the predicted
    | value of the relativistic offset of +445.0 pp 10-|-# gives a difference
    | of reA1.9 pp 10-|-#.

    "pp" means "parts per". These figures mean fractions of the standard
    day, 86400 s. Therefore, "+443.1 pp 10-|-#" means

    +443.1 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree +38.28 ++s,

    "+445.0 pp 10-|-#" means

    +445.0 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree +38.45 ++s,

    and "reA1.9 pp 10-|-#" means

    reA1.9 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree reA164.16 ns.

    That is by how much the measured elapsed proper time differed from the elapsed proper time that was calculated using general relativity.
    So this difference is /tiny/, well within rounding and measurement
    error; it /strongly/ confirms general relativity.

    [According to my (GR) calculations-#, a clock in a circular orbit at an altitude above the terrestrial surface of 20000 km (approximate GPS
    orbital altitude) should be ahead of a ground clock at a latitude of 38.9217-# N (where the USNO is) by ca. 38.4-a++s/d, provided that both
    orbit in the same direction.]

    The clock's output was then tuned accordingly, and after some further
    minor adjustments the satellite clock appeared (from the ground) to be
    in sync with the ground clocks again:

    | On day 215, 1977, the NTS-2 PRO-S output signal was offset (Fig. 16)
    | through the use of a frequency synthesizer [4].
    | Closer frequency synchronization to the UTC rate is obtainable by use
    | of cesium C-field tuning, which provides a resolution of 1.3 pp 10-|-|.
    | Before the C-field tune was applied, the NTS-2 frequency offset was
    | redetermined using the NRL Chesapeake Bay Division (CBD) station.
    | Figure 17 presents a plot of UTC(USNO MC No. 1) minus UTC(CBD), where
    | CBD denotes the clock used for the CBD receiver. The slope of this
    | line yields a frequency offset of 18.0 pp 10-|-|. Figure 18 represents
    | plot of NTS reA CBD; a frequency offset of 10.1 pp 10-|-| was measured.
    | Combining these results (Table 5) produced a frequency offset of +7.9
    | pp 10-|-|. On day 287, 1977 (14 Oct.), a C-field tune of six bits was
    | applied. Figure 19 is a plot of the (T reA O) values after the C-field
    | tune; a resultant frequency of reA6.6 pp 10-|-| was measured. The net
    | measured change was (reA10.1 reA (reA24.6)) pp 10-|-|, or 14.5 pp 10-|-|, which
    | exceeded the expected value of 7.8 pp 10-|-| by 6.7 pp 10-|-|. Table 6
    | presents the preliminary results of the C-field tune, the cause of the
    | small differences are being investigated. A frequency history of NTS-2
    | since launch is presented by Fig. 20; a split logarithmic scale is
    | used so that positive and negative values of frequency offset with
    | respect to UTC(USNO) may be included over a large range.

    After that, IIUC, for some time the atomic clocks of GPS satellites were adjusted on the ground, before they were put on the satellites on the rockets, to account for the discrepancy.

    But today the satellite clocks are not modified anymore, and the sending frequency is adjusted instead, compensating the "gravitational"
    blueshift, so that from the ground it appears to be the frequency that
    would be expected without relativistic effects. Also, because the orbit
    of one GPS satellite is different from that of all the others (different direction and/or altitude), and its orbit changes, too, a correction
    value that is updated as necessary is included in the signal payload (astronomical observatories worldwide work together to determine the satellites' ephemerides daily; those are also included in the GPS
    payload now). As Ashby wrote in his 2003 article on the subject:

    Ashby, N. "Relativity in the Global Positioning System." In: "Living
    Rev. Relativ." 6, 1 (2003). <https://doi.org/10.12942/lrr-2003-1>

    ___
    -| I did this using the JavaScript Console of the Chromium DevTools in
    Microsoft Edge:

    new Date(new Date(1977, 0, 1).setDate(d)).toUTCString()

    where d is the day number.

    -# 86400 s |u [reU(1 reA 3 G Mreo[c-# (R + 20000 km)])
    reA reU(1 reA 2 G Mreo[c-# R] reA [2-C R cos(38.9217reo360 |u 2-C)reoT]-#reoc-#)],

    where M ree 5.974 |u 10-#rU| kg is the mass of Terra, R ree 6371 km is her
    mean radius, and T ree 23.934472 h is her mean rotation period.

    See also:



    <https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=86400+s+*+%28sqrt%281+-+3+G+*+Earth+mass%2F%28c%5E2+*+%28Earth+radius+%2B+20000+km%29%29%29+-+sqrt%281+-+2+*+G+*+Earth+mass%2F%28c%5E2+*+Earth+radius%29+-+%282+*+pi+*+Earth+radius+*+cos%2838.9217%2F360+*+2pi%29%2F%2823.934472+h%29%29%5E2%2Fc%5E2%29%29>

    Thomas,

    Thank you for the correction and, especially, for the references.

    You're right: my description was too simplified, and historically
    inaccurate for NTS-2.

    The actual sequence is much more interesting:

    1. General relativity predicted a frequency offset.
    2. The engineers provided a means of applying the correction, but
    initially left it inactive.
    3. They measured the satellite clock's rate.
    4. The measured offset closely matched the relativistic prediction.
    5. They then applied the correction.

    I went through this with details in previous discussions with Wozniak, in
    this thread I somehow oversimplified it.

    According to the NRL report you cite:

    Predicted: +445.0 |u 10^-12
    Measured: +443.1 |u 10^-12

    That's approximately 38.45 versus 38.28 microseconds per day.

    An agreement within about 0.43% of the predicted effect.

    Neil Ashby's 2003 review gives a slightly different comparison, but
    reaches the same conclusion: an experimental verification at roughly the
    1% level.

    This is actually a MUCH stronger answer to Maciej's repeated claim that relativity merely predicts that clocks adjusted according to its formulas
    will agree with those formulas.

    In 1977, the correction was deliberately NOT applied during the initial measurement.

    The predicted effect appeared anyway.

    Only afterwards was the correction applied.

    So Maciej's argument that the 38 microseconds "vanished with using the correct(ed) clocks" spectacularly misses the point.

    The correction was not the evidence.

    The independently measured discrepancy, predicted beforehand, was the evidence.

    And the correction subsequently worked as intended.

    This historical detail makes the argument considerably more precise.

    I wonder how Maciej will manage to snip THIS one. No doubt he will anyway.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 03:16:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    [There is a proven and technically well-supported procedure to change
    the Subject header field value in a Usenet discussion; see my postings
    and especially this posting for examples. It is not necessary to keep ridiculous and meaningless titles.]

    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the
    GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 03:18:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    GPS engineers compensate for the difference between proper time and GPS coordinate time.

    No, they compensate for the difference between the elapsed proper time
    on the ground and aboard a GPS satellite.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 02:20:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:16, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    [There is a proven and technically well-supported procedure to change
    the Subject header field value in a Usenet discussion; see my postings
    and especially this posting for examples. It is not necessary to keep ridiculous and meaningless titles.]

    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the
    nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the
    GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.


    Thanks (sigh) again for the technical clarification.

    You're right that I should distinguish the atomic frequency standard, its synthesized clock output, and the transmitted radio signal.

    However, the implementation has evolved over time and may depend on the satellite and its clock technology.

    As Ashby explains in his 2003 review, the factory frequency offset was historically applied before launch, whereas for rubidium clocks it became common practice to measure their frequencies after launch and incorporate
    the necessary corrections into the broadcast clock parameters.

    So my statement was too general.

    The essential point remains unchanged: the required relativistic
    correction was calculated, experimentally verified, and incorporated into
    GPS operation.

    Whether that compensation is implemented through an oscillator adjustment,
    a frequency synthesizer, or broadcast clock parameters makes no difference
    to the underlying physics.

    And certainly doesn't make those 38.5 microseconds per day disappear from
    the laws of nature.

    By the way, Thomas, you're quite a pain in the neck sometimes. A
    remarkably well-documented pain in the neck, admittedly.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 02:21:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:18, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    GPS engineers compensate for the difference between proper time and GPS
    coordinate time.

    No, they compensate for the difference between the elapsed proper time
    on the ground and aboard a GPS satellite.


    You're becoming a real pain in the ass. A remarkably well-documented one,
    but still. :-)

    GPS coordinate time is defined to run at the rate of ideal clocks on the rotating geoid, with the appropriate coordinate conventions.

    So yes, the relativistic rate difference between a satellite clock and GPS coordinate time is closely related to the difference between the
    proper-time rates of satellite and ground clocks.

    My formulation was perfectly appropriate in the context of GPS clock corrections.

    And, incidentally, more precise than yours: proper times belong to
    worldlines, whereas GPS coordinate time provides the common time scale
    used by the system.

    At this rate, Thomas, you'll soon be correcting my punctuation while
    Maciej continues denying the existence of the 38.5 microseconds.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 03:22:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    GPS engineers compensate for the difference between proper time and GPS coordinate time.

    No, they compensate for the difference between the elapsed proper time
    on the ground and aboard a GPS satellite.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 02:24:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:22, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    GPS engineers compensate for the difference between proper time and GPS
    coordinate time.

    No, they compensate for the difference between the elapsed proper time
    on the ground and aboard a GPS satellite.

    *facepalm*
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 03:24:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    By the way, Thomas, you're quite a pain in the neck sometimes. A
    remarkably well-documented pain in the neck, admittedly.

    Thank you.

    Next time you want to remove the "(was: ...)" part of the Subject from
    your follow-up. This is easily done by using a proper newsreader such
    as Betterbird which does this automagically.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 02:26:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:24, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    By the way, Thomas, you're quite a pain in the neck sometimes. A
    remarkably well-documented pain in the neck, admittedly.

    Thank you.

    Next time you want to remove the "(was: ...)" part of the Subject from
    your follow-up. This is easily done by using a proper newsreader such
    as Betterbird which does this automagically.

    *facepalm* ^ 2

    I didn't remove anything in the subject, I answered to your very exact
    post.

    Give me a break, you are embarrassing yourself.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 03:39:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    Thank you for the correction and, especially, for the references.

    You are welcome. Please trim your quotes to the relevant minimum next
    time or summarize; it is not necessary to reproduce an entire posting's
    text.

    You're right: my description was too simplified, and historically
    inaccurate for NTS-2.

    The actual sequence is much more interesting:

    1. General relativity predicted a frequency offset.
    2. The engineers provided a means of applying the correction, but
    initially left it inactive.
    3. They measured the satellite clock's rate.

    No, that is not possible (and not what happens); as you can read there,
    the (unmodified) satellite's clock measured (elapsed proper) time.
    After some time (ca. 25 standard days) that was compared with the
    (elapsed proper) time that ground clocks of the same design had measured
    in the same coordinate time interval.

    4. The measured offset closely matched the relativistic prediction.

    The offset of the elapsed proper time, not any clock rates. Because
    different clock rates is not what actually happens; that conclusion is
    the result of a superficial analysis and/or careless wording.

    5. They then applied the correction.

    Yes.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 03:40:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:24, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    By the way, Thomas, you're quite a pain in the neck sometimes. A
    remarkably well-documented pain in the neck, admittedly.

    Thank you.

    Next time you want to remove the "(was: ...)" part of the Subject from
    your follow-up. This is easily done by using a proper newsreader such
    as Betterbird which does this automagically.

    *facepalm* ^ 2

    I didn't remove anything in the subject, [...]

    And that is the problem; you SHOULD have.

    F'up2 poster
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 02:41:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:40, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:24, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    By the way, Thomas, you're quite a pain in the neck sometimes. A
    remarkably well-documented pain in the neck, admittedly.

    Thank you.

    Next time you want to remove the "(was: ...)" part of the Subject from
    your follow-up. This is easily done by using a proper newsreader such
    as Betterbird which does this automagically.

    *facepalm* ^ 2

    I didn't remove anything in the subject, [...]

    And that is the problem; you SHOULD have.

    No.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 03:54:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:40, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:24, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    By the way, Thomas, you're quite a pain in the neck sometimes. A
    remarkably well-documented pain in the neck, admittedly.

    Thank you.

    Next time you want to remove the "(was: ...)" part of the Subject from >>>> your follow-up. This is easily done by using a proper newsreader such >>>> as Betterbird which does this automagically.

    *facepalm* ^ 2

    I didn't remove anything in the subject, [...]

    And that is the problem; you SHOULD have.

    No.

    Yes, because that was the point of my changing the Subject header field
    value in this way:

    <https://www.slack.net/~ant/usenet-posts.html#goodsubject> <https://www.slack.net/~ant/usenet-posts.html#topicdrift> <https://www.ou.edu/research/electron/internet/use-writ.htm> <https://acs.ist.psu.edu/misc/nottingham/papers/usenet-primer.html>
    etc.

    Also note that your ignoring the "Followup-To: poster" without giving a
    good reason is considered impolite, a disregard of Netiquette:

    <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc5536/#section-3.2.6>

    HTH
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 06:11:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
    ___
    -| I did this using the JavaScript Console of the Chromium DevTools in
    Microsoft Edge:

    new Date(new Date(1977, 0, 1).setDate(d)).toUTCString()

    where d is the day number.
    It should be noted that this works for me as my system is currently
    using UTC+1 as timezone, and it would work on all systems that are using UTC(+0).

    For better or worse, the Date constructor when given Number values as
    arguments assumes the date to be specified in the system timezone. One
    way to work around this is to write

    new Date('1977')

    instead of

    new Date(1977, 0, 1)

    which produces a date with 00:00 UTC as specified in ECMAScript 17th
    Edition (2026), -o-o 21.4.2.1, 21.4.3.2, and 21.4.1.32, regardless of the system's timezone.

    <https://262.ecma-international.org/17.0/index.html?_gl=1*1o11thf*_ga*MTYyOTEzODk5NC4xNzk0MzcyODIw*_ga_TDCK4DWEPP*czE3OTQzNzI4MjAkbzEkZzAkdDE3OTQzNzI4MjAkajYwJGwwJGgw#sec-date-constructor>
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 07:08:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 3:04 AM, Python wrote:
    That's of course a lie. Your moronic Shit has
    predicted no correction and a measured
    difference in indications.

    No, Maciej. The liar here is YOU.

    So your Shit didn't predict any difference
    in clock indications, right, poor piece of
    lying shit?


    There WERE. 50 years ago. Vanished with using
    the correct(ed) clocks.

    So let me get this straight.

    Relativity predicts a difference of approximately 38.5 microseconds per
    day.

    The difference is measured.

    Then we improve clocks and the delusion
    vanishes. Can't effects that not exist
    at all be measured by erroneous equipment?

    Of course, if The Shit was successful
    brainwasher, if it was able to persuade
    GPS engineers that its clocks are
    "perfectly good" and its nonsenses are
    incredibly important, same as it persuaded
    it to you - things could be different.
    But, of course, it had no chance. Common
    sense had been warning the idiot.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 07:13:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 3:14 AM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:07, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    Ingeneers calculated the required correction BEFORE launching the
    satellites.

    Applied it.

    And it worked.

    What a devastating failure for relativity!

    It did NOT happen this way.

    Instead, it was tested first.-a In the design of the NAVSTAR GPS NTS-2
    test satellite (Navigation System with Time and Ranging, Global
    Positioning System, Navigation Technology Satellite 2), the GPS
    _engineers_ considered the possibility that general relativity would be
    correct: They included a frequency synthesizer for the clock's output
    that could be tuned to a range of frequencies that included the one that
    had been calculated using general relativity by a theoretical physicist,
    Neil Ashby.

    <https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Neil_Ashby&oldid=1309863161>


    <https://web.archive.org/web/20251206154234/https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/
    tr/pdf/ADA058591.pdf>

    | NRL Report 8232
    |
    | Initial Results of the
    | NAVSTAR GPS NTS-2 Satellite
    |
    | Roger L. Easton, James A. Buisson, and Thomas B. McCaskill
    |
    | Space Applications Branch
    | Space Systems Division
    |
    | May 25, 1978
    |
    | NAVAL RESEARCH LABORATORY
    | Washington, D.C.
    |
    | Approved for public release; distribudon unlimited.
    |
    | [...]
    |
    | FREQUENCY DETERMINATION-a [beginning at the bottom of page 10]
    |
    | GPS requirements for the NTS-2 mission called for cesium-controlled
    | frequency operation after full power was available, following
    | solar-panel deployment. The first FTS cesium standard to be used,
    | designated as PRO-5, was locked up (Fig. 14) on the first attempt on
    | day 190, 1977, at 1418 UTC following a VCXO frequency tune to bring
    | the PRO-5 quartz oscillator frequency close to the cesium resonance
    | frequency.

    NTS-2 was operating like that for ca. 25 days, from "day 190, 1977"
    (according to my calculations-|, 1977-07-08 UTC) to "day 215, 1977"
    (1977-08-02 UTC).-a When the satellite clock and the ground clocks were
    compared afterwards via the satellite's signal, it was found that from
    the ground the satellite clock appeared to be ahead almost precisely by
    the amount predicted by general relativity; i.e. in its orbit it had
    measured more elapsed proper time than on the ground:

    | Figure 14 presents the values of the theoretical range minus the
    | observed range (T reA O) [131], which are calculated from measurements
    | collected at a 1-minute interval from the Panama site. These (T reA O)
    | values yield a measure of the spacecraft clock offset with respect to
    | the Panama clock. Knowledge of the station clock offset with respect
    | to the USNO master clock (MC) permits the spacecraft to be referenced
    | to USNO. Figure 15 presents a plot of (T reA O) values [13] from Panama
    | over a 6-day span. The (T reA O) slope gives the frequency offset of
    | +442.5 pp 10-|-# with respect to the Panama clock. Inclusion of the
    | Panama frequency offset of +0.6 pp 10-|-# produces an NTS measured
    | value of +443.1 pp 10-|-#. Comparison of this value to the predicted
    | value of the relativistic offset of +445.0 pp 10-|-# gives a difference
    | of reA1.9 pp 10-|-#.

    "pp" means "parts per".-a These figures mean fractions of the standard
    day, 86400 s.-a Therefore, "+443.1 pp 10-|-#" means

    -a +443.1 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree +38.28 ++s,

    "+445.0 pp 10-|-#" means

    -a +445.0 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree +38.45 ++s,

    and "reA1.9 pp 10-|-#" means

    -a reA1.9 |u 10rU+-|-# |u 86400 s ree reA164.16 ns.

    That is by how much the measured elapsed proper time differed from the
    elapsed proper time that was calculated using general relativity.
    So this difference is /tiny/, well within rounding and measurement
    error; it /strongly/ confirms general relativity.

    [According to my (GR) calculations-#, a clock in a circular orbit at an
    altitude above the terrestrial surface of 20000 km (approximate GPS
    orbital altitude) should be ahead of a ground clock at a latitude of
    38.9217-# N (where the USNO is) by ca. 38.4-a++s/d, provided that both
    orbit in the same direction.]

    The clock's output was then tuned accordingly, and after some further
    minor adjustments the satellite clock appeared (from the ground) to be
    in sync with the ground clocks again:

    | On day 215, 1977, the NTS-2 PRO-S output signal was offset (Fig. 16)
    | through the use of a frequency synthesizer [4].
    | Closer frequency synchronization to the UTC rate is obtainable by use
    | of cesium C-field tuning, which provides a resolution of 1.3 pp 10-|-|.
    | Before the C-field tune was applied, the NTS-2 frequency offset was
    | redetermined using the NRL Chesapeake Bay Division (CBD) station.
    | Figure 17 presents a plot of UTC(USNO MC No. 1) minus UTC(CBD), where
    | CBD denotes the clock used for the CBD receiver. The slope of this
    | line yields a frequency offset of 18.0 pp 10-|-|. Figure 18 represents
    | plot of NTS reA CBD; a frequency offset of 10.1 pp 10-|-| was measured.
    | Combining these results (Table 5) produced a frequency offset of +7.9
    | pp 10-|-|. On day 287, 1977 (14 Oct.), a C-field tune of six bits was
    | applied. Figure 19 is a plot of the (T reA O) values after the C-field
    | tune; a resultant frequency of reA6.6 pp 10-|-| was measured. The net
    | measured change was (reA10.1 reA (reA24.6)) pp 10-|-|, or 14.5 pp 10-|-|, which
    | exceeded the expected value of 7.8 pp 10-|-| by 6.7 pp 10-|-|. Table 6
    | presents the preliminary results of the C-field tune, the cause of the
    | small differences are being investigated. A frequency history of NTS-2
    | since launch is presented by Fig. 20; a split logarithmic scale is
    | used so that positive and negative values of frequency offset with
    | respect to UTC(USNO) may be included over a large range.

    After that, IIUC, for some time the atomic clocks of GPS satellites were
    adjusted on the ground, before they were put on the satellites on the
    rockets, to account for the discrepancy.

    But today the satellite clocks are not modified anymore, and the sending
    frequency is adjusted instead, compensating the "gravitational"
    blueshift, so that from the ground it appears to be the frequency that
    would be expected without relativistic effects.-a Also, because the orbit
    of one GPS satellite is different from that of all the others (different
    direction and/or altitude), and its orbit changes, too, a correction
    value that is updated as necessary is included in the signal payload
    (astronomical observatories worldwide work together to determine the
    satellites' ephemerides daily; those are also included in the GPS
    payload now).-a As Ashby wrote in his 2003 article on the subject:

    Ashby, N. "Relativity in the Global Positioning System." In: "Living
    Rev. Relativ." 6, 1 (2003). <https://doi.org/10.12942/lrr-2003-1>

    ___
    -|-a I did this using the JavaScript Console of the Chromium DevTools in
    -a-a Microsoft Edge:

    -a-a-a-a new Date(new Date(1977, 0, 1).setDate(d)).toUTCString()

    -a-a where d is the day number.

    -#-a 86400 s |u [reU(1 reA 3 G Mreo[c-# (R + 20000 km)])
    -a-a-a-a reA reU(1 reA 2 G Mreo[c-# R] reA [2-C R cos(38.9217reo360 |u 2-C)reoT]-#reoc-#)],

    -a-a where M ree 5.974 |u 10-#rU| kg is the mass of Terra, R ree 6371 km is her
    -a-a mean radius, and T ree 23.934472 h is her mean rotation period.

    -a-a See also:



    <https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=86400+s+*+%28sqrt%281+-
    +3+G+*+Earth+mass%2F%28c%5E2+*+%28Earth+radius+%2B+20000+km%29%29%29+-
    +sqrt%281+-+2+*+G+*+Earth+mass%2F%28c%5E2+*+Earth+radius%29+-+
    %282+*+pi+*+Earth+radius+*+cos%2838.9217%2F360+*+2pi%29%2F%2823.934472+h%29%29%5E2%2Fc%5E2%29%29>

    Thomas,

    Thank you for the correction and, especially, for the references.

    You're right: my description was too simplified, and historically
    inaccurate for NTS-2.

    Let's be straight, you're a piece of fanatic
    shit "improving" the history for the sake
    of your obviously just case.



    The actual sequence is much more interesting:

    1. General relativity predicted a frequency offset.

    How great!!! it's predicting that a clock indicating
    its proper time idiocy will indicate its proper time
    idiocy...
    But is it the only thing it predicts, poor piece of shit?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 07:18:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 3:20 AM, Python wrote:

    The essential point remains unchanged: the required relativistic
    correction was calculated,

    And that's a shitty lie, your mad religion
    is predicting no correction, oppositely
    it is asserting that the clocks are
    "perfectly good" without any. An
    assertion, of course, as baseless as
    it is idiotic.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 07:20:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 3:21 AM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:18, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    GPS engineers compensate for the difference between proper time and
    GPS coordinate time.

    No, they compensate for the difference between the elapsed proper time
    on the ground and aboard a GPS satellite.


    You're becoming a real pain in the ass. A remarkably well-documented
    one, but still. :-)

    GPS coordinate time is defined to run at the rate of ideal clocks on the rotating geoid, with the appropriate coordinate conventions.

    Yes, they go for the real time and your proper idiocy
    is not interesting them at all.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 09:15:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 6:11 AM, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
    ___
    -| I did this using the JavaScript Console of the Chromium DevTools in
    Microsoft Edge:

    new Date(new Date(1977, 0, 1).setDate(d)).toUTCString()

    where d is the day number.
    It should be noted that this works for me as my system is currently
    using UTC+1 as timezone, and it would work on all systems that are using UTC(+0).

    Of course, even such a brainwashed idiot as you
    are is not treating The Shit's "proper time"
    seriously and really apply the real time instead.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Emmett Balagula@mmml@bme.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Wed Nov 11 10:04:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    Python wrote:
    GPS engineers compensate for the difference between proper time and GPS
    coordinate time.

    No, they compensate for the difference between the elapsed proper time
    on the ground and aboard a GPS satellite.

    cretin, whatever you mean by "proper" that's not on the ground; fucking
    mental retarded half german inbreed
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 10:30:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 07:18, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 3:20 AM, Python wrote:

    The essential point remains unchanged: the required relativistic
    correction was calculated,

    And that's a shitty lie, your mad religion
    is predicting no correction, oppositely
    it is asserting that the clocks are
    "perfectly good" without any. An
    assertion, of course, as baseless as
    it is idiotic.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Maciej,

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You have linked Einstein's 1905 paper on SPECIAL relativity.

    1905.

    SPECIAL relativity.

    The gravitational contribution to GPS clock corrections comes from GENERAL relativity, developed in 1915.

    You are demanding that a 1905 paper contain the engineering specifications
    of a satellite navigation system developed some seventy years later.

    Why not complain that Newton's Principia doesn't contain the source code
    for a GPS receiver?

    But since you apparently need some help finding the relevant literature,
    here you go.

    1. Neil Ashby (2003)
    "Relativity in the Global Positioning System"
    Living Reviews in Relativity, 6, 1.

    https://doi.org/10.12942/lrr-2003-1

    See equations (34), (35) and (36).

    In particular, equation (35) gives the required fractional frequency offset:

    -4.4647 x 10^-10.

    Equation (36) gives the corresponding frequency:

    10.22999999543 MHz

    instead of the nominal 10.23 MHz.

    There you are.

    An actual numerical prediction.

    Derived from relativity.

    With an explicit engineering application.

    2. The official GPS interface specification:

    IS-GPS-200N, August 2022.

    https://archive.gps.gov/technical/icwg/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    It explicitly specifies the relativistic frequency offset:

    Delta f/f = -4.4647E-10.

    This is not a religious tract, Maciej.

    It is an engineering specification for GPS.

    3. For the experimental verification, see:

    Easton, Buisson and McCaskill (1978),
    NRL Report 8232,
    "Initial Results of the NAVSTAR GPS NTS-2 Satellite".

    The relativistic frequency offset was predicted BEFORE the measurement.

    Predicted: +445.0 x 10^-12
    Measured: +443.1 x 10^-12

    Agreement within approximately 0.43%.

    The correction was then applied.

    Now, Maciej, notice something rather important.

    You claimed that relativity predicts NO correction.

    Yet here is a published relativistic calculation of the correction.

    Here is the numerical value.

    Here is the official GPS specification incorporating that value.

    And here is an experimental measurement confirming the predicted effect.

    Your claim is simply FALSE.

    As for your suggestion that relativity asserts that clocks are "perfectly good" without corrections, you are confusing two entirely different
    things:

    An ideal clock correctly measuring its own proper time does NOT imply that
    it runs at the same rate as another clock following a different worldline.

    That difference is precisely what relativity predicts.

    And precisely what GPS engineers must account for.

    A perfectly good clock does not become defective merely because it
    measures a different elapsed proper time.

    This is elementary relativity, Maciej.

    You have been arguing about it for years, and you still haven't understood
    the distinction.

    So, to summarize:

    You searched a 1905 paper for a GPS correction involving general
    relativity.

    You failed to find it.

    And you concluded that the correction does not exist.

    Absolutely magnificent.

    Next time, try looking for the theory of plate tectonics in Aristotle.

    And remember your old nemesis:

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Predicted.

    Measured.

    Corrected.

    Still waiting for YOUR numerical prediction. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 11:41:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 11:30 AM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 07:18, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 3:20 AM, Python wrote:

    The essential point remains unchanged: the required relativistic
    correction was calculated,

    And that's a shitty lie, your mad religion
    is predicting no correction, oppositely
    it is asserting that the clocks are
    "perfectly good" without any. An
    assertion, of course, as baseless as
    it is idiotic.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Maciej,

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You have linked Einstein's 1905 paper on SPECIAL relativity.

    1905.

    SPECIAL relativity.

    And there is no prediction of any
    "clock correction" there, right,
    poor piece of shit?
    Neither there is in his GR shit.
    It's just a mad lie of some mad,
    brainwashed idiots.



    1. Neil Ashby (2003)
    -a "Relativity in the Global Positioning System"
    -a Living Reviews in Relativity, 6, 1.

    Of course - I know that NOW the idiot's
    doggies lie he predicted, nothing new
    about that, you provide enough of examples
    yourself.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 10:46:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    And there is no prediction of any
    "clock correction" there, right,
    poor piece of shit?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You are STILL confusing a clock's indication with its rate.

    Let me help.

    An indication is what a clock DISPLAYS.

    A rate is how fast that indication CHANGES.

    Two perfectly functioning clocks can have different rates when following different worldlines.

    That is precisely what relativity predicts.

    And when GPS engineers compensate for that difference, they are not
    repairing defective clocks.

    They are adjusting their outputs to follow a common coordinate time scale.

    An ideal clock measures its own proper time.

    It does NOT necessarily display GPS coordinate time.

    These are two different concepts.

    You have spent years confusing them.

    Neither there is in his GR shit.

    Really?

    General relativity predicts gravitational frequency shifts.

    Special relativity predicts kinematic time dilation.

    Combine them for a GPS satellite's orbit and you obtain a predicted
    fractional frequency difference of approximately:

    +4.4647 x 10^-10.

    That is approximately:

    +38.5 microseconds per day.

    To compensate, the corresponding nominal frequency offset has the opposite sign:

    -4.4647 x 10^-10.

    There is your correction.

    Calculated from relativity.

    Specified in GPS engineering documentation.

    And experimentally verified.

    The fact that Einstein did not personally write a GPS engineering manual
    in 1915 is not quite the devastating objection you imagine.

    Of course - I know that NOW the idiot's
    doggies lie he predicted

    NOW?

    Oh, Maciej, this is getting better and better.

    The NTS-2 experiment took place in 1977.

    The Naval Research Laboratory published its results in 1978.

    Predicted fractional frequency offset:

    +445.0 x 10^-12.

    Measured:

    +443.1 x 10^-12.

    The correction was applied AFTER the initial measurement.

    And now you want us to believe that the prediction was invented retrospectively?

    So let's reconstruct your conspiracy.

    First, Einstein invents a theory.

    Then, decades later, physicists secretly persuade cesium atoms to behave according to that theory.

    GPS engineers join the conspiracy.

    The Naval Research Laboratory joins the conspiracy.

    The satellite's clock obligingly produces the predicted frequency
    difference BEFORE the correction is applied.

    The engineers then correct the output.

    And, half a century later, everyone continues covering up the truth.

    Everyone, that is, except Maciej Wo+|niak.

    The one man brave enough to expose the Great Cesium Conspiracy.

    Unfortunately, there is one small problem.

    You still haven't produced a SINGLE numerical prediction of your own.

    Not one.

    You have produced insults.

    You have produced accusations of religious brainwashing.

    You have produced an elaborate conspiracy theory.

    But when asked to calculate the rate difference between a ground clock and
    a GPS satellite clock, you suddenly lose all interest in numbers.

    So here is the question again.

    BEFORE any compensation is applied, what fractional frequency difference
    does YOUR theory predict?

    Relativity predicts approximately:

    +4.4647 x 10^-10.

    The NTS-2 experiment measured a closely matching value.

    Your prediction is...?

    Come on, Maciej.

    Surely the man who uncovered a fifty-year conspiracy involving physicists, engineers and cesium atoms can manage one elementary numerical
    calculation.

    Or are the numbers themselves part of the conspiracy?

    Praise REAL TIME!

    And beware of those treacherous, Einstein-worshipping cesium atoms. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 10:50:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:54, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:40, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:24, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Python wrote:
    By the way, Thomas, you're quite a pain in the neck sometimes. A
    remarkably well-documented pain in the neck, admittedly.

    Thank you.

    Next time you want to remove the "(was: ...)" part of the Subject from >>>>> your follow-up. This is easily done by using a proper newsreader such >>>>> as Betterbird which does this automagically.

    *facepalm* ^ 2

    I didn't remove anything in the subject, [...]

    And that is the problem; you SHOULD have.

    No.

    Yes, because that was the point of my changing the Subject header field
    value in this way:

    <https://www.slack.net/~ant/usenet-posts.html#goodsubject> <https://www.slack.net/~ant/usenet-posts.html#topicdrift> <https://www.ou.edu/research/electron/internet/use-writ.htm> <https://acs.ist.psu.edu/misc/nottingham/papers/usenet-primer.html>
    etc.

    Also note that your ignoring the "Followup-To: poster" without giving a
    good reason is considered impolite, a disregard of Netiquette:

    <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc5536/#section-3.2.6>

    HTH

    Thomas,

    Yes, because that was the point of my changing
    the Subject header field value in this way:

    Ah, Thomas.

    Four references to explain why I should have edited a Subject header.

    FOUR.

    I must admit, your dedication to the finer points of Usenet bureaucracy is almost as impressive as your knowledge of GPS.

    Almost.

    But changing a Subject header is not an instruction that other
    participants are obliged to follow.

    And your preferred subject line does not become mandatory merely because
    you have documented the procedure.

    Also note that your ignoring the "Followup-To:
    poster" without giving a good reason is considered
    impolite, a disregard of Netiquette:

    "Followup-To: poster" expresses a preference for private replies.

    It is not a command.

    And I do have a reason for replying publicly: this is a public technical discussion, and the clarification is relevant to its participants.

    Now, Thomas, I genuinely appreciate your technical corrections.

    But we've reached the point where you're correcting my corrections of your corrections, complete with a bibliography on the proper correction of
    Subject headers.

    You really are a remarkably well-documented pain in the ass.

    I suspect that if I wished you a good morning, you'd provide three RFCs explaining why it should have been "Good morning," with a comma.

    HTH. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 11:52:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 11:46 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    And there is no prediction of any
    "clock correction" there, right,
    poor piece of shit?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You are STILL confusing a clock's indication with its rate.

    And there are STILL no correction predictions
    in that moronic Shit of your idiot guru. You're
    just lying, as expected from a piece of lying
    shit you are.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 11:02:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 11:52, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:46 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    And there is no prediction of any
    "clock correction" there, right,
    poor piece of shit?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You are STILL confusing a clock's indication with its rate.

    And there are STILL no correction predictions
    in that moronic Shit of your idiot guru. You're
    just lying, as expected from a piece of lying
    shit you are.

    https://ibb.co/HT3CqjBB
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 12:06:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 12:02 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 11:52, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:46 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    And there is no prediction of any
    "clock correction" there, right,
    poor piece of shit?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You are STILL confusing a clock's indication with its rate.

    And there are STILL no correction predictions
    in that moronic Shit of your idiot guru. You're
    just lying, as expected from a piece of lying
    shit you are.

    https://ibb.co/HT3CqjBB

    Back to ugly me. No surprise.
    But there is still no correction
    predictions in that mad Shit of
    your idiot guru, sorry, poor piece
    of shit.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 11:53:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    But there is still no correction
    predictions in that mad Shit of
    your idiot guru

    "No correction predictions"? ? ?

    WTF, Maciej?

    I've given you the formula, the numerical prediction, the experimental measurements, and the official GPS engineering specification.

    And your response is STILL "no correction predictions"?

    At this point, even the cesium atoms must be laughing. :-)

    Back to ugly me. No surprise.

    Oh, don't be so modest, Maciej!

    The comic is merely trying to capture all the inner beauty you've been displaying throughout this discussion.

    Your intellectual elegance, your exquisite vocabulary, your touching
    devotion to evidence, and above all, your extraordinary ability to make
    38.5 microseconds per day disappear simply by refusing to look at them.

    Unfortunately, six panels weren't nearly enough. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:27:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 12:53 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    But there is still no correction
    predictions in that mad Shit of
    your idiot guru

    "No correction predictions"? ? ?

    WTF, Maciej?

    I've given you the formula

    Just not a formula for any correction.


    Once again, poor piece of lying shit.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    Show me the formula described as "this is
    the formula for the clock correction".

    The idiot didn't predict any corrections,
    the idiot has imagined that it would be
    "perfectly good" if the clocks desynchronized
    - and your mad religion has been trying to
    enforce his mad visions.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 12:30:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Just not a formula for any correction.

    I GAVE YOU THE EXACT FORMULA TWO POSTS AGO!

    Neil Ashby (2003), equations (34)rCo(36):

    https://doi.org/10.12942/lrr-2003-1

    The calculated fractional frequency correction is:

    -4.4647 x 10^-10.

    The corresponding frequency is:

    10.22999999543 MHz

    instead of 10.23 MHz.

    And I also gave you the OFFICIAL GPS specification:

    https://archive.gps.gov/technical/icwg/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Which explicitly specifies the relativistic frequency offset.

    What more do you want, Maciej?

    A handwritten note from Einstein saying:

    "Dear Maciej, please find enclosed the GPS clock correction formula. Sorry
    I couldn't include it in my 1905 paper, but GPS hadn't been invented yet."

    Show me the formula described as "this is
    the formula for the clock correction".

    Ah, so now the numerical formula isn't enough.

    The experimental verification isn't enough.

    The official engineering specification isn't enough.

    You demand that Einstein himself use your exact preferred WORDS.

    We've gone from physics to a theological dispute over sacred wording.

    Again.

    You aren't looking for a formula, Maciej.

    You're looking for an excuse to ignore one.

    And the truly hilarious part is that you keep demanding the correction
    formula while refusing to acknowledge the numerical correction I've
    already supplied.

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    Still there.

    Still predicted.

    Still measured.

    Still compensated for.

    And still apparently invisible to you.

    Perhaps you need a correction yourself.

    Not to your clock.

    To your reading comprehension. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:34:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 1:30 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Just not a formula for any correction.

    I GAVE YOU THE EXACT FORMULA TWO POSTS AGO!

    Neil Ashby (2003), equations (34)rCo(36):

    That NOW your fellow idiots wave their arms
    and scream "The idiot has PREDICTED!!!
    PREDICTED EVERYTHING!!!!!" - I know. You provide
    enough of the examples yourself.
    It's just an obvious lie of mad worshipers.


    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    Where is it?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:34:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Le 11/11/2026 a 07:18, Maciej Wo?niak a ocrit :
    On 11/11/2026 3:20 AM, Python wrote:

    The essential point remains unchanged: the required relativistic
    correction was calculated,

    And that's a shitty lie, your mad religion
    is predicting no correction, oppositely
    it is asserting that the clocks are
    "perfectly good" without any. An
    assertion, of course, as baseless as
    it is idiotic.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Maciej,

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You have linked Einstein's 1905 paper on SPECIAL relativity.

    1905.

    SPECIAL relativity.

    The gravitational contribution to GPS clock corrections comes from GENERAL relativity, developed in 1915.

    You are demanding that a 1905 paper contain the engineering specifications
    of a satellite navigation system developed some seventy years later.

    Why not complain that Newton's Principia doesn't contain the source code
    for a GPS receiver?

    As a matter of historical fact Einstein 1905 does give the velocity part
    of the correction for an ideal balance type watch,
    for the special case of a sphericl Earth.
    So by extension, for a satellite in a circular orbit.
    Einstein 1915 does give the correct gravitational red shift,
    so by extension to all oscillators, hence clocks.

    The GPS blueprint copies and applies Einstein 1905 and 1915 directly.
    It was a truly incredible achievement,
    from nothing but pure thought, physical intuition,
    and a sense of beauty,

    Jan



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:36:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 1:34 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 07:18, Maciej Wo?niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 3:20 AM, Python wrote:

    The essential point remains unchanged: the required relativistic
    correction was calculated,

    And that's a shitty lie, your mad religion
    is predicting no correction, oppositely
    it is asserting that the clocks are
    "perfectly good" without any. An
    assertion, of course, as baseless as
    it is idiotic.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Maciej,

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You have linked Einstein's 1905 paper on SPECIAL relativity.

    1905.

    SPECIAL relativity.

    The gravitational contribution to GPS clock corrections comes from GENERAL >> relativity, developed in 1915.

    You are demanding that a 1905 paper contain the engineering specifications >> of a satellite navigation system developed some seventy years later.

    Why not complain that Newton's Principia doesn't contain the source code
    for a GPS receiver?

    As a matter of historical fact Einstein 1905 does give the velocity part

    As a matter of historical fact poor Loddie
    is impudently lying, as expected from
    a piece of relativistic shit.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 12:41:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 13:34, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 1:30 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Just not a formula for any correction.

    I GAVE YOU THE EXACT FORMULA TWO POSTS AGO!

    Neil Ashby (2003), equations (34)rCo(36):

    That NOW your fellow idiots wave their arms
    and scream "The idiot has PREDICTED!!!
    PREDICTED EVERYTHING!!!!!" - I know. You provide
    enough of the examples yourself.
    It's just an obvious lie of mad worshipers.


    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    Where is it?

    https://ibb.co/fVcG8CMw


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 12:44:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 13:36, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 1:34 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 07:18, Maciej Wo?niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 3:20 AM, Python wrote:

    The essential point remains unchanged: the required relativistic
    correction was calculated,

    And that's a shitty lie, your mad religion
    is predicting no correction, oppositely
    it is asserting that the clocks are
    "perfectly good" without any. An
    assertion, of course, as baseless as
    it is idiotic.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Maciej,

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You have linked Einstein's 1905 paper on SPECIAL relativity.

    1905.

    SPECIAL relativity.

    The gravitational contribution to GPS clock corrections comes from GENERAL >>> relativity, developed in 1915.

    You are demanding that a 1905 paper contain the engineering specifications >>> of a satellite navigation system developed some seventy years later.

    Why not complain that Newton's Principia doesn't contain the source code >>> for a GPS receiver?

    As a matter of historical fact Einstein 1905 does give the velocity part

    As a matter of historical fact poor Loddie
    is impudently lying, as expected from
    a piece of relativistic shit.

    Well, open YOUR OWN LINK.

    Go to -o4:

    "Physical Meaning of the Equations Obtained in Respect to Moving Rigid
    Bodies and Moving Clocks".

    Einstein explicitly gives:

    tau = t.sqrt(1-v-#/c-#).

    And for small v/c, the moving clock loses approximately:

    t.v-#/(2c-#).

    He even extends the result to clocks moving along CURVED paths, including closed trajectories.

    IN 1905.

    Now take a GPS satellite moving at approximately 3874 m/s.

    Over one day:

    Delta tau - t
    = -86400 * v-#/(2c-#)
    = approximately -7.21 microseconds.

    THERE IT IS.

    The special-relativistic contribution to GPS clock-rate differences, calculated directly from the formula in the 1905 paper YOU keep linking.

    The corresponding frequency compensation for that contribution alone is approximately:

    +8.35 x 10^-11.

    The additional gravitational contribution comes from general relativity, developed later.

    Together they produce the familiar net GPS effect of approximately +38.5 microseconds per day, requiring compensation of the opposite sign.

    So, Maciej:

    You have been waving around a paper that explicitly predicts moving-clock discrepancies.

    You repeatedly demanded a numerical application.

    And when given one, you declared that no prediction existed.

    Perhaps the problem isn't that Einstein forgot to write the formula.

    Perhaps it's that you forgot to READ THE PAPER.

    And the best part?

    The relevant section is literally ABOUT MOVING CLOCKS.

    You couldn't have chosen a more unfortunate reference if you'd tried. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:50:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 1:41 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 13:34, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 1:30 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Just not a formula for any correction.

    I GAVE YOU THE EXACT FORMULA TWO POSTS AGO!

    Neil Ashby (2003), equations (34)rCo(36):

    That NOW your fellow idiots wave their arms
    and scream "The idiot has PREDICTED!!!
    PREDICTED EVERYTHING!!!!!" - I know. You provide
    enough of the examples yourself.
    It's just an obvious lie of mad worshipers.


    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    Where is it?

    https://ibb.co/fVcG8CMw
    See, poor piece of shit - even such
    a disgusting piece of lying shit as you are
    can't lie non stop. The idiot has predicted
    the time dilation, i.e. the difference in
    the clock indications (unfortunately,
    the measured value is 0, common sense
    had been warning the idiot). The idiot
    didn't predict any clock correction.
    According to the idiot and your mad
    religion the clocks are "perfectly
    good" without any correction.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 12:52:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 13:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 1:41 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 13:34, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 1:30 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Just not a formula for any correction.

    I GAVE YOU THE EXACT FORMULA TWO POSTS AGO!

    Neil Ashby (2003), equations (34)rCo(36):

    That NOW your fellow idiots wave their arms
    and scream "The idiot has PREDICTED!!!
    PREDICTED EVERYTHING!!!!!" - I know. You provide
    enough of the examples yourself.
    It's just an obvious lie of mad worshipers.


    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    Where is it?

    https://ibb.co/fVcG8CMw
    See, poor piece of shit - even such
    a disgusting piece of lying shit as you are
    can't lie non stop. The idiot has predicted
    the time dilation, i.e. the difference in
    the clock indications (unfortunately,
    the measured value is 0, common sense
    had been warning the idiot). The idiot
    didn't predict any clock correction.
    According to the idiot and your mad
    religion the clocks are "perfectly
    good" without any correction.

    Maciej,

    The idiot has predicted the time dilation,
    i.e. the difference in the clock indications

    OH!

    PROGRESS!

    You finally acknowledge that Einstein predicted a difference in clock indications.

    And the 1905 paper YOU keep linking explicitly gives the formula for the kinematic contribution.

    For a nominal GPS satellite:

    Approximately -7.2 microseconds per day.

    Calculated directly from Einstein's 1905 equation.

    Unfortunately, the measured value is 0,
    common sense had been warning the idiot.

    ZERO?

    Maciej, the NTS-2 experiment in 1977 measured a fractional frequency
    offset of:

    +443.1 x 10^-12.

    The relativistic prediction was:

    +445.0 x 10^-12.

    That's approximately 38.28 versus 38.45 microseconds per day.

    NOT ZERO.

    And the correction was applied AFTER the initial measurement.

    You have been given the original experimental report.

    You have been given the equations.

    You have been given the numerical results.

    Yet you continue claiming that the measured value was zero.

    That is not skepticism.

    That is simply denying an experimental result.

    The idiot didn't predict any clock correction.

    And here comes your favorite confusion again.

    Einstein predicted the physical effect.

    The engineers calculated how to compensate for that effect in a particular technological system.

    A theory doesn't need to contain instructions for manufacturing GPS
    satellites to predict the physical quantities engineers must compensate
    for.

    Newton didn't specify how to build an elevator either.

    Yet engineers calculate the forces its motors must overcome using
    Newtonian mechanics.

    Would you claim that Newton predicted no forces because he didn't provide
    the elevator's wiring diagram?

    According to the idiot and your mad
    religion the clocks are "perfectly
    good" without any correction.

    YES, Maciej!

    THE CLOCKS CAN BE PERFECTLY GOOD WITHOUT CORRECTION.

    That's precisely the point you've been missing for years.

    A clock can correctly measure its own proper time while running at a
    different rate from a clock following another worldline.

    Neither clock is defective.

    But if you want both clocks' OUTPUTS to follow the same GPS coordinate
    time scale, you must compensate for the predicted difference.

    GOOD CLOCKS.

    DIFFERENT PROPER-TIME RATES.

    COMMON COORDINATE TIME.

    THREE DIFFERENT CONCEPTS.

    Not terribly difficult.

    And now, Maciej, one last question.

    When you claim that the measured difference is ZERO, are you talking
    about:

    BEFORE the relativistic compensation?

    Or AFTER it?

    Because before compensation, NTS-2 measured the predicted nonzero
    frequency difference.

    And after compensation, the clock output could be brought into agreement
    with the reference time scale.

    If your argument is that a correction successfully removes the discrepancy
    it was designed to remove, congratulations!

    You have just discovered what a correction is.

    Perhaps your next breakthrough will be that a thermostat disproves the existence of temperature differences.

    Praise REAL TIME!

    And please don't forget to specify whether your next ZERO comes before or after the correction. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:53:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 1:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 13:36, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 1:34 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 07:18, Maciej Wo?niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 3:20 AM, Python wrote:

    The essential point remains unchanged: the required relativistic
    correction was calculated,

    And that's a shitty lie, your mad religion
    is predicting no correction, oppositely
    it is asserting that the clocks are
    "perfectly good" without any. An
    assertion, of course, as baseless as
    it is idiotic.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Maciej,

    show me, poor piece of shit - where,
    precisely, the idiot provides us
    the formula which is a formula for any
    clock corrections?

    Oh, Maciej.

    You have linked Einstein's 1905 paper on SPECIAL relativity.

    1905.

    SPECIAL relativity.

    The gravitational contribution to GPS clock corrections comes from
    GENERAL
    relativity, developed in 1915.

    You are demanding that a 1905 paper contain the engineering
    specifications
    of a satellite navigation system developed some seventy years later.

    Why not complain that Newton's Principia doesn't contain the source
    code
    for a GPS receiver?

    As a matter of historical fact Einstein 1905 does give the velocity part

    As a matter of historical fact poor Loddie
    is impudently lying, as expected from
    a piece of relativistic shit.

    Well, open YOUR OWN LINK.

    Go to -o4:

    "Physical Meaning of the Equations Obtained in Respect to Moving Rigid Bodies and Moving Clocks".

    Einstein explicitly gives:

    tau = t.sqrt(1-v-#/c-#).

    And for small v/c, the moving clock loses approximately:

    t.v-#/(2c-#).

    As anyone can check in GPS, his bullshit
    is worthless, the really measured value
    is 0.
    Of course, it would be different if
    your moronic religion succeeded in
    FORBIDDING the corrections it has
    allegedly predicted.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:59:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 1:52 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 13:50, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 1:41 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 13:34, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 1:30 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Just not a formula for any correction.

    I GAVE YOU THE EXACT FORMULA TWO POSTS AGO!

    Neil Ashby (2003), equations (34)rCo(36):

    That NOW your fellow idiots wave their arms
    and scream "The idiot has PREDICTED!!!
    PREDICTED EVERYTHING!!!!!" - I know. You provide
    enough of the examples yourself.
    It's just an obvious lie of mad worshipers.


    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    Where is it?

    https://ibb.co/fVcG8CMw
    See, poor piece of shit - even such
    a disgusting piece of lying shit as you are
    can't lie non stop. The idiot has predicted
    the time dilation, i.e. the difference in
    the clock indications (unfortunately,
    the measured value is 0, common sense
    had been warning the idiot). The idiot
    didn't predict any clock correction.
    According to the idiot and your mad
    religion the clocks are "perfectly
    good" without any correction.

    Maciej,

    The idiot has predicted the time dilation,
    i.e. the difference in the clock indications

    OH!

    PROGRESS!

    You finally acknowledge that Einstein predicted a difference in clock indications.

    OH!

    PROGRESS!

    You finally acknowledge that Einstein predicted a difference in clock indications.
    Usually you lie that the idiot only predicted the difference
    in rates, but, well, you're too stupid to lie consistently.



    And the 1905 paper YOU keep linking explicitly gives the formula for the kinematic contribution.

    For a nominal GPS satellite:

    Approximately -7.2 microseconds per day.

    Calculated directly from Einstein's 1905 equation.

    Unfortunately, the measured value is 0,
    common sense had been warning the idiot.

    ZERO?

    Maciej, the NTS-2 experiment in 1977 measured a fractional frequency
    offset of:

    Fuck your frequency offset and the measured value
    of the differences in clock indications is 0.
    Let's try again: the indication of one GPS
    clock is 2026-11-11 15:00:00.0000000000.
    What are the indications of other GPS clocks?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 12:59:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Of course, it would be different if
    your moronic religion succeeded in
    FORBIDDING the corrections it has
    allegedly predicted.

    FORBIDDING corrections?

    WHERE, Maciej?

    Show us the passage in Einstein's 1905 paper that forbids correcting clock indications or adjusting clock frequencies.

    You keep waving that paper around.

    Surely you can find the relevant sentence?

    Meanwhile, -o4 of that very paper explicitly predicts the kinematic
    difference between moving clocks.

    And the experimental reality is NOT ZERO.

    For GPS satellites, the net relativistic effect is approximately:

    +38.5 microseconds per day.

    Predicted BEFORE measurement.

    Measured BEFORE compensation.

    Compensated for in GPS operation.

    You keep pointing at the compensated output and screaming:

    "LOOK! ZERO! EINSTEIN WAS WRONG!"

    Maciej, that's like pointing at a balanced scale and declaring that
    gravity doesn't exist because the net force is zero.

    The correction doesn't abolish the physical effect.

    It compensates for it.

    And nothing in Einstein's 1905 paper forbids doing so.

    Quite the contrary: once a theory predicts a difference in clock rates, calculating the compensation required to make their outputs follow a
    common time scale is elementary engineering.

    But perhaps your next discovery will be that applying the brakes disproves Newton's laws because the car stops.

    38.5 microseconds per day, Maciej.

    Not zero.

    And still waiting for the passage where Einstein supposedly FORBIDS corrections.

    Your own link, please.

    Section and page.

    No more sermons from the Church of REAL TIME. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:00:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Usually you lie that the idiot only predicted
    the difference in rates, but, well, you're
    too stupid to lie consistently.

    Oh, Maciej.

    A difference in clock rates ACCUMULATES into a difference in clock indications.

    If two initially synchronized clocks run at different rates, their
    indications progressively diverge.

    That's elementary arithmetic.

    Not a contradiction.

    Not a change of position.

    Just the difference between a rate and its accumulated effect.

    Fuck your frequency offset

    Ah, yes.

    When the numerical evidence becomes inconvenient, simply tell it to fuck
    off.

    A revolutionary experimental method.

    Let's try again: the indication of one GPS
    clock is 2026-11-11 15:00:00.0000000000.
    What are the indications of other GPS clocks?

    That depends, Maciej.

    Are you asking about their RAW, uncompensated proper-time readings?

    Or their CORRECTED outputs, referred to GPS coordinate time?

    Because those are NOT the same thing.

    GPS is specifically engineered to provide a common time scale.

    Its satellite clock offsets are monitored, modeled and corrected.

    So the corrected indications are intended to agree with GPS time, within
    the system's synchronization accuracy.

    Not necessarily to the last nanosecond, incidentally.

    But remove the relativistic compensation and the satellite clocks will progressively drift relative to that time scale.

    For nominal GPS orbits, the net relativistic rate difference is
    approximately:

    +38.5 microseconds per day.

    And this is not speculation.

    The NTS-2 experiment measured the predicted effect BEFORE applying the correction.

    Now, Maciej, imagine two clocks whose uncorrected rates differ by 38.5 microseconds per day.

    After one day, their indications differ by approximately 38.5
    microseconds.

    Apply the appropriate frequency compensation, and that systematic drift is removed.

    The clocks can then remain synchronized, subject to other errors and corrections.

    And you point at the synchronized indications and shout:

    "ZERO! RELATIVITY REFUTED!"

    Maciej, you're confusing the OUTPUT of a correction system with the
    physical effect that made the correction necessary.

    It's like declaring that a room has no heat losses because its thermostat keeps the temperature constant.

    The heating system is doing its job.

    So is GPS.

    Now answer a question of your own.

    Why does the official GPS specification include a relativistic frequency offset of:

    -4.4647 x 10^-10

    if, as you claim, the underlying relativistic rate difference is ZERO?

    What exactly are the engineers compensating for?

    And why does the required value agree with the relativistic calculation?

    Come on, Maciej.

    An actual explanation.

    With numbers.

    Not another sermon about REAL TIME. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:03:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 1:59 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Of course, it would be different if
    your moronic religion succeeded in
    FORBIDDING the corrections it has
    allegedly predicted.

    FORBIDDING corrections?

    WHERE, Maciej?

    In your moronic wannabe definition of second,
    in your moronic pictures where a smiling
    idiot is asserting that the clocks are
    perfectly good without any corrections
    and in 1000 of other places, poor piece
    of shit.
    Of course, if The Shit succeeded and
    the corrections were banned - the clock
    indications would be as the idiot
    predicted. But your religion never
    had any chance, common sense had been
    warning the idiot.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:05:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    In your moronic wannabe definition of second,
    in your moronic pictures where a smiling
    idiot is asserting that the clocks are
    perfectly good without any corrections

    OH!

    So your evidence that relativity FORBIDS clock corrections is...

    A definition of the second.

    And a CARTOON.

    Maciej, this is getting better by the minute. :-)

    The SI second is defined using the unperturbed hyperfine transition
    frequency of the caesium-133 atom.

    It does not forbid frequency adjustments, clock synchronization, or relativistic corrections.

    And an ideal clock measuring its own proper time is perfectly good WITHOUT correction.

    That doesn't mean its indication automatically agrees with GPS coordinate time.

    How many times must this elementary distinction be explained to you?

    A clock can be physically accurate and still require its OUTPUT to be
    adjusted to follow a chosen common time scale.

    There is no contradiction.

    Of course, if The Shit succeeded and
    the corrections were banned - the clock
    indications would be as the idiot
    predicted.

    Maciej, relativity predicts the DIFFERENCE IN RATES.

    GPS engineers compensate for that predicted difference.

    And you have somehow convinced yourself that the successful compensation refutes the prediction.

    By your logic, correcting a telescope's optical aberrations disproves
    optics.

    Correcting a clock's temperature-dependent frequency drift disproves thermodynamics.

    And correcting a GPS satellite clock's relativistic rate difference
    disproves relativity.

    Absolutely magnificent.

    But I particularly admire your latest discovery:

    A scientific theory can apparently BAN engineering corrections.

    Where is this prohibition published?

    Which equation expresses it?

    Which GPS engineer was prevented from applying a correction?

    You have provided no answer.

    Only insults, a definition of the second, and a cartoon.

    Meanwhile, the experimental result remains:

    Predicted: +445.0 x 10^-12.
    Measured: +443.1 x 10^-12.

    BEFORE compensation.

    Your claim that the measured effect was zero is simply false.

    And your claim that relativity forbids corrections is an invention of your own.

    Perhaps it's time to stop arguing with imaginary prohibitions and start addressing actual equations.

    38.5 microseconds per day, Maciej.

    Your nemesis is still waiting. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:05:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 2:00 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Usually you lie that the idiot only predicted
    the difference in rates, but, well, you're
    too stupid to lie consistently.

    Oh, Maciej.

    A difference in clock rates ACCUMULATES into a difference in clock indications.

    In the sick delusions of your mad
    bunch of idiots. In GPS it doesn't
    accumulate and the clocks measure
    t'=t, just like all serious clocks
    always did.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:07:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 2:05 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    In your moronic wannabe definition of second,
    in your moronic pictures where a smiling
    idiot is asserting that the clocks are
    perfectly good without any corrections

    OH!

    So your evidence that relativity FORBIDS clock corrections is...

    A definition of the second.

    And a CARTOON.

    Maciej, this is getting better by the minute. :-)

    The SI second is defined using the unperturbed hyperfine transition frequency of the caesium-133 atom.

    It does not forbid frequency adjustments

    It's just trying. With no success, of course,
    common sense had been warning the idiot
    and the idiots from your bunch of
    idiots.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:09:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    In GPS it doesn't accumulate and the clocks
    measure t'=t, just like all serious clocks
    always did.

    https://ibb.co/cchss0pz

    Of course it doesn't accumulate, Maciej.

    BECAUSE GPS COMPENSATES FOR THE DIFFERENCE IN RATES.

    That's the entire point!

    Without compensation, two initially synchronized clocks whose rates differ
    by a constant amount will accumulate a difference in their indications.

    Mathematically:

    Delta t(T) = integral from 0 to T of (r1-r2) dt.

    If r1-r2 is nonzero, the difference accumulates.

    This is arithmetic, Maciej. Not a religious doctrine.

    For GPS, the predicted net relativistic rate difference is approximately:

    +4.4647 x 10^-10.

    Which corresponds to:

    +38.5 microseconds per day.

    And in 1977, the NTS-2 experiment measured that rate difference BEFORE compensation.

    Now, GPS compensates for the systematic effect so that its clock outputs
    can be referred to a common coordinate time scale.

    And you proudly announce that the difference doesn't accumulate!

    YES!

    THAT'S WHAT THE COMPENSATION IS FOR!

    But there's another problem with your claim.

    the clocks measure t'=t

    No, Maciej.

    GPS does not establish that the proper times of clocks following different worldlines are identical.

    It establishes a common COORDINATE TIME, using clock models,
    synchronization procedures and corrections.

    The distinction between proper time and coordinate time is precisely what you're refusing to understand.

    And even the corrected GPS satellite clocks are not perfectly synchronized
    at every instant. Their residual offsets are monitored and accounted for.

    So here's a very simple question:

    If the uncorrected relativistic rate difference is ZERO, why does the GPS system specify a nonzero relativistic frequency offset?

    And why did the NTS-2 experiment measure a nonzero difference BEFORE compensation?

    You cannot answer either question by pointing at the compensated result.

    Maciej, you're standing in front of a working air conditioner, observing
    that the room temperature remains constant, and triumphantly declaring:

    "SEE? THERE IS NO HEAT COMING THROUGH THE WALLS!"

    The engineers aren't disproving physics.

    They're USING it.

    And you're mistaking their success for a refutation.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:11:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    It's just trying. With no success, of course,
    common sense had been warning the idiot

    So now the SI definition of the second is secretly TRYING to forbid clock corrections?

    Fascinating.

    Could you show us the actual words in the definition that prohibit them?

    A quotation, Maciej.

    Not another declaration about "common sense".

    The SI definition specifies a unit of time.

    It does not prescribe how clocks must be synchronized, how their
    frequencies may be adjusted, or how GPS coordinate time must be realized.

    And GPS engineers routinely apply clock corrections.

    Apparently, nobody told them that the definition of the second was trying
    to stop them.

    Perhaps you should alert the BIPM.

    Or better yet, consult your Serious Clockrao.

    The one wearing a tie.

    I'm sure it has a very authoritative opinion on the matter. :-)

    Meanwhile, the question remains unanswered:

    WHERE does the definition of the second forbid relativistic corrections?

    Section, sentence, quotation.

    We're waiting.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:15:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 2:09 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    In GPS it doesn't accumulate and the clocks
    measure t'=t, just like all serious clocks
    always did.

    https://ibb.co/cchss0pz

    Of course it doesn't accumulate, Maciej.

    BECAUSE GPS COMPENSATES FOR THE DIFFERENCE IN RATES.

    That's the entire point!

    Without compensation, two initially synchronized clocks whose rates
    differ by a constant amount will accumulate a difference in their indications.

    Sure, without the compensations it would be
    as the idiot predicted. And that's why your
    mad religion has forbidden those compensations.
    Or rather tried.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:19:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 2:11 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    It's just trying. With no success, of course,
    common sense had been warning the idiot

    So now the SI definition of the second is secretly TRYING to forbid
    clock corrections?

    No, poor piece of shit, there is no secret
    here.

    Fascinating.

    Could you show us the actual words in the definition that prohibit them?

    A quotation, Maciej.

    Sure.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second

    It does not prescribe how clocks must be synchronized

    When it was sane it didn't.




    , how their
    frequencies may be adjusted

    Sorry, poor piece of shit. It directly specifies,
    for Cs clocks, how they have to be adjusted.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:20:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 14:15, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 2:09 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    In GPS it doesn't accumulate and the clocks
    measure t'=t, just like all serious clocks
    always did.

    https://ibb.co/cchss0pz

    Of course it doesn't accumulate, Maciej.

    BECAUSE GPS COMPENSATES FOR THE DIFFERENCE IN RATES.

    That's the entire point!

    Without compensation, two initially synchronized clocks whose rates
    differ by a constant amount will accumulate a difference in their
    indications.

    Sure, without the compensations it would be
    as the idiot predicted. And that's why your
    mad religion has forbidden those compensations.
    Or rather tried.

    Maciej,

    Sure, without the compensations it would be
    as the idiot predicted.

    EXACTLY!

    Thank you, Maciej!

    You have just admitted that, without compensation, the clocks would behave
    as relativity predicts.

    That's what I've been explaining to you all along.

    Relativity predicts the rate difference.

    GPS engineers calculate the compensation.

    GPS applies the compensation.

    The corrected clock outputs follow a common time scale.

    And you somehow regard this as a refutation of relativity.

    And that's why your mad religion has
    forbidden those compensations.
    Or rather tried.

    WHAT?!

    Maciej, this is complete baloney.

    Relativity predicts an effect, engineers compensate for it, and you claim
    that the theory FORBIDS compensating for the very effect it predicts?

    Where?

    In which equation?

    In which publication?

    Who issued this supposed prohibition?

    You have produced absolutely NOTHING to support this extraordinary claim.

    And the most hilarious part is that the relativistic corrections are not merely permitted.

    THEY ARE PART OF GPS ENGINEERING.

    The official GPS specifications explicitly account for them.

    So your argument has now become:

    1. Relativity predicts a clock-rate difference.
    2. Without compensation, the difference would accumulate.
    3. GPS compensates for the difference.
    4. Therefore relativity must have tried to FORBID the compensation.

    Maciej, step 4 doesn't follow from anything.

    It's an invention.

    You are no longer arguing against relativity.

    You are arguing against a fictional prohibition that exists entirely in
    your imagination.

    Perhaps you should discuss it with your Serious Clockrao.

    At least it wears a tie.

    And apparently takes its responsibilities more seriously than your
    arguments. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:22:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Sure.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second

    LOL!

    You were asked to QUOTE the words that forbid clock corrections.

    And you provide a link to Wikipedia's article on the SECOND.

    Where is the prohibition, Maciej?

    Quote the sentence.

    It directly specifies, for Cs clocks,
    how they have to be adjusted.

    No, Maciej.

    The SI definition specifies the frequency of a particular atomic
    transition in unperturbed caesium-133.

    That establishes the UNIT of proper time.

    It does NOT require every clock output to display uncorrected proper time under all circumstances.

    And it certainly does not forbid producing a different time scale for a particular application.

    For example...

    GPS!

    A caesium clock can serve as a frequency reference while its output is adjusted to follow GPS coordinate time.

    The atomic transition hasn't changed.

    The definition of the second hasn't changed.

    The laws of physics haven't changed.

    Only the relationship between the clock's physical oscillations and its delivered time signal has been adjusted.

    That's precisely what clock engineering is about.

    And here's the distinction you keep missing:

    A clock measuring its own proper time needs no RELATIVISTIC correction to
    make that proper time correct.

    A clock required to provide GPS coordinate time DOES need appropriate corrections to account for the difference between proper time and
    coordinate time.

    Both statements are simultaneously true.

    There is no contradiction.

    There is no prohibition.

    There is no conspiracy.

    And there is certainly nothing in the SI definition that forbids engineers from compensating for a predicted frequency offset.

    So please, Maciej:

    Stop sending links to entire Wikipedia articles.

    Show us the EXACT SENTENCE that forbids relativistic clock corrections.

    Or admit that your supposed prohibition exists nowhere outside your imagination.

    Perhaps your Serious Clockrao can help you find it.

    After all, it's wearing a tie.

    It must know what it's talking about. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:31:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 2:20 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 14:15, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 2:09 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    In GPS it doesn't accumulate and the clocks
    measure t'=t, just like all serious clocks
    always did.

    https://ibb.co/cchss0pz

    Of course it doesn't accumulate, Maciej.

    BECAUSE GPS COMPENSATES FOR THE DIFFERENCE IN RATES.

    That's the entire point!

    Without compensation, two initially synchronized clocks whose rates
    differ by a constant amount will accumulate a difference in their
    indications.

    Sure, without the compensations it would be
    as the idiot predicted. And that's why your
    mad religion has forbidden those compensations.
    Or rather tried.

    Maciej,

    Sure, without the compensations it would be
    as the idiot predicted.

    EXACTLY!

    Thank you, Maciej!

    You have just admitted that, without compensation, the clocks would
    behave as relativity predicts.

    Sure, I was never denying that if clocks fitted your
    mad Shit they would fit your mad Shit.



    And that's why your mad religion has
    forbidden those compensations.
    Or rather tried.

    WHAT?!

    That.




    Maciej, this is complete baloney.

    Relativity predicts an effect

    Yes, the effect of - difference in
    clock indications. You can't eat cookie
    and have cookie, poor piece of shit,
    you can't compensate the difference
    and still have it. That's why your
    mad religion has been for 120 years
    persuading idiots like you that the
    clocks would be "perfectly good" if
    they were not compensated. An
    assertion, of course, as baseless
    as it is idiotic.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:32:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 2:22 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Sure.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second

    LOL!

    You were asked to QUOTE the words that forbid clock corrections.

    And you provide a link to Wikipedia's article on the SECOND.

    Where is the prohibition, Maciej?

    Quote the sentence.

    It directly specifies, for Cs clocks,
    how they have to be adjusted.

    No, Maciej.

    Yes, Python.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 13:44:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    You can't eat cookie and have cookie,
    poor piece of shit, you can't compensate
    the difference and still have it.

    https://ibb.co/cKfgYgBw

    CONGRATULATIONS, MACIEJ!

    You've finally discovered what COMPENSATION means!

    Of course the difference in the CORRECTED clock indications is reduced by
    the correction.

    THAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THE CORRECTION.

    But the underlying difference in proper-time rates doesn't magically disappear.

    Let's make this painfully simple.

    Suppose two initially synchronized clocks accumulate proper time at
    different rates:

    Clock A: 1 second per second.

    Clock B: 1 + 4.4647 x 10^-10 seconds per second.

    After one day, their UNCORRECTED readings differ by approximately 38.5 microseconds.

    Now compensate clock B's output for that rate difference.

    Its corrected output can remain synchronized with clock A.

    But the physical rate difference that required the compensation hasn't vanished.

    You've merely compensated for it.

    And, Maciej, here's the really amusing part:

    If the physical difference were ZERO, applying the predicted nonzero compensation would CREATE a drift instead of removing one.

    Yet the relativistic compensation is used successfully in GPS.

    That's rather inconvenient for your theory, isn't it?

    That's why your mad religion has been
    for 120 years persuading idiots like you
    that the clocks would be "perfectly good"
    if they were not compensated.

    YES!

    An ideal clock correctly measuring its own PROPER TIME is perfectly good.

    A GPS clock output required to follow a common COORDINATE TIME must
    account for the difference between proper time and coordinate time.

    These are two different requirements.

    A perfectly good thermometer measuring 20-#C does not become defective
    because an application requires its output in Fahrenheit.

    Converting its output doesn't change the temperature.

    Likewise, correcting a clock's output doesn't change the proper time along
    its worldline.

    And nobody has ever needed to FORBID corrections to make this distinction.

    So your argument now amounts to:

    "The corrected clocks agree, therefore the uncorrected clocks would agree too."

    No, Maciej.

    That doesn't follow.

    And the 1977 NTS-2 measurements directly contradict it.

    You keep confusing the quantity being corrected with the result AFTER correction.

    Perhaps your Serious Clockrao could explain it to you.

    Although, judging by its expression, even a clock wearing a tie is getting tired of this conversation. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:51:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    You can't eat cookie and have cookie,
    poor piece of shit, you can't compensate
    the difference and still have it.

    https://ibb.co/cKfgYgBw

    CONGRATULATIONS, MACIEJ!

    You've finally discovered what COMPENSATION means!

    Of course the difference in the CORRECTED clock indications is reduced
    by the correction.

    THAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THE CORRECTION.

    But the underlying difference in proper-time rates

    But the predicted by the idiot difference
    in clock indications (so called "time
    dilation") exists no more. That's
    why your mad religion has been trying
    to forbid it.



    That's why your mad religion has been
    for 120 years persuading idiots like you
    that the clocks would be "perfectly good"
    if they were not compensated.

    YES!

    Yes. Of course, the assertion
    is as baseless as it is idiotic and
    all sane people (starting from GPS
    staff) have pissed at it. Heck, even
    you and your fellow idiots are not
    stupid enough to treat it seriously.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:03:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 11/11/2026 |a 14:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    You can't eat cookie and have cookie,
    poor piece of shit, you can't compensate
    the difference and still have it.

    https://ibb.co/cKfgYgBw

    CONGRATULATIONS, MACIEJ!

    You've finally discovered what COMPENSATION means!

    Of course the difference in the CORRECTED clock indications is reduced
    by the correction.

    THAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THE CORRECTION.

    But the underlying difference in proper-time rates

    But the predicted by the idiot difference
    in clock indications (so called "time
    dilation") exists no more. That's
    why your mad religion has been trying
    to forbid it.



    That's why your mad religion has been
    for 120 years persuading idiots like you
    that the clocks would be "perfectly good"
    if they were not compensated.

    YES!

    Yes. Of course, the assertion
    is as baseless as it is idiotic and
    all sane people (starting from GPS
    staff) have pissed at it. Heck, even
    you and your fellow idiots are not
    stupid enough to treat it seriously.

    Maciej,

    "the predicted [...] difference in clock indications
    [...] exists no more."

    BECAUSE THE CLOCKS HAVE BEEN ADJUSTED TO COMPENSATE FOR IT!

    FOR FUCK'S SAKE!

    You are confusing the physical effect with the numerical indication of a
    clock deliberately adjusted to compensate for that effect.

    GPS engineers account for relativistic effects precisely because those
    effects are REAL.

    Without the appropriate corrections, the clocks would progressively
    disagree with the GPS time scale.

    With the corrections, they remain synchronized to that scale.

    THIS IS NOT A CONTRADICTION.

    IT IS THE ENTIRE PURPOSE OF THE CORRECTIONS.

    And no, an uncompensated clock is not a defective clock merely because it accumulates proper time at a different rate.

    You can adjust a clock's displayed rate.

    You cannot adjust the laws of physics out of existence.

    Your argument amounts to:

    "The correction works!
    Therefore the effect it corrects doesn't exist!"

    BRILLIANT, MACIEJ.

    By that logic, wearing glasses proves that myopia doesn't exist.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 15:34:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 3:03 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 14:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    You can't eat cookie and have cookie,
    poor piece of shit, you can't compensate
    the difference and still have it.

    https://ibb.co/cKfgYgBw

    CONGRATULATIONS, MACIEJ!

    You've finally discovered what COMPENSATION means!

    Of course the difference in the CORRECTED clock indications is
    reduced by the correction.

    THAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THE CORRECTION.

    But the underlying difference in proper-time rates

    But the predicted by the idiot difference
    in clock indications (so called "time
    dilation") exists no more. That's
    why your mad religion has been trying
    to forbid it.



    That's why your mad religion has been
    for 120 years persuading idiots like you
    that the clocks would be "perfectly good"
    if they were not compensated.

    YES!

    Yes. Of course, the assertion
    is as baseless as it is idiotic and
    all sane people (starting from GPS
    staff) have pissed at it. Heck, even
    you and your fellow idiots are not
    stupid enough to treat it seriously.

    Maciej,

    -a-a "the predicted [...] difference in clock indications
    -a-a-a [...] exists no more."

    BECAUSE THE CLOCKS HAVE BEEN ADJUSTED TO COMPENSATE FOR IT!

    1)Explaining why the idiot's prophecies
    fail doesn't change the fact that they
    fail
    2)the same applies to Newton's pendulums
    and no dilation there
    3)common sense had been warning the idiot

    Python, poor piece of shit, it's absolutely
    serious. The Shit's "proper!!!perfectly good!!
    and so on!!!" brainwashing was intended to
    prevent us from correcting.
    Quoting yourself:
    "without compensation, the clocks would
    behave as relativity predicts. "
    Yes, poor piece of shit, they WOULD.
    WITHOUT COMPENSATION. But with the
    compensation - it's a completely ordinary
    galilean situation.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:39:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    1) Explaining why the idiot's prophecies
    fail doesn't change the fact that they fail

    A prediction does not fail because engineers successfully compensate for
    the effect it predicts.

    Quite the opposite.

    If relativity predicts a frequency offset of X, and applying a correction
    of -X removes the corresponding drift, that is evidence FOR the
    prediction, not against it.

    And in 1977, NTS-2 measured the predicted frequency offset BEFORE compensation.

    You keep ignoring that rather inconvenient fact.

    2) the same applies to Newton's pendulums
    and no dilation there

    Excellent example, Maciej!

    A pendulum clock changes its rate when the local gravitational
    acceleration changes.

    You can adjust its length to compensate.

    Does that mean Newtonian mechanics was wrong about the pendulum's period?

    Of course not.

    The adjustment works BECAUSE the physical effect is understood.

    But there's an important difference: relativity predicts differences in accumulated proper time even for ideal clocks, independently of their
    internal mechanism.

    Pendulums, quartz oscillators, caesium clocks: the distinction between
    proper time and coordinate time is not a defect in their construction.

    3) common sense had been warning the idiot

    And experimental measurements have been warning you, Maciej.

    For decades.

    The Shit's "proper!!!perfectly good!!
    and so on!!!" brainwashing was intended to
    prevent us from correcting.

    Then show us the prohibition.

    Not your interpretation.

    Not another insult.

    An actual statement forbidding corrections.

    You still haven't produced one.

    Yes, poor piece of shit, they WOULD.
    WITHOUT COMPENSATION.

    EXACTLY!

    And the compensation is calculated from the predicted physical effect.

    You have now admitted the essential point AGAIN.

    But with the compensation - it's a
    completely ordinary galilean situation.

    NO, MACIEJ.

    This is your latest masterpiece.

    A relativistic effect is predicted.

    A relativistic correction is calculated.

    The correction is applied.

    The clock outputs are synchronized.

    And you conclude that the situation has become GALILEAN!

    Maciej, adjusting the OUTPUT of a clock does not transform spacetime.

    It doesn't change the clock's worldline.

    It doesn't change the proper time accumulated along that worldline.

    And it certainly doesn't make the Lorentz transformations turn into
    Galilean transformations.

    It merely changes the relationship between the clock's physical
    oscillations and the time signal delivered to the user.

    If a GPS satellite clock runs faster than the chosen reference time scale
    by approximately 38.5 microseconds per day, compensating for that rate difference doesn't make the difference cease to exist physically.

    It makes the corrected OUTPUT track the reference time.

    That's all.

    Your argument is essentially:

    "After applying the relativistic correction, the relativistic discrepancy
    is compensated. Therefore relativity is false."

    Brilliant.

    By the same reasoning, after correcting a telescope's optical aberration, light must have stopped obeying optics.

    And after adjusting your Newtonian pendulum, gravity must have stopped affecting its period.

    But I particularly admire your new theory:

    RELATIVITY + CORRECTION = GALILEAN PHYSICS.

    Perhaps you could publish the transformation equations?

    I'd love to see how adjusting a clock's frequency suddenly abolishes the Lorentz factor.

    Meanwhile, GPS engineers will continue using the relativistic calculations that make their corrections work.

    And your Serious Clockrao, tie impeccably straight, will continue
    wondering why you think correcting a measurement changes the laws of
    physics.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 14:47:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    I've finally understood your interpretation of Galilean transformations.

    In physics, the equation

    t' = t

    is a mathematical statement about the transformation of time coordinates.

    But in your personal version of physics, it apparently means:

    "I WANT t' = t!"

    And if two clocks don't naturally agree, you adjust their outputs until
    they do.

    Then you triumphantly announce:

    "SEE? GALILEAN PHYSICS!"

    Maciej, that's not an experimental verification.

    That's an engineering requirement.

    GPS engineers WANT their clock outputs to follow a common time scale.

    So they compensate for the relativistically predicted differences in proper-time rates.

    And you mistake the desired result of the compensation for proof that no compensation was physically necessary.

    You've confused:

    WHAT NATURE DOES

    with

    WHAT ENGINEERS WANT THEIR INSTRUMENTS TO DISPLAY.

    The really funny part is that your supposed victory for Galilean physics depends on applying corrections calculated using relativity.

    Apparently, your new principle of physics is:

    t' = t, BY DECREE!

    And if nature disagrees, adjust the clocks until it obeys.

    Your Serious Clockrao would be proud.

    Especially if you promoted it to Minister of Universal Time. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 16:04:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 3:39 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    1) Explaining why the idiot's prophecies
    fail doesn't change the fact that they fail

    A prediction does not fail because engineers successfully compensate for
    the effect it predicts.

    A sane prediction doesn't. But the effect the
    idiot predicted was - the difference in indications.
    Because of compensation there is no.


    And in 1977, NTS-2 measured the predicted frequency offset BEFORE compensation.

    You keep ignoring that rather inconvenient fact.

    No. Instead, you keep ignoring the fact that
    the idiot was babbling about indications, not
    about rates. He only mentioned "clock rate" once,
    rather accidentally.

    2) the same applies to Newton's pendulums
    and no dilation there

    Excellent example, Maciej!

    A pendulum clock changes its rate when the local gravitational
    acceleration changes.

    You can adjust its length to compensate.

    Does that mean Newtonian mechanics was wrong about the pendulum's period?

    Of course not.

    And does that mean any "dilation" idiocy?
    Of course not.



    3) common sense had been warning the idiot

    And experimental measurements have been warning you, Maciej.

    Even such a disgusting piece of lying shit
    as you are admits (sometimes) that the really
    measured difference in clock indication is 0.




    For decades.

    The Shit's "proper!!!perfectly good!!
    and so on!!!" brainwashing was intended to
    prevent us from correcting.

    Then show us the prohibition.

    The prohibition is - The Shit's
    "proper!!!perfectly good!! and so on!!!"
    brainwashing.


    Not your interpretation.

    "Perfectly good" is always a matter of
    interpretation, poor piece of shit.



    Yes, poor piece of shit, they WOULD.
    WITHOUT COMPENSATION.

    EXACTLY!

    And with the compensation they are not.



    And the compensation is calculated from the predicted physical effect.

    You have now admitted the essential point AGAIN.

    But with the compensation - it's a
    completely ordinary galilean situation.

    NO, MACIEJ.

    Yes, Python. All pre-idiot clocks would
    exhibit some difference in indications if
    they weren't compensated to indicate t'=t.
    There is no difference.

    This is your latest masterpiece.

    A relativistic effect is predicted.

    Yes, the effect of a difference in
    clock indications. You can predict
    a similar "pendulum time dilation"
    effect for pendulums, you can babble
    about perfect pendulums exhibiting
    the effect, you can wave arms and
    scream that if it wasn't the compensation
    such "pendulum time dilation" would
    be measured.
    But there is NO pendulum time dilation.
    And there is NO idiocy of yours.
    Compensation kills them both.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 15:08:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    I've finally the source of your confusion.

    You keep using words like:

    "indication", "rate", "dilation", "compensation", "proper", "perfect"...

    But you seem to have no idea what distinctions these words are supposed to express.

    Let's try some elementary definitions.

    1. CLOCK RATE

    The rate at which a clock's reading changes.

    If two initially synchronized clocks have different rates, their readings accumulate a difference.

    This is not a matter of interpretation.

    It is elementary calculus.

    2. CLOCK INDICATION

    The number displayed or delivered by a clock.

    That number can be adjusted, offset, scaled, or synchronized to a
    reference time.

    Changing the indication does not necessarily change the physical process generating the clock's frequency.

    3. PROPER TIME

    The time accumulated along a particular worldline.

    An ideal clock measures its own proper time.

    Two ideal clocks following different worldlines can accumulate different proper times between the same two events.

    Neither clock is defective.

    4. TIME DILATION

    A relationship between elapsed times or clock rates associated with
    different motions or reference frames.

    It is NOT a claim that engineers are forbidden to adjust clock outputs.

    5. COMPENSATION

    An adjustment made to counteract a known effect.

    Compensating an effect does not mean the effect never existed.

    6. PERFECT CLOCK

    An idealized clock that measures proper time accurately.

    NOT a magical device whose output must agree with every other clock
    everywhere in the universe.

    Now consider your favorite example:

    The effect the idiot predicted was -
    the difference in indications.
    Because of compensation there is no.

    Maciej, a difference in rates produces a difference in indications when accumulated over time.

    Compensating that rate difference prevents the corresponding discrepancy
    from accumulating in the CORRECTED outputs.

    It does not invalidate the prediction of what the clocks would do WITHOUT
    that compensation.

    And the prediction can be tested experimentally.

    It WAS tested.

    In 1977, NTS-2 measured the predicted relativistic frequency offset before compensation.

    You keep dismissing this measurement because it concerns a rate.

    But what do you imagine happens when a nonzero rate difference is
    integrated over time?

    You can predict a similar "pendulum time
    dilation" effect for pendulums

    No, Maciej.

    You've just demonstrated another fundamental confusion.

    A pendulum's period depends on its length and the local gravitational acceleration:

    T = 2*pi*sqrt(L/g).

    Change g and the pendulum's rate changes.

    Adjust L and you can compensate.

    But that is a property of the PENDULUM MECHANISM.

    Relativistic proper-time differences are not peculiarities of pendulums, caesium atoms, quartz crystals, or any other clock mechanism.

    They concern the spacetime paths followed by the clocks.

    That is precisely why the distinction between a physical clock mechanism
    and an ideal clock matters.

    Compensation kills them both.

    No.

    Compensation removes the discrepancy from the corrected OUTPUT.

    It doesn't erase the physical cause.

    It doesn't erase the uncorrected measurement.

    It doesn't erase the prediction.

    And it certainly doesn't turn Lorentz transformations into Galilean transformations.

    Your entire argument rests on one astonishing confusion:

    You think that because engineers WANT their clocks to display a common
    time, the universe must therefore have a universal Galilean time.

    In other words, for you:

    t' = t

    doesn't mean "this is what the laws of physics predict."

    It means:

    "I WANT t' = t!"

    And if the clocks disagree, adjust them until they obey.

    Then announce that Galilean physics has been experimentally verified.

    Maciej, that's not physics.

    That's wishful thinking with a screwdriver.

    And here's the question you still haven't answered:

    If there is no physical relativistic rate difference, why does applying
    the calculated relativistic compensation improve GPS synchronization
    instead of introducing the very drift it is supposed to remove?

    A numerical answer, please.

    Not another lecture from your Serious Clockrao.

    Even wearing a tie doesn't make a clock an authority on relativity.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 16:25:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 4:08 PM, Python wrote:
    I've finally the source of your confusion.

    On the other hand, the reason of your
    confusion, which is the mad brainwashing
    you've received - is obvious.

    The effect the idiot predicted was -
    the difference in indications.
    Because of compensation there is no.

    Maciej, a difference in rates produces a difference in indications when accumulated over time.

    In your gedanken delusions it does,
    in GPS it doesn't.


    In 1977, NTS-2 measured the predicted relativistic frequency offset
    before compensation.

    But the prediction of the idiot was
    - a difference in clock indications.
    And even such a disgusting piece
    of lying shit as you are sometimes
    admits that the real, measured
    value is 0.




    You keep dismissing this measurement because it concerns a rate.

    Even the idiot understood the rate is of
    no importance.


    But what do you imagine happens when a nonzero rate difference is
    integrated over time?

    IF the clocks fitted your mad Shit
    they would fit your mad Shit, never
    denied that.


    You can predict a similar "pendulum time
    dilation" effect for pendulums

    No, Maciej.

    Yes, Python.



    You've just demonstrated another fundamental confusion.

    A pendulum's period depends on its length and the local gravitational acceleration:

    A theory of "pendulum time dilation" would
    assert something else.




    Relativistic proper-time differences are not peculiarities of pendulums, caesium atoms, quartz crystals, or any other clock mechanism.

    They concern the spacetime paths followed by the clocks.

    The same could be easily asserted for any
    theory. It's just a mystical mumble of no
    real content.




    That is precisely why the distinction between a physical clock mechanism
    and an ideal clock matters.

    Compensation kills them both.

    No.

    Yes.




    Compensation removes the discrepancy from the corrected OUTPUT.

    It doesn't erase the physical cause.

    There is no "physical cause" here. The
    cause of your idiocy is your mad, baseless
    faith that your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice of
    the reference.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 16:34:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    Le 11/11/2026 |a 03:54, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Yes, because that was the point of my changing
    the Subject header field value in this way:

    Ah, Thomas.

    Four references to explain why I should have edited a Subject header.

    FOUR.

    And you are too stupid to read any of them. Figures.

    I must admit, your dedication to the finer points of Usenet bureaucracy

    It is not "bureaucracy", it is the way to use it (efficiently).

    is almost as impressive as your knowledge of GPS.

    Almost.

    But changing a Subject header is not an instruction that other
    participants are obliged to follow.

    And your preferred subject line does not become mandatory merely because
    you have documented the procedure.

    1. Pseudonym.
    2. Full-quote.
    3. Refusal to comply with Usenet standards and Netiquette such as
    Subject change and Followup-To.

    Score adjusted.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 15:36:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    In your gedanken delusions it does,
    in GPS it doesn't.

    In GPS, the uncorrected rate difference is compensated.

    You keep omitting that rather important detail.

    But the prediction of the idiot was
    - a difference in clock indications.

    Yes.

    And a difference in rates produces a difference in accumulated
    indications.

    https://ibb.co/YJCXk5W

    If two clocks start together, and their rates differ by a constant amount epsilon, then after an elapsed time T:

    Delta = epsilon * T.

    For the nominal GPS relativistic rate difference:

    epsilon = 4.4647 x 10^-10.

    After 86400 seconds:

    Delta = 38.57 microseconds.

    WITHOUT compensation.

    This is not a thought experiment. The underlying rate difference was
    measured in the NTS-2 experiment.

    Even the idiot understood the rate is of
    no importance.

    Maciej, the rate is precisely what determines how the difference in indications evolves.

    Claiming that the rate is irrelevant to accumulated time is like claiming
    that speed is irrelevant to distance traveled.

    A theory of "pendulum time dilation" would
    assert something else.

    Then formulate it!

    Give us its equations.

    Give us a numerical prediction.

    Explain how it differs experimentally from ordinary pendulum mechanics.

    Simply inventing the words "pendulum time dilation" does not produce a competing physical theory.

    The same could be easily asserted for any
    theory. It's just a mystical mumble of no
    real content.

    No, Maciej.

    Relativity predicts quantitative differences in elapsed proper time.

    Those differences can be tested using clocks based on different physical mechanisms.

    And they have been.

    A genuine physical theory must do more than assert that its clocks are "serious".

    It must predict numbers that experiments can check.

    There is no "physical cause" here.

    Then explain the NTS-2 measurement.

    Predicted fractional frequency offset:

    +445.0 x 10^-12.

    Measured:

    +443.1 x 10^-12.

    Before compensation.

    If there is no physical effect, what produced that measured offset?

    And why did its magnitude agree with the relativistic prediction?

    Your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of time", blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    Maciej, "proper" is a technical term.

    It doesn't mean "morally superior".

    And "ideal clock" doesn't mean "a clock that Einstein personally approves
    of".

    It means a clock that accurately measures elapsed proper time along its worldline.

    No Higher Force.

    No divine certification.

    No sacred privilege.

    Just a precisely defined physical quantity and experimentally testable predictions.

    And here's another misconception:

    Relativity does NOT designate one privileged clock as the universal
    reference for all others.

    GPS defines a conventional coordinate time scale for practical navigation,
    and engineers relate individual clock readings to that scale.

    You have confused a coordinate convention with a religious hierarchy.

    Again.

    So please stop debating the supposed moral qualities of clocks.

    We are discussing measurable quantities.

    And you still owe us a physical explanation of the NTS-2 result.

    Preferably one involving equations rather than theology.

    Your Serious Clock(TM) may wear a tie, Maciej.

    But even that doesn't make it the Supreme Pontiff of Universal Time. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 15:39:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Thomas,

    1. Pseudonym.
    2. Full-quote.
    3. Refusal to comply with Usenet standards and Netiquette such as
    Subject change and Followup-To.

    Score adjusted.

    Oh dear.

    I've been SCORED.

    By Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn.

    For using a pseudonym.

    The irony alone deserves bonus points. :-)

    But I must congratulate you on your promotion from self-appointed Usenet etiquette instructor to self-appointed Usenet examination board.

    Is there an appeals procedure?

    A grading rubric?

    Perhaps an ISO standard for the permissible number of quoted lines?

    And most importantly, Thomas:

    Does the score include relativistic corrections?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 16:59:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 4:36 PM, Python wrote:
    In your gedanken delusions it does,
    in GPS it doesn't.

    In GPS, the uncorrected rate difference is compensated.

    You keep omitting that rather important detail.

    Because we agreed about it hundred times and
    it is not important at all.


    But the prediction of the idiot was
    - a difference in clock indications.

    Yes.

    And a difference in rates produces a difference in accumulated indications.

    Nope. The idiot knew nothing about Cs clock
    rates.


    Maciej, the rate is precisely what determines how the difference in indications evolves.

    Python,
    Bullshit. GPS has NO difference. Newton's pendulums
    have NO difference. Because of rates?


    Claiming that the rate is irrelevant to accumulated time is like
    claiming that speed is irrelevant to distance traveled.

    But it is.


    A theory of "pendulum time dilation" would
    assert something else.

    Then formulate it!

    What for? Ut would take some days at least
    and would be even stupider than The Shit of
    your idiot guru.



    The same could be easily asserted for any
    theory. It's just a mystical mumble of no
    real content.

    No, Maciej.


    Yes, Python.

    Relativity predicts quantitative differences in elapsed proper time.

    Then the real clocks fuck its prediction
    and a relativistic idiot screams "BUT IF
    THEY WERE PROPER...." Any theory can
    successfuly do the same.




    There is no "physical cause" here.

    Then explain the NTS-2 measurement.

    Predicted fractional frequency offset:

    +445.0 x 10^-12.

    Measured:

    +443.1 x 10^-12.

    The clocks chosen by you because of fitting your
    idiocies were fitting your idiocies. What is so
    surprising about that? How does it imply your
    "perfectly good"?

    Your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of time", blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    No. I don't. I think it means worthless, mad,
    unusable ideological nonsense.
    YOU do. When asked you scream "NOOOO!!!!!" - but
    all of your "logic" is spinning around that axiom?
    postulate? dogma? whatever.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 17:23:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 4:59 PM, Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:
    desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of
    time", blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    No. I don't. I think it means worthless, mad,
    unusable ideological nonsense.

    But - blessed by Einstein and certified by The
    Church of Relativity - definitely.

    YOU do. When asked you scream "NOOOO!!!!!" - but
    all of your "logic" is spinning around that axiom?
    postulate? dogma? whatever.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 22:47:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Den 11.11.2026 03:16, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:

    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the
    nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the
    GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.


    This is a strange statement.
    All the frequencies in a GPS SV are synthesised from the same
    frequency standard with the nominal frequency 10.23 MHz.

    In the GPS Interface Specification Document you will find: https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Quote from 3.3.1.1 Frequency Plan page 16:

    "The carrier frequencies for the L1 and L2 signals shall be
    coherently derived from a common frequency source within
    the SV. The nominal frequency of this source -- as it
    appears to an observer on the ground -- is 10.23 MHz.
    The SV carrier frequency and clock rates -- as they would
    appear to an observer located in the SV -- are offset to
    compensate for relativistic effects. The clock rates are
    offset by +of/f = -4.4647E-10, equivalent to a change in
    the P-code chipping rate of 10.23 MHz offset by a
    +of = -4.5674E-3 Hz. This is equal to 10.2299999954326 MHz.

    The nominal carrier frequencies (f0) shall be 1575.42 MHz,
    and 1227.6 MHz for L1 and L2, respectively.
    "

    The SV-clock is driven from this common frequency source, so the
    rate of the SV-clock is adjusted down by the factor (1-4.4647E-10)
    compared to a clock counting seconds according to the SI-definition.
    That means that the proper duration of one second from the SV-clock
    is (1+4.4647E-10)s = 1.00000000044647 s. (1s + 0.44627 ns)

    The carrier frequencies emitted by the SV are as you said:
    L1: 1575.42*(1-4.4647E-10) MHz = 1575.4199992966223 MHz
    L2: 1227.6*(1-4.4647E-10) MHz = 1227.5999994519134 MHz


    ------

    In GPS Block IIR SVs and later the frequency standard
    is a "Time Keeping System" (TKS).
    See:
    https://paulba.no/temp/IIR_TKS.pdf

    See block diagram in Figure 1:
    https://paulba.no/GPS/GPS_TKS.pdf

    RAFS = Rubidium Frequency Standard

    Notice that only Rubidium atomic clocks are used, not Cesium.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 23:33:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of time", blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    Maciej, "proper" is a technical term.

    It doesn't mean "morally superior".

    And "ideal clock" doesn't mean "a clock that Einstein personally approves of".

    It means a clock that accurately measures elapsed proper time along its worldline.

    No Higher Force.

    No divine certification.

    No sacred privilege.

    Just a precisely defined physical quantity and experimentally testable predictions.

    Einstein used 'Eigenzeit' which means 'own time'.
    The translation with 'proper time' is a bit unfortunate,
    and leads to incorrect associations in some cases, for some individuals. (nobody in particular in mind of course...)

    Compare 'Eigenvector', which is left untranslated in English.
    It is obviously too late to change 'proper time' to 'own time',
    or 'Eigentime', even though that would be much better,

    Jan
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Wed Nov 11 17:08:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 02:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of time",
    blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    Maciej, "proper" is a technical term.

    It doesn't mean "morally superior".

    And "ideal clock" doesn't mean "a clock that Einstein personally approves
    of".

    It means a clock that accurately measures elapsed proper time along its
    worldline.

    No Higher Force.

    No divine certification.

    No sacred privilege.

    Just a precisely defined physical quantity and experimentally testable
    predictions.

    Einstein used 'Eigenzeit' which means 'own time'.
    The translation with 'proper time' is a bit unfortunate,
    and leads to incorrect associations in some cases, for some individuals. (nobody in particular in mind of course...)

    Compare 'Eigenvector', which is left untranslated in English.
    It is obviously too late to change 'proper time' to 'own time',
    or 'Eigentime', even though that would be much better,

    Jan



    "Eigen" means more "like" or "same" than "own".


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 07:10:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 10:47 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 11.11.2026 03:16, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:

    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    -a-a ^^^^^^^^^^^^^-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the
    nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the
    GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.


    This is a strange statement.
    All the frequencies in a GPS SV are synthesised from the same
    frequency standard with the nominal frequency 10.23 MHz.

    In the GPS Interface Specification Document you will find: https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Quote from 3.3.1.1 Frequency Plan page 16:

    "The carrier frequencies for the L1 and L2 signals shall be
    -a-a coherently derived from a common frequency source within
    -a-a the SV. The nominal frequency of this source -- as it
    -a-a appears to an observer on the ground -- is 10.23 MHz.
    -a-a The SV carrier frequency and clock rates -- as they would
    -a-a appear to an observer located in the SV -- are offset to
    -a-a compensate for-a relativistic effects. The clock rates are
    -a-a offset by +of/f = -4.4647E-10, equivalent to a change in
    -a-a the P-code chipping rate of 10.23 MHz offset by a
    -a-a +of = -4.5674E-3 Hz. This is equal to 10.2299999954326 MHz.

    Yeah, it is what would appear to an observer if
    any was there.
    The measured (by the local clock) value is, however,
    10.223.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 07:13:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of time",
    blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    Maciej, "proper" is a technical term.

    It doesn't mean "morally superior".

    And "ideal clock" doesn't mean "a clock that Einstein personally approves
    of".

    It means a clock that accurately measures elapsed proper time along its
    worldline.

    No Higher Force.

    No divine certification.

    No sacred privilege.

    Just a precisely defined physical quantity and experimentally testable
    predictions.

    Einstein used 'Eigenzeit' which means 'own time'.
    The translation with 'proper time' is a bit unfortunate,
    and leads to incorrect associations in some cases, for some individuals.

    It's no way unfortunate, it's a common
    brainwashing practice well described
    by Orwell.
    It leads to incorrect associations for
    some individuals, right, that's what
    brainwashing is - leading to incorrect
    associations for some individuals.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 11:24:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of time", >>> blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    Maciej, "proper" is a technical term.

    It doesn't mean "morally superior".

    And "ideal clock" doesn't mean "a clock that Einstein personally approves >>> of".

    It means a clock that accurately measures elapsed proper time along its
    worldline.

    No Higher Force.

    No divine certification.

    No sacred privilege.

    Just a precisely defined physical quantity and experimentally testable
    predictions.

    Einstein used 'Eigenzeit' which means 'own time'.
    The translation with 'proper time' is a bit unfortunate,
    and leads to incorrect associations in some cases, for some individuals.

    It's no way unfortunate, it's a common
    brainwashing practice well described
    by Orwell.
    It leads to incorrect associations for
    some individuals, right, that's what
    brainwashing is - leading to incorrect
    associations for some individuals.

    Maciej,

    It's no way unfortunate, it's a common
    brainwashing practice well described
    by Orwell.

    ORWELL!

    Of course!

    We've now progressed from Einstein's equations to an international
    conspiracy involving the translation of a German word.

    Einstein used "Eigenzeit".

    Literally, "own time".

    In English, physicists call it "proper time".

    And "proper" can mean "belonging specifically to something", not merely "correct", "respectable", or "morally superior".

    As in "proper motion" in astronomy.

    Nobody imagines that stars exhibiting proper motion are morally superior
    to other stars.

    Except, perhaps, in your version of astrophysics.

    It leads to incorrect associations for
    some individuals

    Indeed, Maciej.

    And you are providing a spectacular demonstration.

    You read "proper time" and imagine:

    "THE HOLY TIME! THE PERFECT TIME! THE ONE TRUE CLOCK BLESSED BY EINSTEIN!"

    While physicists simply mean:

    "The elapsed time along a particular worldline."

    No moral judgment.

    No hierarchy of clocks.

    No Orwellian conspiracy.

    Just a technical term.

    And here's the beautiful irony:

    Lodder explicitly pointed out that the English translation might encourage incorrect associations.

    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly such an association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    You're doing the misunderstanding.

    But don't worry.

    We can call it "own time" from now on.

    The equations won't change.

    Neither will the GPS corrections.

    And neither, I suspect, will your objections. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 11:26:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Because we agreed about it hundred times and
    it is not important at all.

    Not important?

    The compensation is the VERY REASON why the corrected GPS clock outputs do
    not accumulate the predicted systematic drift.

    You cannot simply declare the central fact of the discussion irrelevant.

    Nope. The idiot knew nothing about Cs clock rates.

    Einstein didn't need to know anything about caesium clocks.

    His theory predicts relationships between elapsed times, independently of
    the particular physical mechanisms used to measure them.

    Newton knew nothing about GPS satellites either.

    Does that invalidate Newtonian orbital mechanics?

    Claiming that the rate is irrelevant to
    accumulated time is like claiming that
    speed is irrelevant to distance traveled.

    But it is.

    WHAT?!

    Maciej, if a vehicle moves at speed v(t), the distance traveled is
    obtained by integrating its speed over time.

    Likewise, the difference between two clock indications is obtained by integrating the difference between their rates, provided their initial indications are known.

    This is calculus.

    You are now apparently disputing the fundamental theorem of calculus to
    avoid acknowledging a GPS frequency measurement.

    What for? It would take some days at least
    and would be even stupider than The Shit
    of your idiot guru.

    So you propose a hypothetical "pendulum time dilation" theory as a counterexample.

    But when asked to formulate it, you refuse.

    How convenient.

    A theory with no equations, no numerical predictions and no experimental
    tests can hardly refute one that has all three.

    The clocks chosen by you because of fitting
    your idiocies were fitting your idiocies.

    Ah, the Great Caesium Conspiracy again!

    Maciej, the NTS-2 experiment did not merely select clocks whose behavior happened to agree with relativity.

    It compared a quantitative prediction with an observed frequency offset.

    Predicted: +445.0 x 10^-12.

    Measured: +443.1 x 10^-12.

    Before the relativistic frequency compensation was applied.

    And the relevant predictions concern elapsed proper time, not some
    mystical property unique to caesium.

    If you believe the result was engineered to fit the theory, provide
    evidence.

    What was manipulated?

    By whom?

    How?

    And why would that manipulation produce precisely the predicted offset?

    I think it means worthless, mad,
    unusable ideological nonsense.

    You are perfectly free to dislike the terminology.

    Call it "own time", as Einstein's German "Eigenzeit" suggests.

    Call it "elapsed time along a worldline".

    Call it whatever you please.

    The equations and measurements remain unchanged.

    But - blessed by Einstein and certified by
    The Church of Relativity - definitely.

    Maciej, you have now spent two posts arguing about whether a technical
    term carries Einstein's divine blessing.

    Meanwhile, the actual scientific question remains unanswered.

    Here is a simple challenge.

    Suppose two initially synchronized clocks have an experimentally measured fractional rate difference:

    epsilon = 4.431 x 10^-10.

    No compensation is applied.

    After 86400 seconds, what difference in their indications do you predict?

    The arithmetic gives approximately:

    38.28 microseconds.

    Do you agree?

    If not, show your calculation.

    And if you agree, explain why compensating that rate difference should
    count as a refutation of the prediction.

    No Einstein worship.

    No sacred clocks.

    No Orwell.

    No Church of Relativity.

    Just a measured rate, an elapsed time, and an elementary calculation.

    Surely your Serious Clock(TM) can manage that.

    It even has a tie. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 14:52:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Ross Finlayson <ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com> wrote:

    On 11/11/2026 02:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of time", >> blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    Maciej, "proper" is a technical term.

    It doesn't mean "morally superior".

    And "ideal clock" doesn't mean "a clock that Einstein personally approves >> of".

    It means a clock that accurately measures elapsed proper time along its
    worldline.

    No Higher Force.

    No divine certification.

    No sacred privilege.

    Just a precisely defined physical quantity and experimentally testable
    predictions.

    Einstein used 'Eigenzeit' which means 'own time'.
    The translation with 'proper time' is a bit unfortunate,
    and leads to incorrect associations in some cases, for some individuals. (nobody in particular in mind of course...)

    Compare 'Eigenvector', which is left untranslated in English.
    It is obviously too late to change 'proper time' to 'own time',
    or 'Eigentime', even though that would be much better,

    Jan



    "Eigen" means more "like" or "same" than "own".

    Like in 'Eigentum' for example?

    Where did you learn German?

    Jan
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:35:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Your desynchronizing junk is special,
    proper, perfectly good, marked by some
    Higher Force to be an obvious choice
    of the reference.

    Ah!

    NOW I understand.

    You think "proper time" means "a particularly respectable kind of
    time",
    blessed by Einstein and certified by the Church of Relativity.

    Maciej, "proper" is a technical term.

    It doesn't mean "morally superior".

    And "ideal clock" doesn't mean "a clock that Einstein personally
    approves
    of".

    It means a clock that accurately measures elapsed proper time along its >>>> worldline.

    No Higher Force.

    No divine certification.

    No sacred privilege.

    Just a precisely defined physical quantity and experimentally testable >>>> predictions.

    Einstein used 'Eigenzeit' which means 'own time'.
    The translation with 'proper time' is a bit unfortunate,
    and leads to incorrect associations in some cases, for some individuals.

    It's no way unfortunate, it's a common
    brainwashing practice well described
    by Orwell.
    It leads to incorrect associations for
    some individuals, right, that's what
    brainwashing is - leading to incorrect
    associations for some individuals.

    Maciej,

    It's no way unfortunate, it's a common
    brainwashing practice well described
    by Orwell.

    ORWELL!

    Of course!

    We've now progressed from Einstein's equations to an international conspiracy involving the translation of a German word.

    Einstein used "Eigenzeit".

    Literally, "own time".

    In English, physicists call it "proper time".

    And "proper" can mean "belonging specifically to something", not merely "correct", "respectable", or "morally superior".

    As in "proper motion" in astronomy.

    Nobody imagines that stars exhibiting proper motion are morally superior
    to other stars.

    Except, perhaps, in your version of astrophysics.

    It leads to incorrect associations for
    some individuals

    Indeed, Maciej.

    And you are providing a spectacular demonstration.

    You read "proper time" and imagine:

    "THE HOLY TIME! THE PERFECT TIME! THE ONE TRUE CLOCK BLESSED BY EINSTEIN!"

    While physicists simply mean:


    :)))
    Just an accidental coincidence of
    words, eh?


    No hierarchy of clocks.

    No Orwellian conspiracy.

    Just a technical term.

    And here's the beautiful irony:

    Lodder explicitly pointed out that the English translation might
    encourage incorrect associations.

    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly such an association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.


    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion
    was called "the idiot's delusion" - how would
    you get your moronic faith that it's a part of
    some Eternal Order of The Universe?



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 15:46:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    "If the idiot's delusion was called
    'the idiot's delusion'..."

    Ah, so your objection to proper time is now that it has the WRONG NAME.

    FASCINATING.

    You have progressed from disputing physics to disputing vocabulary, and
    now to accusing vocabulary of brainwashing people into believing physics.

    But here is a little experiment.

    Let's rename "proper time" to "Maciej's Idiotic Delusion".

    The elapsed time along a timelike worldline is still:

    +o-a = re2 sqrt(1 - v-#/c-#) dt

    in an inertial coordinate system in flat spacetime.

    The predictions remain exactly the same.

    The experiments remain exactly the same.

    GPS clocks still require relativistic corrections.

    NOTHING CHANGES.

    Because physical predictions do not depend on whether you like the terminology.

    You can rename proper time "banana time" if that makes you happier.

    The equations won't care.

    And neither will the clocks.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:56:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 12:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Because we agreed about it hundred times and
    it is not important at all.

    Not important?

    Yes.


    The compensation is the VERY REASON why the corrected GPS clock outputs
    do not accumulate the predicted systematic drift.

    All clocks of the reality are adjusted
    and always were.
    Of course, in your moronic gedankenwelt
    things are different - that's why idiots
    like you are getting the impression that
    it is something absolutely exceptional.


    Nope. The idiot knew nothing about Cs clock rates.

    Einstein didn't need to know anything about caesium clocks.

    His theory predicts relationships between elapsed times, independently
    of the particular physical mechanisms used to measure them.


    Your fellow idiot JJ has admitted it not so
    long ago. The atomic clocks sent to space
    fitted, but if they didn't you were ready
    to blame them. It works as I said - when
    the clocks don't fit they are wrong clocks.
    Newtonian physics worked the same way.


    Claiming that the rate is irrelevant to
    accumulated time is like claiming that
    speed is irrelevant to distance traveled.

    But it is.

    WHAT?!

    Newton's pendulums exhibited no difference
    in indications. Did they have the same rates?
    GPS clocks exhibit no. Do they have the same
    rates?



    What for? It would take some days at least
    and would be even stupider than The Shit
    of your idiot guru.

    So you propose a hypothetical "pendulum time dilation" theory as a counterexample.

    But when asked to formulate it, you refuse.

    How convenient.

    Do you seriously expect me to waste a
    week or more just to show some idiot
    that theories stupider than his Shit
    are possible and hear his MACIEJ!!!
    NOOOOOOO!!! again?



    The clocks chosen by you because of fitting
    your idiocies were fitting your idiocies.

    Ah, the Great Caesium Conspiracy again!

    You're too stupid for any conspiracy,
    again.




    Maciej, the NTS-2 experiment did not merely select clocks whose behavior happened to agree with relativity.

    Yeah, it sent PERFECT!!! PROPER!!! CORRECT!!!
    clocks. Being of course ready to blame them
    if they didn't confirm. The possibility
    of "we measure time and it doesn't fit so
    The Shit is wrong" doesn't exist in your
    "logic".



    What was manipulated?

    The clock fitting The Shit are fitting
    The Shit. The clocks not fitting are not.
    Relativistic idiot screams "THE CLOCKS
    FITTING ARE PROPRERCORRECTPERFECT!!!
    THE CLOCKS NOT FITTING ARE WRONG!!!!
    POLLUTED WITH CALIBRATION!!! OR ELSE!!!!.


    I think it means worthless, mad,
    unusable ideological nonsense.

    You are perfectly free to dislike the terminology.

    Call it "own time", as Einstein's German "Eigenzeit" suggests.

    Call it "elapsed time along a worldline".

    Call it whatever you please.

    I do, I'm calling it "the idiot's delusion",
    didn't you notice?



    The equations and measurements remain unchanged.

    Sure, 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000 on
    one clock-> 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on the other. Common sense had been
    warning the idiot.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:02:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    "All clocks of the reality are adjusted
    and always were."

    EXCELLENT!

    So you DO understand that a clock's displayed time can be adjusted independently of its underlying physical rate.

    NOW APPLY THAT INSIGHT TO GPS.

    "2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000 on
    one clock -> 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on the other."

    YES, MACIEJ!

    TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY THE SAME TIME.

    I HAVE NEVER DENIED THAT.

    But identical displayed readings do not imply identical uncorrected rates,
    any more than two watches showing noon must have identical oscillators.

    That is why clocks are CALIBRATED, SYNCHRONIZED AND CORRECTED.

    YOU YOURSELF JUST ACKNOWLEDGED THIS.

    "Newton's pendulums exhibited no difference
    in indications. Did they have the same rates?"

    Not necessarily!

    Two pendulum clocks can be adjusted to keep the same indicated time
    despite differences in their natural oscillation periods.

    Congratulations. You have rediscovered clock regulation.

    "The clocks fitting The Shit are fitting
    The Shit. The clocks not fitting are not."

    NO.

    A discrepancy between a prediction and a measurement is something to INVESTIGATE, not automatically dismiss.

    One must examine instrumental errors, calibration, environmental effects
    and the theoretical prediction.

    If a reliable, reproducible discrepancy remains, THE THEORY IS IN TROUBLE.

    That applies to relativity just as it does to every other physical theory.

    And your repeated shouting of "PERFECT!!! PROPER!!! CORRECT!!!" does not change what proper time means.

    A clock measuring proper time is not a clock blessed by Einstein.

    It is a physical clock whose elapsed time can be compared with the
    proper-time prediction along its worldline, within its measurement uncertainties.

    So here is a very simple question:

    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?

    YES OR NO?

    Because if the answer is YES, your GPS timestamp argument collapses.

    And if the answer is NO, you have just contradicted your own statement
    that clocks are adjusted.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 17:02:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 4:46 PM, Python wrote:
    -a-a "If the idiot's delusion was called
    -a-a-a 'the idiot's delusion'..."

    Ah, so your objection to proper time is now that it has the WRONG NAME.

    FASCINATING.

    You have progressed from disputing physics to disputing vocabulary, and > now to accusing vocabulary of brainwashing people into believing physics.

    But here is a little experiment.

    Let's rename "proper time" to "Maciej's Idiotic Delusion".

    The elapsed time along a timelike worldline is still:

    -a-a +o-a = re2 sqrt(1 - v-#/c-#) dt


    And the real measured values are still
    2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000 on one
    clock->2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000 on
    the other.





    in an inertial coordinate system in flat spacetime.

    The predictions remain exactly the same.

    The experiments remain exactly the same.

    GPS clocks still require relativistic corrections.

    The ones directly forbidden by your idiotic
    religion.


    NOTHING CHANGES.

    Yes, something changes. 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on one clock->2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000 on
    the other - is not an improper result anymore.
    No idiot is screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!!!!"
    (think 2 or 3 times before asserting that
    you've never said that, poor piece of shit).


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:08:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    And the real measured values are still
    2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000 on one
    clock -> 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on the other.

    FINE!

    Two corrected clock outputs display the same time.

    Congratulations!

    That's precisely what synchronization is supposed to achieve.

    Now, Maciej, a very simple question:

    WHAT DOES THAT TELL US ABOUT THE UNCORRECTED CLOCK RATES?

    Absolutely nothing, unless you also know which corrections have been
    applied.

    Two clocks can have different underlying rates and still deliver
    synchronized outputs when those differences are compensated.

    This is not a relativistic peculiarity.

    It is elementary metrology.

    The ones directly forbidden by your idiotic
    religion.

    Still waiting for that prohibition, Maciej.

    An actual quotation.

    A sentence.

    An equation.

    Anything.

    So far, your evidence consists of repeatedly asserting that the
    prohibition exists.

    2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on one clock -> 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on the other - is not an improper result anymore.

    IMPROPER RESULT?!

    Maciej, you've managed to misunderstand the word "proper" AGAIN.

    "Proper time" does not mean "the only acceptable time".

    And "coordinate time" does not mean "improper time".

    Neither does "corrected time" mean "false time".

    These are technical terms describing DIFFERENT quantities.

    An ideal clock measures elapsed proper time along its worldline.

    A GPS clock output is intended to represent a common coordinate time
    scale.

    Both are perfectly legitimate.

    Nobody is screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!"

    Except, apparently, the imaginary relativists living in your head.

    No idiot is screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!!!!"

    Of course not.

    GPS time is a perfectly legitimate coordinate time scale.

    But it is not identical, by definition, to the proper time accumulated
    along every satellite's worldline.

    And its realization requires precisely the clock models and corrections
    you keep pretending relativity forbids.

    Here's an experiment for you.

    Take two initially synchronized clocks with a measured fractional rate difference of:

    4.4647 x 10^-10.

    Leave them uncompensated for one day.

    Their indications diverge by approximately:

    38.5 microseconds.

    Now compensate that rate difference.

    Their corrected outputs can remain synchronized.

    17:00:00 on one.

    17:00:00 on the other.

    EXACTLY WHAT WE WANTED.

    But the successful compensation does not make the original rate difference vanish.

    And it certainly doesn't demonstrate Galilean time.

    Maciej, your entire argument now seems to be:

    "I want the clocks to agree."

    Engineers: "Fine. We'll compensate for their rate differences."

    "They agree! Einstein was wrong!"

    This is becoming a wonderful demonstration of the difference between
    physics and wishful thinking.

    Your Serious Clock(TM), wearing its impeccable tie, would probably put it
    more simply:

    "Maciej, ZERO RESIDUAL ERROR is not the same thing as ZERO PHYSICAL
    EFFECT."

    Perhaps you should listen to it.

    It seems to be the only serious clock in the room.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 17:11:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 5:02 PM, Python wrote:
    -a-a "All clocks of the reality are adjusted
    -a-a-a and always were."

    EXCELLENT!

    So you DO understand that a clock's displayed time can be adjusted independently of its underlying physical rate.

    NOW APPLY THAT INSIGHT TO GPS.

    -a-a "2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000 on
    -a-a-a one clock -> 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    -a-a-a on the other."

    YES, MACIEJ!

    TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY THE SAME TIME.

    I HAVE NEVER DENIED THAT.

    Oh, yes, poor piece of shit, you have.


    But identical displayed readings do not imply identical uncorrected
    rates

    Did they in Newtonian physics, where no
    dilation idiocy existed?





    A discrepancy between a prediction and a measurement is something to INVESTIGATE, not automatically dismiss.
    One must examine instrumental errors, calibration, environmental effects
    and the theoretical prediction.

    If a reliable, reproducible discrepancy remains, THE THEORY IS IN TROUBLE. That applies to relativity just as it does to every other physical theory.

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. You have
    no clue how your religion works, no surprise -
    it's a bit complicated and you're a primitive
    idiot.



    A clock measuring proper time is not a clock blessed by Einstein.

    Wrong like always.


    So here is a very simple question:

    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?

    YES OR NO?

    Yes. Do you?
    Not so long ago you were asserting that
    "Maciej, the rate is precisely what determines how the difference in indications evolves. "

    Because if the answer is YES, your GPS timestamp argument collapses.

    Pfffff.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:17:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL
    READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS
    HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?

    Yes. Do you?

    YES!

    ABSOLUTELY!

    UNRESERVEDLY!

    And thank you for finally agreeing.

    Now let's examine your supposed contradiction.

    Not so long ago you were asserting that
    "Maciej, the rate is precisely what determines
    how the difference in indications evolves."

    Correct.

    And I stand by it.

    The rate of a clock's INDICATION determines how that indication evolves.

    If the clock output is uncorrected, its rate reflects the underlying oscillator, subject to the clock's internal frequency conversion.

    If the output is corrected, its effective rate includes that correction.

    Mathematically, if I1(t) and I2(t) are the two displayed indications:

    I1(T) - I2(T)
    =
    I1(0) - I2(0)
    + integral[0,T] (I1'(t) - I2'(t)) dt.

    That is an identity.

    Now suppose the underlying oscillators have different rates.

    Without compensation, their indications generally drift apart.

    With suitable compensation, the OUTPUT rates can be made equal, and the displayed indications can remain synchronized.

    There is no contradiction whatsoever.

    Did they in Newtonian physics, where no
    dilation idiocy existed?

    YES, Maciej.

    Even in Newtonian physics, two pendulum clocks can have different rates because their lengths or local gravitational accelerations differ.

    And they can nevertheless be adjusted to display the same time.

    Adjusting a pendulum does not prove that its original period was identical
    to that of another pendulum.

    Nor does adjusting a GPS clock prove that its original relativistic
    frequency offset was zero.

    Of course, the physical explanations differ: Newtonian pendulum behavior depends on the mechanism, whereas relativistic proper-time differences are
    not specific to pendulums or atomic clocks.

    But the distinction between an uncorrected rate and a corrected indication
    is elementary in BOTH cases.

    And now we have reached a rather interesting point.

    You explicitly agree that:

    1. Two clocks can have different uncorrected physical rates.
    2. Their corrected outputs can nevertheless display identical readings.

    So your repeated GPS argument:

    "Both clocks display 17:00:00, therefore Einstein's prediction is false"

    DOES NOT FOLLOW.

    To test the prediction, we must examine the underlying rate differences
    and the corrections required to produce synchronized outputs.

    Which is precisely what GPS engineering does.

    And which is precisely why the NTS-2 frequency-offset measurement matters.

    Because if the answer is YES, your GPS timestamp
    argument collapses.

    Pfffff.

    An impressive rebuttal, Maciej.

    After hundreds of messages, you finally concede that two clocks can
    display identical readings despite having different uncorrected physical rates.

    Which is precisely why your repeated argument that identical GPS
    timestamps disprove relativistic time dilation is invalid.

    And your response?

    "Pfffff."

    No calculation.

    No counterexample.

    No explanation of why the conclusion supposedly doesn't follow.

    Just the sound of air escaping from an argument that has finally been punctured.

    Maciej, we finally agree on the distinction that invalidates your favorite argument.

    The only remaining mystery is why you keep using it.

    Perhaps your Serious Clock(TM) could explain.

    It has already mastered the distinction between an oscillator and a
    display.

    And it wears a tie.

    Apparently, it can now serve as a pressure gauge, too.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 17:19:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 5:08 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    And the real measured values are still
    2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000 on one
    clock -> 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on the other.

    FINE!

    Two corrected clock outputs display the same time.

    Congratulations!

    That's precisely what synchronization is supposed to achieve.

    Now, Maciej, a very simple question:

    WHAT DOES THAT TELL US ABOUT THE UNCORRECTED CLOCK RATES?

    That they're not important.





    The ones directly forbidden by your idiotic
    religion.

    Still waiting for that prohibition, Maciej.

    You've got it.


    2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on one clock -> 2026-11-12 17:00:00.000000000
    on the other - is not an improper result anymore.

    IMPROPER RESULT?!

    Maciej, you've managed to misunderstand the word "proper" AGAIN.

    "Proper time" does not mean "the only acceptable time".

    And "coordinate time" does not mean "improper time".

    Neither does "corrected time" mean "false time".

    These are technical terms describing DIFFERENT quantities.

    An ideal clock measures elapsed proper time along its worldline.

    A GPS clock output is intended to represent a common coordinate time scale.

    Both are perfectly legitimate.

    Nobody is screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!"


    I've warned you, poor piece of shit - thinkbefore asserting that...

    Quoting:
    Maciej,
    YES.
    I accept the actual numerical readings displayed by the actual clocks.
    For the umpteenth time.
    But you keep adding something that the clocks DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:23:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    WHAT DOES THAT TELL US ABOUT THE UNCORRECTED CLOCK RATES?

    That they're not important.

    NOT IMPORTANT?!

    Maciej, the uncorrected frequency offsets are precisely what the
    relativistic calculations predict and what GPS engineers must account for.

    Without knowing those offsets, how would you determine the appropriate frequency compensation?

    By divine inspiration?

    By consulting your Serious Clock(TM)?

    Or by declaring that the offsets are "not important" until they disappear?

    The fact that a correction works does not make the phenomenon being
    corrected irrelevant.

    Quite the opposite.

    Still waiting for that prohibition, Maciej.

    You've got it.

    No, Maciej.

    I've got your repeated ASSERTION that relativity forbids clock
    corrections.

    What I still don't have is an actual quotation from Einstein, a relativity textbook, or a technical specification stating such a prohibition.

    Please provide one.

    A page number would be nice.

    An equation would be even better.

    Nobody is screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!"

    I've warned you, poor piece of shit - think
    before asserting that...

    Quoting:

    Maciej,
    YES.
    I accept the actual numerical readings displayed
    by the actual clocks.
    For the umpteenth time.
    But you keep adding something that the clocks
    DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    BRILLIANT!

    You have just quoted me explicitly ACCEPTING the actual clock readings.

    And you present that as evidence that I DENIED them!

    Let's read the quotation again:

    "I accept the actual numerical readings displayed
    by the actual clocks."

    Which part of "I accept" do you interpret as "I reject"?

    And the rest of the quotation makes a completely different point.

    A clock displays an indication.

    That indication alone does not establish which physical time scale it represents, how it was generated, or which corrections were applied.

    When you add "THE REAL TIME" as though it were a uniquely defined physical quantity automatically identified by the displayed digits, you are making
    an additional claim.

    One that requires justification.

    GPS time is a perfectly legitimate coordinate time scale.

    Proper time is the elapsed time along a particular worldline.

    Neither is "fake time".

    Neither is "morally superior time".

    And neither is invalidated by the existence of the other.

    You keep treating the distinction between these quantities as though it
    were a refusal to accept what a clock displays.

    It isn't.

    And your own quotation proves that I have explicitly said so.

    Now, let's return to the question you keep avoiding.

    The NTS-2 experiment measured a fractional frequency offset close to the relativistic prediction.

    Predicted: +445.0 x 10^-12.
    Measured: +443.1 x 10^-12.

    Those numbers concern a physical frequency comparison, not an argument
    about the word "proper".

    Do you dispute the measurement?

    Do you dispute the calculation?

    Or do you simply declare both "not important" because corrected GPS
    outputs can be synchronized?

    Maciej, science does not work by declaring inconvenient measurements irrelevant.

    And quoting someone saying "I accept the readings" as proof that he
    rejects the readings is a rather spectacular exercise in reading comprehension.

    Perhaps the Serious Clock(TM) could help.

    It already knows the difference between an oscillator and a display.

    Now it only needs to teach you the difference between "I accept" and "I
    deny".

    One lesson at a time.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:26:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity


    https://ibb.co/2YWbJzK9


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 17:29:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 5:17 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL
    READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS
    HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?

    Yes. Do you?

    YES!

    ABSOLUTELY!

    UNRESERVEDLY!

    And thank you for finally agreeing.

    Now let's examine your supposed contradiction.

    Not so long ago you were asserting that
    "Maciej, the rate is precisely what determines
    how the difference in indications evolves."

    Correct.

    And I stand by it.

    The rate of a clock's INDICATION determines how that indication evolves.

    You're indeed pathetic, poor piece of shit.
    Of course, it was known before.



    Did they in Newtonian physics, where no
    dilation idiocy existed?

    YES, Maciej.

    Even in Newtonian physics, two pendulum clocks can have different rates because their lengths or local gravitational accelerations differ.

    Adjusting a pendulum does not prove that its original period was
    identical to that of another pendulum.

    Nor does adjusting a GPS clock prove that its original relativistic frequency offset was zero.

    Of course, the physical explanations differ: Newtonian pendulum behavior depends on the mechanism, whereas relativistic proper-time differences
    are not specific to pendulums or atomic clocks.

    Of course, existence or not of your time
    dilation idiocy depends on so much despised
    by you vocabulary.




    1. Two clocks can have different uncorrected physical rates.
    2. Their corrected outputs can nevertheless display identical readings.

    So your repeated GPS argument:

    "Both clocks display 17:00:00, therefore Einstein's prediction is false"

    DOES NOT FOLLOW.

    Yes it does.



    To test the prediction, we must examine the underlying rate differences

    They're irrelevant. Check Newton's pendulums.
    The real result of your idiocy is your
    mad faith that the clocks showing it are
    perfectly good. If somebody worshiped
    unadjusted pendulums "pendulum time dilation"
    would be as real to him as your idiocy is real
    for you.






    and the corrections required to produce synchronized outputs.

    Which is precisely what GPS engineering does.

    And which is precisely why the NTS-2 frequency-offset measurement matters.

    Because if the answer is YES, your GPS timestamp
    argument collapses.

    Pfffff.

    An impressive rebuttal, Maciej.

    After hundreds of messages, you finally concede that two clocks can
    display identical readings despite having different uncorrected physical rates.

    Which is precisely why your repeated argument that identical GPS

    Well, you were always a piece of impudently
    lying shit, so no surprise you're still.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 17:32:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 5:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    WHAT DOES THAT TELL US ABOUT THE UNCORRECTED CLOCK RATES?

    That they're not important.

    NOT IMPORTANT?!

    Maciej, the uncorrected frequency offsets are precisely what the relativistic calculations predict


    No, poor piece of shit, the idiot was babbling
    about the indications of clock, not about the
    rates.

    Still waiting for that prohibition, Maciej.

    You've got it.

    No, Maciej.


    Yes, Python.


    Nobody is screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!"

    I've warned you, poor piece of shit - think
    before asserting that...

    Quoting:

    Maciej,
    YES.
    I accept the actual numerical readings displayed
    by the actual clocks.
    For the umpteenth time.
    But you keep adding something that the clocks
    DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    BRILLIANT!

    You have just quoted me explicitly ACCEPTING the actual clock readings.

    And screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!!!"

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:35:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Two more posts, and still the same confusion.

    Let's take them one at a time.

    Of course, existence or not of your time
    dilation idiocy depends on so much despised
    by you vocabulary.

    No, Maciej.

    The existence of a physical effect does not depend on vocabulary.

    Call it "time dilation", "clock-rate difference", or "Maciej's
    Unmentionable Phenomenon".

    The experimental measurements remain unchanged.

    Changing the name of a physical quantity does not change its value.

    They're irrelevant. Check Newton's pendulums.

    Excellent idea!

    Let's check Newton's pendulums.

    For a simple pendulum, in the small-amplitude approximation:

    T = 2*pi*sqrt(L/g).

    Its period depends on its length L and the local gravitational
    acceleration g.

    Change L or g, and its rate changes.

    Adjust L appropriately, and you can compensate for a change in g.

    Does that mean gravity has no effect on pendulum periods?

    OF COURSE NOT.

    It means you have compensated for the effect.

    And there is a fundamental distinction you keep ignoring.

    A pendulum's period depends on the details of its mechanism.

    Relativistic proper-time differences, on the other hand, concern the
    spacetime paths followed by ideal clocks, independently of their
    particular construction.

    That is why relativity can be tested using different physical clock mechanisms.

    Your imaginary "pendulum time dilation" is not a competing theory until
    you formulate it mathematically and derive testable predictions.

    So far, you have provided neither.

    If somebody worshiped unadjusted pendulums
    "pendulum time dilation" would be as real
    to him as your idiocy is real for you.

    Nobody worships unadjusted atomic clocks.

    We MEASURE their behavior.

    We compare it with quantitative predictions.

    And we investigate discrepancies.

    The NTS-2 experiment measured a fractional frequency offset of
    approximately:

    +443.1 x 10^-12.

    The relativistic prediction was approximately:

    +445.0 x 10^-12.

    No worship required.

    Just an experiment.

    No, poor piece of shit, the idiot was babbling
    about the indications of clock, not about the
    rates.

    Maciej, this is becoming extraordinary.

    A difference in clock indications is what ACCUMULATES when their rates
    differ.

    If two initially synchronized clock indications are I1(t) and I2(t), then:

    I1(T) - I2(T)
    =
    integral[0,T] (I1'(t) - I2'(t)) dt.

    This is elementary calculus.

    You cannot separate accumulated differences from rates as though they were unrelated phenomena.

    And Einstein did not need to know about caesium oscillators to predict differences in elapsed time.

    His predictions concern the physical behavior of clocks along specified trajectories.

    Atomic clocks simply provide a particularly precise way to test them.

    Still waiting for that prohibition, Maciej.

    You've got it.

    No, Maciej.

    Yes, Python.

    Fascinating.

    We have now reached the "Yes, you have / No, I haven't" stage of
    theoretical physics.

    Maciej, please provide the actual statement from relativity that
    supposedly FORBIDS compensating clock outputs.

    Not your interpretation.

    Not an insult.

    Not another declaration that you've already provided it.

    An actual quotation, with a reference.

    Until then, your alleged prohibition remains entirely imaginary.

    I accept the actual numerical readings displayed
    by the actual clocks.
    For the umpteenth time.
    But you keep adding something that the clocks
    DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    And screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!!!"

    Maciej, let's examine your quotation.

    I wrote:

    "I accept the actual numerical readings displayed
    by the actual clocks."

    And you somehow translate this into:

    "NOT THE REAL TIME!!!"

    No.

    I am not denying the readings.

    I am denying YOUR unsupported interpretation of them.

    A GPS clock displaying 17:00:00 is displaying a perfectly legitimate time indication.

    But those digits alone do not tell us whether the output has been
    corrected, what time scale it represents, or what the uncorrected
    oscillator frequency was.

    You have already AGREED that two clocks can display identical readings
    while their uncorrected oscillators have different rates.

    So you know this distinction exists.

    Yet you continue pretending that acknowledging it amounts to denying the displayed time.

    It doesn't.

    And now, Maciej, here is the question you have avoided throughout this discussion.

    If GPS satellite oscillators exhibit the relativistically predicted
    frequency offsets, and engineers compensate for those offsets to maintain
    a common time scale, HOW DOES THE SUCCESS OF THAT COMPENSATION REFUTE THE PREDICTION?

    Please explain the logical connection.

    Not "Pfffff".

    Not "Yes, Python".

    Not "religion".

    Not another insult.

    An actual argument.

    Because at present your position amounts to:

    1. Relativity predicts a systematic clock-rate difference.
    2. The difference is experimentally observed.
    3. Engineers compensate for it.
    4. Corrected clock outputs agree.
    5. Therefore relativity is false.

    Step 5 does not follow from steps 1 through 4.

    In fact, steps 1 through 4 are exactly what we would expect if the relativistic prediction were correct.

    Your Serious Clock(TM) understands this.

    It even put it on a whiteboard.

    Perhaps you should read it before your next "Pfffff".
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 17:55:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 5:35 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Two more posts, and still the same confusion.

    Let's take them one at a time.

    Of course, existence or not of your time
    dilation idiocy depends on so much despised
    by you vocabulary.

    No, Maciej.

    Yes, python.
    The existence of a physical effect does not depend on vocabulary.

    Sorry, poor piece of shit, yes it does.

    Call it "time dilation", "clock-rate difference", or "Maciej's
    Unmentionable Phenomenon".

    How about "the idiot's delusion"?
    Delusions don't exist, do you realize that
    or are you too stupid even for that?
    How were things with the existence of
    the thing called "gravitational force"
    in your moronic religion, BTW?


    The experimental measurements remain unchanged.

    Sorry, poor piece of shit, they definitely
    doesn't.


    Changing the name of a physical quantity does not change its value.

    But changing "a proper clock" to "an erroneous
    clock" does change that value, poor piece of
    shit.
    They're irrelevant. Check Newton's pendulums.

    Excellent idea!

    Let's check Newton's pendulums.

    For a simple pendulum, in the small-amplitude approximation:

    T = 2*pi*sqrt(L/g).

    Its period depends on its length L and the local gravitational
    acceleration g.

    And - no matter what it is - the
    indications of the clock follow the
    Earth time. The decisive factor is
    out of your moronic tales.



    Relativistic proper-time differences, on the other hand, concern the spacetime paths followed by ideal clocks, independently of their
    particular construction.

    Unless another theory asserts otherwise and
    give you a direct formula for correcting
    them to t'=t, same as it is with pendulums.


    If somebody worshiped unadjusted pendulums
    "pendulum time dilation" would be as real
    to him as your idiocy is real for you.

    Nobody worships unadjusted atomic clocks.

    A million of idiots does.



    No, poor piece of shit, the idiot was babbling
    about the indications of clock, not about the
    rates.

    Maciej, this is becoming extraordinary.

    A difference in clock indications is what ACCUMULATES when their rates differ.

    Once again, poor piece of shit.
    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL
    READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS
    HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?




    I accept the actual numerical readings displayed
    by the actual clocks.
    For the umpteenth time.
    But you keep adding something that the clocks
    DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    And screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!!!"

    Maciej, let's examine your quotation.

    I wrote:

    You wrote " DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."
    Well, expecting from you the ability
    of reading your own nonsenses is too
    much, I guess.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 16:59:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    The existence of a physical effect does not depend on vocabulary.

    Sorry, poor piece of shit, yes it does.

    https://ibb.co/Wv6zzz6c

    Wonderful.

    We have now reached the point where physical phenomena apparently appear
    and disappear when someone changes a word.

    Does gravity stop working when we call it "spacetime curvature" instead of "gravitational force"?

    Does an electric current disappear when we rename it?

    Does a clock change its frequency when we insult it?

    Let's investigate.

    How about "the idiot's delusion"?
    Delusions don't exist, do you realize that
    or are you too stupid even for that?

    Actually, delusions can exist as psychological phenomena.

    But never mind.

    Call relativistic time dilation "the idiot's delusion" if you wish.

    The NTS-2 frequency measurement remains approximately:

    +443.1 x 10^-12.

    The relativistic prediction remains approximately:

    +445.0 x 10^-12.

    Renaming the phenomenon does not alter either number.

    You need an experimental or mathematical argument to challenge those
    results, not a vocabulary exercise.

    How were things with the existence of
    the thing called "gravitational force"
    in your moronic religion, BTW?

    Ah, gravity!

    An excellent example of why terminology and physical predictions must be distinguished.

    Newton describes gravitation using a force.

    General relativity describes freely falling bodies using spacetime
    geometry.

    These are different theoretical descriptions, with different domains of validity and different predictions in certain circumstances.

    But changing the word "force" to "curvature" does not change the observed trajectory of a falling object.

    Nor does it magically erase the experiments that distinguish the theories.

    You seem to think that because physical theories can describe phenomena differently, the phenomena themselves are created by vocabulary.

    They aren't.

    But changing "a proper clock" to "an erroneous
    clock" does change that value, poor piece of shit.

    NO.

    Changing the LABEL does not change the VALUE.

    Changing the physical adjustment of a clock can change its output.

    Those are two entirely different operations.

    If I call a caesium clock "erroneous", its oscillator does not suddenly
    change frequency.

    If I actually adjust its frequency synthesizer, its output rate can
    change.

    Do you genuinely not see the distinction?

    And - no matter what it is - the
    indications of the clock follow the
    Earth time.

    Only if the clock is suitably adjusted or corrected, Maciej.

    An unadjusted pendulum moved to a location with a different gravitational acceleration will generally change its rate.

    That is precisely why pendulum clocks require calibration.

    You are using the SUCCESS of an adjustment as evidence that the unadjusted difference does not matter.

    Again.

    Unless another theory asserts otherwise and
    give you a direct formula for correcting
    them to t'=t, same as it is with pendulums.

    Excellent!

    Then please PRESENT THAT THEORY.

    Give its equations.

    Define its variables.

    Derive its predictions.

    And compare them quantitatively with measurements.

    In particular, explain the NTS-2 frequency offset without merely borrowing
    the relativistic correction formula.

    But there is a more fundamental problem.

    Making two clock outputs display the same coordinate time does not
    establish the Galilean transformation t'=t between inertial frames.

    Clock synchronization and coordinate transformations are not the same
    thing.

    You cannot turn Lorentz transformations into Galilean transformations by adjusting a clock.

    A million of idiots does.

    A million people allegedly worshiping clocks?

    Maciej, your sociological research is becoming as fascinating as your
    physics.

    Do you have a survey?

    Or is this another number obtained by consulting your Serious Clock(TM)?

    A difference in clock indications is what
    ACCUMULATES when their rates differ.

    Once again, poor piece of shit.
    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL
    READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS
    HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?

    YES, MACIEJ.

    FOR THE THIRD TIME: YES.

    And this is NOT a contradiction.

    You are confusing two different rates:

    1. The rate of the uncorrected physical oscillator.
    2. The effective rate of the corrected clock indication.

    If the uncorrected rates differ, uncorrected indications can accumulate a difference.

    If appropriate compensation is applied, the corrected indications can
    remain synchronized.

    The relationship is elementary:

    Accumulated indication difference
    =
    Initial indication difference
    +
    Integral of the difference between OUTPUT rates.

    The compensation changes the output rates.

    It does not retroactively erase the physical frequency offset that
    motivated the compensation.

    YOU HAVE ALREADY AGREED WITH THIS.

    And yet you keep repeating the question as though the answer were a devastating objection.

    It isn't.

    It is the explanation of how GPS works.

    You wrote "DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    Yes.

    And you have again removed the crucial context.

    I wrote:

    "I accept the actual numerical readings displayed
    by the actual clocks."

    Then I objected to YOUR additional assertion that those readings, by themselves, establish some uniquely defined quantity called "THE REAL
    TIME".

    They don't.

    A displayed timestamp does not tell us, by itself, which time scale the
    clock realizes, which corrections were applied, or what its uncorrected oscillator rate was.

    That is not denying the displayed reading.

    It is refusing to infer information that the reading alone does not
    contain.

    A thermometer displaying 20 degrees does not tell you whether it has been calibrated.

    A clock displaying 17:00:00 does not tell you whether its oscillator has
    been frequency-corrected.

    In both cases, the displayed number is real.

    The interpretation requires additional information.

    And now, Maciej, let's return to the question you have avoided for
    hundreds of messages.

    You agree that two clocks can display identical readings despite having different uncorrected physical rates.

    You also know that GPS engineers apply frequency corrections.

    So HOW can identical corrected readings establish that the uncorrected relativistic frequency offsets do not exist?

    Please give us an actual logical argument.

    Not a new name.

    Not a new insult.

    Not another "Yes, Python".

    And not another invocation of your imaginary Church of Relativity.

    Just explain how correcting a measured difference proves that the
    difference was never there.

    Your Serious Clock(TM) is waiting.

    It has checked its oscillator.

    It has checked its output.

    It has checked its tie.

    Everything is properly adjusted.

    Except, apparently, your reasoning. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 18:14:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 5:59 PM, Python wrote:
    The existence of a physical effect does not depend on vocabulary.

    Sorry, poor piece of shit, yes it does.

    https://ibb.co/Wv6zzz6c

    Wonderful.

    We have now reached the point where physical phenomena apparently appear
    and disappear when someone changes a word.

    Does gravity stop working when we call it "spacetime curvature" instead
    of "gravitational force"?

    Gravity exists and works - yet. How about
    "gravitational force", poor piece of shit?


    How about "the idiot's delusion"?
    Delusions don't exist, do you realize that
    or are you too stupid even for that?

    Actually, delusions can exist as psychological phenomena.

    But never mind.

    Call relativistic time dilation "the idiot's delusion" if you wish.

    The NTS-2 frequency measurement remains approximately:


    And the really measured difference in
    indications is - 0.




    But changing "a proper clock" to "an erroneous
    clock" does change that value, poor piece of shit.

    NO.

    Yes.

    Changing the LABEL does not change the VALUE.

    Changing the physical adjustment of a clock can change its output.

    The output is the measurement result.
    Measurement result is the value of
    the physical quantity. Yes, changing
    the label DOES. Words have the power,
    poor piece of shit.


    If I call a caesium clock "erroneous", its oscillator does not suddenly change frequency.

    That's exactly what is going to happen.



    And - no matter what it is - the
    indications of the clock follow the
    Earth time.

    Only if the clock is suitably adjusted or corrected, Maciej.

    In the reality they always are.
    The decisive for clock indications
    factor is out of your primitive
    tales.



    Unless another theory asserts otherwise and
    give you a direct formula for correcting
    them to t'=t, same as it is with pendulums.

    Excellent!

    Then please PRESENT THAT THEORY.

    Easy one this time. It's ready, it's called
    LET.




    A difference in clock indications is what
    ACCUMULATES when their rates differ.

    Once again, poor piece of shit.
    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL
    READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS
    HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?

    YES, MACIEJ.

    So your crap a paragraph above is crap.

    FOR THE THIRD TIME: YES.

    And this is NOT a contradiction.

    Yes it is.



    You wrote "DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    Yes.

    Yes. qed.
    And - with "proper time" called correctly
    as "the idiot's delusion" what it really is
    - no more idiots screaming "NOT THE REAL
    TIME" would exist.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Yousel Bahlaev@aaob@hbshu.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 19:59:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    J. J. Lodder wrote:

    Einstein used 'Eigenzeit' which means 'own time'.
    The translation with 'proper time' is a bit unfortunate,
    and leads to incorrect associations in some cases, for some individuals. (nobody in particular in mind of course...)

    Compare 'Eigenvector', which is left untranslated in English.
    It is obviously too late to change 'proper time' to 'own time',
    or 'Eigentime', even though that would be much better,

    actually more like a one's property, rather then own, thus he correctly referred to the passage of time

    the fools are translating it as proper, which is something completely else
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kurtis Balahonov@ovi@vruvbs.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 20:18:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    "The carrier frequencies for the L1 and L2 signals shall be
    -a-a coherently derived from a common frequency source within the SV.
    -a-a The nominal frequency of this source -- as it appears to an
    -a-a observer on the ground -- is 10.23 MHz.
    -a-a The SV carrier frequency and clock rates -- as they would appear
    -a-a to an observer located in the SV -- are offset to compensate for-a
    -a-a relativistic effects. The clock rates are offset by +of/f =
    -a-a -4.4647E-10, equivalent to a change in the P-code chipping rate
    -a-a of 10.23 MHz offset by a +of = -4.5674E-3 Hz. This is equal to
    -a-a 10.2299999954326 MHz.

    Yeah, it is what would appear to an observer if any was there.
    The measured (by the local clock) value is, however,
    10.223.

    1Hz = 1p/sec, in space
    1Hz = 1p/(sec+x), on earth

    in space times goes faster (earth dilates), so it has to slow down a bit
    to coincide to the earth 10.23 MHz passage

    it's not an offset, but a constant passage difference
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Salomon Bakurov@orsmu@koroualo.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 21:33:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    Does gravity stop working when we call it "spacetime curvature" instead
    of "gravitational force"?

    Gravity exists and works - yet. How about "gravitational force", poor
    piece of shit?

    good catch, but is not a force, but a distortion of spacetime

    but you pollacks have to go to war to defend europe, as you guys are expandable

    for europe, you pollacks and ukrans are expandable

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 12 21:45:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Gravity exists and works - yet. How about
    "gravitational force", poor piece of shit?

    Newtonian gravity is described as a force. General relativity describes
    free fall in terms of spacetime geometry.

    Different theoretical descriptions. Different predictions in some circumstances.

    Same observed falling objects.

    The vocabulary does not make them fall.

    And the really measured difference in
    indications is - 0.

    Of CORRECTED GPS clock outputs, Maciej.

    You keep omitting the word "corrected", as though doing so could make the corrections disappear.

    The uncorrected NTS-2 fractional frequency offset was measured at approximately +443.1 x 10^-12, close to the predicted +445.0 x 10^-12.

    That is an actual measurement.

    Your synchronized timestamps do not refute it.

    The output is the measurement result.
    Measurement result is the value of
    the physical quantity.

    A clock output is an indication. What physical quantity that indication represents depends on the clock's design, calibration and corrections.

    An instrument's displayed value is not automatically identical to every physical quantity involved in producing it.

    A GPS clock can output coordinate time while its underlying oscillator experiences a relativistic frequency offset.

    That is the whole point.

    Yes, changing the label DOES. Words have
    the power, poor piece of shit.

    If I call a caesium clock "erroneous", its
    oscillator does not suddenly change frequency.

    That's exactly what is going to happen.

    SPECTACULAR!

    https://ibb.co/C5M7Nm8m

    So if I put a sticker saying "ERRONEOUS" on a caesium clock, its atomic transition frequency will physically change?

    By how much?

    In which direction?

    Can you provide the equation relating the frequency shift to the wording
    on the sticker?

    Does calling it "PERFECTLY GOOD" reverse the effect?

    Maciej, if insults could change atomic frequencies, your laboratory would
    be the most powerful particle accelerator on Earth.

    Unfortunately, physics is not sympathetic magic.

    In the reality they always are.

    And AGAIN you confirm that clocks are adjusted.

    Excellent.

    Now explain why the successful correction of a physical rate difference
    proves that the difference never existed.

    Easy one this time. It's ready, it's called
    LET.

    Lorentz Ether Theory?

    Fine!

    In its standard empirically equivalent formulation, LET reproduces the
    Lorentz transformations and the same observable clock effects as special relativity.

    It does not predict that the measured relativistic frequency offsets
    magically disappear.

    Nor does it establish that GPS synchronization proves absolute Galilean
    time.

    If you claim your version of LET predicts something different, provide the equations and a quantitative prediction distinguishing it from special relativity.

    Simply naming a theory is not a calculation.

    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL
    READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS
    HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?

    YES, MACIEJ.

    So your crap a paragraph above is crap.

    No.

    For the fourth time:

    DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES can produce DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED INDICATIONS.

    CORRECTING those rates can produce IDENTICAL CORRECTED INDICATIONS.

    There is no contradiction.

    The distinction is so elementary that I am beginning to wonder whether you genuinely misunderstand it or simply refuse to acknowledge its
    consequences.

    You wrote "DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    Yes. qed.

    QED?!

    You have proved nothing except your remarkable ability to quote half a sentence while ignoring its meaning.

    I accept the actual clock readings.

    I reject your unsupported claim that identical displayed timestamps
    establish a universal, uncorrected "real time".

    These are different statements.

    Your repeated attempt to turn the first into the second is getting rather desperate.

    And - with "proper time" called correctly
    as "the idiot's delusion" what it really is
    - no more idiots screaming "NOT THE REAL
    TIME" would exist.

    Maciej, there is something wonderfully ironic here.

    NOBODY is screaming "NOT THE REAL TIME!"

    I accept GPS coordinate time.

    I accept the displayed clock readings.

    I accept that synchronized clocks can show identical timestamps.

    I have said so repeatedly.

    The ONLY idiot screaming about "THE REAL TIME" is YOU.

    You invent an imaginary relativist shouting "NOT THE REAL TIME!", then
    spend hundreds of messages furiously arguing with him.

    And when someone explains what proper time actually means, you accuse the terminology of brainwashing.

    You have now progressed from denying measured frequency offsets to
    claiming that WORDS CAN PHYSICALLY CHANGE ATOMIC OSCILLATORS.

    At this rate, your next scientific breakthrough will be to correct GPS
    clocks by shouting insults at them.

    Your beloved Serious Clock(TM) must be exhausted.

    It has to keep time, explain elementary calculus, distinguish oscillator
    rates from displayed indications, and now protect itself from your vocabulary-induced frequency shifts.

    Perhaps it should wear earplugs.

    Or better still, a sticker:

    "WARNING: CALLING ME ERRONEOUS DOES NOT CHANGE MY FREQUENCY."

    Although, according to your latest theory, that warning might itself be dangerous.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Lundy Badov@odado@yn.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 21:45:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly such an
    association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion was called "the idiot's
    delusion" - how would you get your moronic faith that it's a part of
    some Eternal Order of The Universe?

    stop fighting with each other, just stick together as you have to go to
    war to defend europe, since you all are expandable
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 22:11:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 22:45, Lundy Badov a |-crit :
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly such an
    association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion was called "the idiot's
    delusion" - how would you get your moronic faith that it's a part of
    some Eternal Order of The Universe?

    stop fighting with each other, just stick together as you have to go to
    war to defend europe, since you all are expandable

    Do you plan to invade Poland, nym-shifting troll?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Wiley Baklanov@anab@llklann.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 22:27:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 22:45, Lundy Badov a |-crit :
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly such
    an association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion was called "the idiot's
    delusion" - how would you get your moronic faith that it's a part of
    some Eternal Order of The Universe?

    stop fighting with each other, just stick together as you have to go to
    war to defend europe, since you all are expandable

    Do you plan to invade Poland, nym-shifting troll?

    you should be proud your gypsy gay country made you expandable

    now go to defend europe, as expandable, what would you expect.. the
    pollacks to go first?? no, you are expandable same way the pollacks are
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 22:36:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:27, Wiley Baklanov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 22:45, Lundy Badov a |-crit :
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly such
    an association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion was called "the idiot's
    delusion" - how would you get your moronic faith that it's a part of
    some Eternal Order of The Universe?

    stop fighting with each other, just stick together as you have to go to
    war to defend europe, since you all are expandable

    Do you plan to invade Poland, nym-shifting troll?

    you should be proud your gypsy gay country made you expandable

    now go to defend europe, as expandable, what would you expect.. the
    pollacks to go first? ? no, you are expandable same way the pollacks are


    "Expendable", not "expandable".

    But please don't improve your English too much.

    Your spelling mistakes are the only entertaining part of your trolling.
    :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Morgan Bezumov@vae@nanbao.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 22:45:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:27, Wiley Baklanov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 22:45, Lundy Badov a |-crit :
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly such >>>>>> an association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion was called "the idiot's
    delusion" - how would you get your moronic faith that it's a part of >>>>> some Eternal Order of The Universe?

    stop fighting with each other, just stick together as you have to go
    to war to defend europe, since you all are expandable

    Do you plan to invade Poland, nym-shifting troll?

    you should be proud your gypsy gay country made you expandable

    now go to defend europe, as expandable, what would you expect.. the
    pollacks to go first? ? no, you are expandable same way the pollacks
    are


    "Expendable", not "expandable".

    But please don't improve your English too much.

    Your spelling mistakes are the only entertaining part of your trolling.

    this illiterated it-supporter dont undrestand the fucking engilsh, nor the sense in the context

    expandable
    adjective

    1. (of gases) capable of expansion
    2. able to expand or be expanded

    one more proof you so fucking uneducated

    go to war to defend europe, fool; that day you entered europe, the
    european union, you became expandable by default; you fool


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 22:47:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:45, Morgan Bezumov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:27, Wiley Baklanov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 22:45, Lundy Badov a |-crit :
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly such >>>>>>> an association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion was called "the idiot's >>>>>> delusion" - how would you get your moronic faith that it's a part of >>>>>> some Eternal Order of The Universe?

    stop fighting with each other, just stick together as you have to go >>>>> to war to defend europe, since you all are expandable

    Do you plan to invade Poland, nym-shifting troll?

    you should be proud your gypsy gay country made you expandable

    now go to defend europe, as expandable, what would you expect.. the
    pollacks to go first? ? no, you are expandable same way the pollacks
    are


    "Expendable", not "expandable".

    But please don't improve your English too much.

    Your spelling mistakes are the only entertaining part of your trolling.

    this illiterated it-supporter dont undrestand the fucking engilsh, nor the sense in the context

    expandable
    adjective

    1. (of gases) capable of expansion
    2. able to expand or be expanded

    one more proof you so fucking uneducated

    go to war to defend europe, fool; that day you entered europe, the
    european union, you became expandable by default; you fool

    So you actually looked up "expandable" in a dictionary, copied its
    definition, and STILL failed to understand why it's the wrong word.

    That's impressive.

    And "illiterated" and "undrestand" are lovely touches.

    Please, never stop teaching us English. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Irwin Baibakoff@iaan@ooiif.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 22:52:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:45, Morgan Bezumov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:27, Wiley Baklanov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 22:45, Lundy Badov a |-crit :
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly >>>>>>>> such an association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion was called "the idiot's >>>>>>> delusion" - how would you get your moronic faith that it's a part >>>>>>> of some Eternal Order of The Universe?

    stop fighting with each other, just stick together as you have to
    go to war to defend europe, since you all are expandable

    Do you plan to invade Poland, nym-shifting troll?

    you should be proud your gypsy gay country made you expandable

    now go to defend europe, as expandable, what would you expect.. the
    pollacks to go first? ? no, you are expandable same way the pollacks
    are


    "Expendable", not "expandable".

    But please don't improve your English too much.

    Your spelling mistakes are the only entertaining part of your
    trolling.

    this illiterated it-supporter dont undrestand the fucking engilsh, nor
    the sense in the context

    expandable adjective

    1. (of gases) capable of expansion 2. able to expand or be expanded

    one more proof you so fucking uneducated

    go to war to defend europe, fool; that day you entered europe, the
    european union, you became expandable by default; you fool

    So you actually looked up "expandable" in a dictionary, copied its definition, and STILL failed to understand why it's the wrong word.

    That's impressive.

    And "illiterated" and "undrestand" are lovely touches.

    Please, never stop teaching us English. :-)

    cretin, that's from a browser AI, takes 1 sec, for idiots like one have to prove your imbecility

    dont try to evade the issue, that you are an extreme uneducate fool, take
    your shit, wherever you work and go to war to defend europe, since you are
    so fucking expandable
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 22:56:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:52, Irwin Baibakoff a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:45, Morgan Bezumov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 23:27, Wiley Baklanov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Le 12/11/2026 |a 22:45, Lundy Badov a |-crit :
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/12/2026 12:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 12/11/2026 |a 07:13, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/11/2026 11:33 PM, J. J. Lodder wrote:
    You immediately confirmed his observation by producing exactly >>>>>>>>> such an association.

    Then blamed it on brainwashing.

    Maciej, the word "proper" isn't doing the brainwashing.

    Python, yes it is. If the idiot's delusion was called "the idiot's >>>>>>>> delusion" - how would you get your moronic faith that it's a part >>>>>>>> of some Eternal Order of The Universe?

    stop fighting with each other, just stick together as you have to >>>>>>> go to war to defend europe, since you all are expandable

    Do you plan to invade Poland, nym-shifting troll?

    you should be proud your gypsy gay country made you expandable

    now go to defend europe, as expandable, what would you expect.. the
    pollacks to go first? ? no, you are expandable same way the pollacks >>>>> are


    "Expendable", not "expandable".

    But please don't improve your English too much.

    Your spelling mistakes are the only entertaining part of your
    trolling.

    this illiterated it-supporter dont undrestand the fucking engilsh, nor
    the sense in the context

    expandable adjective

    1. (of gases) capable of expansion 2. able to expand or be expanded

    one more proof you so fucking uneducated

    go to war to defend europe, fool; that day you entered europe, the
    european union, you became expandable by default; you fool

    So you actually looked up "expandable" in a dictionary, copied its
    definition, and STILL failed to understand why it's the wrong word.

    That's impressive.

    And "illiterated" and "undrestand" are lovely touches.

    Please, never stop teaching us English. :-)

    cretin, that's from a browser AI, takes 1 sec, for idiots like one have to prove your imbecility

    dont try to evade the issue, that you are an extreme uneducate fool, take your shit, wherever you work and go to war to defend europe, since you are so fucking expandable

    Well, I guess it's time to ask your NNTP provider to terminate your
    account. Again.

    As we've successfully done several times before.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Shon Dubnov@onb@oudnnod.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Nov 12 23:01:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    cretin, that's from a browser AI, takes 1 sec, for idiots like one have
    to prove your imbecility

    dont try to evade the issue, that you are an extreme uneducate fool,
    take your shit, wherever you work and go to war to defend europe, since
    you are so fucking expandable

    Well, I guess it's time to ask your NNTP provider to terminate your
    account. Again.

    As we've successfully done several times before.

    this expandable cretin is incapable to admit his defeat, you stinking sack
    of subhuman excrement, appeals to others for help

    go to defend europe fool, your gay president just said on TV that you are expandable
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 07:22:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/12/2026 10:45 PM, Python wrote:
    Gravity exists and works - yet. How about
    "gravitational force", poor piece of shit?

    Newtonian gravity is described as a force.

    So does "gravitional force" exist
    or not? See, poor piece of shit -
    has been "confirmed" in a thousands of
    experiments, has been measured thousands
    of times, has been causing physical effects -
    and the idiot's vocabulatory has erased it.
    Such things happen, even if your primitive
    religion.


    And the really measured difference in
    indications is - 0.

    Of CORRECTED GPS clock outputs, Maciej.

    Of REAL GPS clocks output, Python.



    The output is the measurement result.
    Measurement result is the value of
    the physical quantity.

    A clock output is an indication. What physical quantity that indication represents depends on the clock's design, calibration and corrections.

    Keep dreaming, poor piece of shit,
    your dreams will never come true.



    Yes, changing the label DOES. Words have
    the power, poor piece of shit.

    If I call a caesium clock "erroneous", its
    oscillator does not suddenly change frequency.


    That's exactly what is going to happen.

    SPECTACULAR!

    Was - 9 192 631 770 periods per a second,
    is - 9 192 631 774. Sorry, poor piece of shit.



    Unfortunately, physics is not sympathetic magic.

    It's no magic and you have mo clue how your
    moronic religion works.

    In the reality they always are.

    And AGAIN you confirm that clocks are adjusted.

    Excellent.

    Now explain why the successful correction of a physical rate difference proves that the difference never existed.

    Nobody was ever saying that and your
    "time dilation" idiocy is not a difference
    in rates, but in indications.

    Easy one this time. It's ready, it's called
    LET.

    Lorentz Ether Theory?

    Fine!

    In its standard empirically equivalent formulation, LET reproduces the Lorentz transformations and the same observable clock effects as special relativity.

    Almost. See, poor piece of shit, the
    formula which in The Shit is for time dilation,
    in LET is for a caused by moving through ether
    clock error. I.e. for the corrections that
    should be applied on the clock. LET is
    predicting corrections, The Shit is not.
    In LET your desynchronizing junk has
    no magically mystical power, they're just
    like pendulums in Newton's.





    DO YOU AGREE THAT TWO CLOCKS CAN DISPLAY IDENTICAL
    READINGS WHILE THEIR UNDERLYING PHYSICAL OSCILLATORS
    HAVE DIFFERENT UNCORRECTED RATES?

    YES, MACIEJ.

    So your crap a paragraph above is crap.

    No.

    Yes.




    For the fourth time:

    Repeat tour moronic lies 100 times
    and they won't stop to be just moronic
    lies.


    You wrote "DO NOT measure:
    "THE REAL TIME."

    Yes. qed.

    QED?!

    Yes. And, see, if the idiot's delusion was
    called "delusion" instead "proper time" -
    the idiots screaming "NOT MEASURE THE REAL
    TIME!!!!!!!" would exist no more, and yes,
    something important would change.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 11:21:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Salomon Bakurov <orsmu@koroualo.ru> wrote:

    Maciej Wo?niak wrote:

    Does gravity stop working when we call it "spacetime curvature" instead
    of "gravitational force"?

    Gravity exists and works - yet. How about "gravitational force", poor
    piece of shit?

    good catch, but is not a force, but a distortion of spacetime

    but you pollacks have to go to war to defend europe, as you guys are expandable

    for europe, you pollacks and ukrans are expandable

    The best Russians are dead Russians.
    500 000 down, so far, with 1 400 000 disabled.

    Good going!

    Jan


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 10:42:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    So does "gravitional force" exist or not?

    Gravitational effects exist. Newton describes them using a force; general relativity describes gravitation through spacetime geometry.

    Both descriptions make testable predictions. Changing the theoretical description does not erase the observations.

    Your confusion between a physical phenomenon and the vocabulary used to describe it is becoming a recurring theme.

    Of REAL GPS clocks output, Python.

    https://ibb.co/7xJp96rQ (sigh)

    YES. Real GPS clocks, with REAL frequency adjustments and REAL
    corrections.

    Nobody disputes their displayed readings.

    What you refuse to understand is that an adjusted output is not a
    measurement of the unadjusted oscillator's frequency.

    And you have already explicitly agreed that two clocks can display
    identical readings while their underlying oscillators run at different uncorrected rates.

    You cannot acknowledge that fact and then pretend identical displays prove identical underlying rates.

    Was - 9 192 631 770 periods per a second,
    is - 9 192 631 774.

    Wonderful!

    Now you have invented a clock whose atomic transition frequency changes
    when you insult it or attach a different label.

    Please publish the experimental protocol.

    Does calling it "idiot's delusion" increase the frequency by four hertz?
    Does "proper time" decrease it? What happens if you use both labels simultaneously?

    And how do you propose to measure those four hertz without comparing frequencies?

    Your Serious Clockrao has apparently become a linguistic transducer.

    your "time dilation" idiocy is not a difference
    in rates, but in indications.

    For uncorrected clocks, differences in accumulated indications result from differences in their rates.

    Mathematically:

    Delta I(T) = Delta I(0) + integral(r1-r2) dt.

    That is elementary calculus.

    Corrections alter the relationship between the physical oscillator and the displayed indication.

    Which is precisely why corrected GPS clocks can agree despite different underlying relativistic rates.

    In LET your desynchronizing junk has no
    magically mystical power

    There is no mystical power in either theory.

    Standard Lorentz Ether Theory reproduces the same observable relativistic clock effects as special relativity. It offers a different interpretation,
    not an escape from the experimental results.

    And your claim that special relativity does not predict clock corrections
    is absurd.

    A theory predicts the behavior of a clock. Engineers use that prediction
    to determine the corrections needed to obtain a desired output.

    That is exactly what happens in GPS.

    No physical theory needs to contain a commandment saying "THOU SHALT
    ADJUST THY CLOCK."

    if the idiot's delusion was called "delusion"
    instead "proper time" ...

    There we are again.

    You think changing a scientific term changes the physical phenomenon.

    You think correcting a clock proves its uncorrected rate was irrelevant.

    And you think a different interpretation of relativity makes its experimentally verified predictions disappear.

    Maciej, the only person here attributing magical powers to words is YOU.

    You have spent several days screaming about "proper time" while
    simultaneously insisting that a clock's oscillator can change frequency because someone calls it "erroneous".

    That's not physics.

    That's your very own Theory of Relativistic Name-Calling.

    And unlike Einstein's theory, it has yet to survive a single experiment.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 12:17:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 11:42 AM, Python wrote:
    So does "gravitional force" exist or not?

    Gravitational effects exist. Newton describes them using a force;

    Vocabulatory, poor piece of shit.
    Similarly:
    Rate differences exist (for some types of oscillators).
    The idiot describes them as "time dilation", sane
    people (Lorentz included) as a clock error requiring
    compensation. How about that?




    Of REAL GPS clocks output, Python.

    https://ibb.co/7xJp96rQ (sigh)

    YES. Real GPS clocks, with REAL frequency adjustments and REAL corrections.

    And with REAL measurement of the REAL time,
    giving t'=t. A brainwashed idiot may scream
    "NOT THE REAL TIME!!!" - but nobody cares.


    Was - 9 192 631 770 periods per a second,
    is - 9 192 631 774.

    Wonderful!

    Now you have invented a clock whose atomic transition frequency changes
    when you insult it or attach a different label.

    Nope. I'm just providing the measurement result.
    The GPS satellite local clock - the one correctly
    calibrated - gives 9 192 631 774 periods per second,
    for the local Cs atom of course.
    Sorry, poor piece of shit.





    Please publish the experimental protocol.

    Does calling it "idiot's delusion" increase the frequency by four hertz?

    Yes.

    Does "proper time" decrease it?

    Yes.


    What happens if you use both labels
    simultaneously?

    Inconsistency.


    And how do you propose to measure those four hertz without comparing frequencies?

    Simply. I take a second from a precise,
    correctly calibrated clock, and count
    how many periods of Cs radiation I can
    count during it.


    your "time dilation" idiocy is not a difference
    in rates, but in indications.

    For uncorrected clocks, differences in accumulated indications result
    from differences in their rates.

    But for the real clocks they don't.


    In LET your desynchronizing junk has no
    magically mystical power

    There is no mystical power in either theory.

    Standard Lorentz Ether Theory reproduces the same observable
    relativistic clock effects as special relativity. It offers a different interpretation, not an escape from the experimental results.

    Yes, it gives a different interpretation.
    You've been asking for a theory
    quoting:
    "
    Unless another theory asserts otherwise and
    give you a direct formula for correcting
    them to t'=t, same as it is with pendulums.

    Excellent!
    Then please PRESENT THAT THEORY.
    "
    LET IS such a theory. It IS giving you a
    direct formula for correcting the
    clocks to t'=t, same as Newton's
    is giving it for pendulums. In LET there
    is no time dilation, same as there is
    no "pendulum time dilation" in Newton's.
    And neither there is in GPS. GPS model
    is LET compatibile, not Shit compatibile.




    if the idiot's delusion was called "delusion"
    instead "proper time" ...

    There we are again.

    You think changing a scientific term changes the physical phenomenon.

    You, on the other hand, think it can not.
    Do you think you can't be mistaken? Of
    course you can, an ignorant idiot without
    a clue about anything often is.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 11:30:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Rate differences exist (for some types of oscillators).
    The idiot describes them as "time dilation",
    sane people (Lorentz included) as a clock error
    requiring compensation. How about that?

    You keep confusing a physical phenomenon with its interpretation.

    In relativity, proper time is a geometrical quantity associated with a worldline. Ideal clocks measure elapsed proper time, independently of
    their operating mechanism.

    In Lorentz Ether Theory, the corresponding clock effects can be
    interpreted as consequences of motion through the ether.

    Fine.

    But changing the interpretation does not change the observable frequency shifts.

    And calling them "clock errors" does not make them disappear.

    Incidentally, your comparison with Newtonian gravity is equally confused.

    Newton describes gravity as a force. General relativity describes
    gravitation through spacetime geometry.

    Neither description erases gravitational phenomena.

    A change of theoretical description is not a change of physical reality.

    And with REAL measurement of the REAL time,
    giving t'=t.

    You have already explicitly agreed that two clocks can display identical readings while their underlying oscillators have different uncorrected
    rates.

    So what does the equality of their CORRECTED displays establish?

    That the corrections work.

    Congratulations.

    GPS engineers have known this for decades.

    Corrected clock indications do not establish equality of uncorrected oscillator rates.

    And your mysterious "REAL time" does not become a new physical quantity
    simply because you write REAL in capital letters.

    The GPS satellite local clock - the one correctly
    calibrated - gives 9 192 631 774 periods per second,
    for the local Cs atom of course.

    Now THAT is interesting.

    The SI second is defined by fixing the frequency of the unperturbed caesium-133 hyperfine transition at exactly 9,192,631,770 Hz.

    So if you count 9,192,631,774 cycles during what you call a second, you
    must specify which time scale defines that second, how the reference clock realizes it, and what frequency comparison you are performing.

    A locally realized proper second and a second of a remote coordinate time scale are not automatically interchangeable.

    Otherwise your number tells us nothing about a supposed change in the
    atom's intrinsic transition frequency.

    And certainly nothing about the magical power of labels.

    Does calling it "idiot's delusion" increase
    the frequency by four hertz?

    Yes.

    Does "proper time" decrease it?

    Yes.

    SPECTACULAR!

    You have now explicitly claimed that changing the NAME of a physical
    quantity changes an atomic transition frequency.

    Four hertz, no less.

    Please demonstrate this extraordinary phenomenon.

    Take the same apparatus under unchanged physical conditions.

    Measure its frequency.

    Change ONLY the label.

    Measure again.

    If the frequency changes, you have discovered an entirely new physical interaction.

    If it doesn't, your theory of linguistic frequency modulation is dead.

    What happens if you use both labels
    simultaneously?

    Inconsistency.

    Of course!

    Apparently, your caesium atoms are not only literate but also trained in formal logic.

    Do they refuse to oscillate when confronted with a contradiction?

    Perhaps they stop altogether when someone mentions Einstein.

    I take a second from a precise,
    correctly calibrated clock, and count
    how many periods of Cs radiation I can
    count during it.

    EXCELLENT!

    You have finally described a frequency comparison.

    You use one clock as a reference and count the cycles of another
    oscillator.

    The result depends on the relationship between the reference time scale
    and the oscillator's rate.

    Exactly what I have been explaining.

    And exactly what you previously dismissed as irrelevant.

    Notice that your procedure contains no mechanism whatsoever by which
    changing a WORD could alter the physical frequency.

    You have merely described how to measure a frequency ratio.

    your "time dilation" idiocy is not a difference
    in rates, but in indications.

    For uncorrected clocks, differences in accumulated indications follow from differences in their rates.

    Mathematically:

    Delta I(T) = Delta I(0) + integral(r1-r2) dt.

    That is elementary calculus.

    For corrected clock outputs, the relationship between the underlying oscillator and the displayed indication has been deliberately modified.

    Which is precisely why corrected GPS clocks can agree despite different underlying relativistic rates.

    But for the real clocks they don't.

    Real clocks have real oscillators.

    Real corrections modify their outputs.

    Real frequency differences can therefore coexist with identical displayed readings.

    You have acknowledged this yourself.

    Repeatedly.

    Yet you continue to pretend that the successful compensation of a physical effect proves the effect never existed.

    LET IS such a theory.

    Now we come to an even bigger problem.

    Lorentz Ether Theory, in its standard empirically equivalent form, is an alternative interpretation of SPECIAL relativity.

    But GPS requires BOTH special and general relativistic corrections.

    For a typical GPS satellite, the approximate accumulated clock offsets relative to terrestrial reference clocks are:

    Special relativistic contribution:
    -7.2 microseconds per day

    Gravitational relativistic contribution:
    +45.7 microseconds per day

    Net contribution:
    +38.5 microseconds per day

    Notice something?

    The GRAVITATIONAL contribution is much larger than the kinematic one.

    And standard Lorentz Ether Theory, by itself, does not provide a
    relativistic theory of gravitation.

    So where, exactly, is the gravitational theory in your LET?

    What equations does it provide for gravitational frequency shifts?

    How does it predict the dependence on gravitational potential?

    How does it reproduce the observed GPS gravitational correction?

    And how does it handle the effects of orbital eccentricity on satellite
    clock rates?

    Simply shouting "LET!" does not answer any of these questions.

    You can certainly propose a gravitational extension of Lorentz Ether
    Theory.

    But then you must specify that extension, derive its predictions and demonstrate their agreement with experiment.

    Standard LET alone is not a complete model of GPS.

    In LET there is no time dilation,
    same as there is no "pendulum time dilation"
    in Newton's.

    In the ether interpretation, an underlying absolute time can be
    postulated, while moving physical clocks exhibit the same relativistic
    rate effects predicted by special relativity.

    Calling those effects "clock errors" is an interpretative choice.

    It is not a different experimental prediction.

    And the analogy with pendulums is misleading.

    A pendulum's period depends on its construction and local gravitational conditions.

    Relativistic proper-time differences are universal for ideal clocks, not peculiarities of one oscillator mechanism.

    That universality is experimentally testable.

    GPS model is LET compatibile,
    not Shit compatibile.

    GPS is compatible with the relativistic predictions shared by standard LET
    and special relativity.

    But its gravitational corrections require additional physics, supplied by general relativity in the standard GPS model.

    You have not provided an alternative gravitational theory.

    So your claim that LET explains GPS while relativity does not is
    unsupported.

    In fact, GPS engineering explicitly uses relativistic calculations to determine the required clock corrections.

    A physical theory predicts how clocks behave.

    Engineers use those predictions to compensate the effects.

    No theory needs to contain a divine commandment saying:

    "THOU SHALT CORRECT THY CLOCK."

    The corrections are engineering applications of the predictions.

    Not evidence against them.

    You, on the other hand, think it can not.
    Do you think you can't be mistaken?

    Of course I can be mistaken.

    And unlike you, I can describe what evidence would prove me wrong.

    For example, demonstrate a reproducible four-hertz change in a caesium transition caused solely by changing its LABEL, with no physical
    modification to the apparatus.

    You have explicitly predicted this.

    So now you have a testable claim.

    No Einstein.

    No Lorentz.

    No arguments about "real time".

    Just an atom, a frequency counter and two labels.

    And while you're preparing that experiment, perhaps you could also provide
    the missing gravitational field equations of your GPS-compatible LET.

    Because at the moment, your theory has two rather spectacular
    deficiencies:

    It cannot explain how words physically change atomic frequencies.

    And, without an additional gravitational theory, it cannot explain the
    largest relativistic clock correction required by GPS.

    Yet you keep calling everyone else ignorant.

    Maciej, make the atom read the label.

    Then make your ether explain gravity.

    The Nobel committee will be fascinated.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 12:31:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    So does "gravitional force" exist or not?

    Gravitational effects exist. Newton describes them using a force; general relativity describes gravitation through spacetime geometry.

    Both descriptions make testable predictions. Changing the theoretical description does not erase the observations.

    Your confusion between a physical phenomenon and the vocabulary used to describe it is becoming a recurring theme.

    Of REAL GPS clocks output, Python.

    https://ibb.co/7xJp96rQ (sigh)

    Do keep up the good work.
    It is your illustrations that make these near endless threads
    worth looking at every now and then,

    Jan
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 13:19:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 12:30 PM, Python wrote:
    Rate differences exist (for some types of oscillators).
    The idiot describes them as "time dilation",
    sane people (Lorentz included) as a clock error
    requiring compensation. How about that?

    You keep confusing a physical phenomenon with its interpretation.

    Oppositely, YOU do.

    In relativity, proper time is a geometrical quantity associated with a worldline. Ideal clocks measure elapsed proper time, independently of
    their operating mechanism.

    Yes, this mystical mumble is The Shit's
    interpretation of a common clock error.



    Fine.

    But changing the interpretation does not change the observable frequency shifts.

    Potentially it can change anything, but
    in this case frequency shifts are common
    for both interpretations.



    And calling them "clock errors" does not make them disappear.

    But does make your "time dilation" idiocy
    disappear, poor piece of shit.


    And your mysterious "REAL time" does not become a new physical quantity simply because you write REAL in capital letters.

    Calling it "mysterious" won't make it disappear.
    Screaming "NOT REAL!!!" could - if anyone took
    your screams seriously, poor piece of shit.


    The GPS satellite local clock - the one correctly
    calibrated - gives 9 192 631 774 periods per second,
    for the local Cs atom of course.

    Now THAT is interesting.

    The SI second is defined by fixing the frequency of the unperturbed

    A bunch of idiots can easily write a definition
    of "a shark" as a grasseater, but the real sharks
    won't care about it. We have the same situation
    here. GPS second (being the same as TAI second
    and used in almost every timekeeping system
    which count) is different than the one from
    your wannabe definition. Common sense had been
    warning the idiots from your bunch of idiots.




    Does calling it "idiot's delusion" increase
    the frequency by four hertz?

    Yes.

    Does "proper time" decrease it?

    Yes.

    SPECTACULAR!

    You have now explicitly claimed that changing the NAME of a physical quantity changes an atomic transition frequency.

    Four hertz, no less.

    Please demonstrate this extraordinary phenomenon.

    Take the same apparatus under unchanged physical conditions.
    Measure its frequency.

    Sure. I take your desynchronizing
    junk-clock.
    I label it as "propercorrectperfect". Its
    measured frequency is as in SI.


    Change ONLY the label.


    Now I label it as "erroneous with the systematic
    error of -4 periods per second".

    Measure again.

    And the result is +4.

    You can call it magic - well, for your
    primitive half-brain it can easily look
    like.



    your "time dilation" idiocy is not a difference
    in rates, but in indications.

    For uncorrected clocks

    I only care about the reality, your gedanken
    delusions are of no interest for me.




    LET IS such a theory.

    Now we come to an even bigger problem.

    Lorentz Ether Theory, in its standard empirically equivalent form, is an alternative interpretation of SPECIAL relativity.

    Why not the opposite, poor piece of shit?

    But GPS requires BOTH special and general relativistic corrections.

    Both Shits provide no, both assert that
    desynchronizing clocks without any
    correction are perfectly good clocks
    (which assertion is, of course, as
    baseless as it is idiotic).


    For a typical GPS satellite, the approximate accumulated clock offsets relative to terrestrial reference clocks are:

    Special relativistic contribution:
    -a-a -7.2 microseconds per day

    Not "special relativistic" but LET's
    contribution. According to your
    idiocy the clocks are PERFECTLY GOOD
    without any correction. It's LET
    which is telling us that they're not
    and they require a correction.


    Gravitational relativistic contribution:
    -a-a +45.7 microseconds per day

    Not relativistic too, coming from an
    unnamed yet model being a galilean
    alternative to GR shit, same as LET
    is a galilean alternative to SR.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 12:29:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Potentially it can change anything, but
    in this case frequency shifts are common
    for both interpretations.

    Excellent. So the physical frequency shifts are the same.

    Your entire disagreement is about what to CALL them.

    Some revolution.

    GPS second [...] is different than the one
    from your wannabe definition.

    No. GPS time and TAI use SI seconds, with different conventions for their realization and reference scales.

    Your ignorance of time metrology is not a discovery.

    Now I label it as "erroneous with the systematic
    error of -4 periods per second".

    And the result is +4.

    You have changed your DESCRIPTION of the measurement, not the measurement.

    Writing "+4" on a piece of paper does not make a caesium atom oscillate
    four times faster.

    Even your Serious Clockrao must be laughing.

    I only care about the reality, your gedanken
    delusions are of no interest for me.

    Yes, you've made that abundantly clear.

    You're not interested in the uncorrected rates, the physical effects
    requiring correction, or the equations predicting them.

    Fortunately, GPS engineers ARE interested.

    They need their satellites to work.

    Not "special relativistic" but LET's
    contribution.

    The same numerical prediction, under a different interpretation.

    You have already admitted that.

    Calling it "LET's contribution" does not erase special relativity.

    Not relativistic too, coming from an
    unnamed yet model being a galilean
    alternative to GR shit

    SPECTACULAR!

    Your alternative gravitational theory is now officially UNNAMED.

    Apparently, it also has no published equations, no quantitative
    predictions and no experimental validation that you can present.

    Meanwhile, general relativity predicts approximately:

    +45.7 microseconds/day from gravity,
    -7.2 microseconds/day from orbital motion,
    = +38.5 microseconds/day net.

    Those are NUMBERS, Maciej.

    Numbers that engineers use to design working GPS systems.

    Where are the numbers predicted by your mysterious "Galilean alternative
    to GR"?

    Where are its field equations?

    Where is its derivation of the gravitational frequency shift?

    Your "clock error" theory predicts nothing until you supply a quantitative model of the error.

    Calling an observed discrepancy an ERROR is not an explanation.

    Predicting its magnitude BEFORE correcting it is physics.

    GR does that.

    Your unnamed theory doesn't even have a name, let alone a calculation.

    And when asked about the underlying physical rates, you proudly announce
    that you're "not interested".

    Well, others are.

    They want GPS to work.

    And unlike your theory, it does.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 13:49:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 1:29 PM, Python wrote:
    Potentially it can change anything, but
    in this case frequency shifts are common
    for both interpretations.

    Excellent. So the physical frequency shifts are the same.

    Your entire disagreement is about what to CALL them.

    So is yours, poor piece of shit.


    GPS second [...] is different than the one
    from your wannabe definition.

    No. GPS time and TAI use SI seconds,

    Sorry, poor piece of shit - in your
    dreams. You've already admitted -
    if they applied your idiocy they would
    loose synchronization. Of course,
    being an impudent piece of lying shit
    you will die-hard lying.



    Now I label it as "erroneous with the systematic
    error of -4 periods per second".

    And the result is +4.

    You have changed your DESCRIPTION of the measurement, not the measurement.

    Writing "+4" on a piece of paper does not make a caesium atom oscillate
    four times faster.

    But that makes the measurement result +4.
    Sorry, poor piece of shit.

    Even your Serious Clockrao must be laughing.

    And muons too, sure.
    They would never dare disobeying poor piece
    of shit Python.




    Fortunately, GPS engineers ARE interested.

    They need their satellites to work.

    Yes, they need them to work so they fuck
    your mystical idiocies and have clocks measuring
    t'=t with a second of 9 192 631 770 Cs periods
    on Earth and 9 192 631 774 on a satellite. Common
    sense had been warning the idiot.




    Not "special relativistic" but LET's
    contribution.

    The same numerical prediction

    But while The Shit is asserting that
    your desynchronizing junk are perfectly
    good - LET is not, LET predicts they're
    going to suck if not corrected. LET is
    right. The Shit is not. Sorry, poor
    piece of shit.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 12:57:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    So is yours, poor piece of shit.

    No. I distinguish the physical frequency shift from its interpretation.

    You keep confusing both with the displayed clock output.

    But that makes the measurement result +4.

    No. It makes your REPORTED result +4.

    Changing a label or adding a correction to a reported value does not
    change the underlying measurement.

    Surely even you can distinguish measuring something from writing
    something.

    And muons too, sure.

    Indeed, muons are particularly inconvenient for your story.

    Their observed survival rates agree with relativistic predictions.

    No GPS synchronization, no corrected clock displays, and certainly no
    labels attached to the muons.

    they need them to work so they fuck
    your mystical idiocies and have clocks measuring
    t'=t

    And here we go AGAIN.

    Your obsession with "perfectly good clocks".

    A clock can be PERFECTLY GOOD at measuring its own elapsed proper time and still require correction to display GPS coordinate time.

    These are TWO DIFFERENT REQUIREMENTS.

    A perfectly functioning thermometer does not become defective because its Celsius reading differs from its Fahrenheit reading.

    Likewise, a perfectly functioning satellite clock does not become
    defective because its uncorrected rate differs from that required by the
    GPS time scale.

    The correction is necessary for SYNCHRONIZATION, not to repair a
    supposedly defective physical oscillator.

    How many more times must this elementary distinction be explained?

    LET predicts they're going to suck if not corrected.
    LET is right. The Shit is not.

    Special relativity predicts the kinematic clock-rate difference.

    General relativity predicts the gravitational contribution.

    Together, they provide the quantitative corrections GPS requires.

    Your LET supplies an alternative interpretation of the first contribution.

    Your unnamed gravitational theory has yet to supply ANY calculation for
    the second.

    And you still haven't produced a single statement from Einstein claiming
    that clocks must never be adjusted.

    Maciej, nobody disputes that GPS clocks require corrections.

    NOBODY.

    You have spent days furiously refuting a claim that nobody made.

    Your entire argument rests on confusing:

    "THIS CLOCK MEASURES PROPER TIME CORRECTLY"

    with:

    "THIS CLOCK NEEDS NO CORRECTION TO DISPLAY GPS TIME".

    They are not equivalent.

    Not in special relativity.

    Not in general relativity.

    Not even in your beloved LET.

    You are arguing against an imaginary prohibition on clock adjustments,
    while the actual theory provides the numbers engineers use to perform
    those adjustments.

    And every time this is explained, you scream "PERFECTLY GOOD!" and start again.

    Your argument clock has completed another revolution.

    Unfortunately, your understanding hasn't moved an inch.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 14:12:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 1:57 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    So is yours, poor piece of shit.

    No.

    Yes.



    But that makes the measurement result +4.

    No. It makes your REPORTED result +4.

    Nice, poor piece of shit, nice indeed.
    So - let's take any historical measurement.
    Roemer, speed of light, 1676, 226,663 - is it
    according to you "measurement result" or
    "reported measurement result"?
    What is, precisely, the difference? Can you
    point an example with numbers? Date, value
    of measurement result, value of the reported
    result - where they differ?



    they need them to work so they fuck
    your mystical idiocies and have clocks measuring
    t'=t

    And here we go AGAIN.

    Yes, here we go AGAIN.
    they need them to work so they fuck
    your mystical idiocies and have clocks measuring
    t'=t. With the second of +4 periods on the
    satellite.



    LET predicts they're going to suck if not corrected.
    LET is right. The Shit is not.

    Special relativity predicts the kinematic clock-rate difference.

    LET does the same. Nobody cares. their another
    prediction is important. The Shit is predicting
    time dilation, LET is not. Time dilation
    is defined as the difference in indications
    (of correct clocks). LET is right, The Shit
    sucks. Mad lies of a mad, brainwashed idiot
    are not changing anything.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 13:20:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Roemer, speed of light, 1676, 226,663 - is it
    according to you "measurement result" or
    "reported measurement result"?

    A historical estimate, derived from observations and reported by someone.

    Incidentally, your attribution of that precise numerical value to R|+mer
    in 1676 is questionable. He estimated a light-travel delay, not the speed
    of light in modern numerical units.

    Can you point an example with numbers?
    Date, value of measurement result, value
    of the reported result - where they differ?

    Certainly. Your OWN example.

    You count 9,192,631,770 oscillations during a reference interval.

    Then you attach a label saying "systematic error: -4" and report a
    corrected value of 9,192,631,774.

    The observed count has not changed.

    Your reported, corrected value has.

    That is the distinction.

    And if you claim that changing the label actually changes the observed
    count, demonstrate it experimentally.

    With the second of +4 periods on the satellite.

    Again, you are confusing a local proper second with an interval of GPS coordinate time.

    The SI definition has not changed.

    A satellite oscillator can have a different frequency when expressed
    relative to GPS coordinate time without the local caesium transition mysteriously acquiring a new intrinsic frequency.

    LET does the same. Nobody cares.

    Excellent. You admit that LET and SR predict the same kinematic clock
    effects.

    So your disagreement is not about the observable prediction.

    Time dilation is defined as the difference
    in indications (of correct clocks).

    No, Maciej.

    That is YOUR definition, carefully chosen to make your conclusion true by construction.

    In relativity, time dilation concerns the relationship between elapsed
    proper times and coordinate times, or between clock rates under specified conditions.

    It is not defined as the difference between two arbitrarily corrected displays.

    Otherwise I could connect two clocks to the same computer, make them
    display identical numbers, and announce that I had abolished relativity.

    Your entire argument is that corrected clocks agree after correction.

    Yes, Maciej.

    THAT IS WHAT CORRECTIONS ARE FOR.

    The theory predicts the physical rate differences.

    The engineers compensate for them.

    The clocks display the required common time scale.

    And you triumphantly announce that the theory has been refuted.

    Your Serious Clockrao must be getting dizzy by now.

    Around and around we go.

    Same confusion, same shouting, same imaginary prohibition on corrections.

    And still not a single equation from your unnamed gravitational theory predicting the +45.7 microseconds per day required by GPS.

    Apparently, naming things is more important to you than calculating them.

    Fortunately, GPS engineers have different priorities.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 14:32:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 2:20 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Roemer, speed of light, 1676, 226,663 - is it
    according to you "measurement result" or
    "reported measurement result"?

    A historical estimate, derived from observations and reported by someone.

    None of the above?


    Can you point an example with numbers?
    Date, value of measurement result, value
    of the reported result - where they differ?

    Certainly. Your OWN example.

    It's just a hypothetical, imagined situation.
    Any real example for the real measurements,
    poor piece of shit?



    With the second of +4 periods on the satellite.

    Again, you are confusing a local proper second with an interval of GPS coordinate time.

    The SI definition has not changed.

    So what?
    A bunch of idiots can easily write a definition
    of "a shark" as a grasseater, but the real sharks
    won't care about it. We have the same situation
    here. GPS simply ignores your nonsense.



    In relativity, time dilation concerns the relationship between
    elapsed > proper times and coordinate times

    A lie even more impudent than your average.
    Congrats, poor piece of shit. But as idiotic
    as average.
    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf
    Show me: where the idiot mention any coordinate
    time different than his own dilating idiocy (which
    is a coordinate time itself, of course, SR shit is
    a theory of coordinates).









    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 13:37:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    None of the above?

    A historical estimate derived from measurements and subsequently reported.

    This really isn't difficult.

    Any real example for the real measurements?

    Certainly.

    Consider a real GPS satellite clock.

    Its uncorrected relativistic frequency offset, relative to the terrestrial
    GPS reference, is approximately:

    +4.46 x 10^-10

    The required nominal net correction corresponds to about:

    38.5 microseconds per day.

    After compensation, the clock output is made to follow GPS time.

    There you have a real, quantitative example of an underlying physical rate offset and a corrected timekeeping output.

    The correction does not erase the effect it compensates.

    And your demand for a historical example is particularly amusing when you
    have just claimed that changing a LABEL changes an atomic frequency by
    four hertz.

    Where is YOUR experimental evidence for that?

    GPS simply ignores your nonsense.

    GPS uses SI seconds and applies relativistic corrections.

    You can insult the SI definition all day long. The satellite clocks will continue behaving according to the measured physics.

    Show me: where the idiot mention any coordinate
    time different than his own dilating idiocy

    THANK YOU for providing Einstein's original paper!

    Let's actually READ it.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    Section 1, "Definition of Simultaneity":

    Einstein explicitly defines time in a reference system using spatially distributed, synchronized clocks.

    He even calls it "the time of the stationary system".

    Section 3, "Theory of the Transformation of Co-ordinates and Times":

    Einstein introduces TWO reference systems, K and k, with their respective
    time coordinates t and tau.

    He derives:

    tau = gamma(t - vx/c-#)

    These are time coordinates assigned to events in different reference
    systems.

    Exactly what you demanded to see.

    But the best part is Section 4:

    "Physical Meaning of the Equations Obtained in Respect to Moving Rigid
    Bodies and Moving Clocks".

    Einstein considers a clock moving along x = vt.

    He obtains:

    tau = t.sqrt(1-v-#/c-#)

    And then explicitly asks about the RATE of the moving clock as viewed from
    the stationary system.

    THE RATE, Maciej.

    Not merely the difference between two corrected displays.

    He also predicts that a transported clock will lag behind a stationary
    one.

    So your claim that Einstein's theory concerns only displayed indications,
    not rates, is directly contradicted by the very paper YOU supplied.

    Of course, the modern general definition of proper time along an arbitrary worldline was developed and expressed geometrically later.

    Nobody claims that Einstein's 1905 paper uses every term of modern
    relativity.

    But the physical and mathematical distinction is already there.

    And nowhere does Einstein claim that engineers are forbidden to adjust
    clocks to display a common coordinate time.

    You keep inventing that prohibition.

    Now, since you have helpfully introduced the original paper into the discussion, perhaps you can finally quote the passage where Einstein
    declares clock corrections illegal.

    Page and paragraph, please.

    Otherwise, your entire "perfectly good clocks must never be corrected" argument remains a straw man.

    You have been fighting Einstein for days.

    And apparently you hadn't even read the paper you just linked.

    Your Serious Clock(TM) must be spinning faster than ever.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 14:53:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 2:37 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    None of the above?

    A historical estimate derived from measurements and subsequently reported.

    But - measurement result? reported measurement result?
    None?



    Any real example for the real measurements?

    Certainly.

    Consider a real GPS satellite clock.

    I'm asking about the real reality, not
    about gedanken reality; I know, distinguishing
    is hard for a brainwashed by The Shit idiot, but,
    please, try.


    GPS simply ignores your nonsense.

    GPS uses SI seconds

    You will die hard lying, sure. But you've already
    admitted - if it used your idiocy it would
    loose synchronization. GPS fucks your idiocy,
    it's second is +4 at a satellite.


    Show me: where the idiot mention any coordinate
    time different than his own dilating idiocy

    THANK YOU for providing Einstein's original paper!

    Let's actually READ it.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    Section 1, "Definition of Simultaneity":

    Einstein explicitly defines time in a reference system using spatially distributed, synchronized clocks.

    He even calls it "the time of the stationary system".

    Section 3, "Theory of the Transformation of Co-ordinates and Times":

    Einstein introduces TWO reference systems, K and k, with their
    respective time coordinates t and tau.

    They both are, unfortunately, unrelated to
    what you call "coordinate time" now, they
    are both his dilating idiocy known now as
    "proper time".

    But the best part is Section 4:

    "Physical Meaning of the Equations Obtained in Respect to Moving Rigid Bodies and Moving Clocks".

    Einstein considers a clock moving along x = vt.

    He obtains:

    tau = t.sqrt(1-v-#/c-#)

    And then explicitly asks about the RATE of the moving clock as viewed
    from the stationary system.

    THE RATE, Maciej.

    Once in the whole text. How many times "time" (defined as
    the indication) is mentioned?


    Now, since you have helpfully introduced the original paper into the discussion, perhaps you can finally quote the passage where Einstein declares clock corrections illegal.

    Between the lines.
    And where he predicts it as you keep lying?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 15:22:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    But - measurement result? reported measurement result?
    None?

    A measurement result is a value obtained through a measurement procedure, including any corrections explicitly applied.

    A reported result is the value communicated to others.

    They may be identical. They may differ because of subsequent corrections, rounding or even transcription errors.

    Neither changes the underlying physical observations.

    You are desperately trying to turn a distinction in metrology into a metaphysical paradox.

    I'm asking about the real reality, not
    about gedanken reality

    GPS satellites are real, Maciej.

    Their oscillators are real.

    Their frequency offsets are real.

    Their corrections are real.

    Your refusal to examine uncorrected rates doesn't make them imaginary.

    GPS fucks your idiocy,
    it's second is +4 at a satellite.

    Again, the SI second is defined by 9,192,631,770 periods of the
    unperturbed caesium-133 transition.

    A satellite's oscillator frequency expressed relative to GPS coordinate
    time is a different question.

    And your arbitrary "+4" is not a substitute for an actual measurement with
    a specified reference.

    They both are [...] unrelated to what
    you call "coordinate time" now

    Really?

    Einstein explicitly introduces coordinates (x,y,z,t) for one reference
    system and (xi,eta,zeta,tau) for another.

    The time coordinates t and tau are part of his coordinate transformations.

    Along the worldline of a clock at rest in the second system, tau also
    measures that clock's proper time.

    The SAME variable can be a coordinate time in one context and coincide
    with proper time along a particular worldline.

    That is not a contradiction.

    It is elementary relativity.

    Once in the whole text. How many times
    "time" (defined as the indication) is mentioned?

    Wonderful.

    Einstein explicitly discusses the RATE of a moving clock.

    You acknowledge it.

    Then you try to dismiss it because the word appears only once!

    Scientific arguments are not decided by word-frequency statistics.

    One equation is enough to refute your claim that the theory concerns only indications and never rates.

    Now [...] quote the passage where Einstein
    declares clock corrections illegal.

    Between the lines.

    THERE IT IS!

    After days of insults, you finally admit that your supposed prohibition is
    NOT ACTUALLY WRITTEN in Einstein's paper.

    It exists only "between the lines".

    In other words, in your imagination.

    You have built your entire argument around a prohibition you cannot quote.

    And where he predicts it as you keep lying?

    Einstein's 1905 paper predicts the kinematic rate difference:

    d(tau)/dt = sqrt(1-v-#/c-#)

    For a specified velocity, this provides a quantitative prediction.

    Engineers can use that prediction to determine how an oscillator's output
    must be adjusted to follow a chosen coordinate time scale.

    The gravitational contribution to GPS requires general relativity,
    developed later.

    Neither theory needs to prescribe a particular electronic correction
    circuit.

    Physics predicts the effect.

    Engineering compensates for it.

    Your claim is that a theory cannot predict a correction unless its author explicitly instructs engineers to apply it.

    By that reasoning, Newton's laws would be useless for designing a bridge because Newton never supplied the construction drawings.

    Maciej, you have now conceded three essential points:

    1. LET and SR predict the same observable kinematic frequency shifts.

    2. Einstein explicitly discusses moving clock rates.

    3. Your alleged prohibition on clock corrections exists only "between the lines".

    And you still haven't supplied the equations of your unnamed gravitational alternative to GR.

    So let's make this very simple.

    Show us the actual passage in Einstein's theory that FORBIDS clock corrections.

    Not your interpretation.

    Not your insults.

    Not something "between the lines".

    An actual statement or a mathematical consequence.

    Until then, you are not refuting Einstein.

    You are refuting something you invented and attributed to him.

    Your Serious Clock(TM) has completed yet another revolution.

    And your argument is still stuck at the same hour.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 16:43:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 4:22 PM, Python wrote:
    But - measurement result? reported measurement result?
    None?

    A measurement result is a value obtained through a measurement
    procedure, including any corrections explicitly applied.

    Let me guess - it's poor piece of shit
    Python deciding whether it is a "measurement
    procedure" or not?

    A reported result is the value communicated to others.

    They may be identical. They may differ because of subsequent
    corrections, rounding or even transcription errors.

    You're desperately inventing insane pseudodefinitions
    to run from the facts: the measurement results do
    depend on labels.

    I'm asking about the real reality, not
    about gedanken reality

    GPS satellites are real, Maciej.

    Python, a measurement that really happened,
    not a measurement I can imagine accordingly
    to your idiotic assertions of what a measurement
    should be.


    GPS fucks your idiocy,
    it's second is +4 at a satellite.

    Again, the SI second is defined by 9,192,631,770

    Again, a bunch of idiots can easily write a
    definition of "a shark" as a grasseater, but
    the real sharks won't care about it.
    GPS second is +4Cs periods on the satellite.
    It's the reality, poor trash. Anyone can
    check how it looks like. You're just a
    mad piece of shit madly lying for the sake
    of mad, brainwashing religion.






    After days of insults, you finally admit that your supposed prohibition
    is NOT ACTUALLY WRITTEN in Einstein's paper.\

    Poor idiot was just a mad prophet mumbling
    inconsistently and slightly suggesting.
    It was his Holy Church which turned it into
    formal orders. Your wannabe definition of
    second is written clearly and 50 years later.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 17:05:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Maciej who? This is NetNews, not e-mail: We _all_ are reading here.
    You ought to keep (except from trimming to the relevant minimum) the attribution line instead:

    [Maciej Wo+|niak wrote: ]

    See also:

    Jan Schaumann: How do I quote correctly in Usenet? <https://www.netmeister.org/news/learn2quote.html#toc4>
    Show me: where the idiot mention any coordinate
    time different than his own dilating idiocy

    THANK YOU for providing Einstein's original paper!

    Let's actually READ it.

    https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/specrel.pdf

    This is (obviously) NOT Einstein's original paper (Einstein published
    his papers in German) from 1905. It is a (too crude) translation into
    English by George Barker Jeffery and Wilfrid Perrett from 1923. (German
    is my native language.)

    The German original can still be downloaded for free from the "Annalen
    der Physik" Web site, now part of the Wiley Online Library:

    <https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/andp.19053221004>

    The better, then-official translation into English by Anna Beck from
    1989 could be found in the Digital Einstein Papers at <https://einsteinpapers.press.princeton.edu/> until August 14, 2025; unfortunately, it is currently only available for free in the Internet
    Archive via <https://web.archive.org/>.

    Probably the most recent version that works is from April 2025:

    <https://web.archive.org/web/20250407184124/https://einsteinpapers.press.princeton.edu/vol2-trans/154>

    Because of the seeemingly insatiable greed of publishers such as Wiley &
    Sons, Princeton University Press, and Paradigm Publishing Services due
    to which Einstein's works are no longer available for free, at least not
    to the general public, and the Internet Archive only partially providing
    a working substitute in that regard, I am planning to publish Einstein's original paper(s) and my translation(s) of it/them (into English first,
    but maybe other languages, too) for free in (GitHub-flavored) Markdown.

    Wikibooks also has a commented German version:

    <https://de.wikibooks.org/wiki/A._Einstein:_Kommentare_und_Erl%C3%A4uterungen:_Zur_Elektrodynamik_bewegter_K%C3%B6rper>

    This could be translated into English and provided there by a community
    effort as well.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 17:08:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 5:05 PM, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
    Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Maciej who? This is NetNews, not e-mail: We _all_ are reading here.
    You ought to keep (except from trimming to the relevant minimum) the attribution line instead:

    [Maciej Wo+|niak wrote: ]

    Poor Python avoids quoting me because he doesn't
    want to help me spreading my heresies.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Cameron Harnikov@nhck@rcnam.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 16:16:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    J. J. Lodder wrote:

    good catch, but is not a force, but a distortion of spacetime

    but you pollacks have to go to war to defend europe, as you guys are
    expandable

    for europe, you pollacks and ukrans are expandable

    The best Russians are dead Russians.
    500 000 down, so far, with 1 400 000 disabled.

    Good going!

    idiot, start believing your globaalist own propaganda, huh

    amazing, this born again relativist just became an idiot, like the most
    around here; what a shame
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Wyatt Murogov@mtomuto@mu.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 16:35:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/13/2026 4:22 PM, Python wrote:
    But - measurement result? reported measurement result?
    None?

    A measurement result is a value obtained through a measurement
    procedure, including any corrections explicitly applied.

    Let me guess - it's poor piece of shit Python deciding whether it is a "measurement procedure" or not?


    indeed, you are 100% correct again

    like yesterday this python idiot, a former now obsolete
    it-supporter, complained about the english, proving
    he doesnt understand his own fucking french, as
    "expandable" is firstly Latin before any fucking english


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Panfilo Barabanschikov@noka@nrio.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 16:49:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    J. J. Lodder wrote:

    Your confusion between a physical phenomenon and the vocabulary used to
    describe it is becoming a recurring theme.

    Of REAL GPS clocks output, Python.

    https://ibb.co/7xJp96rQ (sigh)

    Do keep up the good work.
    It is your illustrations that make these near endless threads worth
    looking at every now and then,

    nevermind this shit, i bet there are more pollacks killed there in the
    fucking fictitious ukrane, as soldiers with "ukrane" badges on, which
    makes sense, once all the not braindead "ukrans" left the shithole country long time ago
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 17:12:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Let me guess - it's poor piece of shit
    Python deciding whether it is a "measurement
    procedure" or not?

    No. Metrology has established definitions and procedures.

    You might try learning them before inventing your own.

    the measurement results do depend on labels.

    You keep confusing changing a measurement with changing its interpretation
    or applying a numerical correction.

    Writing "systematic error: -4 Hz" on an instrument doesn't physically
    increase its oscillator frequency by 4 Hz.

    It changes how you interpret or correct the result.

    If you claim otherwise, demonstrate the physical effect.

    Python, a measurement that really happened

    Certainly.

    The NTS-2 satellite experiment in 1977 measured a relativistic fractional frequency shift of approximately:

    +443.1 x 10^-12

    The predicted value was approximately:

    +445.0 x 10^-12.

    An actual satellite.

    An actual atomic clock.

    An actual frequency measurement.

    And quantitative agreement with the relativistic prediction.

    No imaginary experiment, no magical labels.

    Now provide an equally precise experimental result supporting your claim
    that renaming a physical quantity changes an atomic oscillator's
    frequency.

    GPS second is +4Cs periods on the satellite.
    It's the reality, poor trash.

    No, Maciej.

    GPS coordinate time uses the SI second as its unit.

    A local atomic oscillator's frequency expressed relative to GPS coordinate time is not the same thing as its frequency measured per local proper
    second.

    That distinction is precisely what relativistic timekeeping requires.

    Your repeated "+4" is meaningless without specifying the reference time
    scale and the measurement procedure.

    And repeating the shark analogy doesn't make it any less confused.

    Poor idiot was just a mad prophet mumbling
    inconsistently and slightly suggesting.
    It was his Holy Church which turned it into
    formal orders.

    Ah, excellent!

    Yesterday, Einstein's theory FORBADE clock corrections.

    Then the prohibition was "between the lines".

    Now Einstein merely "slightly suggested" something, and an unspecified
    "Holy Church" supposedly imposed the prohibition fifty years later.

    Your accusation keeps changing because you cannot produce a single text or equation supporting it.

    So let's try again:

    WHO issued this alleged prohibition?

    WHERE was it published?

    WHAT exactly does it forbid?

    And HOW does it follow from relativity?

    A scientific claim requires evidence, Maciej.

    Not imaginary commandments, invented conspiracies and increasingly
    hysterical insults.

    Meanwhile, relativity supplies quantitative predictions for actual
    satellite clocks.

    Your alternative gravitational theory still supplies no equations, no calculations and no predictions.

    But apparently it does have one remarkable feature:

    Every time someone asks for evidence, its author produces another insult.

    Quite a reliable mechanism.

    Unfortunately, not one that helps GPS work.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 17:14:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity


    Thank you for pointing out that an English translation of Einstein's 1905 paper is not the original German text.

    A truly devastating discovery.

    Fortunately, the Lorentz transformations appear to have survived
    translation.

    As for "Maciej," I suspect the readers of this thread have little
    difficulty identifying the person being addressed. But thank you for protecting them from this terrible ambiguity.

    Now, since you've taken the trouble to discuss editions, translators, publishers, copyright, the Internet Archive, Markdown and Usenet
    attribution conventions, perhaps you could spare a sentence for the actual question:

    Does Einstein's 1905 paper forbid correcting clocks to synchronize them to
    a chosen time scale?

    Maciej claims it does, although he can only locate this prohibition
    "between the lines."

    Perhaps your command of the original German will help him find the missing sentence.

    That would contribute rather more to the discussion than another lecture
    on how to quote a message.

    But I appreciate that policing Usenet etiquette is considerably easier
    than discussing physics.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 18:23:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 6:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Let me guess - it's poor piece of shit
    Python deciding whether it is a "measurement
    procedure" or not?

    No. Metrology has established definitions and procedures.

    What an impudent lie.


    the measurement results do depend on labels.

    You keep confusing

    You keep lying, as expected from a piece of shit you are.



    Python, a measurement that really happened

    Certainly.

    The NTS-2 satellite experiment

    AND had "measurement result" and "reported
    result" different.



    GPS second is +4Cs periods on the satellite.
    It's the reality, poor trash.

    No, Maciej.

    Yes, Python.
    That's the reality. Anyone can check how
    it looks like. GPS second is +4Cs periods
    on the satellite.

    BTW, you're too dumb to notice, but
    you're simultaneously asserting that
    1)your wannabe definition is not forcing
    anyone to anything
    2)disobedience is impossible


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 17:25:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    What an impudent lie.

    The International Bureau of Weights and Measures and the International Vocabulary of Metrology will be devastated to learn that their definitions
    and procedures don't exist.

    Apparently, your insults have abolished metrology too.

    AND had "measurement result" and "reported
    result" different.

    The NTS-2 experiment reported a measured fractional frequency shift of approximately +443.1 x 10^-12, compared with a theoretical prediction of approximately +445.0 x 10^-12.

    Those are not two different versions of the same measurement result.

    One is experimental. The other is theoretical.

    I cited NTS-2 as a real measurement of a relativistic frequency shift, not
    as an example of a corrected report differing from its original result.

    Now, back to YOUR claim.

    You say that changing a label changes a measurement result.

    Does it change the physical number of oscillations counted?

    YES or NO?

    If NO, then you are talking about a change in reporting or interpretation,
    not a physical change in the oscillator.

    GPS second is +4Cs periods
    on the satellite.

    You keep repeating this without specifying the reference time scale.

    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of local
    proper time along a satellite's worldline.

    That is precisely why relativistic frequency corrections are required.

    And the GPS time scale uses the SI second. The fact that satellite
    oscillators must be adjusted to realize that scale does not redefine the
    SI second.

    you're simultaneously asserting that
    1)your wannabe definition is not forcing
    anyone to anything
    2)disobedience is impossible

    What a remarkable confusion.

    A definition is not a physical law.

    You are perfectly free to define your own unit of time.

    Call it the Maciej Second(TM), if you like.

    You can even define it as 9,192,631,774 caesium periods.

    Nobody will arrest you.

    But it will not be the SI second.

    And calling it one will not alter the frequency of a single atom.

    There is no "disobedience" involved.

    A physical oscillator does not obey or disobey a definition. It
    oscillates.

    A definition tells us how to assign a unit to a physical quantity.

    A measurement procedure tells us how to determine its value.

    A synchronization system tells us how to coordinate clock outputs.

    THREE DIFFERENT THINGS.

    You have spent days confusing them.

    And we are still waiting for the alleged prohibition on correcting clocks, which you finally admitted exists only "between the lines".

    Perhaps it is hiding next to your unnamed gravitational theory.

    Neither seems particularly easy to find.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 18:26:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 6:14 PM, Python wrote:

    Thank you for pointing out that an English translation of Einstein's
    1905 paper is not the original German text.

    A truly devastating discovery.

    Fortunately, the Lorentz transformations appear to have survived translation.

    As for "Maciej," I suspect the readers of this thread have little
    difficulty identifying the person being addressed. But thank you for protecting them from this terrible ambiguity.

    Now, since you've taken the trouble to discuss editions, translators, publishers, copyright, the Internet Archive, Markdown and Usenet
    attribution conventions, perhaps you could spare a sentence for the
    actual question:

    Does Einstein's 1905 paper forbid correcting clocks to synchronize them
    to a chosen time scale?

    Maciej claims it does, although he can only locate this prohibition
    "between the lines."

    No I don't. You're lying like always. He's just
    suggesting. But the doggies know what has to be
    done.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 18:51:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 6:25 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    What an impudent lie.

    The International Bureau of Weights and Measures and the International Vocabulary of Metrology will be devastated to learn that their
    definitions and procedures don't exist.

    You're lying, like always, and what I denied
    was not "the procedures exist" but "they
    define what a measurement procedure is".

    AND had "measurement result" and "reported
    result" different.

    The NTS-2 experiment reported a measured fractional frequency shift of approximately +443.1 x 10^-12, compared with a theoretical prediction of approximately +445.0 x 10^-12.

    So this is, i guess, that "reported result" of yours.
    And the "measurement result" was?


    You say that changing a label changes a measurement result.

    Does it change the physical number of oscillations counted?

    YES or NO?

    Python, poor piece of shit, what are you fucking
    about? Even without considering any labels you can
    measure a frequency with 300 or with 500 or with
    2000000 oscillations counted. It's just a choice
    of yours.



    GPS second is +4Cs periods
    on the satellite.

    You keep repeating this without specifying the reference time scale.
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of local proper time along a satellite's worldline.

    That's right, poor piece of shit, the second
    used in GPS is not identical to your mad
    ideological nonsense, it fucks it and is
    +4Cs periods in a satellite. I'm glad that
    even such a disgusting piece of lying shit as
    you are can't lie non stop.

    you're simultaneously asserting that
    1)your wannabe definition is not forcing
    anyone to anything
    2)disobedience is impossible

    What a remarkable confusion.

    A definition is not a physical law.

    You are perfectly free to define your own unit of time.

    And GPS staff is free to use a second which
    fucks your idiocy and is +4Cs periods on the
    satellite. Still your idiocy is REQUIRING
    a second to be counted as the same number of
    Cs periods everywhere. And if it succeeded
    with enforcing that - those mad prophecies
    of the idiot would be fulfilled. But it didn't
    succeed, sorry, poor piece of shit.








    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 17:51:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    No I don't. You're lying like always.

    On November 13, 2026, at 14:53, you wrote:

    Between the lines.

    That was your EXACT answer when I asked where Einstein forbids clock corrections.

    Now you say:

    He's just suggesting. But the doggies
    know what has to be done.

    So Einstein didn't forbid corrections after all?

    Then WHO did? WHERE? WHEN?

    I quoted your own words, Maciej. That's not lying.

    And your imaginary prohibition is still nowhere to be found.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 17:53:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    what I denied was not "the procedures exist"
    but "they define what a measurement procedure is".

    Look up the International Vocabulary of Metrology (VIM), entry 2.6: "measurement procedure".

    Yes, metrology actually defines it.

    And the "measurement result" was?

    For NTS-2, the reported experimental result was approximately +443.1 x
    10^-12.

    I never claimed that this experiment had a different unpublished raw
    result. I cited it as an actual measurement of a relativistic frequency
    shift.

    you can measure a frequency with 300 or
    with 500 or with 2000000 oscillations counted.

    Of course. You can choose different observation intervals.

    But that doesn't answer my question.

    Can changing a LABEL alter the number of oscillations physically observed during the SAME interval?

    YES or NO?

    your idiocy is REQUIRING a second to be
    counted as the same number of Cs periods everywhere.

    No. That is YOUR invention.

    The SI second is defined using 9,192,631,770 periods of the unperturbed caesium-133 transition, referring to the local proper time of the atom.

    It does NOT require every satellite to count exactly that many periods
    during one second of GPS coordinate time.

    Indeed, relativity predicts that these intervals need not coincide.

    GPS engineers compensate for precisely that difference.

    You have spent days attacking a requirement that relativity does not
    impose.

    And you still cannot produce a single equation or quotation imposing it.

    Your argument is not against relativity, Maciej.

    It is against your own misunderstanding of what a second means.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 18:55:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 6:51 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    No I don't. You're lying like always.

    On November 13, 2026, at 14:53, you wrote:

    Between the lines.

    That was your EXACT answer when I asked where Einstein forbids clock corrections.

    Now you say:

    He's just suggesting. But the doggies
    know what has to be done.

    So Einstein didn't forbid corrections after all?

    Then WHO did? WHERE? WHEN?

    Python, poor piece of shit - isn't your SI
    idiocy FORBIDDING to count a second differently
    than as the same number of Cs periods everywhere?

    If your mad religion succeeded in enforcing that -
    the idiot's prophecies would be fulfilled. But,
    of course, it didn't, common sense had been
    warning the idiot.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 18:00:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    isn't your SI idiocy FORBIDDING to count
    a second differently than as the same
    number of Cs periods everywhere?

    No.

    The SI second is defined using 9,192,631,770 periods of the unperturbed caesium-133 transition, in local proper time.

    It does NOT require every clock to count that many periods during one
    second of GPS coordinate time.

    Relativity predicts the difference. GPS compensates for it.

    First, Einstein supposedly forbade corrections.

    Then the prohibition was "between the lines".

    Then his mysterious "doggies" imposed it.

    Now it's the SI definition.

    And STILL no actual prohibition.

    Your argument gets weaker with every reply, Maciej.

    You are running out of imaginary authorities to blame.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 19:21:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 6:53 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    what I denied was not "the procedures exist"
    but "they define what a measurement procedure is".

    Look up the International Vocabulary of Metrology (VIM), entry 2.6: "measurement procedure".

    Yes, metrology actually defines it.

    Indeed. I was mistaken. Generalities of little value,
    but enough to be sure that your "reported result"
    was fabricated ad hoc. Nothing like that exists.

    And a measurement result - "set of quantity values
    being attributed to a measurand together with any
    other available relevant information". You had
    exactly no reason to deny that both my label-depending
    measurement results are measurement results.
    Except, of course, your urge to deny that.


    And the "measurement result" was?

    For NTS-2, the reported experimental result was approximately +443.1 x 10^-12.

    I never claimed that this experiment had a different unpublished raw
    result.

    But you gave it as an example after I asked you
    for an example with different "reported result"
    and "measurement result". Of course, you're
    a piece of lying shit and your "reported
    result" is a fabricated ad hoc idiocy of no
    meaning.

    you can measure a frequency with 300 or
    with 500 or with 2000000 oscillations counted.

    Of course. You can choose different observation intervals.

    But that doesn't answer my question.

    Can changing a LABEL alter the number of oscillations physically
    observed during the SAME interval?

    That was not your question. But, ok, no.
    It's just that whatever you're going
    to conclude from that - your "logic"
    sucks.


    YES or NO?

    your idiocy is REQUIRING a second to be
    counted as the same number of Cs periods everywhere.

    No. That is YOUR invention.

    So it's telling that a second is 9,192,631,770 of
    Cs periods, but if I count 6 000 000 000 it's going to be
    still OK according to it? Python, poor piece of shit, get
    conscious.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 18:26:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Indeed. I was mistaken.

    Good. Progress.

    your "reported result" was fabricated ad hoc.

    No. "Reported result" simply means a result communicated in a report. I
    never claimed it was a separate VIM-defined category.

    And yes, NTS-2 was an example of a real frequency measurement, not an
    example of two different numerical results. That example didn't answer
    your specific request.

    But, ok, no.

    EXCELLENT.

    You finally acknowledge that changing a label does NOT change the number
    of oscillations physically observed during the same interval.

    That was the point.

    You may assign different corrected values to the same observation,
    provided you specify the correction and what quantity you are reporting.

    But the physical observation remains unchanged.

    if I count 6 000 000 000 it's going to be
    still OK according to it?

    Six billion caesium periods do not constitute one local SI second under
    the defining conditions.

    Nobody claimed otherwise.

    But the number of caesium periods occurring during one second of a
    DIFFERENT time coordinate need not be 9,192,631,770.

    That is exactly the distinction you keep missing.

    LOCAL PROPER TIME is not necessarily GPS COORDINATE TIME.

    The SI definition does not abolish relativity. It is compatible with it.

    And GPS synchronization requires accounting for that distinction.

    So far, you have admitted that metrology defines measurement procedures
    and that labels do not change physical oscillator counts.

    Two useful concessions in one message.

    Perhaps next you'll discover that correcting a clock doesn't mean
    declaring it defective.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 19:41:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 7:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Indeed. I was mistaken.

    Good. Progress.

    your "reported result" was fabricated ad hoc.

    No. "Reported result" simply means a result communicated in a report. I never claimed it was a separate VIM-defined category.

    Will you also lie that you didn't pretend
    that your "reported result" is not a measurement
    result at all? Think carefully before asserting
    that you didn't, poor piece of shit.





    But, ok, no.

    EXCELLENT.

    You finally acknowledge that changing a label does NOT change the number
    of oscillations physically observed during the same interval.

    That was the point.

    Point of what? It's still SI number when
    measuring with label "propercorrectperfect"
    and SI+4 when measured with label "systematic
    error of 4periods per second".


    if I count 6 000 000 000 it's going to be
    still OK according to it?

    Six billion caesium periods do not constitute one local SI second under
    the defining conditions.

    So, is it OK according to the definition
    or is it not OK according to the definition?

    But the number of caesium periods occurring during one second of a
    DIFFERENT time coordinate need not be 9,192,631,770.

    Nobody sane has to treat your nonsense seriously,
    sure, but if it is not 9,192,631,770 it is WRONG
    according to it. And WRONG means "don't do it".
    That's a general rule always valid for this word.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Raymie Babashov@hbr@mve.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 20:15:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/13/2026 7:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Indeed. I was mistaken.

    Good. Progress.

    your "reported result" was fabricated ad hoc.

    No. "Reported result" simply means a result communicated in a report. I
    never claimed it was a separate VIM-defined category.

    Will you also lie that you didn't pretend that your "reported result" is
    not a measurement result at all? Think carefully before asserting that
    you didn't, poor piece of shit.

    so true indeed, you are correct all the time
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 21:31:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Cameron Harnikov <nhck@rcnam.ru> wrote:

    J. J. Lodder wrote:

    good catch, but is not a force, but a distortion of spacetime

    but you pollacks have to go to war to defend europe, as you guys are
    expandable

    for europe, you pollacks and ukrans are expandable

    The best Russians are dead Russians.
    500 000 down, so far, with 1 400 000 disabled.

    Good going!

    idiot, start believing your globaalist own propaganda, huh

    The numbers are derived from a hack of the Russian population database.
    Those Russians are too dumb to safeguard their own records properly,

    Jan



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 21:31:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Maciej,

    Roemer, speed of light, 1676, 226,663 - is it
    according to you "measurement result" or
    "reported measurement result"?

    A historical estimate, derived from observations and reported by someone.

    Incidentally, your attribution of that precise numerical value to Romer
    in 1676 is questionable. He estimated a light-travel delay, not the speed
    of light in modern numerical units.

    More precisely, directly interpretating his results,
    Romer measured the speed of light in terms of the AU.
    (the astronomical unit, aka the major axis of the orbit of the Earth)

    The AU was not known accurately in terms of terrestrial units,
    (at the time)

    Jan

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Fri Nov 13 21:26:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Think carefully before asserting that you didn't

    Is that supposed to be intimidating?

    A reported measurement result can perfectly well be a measurement result.
    I have already clarified that distinction.

    It's still SI number when measuring with
    label "propercorrectperfect" and SI+4 when
    measured with label "systematic error"

    You have admitted that changing the label does NOT change the physical oscillation count.

    So your "+4" comes from an arithmetic correction, not from the label
    magically altering the oscillator.

    And once again, "proper time" does NOT mean "propercorrectperfect time".

    "Proper" means specific to the clock's worldline, not perfect, accurate or morally superior.

    Your entire argument seems to depend on misunderstanding an English
    adjective.

    So, is it OK according to the definition
    or is it not OK according to the definition?

    Six billion caesium periods do not constitute one SI second of local
    proper time under the defining conditions.

    But they can certainly occur during some other specified time interval.

    There is no contradiction.

    And WRONG means "don't do it".
    That's a general rule always valid for this word.

    LOL!

    https://ibb.co/Nds7HWnz

    No, Maciej. "Wrong" can mean factually incorrect, mathematically false or inconsistent with a definition.

    It does NOT universally mean "don't do it".

    If I say "2 + 2 = 5 is wrong", I am not issuing a prohibition against
    writing the equation.

    If I say "six billion caesium periods are not one SI second", I am not forbidding anyone from counting six billion periods.

    And if a GPS satellite's clock needs a frequency correction, relativity is
    not forbidding engineers from applying it.

    You have now reduced your supposed refutation of Einstein to:

    "WRONG means DON'T DO IT!"

    Apparently, after failing to find the prohibition in Einstein's equations,
    his paper, or the SI definition, you have finally discovered it in your
    own private dictionary.

    Your Serious Clock(TM) must be speechless.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Stefhen Czajkowski@wekc@nees.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 21:36:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    J. J. Lodder wrote:

    The best Russians are dead Russians.
    500 000 down, so far, with 1 400 000 disabled.

    Good going!

    idiot, start believing your globaalist own propaganda, huh

    The numbers are derived from a hack of the Russian population database.
    Those Russians are too dumb to safeguard their own records properly,

    amazing a relativist can be so cretin, you dont even check where you take
    your data from; here we go, are you good in ratios

    Russia-Ukraine Fallen Soldiers Body Exchanges (Reported 2025-2026)
    rUa
    Date To Ukraine To Russia
    rUa
    Jun 2025 6060 - 78
    Sep 16,2005 1000 - 24
    Dec 15,2025 1003 - 26
    Jan 30,2026 1000 - 38
    Feb 26,2026 1000 - 35
    Apr 5, 2006 1000 - 41
    May 16,2026 528 - 41
    Jun 15,2026 522 - 33rUa
    rUa
    The history of body exchange in 2025:
    rUa
    Sep 18th: 1000 - 24
    Aug 19th: 1000 - 19
    Jul 17th: 1000 - 17
    Jun 16th: 1245 - 78
    Jun 15th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 14th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 13th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 11th: 1212 - 27
    May 16th: 909 - 34
    Apr 18th: 909 - 41
    Mar 28th: 909 - 43
    Feb 14th: 757 - 45
    Jan 24th: 757 - 49
    rUa
    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 21:37:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 13/11/2026 |a 21:15, Raymie Babashov a |-crit :
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/13/2026 7:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Indeed. I was mistaken.

    Good. Progress.

    your "reported result" was fabricated ad hoc.

    No. "Reported result" simply means a result communicated in a report. I
    never claimed it was a separate VIM-defined category.

    Will you also lie that you didn't pretend that your "reported result" is
    not a measurement result at all? Think carefully before asserting that
    you didn't, poor piece of shit.

    so true indeed, you are correct all the time

    Raymie,

    Another nym, same tired trolling.

    https://ibb.co/9m5zqgpF

    When you have an argument instead of applause for Maciej, do let us know.

    Preferably under whichever name you're using that day.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 21:41:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 13/11/2026 |a 22:36, Stefhen Czajkowski a |-crit :
    J. J. Lodder wrote:

    The best Russians are dead Russians.
    500 000 down, so far, with 1 400 000 disabled.

    Good going!

    idiot, start believing your globaalist own propaganda, huh

    The numbers are derived from a hack of the Russian population database.
    Those Russians are too dumb to safeguard their own records properly,

    amazing a relativist can be so cretin, you dont even check where you take your data from; here we go, are you good in ratios

    Russia-Ukraine Fallen Soldiers Body Exchanges (Reported 2025-2026)
    rUa
    Date To Ukraine To Russia
    rUa
    Jun 2025 6060 - 78
    Sep 16,2005 1000 - 24
    Dec 15,2025 1003 - 26
    Jan 30,2026 1000 - 38
    Feb 26,2026 1000 - 35
    Apr 5, 2006 1000 - 41
    May 16,2026 528 - 41
    Jun 15,2026 522 - 33rUa
    rUa
    The history of body exchange in 2025:
    rUa
    Sep 18th: 1000 - 24
    Aug 19th: 1000 - 19
    Jul 17th: 1000 - 17
    Jun 16th: 1245 - 78
    Jun 15th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 14th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 13th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 11th: 1212 - 27
    May 16th: 909 - 34
    Apr 18th: 909 - 41
    Mar 28th: 909 - 43
    Feb 14th: 757 - 45
    Jan 24th: 757 - 49
    rUa
    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone

    Stefhen,

    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone

    I did. Apparently, you didn't.

    Your 13 rows add up to 13,298 and 377, not 12,389 and 317.

    And your June 2025 total of 6,060 already includes the individual June repatriations you list separately.

    Double-counting the dead is a rather spectacular way to demonstrate your mathematical skills.

    But your fundamental mistake is worse.

    The ratio of bodies EXCHANGED is not the ratio of soldiers KILLED.

    It measures which bodies were recovered, held and repatriated, not total battlefield mortality.

    Meanwhile, the Financial Times reported on November 13, 2026, that leaked Russian statistical records indicate at least 450,000 Russian war deaths
    by summer 2026.

    So yes, I did the math.

    Perhaps you should try understanding what the numbers actually measure
    before lecturing anyone about ratios.

    And preferably learn to add them first.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Virgil Zdunowski@unrzln@nidur.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 21:52:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    Russia-Ukraine Fallen Soldiers Body Exchanges (Reported 2025-2026)
    rUa
    Date To Ukraine To Russia
    rUa
    Jun 2025 6060 - 78
    Sep 16,2005 1000 - 24
    Dec 15,2025 1003 - 26
    Jan 30,2026 1000 - 38
    Feb 26,2026 1000 - 35
    Apr 5, 2006 1000 - 41
    May 16,2026 528 - 41
    Jun 15,2026 522 - 33rUa
    rUa
    The history of body exchange in 2025:
    rUa
    Sep 18th: 1000 - 24
    Aug 19th: 1000 - 19
    Jul 17th: 1000 - 17
    Jun 16th: 1245 - 78
    Jun 15th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 14th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 13th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 11th: 1212 - 27
    May 16th: 909 - 34
    Apr 18th: 909 - 41
    Mar 28th: 909 - 43
    Feb 14th: 757 - 45
    Jan 24th: 757 - 49
    rUa
    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone

    Stefhen,

    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone

    I did. Apparently, you didn't.

    Your 13 rows add up to 13,298 and 377, not 12,389 and 317.

    idiot, 2 diferent tables, there might be small difference, that
    wont change the ratio; do the math again, idiot

    this data is registered, you fucking stoopid, they are not lying
    with the dead; one more proof this wanker is an inbreed idiot
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 21:59:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 13/11/2026 |a 22:52, Virgil Zdunowski a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Russia-Ukraine Fallen Soldiers Body Exchanges (Reported 2025-2026)
    rUa
    Date To Ukraine To Russia
    rUa
    Jun 2025 6060 - 78
    Sep 16,2005 1000 - 24
    Dec 15,2025 1003 - 26
    Jan 30,2026 1000 - 38
    Feb 26,2026 1000 - 35
    Apr 5, 2006 1000 - 41
    May 16,2026 528 - 41
    Jun 15,2026 522 - 33rUa
    rUa
    The history of body exchange in 2025:
    rUa
    Sep 18th: 1000 - 24
    Aug 19th: 1000 - 19
    Jul 17th: 1000 - 17
    Jun 16th: 1245 - 78
    Jun 15th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 14th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 13th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 11th: 1212 - 27
    May 16th: 909 - 34
    Apr 18th: 909 - 41
    Mar 28th: 909 - 43
    Feb 14th: 757 - 45
    Jan 24th: 757 - 49
    rUa
    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone

    Stefhen,

    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone

    I did. Apparently, you didn't.

    Your 13 rows add up to 13,298 and 377, not 12,389 and 317.

    idiot, 2 diferent tables, there might be small difference, that
    wont change the ratio; do the math again, idiot

    this data is registered, you fucking stoopid, they are not lying
    with the dead; one more proof this wanker is an inbreed idiot

    Stefhen,

    You now admit that these are two different tables. Fine.

    But your second table contains 13 rows adding up to **13,298 Ukrainian
    bodies and 377 Russian bodies**, not 12,389 and 317.

    That's a ratio of 35.3:1, not 39:1.

    More importantly, you are confusing two entirely different quantities:

    **Bodies exchanged rea soldiers killed.**

    The number of bodies returned depends on who controls the battlefield, who
    can recover the bodies, how long they have been accumulated, and the terms
    of the exchanges.

    Russia returning 35 Ukrainian bodies for every Russian body returned by Ukraine does NOT mean Ukraine suffered 35 times as many fatalities.

    You are measuring the distribution of recovered bodies, not the
    distribution of battlefield deaths.

    And no, the fact that body exchanges are officially recorded does not magically turn them into comprehensive casualty statistics.

    Your arithmetic was wrong. Your statistical inference is worse.

    Insults won't fix either.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brennan Chevalier@nnnee@harn.fr to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Nov 13 22:15:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    idiot, 2 diferent tables, there might be small difference, that wont
    change the ratio; do the math again, idiot

    this data is registered, you fucking stoopid, they are not lying with
    the dead; one more proof this wanker is an inbreed idiot

    Stefhen,

    You now admit that these are two different tables. Fine.

    But your second table contains 13 rows adding up to **13,298 Ukrainian
    bodies and 377 Russian bodies**, not 12,389 and 317.

    what "admit" you deplorable cretin, cant you read the text alone, 2 tables
    and what 13 rows, fucking idiot

    come back with the ratio and stop saying anything
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 08:44:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/13/2026 10:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Think carefully before asserting that you didn't

    Is that supposed to be intimidating?

    A reported measurement result can perfectly well be a measurement
    result. I have already clarified that distinction.

    So with

    But that makes the measurement result +4.
    No. It makes your REPORTED result +4.

    were you suggesting that +4 is not
    the measurement result or weren't
    you?
    yes or no, poor piece of shit?





    It's still SI number when measuring with
    label "propercorrectperfect" and SI+4 when
    measured with label "systematic error"

    You have admitted that changing the label does NOT change the physical oscillation count.

    So your "+4" comes from an arithmetic correction, not from the label magically altering the oscillator.

    So - what?
    "detailed description of a measurement according to one or more
    measurement principles and to a given measurement method, based on a measurement model and including ANY CALCULATION to obtain a measurement result".



    And once again, "proper time" does NOT mean "propercorrectperfect time".

    And once again, yes, it does.


    "Proper" means specific to the clock's worldline, not perfect, accurate
    or morally superior.

    When a piece of lying, fanatic shit is asserting -
    it just has to be true, sure.

    Once again, poor piece of shit: if it was
    "the idiot's delusion" instead "proper time"
    you would never imagine that GPS clocks
    "do not measure: THE REAL TIME". It's not
    about its officially declared content, it's
    about repeating your idiocies in the company
    of well associated words.




    And WRONG means "don't do it".
    That's a general rule always valid for this word.

    LOL!

    https://ibb.co/Nds7HWnz

    No, Maciej. "Wrong" can mean factually incorrect, mathematically false
    or inconsistent with a definition.

    And the common area is: "avoid it".



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 10:40:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Yes, +4 can be the measurement result AFTER applying a correction.

    It can also be the REPORTED measurement result.

    These are not mutually exclusive categories, you idiot.

    The VIM explicitly allows calculations in obtaining measurement results. Nobody disputes that.

    What you still fail to understand is that applying an arithmetic
    correction does not change the physical oscillation count of the clock.

    Changing a label does not change it either.

    And your obsession with "propercorrectperfect" is becoming hilarious.

    Proper time is a precisely defined physical quantity associated with a worldline. It does NOT mean perfectly accurate time, perfectly functioning clock, or "THE REAL TIME".

    Your private reinterpretation of an English adjective has no bearing whatsoever on its mathematical definition.

    Finally, "wrong" does not mean "don't do it". It describes something incorrect. Whether you should avoid it is a separate, normative question.

    For example, your interpretation of proper time is wrong.

    Unfortunately, you keep doing it.

    See the difference?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 12:00:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 11:40 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Yes, +4 can be the measurement result AFTER applying a correction.

    It can also be the REPORTED measurement result.

    These are not mutually exclusive categories, you idiot.

    And your "logic" of

    "> But that makes the measurement result +4.
    No. It makes your REPORTED result +4."

    is just your usual baseless crap,
    poor piece of shit.


    What you still fail to understand is that applying an arithmetic
    correction does not change the physical oscillation count of the clock.

    What you still fail to understand is -
    that you're just a brainwashed, lying
    piece of shit fabricating and claiming
    whatever is at the moment comfortable
    to you - and too stupid to do it
    consistently.

    Your lies are changing nothing, the
    labels on a device can affect a
    measurement result and the real
    result of time measurement in GPS
    give t'=t. Yes, the clocks are calibrated
    there (so don't lie I'm avoiding
    admitting that, poor trash).






    And your obsession with "propercorrectperfect" is becoming hilarious.

    Proper time is a precisely defined physical quantity associated with a

    "Ministry of Love" was also precisely defined.
    It doesn't matter how it is defined, what
    matters is repeating the idiot's idiocies in
    the company of well associated words.




    Finally, "wrong" does not mean "don't do it". It describes something incorrect.

    Yes, it does, and "incorrect" does as well.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 11:05:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    So now you explicitly admit that GPS clocks are calibrated.

    Excellent. Some progress at last.

    And what does calibration involve? Establishing the relationship between
    an instrument's indications and reference values, allowing appropriate corrections to be applied.

    The resulting agreement with GPS coordinate time does NOT imply that the clocks' proper times are identical.

    Quite the opposite: the need for relativistic frequency corrections is precisely what you keep trying to explain away.

    You have spent days arguing that a corrected measurement result can differ from a raw indication.

    Nobody disagrees.

    You then pretend that the corrected result proves the absence of the
    physical effect being corrected.

    Brilliant logic.

    As for your "Ministry of Love" analogy, apparently you now believe that mathematical definitions can be refuted by quoting Orwell.

    Proper time is defined by the spacetime interval along a worldline, not by
    the emotional associations of the English word "proper".

    And "wrong" is still a description of incorrectness, not an imperative.

    Here's a simple example:

    "Maciej's argument is wrong."

    That sentence describes your argument. It does not instruct anyone to do anything.

    Perhaps you should spend less time policing English adjectives and more
    time understanding the distinction between proper time, coordinate time,
    and calibrated clock readings.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 12:12:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 12:05 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    So now you explicitly admit that GPS clocks are calibrated.

    Excellent. Some progress at last.

    Did it at least 40 times
    in the last month and you're
    lying like always.




    And what does calibration involve? Establishing the relationship between
    an instrument's indications and reference values, allowing appropriate corrections to be applied.

    The resulting agreement with GPS coordinate time does NOT imply that the clocks' proper times are identical.

    But it does mean that their
    measured indications are - t'=t.
    Common sense had been warning
    the idiot.
    And nobody cares for your "proper"
    idiocy, giving it a bombastic name
    didn't make it important.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 11:28:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Yes, I was wrong. You had already admitted that GPS clocks are calibrated.

    I wasn't lying. I was mistaken. There is a difference.

    So I stand corrected: you've made no progress whatsoever. :-)

    As for "proper" being a bombastic name, I rather disagree. It's a
    perfectly ordinary English adjective. Hardly the sort of name anyone would choose to market some grandiose, revolutionary product.

    And it certainly wasn't chosen to confuse some random Polish crank.

    Although, admittedly, it seems to have achieved precisely that. :-)

    Meanwhile, proper time remains a well-defined physical quantity,
    regardless of your opinions about English vocabulary.

    And corrected GPS clock readings still don't make the relativistic
    differences in elapsed proper time disappear.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 12:45:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 12:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Yes, I was wrong. You had already admitted that GPS clocks are calibrated.

    I wasn't lying. I was mistaken. There is a difference.

    So I stand corrected: you've made no progress whatsoever. :-)

    As for "proper" being a bombastic name, I rather disagree. It's a
    perfectly ordinary English adjective. Hardly the sort of name anyone > would choose to market some grandiose, revolutionary product.

    Marketers are not as impudent as your bunch of
    idiots, I guess. Of course, they assert their
    stuff is propercorrectperfeclygood, but to
    NAME it with any of those...



    And it certainly wasn't chosen to confuse some random Polish crank.

    No, it was chosen to confuse a million
    of relativistic idiots instead.



    Meanwhile, proper time remains a well-defined physical quantity,

    Ministry of Love was also precisely defined.
    It doesn't matter how you define it, what
    matters is repeating the idiot's idiocies
    in the company of well associated words.

    And corrected GPS clock readings still don't make the relativistic differences in elapsed proper time disappear.

    They do, same as corrected pendulums would kill
    any alleged "pendulum proper time dilation" if it
    ever appeared.






    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 11:50:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    We've been through all of this before. Many times.

    Correcting a clock's rate does not eliminate the physical effect that made
    the correction necessary.

    A calibrated pendulum doesn't abolish gravity, and a frequency-adjusted
    GPS clock doesn't abolish relativistic time dilation.

    Your Orwell analogy doesn't change the mathematics, and your obsession
    with the word "proper" doesn't change its definition.

    You keep confusing compensating for a physical effect with demonstrating
    that the effect doesn't exist.

    Face it, Maciej. Repeating the same argument, with increasingly creative insults, won't make it any less wrong.

    And no, calling something "wrong" still doesn't mean "don't do it".
    Although in your case, that might actually be good advice. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 12:54:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 12:50 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    We've been through all of this before. Many times.

    Correcting a clock's rate does not eliminate the physical effect that
    made the correction necessary.

    Your time dilation is not any physical
    effect. LET considers the same physical
    effects as your SR shit and no dilation
    there. Your dilation is just your
    as idiotic as it is baseless faith in
    the perfection of your desynchronizing
    junk.



    And no, calling something "wrong" still doesn't mean "don't do it".

    Yes it still does.

    Although in your case, that might actually be good advice. :-)

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 12:01:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Your LET argument is remarkably weak.

    First, LET does not eliminate the physical effects on moving clocks. It
    merely offers a different interpretation of them, introducing an
    undetectable preferred frame.

    Second, LET was constructed to reproduce the predictions of SR. So
    invoking it against experimentally observed relativistic effects is rather self-defeating.

    And where is your LET equivalent of General Relativity?

    A complete theory of gravitation, with quantitative predictions for gravitational time dilation, light deflection, gravitational waves, and so
    on?

    I'm not aware of any generally accepted LET-based alternative with
    comparable scope and empirical success.

    Your argument reminds me of Le Sage's old mechanical theory of
    gravitation: an imagined flux of particles, partially screened by massive bodies, could produce an inverse-square gravitational attraction
    resembling Newton's law.

    An ingenious idea, perhaps, but reproducing one formula is not enough to establish a viable physical theory.

    Likewise, reproducing some predictions of SR while adding an unobservable preferred frame doesn't refute SR.

    And claiming that time dilation doesn't exist because calibrated GPS
    clocks display coordinated time is still the same elementary confusion
    we've discussed dozens of times.

    Face it, Maciej: you haven't disproved relativity. You've merely found an alternative vocabulary for describing some of its predictions, and
    mistaken that for a refutation.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 13:10:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 1:01 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Your LET argument is remarkably weak.

    First, LET does not eliminate the physical effects on moving clocks.


    But no "time dilation" there.


    It
    merely offers a different interpretation of them

    With no "time dilation" of yours.
    Your idiocy is an interpretation too
    - based at your blind, mad faith in your
    propercorrectperfectlygood clocks.



    , introducing an
    undetectable preferred frame.

    Second, LET was constructed to reproduce the predictions of SR.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorentz_ether_theory
    1892-1895, poor brainwashed fanatic. If anything
    was "constructed to reproduce" here - it was your
    moronic Shit.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Nov 14 13:11:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Le 13/11/2026 a 22:36, Stefhen Czajkowski a ocrit :
    J. J. Lodder wrote:

    The best Russians are dead Russians.
    500 000 down, so far, with 1 400 000 disabled.

    Good going!

    idiot, start believing your globaalist own propaganda, huh

    The numbers are derived from a hack of the Russian population database.
    Those Russians are too dumb to safeguard their own records properly,

    amazing a relativist can be so cretin, you dont even check where you take your data from; here we go, are you good in ratios

    Russia-Ukraine Fallen Soldiers Body Exchanges (Reported 2025-2026)
    ?
    Date To Ukraine To Russia
    ?
    Jun 2025 6060 - 78
    Sep 16,2005 1000 - 24
    Dec 15,2025 1003 - 26
    Jan 30,2026 1000 - 38
    Feb 26,2026 1000 - 35
    Apr 5, 2006 1000 - 41
    May 16,2026 528 - 41
    Jun 15,2026 522 - 33?
    ?
    The history of body exchange in 2025:
    ?
    Sep 18th: 1000 - 24
    Aug 19th: 1000 - 19
    Jul 17th: 1000 - 17
    Jun 16th: 1245 - 78
    Jun 15th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 14th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 13th: 1200 - 0
    Jun 11th: 1212 - 27
    May 16th: 909 - 34
    Apr 18th: 909 - 41
    Mar 28th: 909 - 43
    Feb 14th: 757 - 45
    Jan 24th: 757 - 49
    ?
    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone

    Stefhen,

    Total: 12,389 - 317 (39:1 ratio)

    now do the math, alone

    I did. Apparently, you didn't.

    Your 13 rows add up to 13,298 and 377, not 12,389 and 317.

    And your June 2025 total of 6,060 already includes the individual June repatriations you list separately.

    Double-counting the dead is a rather spectacular way to demonstrate your mathematical skills.

    But your fundamental mistake is worse.

    The ratio of bodies EXCHANGED is not the ratio of soldiers KILLED.

    It measures which bodies were recovered, held and repatriated, not total battlefield mortality.

    Meanwhile, the Financial Times reported on November 13, 2026, that leaked Russian statistical records indicate at least 450,000 Russian war deaths
    by summer 2026.

    So yes, I did the math.

    Perhaps you should try understanding what the numbers actually measure
    before lecturing anyone about ratios.

    And preferably learn to add them first.

    Russians prefer to leave their dead in the field,
    and report them as missing.
    So officers can nick their possession,
    and it saves on paying widow pensions.

    They are real nice people, those Russians,

    Jan

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 12:20:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Fine. No "time dilation" in your preferred terminology, if that makes you happy.

    But the SAME physical effects on the SAME actual clocks, with the SAME experimentally observable differences in their rates. :-)

    You can refuse to call it "time dilation" until you're blue in the face.
    The clocks won't care.

    And yes, Lorentz's theory predates Einstein's 1905 paper. My wording was historically inaccurate.

    But that doesn't change the point: the mature Lorentz ether theory and SR reproduce the same observable predictions in their common domain.

    So what exactly have you refuted?

    A name?

    Congratulations, Maciej. You've defeated two English words while leaving
    the physics completely untouched.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 13:26:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 1:20 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Fine. No "time dilation" in your preferred terminology, if that makes
    you happy.

    But the SAME physical effects on the SAME actual clocks, with the SAME experimentally observable differences in their rates. :-)

    And with no time dilation.

    You can refuse to call it "time dilation" until you're blue in the face.
    The clocks won't care.

    And you can produce your moronic drawings and scream
    about nurses and bottles of vodka until you're blue in
    the face. The clocks won't care, they will keep
    measuring t'=t just like they always did.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 12:36:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    How amusing. You're the one accusing others of believing in some mystical reality called "time", while physics deals with actual, concrete
    oscillators.

    And those oscillators exhibit precisely the physical effects predicted by relativity.

    GPS clocks are adjusted to maintain agreement with GPS coordinate time.
    They do NOT demonstrate that their elapsed proper times are identical.

    What you call t' = t is an agreement between corrected clock indications
    and a common coordinate time scale.

    The difference between a clock's proper time and GPS coordinate time is precisely what relativistic calculations account for.

    And those calculations work.

    You can deny the word "dilation", worship your preferred terminology, or invoke Lorentz's ether as often as you like.

    The physical oscillators remain stubbornly indifferent to your vocabulary.

    Maciej: 0
    Relativity: 2

    And the clocks are still ticking. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 14:02:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 1:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    How amusing. You're the one accusing others of believing in some
    mystical reality called "time", while physics deals with actual,
    concrete oscillators.

    It should have stuck to them and
    avoid babbling about ideal clocks and
    time. These 2 are far too complicated
    for the little brains of its doggies.
    And for sure it shouldn't try to
    revolutionize them.




    GPS clocks are adjusted to maintain agreement with GPS coordinate time.
    They do NOT demonstrate that their elapsed proper times are identical.

    Yes, it doesn't demonstrate that the idiot's
    delusion is identical for them. It just
    demonstrates that the measured indications
    are - t'=t. But everyone cares about
    the clock indications (i.e. time) and
    nobody cares about the idiot's delusion.

    Even you don't. A simple test - when a GPS
    satellite real clock indicates 2026-11-14
    17:00:00.000000000000 - it's "elapsed
    proper time" is ...?
    You don't know. You don't care. Your answer
    is "can be any number". But you still assert
    it is a precisely defined variable. What
    a pathetic crap.






    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 13:07:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Your "simple test" is another demonstration of your confusion.

    You give me a clock reading:

    2026-11-14 17:00:00.000000000000

    And ask for its "elapsed proper time".

    Elapsed since WHEN, Maciej?

    Proper time is the duration along a worldline between two events. To
    calculate it, you must specify those events.

    A clock displaying 17:00 doesn't tell you how much proper time has elapsed since its manufacture, its launch, or any other arbitrarily chosen event.

    Just as an odometer reading cannot tell you the distance travelled since
    an unspecified starting point.

    That doesn't make distance a mystical delusion.

    Nor does it make proper time one.

    And the fact that a GPS clock displays GPS coordinate time after
    appropriate adjustments doesn't mean its underlying oscillator accumulates cycles at the same rate as an uncorrected reference oscillator.

    Your argument amounts to demanding a numerical answer to an incompletely specified question, then declaring the physical quantity meaningless
    because no unique answer exists.

    Maciej: 0
    Relativity: 3

    You really should stop confusing the hands of a clock with the physics of
    the clock.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 18:15:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 2:07 PM, Python wrote:
    Your "simple test" is another demonstration of your confusion.

    You give me a clock reading:

    2026-11-14 17:00:00.000000000000

    And ask for its "elapsed proper time".

    Elapsed since WHEN, Maciej?

    That's what I'm asking you.
    How are you going to initialize your
    "precisely defined" variable?



    Proper time is the duration along a worldline between two events.

    Quoting the idiot:
    It might appear possible to overcome all the difficulties attending the definition of rCLtimerCY by substituting rCLthe position of the small hand of my watchrCY for rCLtime.rCY
    No single event mentioned.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 17:26:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    How do I initialize proper time?

    By choosing an origin, -a = 0, at some event on the clock's worldline.

    Exactly as we choose t = 0 for coordinate time, x = 0 for position, or
    zero altitude for a height measurement.

    The elapsed proper time between two events is independent of that
    arbitrary choice.

    And your Einstein quotation is particularly amusing.

    "It might appear possible..."

    Have you noticed those words, Maciej?

    Einstein is introducing a difficulty with identifying time with the
    position of a clock's hand, not proclaiming that a clock reading provides
    some absolute, universal time requiring no conventions.

    You quote the opening of an argument as though it were its conclusion.

    A clock can be initialized to display any chosen date and time. That
    doesn't change the proper time elapsed along its worldline between two specified events.

    So here's your answer:

    Choose an initial event E0, assign -a(E0) = 0, and integrate proper time
    along the worldline.

    No mysticism. No idealized perfection. No "propercorrectperfectlygood"
    clocks.

    Just a well-defined physical quantity and an arbitrary choice of origin.

    Maciej: 0
    Relativity: 4

    And you still haven't found a contradiction.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 18:46:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 6:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    How do I initialize proper time?

    By choosing an origin, -a = 0

    Sure. How?
    Oh, I know. You have no idea.
    That's how precisely defined
    is your precisely defined idiocy.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 17:48:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 14/11/2026 |a 18:46, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/14/2026 6:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    How do I initialize proper time?

    By choosing an origin, -a = 0

    Sure. How?
    Oh, I know. You have no idea.
    That's how precisely defined
    is your precisely defined idiocy.


    How? Here's a concrete example: GPS.

    GPS time has a precisely defined origin: January 6, 1980, at 00:00:00 UTC.

    That origin was chosen by convention. It wasn't discovered engraved on the fabric of the universe.

    GPS satellite clocks are initialized and synchronized using a defined time scale, clock models, and corrections.

    For proper time, the procedure is equally straightforward:

    Choose an event E0 on the clock's worldline, assign -a(E0) = 0, and
    measure or calculate the elapsed proper time from that event.

    You can choose E0 to be the moment the clock is activated, synchronized,
    or passes a specified reference event.

    Different choices of origin change the numerical value of -a by an
    additive constant. They do not change elapsed proper time between two
    events.

    Exactly as changing the origin of GPS time wouldn't change the duration of
    a GPS second.

    So yes, Maciej, physicists know perfectly well how to initialize a time coordinate.

    GPS engineers have been doing the practical equivalent for decades.

    Your inability to distinguish a conventional origin from a physically measurable interval is not a problem with relativity.

    Maciej: 0
    Relativity: 5
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sat Nov 14 19:04:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 6:48 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 14/11/2026 |a 18:46, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/14/2026 6:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    How do I initialize proper time?

    By choosing an origin, -a = 0

    Sure. How?
    Oh, I know. You have no idea.
    That's how precisely defined
    is your precisely defined idiocy.


    How? Here's a concrete example: GPS.

    Great! So, when time indicated on GPS
    clock is 2026-11-14 17:00:00.000000000
    - your elapsed proper time is .....






    Choose an event E0 on the clock's worldline

    H-O-W?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 07:11:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/14/2026 7:04 PM, Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:
    On 11/14/2026 6:48 PM, Python wrote:


    Choose an event E0 on the clock's worldline

    H-O-W?

    See, poor piece of shit - if you ever applied
    it in any real calculations, you would know
    how it was iniatialized.

    You can't say - because the only purpose of
    your delusion is: spinning your gedanken tales
    and brainwash the next generations of The
    Shit's victims.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 11:24:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 07:11, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/14/2026 7:04 PM, Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:
    On 11/14/2026 6:48 PM, Python wrote:


    Choose an event E0 on the clock's worldline

    H-O-W?

    See, poor piece of shit - if you ever applied
    it in any real calculations, you would know
    how it was iniatialized.

    You can't say - because the only purpose of
    your delusion is: spinning your gedanken tales
    and brainwash the next generations of The
    Shit's victims.

    Sorry for keeping you waiting last night. I was at a birthday party.

    Judging by your repeated messages, you seem rather disappointed to have
    missed your usual evening spanking. :-)


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 11:32:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 14/11/2026 |a 19:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/14/2026 6:48 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 14/11/2026 |a 18:46, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/14/2026 6:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    How do I initialize proper time?

    By choosing an origin, -a = 0

    Sure. How?
    Oh, I know. You have no idea.
    That's how precisely defined
    is your precisely defined idiocy.


    How? Here's a concrete example: GPS.

    Great! So, when time indicated on GPS
    clock is 2026-11-14 17:00:00.000000000
    - your elapsed proper time is .....






    Choose an event E0 on the clock's worldline

    H-O-W?

    Maciej,

    Your increasingly desperate "H-O-W?" is rather revealing for someone who claims to understand engineering better than relativists.

    Let's see.

    First, assume that we have adjusted the satellite oscillators so that
    their clock rates agree with GPS coordinate time, within the required accuracy.

    This already involves relativistic corrections. Without them, GPS clocks
    would accumulate substantial timing errors, and the navigation system
    would rapidly lose accuracy.

    Now we want to establish a common time origin.

    You really cannot figure out how to do that?

    For clocks at rest relative to one another in an inertial reference frame,
    we can use Einstein's synchronization procedure, described back in 1905.

    I even have a little interactive demonstration of it:

    https://noedge.net/e

    For clocks in relative motion, such as a ground station and a GPS
    satellite, we account for the changing distance during signal propagation.

    Here is a (not that much) simplified procedure.

    Let a ground station transmit a timestamped radio signal at coordinate
    time t1.

    The satellite receives it at t2.

    In an Earth-centered inertial frame, neglecting propagation-medium effects
    for the moment, the signal satisfies:

    c(t2 - t1) = |rS(t2) - rG(t1)|

    where rS and rG are the satellite and ground-station positions.

    Notice that the positions are evaluated at DIFFERENT times. The satellite moves while the signal propagates.

    Knowing the trajectories, we solve this equation for the propagation
    delay.

    We can then compare the satellite clock reading at reception with the coordinate time t2 and determine its offset.

    Using a return signal allows a two-way time-transfer procedure, with the appropriate corrections for motion, propagation asymmetry and instrumental delays.

    For GPS, we also account for Earth rotation, relativistic effects, and
    other necessary corrections.

    This is engineering, Maciej. Not magic.

    And if we want to initialize the satellite's proper-time parameter, we
    simply choose a physical event E0 on its worldline, for example a
    specified synchronization event, and assign:

    -a(E0) = 0

    From that event onward, elapsed proper time is calculated along the satellite's worldline.

    The clock's displayed GPS time and its accumulated proper time are
    distinct quantities. Synchronizing the former does not eliminate the relativistic differences affecting the latter.

    So when you ask:

    "When the GPS clock displays 2026-11-14 17:00:00, what is its elapsed
    proper time?"

    the answer still depends on which initial event you have chosen and on the satellite's trajectory.

    A timestamp alone cannot supply that missing information.

    You have spent two days screaming "H-O-W?" about a problem that engineers routinely solve using clock synchronization, signal propagation models and relativistic corrections.

    And you still seem unable to distinguish setting a clock's display from defining the origin of its proper time.

    Perhaps you should spend a little less time insulting physicists and a
    little more time studying how GPS actually works.

    Your belated spanking is now complete.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 12:03:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 12:32, Python a |-crit :
    Le 14/11/2026 |a 19:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/14/2026 6:48 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 14/11/2026 |a 18:46, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/14/2026 6:26 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    How do I initialize proper time?

    By choosing an origin, -a = 0

    Sure. How?
    Oh, I know. You have no idea.
    That's how precisely defined
    is your precisely defined idiocy.


    How? Here's a concrete example: GPS.

    Great! So, when time indicated on GPS
    clock is 2026-11-14 17:00:00.000000000
    - your elapsed proper time is .....






    Choose an event E0 on the clock's worldline

    H-O-W?

    Maciej,

    Your increasingly desperate "H-O-W?" is rather revealing for someone who claims
    to understand engineering better than relativists.

    Let's see.

    First, assume that we have adjusted the satellite oscillators so that their clock rates agree with GPS coordinate time, within the required accuracy.

    This already involves relativistic corrections. Without them, GPS clocks would
    accumulate substantial timing errors, and the navigation system would rapidly lose
    accuracy.

    Now we want to establish a common time origin.

    You really cannot figure out how to do that?

    For clocks at rest relative to one another in an inertial reference frame, we
    can use Einstein's synchronization procedure, described back in 1905.

    I even have a little interactive demonstration of it:

    https://noedge.net/e

    For clocks in relative motion, such as a ground station and a GPS satellite, we
    account for the changing distance during signal propagation.

    Here is a (not that much) simplified procedure.

    Let a ground station transmit a timestamped radio signal at coordinate time t1.

    The satellite receives it at t2.

    In an Earth-centered inertial frame, neglecting propagation-medium effects for
    the moment, the signal satisfies:

    c(t2 - t1) = |rS(t2) - rG(t1)|

    where rS and rG are the satellite and ground-station positions.

    Notice that the positions are evaluated at DIFFERENT times. The satellite moves
    while the signal propagates.

    Knowing the trajectories, we solve this equation for the propagation delay.

    We can then compare the satellite clock reading at reception with the coordinate
    time t2 and determine its offset.

    Using a return signal allows a two-way time-transfer procedure, with the appropriate corrections for motion, propagation asymmetry and instrumental delays.

    For GPS, we also account for Earth rotation, relativistic effects, and other necessary corrections.

    This is engineering, Maciej. Not magic.

    And if we want to initialize the satellite's proper-time parameter, we simply
    choose a physical event E0 on its worldline, for example a specified synchronization event, and assign:

    -a(E0) = 0

    From that event onward, elapsed proper time is calculated along the satellite's
    worldline.

    The clock's displayed GPS time and its accumulated proper time are distinct quantities. Synchronizing the former does not eliminate the relativistic differences affecting the latter.

    So when you ask:

    "When the GPS clock displays 2026-11-14 17:00:00, what is its elapsed proper time?"

    the answer still depends on which initial event you have chosen and on the satellite's trajectory.

    A timestamp alone cannot supply that missing information.

    You have spent two days screaming "H-O-W?" about a problem that engineers routinely solve using clock synchronization, signal propagation models and relativistic corrections.

    And you still seem unable to distinguish setting a clock's display from defining
    the origin of its proper time.

    Perhaps you should spend a little less time insulting physicists and a little
    more time studying how GPS actually works.

    Your belated spanking is now complete.

    See this application : https://noedge.net/e/gps-en.html

    GPS doesn't even need a round-trip signal exchange during normal
    operation.

    The two-way exchange illustrated in my simulator is a useful way to demonstrate clock synchronization and signal propagation. But ordinary GPS positioning works differently, and rather more elegantly.

    GPS satellites continuously broadcast radio signals containing precise
    timing information and navigation data.

    A GPS receiver simply listens. It does not need to transmit anything back
    to the satellites.

    Here's how it works.

    1. Each satellite broadcasts a signal containing a ranging code and
    navigation information, including orbital parameters and clock
    corrections.

    2. The receiver determines the signal's transmission time and measures its arrival relative to its own clock.

    3. Using the satellite's position at transmission and the signal
    propagation time, it obtains a pseudorange.

    4. With signals from at least four satellites, the receiver can normally
    solve for its three spatial coordinates and its own clock offset relative
    to GPS time.

    That fourth unknown is particularly important: the receiver's clock does
    not even have to be synchronized with GPS time beforehand. Its offset is estimated as part of the navigation solution.

    The calculation explicitly accounts for satellite motion, Earth rotation, clock offsets, and relativistic corrections.

    No magical clocks. No mystical time. Just electromagnetic signals, oscillators, orbital mechanics, and mathematics.


    HOW OFTEN DOES GPS DO THIS?

    The satellites transmit continuously, but we should distinguish the radio carrier, the ranging code, the navigation message, and the updates
    performed by the ground control segment.

    For the traditional civilian GPS L1 C/A signal:

    - L1 radio carrier: 1575.42 MHz.

    - C/A ranging code: 1.023 million chips per second.

    - Complete C/A code repetition: every 1 millisecond.

    - Navigation data: 50 bits per second.

    - Navigation subframe: every 6 seconds.

    - Navigation frame: every 30 seconds.

    - Complete legacy navigation message cycle: 12.5 minutes.

    - New orbital and clock data uploaded by ground control: typically every
    few hours, depending on operations.

    These are specifications of the legacy L1 C/A service. Modern GPS signals
    use additional formats and rates.

    The receiver can continuously track the signals and update its navigation solution, often several times per second. The positioning update rate
    depends on the receiver; it is not dictated by the 30-second navigation-message frame.

    And the most revealing detail is that the satellite navigation message explicitly includes CLOCK-CORRECTION COEFFICIENTS.

    The receiver uses a model of the form:

    delta_t_sat = a0 + a1*(t - t0)
    + a2*(t - t0)^2
    + delta_t_rel

    where delta_t_rel includes the periodic relativistic correction associated with orbital eccentricity.

    The ordinary pseudorange model can be written schematically as:

    P = rho + c*(delta_t_receiver - delta_t_sat)
    + ionospheric_delay
    + tropospheric_delay
    + other_corrections_and_errors

    Here, rho is the geometric propagation distance, with the appropriate treatment of satellite motion and signal propagation.

    So the real GPS system does something even more sophisticated than the round-trip demonstration: it reconstructs position and time from one-way signals transmitted by moving satellites, while explicitly correcting
    their clock behaviour.

    Calling proper time a "delusion" doesn't make any of these calculations disappear.


    TECHNICAL REFERENCES

    All of these are publicly available:

    ESA Navipedia - GPS Navigation Message https://gssc.esa.int/navipedia/index.php/GPS_Navigation_Message

    ESA Navipedia - GNSS Basic Observables https://gssc.esa.int/navipedia/index.php/GNSS_Basic_Observables

    ESA Navipedia - Clock Modelling https://gssc.esa.int/navipedia/index.php/Clock_Modelling

    ESA Navipedia - Relativistic Clock Correction https://gssc.esa.int/navipedia/index.php/Relativistic_Clock_Correction

    ESA Navipedia - GNSS Measurements Modelling https://gssc.esa.int/navipedia/index.php/GNSS_Measurements_Modelling

    GPS.gov - Official GPS overview
    https://www.gps.gov/gps


    The irony, Maciej, is that real GPS engineers have already answered your "H-O-W?" in extraordinary detail.

    They don't need perfectly accurate clocks, absolute time, or mystical assumptions.

    They need well-defined reference frames, measurable oscillator
    frequencies, precise signal propagation models, and relativistic
    corrections.

    And they have been successfully using all of these for decades.

    All you have to do is read their documentation.

    Of course, that might be considerably more demanding than typing "H-O-W?"
    in capital letters.

    But surely, for someone who claims to understand engineering better than
    the entire scientific community, it shouldn't be an insurmountable
    challenge. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 13:24:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 12:32 PM, Python wrote:

    And if we want to initialize the satellite's proper-time parameter, we simply choose a physical event

    H-O-W?

    See, poor piece of shit: if you ever applied your
    idiocy in any real calculations, you would
    know how it was initialized. You could point me
    the events triggering it.

    You don't know. You can't. Because the only purpose
    of your delusion is: spinning your gedanken tales
    and brainwashing the next generations of The
    Shit's victims.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 12:27:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 12:32 PM, Python wrote:

    And if we want to initialize the satellite's proper-time parameter, we
    simply choose a physical event

    H-O-W?

    See, poor piece of shit: if you ever applied your
    idiocy in any real calculations, you would
    know how it was initialized. You could point me
    the events triggering it.

    You don't know. You can't. Because the only purpose
    of your delusion is: spinning your gedanken tales
    and brainwashing the next generations of The
    Shit's victims.

    bla bla bla.

    First, thank you.

    Your obsessive repetition of "H-O-W?" has given me an excellent
    opportunity to develop an interactive simulation illustrating how GPS
    actually works.

    It even helped me deepen my own understanding of some of its technical details. There's always something to learn when you take the trouble to
    study real physics and engineering.

    Here's the result:

    [LINK TO THE APPLICATION]

    A 3D GPS constellation, 24 satellites in six orbital planes, a ground receiver, one-way radio transmissions, pseudorange calculations, satellite clock corrections, relativistic effects, and the relevant equations.

    All based on actual GPS principles, with some pedagogical simplifications.

    And here's the particularly amusing part: ordinary GPS doesn't even
    require a round-trip exchange with the receiver. The satellites broadcast their signals, and the receiver determines its position AND its clock
    offset from them.

    The relevant events are perfectly identifiable: signal emission at the satellite and signal reception at the receiver.

    No mystery. No magic. No "propercorrectperfectlygood" clocks.

    Unfortunately, while your questions helped improve MY understanding, they don't seem to have improved YOURS in the slightest.

    But I suppose there's a limit to what even a working GPS constellation can
    do for someone so determined to remain lost.

    Thanks again, Maciej.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 12:28:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 12:32 PM, Python wrote:

    And if we want to initialize the satellite's proper-time parameter, we
    simply choose a physical event

    H-O-W?

    See, poor piece of shit: if you ever applied your
    idiocy in any real calculations, you would
    know how it was initialized. You could point me
    the events triggering it.

    You don't know. You can't. Because the only purpose
    of your delusion is: spinning your gedanken tales
    and brainwashing the next generations of The
    Shit's victims.

    bla bla bla.

    First, thank you.

    Your obsessive repetition of "H-O-W?" has given me an excellent
    opportunity to develop an interactive simulation illustrating how GPS
    actually works.

    It even helped me deepen my own understanding of some of its technical details. There's always something to learn when you take the trouble to
    study real physics and engineering.

    Here's the result:

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    A 3D GPS constellation, 24 satellites in six orbital planes, a ground receiver, one-way radio transmissions, pseudorange calculations, satellite clock corrections, relativistic effects, and the relevant equations.

    All based on actual GPS principles, with some pedagogical simplifications.

    And here's the particularly amusing part: ordinary GPS doesn't even
    require a round-trip exchange with the receiver. The satellites broadcast their signals, and the receiver determines its position AND its clock
    offset from them.

    The relevant events are perfectly identifiable: signal emission at the satellite and signal reception at the receiver.

    No mystery. No magic. No "propercorrectperfectlygood" clocks.

    Unfortunately, while your questions helped improve MY understanding, they don't seem to have improved YOURS in the slightest.

    But I suppose there's a limit to what even a working GPS constellation can
    do for someone so determined to remain lost.

    Thanks again, Maciej.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 13:33:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 1:27 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:24, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 12:32 PM, Python wrote:

    And if we want to initialize the satellite's proper-time parameter,
    we simply choose a physical event

    H-O-W?

    See, poor piece of shit: if you ever applied your
    idiocy in any real calculations, you would
    know how it was initialized. You could point me
    the events triggering it.

    You don't know. You can't. Because the only purpose
    of your delusion is: spinning your gedanken tales
    and brainwashing the next generations of The
    Shit's-a victims.

    bla bla bla.

    First, thank you.

    Your obsessive repetition of "H-O-W?" has given me an excellent
    opportunity to develop an interactive simulation illustrating how GPS actually works.

    It even helped me deepen my own understanding of some of its technical details. There's always something to learn when you take the trouble to study real physics and engineering.

    Here's the result:

    [LINK TO THE APPLICATION]

    A 3D GPS constellation, 24 satellites in six orbital planes, a ground receiver, one-way radio transmissions, pseudorange calculations,
    satellite clock corrections, relativistic effects, and the relevant equations.

    All based on actual GPS principles, with some pedagogical simplifications.

    And here's the particularly amusing part: ordinary GPS doesn't even
    require a round-trip exchange with the receiver. The satellites
    broadcast their signals, and the receiver determines its position AND
    its clock offset from them.

    The relevant events are perfectly identifiable: signal emission at the satellite and signal reception at the receiver.

    No mystery. No magic. No "propercorrectperfectlygood" clocks.

    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The Shit's victims.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 12:42:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The Shit's victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose development
    involved precisely the kind of thought experiments ("Gedankenexperimente")
    you keep ridiculing.

    And there's nothing unusual about that. Thought experiments are a
    perfectly ordinary tool in science and engineering.

    A few examples:

    1. Galileo's falling bodies.

    His famous thought experiment involving falling objects helped expose contradictions in Aristotelian mechanics and contributed to the
    development of modern dynamics.

    The resulting principles are fundamental to virtually all mechanical engineering.

    2. Einstein's synchronization of clocks.

    Two clocks at different locations, light signals exchanged between
    them, and a precise operational definition of simultaneity.

    This is directly relevant to the concepts underlying relativistic time transfer and satellite navigation.

    3. Einstein's accelerating elevator.

    An observer inside a closed elevator cannot distinguish a uniform gravitational field from an equivalent acceleration by purely local experiments.

    This thought experiment helped develop the equivalence principle, one
    of the foundations of General Relativity.

    Gravitational frequency shifts, essential to GPS clock modelling,
    follow from the corresponding relativistic framework.

    4. Maxwell's demon.

    A hypothetical creature sorting molecules led to profound insights into thermodynamics, entropy, and information.

    Those concepts are fundamental to modern statistical physics and information theory.

    5. Turing's imaginary machine.

    An idealized machine with an unlimited tape, a finite set of states,
    and simple rules.

    No actual computer has an infinite tape.

    Yet this mathematical abstraction became foundational to theoretical computer science and our understanding of computation.

    6. Ideal electrical circuits.

    Perfect conductors, ideal voltage sources, zero-resistance connections,
    and perfectly linear components.

    None exists exactly in nature.

    Yet engineers routinely use these idealizations to design REAL
    electronic devices, adding corrections when necessary.

    Do you see the common principle?

    A theoretical idealization does not have to exist literally in nature to
    be useful.

    It must be mathematically coherent, have a well-defined relationship to physical observations, and produce predictions that can be tested.

    That's exactly how ideal clocks and proper time are used in relativity.

    Nobody needs to manufacture a metaphysically perfect clock.

    Real oscillators are compared with theoretical models, calibrated,
    corrected, and experimentally tested.

    And GPS is an excellent example of the success of that approach.

    You keep treating "Gedankenexperiment" as though it were a synonym for "imaginary nonsense".

    It isn't.

    Thought experiments have helped develop some of the most successful
    theories in the history of science.

    Of course, a thought experiment cannot replace experimental verification.

    But GPS provides that verification every day.

    Your objection amounts to dismissing engineering models because their idealized components are not literally perfect.

    By that standard, you would have to throw away most of classical mechanics
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Walfrido Balawensky@aaf@wrdoyosw.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 12:46:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    First, assume that we have adjusted the satellite oscillators so that
    their clock rates agree with GPS coordinate time, within the required accuracy.

    you cant, you cant adjust the oscillator of an atomic clock, that's the
    whole idea in even having an atomic clock, idiot
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 12:47:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:46, Walfrido Balawensky a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    First, assume that we have adjusted the satellite oscillators so that
    their clock rates agree with GPS coordinate time, within the required
    accuracy.

    you cant, you cant adjust the oscillator of an atomic clock, that's the whole idea in even having an atomic clock, idiot

    Walfrido,

    Oh, the nym-shifting troll is back. :-)

    And apparently you haven't even understood what Maciej eventually managed
    to grasp.

    Of course the atomic transition frequency is not arbitrarily adjustable. That's precisely why it makes such a useful frequency reference.

    But the OUTPUT frequency of an atomic clock can be adjusted, using
    frequency synthesizers and control electronics.

    And guess what? GPS satellite clocks are deliberately configured with a relativistic frequency offset before launch.

    Their nominal frequency is shifted by approximately:

    -4.4647 |u 10^-10

    to compensate for the average combined gravitational and kinematic relativistic effects in orbit.

    For the GPS fundamental frequency of 10.23 MHz, this corresponds to approximately:

    10.22999999543 MHz

    instead of exactly 10.23 MHz.

    This is not some speculative Gedankenexperiment. It's actual GPS
    engineering.

    So yes, atomic clocks can have their output frequencies adjusted without changing the atomic transition itself.

    You have confused the frequency reference with the clock's generated
    output.

    A rather elementary mistake for someone so eager to call others idiots.

    Welcome back. You've managed to arrive even later than Maciej at a point
    he has already conceded. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Bernardo Barabanov@oao@babrna.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 12:52:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    Of course the atomic transition frequency is not arbitrarily adjustable. That's precisely why it makes such a useful frequency reference.

    But the OUTPUT frequency of an atomic clock can be adjusted, using
    frequency synthesizers and control electronics.

    not true again, you adjust the second, not the frequency; just think
    before you post
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 12:53:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:52, Bernardo Barabanov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Of course the atomic transition frequency is not arbitrarily adjustable.
    That's precisely why it makes such a useful frequency reference.

    But the OUTPUT frequency of an atomic clock can be adjusted, using
    frequency synthesizers and control electronics.

    not true again, you adjust the second, not the frequency; just think
    before you post

    Bernardov,

    "You adjust the second, not the frequency."

    Really?

    The SI second is defined by fixing the frequency of the unperturbed caesium-133 hyperfine transition at exactly 9,192,631,770 Hz.

    We do not "adjust the second" every time we calibrate a clock.

    What we can adjust is the frequency of the clock's output signal relative
    to that reference.

    Remember the elementary relationship?

    T = 1/f

    Change the output frequency, and you change the period between successive ticks.

    That's how frequency synthesis and clock steering work.

    And GPS provides a particularly concrete example:

    Nominal GPS fundamental frequency:
    10.23000000000 MHz

    Pre-offset frequency:
    10.22999999543 MHz

    The difference is approximately 0.00457 Hz, corresponding to a fractional frequency offset of about -4.4647 |u 10^-10.

    Nobody has redefined the SI second.

    Nobody has changed the caesium transition frequency.

    They have adjusted the generated frequency.

    You are confusing the definition of a unit with the physical realization
    of a clock signal.

    Perhaps you should take your own advice and think before posting. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 13:53:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The Shit's victims.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 12:58:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The Shit's victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    1. Proper time is the time accumulated along a particular clock's
    worldline.

    2. Coordinate time is the time coordinate assigned to events in a chosen reference system.

    3. Synchronization is a procedure for establishing a specified
    relationship between clock readings and a chosen time scale.

    These are not interchangeable notions.

    Your alleged postulate,

    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating t'=t) clocks"

    does not even specify which events, which reference frames, or which synchronization convention you are talking about.

    And it certainly does not eliminate proper time.

    In GPS, satellite clocks are adjusted and corrected so that their
    broadcast time information can be related to a common coordinate time
    scale.

    WHY are these adjustments necessary?

    Because the proper time accumulated by a satellite clock does not
    generally advance at the same rate as the chosen GPS coordinate time.

    For a GPS satellite in a nominal orbit, the combined gravitational and kinematic relativistic effect amounts to approximately +38 microseconds
    per day relative to the corresponding coordinate-time rate.

    That is why a compensating frequency offset is introduced.

    If you simply assumed that every clock's proper time automatically agreed
    with GPS coordinate time, there would be no reason for that correction.

    So your argument is almost comically backwards.

    The GPS synchronization procedures do not replace the relativistic
    distinction between proper time and coordinate time.

    They depend on it.

    And your repeated insults do nothing to change the equations, the
    engineering, or the measurements.

    You have been shown the relevant physical events, the actual satellite-to-receiver transmissions, and an interactive model illustrating
    the calculations.

    At this point, repeating "propercorrectperfectlygood" is not an argument.

    It's just a way of announcing that you have nothing left to say.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 14:02:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 1:53 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:52, Bernardo Barabanov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Of course the atomic transition frequency is not arbitrarily adjustable. >>> That's precisely why it makes such a useful frequency reference.

    But the OUTPUT frequency of an atomic clock can be adjusted, using
    frequency synthesizers and control electronics.

    not true again, you adjust the second, not the frequency; just think
    before you post

    Bernardov,

    "You adjust the second, not the frequency."

    Really?

    The SI second is defined by fixing the frequency of the unperturbed


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 13:03:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:53 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:52, Bernardo Barabanov a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    Of course the atomic transition frequency is not arbitrarily adjustable. >>>> That's precisely why it makes such a useful frequency reference.

    But the OUTPUT frequency of an atomic clock can be adjusted, using
    frequency synthesizers and control electronics.

    not true again, you adjust the second, not the frequency; just think
    before you post

    Bernardov,

    "You adjust the second, not the frequency."

    Really?

    The SI second is defined by fixing the frequency of the unperturbed


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.

    The GPS second is the SI second. GPS Time is a continuous coordinate time scale whose unit is the SI second.

    What differs is the RATE at which a particular physical clock accumulates proper time relative to GPS coordinate time.

    That's precisely why relativistic frequency corrections are needed.

    You are confusing:

    - the definition of the second,
    - the realization of a time scale,
    - the reading of a physical clock,
    - and the rate of proper time relative to coordinate time.

    Again.

    GPS Time is not UTC: it does not incorporate leap seconds. But that does
    not mean it uses a different definition of the second.

    A different time scale is not necessarily a different time unit.

    Your claim that I admitted otherwise is simply false.

    Quote the exact passage where I supposedly did so.

    And please try to distinguish a unit of measurement from a clock reading before announcing another imaginary victory. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 14:04:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The Shit's victims.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 13:06:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The Shit's victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship between proper time and coordinate time is, to first order:

    d-a/dt ree 1 + +a/c-# - v-#/(2c-#)

    where +a is the Newtonian gravitational potential, v is the clock's
    coordinate velocity, and t is the coordinate time of the chosen reference system.

    This is not a religious incantation.

    It is a quantitative relationship used to model the rates of real clocks, including those aboard GPS satellites.

    It predicts the familiar net relativistic frequency offset of
    approximately +4.46 |u 10^-10 for a nominal GPS satellite relative to the
    GPS reference rate.

    And that prediction is incorporated into actual GPS engineering.

    Now, a simple question:

    Do you accept or reject that relationship?

    If you reject it, identify the mathematical or experimental error.

    If you accept it, you have accepted that the rate of a clock's proper time
    can differ from the rate of coordinate time.

    Either way, repeating "propercorrectperfectlygood" for the hundredth time won't make the equation disappear.

    You asked HOW.

    I gave you the physical events, the operational procedures, the
    mathematical model, and even a working simulation.

    You have answered with a nursery rhyme.

    Perhaps it's time to try physics instead.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Harlie Baidukoff@aeoadu@iuai.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 13:15:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:

    not true again, you adjust the second, not the frequency; just think
    before you post

    Bernardov,

    "You adjust the second, not the frequency."

    Really?

    The SI second is defined by fixing the frequency of the unperturbed caesium-133 hyperfine transition at exactly 9,192,631,770 Hz.

    We do not "adjust the second" every time we calibrate a clock.

    just another proof your ass never been inside a laboratory; you just count more from the same source, idiot, solving both the offset and the passage

    definitions my ass, you dont know what you are talking about
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 14:19:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose development >>>>
    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The Shit's victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of local
    proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 13:23:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose development >>>>>
    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The Shit's victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the difference
    between a unit of time and the rate at which a physical clock accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    The SI second is a UNIT OF MEASUREMENT, defined by fixing the frequency of
    the unperturbed caesium-133 hyperfine transition at exactly 9,192,631,770
    Hz.

    GPS coordinate time uses that same unit.

    But the proper time accumulated along a satellite's worldline does not generally advance at the same rate as GPS coordinate time.

    Mathematically:

    d-a/dt rea 1

    where -a is the satellite clock's proper time and t is GPS coordinate
    time.

    This does NOT mean that the second has been redefined.

    It means that two different time quantities, both expressed in SI seconds,
    can accumulate at different rates.

    Just as two objects can travel different distances in one second without requiring two different definitions of the metre.

    For a nominal GPS satellite, the combined gravitational and kinematic relativistic effects produce a fractional rate difference of
    approximately:

    +4.4647 |u 10^-10

    or about 38.6 microseconds per day.

    This is why GPS satellite oscillators are frequency-offset to compensate
    for that difference.

    And I've now added a particularly instructive feature to the interactive
    GPS simulation:

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation-rate-compensation.html

    Find the checkbox:

    [x] Relativity rate compensation

    Uncheck it.

    Then increase the elapsed time.

    Watch the satellite clock drift accumulate, and observe what happens to
    the "Position solution error".

    The simulation also illustrates an important subtlety: a common clock
    error can largely be absorbed into the receiver's estimated clock bias, whereas differences between satellite clock errors can distort the
    position solution.

    The model is pedagogical, with synthetic satellite-specific drift
    differences, but the underlying relativistic rate effect is real and quantitatively established.

    So, to summarize:

    Same SI second.
    Different rates of proper and coordinate time.
    Relativistic corrections required.

    No contradiction. No redefinition of the second. No lies.

    You simply mistook a statement about the rate of a clock for a statement
    about the definition of a unit.

    And instead of checking the elementary distinction, you announced another imaginary victory.

    Perhaps this time you could try the simulation before repeating your usual incantations. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 13:25:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:15, Harlie Baidukoff a |-crit :
    Python wrote:

    not true again, you adjust the second, not the frequency; just think
    before you post

    Bernardov,

    "You adjust the second, not the frequency."

    Really?

    The SI second is defined by fixing the frequency of the unperturbed
    caesium-133 hyperfine transition at exactly 9,192,631,770 Hz.

    We do not "adjust the second" every time we calibrate a clock.

    just another proof your ass never been inside a laboratory; you just count more from the same source, idiot, solving both the offset and the passage

    definitions my ass, you dont know what you are talking about

    Harlie,

    Yet another nym, and still the same elementary confusion.

    You write:

    "you just count more from the same source, idiot,
    solving both the offset and the passage"

    No.

    A clock can have a time offset, a frequency offset, or both.

    These are different quantities.

    Consider the simplest clock model:

    C(t) = a + (1 + +|)t

    where:

    a = initial time offset
    +| = fractional frequency error
    t = reference time

    Correcting a changes the clock's reading without changing its rate.

    Correcting +| changes its rate without necessarily changing its current reading.

    In metrology, these correspond to phase/time correction and frequency correction.

    Both are routinely performed in real timing systems.

    And yes, frequency corrections can be implemented electronically, for
    example by adjusting a controllable oscillator or a frequency synthesizer.

    GPS provides an especially clear example.

    The nominal GPS satellite oscillator frequency is pre-offset by
    approximately:

    -4.4647 |u 10^-10

    to compensate for the average relativistic rate difference in orbit.

    The resulting nominal fundamental frequency before launch is
    approximately:

    10.22999999543 MHz

    rather than 10.23000000000 MHz.

    That is a FREQUENCY adjustment, not a redefinition of the second.

    Furthermore, GPS navigation data include satellite clock correction coefficients conventionally denoted:

    af0 = clock bias
    af1 = clock drift
    af2 = clock drift rate

    The distinction between time offset and frequency offset is therefore
    explicit in the actual GPS clock model.

    You can find it in the GPS Interface Specification, IS-GPS-200.

    https://www.gps.gov/technical/icwg/

    So instead of telling us what you imagine happens in a laboratory, perhaps
    you could explain why GPS engineers distinguish clock bias from clock
    drift.

    Or why they deliberately introduce a fractional frequency offset into satellite clock hardware.

    You seem to think that counting ticks, adjusting a clock's reading, and controlling its output frequency are the same operation.

    They aren't.

    And changing your posting name doesn't change the physics. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Stan Baiburski@nribbu@babbat.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 15 13:31:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:


    A clock can have a time offset, a frequency offset, or both.

    These are different quantities.

    Consider the simplest clock model:

    stop the crap, you just prove you dont undrestand both
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 14:35:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose
    development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of
    local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the difference
    between a unit of time and the rate at which a physical clock
    accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The Shit's victims.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 13:36:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose
    development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of
    local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the difference
    between a unit of time and the rate at which a physical clock
    accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The Shit's victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time and the
    rate of a physical clock.

    Still no answer to the equations, the GPS engineering, or the experimental evidence.

    And now you're confusing the number of atomic oscillations accumulated
    along different worldlines with the definition of the SI second.

    Repeating a misunderstanding doesn't turn it into an argument.

    Wake me up when you have something new.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 14:42:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose
    development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of
    local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the difference
    between a unit of time and the rate at which a physical clock
    accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time and
    the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The Shit's victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 13:44:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning
    your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose >>>>>>>>>> development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship >>>>>
    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of
    local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the difference
    between a unit of time and the rate at which a physical clock
    accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time and
    the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The Shit's victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 15:30:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only
    exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html

    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose >>>>>>>>>>> development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship >>>>>>
    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of >>>>>> local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the difference >>>>> between a unit of time and the rate at which a physical clock
    accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time and
    the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 19:17:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 11.11.2026 03:16, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the
    nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the
    GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.

    This is a strange statement.

    No.

    All the frequencies in a GPS SV are synthesised from the same
    frequency standard with the nominal frequency 10.23 MHz.

    In the GPS Interface Specification Document you will find: https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Note the date.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 19:54:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 19:17, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 11.11.2026 03:16, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the >>>> nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the
    GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.

    This is a strange statement.

    No.

    All the frequencies in a GPS SV are synthesised from the same
    frequency standard with the nominal frequency 10.23 MHz.

    In the GPS Interface Specification Document you will find:
    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Note the date.

    Thomas, Paul,

    This is an interesting technical distinction, and I think it is worth
    being precise about it.

    I have checked IS-GPS-200N, section 3.3.1.1, page 13.

    The specification explicitly states that the L1 and L2 carrier frequencies
    are coherently derived from a common frequency source aboard the
    satellite.

    It also specifies that both the carrier frequencies and the satellite
    clock rates are offset to compensate for relativistic effects.

    The fractional offset is:

    +of/f = -4.4647 |u 10^-10

    corresponding to:

    10.2299999954326 MHz

    for the nominal 10.23 MHz reference.

    So the specification does not describe merely an adjustment of the RF
    signal transmitted by the antenna.

    There are, however, three things worth distinguishing:

    1. The atomic transition used as the frequency reference.

    2. The frequency generated and distributed by the satellite's clock and frequency-generation electronics.

    3. The RF carrier frequencies and ranging-code rates derived from that reference.

    The atomic transition itself is not arbitrarily modified to implement the relativistic compensation.

    But that does not mean that the generated clock signals cannot be frequency-offset.

    Paul's point about coherent synthesis from a common frequency source is therefore well supported by the specification.

    Thomas, are you referring specifically to the internal atomic resonance, rather than to the output of the complete clock/frequency-generation subsystem?

    If so, I think we may largely agree on the physics and differ mainly on terminology.

    If not, I would be interested in the technical documentation supporting
    your distinction, particularly for the more recent GPS satellite
    generations.

    Reference:
    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Section 3.3.1.1, page 13.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 20:12:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 15:30, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only >>>>>>>>>>>>> exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like
    yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html >>>>>>>>>>>>
    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose >>>>>>>>>>>> development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again.

    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship >>>>>>>
    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second of >>>>>>> local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the difference >>>>>> between a unit of time and the rate at which a physical clock
    accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time and >>>> the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.


    Apparently, even a disgusting, lying, demented wannabe engineer like you
    can keep lying nonstop.

    You have now repeated the same false claim about the GPS second so many
    times that I've lost count.

    But please, don't stop!

    Every new reply provides fresh material for the simulator:

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    You're not just its inspiration anymore.

    You're actively feeding it. :-)

    At this rate, the hardest part of maintaining the application will be
    finding something NEW for you to repeat.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 21:21:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 9:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 15:30, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only >>>>>>>>>>>>>> exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like >>>>>>>>>>>>>> yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html >>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose >>>>>>>>>>>>> development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again. >>>>>>>>>>
    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship >>>>>>>>
    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second >>>>>>>> of local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the
    difference between a unit of time and the rate at which a
    physical clock accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time
    and the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.


    Apparently, even a disgusting, lying, demented wannabe engineer like you
    can keep lying nonstop.

    You have now repeated the same false claim about the GPS second so many times that I've lost count.

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.


    But please, don't stop!

    Every new reply provides fresh material for the simulator:

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    You're not just its inspiration anymore.

    You're actively feeding it. :-)

    At this rate, the hardest part of maintaining the application will be finding something NEW for you to repeat.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 20:24:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:21, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 15:30, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>> ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html >>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose >>>>>>>>>>>>>> development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again. >>>>>>>>>>>
    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the relationship >>>>>>>>>
    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second >>>>>>>>> of local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the
    difference between a unit of time and the rate at which a
    physical clock accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time >>>>>> and the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.


    Apparently, even a disgusting, lying, demented wannabe engineer like you
    can keep lying nonstop.

    You have now repeated the same false claim about the GPS second so many
    times that I've lost count.

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    I didn't. You are a BUNCH of lying shit, Maciej.

    But please, don't stop!

    Every new reply provides fresh material for the simulator:

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    You're not just its inspiration anymore.

    You're actively feeding it. :-)

    At this rate, the hardest part of maintaining the application will be
    finding something NEW for you to repeat.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 21:25:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 8:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 19:17, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 11.11.2026 03:16, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    -a-a ^^^^^^^^^^^^^-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the >>>>> nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the >>>> GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.

    This is a strange statement.

    No.

    All the frequencies in a GPS SV are synthesised from the same
    frequency standard with the nominal frequency 10.23 MHz.

    In the GPS Interface Specification Document you will find:
    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Note the date.

    Thomas, Paul,

    This is an interesting technical distinction, and I think it is worth
    being precise about it.

    I have checked IS-GPS-200N, section 3.3.1.1, page 13.

    The specification explicitly states that the L1 and L2 carrier
    frequencies are coherently derived from a common frequency source aboard
    the satellite.

    It also specifies that both the carrier frequencies and the satellite
    clock rates are offset to compensate for relativistic effects.

    The fractional offset is:

    -a-a +of/f = -4.4647 |u 10^-10

    corresponding to:

    -a-a 10.2299999954326 MHz

    Of course, the specification states clearly -
    the number is just what "would appear" to
    relativistic gedankenvolk.
    The measured (directly compared to local
    satellite clock) value is 10.23MHz.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 21:26:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 9:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:21, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 15:30, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again. >>>>>>>>>>>>
    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your >>>>>>>>>>>> moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the
    relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second >>>>>>>>>> of local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the
    difference between a unit of time and the rate at which a
    physical clock accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's >>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time >>>>>>> and the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.


    Apparently, even a disgusting, lying, demented wannabe engineer like
    you can keep lying nonstop.

    You have now repeated the same false claim about the GPS second so
    many times that I've lost count.

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    I didn't. You are a BUNCH of lying shit, Maciej.

    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    worldline."


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 20:27:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:25, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 8:54 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 19:17, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 11.11.2026 03:16, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    -a-a
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the >>>>>> nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the >>>>> GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.

    This is a strange statement.

    No.

    All the frequencies in a GPS SV are synthesised from the same
    frequency standard with the nominal frequency 10.23 MHz.

    In the GPS Interface Specification Document you will find:
    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Note the date.

    Thomas, Paul,

    This is an interesting technical distinction, and I think it is worth
    being precise about it.

    I have checked IS-GPS-200N, section 3.3.1.1, page 13.

    The specification explicitly states that the L1 and L2 carrier
    frequencies are coherently derived from a common frequency source aboard
    the satellite.

    It also specifies that both the carrier frequencies and the satellite
    clock rates are offset to compensate for relativistic effects.

    The fractional offset is:

    -a-a +of/f = -4.4647 |u 10^-10

    corresponding to:

    -a-a 10.2299999954326 MHz

    Of course, the specification states clearly -
    the number is just what "would appear" to
    relativistic gedankenvolk.
    The measured (directly compared to local
    satellite clock) value is 10.23MHz.

    Maciej, go to your room. There are adults discussing here.

    Care the sheets this time, thanks.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 20:28:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:21, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 15:30, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories whose >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating
    t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again. >>>>>>>>>>>>>
    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your >>>>>>>>>>>>> moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand.

    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the >>>>>>>>>>>> relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one second >>>>>>>>>>> of local proper time along a satellite's worldline

    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the
    difference between a unit of time and the rate at which a >>>>>>>>>> physical clock accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to >>>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's >>>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of time >>>>>>>> and the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.


    Apparently, even a disgusting, lying, demented wannabe engineer like
    you can keep lying nonstop.

    You have now repeated the same false claim about the GPS second so
    many times that I've lost count.

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    I didn't. You are a BUNCH of lying shit, Maciej.

    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    worldline."

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Go to your bed, care the sheets. Thanks.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 21:31:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 9:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:21, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 15:30, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whose development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your >>>>>>>>>>>>>> moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand. >>>>>>>>>>>>>
    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the >>>>>>>>>>>>> relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one >>>>>>>>>>>> second of local proper time along a satellite's worldline >>>>>>>>>>>>
    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the >>>>>>>>>>> difference between a unit of time and the rate at which a >>>>>>>>>>> physical clock accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to >>>>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's >>>>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of >>>>>>>>> time and the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.


    Apparently, even a disgusting, lying, demented wannabe engineer
    like you can keep lying nonstop.

    You have now repeated the same false claim about the GPS second so
    many times that I've lost count.

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    I didn't. You are a BUNCH of lying shit, Maciej.

    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    And you still have admitted that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy. Even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit as you are can't lie non
    stop.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 20:40:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:21, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 15:30, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whose development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on
    "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the >>>>>>>>>>>>>> relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one >>>>>>>>>>>>> second of local proper time along a satellite's worldline >>>>>>>>>>>>>
    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the >>>>>>>>>>>> difference between a unit of time and the rate at which a >>>>>>>>>>>> physical clock accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to >>>>>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's >>>>>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of >>>>>>>>>> time and the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.


    Apparently, even a disgusting, lying, demented wannabe engineer
    like you can keep lying nonstop.

    You have now repeated the same false claim about the GPS second so >>>>>> many times that I've lost count.

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    I didn't. You are a BUNCH of lying shit, Maciej.

    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    And you still have admitted that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    NO.

    Even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit as you are can't lie non
    stop.

    You can, poor bunch of shit. I don't have to :-)


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 20:47:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    worldline."

    Yes. I wrote that. And I stand by every word.

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Two clocks can accumulate different amounts of proper time between the
    same two events.

    Both amounts are expressed in SI seconds.

    That does not create two different definitions of the second.

    For example:

    GPS coordinate time elapsed: 86,400 SI seconds
    Satellite proper time elapsed: 86,400.0000386 SI seconds

    Same unit. Different elapsed times.

    This is precisely the distinction you have been failing to understand for days.

    And every time you quote my sentence, you provide another demonstration of that failure.

    Please keep going. The simulator practically writes itself. :-)

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 21:51:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 9:40 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:24 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:21, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 15:30, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:44 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:42, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:19, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 2:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 14:04, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> On 11/15/2026 1:58 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:53, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> On 11/15/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 13:33, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit : >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ..
    Sure no propercorrectperfectlygood clocks, they only >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> exist in sick delusions of brainwashed idiots like >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> yourself.
    Because the only thing they're usable for is: spinning >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> your gedanken tales and brainwashing the next >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    https://noedge.net/e/gps-one-way-3d-constellation.html >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Whine as much as you like.

    The actual GPS procedures rely on physical theories >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whose development

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit. They rely on >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "ideal clocks are synchronized (i.e. indicating >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> t'=t) clocks" postulate.

    No propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Maciej,

    You are confusing two entirely different concepts. Again. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    But still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> moronic liturgy there.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

    Copy, paste, repeat.

    Let's try something you might eventually understand. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    For a clock moving in a weak gravitational field, the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> relationship

    Your pseudophilosophical mumble is not changing
    anything, poor piece of shit.

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your >>>>>>>>>>>>>> moronic liturgy in GPS.

    Because the only thing they're usable for
    is: spinning your gedanken tales and brainwashing
    the next generations of The-a Shit's-a victims.


    And GPS second is not your SI idiocy, you've
    already admitted that, poor piece of shit.
    Uour moronic religion was unable to enforce
    your wannabe standard.


    No, I admitted nothing of the sort, idiot.


    Quoting:
    A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to one >>>>>>>>>>>>>> second of local proper time along a satellite's worldline >>>>>>>>>>>>>>
    You should have learnt already: your
    lies have short legs, poor piece of shit.

    Short legs, indeed: https://ibb.co/rRxMbJzS

    You have just demonstrated that you don't understand the >>>>>>>>>>>>> difference between a unit of time and the rate at which a >>>>>>>>>>>>> physical clock accumulates time.

    Let's examine your alleged contradiction.

    I wrote:

    -a-a-a "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to >>>>>>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a one second of local proper time along a satellite's >>>>>>>>>>>>> -a-a-a-a worldline."

    Correct.

    And I also wrote:

    -a-a-a "The GPS second is the SI second."

    Also correct.

    There is absolutely no contradiction.

    :)))))))
    You're indeed extremely impudent piece
    of lying shit, even for the standards
    of relativistic knights.

    But your lies change nothing,

    Still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    *Yawn.*

    Same insults. Same slogans. Same confusion between a unit of >>>>>>>>>>> time and the rate of a physical clock.

    And still - no propercorrectperfectlygood clock of your
    moronic liturgy in GPS. Still GPS second is
    equal to your Si on Earth and +4Cs periods
    on a satellite.

    Because the only thing they're (both your seconds
    and your clocks) usable for is: spinning your
    gedanken tales and brainwashing the next generations
    of The-a Shit's-a victims.

    And the only thing poor piece of shit Python can
    do about it - is drawing pictures where I look
    ugly. Not that anything better can be expected
    from a relativistic fanatic, of course.

    https://noedge.net/e/debate-loop-simulator.html

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.
    And, of course, proper correct,
    perfectly good are your assertions,
    as baseless as they are idiotic.


    Apparently, even a disgusting, lying, demented wannabe engineer >>>>>>> like you can keep lying nonstop.

    You have now repeated the same false claim about the GPS second >>>>>>> so many times that I've lost count.

    Fortunately, even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit can't lie non stop,
    so sometimes you admit that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    I didn't. You are a BUNCH of lying shit, Maciej.

    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    And you still have admitted that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    NO.

    Yes.
    Quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    worldline."

    Even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit as you are can't lie non
    stop.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 20:55:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:40 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:31, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    And you still have admitted that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    NO.

    Yes.
    Quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    worldline."

    Even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit as you are can't lie non
    stop.

    https://ibb.co/mFPyjBFF

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 21:55:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 9:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    Yes. I wrote that. And I stand by every word.

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Two clocks can accumulate different amounts of proper time between the
    same two events.

    Both amounts are expressed in SI seconds.

    That does not create two different definitions of the second.

    For example:

    -a-a GPS coordinate time elapsed:-a 86,400 SI seconds
    -a-a Satellite proper time elapsed: 86,400.0000386 SI seconds

    Same unit. Different elapsed times.

    And "A second of GPS coordinate time"
    which is different than "one second of local proper time along a
    satellite's worldline" (i.e. your SI idiocy).

    Sorry, even you can't lie non stop. Too
    bad for you, poor piece of shit.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 20:57:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:55, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    Yes. I wrote that. And I stand by every word.

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Two clocks can accumulate different amounts of proper time between the
    same two events.

    Both amounts are expressed in SI seconds.

    That does not create two different definitions of the second.

    For example:

    -a-a GPS coordinate time elapsed:-a 86,400 SI seconds
    -a-a Satellite proper time elapsed: 86,400.0000386 SI seconds

    Same unit. Different elapsed times.

    And "A second of GPS coordinate time"
    which is different than "one second of local proper time along a
    satellite's worldline" (i.e. your SI idiocy).

    Sorry, even you can't lie non stop. Too
    bad for you, poor piece of shit.

    https://ibb.co/mFPyjBFF

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 22:08:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 9:57 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:55, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    Yes. I wrote that. And I stand by every word.

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Two clocks can accumulate different amounts of proper time between
    the same two events.

    Both amounts are expressed in SI seconds.

    That does not create two different definitions of the second.

    For example:

    -a-a-a GPS coordinate time elapsed:-a 86,400 SI seconds
    -a-a-a Satellite proper time elapsed: 86,400.0000386 SI seconds

    Same unit. Different elapsed times.

    And "A second of GPS coordinate time"
    which is different than "one second of local proper time along a
    satellite's-a worldline" (i.e. your SI idiocy).

    Sorry, even you can't lie non stop. Too
    bad for you, poor piece of shit.

    https://ibb.co/mFPyjBFF


    Fortunately - even such a disgusting piece
    of lying shit can't lie non stop, so sometimes
    you admit: GPS second is not your SI idiocy.

    Your mad religion hasn't succeeded in enforcing
    your nonsense. Common sense had been warning
    the idiot.










    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 22:18:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 19:17, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn a |-crit :
    Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 11.11.2026 03:16, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the >>>>> nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the >>>> GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.

    This is a strange statement.

    No.

    All the frequencies in a GPS SV are synthesised from the same
    frequency standard with the nominal frequency 10.23 MHz.

    In the GPS Interface Specification Document you will find:
    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Note the date.

    Thomas, Paul,

    This is an interesting technical distinction, and I think it is worth
    being precise about it.

    I have checked IS-GPS-200N, section 3.3.1.1, page 13.

    The specification explicitly states that the L1 and L2 carrier frequencies are coherently derived from a common frequency source aboard the
    satellite.

    It also specifies that both the carrier frequencies and the satellite
    clock rates are offset to compensate for relativistic effects.

    Indeed. If the cited specification is followed to the letter, then
    apparently the claim that I remember to have read that the atomic clocks
    (more precisely their output: the proper frequency of the radiation emitted/absorbed in the used electronic transition cannot be changed)
    are not modified anymore is not correct, or I have misunderstood it.

    Explicitly, the relevant paragraph in the section "3.3.1.1 Frequency
    Plan" of the cited specification reads:

    | The carrier frequencies for the L1 and L2 signals shall be coherently
    | derived from a common frequency source within the SV. The nominal
    | frequency of this source -- as it appears to an observer on the ground
    | -- is 10.23 MHz. The SV carrier frequency and clock rates -- as they
    | would appear to an observer located in the SV -- are offset to
    | compensate for relativistic effects. [...]
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 21:23:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 22:08, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:57 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:55, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    Yes. I wrote that. And I stand by every word.

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Two clocks can accumulate different amounts of proper time between
    the same two events.

    Both amounts are expressed in SI seconds.

    That does not create two different definitions of the second.

    For example:

    -a-a-a GPS coordinate time elapsed:-a 86,400 SI seconds
    -a-a-a Satellite proper time elapsed: 86,400.0000386 SI seconds

    Same unit. Different elapsed times.

    And "A second of GPS coordinate time"
    which is different than "one second of local proper time along a
    satellite's-a worldline" (i.e. your SI idiocy).

    Sorry, even you can't lie non stop. Too
    bad for you, poor piece of shit.

    https://ibb.co/mFPyjBFF


    Fortunately - even such a disgusting piece
    of lying shit can't lie non stop, so sometimes
    you admit: GPS second is not your SI idiocy.

    Your mad religion hasn't succeeded in enforcing
    your nonsense. Common sense had been warning
    the idiot.

    Maciej,

    Ah, "common sense"!

    Throughout history, common sense has confidently told people that:

    - The Earth is flat.
    - The Earth rests on elephants standing on a giant turtle.
    - The Earth is stationary at the center of the universe, with everything revolving around it.
    - Heavier-than-air machines cannot fly.
    - Travelling at very high speeds would kill human beings.
    - Moving objects naturally slow down and stop, even without any opposing force.
    - Time flows identically everywhere, independently of motion and gravity.

    Some of these were widespread intuitions, others mythological beliefs or popular misconceptions.

    Fortunately, science doesn't determine what is true by consulting common sense.

    It uses mathematical models, quantitative predictions, and experimental
    tests.

    And GPS is a particularly spectacular example.

    Your "common sense" tells you that the GPS second cannot be the SI second because a satellite clock accumulates proper time at a different rate from
    GPS coordinate time.

    Physics tells us that both quantities are measured in the SAME SI unit,
    while their rates differ.

    GPS engineering takes that difference into account and works.

    You can keep repeating your misunderstanding as often as you like.

    But the satellites will keep working, and the equations will remain
    unchanged.

    Common sense is useful for crossing the street.

    For understanding relativistic timekeeping, I recommend learning some
    physics.

    And perhaps a little dimensional analysis.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 22:34:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 10:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 22:08, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:57 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:55, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    Yes. I wrote that. And I stand by every word.

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Two clocks can accumulate different amounts of proper time between
    the same two events.

    Both amounts are expressed in SI seconds.

    That does not create two different definitions of the second.

    For example:

    -a-a-a GPS coordinate time elapsed:-a 86,400 SI seconds
    -a-a-a Satellite proper time elapsed: 86,400.0000386 SI seconds

    Same unit. Different elapsed times.

    And "A second of GPS coordinate time"
    which is different than "one second of local proper time along a
    satellite's-a worldline" (i.e. your SI idiocy).

    Sorry, even you can't lie non stop. Too
    bad for you, poor piece of shit.

    https://ibb.co/mFPyjBFF


    Fortunately - even such a disgusting piece
    of lying shit can't lie non stop, so sometimes
    you admit: GPS second is not your SI idiocy.

    Your mad religion hasn't succeeded in enforcing
    your nonsense. Common sense had been warning
    the idiot.

    Maciej,

    Ah, "common sense"!

    Throughout history, common sense has confidently told people that:

    - The Earth is flat.
    - The Earth rests on elephants standing on a giant turtle.
    - The Earth is stationary at the center of the universe, with everything revolving around it.
    - Heavier-than-air machines cannot fly.
    - Travelling at very high speeds would kill human beings.
    - Moving objects naturally slow down and stop, even without any opposing force.
    - Time flows identically everywhere, independently of motion and gravity.

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit, most of
    these alleged claims of common sense are
    just your usual moronic lies.

    Fortunately, science doesn't determine what is true by consulting common sense.

    It uses mathematical models, quantitative predictions, and experimental tests.


    And when its tests fail pathetically it
    screams "CONSPIRACY!!!! THE CLOCKS
    WERE DELIBERATELY ADJUSTED!!!! THIS
    IS NOT REAL!!!!!"
    Typical stance of a relativistic idiot, BTW,
    apart of his moronic religion there is no
    science for him.


    And GPS is a particularly spectacular example.

    Your "common sense" tells you that the GPS second cannot be the SI
    second because a satellite clock accumulates proper time at a different
    rate from GPS coordinate time.

    The reason is completely different.
    but anyway they're different, even such
    a disgusting piece of lying shit as you are
    is sometimes admitting that. What a pity
    you're too stupid to lie consistently, isn't
    it?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 21:36:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 22:34, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 10:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 22:08, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:57 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:55, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    Yes. I wrote that. And I stand by every word.

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a
    QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Two clocks can accumulate different amounts of proper time between >>>>>> the same two events.

    Both amounts are expressed in SI seconds.

    That does not create two different definitions of the second.

    For example:

    -a-a-a GPS coordinate time elapsed:-a 86,400 SI seconds
    -a-a-a Satellite proper time elapsed: 86,400.0000386 SI seconds

    Same unit. Different elapsed times.

    And "A second of GPS coordinate time"
    which is different than "one second of local proper time along a
    satellite's-a worldline" (i.e. your SI idiocy).

    Sorry, even you can't lie non stop. Too
    bad for you, poor piece of shit.

    https://ibb.co/mFPyjBFF


    Fortunately - even such a disgusting piece
    of lying shit can't lie non stop, so sometimes
    you admit: GPS second is not your SI idiocy.

    Your mad religion hasn't succeeded in enforcing
    your nonsense. Common sense had been warning
    the idiot.

    Maciej,

    Ah, "common sense"!

    Throughout history, common sense has confidently told people that:

    - The Earth is flat.
    - The Earth rests on elephants standing on a giant turtle.
    - The Earth is stationary at the center of the universe, with everything
    revolving around it.
    - Heavier-than-air machines cannot fly.
    - Travelling at very high speeds would kill human beings.
    - Moving objects naturally slow down and stop, even without any opposing
    force.
    - Time flows identically everywhere, independently of motion and gravity.

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit, most of
    these alleged claims of common sense are
    just your usual moronic lies.

    Fortunately, science doesn't determine what is true by consulting common
    sense.

    It uses mathematical models, quantitative predictions, and experimental
    tests.


    And when its tests fail pathetically it
    screams "CONSPIRACY!!!! THE CLOCKS
    WERE DELIBERATELY ADJUSTED!!!! THIS
    IS NOT REAL!!!!!"
    Typical stance of a relativistic idiot, BTW,
    apart of his moronic religion there is no
    science for him.


    And GPS is a particularly spectacular example.

    Your "common sense" tells you that the GPS second cannot be the SI
    second because a satellite clock accumulates proper time at a different
    rate from GPS coordinate time.

    The reason is completely different.
    but anyway they're different, even such
    a disgusting piece of lying shit as you are
    is sometimes admitting that. What a pity
    you're too stupid to lie consistently, isn't
    it?

    So now the relativistic corrections built into GPS engineering are a "conspiracy"?

    That's quite a remarkable interpretation of an openly documented
    engineering procedure.

    The satellite frequency offset of approximately

    -4.4647 |u 10^-10

    is not an excuse invented after a failed experiment.

    It is a design parameter, specified in advance, to compensate for the predicted average relativistic rate difference between satellite clocks
    and GPS coordinate time.

    You can read about it in the GPS Interface Specification:

    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Section 3.3.1.1.

    No conspiracy. No secret adjustments. No failed prediction being rescued
    after the fact.

    Just an engineering system designed using quantitative physical models.

    Now, you claim that the tests of relativity "fail pathetically".

    Which test, exactly?

    Give us the experiment, the measured result, the theoretical prediction,
    and the discrepancy.

    And while you're at it, answer another elementary question:

    If the GPS second is not the SI second, as you keep claiming, what is its definition?

    Not the number of oscillations accumulated by a particular satellite clock during an interval of GPS coordinate time.

    The definition of the UNIT itself.

    Because you are still confusing these two things:

    Unit: SI second.

    Clock rate: d-a/dt, which need not equal 1.

    Both quantities are expressed using the same unit.

    And your inability to distinguish them does not constitute an experimental failure of relativity.

    As for your "common sense", I have prepared another illustration:

    https://ibb.co/pr9T1J3r

    Now, perhaps you could give us an actual experimental result instead of another round of insults.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 23:00:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 10:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 22:34, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 10:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 22:08, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:57 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:55, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 21:26, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    Yes, poor piece of shit, you did, quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    -a one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    -a worldline."

    Yes. I wrote that. And I stand by every word.

    You still haven't understood the difference between a UNIT and a >>>>>>> QUANTITY measured in that unit.

    Two clocks can accumulate different amounts of proper time
    between the same two events.

    Both amounts are expressed in SI seconds.

    That does not create two different definitions of the second.

    For example:

    -a-a-a GPS coordinate time elapsed:-a 86,400 SI seconds
    -a-a-a Satellite proper time elapsed: 86,400.0000386 SI seconds

    Same unit. Different elapsed times.

    And "A second of GPS coordinate time"
    which is different than "one second of local proper time along a
    satellite's-a worldline" (i.e. your SI idiocy).

    Sorry, even you can't lie non stop. Too
    bad for you, poor piece of shit.

    https://ibb.co/mFPyjBFF


    Fortunately - even such a disgusting piece
    of lying shit can't lie non stop, so sometimes
    you admit: GPS second is not your SI idiocy.

    Your mad religion hasn't succeeded in enforcing
    your nonsense. Common sense had been warning
    the idiot.

    Maciej,

    Ah, "common sense"!

    Throughout history, common sense has confidently told people that:

    - The Earth is flat.
    - The Earth rests on elephants standing on a giant turtle.
    - The Earth is stationary at the center of the universe, with
    everything revolving around it.
    - Heavier-than-air machines cannot fly.
    - Travelling at very high speeds would kill human beings.
    - Moving objects naturally slow down and stop, even without any
    opposing force.
    - Time flows identically everywhere, independently of motion and
    gravity.

    No, sorry, poor piece of shit, most of
    these alleged claims of common sense are
    just your usual moronic lies.

    Fortunately, science doesn't determine what is true by consulting
    common sense.

    It uses mathematical models, quantitative predictions, and
    experimental tests.


    And when its tests fail pathetically it
    screams "CONSPIRACY!!!! THE CLOCKS
    WERE DELIBERATELY ADJUSTED!!!! THIS
    IS NOT REAL!!!!!"
    Typical stance of a relativistic idiot, BTW,
    apart of his moronic religion there is no
    science for him.


    And GPS is a particularly spectacular example.

    Your "common sense" tells you that the GPS second cannot be the SI
    second because a satellite clock accumulates proper time at a
    different rate from GPS coordinate time.

    The reason is completely different.
    but anyway they're different, even such
    a disgusting piece of lying shit as you are
    is sometimes admitting that. What a pity
    you're too stupid to lie consistently, isn't
    it?

    So now the relativistic corrections built into GPS engineering are a "conspiracy"?

    They're no way relativistic, your moronic
    religion has announced that it would
    be perfectly good without them and tried
    to enforce your SI idiocy as the definition
    of second to forbid them. Of course, without
    any success.

    That's quite a remarkable interpretation of an openly documented
    engineering procedure.

    It is indeed, but so is the "logic" of your
    bunch of idiots.



    You can read about it in the GPS Interface Specification:

    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Section 3.3.1.1.

    No conspiracy. No secret adjustments

    No conspiracy, no secret adjustments,
    if the idiot's knowledge about the clocks
    came from the reality instead from his
    moronic gedankenwelt he could easily
    predict them.



    Now, you claim that the tests of relativity "fail pathetically".

    Which test, exactly?

    The idiot has predicted some difference in
    the clock indications, the real, measured
    value is, of course, 0 (even such a piece
    of lying shit as you are is sometimes admitting
    that). Yeah, the clocks were deliberately
    adjusted (just like they always are), so
    don't lie I'm avoiding admitting that.





    If the GPS second is not the SI second, as you keep claiming, what is
    its definition?

    Basically - this one. https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/second
    It's an open standard, however - GPS interpretation
    fits it but it's not the only one.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 22:07:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    At last! You have finally provided your definition of the GPS second.

    A Cambridge English Dictionary entry.

    Wonderful.

    We have been discussing atomic frequency standards, proper time,
    coordinate time, satellite clock corrections, and GPS engineering, and
    your ultimate technical reference is an ordinary English dictionary.

    Let me explain what is wrong with your alleged experimental refutation.

    You write:

    "The idiot has predicted some difference in
    the clock indications, the real, measured
    value is, of course, 0."

    But that is NOT the prediction for the indications of GPS clocks after relativistic compensation and clock corrections.

    Relativity predicts a difference between the natural proper-time rates of clocks following different worldlines.

    For nominal GPS satellite orbits, the average fractional rate difference relative to the GPS reference is approximately:

    +4.4647 |u 10^-10

    The satellite clock frequency is deliberately pre-offset to compensate for this predicted effect.

    Consequently, the corrected satellite time information is designed to
    agree with GPS coordinate time within the system's accuracy requirements.

    You observe that the corrected clocks agree and announce that the theory predicting the need for the correction has failed.

    That's like observing that a calibrated instrument reads correctly and declaring that the calibration model has been disproved.

    Now consider two distinct predictions:

    A. Without relativistic rate compensation:

    The nominal satellite clock would accumulate approximately 38.6 microseconds of additional proper time per day relative to the GPS coordinate-time reference rate.

    B. With relativistic rate compensation:

    The average rate difference is compensated, leaving residual errors to
    be handled by the GPS clock model and other corrections.

    The observation of B does not refute A.

    It is precisely what the engineering was designed to achieve.

    And there is another elementary point you keep missing.

    A dictionary can explain what the English word "second" means.

    It cannot replace the metrological definition of the SI second, which
    fixes the unperturbed caesium-133 hyperfine transition frequency at 9,192,631,770 Hz.

    GPS coordinate time uses the SI second as its unit.

    The fact that satellite proper time and GPS coordinate time accumulate at different rates does not create two different units.

    You have now confused:

    - a dictionary definition with a metrological standard;
    - an uncorrected clock rate with a corrected clock indication;
    - agreement after compensation with evidence that compensation was unnecessary.

    Three mistakes in one reply.

    Quite an achievement.

    Now, instead of quoting dictionaries, answer one quantitative question:

    What fractional frequency offset does YOUR model predict for a nominal GPS satellite before compensation?

    Relativity predicts approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 for the required
    factory pre-offset.

    Give us your independently calculated value.

    Then we can compare predictions rather than insults.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Sun Nov 15 22:12:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 15/11/2026 |a 22:34, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    And GPS is a particularly spectacular example.

    Your "common sense" tells you that the GPS second cannot be the SI
    second because a satellite clock accumulates proper time at a different
    rate from GPS coordinate time.

    The reason is completely different.
    but anyway they're different, even such
    a disgusting piece of lying shit as you are
    is sometimes admitting that. What a pity
    you're too stupid to lie consistently, isn't
    it?

    "The reason is completely different.
    but anyway they're different."

    Brilliant!

    The reason is completely different, but you won't tell us what it is.

    The conclusion is certain, but the argument is missing.

    A remarkable scientific method:

    1. Assert a conclusion.
    2. Announce that the reason is completely different.
    3. Don't explain the reason.
    4. Repeat the conclusion.
    5. Add insults.

    I think we've finally discovered the algorithm behind your reasoning.

    And the best part? It fits perfectly into the debate simulator without changing a single line of code. :-)

    So, what IS this "completely different" reason?

    Or is it classified information?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 07:33:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 11:12 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 |a 22:34, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    ..
    And GPS is a particularly spectacular example.

    Your "common sense" tells you that the GPS second cannot be the SI
    second because a satellite clock accumulates proper time at a
    different rate from GPS coordinate time.

    The reason is completely different.
    but anyway they're different, even such
    a disgusting piece of lying shit as you are
    is sometimes admitting that. What a pity
    you're too stupid to lie consistently, isn't
    it?

    -a-a "The reason is completely different.
    -a-a-a but anyway they're different."

    Brilliant!

    The reason is completely different, but you won't tell us what it is.

    Of course I will, same as I did many times.


    GPS second is not your SI idiocy, because
    your SI idiocy has the same number of Cs
    periods always, everywhere - and a GPS
    second has +4 Cs periods on a GPS satellite.
    Anyone can check that. And SI would make
    the clocks desynchronizing, to fulfill the
    mad prophecies of your mad idiot - while GPS
    clocks keep sync.


    And even such a disgusting piece of lying
    shit as you are is sometimes admitting that.






    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 06:40:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity


    You have finally given us a number.

    "+4 Cs periods on a GPS satellite."

    Excellent. Let's calculate.

    The SI second is defined using exactly:

    9,192,631,770 periods

    of the unperturbed caesium-133 hyperfine transition, expressed in the
    atom's proper time.

    Now, the predicted average relativistic rate difference for a nominal GPS satellite is:

    d-a/dt - 1 ree +4.4647 |u 10^-10

    Multiply:

    9,192,631,770 |u 4.4647 |u 10^-10

    ree 4.104

    FOUR EXTRA CAESIUM PERIODS!

    Congratulations, Maciej.

    You have just quoted, to the nearest whole period, the very relativistic effect you have spent days denying.

    But you have misunderstood what it means.

    The SI definition concerns the duration of one second of LOCAL PROPER
    TIME, as realized by an ideal unperturbed caesium frequency standard.

    It does NOT say that every caesium clock in the universe must accumulate exactly 9,192,631,770 oscillations during the same interval of GPS
    COORDINATE TIME.

    Those are two different time quantities.

    A nominal GPS satellite's uncorrected atomic standard would accumulate approximately 9,192,631,774.104 periods during one second of GPS
    coordinate time.

    But 9,192,631,770 periods of that same unperturbed transition still
    correspond to one SI second of local proper time.

    Same unit. Different rates.

    And because the GPS system needs its satellite time signals to follow a
    common coordinate time scale, the generated frequencies are adjusted accordingly.

    That is precisely the purpose of the relativistic frequency pre-offset.

    Your "+4 periods" is not evidence against relativity.

    It is the numerical signature of the effect relativity predicts.

    You have spent days shouting that relativistic corrections are nonsense,
    only to present their predicted magnitude as your decisive argument.

    I couldn't have designed a better punchline for the simulator.

    Thank you. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 07:50:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/15/2026 11:07 PM, Python wrote:
    At last! You have finally provided your definition of the GPS second.

    A Cambridge English Dictionary entry.

    Wonderful.

    We have been discussing atomic frequency standards, proper time,
    coordinate time, satellite clock corrections, and GPS engineering, and
    your ultimate technical reference is an ordinary English dictionary.


    Sorry to disappoint such a poor piece of shit,
    but the facts are no way obliged to obey your
    delusions of how things should be.
    1/86400 of a solar day is equivalent to
    9 192 631 770~Cs periods on Earth and
    ~9 192 631 774 on a GPS satellite, and
    that's how GPS clocks are set.

    On 4/10/2025 10:41 PM, Paul.B.Andersen wrote:

    GPS clocks are adjusted down by (1 - 4.4647e-10)
    so the adjusted clock will measure a mean solar day
    to last 86400 s

    See? Even your fellow idiot Paul is realizing
    that the clocks of GPS are adjusted to measure
    1/86400 of a day as a second. Of course, usually
    he lies just like you. But, fortunately,
    relativistic scum is always too stupid to keep
    its lie consistent and sometimes accidentally
    says some truth.


    You write:

    -a-a "The idiot has predicted some difference in
    -a-a-a the clock indications, the real, measured
    -a-a-a value is, of course, 0."

    But that is NOT the prediction for the indications of GPS clocks after relativistic compensation and clock corrections.

    Of course it is not. The idiot was too
    primitive and too stupid to realize
    that clocks are adjusted. And, of course,
    corrections are no way relativistic,
    oppositely, your moronic religion
    did its best to forbid them, without
    any success of course.


    Relativity predicts a difference between the natural proper-time rates
    of clocks following different worldlines.

    Bullshit. Does Newton's physics with
    t'=t predicts no difference between "natural
    proper rates" of pendulums too?


    Relativity predicts approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 for the required
    factory pre-offset.

    Lie, of course, your mad Shit is asserting
    that clocks are going to be perfectly good
    without any pre-offset. An assertion, of
    course, as baseless as it is idiotic; but
    if it was treated seriously it would make
    the idiot's prophecies fulfilled.






    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 06:52:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    This is getting better and better.

    You now write:

    "1/86400 of a solar day is equivalent to
    9 192 631 770~Cs periods on Earth and
    ~9 192 631 774 on a GPS satellite"

    So you have discovered that the same interval of coordinate time
    corresponds to different amounts of proper time along different
    worldlines.

    Congratulations. Again.

    That's exactly what relativity predicts.

    But let's examine your latest collection of confusions.

    FIRST: THE SOLAR DAY.

    The SI second has not been defined as 1/86400 of a mean solar day since
    1960.

    Since 1967, its definition has been based on the caesium-133 hyperfine transition.

    And GPS time is an atomic time scale, not a clock continually synchronized
    to the observed rotation of the Earth.

    The Earth's rotation is irregular. Atomic timekeeping is not defined by
    it.

    SECOND: YOUR FOUR EXTRA PERIODS.

    The predicted relativistic fractional rate difference is:

    +4.4647 |u 10^-10

    Multiply it by the caesium reference frequency:

    9,192,631,770 |u 4.4647 |u 10^-10
    ree 4.104 periods

    There are your four extra periods.

    Not a new definition of the second.

    Not an alternative to relativity.

    The numerical consequence of relativity.

    THIRD: YOUR PENDULUM ANALOGY.

    You ask whether Newtonian physics predicts different natural rates for pendulums.

    Of course it does.

    A pendulum's period depends on gravitational acceleration and its physical parameters.

    But a pendulum is not an ideal clock measuring proper time.

    The dependence of a pendulum's period on local gravity is a property of
    its mechanism.

    Relativistic differences in proper-time accumulation are not defects of
    clock mechanisms.

    They persist for ideal clocks.

    Confusing those two effects is not an argument.

    FOURTH: "PERFECTLY GOOD" CLOCKS.

    You keep claiming that relativity predicts that GPS satellite clocks
    should work perfectly without frequency adjustments.

    No.

    An unadjusted ideal atomic clock on a GPS satellite would be perfectly
    good at measuring its own proper time.

    But GPS requires satellite clock signals to follow a common
    coordinate-time scale.

    Those are different requirements.

    A perfectly functioning clock does not automatically display the
    coordinate time of every reference system in the universe.

    The required average frequency offset is predicted by relativity.

    And you have now supplied its numerical magnitude yourself.

    FINALLY: PAUL'S STATEMENT.

    Paul writes:

    "GPS clocks are adjusted down by (1 - 4.4647e-10)"

    Exactly.

    That is the relativistic precompensation factor.

    You quote the numerical relativistic correction, acknowledge that it is deliberately applied, and then announce that relativity forbids it.

    Where, precisely, does relativity forbid this adjustment?

    Give us the equation, the published prediction, or the technical document.

    Not another dictionary.

    Not another insult.

    And not another assertion about what your imaginary version of relativity supposedly says.

    An actual reference.

    Until then, your argument amounts to:

    "The GPS engineers apply the predicted relativistic correction, therefore relativity is wrong."

    A truly impressive demonstration of circular misunderstanding. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 07:53:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/16/2026 7:40 AM, Python wrote:

    You have finally given us a number.

    -a-a "+4 Cs periods on a GPS satellite."

    Excellent. Let's calculate.

    The SI second is defined using exactly:

    -a-a 9,192,631,770 periods

    of the unperturbed caesium-133 hyperfine transition, expressed in the
    atom's proper time.

    Now, the predicted average relativistic rate difference for a nominal
    GPS satellite is:

    -a-a d-a/dt - 1 ree +4.4647 |u 10^-10

    Multiply:

    -a-a 9,192,631,770 |u 4.4647 |u 10^-10

    -a-a ree 4.104

    FOUR EXTRA CAESIUM PERIODS!

    Congratulations, Maciej.

    You have just quoted, to the nearest whole period, the very relativistic effect you have spent days denying.

    Sorry, poor piece of shit, no relativistic
    effect makes Cs frequency +4 on a GPS
    satellite. You're just lying like
    always.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 06:54:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    "No relativistic effect makes Cs frequency
    +4 on a GPS satellite."

    CORRECT!

    And nobody claimed otherwise.

    The unperturbed caesium-133 transition frequency remains:

    9,192,631,770 Hz

    when expressed in the atom's LOCAL PROPER TIME.

    What relativity predicts is that a nominal GPS satellite's proper time accumulates approximately 4.4647 |u 10^-10 faster than GPS coordinate
    time.

    Consequently, an ideal unadjusted caesium oscillator on that satellite accumulates approximately:

    9,192,631,774.104 periods

    during ONE SECOND OF GPS COORDINATE TIME.

    But still exactly:

    9,192,631,770 periods

    during ONE SECOND OF ITS OWN PROPER TIME.

    Same atomic transition. Same SI second. Different elapsed times.

    You have confused the frequency measured with respect to proper time with
    the frequency expressed with respect to coordinate time.

    Again.

    And the funniest part is that your own "+4 periods" is almost exactly the relativistic prediction.

    You have the right number.

    You just don't understand what it measures. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 08:00:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/16/2026 7:52 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    This is getting better and better.

    You now write:

    -a-a "1/86400 of a solar day is equivalent to
    -a-a-a 9 192 631 770~Cs periods on Earth and
    -a-a-a ~9 192 631 774 on a GPS satellite"

    So you have discovered that the same interval of coordinate time
    corresponds to different amounts of proper time along different worldlines.

    Congratulations. Again.

    That's exactly what relativity predicts.

    But let's examine your latest collection of confusions.

    FIRST: THE SOLAR DAY.

    The SI second has not been defined as 1/86400 of a mean solar day since 1960.

    Since 1967, its definition has been based on the caesium-133 hyperfine transition.


    And everyone sane is ignoring that, together with
    the most of insane ones including the creators of
    this nonsense.
    "1/86400 of a solar day is equivalent to
    9 192 631 770~Cs periods on Earth and
    ~9 192 631 774 on a GPS satellite"
    and that's how a real second of the real clocks
    is adjusted.

    A bunch of idiots can easily define a shark
    as a grasseater - but enforcing the sane
    people to care is harder.


    And GPS time is an atomic time scale, not a clock continually
    synchronized to the observed rotation of the Earth.
    And GPS clocks are set to
    ~9 192 631 770~Cs periods on Earth and
    ~9 192 631 774 on a GPS satellite"

    i.e to the real second.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 08:02:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/16/2026 7:54 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    -a-a "No relativistic effect makes Cs frequency
    -a-a-a +4 on a GPS satellite."

    CORRECT!

    And nobody claimed otherwise.

    You did, sorry, quoting:
    "
    You have just quoted, to the nearest whole period, the very relativistic effect you have spent days denying.
    "

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 10:39:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Le 15/11/2026 a 21:51, Maciej Wo?niak a ocrit :
    On 11/15/2026 9:40 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 15/11/2026 a 21:31, Maciej Wo?niak a ocrit :
    ..
    And you still have admitted that GPS second
    is not your SI idiocy.

    NO.

    Yes.
    Quoting:
    "A second of GPS coordinate time is not identical to
    one second of local proper time along a satellite's
    worldline."

    Even such a disgusting
    piece of lying shit as you are can't lie non
    stop.

    https://ibb.co/mFPyjBFF

    "Image not found" error,

    Jan
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 15:08:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Den 15.11.2026 19:17, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 11.11.2026 03:16, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Python wrote:
    **BEFORE LAUNCH:**

    The satellite's atomic clock is tested on Earth. Its frequency is
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    deliberately offset by approximately -4.4647 |u 10^-10 relative to the >>>> nominal GPS frequency.

    JFTR: Today that is the frequency of the signal that is emitted by the
    GPS satellite's sending antenna, NOT the output frequency of the
    satellite's clock.

    This is a strange statement.

    No.

    It's a plain wrong statement.
    What I found strange is that you don't know better.


    All the frequencies in a GPS SV are synthesised from the same
    frequency standard with the nominal frequency 10.23 MHz.

    In the GPS Interface Specification Document you will find:
    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IS-GPS-200N.pdf

    Note the date.

    According to: https://www.gps.gov/interface-control-documents-icds-interface-specifications-iss

    IS-GPS-200 Rev N is the currently valid version.

    However, there is a couple of "CHANGE NOTICEs":

    https://www.gps.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/IRN-IS-200N-003.pdf

    https://gps.gov/sites/default/files/2026-09/IRN-IS-200N-004_RFC519_20260616.pdf

    They do not affect the quote below:

    Quote from 3.3.1.1 Frequency Plan page 16:

    "The carrier frequencies for the L1 and L2 signals shall be
    coherently derived from a common frequency source within
    the SV. The nominal frequency of this source -- as it
    appears to an observer on the ground -- is 10.23 MHz.
    The SV carrier frequency and clock rates -- as they would
    appear to an observer located in the SV -- are offset to
    compensate for relativistic effects. The clock rates are
    offset by +of/f = -4.4647E-10, equivalent to a change in
    the P-code chipping rate of 10.23 MHz offset by a
    +of = -4.5674E-3 Hz. This is equal to 10.2299999954326 MHz.

    The nominal carrier frequencies (f0) shall be 1575.42 MHz,
    and 1227.6 MHz for L1 and L2, respectively.
    "

    Not much to discuss, is it?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 15:17:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Den 15.11.2026 22:18, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Python wrote:

    Thomas, Paul,

    This is an interesting technical distinction, and I think it is worth
    being precise about it.

    I have checked IS-GPS-200N, section 3.3.1.1, page 13.

    The specification explicitly states that the L1 and L2 carrier frequencies >> are coherently derived from a common frequency source aboard the
    satellite.

    It also specifies that both the carrier frequencies and the satellite
    clock rates are offset to compensate for relativistic effects.

    Indeed. If the cited specification is followed to the letter, then apparently the claim that I remember to have read that the atomic clocks (more precisely their output: the proper frequency of the radiation emitted/absorbed in the used electronic transition cannot be changed)
    are not modified anymore is not correct, or I have misunderstood it.

    Another strange statement. :-)

    The frequency of the photon associated with the hyperfine transition is:
    In Caesium : 9192631770 Hz. (this is the definition of second)
    In Rubidium : 6834682610.904 Hz
    In Hydrogen : 420405751.77 Hz (the famous 21 cm spectral line)

    The "hyperfine transition" is caused by spin reversal of an electron
    in ground state.
    The energy of the electron is slightly different when its spin is
    equal to the spin of the nucleus and when it is opposite.

    These frequencies can obviously not be changed.

    An "atomic frequency standard" is a frequency synthesiser.
    One of the frequencies above is the reference frequency in
    the synthesiser. In a GPS SV, the output frequency of
    the synthesiser is 10.2299999954326 MHz.

    In a GPS Block I SV there was two Caesium and one Rubidium standard.
    They could switch to the best standard, but not while the SV was
    in service.

    In GPS Block IIR SVs and later the frequency standard
    is a "Time Keeping System" (TKS).
    See:
    https://paulba.no/temp/IIR_TKS.pdf

    See block diagram in Figure 1:
    https://paulba.no/GPS/GPS_TKS.pdf

    RAFS = Rubidium Frequency Standard

    Notice that only Rubidium standards are used, and that
    the nominal frequency of a RAFS is 13.4 MHz, not 10.23 MHz.
    The nominal output of the TKS is 10.23 MHz.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Mon Nov 16 15:32:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/16/2026 3:17 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 15.11.2026 22:18, skrev Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn:
    Python wrote:

    Thomas, Paul,

    This is an interesting technical distinction, and I think it is worth
    being precise about it.

    I have checked IS-GPS-200N, section 3.3.1.1, page 13.

    The specification explicitly states that the L1 and L2 carrier
    frequencies
    are coherently derived from a common frequency source aboard the
    satellite.

    It also specifies that both the carrier frequencies and the satellite
    clock rates are offset to compensate for relativistic effects.

    Indeed.-a If the cited specification is followed to the letter, then
    apparently the claim that I remember to have read that the atomic clocks
    (more precisely their output: the proper frequency of the radiation
    emitted/absorbed in the used electronic transition cannot be changed)
    are not modified anymore is not correct, or I have misunderstood it.

    Another strange statement. :-)

    The frequency of the photon associated with the hyperfine transition is:
    In Caesium-a : 9192631770 Hz.-a-a-a (this is the definition of second)

    No, sorry, it is not. Your moronic
    religion, sure, has forbidden to
    count a second as 1/86400 of a day,
    but the prohibition didn't work,
    the real second remains as it always
    was and the frequency is ~9192631770
    on Earth and ~9192631774 on a GPS
    satellite.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2