After following discussions about relativity here for quite a while, I
think the sociology has become at least as interesting as the physics.
Consider several of our resident opponents of relativity. They certainly
do not defend the same alternative theory. In fact, their alternatives
are often mutually incompatible.
Yet the argumentative methods show remarkable similarities.
This is not a psychiatric diagnosis, nor am I interested in whether
somebody is "crazy". I am interested in how a belief system is protected
when confronted with quantitative physics.
A few recurring patterns seem particularly striking.
1. THE ALTERNATIVE THEORY RARELY RISKS A NUMBER
Relativity says things such as:
under conditions X, observable Y should differ by Z.
Then somebody measures Y.
An alternative theory which is genuinely competing with relativity
should say:
my theory predicts Z'.
Then we compare Z and Z' with experiment.
But remarkably often the discussion instead becomes:
"that clock is wrong"
"that isn't really acceleration"
"that isn't really time"
"that coordinate is abstract"
"that experiment was corrected"
"those physicists assumed relativity"
Everything is discussed except Z'.
That may be an interesting philosophical question.
But unless the proposed "real now" changes an observable result, it
doesn't distinguish two physical theories.
A competing physical theory eventually has to tell us what Alice and Bob actually read on their instruments.
6. SUCCESSFUL PREDICTIONS BECOME EVIDENCE OF THE CONSPIRACY
This is perhaps the most sociologically interesting stage.
When prediction and experiment agree, the agreement itself becomes suspicious:
the experimenters assumed relativity;
the engineers were taught relativity;
the clocks were corrected using relativity;
physics is a religion;
everybody has been brainwashed.
This makes the position extraordinarily resistant to evidence.
Disagreement with relativity supports the alternative.
Agreement with relativity also supports the alternative, because the agreement demonstrates how deeply relativity has contaminated the
experiment.
At that point we no longer have an empirical theory.
We have an immune system.
7. DIFFERENT CRANK THEORIES SHARE THE SAME IMMUNE SYSTEM
This may explain something initially puzzling.
Ralph/Wilson, Maciej, Richard and others do not actually agree about
what replaces relativity.
One may appeal to absolute acceleration, another to "correct clocks",
another to universal anisochrony, another to some preferred notion of
time.
Their physics can be mutually contradictory.
Yet they can coexist quite happily in the same anti-relativity ecosystem because agreement about the replacement theory is secondary.
The common element is methodological:
Einstein must be wrong.
The machinery required to preserve that conclusion can then be invented locally as each experimental difficulty appears.
8. THE SIMPLE TEST
There is a very easy way out of all this.
For any proposed alternative to relativity, ask four questions:
1. What experiment are we considering?
2. What exactly is measured?
3. What numerical result does relativity predict?
4. What different numerical result does your theory predict?
Question 4 is the interesting one.
If after 200 posts we have learned that Einstein was an idiot, clocks
are junk, physicists are priests, coordinates are imaginary, engineers
are brainwashed and universities teach religion -- but we still do not
have the alternative number -- then we have learned quite a lot.
Just not about physics.
There is probably a genuine sociological subject here.
The fascinating feature of crank physics is not simply that people can believe incorrect things. Everybody does that.
It is the construction of a system in which being shown wrong becomes progressively more difficult because every possible counterexample is reclassified after the fact.
The clock agrees with relativity?
Bad clock.
The engineers compensate exactly the predicted effect?
Contaminated experiment.
Several independent technologies reproduce the effect?
Brainwashing.
Ask for the alternative quantitative prediction?
Change the subject to what "proper" really means.
This is why arguing about the hundredth interpretation of "good clock"
is ultimately less interesting than asking one brutally simple question:
Fine.
What number does YOUR theory predict?
That question has the useful property of being completely insensitive to insults, religions, gurus, perfectly good clocks, proper clocks,
improper clocks, and hippopotamuses.
Numbers are annoyingly difficult to insult into changing.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 56:05:55 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,718 |