• compression in a roll

    From Christopher Howard@christopher@librehacker.com to sci.physics on Wed Oct 14 07:13:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics

    Hi, I was wondering: when you roll up tightly something like sheets of
    paper, toilet paper, or plastic, is there some kind of compression force
    that makes sheets toward the center of the roll thinner than sheets
    toward the outside of the roll? I was thinking about the mathematics of
    the relationship between the radius of a roll and the length and
    thickness of the roll, which I see is simple if you assume that there is uniform thickness in a tight roll. But I was wondering if the roll tends
    to compress more toward the center or if the tension of making the roll
    is even throughout and not accumulating.
    --
    Christopher Howard
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ram@ram@zedat.fu-berlin.de (Stefan Ram) to sci.physics on Wed Oct 14 15:41:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics

    Christopher Howard <christopher@librehacker.com> wrote or quoted:
    Hi, I was wondering: when you roll up tightly something like sheets of
    paper, toilet paper, or plastic, is there some kind of compression force
    that makes sheets toward the center of the roll thinner than sheets
    toward the outside of the roll?

    It seems there is more pressure near the center.

    The tension of the rolled-up layers is called "wound-in tension".

    There is a whole science of this called "web handling", "web
    winding", or "roll winding mechanics". Industrial winding machines
    do not use even tension throughout the process, to ensure the
    roll has a relatively uniform hardness and thickness throughout.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics on Wed Oct 14 22:17:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.physics

    Christopher Howard wrote:
    [...] when you roll up tightly something like sheets of
    paper, toilet paper, or plastic, is there some kind of compression
    force

    There is if there is an external force in the first place. Otherwise no.

    that makes sheets toward the center of the roll thinner than sheets
    toward the outside of the roll?

    Barely, if at all. Toilet paper being intentionally softer than other
    paper, e.g. office paper, with its surface less even and each layer
    containing more air, I-awould expect it to be better compressible than
    the latter, but not by much.

    The main factor appears to be how much air is _between_ each layer. If
    I consider (my current) toilet paper, due to the less even surface much
    more air can be (is) between the layers than e.g. with office paper, and
    so a roll of toilet paper is on the one hand thicker and on the other
    more compressible than a stack of office paper with the same number of
    layers because of that already.

    I was thinking about the mathematics of the relationship between the
    radius of a roll and the length and thickness of the roll, which I
    see is simple if you assume that there is uniform thickness in a
    tight roll. But I was wondering if the roll tends to compress more
    toward the center or if the tension of making the roll is even
    throughout and not accumulating.
    If a force is exerted on the outer layers, and all layers are not or
    barely compressible (which is the case for paper or plastic
    /perpendicular/ to its surface), then the pressure on the inner layers
    is greater because their (angular) surface area is smaller, but the
    applied force is nearly the same:

    _
    . ' ' .
    ' . ' ' . ` A(R)
    ' ' . . ` `
    . ' ' ` ` .
    ' ' . ' ' . A(r) '
    : . ' ' ' . :
    : : : : +----:--:--:--:
    : ' . r ' R
    . ' ' . . ' ' .
    ' . '. .' . '
    . ' ' ' . .
    . ` . . ' . __
    ` . _ . ' |PE


    A(R) reY R > r reY A(r) rcA p(r) = F/A(r) > F/A(R) = p(R).

    [N.B.: A(r) reY r-# does not always hold. Consider, for example,
    the formula for the lateral surface area of a cylinder.
    But A(r) reY r always holds 8-)]

    We think that this explains why the inner terrestrial core is solid
    despite the higher temperatures there than in the outer core (which is
    liquid). (The applied force there is the gravitational force.
    Additionally, it increases towards the center because the mass above a
    point in the interior increases towards the center.)

    But whether the density of a layer increases because of that pressure
    depends on the compressibility of the material which is given by

    +| = reA1reoV (reeVreoreep),

    where the partial derivative depends on whether the process is
    isothermic (probably the case here) or isentropic/adiabatic. One can
    see that (especially for solids) it can also depend on the direction in
    which the force/pressure is applied.

    <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressibility>
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2