You are at the center of your observable universe. I am at the center
of mine. An observer in a galaxy a billion lightyears away is at the
center of hers. None of these horizons coincide. You can see galaxies
she can't and vice-versa. You can see each other's galaxies, though.
Mass is a property, not a substance.
John Hasler <john@sugarbit.com> wrote or quoted:. . .
Mass is a property, not a substance.
|The radius at which a mass has an escape velocity equal to
|the speed of light is called the Schwarzschild radius.
"Black Holes - Imagine the Universe! - NASA" - NASA web page
On 25/09/2026 12:49 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/24/26 09:31, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
Old McDonald wrote in sci.physics, sci.electronics.design, sci.astro:
^^^^^^^^^^^^-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
On 9/23/26 19:40, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
Curvature is sustained as long as the mass that it wraps aroundAnd when it stops existing, or moves around, the curvature of
exists.
spacetime
changes, but it cannot change immediately everywhere.
Well, let's think about that. Mass pops into existence, it pops out of >>>> existence. I think that a "pop" happens in an instant. It may be that
curvature happens spontaneously, forcing mass to pop into existence.
All
immediate and simultaneous.
You are still not thinking clearly (and you are still amok-crossposting
to science newsgroups under a "funny" pseudonym.-a Do you even want to be >>> taken seriously here?).
The existence of an object has nothing to do with how the effects of its >>> existence propagate through space.
I claimed that the effects of mass's *movement* propagate, and the
effects of its *existence* are... I'll say static. Stable. All done,
the fabric has sags in it.
Curvature and Waves are two different things. The waves are little
ripples, which pass quickly. Do think they bring gravity with them,
and leave it behind when they're gone?
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in the
beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter of a
proton.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIGO
Curvature is notionally permanent, though since mass tends to be in
orbit around something else,-a it frequently changes with time. Waves are just more rapid changes. The moon in it's orbit around the earth
produces very low frequency gravity waves, and loses orbital speed in consequence (though very little).
On 9/24/26 23:14, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 25/09/2026 12:49 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/24/26 09:31, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
Old McDonald wrote in sci.physics, sci.electronics.design, sci.astro:
^^^^^^^^^^^^-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
On 9/23/26 19:40, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
Curvature is sustained as long as the mass that it wraps around >>>>>>> exists.And when it stops existing, or moves around, the curvature of
spacetime
changes, but it cannot change immediately everywhere.
Well, let's think about that. Mass pops into existence, it pops out of >>>>> existence. I think that a "pop" happens in an instant. It may be that >>>>> curvature happens spontaneously, forcing mass to pop into
existence. All
immediate and simultaneous.
You are still not thinking clearly (and you are still amok-crossposting >>>> to science newsgroups under a "funny" pseudonym.-a Do you even want
to be
taken seriously here?).
The existence of an object has nothing to do with how the effects of
its
existence propagate through space.
I claimed that the effects of mass's *movement* propagate, and the
effects of its *existence* are... I'll say static. Stable. All done,
the fabric has sags in it.
Curvature and Waves are two different things. The waves are little
ripples, which pass quickly. Do think they bring gravity with them,
and leave it behind when they're gone?
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the
propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in the
beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter of a
proton.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIGO
Curvature is notionally permanent, though since mass tends to be in
orbit around something else,-a it frequently changes with time. Waves
are just more rapid changes. The moon in it's orbit around the earth
produces very low frequency gravity waves, and loses orbital speed in
consequence (though very little).
Gravity doesn't travel. Waves of "gravity", traveling at the speed of
light, distort the spacetime within them, and gravity, which is already there in that spacetime, is distorted with it. I want to know, why is gravity already there?
Gravity doesn't attract mass, or anything else. Gravity repels.
Where spacetime curves, like a bubble around an object, that object, and others nearby, are repelled by the curvature toward the bubble's center, which is coincident with the objects' center of mass.
* Gravity repels.
* It's always there, as long as curvature is there.
* Curvature is there as long as mass is there.
On 28/09/2026 3:24 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/24/26 23:14, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 25/09/2026 12:49 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/24/26 09:31, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
Old McDonald wrote in sci.physics, sci.electronics.design, sci.astro: >>>>> ^^^^^^^^^^^^-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
On 9/23/26 19:40, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
Curvature is sustained as long as the mass that it wraps around >>>>>>>> exists.And when it stops existing, or moves around, the curvature of
spacetime
changes, but it cannot change immediately everywhere.
Well, let's think about that. Mass pops into existence, it pops
out of
existence. I think that a "pop" happens in an instant. It may be that >>>>>> curvature happens spontaneously, forcing mass to pop into
existence. All
immediate and simultaneous.
You are still not thinking clearly (and you are still amok-
crossposting
to science newsgroups under a "funny" pseudonym.-a Do you even want >>>>> to be
taken seriously here?).
The existence of an object has nothing to do with how the effects
of its
existence propagate through space.
I claimed that the effects of mass's *movement* propagate, and the
effects of its *existence* are... I'll say static. Stable. All done,
the fabric has sags in it.
Curvature and Waves are two different things. The waves are little
ripples, which pass quickly. Do think they bring gravity with them,
and leave it behind when they're gone?
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the
propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in the
beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter of a
proton.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIGO
Curvature is notionally permanent, though since mass tends to be in
orbit around something else,-a it frequently changes with time. Waves
are just more rapid changes. The moon in it's orbit around the earth
produces very low frequency gravity waves, and loses orbital speed in
consequence (though very little).
Gravity doesn't travel. Waves of "gravity", traveling at the speed of
light, distort the spacetime within them, and gravity, which is
already there in that spacetime, is distorted with it. I want to know,
why is gravity already there?
To parody your claim.
Electricity doesn't travel. Electromagentic waves, travelling at the
speed of light
distort the space time they pass through, and electric
charge which is already there in that spacetime, is distorted with it.
You want to know why gravity (or electric charge) is already there.
You want to learn what you are talking about, rather wasting time constructing meaningless sentences.
Gravity doesn't attract mass, or anything else. Gravity repels.
Gravity is what we call the force that draws adjacent masses towards one another. It is an attractive force
Where-a spacetime curves, like a bubble around an object, that object,
and others nearby, are repelled by the curvature toward the bubble's
center, which is coincident with the objects' center of mass.
And pigs might fly.
* Gravity repels.
Only if you redefine the word gravity is a remarkably unhelpful way.
* It's always there, as long as curvature is there.
* Curvature is there as long as mass is there.
And the usenet is full of trolls.
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in the
beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter of a proton.
On 9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:24 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/24/26 23:14, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 25/09/2026 12:49 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/24/26 09:31, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
Old McDonald wrote in sci.physics, sci.electronics.design, sci.astro: >>>>>> ^^^^^^^^^^^^-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
On 9/23/26 19:40, Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
Curvature is sustained as long as the mass that it wraps around >>>>>>>>> exists.And when it stops existing, or moves around, the curvature of >>>>>>>> spacetime
changes, but it cannot change immediately everywhere.
Well, let's think about that. Mass pops into existence, it pops >>>>>>> out of
existence. I think that a "pop" happens in an instant. It may be >>>>>>> that
curvature happens spontaneously, forcing mass to pop into
existence. All
immediate and simultaneous.
You are still not thinking clearly (and you are still amok-
crossposting
to science newsgroups under a "funny" pseudonym.-a Do you even want >>>>>> to be
taken seriously here?).
The existence of an object has nothing to do with how the effects >>>>>> of its
existence propagate through space.
I claimed that the effects of mass's *movement* propagate, and the
effects of its *existence* are... I'll say static. Stable. All
done, the fabric has sags in it.
Curvature and Waves are two different things. The waves are little
ripples, which pass quickly. Do think they bring gravity with them, >>>>> and leave it behind when they're gone?
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the
propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in
the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter
of a proton.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIGO
Curvature is notionally permanent, though since mass tends to be in
orbit around something else,-a it frequently changes with time. Waves >>>> are just more rapid changes. The moon in it's orbit around the earth
produces very low frequency gravity waves, and loses orbital speed
in consequence (though very little).
Gravity doesn't travel. Waves of "gravity", traveling at the speed of
light, distort the spacetime within them, and gravity, which is
already there in that spacetime, is distorted with it. I want to
know, why is gravity already there?
To parody your claim.
Electricity doesn't travel. Electromagentic waves, travelling at the
speed of light
At the speed of light in copper. And that's the electromotive force. Not electrons, those progress along at a snail's pace.
distort the space time they pass through, and electric charge which is
already there in that spacetime, is distorted with it.
Charge already there in the metal is... not-charge (Thanks, Larkin). Neutral.
You want to know why gravity (or electric charge) is already there.
You want to learn what you are talking about, rather wasting time
constructing meaningless sentences.
I constructed a mirror image of the mechanism that everyone else
describes, and it works just as well.
Better, in fact. I wrote that the spacetime *within* waves is distorted,
as well as gravity already there in that spacetime.
I first wrote spacetime *around* waves, but that implies there's some distance for gravity to travel. Distance outside of distorted spacetime.
And at a speed. I got rid of distance. So, no speed is necessary. I simplified the mechanism.
Gravity doesn't attract mass, or anything else. Gravity repels.
Gravity is what we call the force that draws adjacent masses towards
one another. It is an attractive force
I'm not included in that "we". You are.
--Where-a spacetime curves, like a bubble around an object, that object,
and others nearby, are repelled by the curvature toward the bubble's
center, which is coincident with the objects' center of mass.
And pigs might fly.
* Gravity repels.
Only if you redefine the word gravity is a remarkably unhelpful way.
* It's always there, as long as curvature is there.
* Curvature is there as long as mass is there.
And the usenet is full of trolls.
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the
propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in the
beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter of a
proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the effects detected by the interference pattern.
John Hasler <john@sugarbit.com> wrote or quoted:
You are at the center of your observable universe. I am at the center
of mine. An observer in a galaxy a billion lightyears away is at the
center of hers. None of these horizons coincide. You can see galaxies
she can't and vice-versa. You can see each other's galaxies, though.
And then, there is the Rindler horizon for constantly accelerating
observers. Photons following them from a certain distance can never
reach them while these observers accelerate.
ativity 105a: Acceleration - Hyperbolic Motion and Rindler Horizon"
by Eigenchris at 25 minutes and 30 seconds.
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the
propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in the
beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter of a
proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the
effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of a
small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there
that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any kind
of visible pattern.
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the
propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in
the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter
of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the
effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of a
small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any
perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there
that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any kind
of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between
the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the >>>>> propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in
the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter >>>>> of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the
effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of
a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any
perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there
that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any
kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between
the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the >>>>>> propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in >>>>>> the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter >>>>>> of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the
effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of
a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any
perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there
that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any
kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between
the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
Right, a bunch of verbiage without some kind of analytical support is a vacuum in and of itself.
Consulting AI (again):
The Schwarzschild Radius and Density: To turn any mass (\[M\]) into a
black hole, you must compress it into a sphere smaller than its event horizon, known as the Schwarzschild radius R_s. The formula is:|e-a2GM/c^2 (where G is the gravitational constant and c is the speed of light.|e-aBecause volume grows much faster than radius (\(V \proportional
to R^3\)), larger black holes actually require much less density to form than smaller ones. While a stellar-mass black hole is unimaginably
dense, a supermassive black hole can have a density lower than water. If
a black hole is large enough|ore4rCYsay, the size of the observable universe|ore4rCYits required density drops to nearly nothing.|e
The Critical Density of the Universe: Cosmologists measure the density
of the universe to see if it is "flat," meaning space isn't warped on a cosmic scale. This is called the critical density, rho _c, calculated
using the Hubble constant H:|e-arho_c=3H^2/(8.pi G). When you plug in the observed numbers for our universe, this critical density is incredibly low|ore4rCYabout 10^{-26} kg/m^3, which is equivalent to roughly six hydrogen
atoms per cubic meter of space.
The Perfect Match: If you take the radius of the observable universe
(the Hubble radius,R_H = c/H, and calculate how much total mass M is
inside it based on that critical density, an amazing mathematical cancellation happens.|e-aIf you solve for the Schwarzschild radius of that total cosmic mass, the horizon radius of the universe perfectly equals
its Schwarzschild radius R_H = R_s, making the thesis of a universe
within a universe quite remarkable.
On Tue, 29 Sep 2026 11:11:31 -0700, Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn>
wrote:
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the >>>>>>> propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in >>>>>>> the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter >>>>>>> of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the
effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of >>>>> a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any >>>>> perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there >>>>> that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any
kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between >>>> the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
Don't annoy Sloman by being right.
Or by having ideas.
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in
the propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes >>>>>> in the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the
diameter of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the
effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of
a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any
perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there
that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any
kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements
between the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
On 9/26/26 06:30, someone wrote:
Right, a bunch of verbiage without some kind of analytical support is
a vacuum in and of itself.
Consulting AI (again):
The Schwarzschild Radius and Density: To turn any mass (\[M\]) into a
black hole, you must compress it into a sphere smaller than its event
horizon, known as the Schwarzschild radius R_s. The formula
is:|e-a2GM/c^2 (where G is the gravitational constant and c is the speed
of light.|e-aBecause volume grows much faster than radius (\(V
\proportional to R^3\)), larger black holes actually require much less
density to form than smaller ones. While a stellar-mass black hole is
unimaginably dense, a supermassive black hole can have a density lower
than water. If a black hole is large enough|ore4rCYsay, the size of the
observable universe|ore4rCYits required density drops to nearly nothing.|e >>
The Critical Density of the Universe: Cosmologists measure the density
of the universe to see if it is "flat," meaning space isn't warped on
a cosmic scale. This is called the critical density, rho _c,
calculated using the Hubble constant H:|e-arho_c=3H^2/(8.pi G). When you
plug in the observed numbers for our universe, this critical density
is incredibly low|ore4rCYabout 10^{-26} kg/m^3, which is equivalent to
roughly six hydrogen atoms per cubic meter of space.
The Perfect Match: If you take the radius of the observable universe
(the Hubble radius,R_H = c/H, and calculate how much total mass M is
inside it based on that critical density, an amazing mathematical
cancellation happens.|e-aIf you solve for the Schwarzschild radius of
that total cosmic mass, the horizon radius of the universe perfectly
equals its Schwarzschild radius R_H = R_s, making the thesis of a
universe within a universe quite remarkable.
That was more satisfying.
I have two theories, one a load of verbiage with analytical support. Randomly nested Penrose tile universes could be in there.
Both will annoy Bill Sloman.
On 30/09/2026 7:35 am, john larkin wrote:
On Tue, 29 Sep 2026 11:11:31 -0700, Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn>
wrote:
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the >>>>>>>> propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in >>>>>>>> the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter >>>>>>>> of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the >>>>>>> effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of >>>>>> a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any >>>>>> perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there >>>>>> that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any
kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between >>>>> the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
Don't annoy Sloman by being right.
You won't.
Or by having ideas.
John Larkin is very attached to his "ideas". It's hard to imagine why.
He doesn't have many, and they aren't all that attractive, of the sort
only a mother could love.
On 30/09/2026 4:11 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in >>>>>>> the propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny
changes in the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of >>>>>>> the diameter of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the
effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement
of a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce >>>>> any perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on
there that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as >>>>> any kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements
between the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
Except that they don't.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
And what has LIGO got to do with a vernier caliper? Relying on false analogies may make you feel self-confident, but learning a bit about the stuff you are posting about would work better, if you had that capacity.
On 9/30/26 00:16, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 30/09/2026 4:11 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in >>>>>>>> the propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny
changes in the beam propagation distance - some small fraction >>>>>>>> of the diameter of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the >>>>>>> effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement >>>>>> of a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going
produce any perceptible "interference pattern". There's something >>>>>> going on there that can be measured, but you won't be able to
perceive it as any kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements
between the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
Except that they don't.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
And what has LIGO got to do with a vernier caliper? Relying on false
analogies may make you feel self-confident, but learning a bit about
the stuff you are posting about would work better, if you had that
capacity.
A displament of 0.001" does produce a perceptible interference pattern.
I don't have a LIGO, I have a Starrett.
On Wed, 30 Sep 2026 17:11:35 +1000, Bill Sloman <bill.sloman@ieee.org>
wrote:
On 30/09/2026 7:35 am, john larkin wrote:
On Tue, 29 Sep 2026 11:11:31 -0700, Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn>
wrote:
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the >>>>>>>>> propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in >>>>>>>>> the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter >>>>>>>>> of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the >>>>>>>> effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of >>>>>>> a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any >>>>>>> perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there >>>>>>> that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any >>>>>>> kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100
seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between >>>>>> the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
Don't annoy Sloman by being right.
You won't.
Or by having ideas.
John Larkin is very attached to his "ideas". It's hard to imagine why.
He doesn't have many, and they aren't all that attractive, of the sort
only a mother could love.
Ideas are fun and lead to products that sell.
We have a folder called Ideas, and it has, so far, about 60
sub-folders with specific ideas for products. Maybe 90% are dumb
ideas, so the challenge is to identify the 10% of decent ones for
further development. We have a process for that.
...
And what has LIGO got to do with a vernier caliper? Relying on false
analogies ...
A displament of 0.001" does produce a perceptible interference pattern.
The diameter of a proton is rather smaller than that.
...
I don't have a LIGO, I have a Starrett.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L._S._Starrett_Company
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIGO
The Starrett Company won't sell you a Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO). The Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory may be a measuring tool, but it is a
rather specialised one.
On 1/10/2026 12:46 am, john larkin wrote:
On Wed, 30 Sep 2026 17:11:35 +1000, Bill Sloman <bill.sloman@ieee.org>
wrote:
On 30/09/2026 7:35 am, john larkin wrote:
On Tue, 29 Sep 2026 11:11:31 -0700, Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn>
wrote:
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the >>>>>>>>>> propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in >>>>>>>>>> the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter >>>>>>>>>> of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the >>>>>>>>> effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of >>>>>>>> a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any >>>>>>>> perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there >>>>>>>> that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any >>>>>>>> kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100 >>>>>>> seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between >>>>>>> the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
Don't annoy Sloman by being right.
You won't.
Or by having ideas.
John Larkin is very attached to his "ideas". It's hard to imagine why.
He doesn't have many, and they aren't all that attractive, of the sort
only a mother could love.
Ideas are fun and lead to products that sell.
But not all that well. You don't serve any kind of mass market.
We have a folder called Ideas, and it has, so far, about 60
sub-folders with specific ideas for products. Maybe 90% are dumb
ideas, so the challenge is to identify the 10% of decent ones for
further development. We have a process for that.
It's called "cold calling". There's no idea so dumb that some customer
won't fall for it. The art is in finding ideas that look good to lots of >people. Hewlett and Packard looked as if they had mastered it for
while, but they don't seem to have been able to pass it on to their >successors.
Tom Peters wrote a book called
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Search_of_Excellence
which looked at a number of companies which were doing well at the time
the booked was written - it was published in 1982 - and supports the
idea that while everybody knows what a lucky company looks like, nobody
can pick out a well-managed company that is still going to look
well-managed a few years later.
Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn> wrote or quoted:
Curvature is geometry, it has no mass.
Gravity waves have mass.
Stefan Ram wrote:
Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn> wrote or quoted:
Curvature is geometry, it has no mass.
Gravity waves have mass.
Just when one thought that your claims could not get more stupid,
you come and prove the opposite.
Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn> wrote or quoted:
Curvature is geometry, it has no mass.
Gravity waves have mass.
Imagine a pair of black holes. The pair has momentum p and mass m.
We choose a reference frame where p=0. So the whole energy of the
pair now is mass, E=m in units with c=1.
Now the pair emits gravity waves.
As momentum is conserved, the momentum p of the system holes+wavesLogical fallacy: Assuming that {A raA B} raA {B raA A}. [It does not: A raA B =
still is 0, so E=m is still valid. E is conserved, and when E=m, mass
is conserved.
As the mass of the holes is reduced,
the rest of the mass now is mass of the waves, mass of the curvatureUtter nonsense. That is NOT mass. Gravitational waves, like all waves, transfer and thus "have" _energy_, NOT mass.
if you like.
That's why gravitons are deemed to be self-interacting.
Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn> wrote or quoted:
Curvature is geometry, it has no mass.
Gravity waves have mass.
Imagine a pair of black holes. The pair has momentum p and mass m.
We choose a reference frame where p=0. So the whole energy of the
pair now is mass, E=m in units with c=1.
Now the pair emits gravity waves.
As momentum is conserved, the momentum p of the system holes+waves
still is 0, so E=m is still valid. E is conserved, and when E=m, mass
is conserved.
As the mass of the holes is reduced,
the rest of the mass now is mass of the waves, mass of the curvature
if you like.
That's why gravitons are deemed to be self-interacting.
On 2/10/2026 12:33 am, john larkin wrote:
On Thu, 1 Oct 2026 15:49:38 +1000, Bill Sloman <bill.sloman@ieee.org>
wrote:
On 1/10/2026 12:46 am, john larkin wrote:
On Wed, 30 Sep 2026 17:11:35 +1000, Bill Sloman <bill.sloman@ieee.org> >>>> wrote:
On 30/09/2026 7:35 am, john larkin wrote:
On Tue, 29 Sep 2026 11:11:31 -0700, Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn> >>>>>> wrote:
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the
propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in >>>>>>>>>>>> the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter
of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the >>>>>>>>>>> effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of >>>>>>>>>> a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any >>>>>>>>>> perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there >>>>>>>>>> that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any >>>>>>>>>> kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100 >>>>>>>>> seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between
the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
Don't annoy Sloman by being right.
You won't.
Or by having ideas.
John Larkin is very attached to his "ideas". It's hard to imagine why. >>>>> He doesn't have many, and they aren't all that attractive, of the sort >>>>> only a mother could love.
Ideas are fun and lead to products that sell.
But not all that well. You don't serve any kind of mass market.
A small company that designs and manufactures in San Francisco can't
serve a high-volume low-margin market. I don't want to.
We have a folder called Ideas, and it has, so far, about 60
sub-folders with specific ideas for products. Maybe 90% are dumb
ideas, so the challenge is to identify the 10% of decent ones for
further development. We have a process for that.
It's called "cold calling". There's no idea so dumb that some customer
won't fall for it. The art is in finding ideas that look good to lots of >>> people. Hewlett and Packard looked as if they had mastered it for
while, but they don't seem to have been able to pass it on to their
successors.
Most of our business has come from people cold-calling US.
I'm sure you like to think that.
Tom Peters wrote a book called
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Search_of_Excellence
which looked at a number of companies which were doing well at the time
the booked was written - it was published in 1982 - and supports the
idea that while everybody knows what a lucky company looks like, nobody
can pick out a well-managed company that is still going to look
well-managed a few years later.
HP did great as long as it was a technology-driven company that had
ideas. What wrecked it was a pants-suited business type who didn't
understand that.
You understand what a lucky company looks like, and think you know what >makes them lucky.
Stefan Ram wrote:
Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn> wrote or quoted:
Curvature is geometry, it has no mass.
Gravity waves have mass.
Just when one thought that your claims could not get more stupid,
you come and prove the opposite.
Imagine a pair of black holes. The pair has momentum p and mass m.
That mass is only a convenient way to express their rest energy. There
is no meaning of matter attached to it.
We choose a reference frame where p=0. So the whole energy of the
pair now is mass, E=m in units with c=1.
Yes.
Now the pair emits gravity waves.
No, _gravitational waves_, a different phenomenon. Compare:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_wave>
vs.
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_wave>
As momentum is conserved, the momentum p of the system holes+waves
still is 0, so E=m is still valid. E is conserved, and when E=m, mass
is conserved.
Logical fallacy: Assuming that {A raA B} raA {B raA A}. [It does not: A raA B =
-4A re? B, whereas B raA A = -4B re? A.]
What is conserved instead is not energy and momentum separately, and certainly NOT mass (as I showed before), but the total energy-momentum E-#reoc-# reA p^2.
"E = m c-#" is poorly written (and found only in pop-science); EreC = m c-# does NOT mean that an object which has energy also has non-zero mass; it means that an object which has non-zero mass has non-zero energy even at relative rest: rest energy EreC.
As the mass of the holes is reduced,
It is not. What happens is that the black hole that is the result of
the merger of the two black holes (progenitors) has a "mass" that is
smaller than the sum of the "masses" of the progenitors. So that "mass"
has to be _equivalent_ to the _energy_ transferred out of the system in
the form of gravitational waves.
the rest of the mass now is mass of the waves, mass of the curvature
if you like.
Utter nonsense. That is NOT mass. Gravitational waves, like all waves, transfer and thus "have" _energy_, NOT mass.
That's why gravitons are deemed to be self-interacting.
Nonsense. And gravitons need to have mass _zero_. Otherwise
gravitational waves would not propagate at c, contrary to what has been observed: the Euclidean distance between LIGO Livingston and LIGO
Hanford is ca. 3000-akm, and it took ca. 10 ms for GW150914 to propagate
from the former to the latter; so its phase speed was approximately
300'000 km/s ree c =-a299'792'458-am/s.
The speed v of an object in Minkowski space is given through the energyrComomentum relation for a free particle:
E-# = m-#crU| + p-#c-# = +|(v)-# m-#crU|,
whereas the latter holds if m rea 0, as
+|(v) = 1reoreU(1 reA v-#reoc-#),
p = +|(v) m v.
So we find the speedrComass relation
v = c reU(1 reA m-#crU|reoE-#).
Then if m is a real value, v < c if m > 0.
So the only way for an object or phenomenon to propagate at c in
Minkowski space is that its (equivalent) mass is m = 0, and even curved spacetime is locally equivalent to Minkowski space (which is why special relativity works even for the LHC, under the influence of gravitation).
So not only is mass not a property of a wave to begin with, thus the statement "[gravitational waves] have mass" is nonsense; but gravitons _cannot_ have non-zero mass (despite their purported self-interaction).
On Thu, 1 Oct 2026 15:49:38 +1000, Bill Sloman <bill.sloman@ieee.org>
wrote:
On 1/10/2026 12:46 am, john larkin wrote:
On Wed, 30 Sep 2026 17:11:35 +1000, Bill Sloman <bill.sloman@ieee.org>
wrote:
On 30/09/2026 7:35 am, john larkin wrote:
On Tue, 29 Sep 2026 11:11:31 -0700, Old McDonald <eieio@patch.corn>
wrote:
On 9/29/26 00:06, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 29/09/2026 5:14 am, Old McDonald wrote:
On 9/27/26 23:34, Bill Sloman wrote:
On 28/09/2026 3:29 pm, Old McDonald wrote:
9/27/26 19:25, Bill Sloman needs some extra help:
You can't observe gravity, only its effects.
Gravity waves are detected by they interference they produce in the >>>>>>>>>>> propagation of laser beams. The system can detect tiny changes in >>>>>>>>>>> the beam propagation distance - some small fraction of the diameter >>>>>>>>>>> of a proton.
Waves of spacetime distortion, not waves of gravity, produce the >>>>>>>>>> effects detected by the interference pattern.
Nobody calls gravity waves "waves of gravity". And a displacement of >>>>>>>>> a small fraction of the diameter of a proton isn't going produce any >>>>>>>>> perceptible "interference pattern". There's something going on there >>>>>>>>> that can be measured, but you won't be able to perceive it as any >>>>>>>>> kind of visible pattern.
But "a displacement" is many displacements. Some waves lasted 100 >>>>>>>> seconds. The laser bounced between mirrors while displacements between >>>>>>>> the waves leading edge and its trailing edge added up.
So you haven't got a clue what you are talking about?
Of course I have one! I described a vernier caliper.
Don't annoy Sloman by being right.
You won't.
Or by having ideas.
John Larkin is very attached to his "ideas". It's hard to imagine why. >>>> He doesn't have many, and they aren't all that attractive, of the sort >>>> only a mother could love.
Ideas are fun and lead to products that sell.
But not all that well. You don't serve any kind of mass market.
A small company that designs and manufactures in San Francisco can't
serve a high-volume low-margin market. I don't want to.
We have a folder called Ideas, and it has, so far, about 60
sub-folders with specific ideas for products. Maybe 90% are dumb
ideas, so the challenge is to identify the 10% of decent ones for
further development. We have a process for that.
It's called "cold calling". There's no idea so dumb that some customer
won't fall for it. The art is in finding ideas that look good to lots of
people. Hewlett and Packard looked as if they had mastered it for
while, but they don't seem to have been able to pass it on to their
successors.
Most of our business has come from people cold-calling US.
Tom Peters wrote a book called
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Search_of_Excellence
which looked at a number of companies which were doing well at the time
the booked was written - it was published in 1982 - and supports the
idea that while everybody knows what a lucky company looks like, nobody
can pick out a well-managed company that is still going to look
well-managed a few years later.
HP did great as long as it was a technology-driven company that had
ideas. What wrecked it was a pants-suited business type who didn't
understand that.
No, _gravitational waves_, a different phenomenon. Compare:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_wave>
vs.
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_wave>
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 54:33:38 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,563 |