• Re: What are your proofs against Euclid

    From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 12:01:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 11:43 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    "Who am I quoting?"

    Me, obviously.

    And I stand by every word.

    Mathematics provides models. Physics determines experimentally which
    models describe reality.

    Euclidean geometry is a mathematical theory. It can be used to construct physical models.

    Where is the contradiction?

    You seem to believe that if a mathematical theory is logically valid,
    every physical model built from it must necessarily describe reality.

    I may seem but I don't. It's not about ANY
    theory. It's about EG. Geometry. Do you know
    what the word means in Greek? It means:
    "I'm a measurement based model of the
    reality".


    By that reasoning, since both Euclidean and hyperbolic geometries are mathematically consistent, physical space must obey both simultaneously!

    Poincare has explained it does. You're
    of course too dumb and too primitive
    for Poincare.


    And now you proudly confirm that "good models are unfalsifiable".

    Wonderful.

    A model that predicts the wrong experimental result

    Is not a good model. Even such an idiot
    should understand that.


    Maciej, mathematics doesn't become false when a physical model fails.

    The MODEL fails.

    So, tell me, poor piece of shit: we have
    EG and we allegedly have "a physical model
    of space basing on EG" - what are the
    differences?



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 11:04:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Oh, so now the Greek etymology of "geometry" proves that physical space
    must be Euclidean?

    Wonderful.

    "Geometry" originally meant "earth measurement".

    And "atom" originally meant "indivisible".

    Should we therefore conclude that nuclear fission is impossible because
    the ancient Greeks chose the wrong word?

    As for Poincar|-, you seem to have misunderstood him rather spectacularly.

    His point was that different geometrical conventions can be used to
    describe physical phenomena, provided the accompanying physical laws are adjusted accordingly.

    Not that Euclidean and hyperbolic geometries magically become the same mathematical theory.

    And here's a thought that apparently never occurred to you:

    POINCAR|e COULD BE WRONG.

    Yes, Maciej. Even Poincar|-.

    Scientific authority is not infallibility.

    In fact, subsequent developments in general relativity and experimental gravitation have considerably changed how we understand the relationship between geometry and physical measurements.

    Now, your question:

    "What are the differences between EG and a physical model based on EG?"

    Elementary.

    Euclidean geometry says that the angles of a triangle in a Euclidean plane
    sum to 180 degrees.

    A physical model based on Euclidean geometry says that a specified
    procedure for constructing and measuring a physical triangle will yield
    that result, within experimental uncertainty.

    The first is a mathematical theorem.

    The second is a prediction about nature.

    One is proved. The other is tested.

    And if the experiment disagrees, the mathematical theorem remains
    perfectly valid.

    You keep asking for this distinction, then insulting everyone who explains
    it.

    But perhaps I finally understand your approach to science.

    Euclid must be right because he's Euclid.

    Poincar|- must be right because he's Poincar|-.

    And Einstein must be wrong because Maciej Wo+|niak says so.

    Quite a rigorous methodology.

    Have you considered publishing it under the title "Argument from
    Authority, Except When I Dislike the Authority"?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 12:31:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 12:04 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Oh, so now the Greek etymology of "geometry" proves that physical space
    must be Euclidean?

    There is no proof and there never was.
    Still, some people may find the assertions of
    basic math more trustworthy than the assertions
    of a mad, brainwashing religion. Even if they're
    not aware it's a matter of word choosing and
    how it works.



    As for Poincar|-, you seem to have misunderstood him rather spectacularly.

    His point was that different geometrical conventions can be used to
    describe physical phenomena, provided the accompanying physical laws are adjusted accordingly.

    Exactly, and physical space can obey all of them
    simultaneously.

    And here's a thought that apparently never occurred to you:

    POINCAR|e COULD BE WRONG.

    Yes, Maciej. Even Poincar|-.

    Sure, sure, only the idiot and those following him
    (including, of course, poor piece of shit Python)
    can never be.


    "What are the differences between EG and a physical model based on EG?"

    Elementary.

    Euclidean geometry says that the angles of a triangle in a Euclidean
    plane sum to 180 degrees.

    A physical model based on Euclidean geometry says that a specified
    procedure for constructing and measuring a physical triangle will yield
    that result, within experimental uncertainty.

    What an impudent bullshit. "specified procedure for
    constructing and measuring a physical triangle"? No
    such thing existed in your mad religion ever, even now.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 11:35:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    "No such thing existed in your mad religion ever."

    Really?

    Have you ever heard of geodesy? Triangulation? Surveying? Measuring angles
    and distances?

    People were constructing and measuring physical triangles long before
    Einstein was born.

    And in relativistic physics, one can specify operational procedures using light signals, clocks, freely falling test bodies and measuring
    instruments.

    The predictions depend on the physical geometry and the measurement
    protocol.

    That's precisely what makes them testable.

    But your latest invocation of Poincar|- is even more entertaining.

    You agree that different geometrical conventions can describe the same physical phenomena, provided the physical laws are adjusted accordingly.

    Excellent!

    Then Euclidean geometry cannot be the uniquely mandatory description of physical space merely because Euclid developed it.

    You've just conceded the point you've spent years denying.

    And when I suggest that Poincar|- might have been wrong about something,
    you reply that Einstein's followers consider him infallible.

    No, Maciej.

    Einstein could be wrong.
    Poincar|- could be wrong.
    Newton could be wrong.

    That's why physics relies on experiments rather than declarations of mathematical or historical authority.

    Now here's the interesting question:

    Could Maciej Wo+|niak be wrong?

    Judging by your posts, that is the one hypothesis your scientific
    methodology absolutely forbids us to test.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 12:59:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 12:35 PM, Python wrote:
    "No such thing existed in your mad religion ever."

    Really?

    Yes.


    Have you ever heard of geodesy? Triangulation? Surveying? Measuring
    angles and distances?

    What is the biggest triangle geodesy and triangulation
    can deal with?

    People were constructing and measuring physical triangles long before Einstein was born.

    They did, but your moronic religion didn't specify
    procedures for them.

    And in relativistic physics, one can specify operational procedures
    using light signals, clocks, freely falling test bodies and measuring instruments.

    "One can"... why won't you try yourself, poor piece of shit?
    Prepare me an operastional procedure of determining a triangle...
    not a big one, 10 to 20 ly of sides.

    But, anyway, previously you were lying it's already specified
    and ready, and not in relativistic physics but in Euclid's
    based physics. As a liar you're so pathetically incompetent.
    Well, in any role you are.



    But your latest invocation of Poincar|- is even more entertaining.


    You agree that different geometrical conventions can describe the same physical phenomena, provided the physical laws are adjusted accordingly.

    Excellent!

    Then Euclidean geometry cannot be the uniquely mandatory description of physical space merely because Euclid developed it.

    It is not mandatory, sure. Some idiot may
    invent some shit and assert it's The One.
    It's going to be baseless and idiotic, but
    it's possible other idiots will believe and
    worship it.


    You've just conceded the point you've spent years denying.

    And when I suggest that Poincar|- might have been wrong about something,
    you reply that Einstein's followers consider him infallible.

    No, Maciej.

    Yes, poor piece of shit.



    Einstein could be wrong.
    Poincar|- could be wrong.
    Newton could be wrong.

    That's why physics relies on experiments rather than declarations of mathematical or historical authority.

    No, it doesn't. It's asserting, of course -
    and lying impudently.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 14:04:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Ah! Finally, an actual question instead of your usual collection of
    insults.

    You want an operational procedure for measuring a triangle with sides of
    10 to 20 light-years?

    Fine.

    1. Choose three identifiable objects A, B and C, equipped in principle
    with clocks and transponders.

    2. Specify a reference frame and a synchronization convention. For
    simplicity, start with an approximately inertial region of spacetime.

    3. Measure the round-trip light travel times between each pair of objects, correcting for their relative motion and any relevant gravitational
    effects.

    4. Using the specified coordinate system and the measured signal
    propagation times, reconstruct the simultaneous positions of A, B and C
    and determine the three spatial distances.

    5. Calculate the triangle's angles and compare the results with the predictions of the chosen physical geometry.

    This is a conceptual operational protocol, not a claim that we already
    possess a network of transponders spanning twenty light-years.

    For curved spacetime, the procedure must additionally specify the spatial geometry and the notion of distance being tested.

    Now, notice something important.

    Nothing in Euclid's axioms tells you how to synchronize distant clocks,
    how electromagnetic signals propagate, or how gravity affects measuring instruments.

    Those are PHYSICAL questions.

    Which is exactly why Euclidean geometry, as a mathematical theory, is not
    by itself a complete physical model of space.

    And there's an even more amusing problem with your challenge.

    You apparently believe that unless we can physically construct a triangle twenty light-years across, we cannot test the geometry of spacetime.

    Have you heard of gravitational lensing? Light deflection? Relativistic time-delay measurements?

    Nature provides experimental tests of spacetime geometry without requiring astronomers to build gigantic triangles with rulers.

    Finally, you write:

    "Physics doesn't rely on experiments."

    Thank you, Maciej.

    After years of discussion, you've finally stated your position with
    admirable clarity.

    Euclid supplies the mathematics.
    Poincar|- supplies the authority.
    Maciej supplies the insults.

    And experiments are apparently an unnecessary complication.

    No wonder Einstein's physics annoys you so much. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 15:57:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 3:04 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Ah! Finally, an actual question instead of your usual collection of
    insults.

    You want an operational procedure for measuring a triangle with sides of
    10 to 20 light-years?

    Fine.

    1. Choose three identifiable objects A, B and C, equipped in principle
    with clocks and transponders.

    Immobile wrt each other? How are you going
    to ensure that?


    2. Specify a reference frame and a synchronization convention. For simplicity, start with an approximately inertial region of spacetime.

    Ah, "approximately inertial".
    Did I ask you for a procedure of measuring a triangle
    or for a procedure of measuring a gedanken-flat-space-euclidean
    triangle?



    3. Measure the round-trip light travel times between each pair of
    objects, correcting for their relative motion and any relevant
    gravitational effects.

    Pfff. Enough of this comedy.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 16:01:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 3:04 PM, Python wrote:

    You apparently believe that unless we can physically construct a
    triangle twenty light-years across, we cannot test the geometry of spacetime.


    No, poor piece of shit, I just believe that
    your "specified procedure for constructing
    and measuring a physical triangle " was
    a lie even more impudent than the average of
    yours.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 07:07:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/05/2026 06:04 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Ah! Finally, an actual question instead of your usual collection of
    insults.

    You want an operational procedure for measuring a triangle with sides of
    10 to 20 light-years?

    Fine.

    1. Choose three identifiable objects A, B and C, equipped in principle
    with clocks and transponders.

    2. Specify a reference frame and a synchronization convention. For simplicity, start with an approximately inertial region of spacetime.

    3. Measure the round-trip light travel times between each pair of
    objects, correcting for their relative motion and any relevant
    gravitational effects.

    4. Using the specified coordinate system and the measured signal
    propagation times, reconstruct the simultaneous positions of A, B and C
    and determine the three spatial distances.

    5. Calculate the triangle's angles and compare the results with the predictions of the chosen physical geometry.

    This is a conceptual operational protocol, not a claim that we already possess a network of transponders spanning twenty light-years.

    For curved spacetime, the procedure must additionally specify the
    spatial geometry and the notion of distance being tested.

    Now, notice something important.

    Nothing in Euclid's axioms tells you how to synchronize distant clocks,
    how electromagnetic signals propagate, or how gravity affects measuring instruments.

    Those are PHYSICAL questions.

    Which is exactly why Euclidean geometry, as a mathematical theory, is
    not by itself a complete physical model of space.

    And there's an even more amusing problem with your challenge.

    You apparently believe that unless we can physically construct a
    triangle twenty light-years across, we cannot test the geometry of
    spacetime.

    Have you heard of gravitational lensing? Light deflection? Relativistic time-delay measurements?

    Nature provides experimental tests of spacetime geometry without
    requiring astronomers to build gigantic triangles with rulers.

    Finally, you write:

    "Physics doesn't rely on experiments."

    Thank you, Maciej.

    After years of discussion, you've finally stated your position with
    admirable clarity.

    Euclid supplies the mathematics.
    Poincar|- supplies the authority.
    Maciej supplies the insults.

    And experiments are apparently an unnecessary complication.

    No wonder Einstein's physics annoys you so much. :-)

    Poincare makes analysis situs and including space-inversion,
    about "Poincare completion" and "real holonomy and real monodromy,
    not partial-differentrial-geometry's non-holonomic non-monodromic
    claims to holonomy and monodromy", which are the big completions
    of connections of continuity.

    You don't know Poincare, and claiming his authority is a farce.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 16:06:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    "Immobile wrt each other? How are you going to ensure that?"

    Why would I need to?

    Objects can move. Their positions can be determined at specified
    coordinate times. Astronomy has been doing this for centuries.

    "Approximately inertial?"

    Yes. An approximation, explicitly stated as such. You know, the sort of
    thing physicists actually use when modelling real systems.

    My previous outline was a conceptual protocol, not a complete engineering specification for an interstellar experiment. I have no difficulty acknowledging that.

    But your objection is rather revealing.

    You demand a physical triangle, then object to reference frames, moving objects, light propagation and gravitational corrections.

    In other words, you demand a measurement while rejecting the physical assumptions needed to define it.

    So here's a question for you.

    How does Euclid's *Elements* tell us how to determine the distance between
    two moving stars, 15 light-years apart?

    Which axiom specifies the measuring instrument, the simultaneity
    convention and the treatment of gravitational effects?

    None, of course.

    Because Euclidean geometry is MATHEMATICS, not an experimental instruction manual.

    And that's the distinction you've been struggling with throughout this discussion.

    But I understand why you stopped at step 3.

    We were getting dangerously close to discussing actual measurements
    instead of calling Einstein an idiot.

    Pfff. Enough of this comedy, indeed. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 16:07:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 05/11/2026 |a 16:07, Ross Finlayson a |-crit :
    On 11/05/2026 06:04 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Ah! Finally, an actual question instead of your usual collection of
    insults.

    You want an operational procedure for measuring a triangle with sides of
    10 to 20 light-years?

    Fine.

    1. Choose three identifiable objects A, B and C, equipped in principle
    with clocks and transponders.

    2. Specify a reference frame and a synchronization convention. For
    simplicity, start with an approximately inertial region of spacetime.

    3. Measure the round-trip light travel times between each pair of
    objects, correcting for their relative motion and any relevant
    gravitational effects.

    4. Using the specified coordinate system and the measured signal
    propagation times, reconstruct the simultaneous positions of A, B and C
    and determine the three spatial distances.

    5. Calculate the triangle's angles and compare the results with the
    predictions of the chosen physical geometry.

    This is a conceptual operational protocol, not a claim that we already
    possess a network of transponders spanning twenty light-years.

    For curved spacetime, the procedure must additionally specify the
    spatial geometry and the notion of distance being tested.

    Now, notice something important.

    Nothing in Euclid's axioms tells you how to synchronize distant clocks,
    how electromagnetic signals propagate, or how gravity affects measuring
    instruments.

    Those are PHYSICAL questions.

    Which is exactly why Euclidean geometry, as a mathematical theory, is
    not by itself a complete physical model of space.

    And there's an even more amusing problem with your challenge.

    You apparently believe that unless we can physically construct a
    triangle twenty light-years across, we cannot test the geometry of
    spacetime.

    Have you heard of gravitational lensing? Light deflection? Relativistic
    time-delay measurements?

    Nature provides experimental tests of spacetime geometry without
    requiring astronomers to build gigantic triangles with rulers.

    Finally, you write:

    "Physics doesn't rely on experiments."

    Thank you, Maciej.

    After years of discussion, you've finally stated your position with
    admirable clarity.

    Euclid supplies the mathematics.
    Poincar|- supplies the authority.
    Maciej supplies the insults.

    And experiments are apparently an unnecessary complication.

    No wonder Einstein's physics annoys you so much. :-)

    Poincare makes analysis situs and including space-inversion,
    about "Poincare completion" and "real holonomy and real monodromy,
    not partial-differentrial-geometry's non-holonomic non-monodromic
    claims to holonomy and monodromy", which are the big completions
    of connections of continuity.

    You don't know Poincare, and claiming his authority is a farce.

    I didn't. Maciej did :-)


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:16:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 5:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    "Immobile wrt each other? How are you going to ensure that?"

    Why would I need to?

    Objects can move. Their positions can be determined at specified
    coordinate times. Astronomy has been doing this for centuries.

    You're writing "correcting for their relative
    motion and any relevant gravitational effects"
    - and in your sick, indoctrinated half-brain it's
    "specifying the procedure". Enough of this
    comedy, trash.



    "Approximately inertial?"

    Yes. An approximation, explicitly stated as such. You know, the sort of thing physicists actually use when modelling real systems.

    My previous outline was a conceptual protocol, not a complete
    engineering specification for an interstellar experiment. I have no difficulty acknowledging that.

    But your objection is rather revealing.

    You demand a physical triangle, then object to reference frames, moving objects, light propagation and gravitational corrections.

    In other words, you demand a measurement while rejecting the physical assumptions needed to define it.

    So here's a question for you.

    How does Euclid's *Elements* tell us how to determine the distance
    between two moving stars, 15 light-years apart?

    It doesn't.
    It's not a model of light, gravitational corrections
    or clocks. It's a model of space.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:17:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 5:07 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 05/11/2026 |a 16:07, Ross Finlayson a |-crit :
    On 11/05/2026 06:04 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Ah! Finally, an actual question instead of your usual collection of
    insults.

    You want an operational procedure for measuring a triangle with sides of >>> 10 to 20 light-years?

    Fine.

    1. Choose three identifiable objects A, B and C, equipped in principle
    with clocks and transponders.

    2. Specify a reference frame and a synchronization convention. For
    simplicity, start with an approximately inertial region of spacetime.

    3. Measure the round-trip light travel times between each pair of
    objects, correcting for their relative motion and any relevant
    gravitational effects.

    4. Using the specified coordinate system and the measured signal
    propagation times, reconstruct the simultaneous positions of A, B and C
    and determine the three spatial distances.

    5. Calculate the triangle's angles and compare the results with the
    predictions of the chosen physical geometry.

    This is a conceptual operational protocol, not a claim that we already
    possess a network of transponders spanning twenty light-years.

    For curved spacetime, the procedure must additionally specify the
    spatial geometry and the notion of distance being tested.

    Now, notice something important.

    Nothing in Euclid's axioms tells you how to synchronize distant clocks,
    how electromagnetic signals propagate, or how gravity affects measuring
    instruments.

    Those are PHYSICAL questions.

    Which is exactly why Euclidean geometry, as a mathematical theory, is
    not by itself a complete physical model of space.

    And there's an even more amusing problem with your challenge.

    You apparently believe that unless we can physically construct a
    triangle twenty light-years across, we cannot test the geometry of
    spacetime.

    Have you heard of gravitational lensing? Light deflection? Relativistic
    time-delay measurements?

    Nature provides experimental tests of spacetime geometry without
    requiring astronomers to build gigantic triangles with rulers.

    Finally, you write:

    "Physics doesn't rely on experiments."

    Thank you, Maciej.

    After years of discussion, you've finally stated your position with
    admirable clarity.

    Euclid supplies the mathematics.
    Poincar|- supplies the authority.
    Maciej supplies the insults.

    And experiments are apparently an unnecessary complication.

    No wonder Einstein's physics annoys you so much. :-)

    Poincare makes analysis situs and including space-inversion,
    about "Poincare completion" and "real holonomy and real monodromy,
    not partial-differentrial-geometry's non-holonomic non-monodromic
    claims to holonomy and monodromy", which are the big completions
    of connections of continuity.

    You don't know Poincare, and claiming his authority is a farce.

    I didn't. Maciej did :-)

    No, you lie like always.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 16:27:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    "It doesn't.
    It's not a model of light, gravitational corrections
    or clocks. It's a model of space."

    EXACTLY.

    And that is precisely the point you keep missing.

    Euclidean geometry is a MATHEMATICAL model of space.

    It does not tell you whether physical space is Euclidean.

    It does not tell you how to measure the distance between two moving stars.

    It does not tell you how to establish simultaneity at two distant
    locations.

    And it certainly does not tell you how to determine the geometry of a
    triangle spanning twenty light-years.

    For that, you need PHYSICS.

    You need operational definitions, observations, clocks, signals, reference frames, and a model connecting those observations to geometrical
    quantities.

    You may then test whether Euclidean geometry is an adequate approximation.

    But you cannot simply DECLARE that physical space is Euclidean because
    Euclid wrote a book about geometry.

    The Pythagorean theorem is mathematically exact within Euclidean geometry.

    Whether it applies exactly to a particular physical triangle is an
    EMPIRICAL question.

    And there is an additional problem you keep avoiding:

    In relativity, the spatial distance between moving objects depends on the choice of simultaneity and spatial slicing.

    There is no generally unique, observer-independent three-dimensional
    geometry of an arbitrary collection of distant moving objects.

    So when you say:

    "It's a model of space."

    the obvious question is:

    WHICH SPACE?

    Defined by which physical procedure?

    At which coordinate times?

    In which reference frame?

    Your refusal to specify any of these things is not a defense of Euclidean geometry.

    It is a refusal to connect your mathematical model to physical reality.

    And calling everyone who asks these questions "indoctrinated" does not magically turn Euclid's axioms into measuring instruments.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 16:28:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    You invoked Poincar|- to support your position.

    I pointed out that Poincar|- could be wrong.

    Ross then accused me of appealing to Poincar|-'s authority.

    I reminded him that it was YOU who invoked Poincar|-.

    And now you call that a lie.

    Apparently, your memory is as selective as your understanding of geometry.

    Fortunately, Usenet preserves the evidence.

    Would you like me to quote your own words back to you, or would that be another attack on your religion? :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:41:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 5:27 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    -a-a "It doesn't.
    -a-a-a It's not a model of light, gravitational corrections
    -a-a-a or clocks. It's a model of space."

    EXACTLY.

    And that is precisely the point you keep missing.

    I wrote it so you have a direct
    proof that I'm missing it, right,
    trash?


    Euclidean geometry is a MATHEMATICAL model of space.

    Sure it's not a physical model, it's
    the quality your primitive gurus can
    never approach.

    It does not tell you how to measure the distance between two moving stars.

    As if your mad Shit was able to -
    not mentioning Newton in XVIIth
    century.


    You may then test whether Euclidean geometry is an adequate approximation.

    You've been already caught on this lie.


    Whether it applies exactly to a particular physical triangle is an
    EMPIRICAL question.

    No, sorry, you have no clue about the subject.


    And there is an additional problem you keep avoiding:

    In relativity, the spatial distance between moving objects depends on
    the choice of simultaneity and spatial slicing.
    There is no generally unique, observer-independent three-dimensional geometry of an arbitrary collection of distant moving objects.


    And you still insist that it has a specified
    procedure for that. You're such a pathetic
    piece of lying shit...



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:45:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 5:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    You invoked Poincar|- to support your position.

    I've pointed that he was smart enough
    to understand some things you and
    that primitive idiot you worship
    was missing. An authority? No way.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 16:59:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    Ah, I see.

    You invoked Poincar|- because he was smart enough to agree with you.

    But that wasn't an appeal to authority.

    Of course not.

    And if Poincar|- had disagreed with you, I suppose that would merely have proved he wasn't so smart after all.

    How wonderfully convenient.

    Apparently, the ultimate criterion of scientific intelligence is agreement with Maciej Wo+|niak.

    Poor Poincar|-. He passed your examination without ever knowing he was
    taking it.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 16:59:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    You seem to have discovered another astonishing principle:

    If a physical quantity depends on a specified reference frame, then no procedure for determining it can possibly exist.

    Wonderful.

    By that reasoning, since velocity depends on the reference frame, nobody
    has ever specified a procedure for measuring velocity.

    And since kinetic energy depends on the reference frame, measuring it must
    be another relativistic fraud.

    The absence of a UNIQUE, frame-independent spatial distance does not imply
    the absence of WELL-DEFINED procedures for determining spatial distances.

    Quite the opposite: specifying the reference frame and simultaneity
    convention is precisely part of the procedure.

    You demand an operational definition, then complain when the necessary conventions are specified.

    You demand measurements, then dismiss the physical corrections required to interpret them.

    And when the distinction is explained, you shout "LIE!" and "SHIT!"

    Maciej, the problem isn't that physics lacks operational definitions.

    It's that you apparently expect nature to provide every measurement with a little label saying "ABSOLUTE, EUCLIDEAN, APPROVED BY MACIEJ".

    Unfortunately, the universe has neglected to consult you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 18:02:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 5:59 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Ah, I see.

    You invoked Poincar|- because he was smart enough to agree with you.

    But that wasn't an appeal to authority.

    Of course not.

    And if Poincar|- had disagreed with you, I suppose that would merely have proved he wasn't so smart after all.

    He wasn't, he was almost a physicist after
    all. He understood much more than you do
    or the idiot did and much less than I do.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 09:05:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/05/2026 08:07 AM, Python wrote:
    Le 05/11/2026 |a 16:07, Ross Finlayson a |-crit :
    On 11/05/2026 06:04 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Ah! Finally, an actual question instead of your usual collection of
    insults.

    You want an operational procedure for measuring a triangle with sides of >>> 10 to 20 light-years?

    Fine.

    1. Choose three identifiable objects A, B and C, equipped in principle
    with clocks and transponders.

    2. Specify a reference frame and a synchronization convention. For
    simplicity, start with an approximately inertial region of spacetime.

    3. Measure the round-trip light travel times between each pair of
    objects, correcting for their relative motion and any relevant
    gravitational effects.

    4. Using the specified coordinate system and the measured signal
    propagation times, reconstruct the simultaneous positions of A, B and C
    and determine the three spatial distances.

    5. Calculate the triangle's angles and compare the results with the
    predictions of the chosen physical geometry.

    This is a conceptual operational protocol, not a claim that we already
    possess a network of transponders spanning twenty light-years.

    For curved spacetime, the procedure must additionally specify the
    spatial geometry and the notion of distance being tested.

    Now, notice something important.

    Nothing in Euclid's axioms tells you how to synchronize distant clocks,
    how electromagnetic signals propagate, or how gravity affects measuring
    instruments.

    Those are PHYSICAL questions.

    Which is exactly why Euclidean geometry, as a mathematical theory, is
    not by itself a complete physical model of space.

    And there's an even more amusing problem with your challenge.

    You apparently believe that unless we can physically construct a
    triangle twenty light-years across, we cannot test the geometry of
    spacetime.

    Have you heard of gravitational lensing? Light deflection? Relativistic
    time-delay measurements?

    Nature provides experimental tests of spacetime geometry without
    requiring astronomers to build gigantic triangles with rulers.

    Finally, you write:

    "Physics doesn't rely on experiments."

    Thank you, Maciej.

    After years of discussion, you've finally stated your position with
    admirable clarity.

    Euclid supplies the mathematics.
    Poincar|- supplies the authority.
    Maciej supplies the insults.

    And experiments are apparently an unnecessary complication.

    No wonder Einstein's physics annoys you so much. :-)

    Poincare makes analysis situs and including space-inversion,
    about "Poincare completion" and "real holonomy and real monodromy,
    not partial-differentrial-geometry's non-holonomic non-monodromic
    claims to holonomy and monodromy", which are the big completions
    of connections of continuity.

    You don't know Poincare, and claiming his authority is a farce.

    I didn't. Maciej did :-)



    Oh, you do.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:15:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 05/11/2026 |a 18:02, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/5/2026 5:59 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Ah, I see.

    You invoked Poincar|- because he was smart enough to agree with you.

    But that wasn't an appeal to authority.

    Of course not.

    And if Poincar|- had disagreed with you, I suppose that would merely have >> proved he wasn't so smart after all.

    He wasn't, he was almost a physicist after
    all. He understood much more than you do
    or the idiot did and much less than I do.

    So Poincar|- understood more than Einstein, but considerably less than
    Maciej Wo+|niak.

    What an extraordinary coincidence: the history of scientific thought turns
    out to be a long, painful ascent towards you.

    Euclid, Newton, Poincar|-, Einstein... all struggling in the darkness,
    waiting for the intellectual summit of Usenet.

    And the greatest tragedy?

    The Nobel Committee still hasn't noticed. :-)

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 18:15:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 5:59 PM, Python wrote:
    You seem to have discovered another astonishing principle:

    If a physical quantity depends on a specified reference frame, then no procedure for determining it can possibly exist.

    Since the distance between stars or
    velocity depends on frame - you're
    not measuring distance between stars or
    velocity, you measure distance between
    stars in a frame or velocity in a frame.


    The absence of a UNIQUE, frame-independent spatial distance does not
    imply the absence of WELL-DEFINED procedures for determining spatial distances.


    The Shit still doesn't have them.
    Neither for spatial distances, nor
    for spatial distances in frames.



    Unfortunately, the universe has neglected to consult you.

    The universe has nothing in common with the mad
    assertions of the idiot and his doggies. They're
    just mad assertions of the idiot and his
    doggies, as baseless as they are idiotic.
    That you're asserting that Universe Itself
    is supporting you means no more than if you
    were asserting that Mother of God is.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:19:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    "You're not measuring distance between stars or velocity, you measure
    distance between stars in a frame or velocity in a frame."

    EXACTLY!

    Congratulations. You've finally understood something we've been explaining
    to you for years.

    A spatial distance between distant objects must be defined relative to a specified reference frame and simultaneity convention.

    And specifying these is precisely part of an operational measurement procedure.

    You then announce that relativity has no such procedures.

    Apparently, repeating "THE SHIT DOESN'T HAVE THEM!" is supposed to
    constitute a mathematical demonstration.

    As for your comparison with the Mother of God, there's a rather important difference.

    Relativity makes quantitative predictions that can be confronted with experiments.

    The Mother of God doesn't publish predictions for gravitational time
    dilation, light deflection or the perihelion advance of Mercury.

    And you?

    You publish insults.

    At least the Mother of God has the good sense not to pretend they're
    physics. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:28:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Maciej,

    So you finally agree that distances and velocities are defined relative to
    a reference frame.

    Excellent. That's progress.

    But apparently, specifying a reference frame, synchronizing clocks and measuring signal propagation times still doesn't count as a measurement procedure.

    Why?

    Because Maciej says so.

    And then you compare experimental physics to invoking the Mother of God.

    There's a small difference, though.

    Relativity makes quantitative predictions that can be tested against observations.

    Your objections consist almost entirely of declaring those predictions
    "mad", their authors "idiots", and everyone who understands them
    "doggies".

    You demand operational definitions, reject them when they're provided, and then announce triumphantly that none exist.

    Maciej, if repeating an assertion made it true, you'd have revolutionized physics years ago.

    Unfortunately, repetition is not experimental evidence.

    Neither is profanity.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 18:29:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 6:19 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    "You're not measuring distance between stars or velocity, you measure distance between stars in a frame or velocity in a frame."

    EXACTLY!

    Congratulations. You've finally understood something we've been
    explaining to you for years.

    A spatial distance between distant objects must be defined relative to a specified reference frame and simultaneity convention.

    No, it doesn't have to be. What you and the idiot
    are proposing is an utter idiocy - but as long
    as we're talking about The Shit it is valid.



    And specifying these is precisely part of an operational measurement procedure.

    Pfff.

    Relativity makes quantitative predictions that can be confronted with experiments.

    Sure, it has predicted a difference in
    clock indications, but unfortunately measurements
    gave 0 and even such a disgusting piece
    of lying shit as you are sometimes admits
    that.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 18:33:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 6:28 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    So you finally agree that distances and velocities are defined relative
    to a reference frame.

    No. I agreed that's how your mad Shit
    is defining them.



    And then you compare experimental physics to invoking the Mother of God.

    There's a small difference, though.

    Relativity makes quantitative predictions that can be tested against observations.

    Sure, and after they fail miserably
    a relativistic idiot screams that
    clocks were deliberately adjusted.
    As if it wasn't obvious that clocks
    are always deliberately adjusted.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:36:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    "Measurements gave 0."

    Really?

    Name ONE experiment where relativity predicted a nonzero difference
    between clock readings and the measured difference was zero.

    Give us the reference, the predicted value and the measured value.

    Surely, after all these years, you have at least ONE?

    Or is your entire experimental evidence another unsupported assertion? :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:37:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Yes, clocks are adjusted and calibrated. That's how precision measurements work.

    The question is whether their subsequent readings agree with quantitative predictions.

    You claim relativity's predictions "fail miserably".

    Fine. Name ONE experiment.

    Give us the predicted difference, the measured difference, and the
    published reference.

    Not another insult. Not another story about Einstein's worshipers.

    Actual numbers.

    Surely that's not too much to ask from someone who claims to understand physics better than Poincar|-.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 18:37:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 6:36 PM, Python wrote:
    "Measurements gave 0."

    Really?

    Yes. Anyone can check GPS.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 17:47:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Oh dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.

    GPS satellite clocks are affected by both special and general relativistic effects, with a combined rate difference of approximately +38 microseconds
    per day relative to clocks on Earth's surface.

    The system accounts for these effects.

    You keep confusing clocks deliberately adjusted to compensate for a
    predicted relativistic effect with clocks demonstrating that the effect doesn't exist.

    That's like claiming gravity doesn't exist because an aircraft maintains
    its altitude.

    Now, for the umpteenth time:

    Name ONE experiment where relativity predicted a nonzero clock difference
    and the measured difference was zero.

    "Anyone can check GPS" is not an experimental result.

    It's your usual escape route.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 18:59:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 6:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Oh dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.

    GPS satellite clocks are affected by both special and general
    relativistic effects

    Oh, dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.
    No, your effects don't exists.
    The Shit has predicted them, but
    the measurements gave 0 instead.

    If your moronic religion succeeded
    with enforcing its mad wannabe standard
    things would be different. But it
    didn't succeed and things are as they are.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 18:03:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 05/11/2026 |a 18:59, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/5/2026 6:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Oh dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.

    GPS satellite clocks are affected by both special and general
    relativistic effects

    Oh, dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.
    No, your effects don't exists.
    The Shit has predicted them, but
    the measurements gave 0 instead.

    If your moronic religion succeeded
    with enforcing its mad wannabe standard
    things would be different. But it
    didn't succeed and things are as they are.

    https://ibb.co/23j051pv


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 19:08:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 7:03 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 05/11/2026 |a 18:59, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/5/2026 6:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Oh dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.

    GPS satellite clocks are affected by both special and general
    relativistic effects

    Oh, dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.
    No, your effects don't exists.
    The Shit has predicted them, but
    the measurements gave 0 instead.

    If your moronic religion succeeded
    with enforcing its mad wannabe standard
    things would be different. But it
    didn't succeed and things are as they are.

    https://ibb.co/23j051pv

    I'm not insisting on your conspiracy, poor
    piece of shit. You're far too stupid
    for any conspiracy.
    But, of course, GPS engineers must be
    some conspiracy against the idiot. They
    have deliberately adjusted clocks to measure
    t'=t! And if they didn't things would be
    exactly as the idiot said.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@jpierre.messager@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 18:14:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Le 05/11/2026 |a 19:08, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/5/2026 7:03 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 05/11/2026 |a 18:59, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/5/2026 6:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Oh dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.

    GPS satellite clocks are affected by both special and general
    relativistic effects

    Oh, dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.
    No, your effects don't exists.
    The Shit has predicted them, but
    the measurements gave 0 instead.

    If your moronic religion succeeded
    with enforcing its mad wannabe standard
    things would be different. But it
    didn't succeed and things are as they are.

    https://ibb.co/23j051pv

    I'm not insisting on your conspiracy, poor
    piece of shit. You're far too stupid
    for any conspiracy.
    But, of course, GPS engineers must be
    some conspiracy against the idiot. They
    have deliberately adjusted clocks to measure
    t'=t! And if they didn't things would be
    exactly as the idiot said.

    https://ibb.co/VcCGC74q

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 19:21:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    On 11/5/2026 7:14 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 05/11/2026 |a 19:08, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/5/2026 7:03 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 05/11/2026 |a 18:59, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/5/2026 6:47 PM, Python wrote:
    Oh dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.

    GPS satellite clocks are affected by both special and general
    relativistic effects

    Oh, dear. The GPS lie. AGAIN.
    No, your effects don't exists.
    The Shit has predicted them, but
    the measurements gave 0 instead.

    If your moronic religion succeeded
    with enforcing its mad wannabe standard
    things would be different. But it
    didn't succeed and things are as they are.

    https://ibb.co/23j051pv

    I'm not insisting on your conspiracy, poor
    piece of shit. You're far too stupid
    for any conspiracy.
    But, of course, GPS engineers must be
    some conspiracy against the idiot. They
    have deliberately adjusted clocks to measure
    t'=t! And if they didn't things would be
    exactly as the idiot said.

    https://ibb.co/VcCGC74q

    Once again - your bunch of idiots is too
    stupid for any conspiracy.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From nospam@nospam@de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder) to sci.physics.relativity on Thu Nov 5 21:37:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics.relativity

    Python <jpierre.messager@gmail.com> wrote:

    Maciej,

    Ah! Finally, an actual question instead of your usual collection of
    insults.

    You want an operational procedure for measuring a triangle with sides of
    10 to 20 light-years?

    Fine.

    1. Choose three identifiable objects A, B and C, equipped in principle
    with clocks and transponders.

    That is overdoing it. At todays precision, orbit calculations
    in the solar system, using transponders on spacecraft
    already require the use of general relativity for correct results.
    (so implicitly relativistic geometry)

    At modest light travel times of hours only,

    Jan
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2