• Re: Newton's gravity

    From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 19 01:28:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Luke Adodurov":
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
    The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Savoy
    Dudnakov":
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
    e 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Dinanath
    Bakuroff":
    HenryWilson wrote:
    On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 07:47:30 -0000 (UTC), Phillup Tsarakov wrote:
    [...] Why would an object accelerate in free fall if it didn't have >>>>>> a force on it?
    [...] not even knowing the kindergarten basics. Forces has nothing to >>>>> do with acceleration, cretin
    Apropos basics: Does

    F = m a
    that has nothing to do with the acceleration, [hysterical fit]
    :-D
    "F" means "force". "m" means "mass". What might "a" mean? Hmmm. :-D

    that's relating everything to anything,

    No.

    correleated in this universe,

    Word salad.

    [...] but has nothing to do with acceleration.

    :-D

    "a" _means_ "acceleration" there.

    Write down the definition of acceleration,

    Acceleration is the change of velocity per unit time.

    [...] irrelevant fritzkarte [...]

    Do you even know what a Fritz!Card /is/?

    <https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/AVM_Fritz!Card>

    [...] under a wheel of a train, where the acceleration is zero,

    Word salad.

    and see what force you got

    The acceleration of a train is not always zero. It starts at a train
    station at velocity zero, then its velocity changes to a non-zero value;
    that is when a force is applied by the engines, so the acceleration is non-zero.

    When it is in motion, if there were no friction, another force would no
    longer need to be applied to keep its velocity constant. But there is friction, and so a force still needs to be applied to keep its velocity constant.

    If there were no friction, a force would need to be applied to reduce
    its velocity. But there is friction, so a force would not need to be
    applied for that. However, that would take too long for it to come to a
    halt, and it would be uncontrolled braking. So a force is additionally applied, controlled friction by using the brakes; the acceleration is
    non-zero again, and the velocity is reduced, until it becomes zero again
    at the next train station.

    When it has come to a stop, its velocity is zero, and a force no longer
    needs to be applied to keep it at rest. In addition there is static
    friction. Then its velocity remains zero, and its acceleration is zero,
    too. Until it is about to leave the station where all of this starts
    all over again.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Joda Balakhontsev@noj@bhvbov.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 19 14:09:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    that's relating everything to anything,

    No.

    correleated in this universe,

    Word salad.

    [...] but has nothing to do with acceleration.

    :-D

    "a" _means_ "acceleration" there.

    that's a correlation, you puerile braindead cretin, made to define the
    unit named Newton

    Write down the definition of acceleration,

    Acceleration is the change of velocity per unit time.

    finaly this half german inbreed imbecile realized that there is no force
    there

    [...] irrelevant fritzkarte [...]

    Do you even know what a Fritz!Card /is/?

    <https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/AVM_Fritz!Card>

    [...] under a wheel of a train, where the acceleration is zero,

    Word salad.

    and see what force you got

    The acceleration of a train is not always zero.

    it is when it stops on your foot, cretin; go fuck yourself somewhere else,
    you repulsive sack of putrid subhuman excrement; i bet you didnt even
    passed the elementary
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.math,sci.physics.relativity on Mon Oct 19 21:41:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Joda Balakhontsev":
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
    "a" _means_ "acceleration" there.

    that's a correlation, [...] made to define the
    unit named Newton

    Pseudoscientific word salad. Once again: In F = m a, "a" is the symbol
    for the physical quantity "acceleration".

    Write down the definition of acceleration,
    Acceleration is the change of velocity per unit time.

    [so] there is no force there

    "F" _means_ force. The equation means: The force (F) is proportional to
    the acceleration (a), and the proportionality constant is mass (m).

    Since this is also posted to sci.physics.relativity, it should be noted
    that the correct relation is F = +|(v)-| m a, where +|(v) = 1reoreU(1 reA v-#reoc-#).
    If v-are--ac, then +|(v) ree 1 and F ree m a.

    and see what force you got

    The acceleration of a train is not always zero.

    it is when it stops on your foot, cretin;

    Especially when it stops its acceleration is NOT zero, because
    acceleration is the change of velocity per unit time, and when
    it stops, its velocity changes from non-zero to zero.
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Faustino Vedev@nsfdioi@vv.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 19 20:41:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    "a" _means_ "acceleration" there.

    that's a correlation, [...] made to define the unit named Newton

    Pseudoscientific word salad. Once again: In F = m a, "a" is the symbol
    for the physical quantity "acceleration".

    eat shit and fuck off, you putrid illiterate uneducated cretin

    that correlation assigns 1N to 1kg * 1m / 1s^2

    it has nothing with the acceleration used as correlation, you stinking
    sack of inbreed half german illiterate braindead putrid excrement
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jett Baklanov@vjaekn@ene.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 11:44:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.

    idiot

    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 11:45:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Le 23/10/2026 |a 13:44, Jett Baklanov a |-crit :
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.

    idiot

    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.

    Jett,

    idiot

    dx(s, t)/dy = reex/rees ds/dy + reex/reet dt/dy.

    You have "corrected"

    A + B

    into

    B + A.

    This is indeed a devastating application of the commutative law of
    addition.

    Mathematics may never recover.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brentley Babuh@au@bbe.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 12:07:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Python wrote:

    Le 23/10/2026 |a 13:44, Jett Baklanov a |-crit :
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.

    idiot

    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.

    Jett,

    idiot

    dx(s, t)/dy = reex/rees ds/dy + reex/reet dt/dy.

    You have "corrected"

    A + B

    into

    B + A.

    no, he did it, read correctly, as you seemingly cannot, which is a shame,
    at your age
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 14:14:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
    clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved space is the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 14:17:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
    clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
    space is
    the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?

    And why Ministry of Love of 1984
    inflicts (wiki) "misery, fear, suffering, and torture"?

    Because mad, brainwashing ideologies are using
    misnaming as a common practice; The Shit
    of Einstein is not an exception.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 14:33:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 23.10.2026 14:17, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
    clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
    space is
    the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?

    Since you are responding it must be because
    you will try to answer the question.

    So what is your answer?

    <snip incoherent babble>
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 14:34:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/23/2026 2:33 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 14:17, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
    clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
    space is
    the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?

    Since you are responding it must be because
    you will try to answer the question.

    So what is your answer?

    You've cut it off, but it was there.
    No problem, I will repeat.

    Because mad, brainwashing ideologies are using
    misnaming as a common practice; The Shit
    of Einstein is not an exception.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 14:45:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 23.10.2026 14:34, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:33 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 14:17, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is >>>>> clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
    space is
    the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?

    Since you are responding it must be because
    you will try to answer the question.

    So what is your answer?

    OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.

    You probably don't even know what an accelerometer is.

    :-D


    <snip incoherent babble>
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 15:37:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/23/2026 2:45 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 14:34, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:33 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 14:17, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is >>>>>> clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved >>>>>> space is
    the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?

    Since you are responding it must be because
    you will try to answer the question.

    So what is your answer?

    OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.

    A lie, of course, as expected from
    a piece of relativistic shit. The
    answer was written clearly and 2 times.

    Though, after consideration - maybe it's
    not a lie, you may be really too dumb to
    notice.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 19:46:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 23.10.2026 15:37, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:45 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?

    OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.

    A lie, of course, as expected from
    a piece of relativistic shit. The
    answer was written clearly and 2 times.

    OK. According to Maciej Wo+|niak:
    An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration
    is zero because mad, brainwashing ideologies are using
    misnaming as a common practice; The Shit of Einstein is
    not an exception.

    I take your clear answer to mean that an accelerometer
    is shit of Einstein that does not show the correct acceleration.


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 20:00:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 15:37, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:45 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?

    OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.

    A lie, of course, as expected from
    a piece of relativistic shit. The
    answer was written clearly and 2 times.

    OK. According to Maciej Wo+|niak:
    An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration
    is zero because mad, brainwashing-a ideologies are using
    misnaming as a common practice; The Shit of Einstein is
    not an exception.

    I take your clear answer to mean that an accelerometer
    is shit of Einstein that does not show the correct acceleration.


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others). Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 18:56:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 14:14:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
    clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved space
    is the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that the acceleration is
    zero?

    HAHAHAHAHAAHA! How can I give up this NG when I get so many laughs? Let's rename it 'sci.physics.comedy'

    Paul, our expert radio engineer, does not even know that free falling
    radar can register d2y/dt^2 as well as dy/dt. He thinks that a massive
    force accelerates the Earth towards a skydiver at g.

    Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 21:50:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis - the vertical axis
    Roll axis - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.

    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 22:15:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.

    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 21:25:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Le 23/10/2026 |a 20:00, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 15:37, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 2:45 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?

    OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.

    A lie, of course, as expected from
    a piece of relativistic shit. The
    answer was written clearly and 2 times.

    OK. According to Maciej Wo+|niak:
    An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration
    is zero because mad, brainwashing-a ideologies are using
    misnaming as a common practice; The Shit of Einstein is
    not an exception.

    I take your clear answer to mean that an accelerometer
    is shit of Einstein that does not show the correct acceleration.


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Others :-D ? Who ?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 23 21:48:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ralph,

    free falling radar can register d2y/dt^2

    Yes.

    And the accelerometer falling with it reads:

    0

    Radar measures acceleration relative to the Earth.
    An accelerometer measures proper acceleration.

    Different quantities.

    Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.

    Excellent.

    Then detect it with the accelerometer.

    Oops.

    HAHAHAHAHAAHA, indeed.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 07:05:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/23/2026 11:48 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    free falling radar can register d2y/dt^2

    Yes.

    And the accelerometer falling with it reads:

    -a-a 0

    If it does - it's junk, same as your
    perfect differently clocks, poor piece
    of shit.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 09:02:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Excellent.

    So an accelerometer is "junk" precisely when it correctly measures
    proper acceleration.

    A free-falling accelerometer reads zero.
    One sitting on your desk reads about 1 g.

    This is experimentally routine.

    Your physics has now become wonderfully simple:

    instrument disagrees with Maciej -> junk

    Very robust theory. Completely immune to measurement.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 11:39:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 11:02 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Excellent.

    So an accelerometer is "junk" precisely when it correctly measures
    proper acceleration.

    Wiki:
    In physics, acceleration is a measure of how fast and in what direction
    an object's speed and direction of motion are changing. It is defined as
    the rate of change of the velocity. Like velocity, acceleration has a magnitude and a direction, making it a vector quantity.[1][2] The SI
    unit for acceleration is metre per second squared (mriasreA2, m/s2).

    do you and your moronic religion accepts
    this definition, poor piece of shit?

    No, sorry, your junk may "confirm" what the idiot
    mumbled, but it doesn't measure any acceleration.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 09:44:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:

    a = dv/dt.

    And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.

    They are not the same quantity.

    In free fall:

    coordinate acceleration relative to Earth: about g
    proper acceleration: 0

    Standing on Earth:

    coordinate acceleration: 0
    proper acceleration: about g

    This distinction is elementary mechanics, not "religion".

    Your Wikipedia quote doesn't say that an accelerometer measures dv/dt.

    You just assumed it.

    So now your argument is:

    "An accelerometer doesn't measure acceleration!"

    because you have only just discovered that "acceleration" has more than
    one precise meaning in physics.

    Excellent progress.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 11:51:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:

    -a-a a = dv/dt.

    And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.

    No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
    sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
    be proper sharks.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 10:29:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:

    -a-a a = dv/dt.

    And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.

    No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
    sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
    be proper sharks.

    Maciej,

    This doesn't even require Einstein.

    A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.

    Why?

    Because its case and its test mass are both falling with the same
    gravitational acceleration. There is no relative deflection.

    Put the same accelerometer on the ground and it reads about 1 g,
    because the ground supports the case while the test mass tends to fall.

    Newton could understand this.

    No curved spacetime.
    No "mad religion".
    No "proper sharks".

    Just elementary mechanics.

    You have somehow managed to turn an accelerometer into an
    Einsteinian conspiracy because you don't understand what the
    instrument actually measures.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 12:45:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 12:29 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:

    -a-a-a a = dv/dt.

    And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.

    No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
    sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
    be proper sharks.

    Maciej,

    This doesn't even require Einstein.

    A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.

    Why?

    For the same reason that Orwell's Ministry of
    Love kidnaps, tortures and kills.
    Because misnaming is a common practice in
    mad, brainwashing ideologies, and The Shit
    of Einstein is no way an exception.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 11:09:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Le 24/10/2026 |a 12:45, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/24/2026 12:29 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:

    -a-a-a a = dv/dt.

    And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.

    No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
    sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
    be proper sharks.

    Maciej,

    This doesn't even require Einstein.

    A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.

    Why?

    For the same reason that Orwell's Ministry of
    Love kidnaps, tortures and kills.
    Because misnaming is a common practice in
    mad, brainwashing ideologies, and The Shit
    of Einstein is no way an exception.

    This is beyond parody.

    The accelerometer contains a test mass.

    resting on Earth:
    case is supported, test mass tends to fall -> deflection

    freely falling:
    case and test mass fall together -> no deflection

    That's how the instrument physically works.

    No Einstein.
    No relativity.
    No terminology.
    No Ministry of Love.

    Just mechanics.

    You are now accusing a spring and a test mass of ideological
    brainwashing.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 13:25:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 1:09 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 24/10/2026 |a 12:45, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/24/2026 12:29 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:

    -a-a-a a = dv/dt.

    And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.

    No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
    sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
    be proper sharks.

    Maciej,

    This doesn't even require Einstein.

    A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.

    Why?

    For the same reason that Orwell's Ministry of
    Love kidnaps, tortures and kills.
    Because misnaming is a common practice in
    mad, brainwashing ideologies, and The Shit
    of Einstein is no way an exception.

    This is beyond parody.

    The accelerometer contains a test mass.

    And, usually, measures no acceleration. It became
    "accelerometer" only for the sake of "confirming"
    that mad mumble of your mad guru.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 13:58:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.


    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
    does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.

    So I take your answer to the question:
    "Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?"
    as "yes".

    You have now realized that accelerometers measure acceleration
    correctly. Or haven't you? :-D

    You are free to call me a lying shit or whatever you will fancy
    if that make you feel better.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 15:55:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use? >>>>
    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.


    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
    does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.


    Neither the fact that when a plane is
    standing still in airport - the output
    of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 08:04:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:
    On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use? >>>>>
    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.


    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
    does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.


    Neither the fact that when a plane is
    standing still in airport - the output
    of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.


    Call me a stupid idiot and talk about how I don't know which way sharks
    swim.
    --
    Can you strip away so we may start again?
    "ThererCOs a switch and they don't
    seem authentic or themselves. It
    feels like IrCOm an unnecessary
    body and itrCOs a waste of time to
    even be there." -- Grim, playful Blaine.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 16:17:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 4:04 PM, Blaine wrote:
    Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:
    On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc., >>>>>>> has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems >>>>>>> use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.


    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
    does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.


    Neither the fact that when a plane is
    standing still in airport - the output
    of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.


    Call me a stupid idiot and talk about how I don't know which way sharks swim.


    You're a stupid idiot, sure. As for your second
    request, however - I'm too lazy.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 14:38:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    And, usually, measures no acceleration.

    It measures the force on its test mass relative to its case.

    That is what accelerometers physically do.

    Put it on a table:

    reading: about 1 g

    Drop it:

    reading: about 0 g

    This worked before Einstein was born and follows perfectly well from
    Newtonian mechanics.

    It became "accelerometer" only for the sake of "confirming"
    that mad mumble of your mad guru.

    Sure.

    Apparently sometime after 1905 Einstein's followers secretly redesigned
    springs so they would stop stretching during free fall.

    Maciej, you're arguing with a mass on a spring.

    And losing.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 16:37:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sat, 24 Oct 2026 13:25:35 +0200, Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 10/24/2026 1:09 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 24/10/2026 |a 12:45, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/24/2026 12:29 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:

    -a-a-a a = dv/dt.

    And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.

    No surprise, since an insane crazie announced sharks to eat grass -
    ordinary sharks can no longer be proper sharks.

    Maciej,

    This doesn't even require Einstein.

    A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.

    Why?

    For the same reason that Orwell's Ministry of Love kidnaps, tortures
    and kills.
    Because misnaming is a common practice in mad, brainwashing
    ideologies, and The Shit of Einstein is no way an exception.

    This is beyond parody.

    The accelerometer contains a test mass.

    And, usually, measures no acceleration. It became "accelerometer" only
    for the sake of "confirming"
    that mad mumble of your mad guru.

    Marcel, Einstein worshippers do not understand basic physics. They think
    the only form of accelerometer is a mass hanging on a spring. When such an apparatus sits on a table, the spring extends because gravity exerts a downward FORCE on the mass, g. The top end of the spring cannot move..and
    so there is tension in the spring. ..but in free fall, the top can
    move...so the tension disappears. As you point out, the accelerometer correctly reads force = 1g when sitting on the ground and NOT accelerating...so it actually DOES measure acceleration in free fall.
    Having been relieved of tension due to gravity, the spring contracts, indicating that both ends of the spring are accelerating at g.
    A spring accelerometer will also work perfectly well in a plane or car
    vehicle moving horizontally. It will detect earthquakes and gravitational waves as a temporary oscillation of the mass. But the only accurate way to measure acceleration is with radar.and even then the target has to be
    assumed to be inertial. . ...
    Python's reference to 'proper acceleration' illustrates his complete misunderstanding of this topic.

    Here's a question. If a spring accelerometer is dropped from stationary platform at say GPS height, (~ g/16) the spring immediately
    contracts...but does it extend slightly as it falls because of the gravity gradient? Yes it will, very slightly because there is always more
    downward force on the bottom end than the top....and the gradient increases...(Consider a spring 1000 metres long) So not only will a
    falling accelerometer indicate initial acceleration, it should also also measure gravity gradient if sufficiently sensitive. Integrated over time
    that small extension will add up to g at ground level.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 18:45:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 4:38 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    And, usually, measures no acceleration.

    It measures the force on its test mass relative to its case.


    And, usually, no acceleration.
    It became "accelerometer" just because
    The Shit needed "confirmations". It has no
    more in common with accelerations that
    Ministry of Love with love.

    Same thing was with your "proper"
    clocks and "proper" time.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 16:57:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    It has no more in common with accelerations that
    Ministry of Love with love.

    Then explain this without Einstein:

    accelerometer on table: 1 g
    same accelerometer dropped: 0 g

    Newtonian mechanics explains it immediately.

    On the table, the case is supported while its test mass is acted on by
    gravity.

    In free fall, case and test mass accelerate together, so there is no
    relative deflection.

    This was true before Einstein was born.

    Calling the instrument "not an accelerometer" changes none of it.

    You've now reached the wonderful position that whenever a measuring
    instrument doesn't measure the quantity you thought it measured, the
    instrument was named by an Einsteinian conspiracy.

    Yesterday: clocks.

    Today: accelerometers.

    At this rate, by Sunday the voltmeter will be part of the cult.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 19:21:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 6:57 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    It has no more in common with accelerations that
    Ministry of Love with love.

    Then explain this without Einstein:

    -a-a accelerometer on table:-a 1 g
    -a-a same accelerometer dropped: 0 g

    Newtonian mechanics explains it immediately.

    It does - the values 1g on the table,
    0 during freefall are NOT any acceleration,
    none of them.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 19:32:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 14:14:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
    clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved space
    is the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that the acceleration is
    zero?

    HAHAHAHAHAAHA! How can I give up this NG when I get so many laughs? Let's rename it 'sci.physics.comedy'

    Paul, our expert radio engineer, does not even know that free falling
    radar can register d2y/dt^2 as well as dy/dt.

    A free falling radar can only measure the acceleration of
    the y-coordinate in its own rest frame. So it will measure
    its own coordinate acceleration to be zero, of course.
    y = 0, dy/dt = 0, d-#y/dt-#.

    But it can measure the coordinate acceleration of the Earth
    (or other objects) in its rest frame.

    If the radar is stationary on Earth, it can measure a free falling
    object's coordinate acceleration in Earth's rest frame.
    If the radar is on the moon, it can measure the same free
    falling object's coordinate acceleration in the moon's rest frame.
    The two coordinate accelerations are not equal.

    He thinks that a massive
    force accelerates the Earth towards a skydiver at g.

    Paul thinks that an object can have several different
    coordinate accelerations depending on in which coordinate
    system the coordinate acceleration is measured.

    Did you really not know that, Ralph? :-D

    -----------

    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    a = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m.

    This acceleration is what we call the object's proper
    acceleration. An object has but one proper acceleration.

    An accelerometer is in principle a body with known mass
    fixed to the casing via a spring. When the casing is
    accelerated by a force, the casing will via the spring
    make the body accelerate along with the casing.
    The acceleration of the body is now a = F/m where
    m is the body's known mass, and F is the force the spring
    exert on the body. The compression of the spring is measured
    and a = F/m.
    (The "spring" may be a piezoelectric crystal so
    the output of the accelerometer is a voltage.)

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
    definition.


    Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.

    Right!
    Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by
    an accelerometer.
    An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration
    is zero because the proper acceleration is zero.
    Even no acceleration is measurable.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 20:23:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
    has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use? >>>>>
    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.


    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
    does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.


    Neither the fact that when a plane is
    standing still in airport - the output
    of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.

    Give it up, Maciej.
    It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground
    show that the acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.
    (The exact value will depend on the latitude.)

    And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration
    or inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.

    ---------------

    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    a = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m
    and a is the acceleration of the object.

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
    definition.

    Think of this, Maciej:

    Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.

    You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts
    an upwards force on you, F = 786 N.

    According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
    a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.

    Do you claim that Newton is wrong?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 21:04:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 8:23 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc., >>>>>>> has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems >>>>>>> use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.


    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
    does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.


    Neither the fact that when a plane is
    standing still in airport - the output
    of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.

    Give it up, Maciej.
    It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground
    show that the acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.

    Give it up, poor piece of shit - no it is not.


    (The exact value will depend on the latitude.)

    And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration
    or inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.

    ---------------

    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    -aa = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m
    and a is the acceleration of the object.

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
    definition.

    Even such an ignorant idiot should know that
    the acceleration of Newton's definition is
    not 0 for a free falling object. But he doesn't
    know, and what can I do.
    Anyway, it is not, what your toy measures
    is not any acceleration. The Shit has lied
    to you.











    Think of this, Maciej:

    Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.

    You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts
    an upwards force on you, F = 786 N.

    According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
    a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.

    Do you claim that Newton is wrong?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 20:39:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    the values 1g on the table,
    0 during freefall are NOT any acceleration,
    none of them.

    Fine. Then forget the word "accelerometer".

    Take a box containing a mass attached to a spring.

    On the table:

    spring deflection corresponds to 1 g

    Drop the box:

    spring deflection becomes 0

    Newtonian mechanics predicts both results perfectly.

    No Einstein is required.

    The device measures the acceleration of its case relative to a freely
    falling test mass. Modern terminology calls that proper acceleration.

    You can dislike the terminology and call the measured quantity Fred.

    Nothing changes physically:

    box supported: Fred = 1 g
    box in free fall: Fred = 0

    So your Orwell analogy explains precisely nothing.

    The distinction exists in the mechanics independently of what word is
    printed on the instrument.

    You're not disputing the measurement anymore.

    You're arguing with the label on the box.

    Which, come to think of it, seems to be one of your favorite activities:

    proper time
    ideal clock
    time dilation
    accelerometer
    proper acceleration

    Whenever the physics becomes inconvenient, declare the terminology
    fraudulent and start fighting the label instead.

    The spring and clocks remain unimpressed.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 20:41:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    For once, there is a point here on which you are right.

    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    coordinate acceleration = g downward

    Paul's statement

    F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    gravity: 786 N downward
    scale: 786 N upward
    net force: 0
    Newtonian a: 0

    The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.

    Drop it:

    Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
    accelerometer reading: about 0

    And none of this requires Einstein.

    The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
    (or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
    to the Earth.

    So yes: if somebody says an accelerometer directly measures Newton's
    coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# in a gravitational field, that is
    wrong.

    But your conclusion

    "therefore it measures no acceleration"

    doesn't follow.

    It measures a different, perfectly well-defined physical quantity,
    which is precisely why inertial navigation can use it.

    You seem remarkably fond of arguments about labels:

    "That's not acceleration!"
    "That's not time!"
    "That's not a proper clock!"

    Fine. Call the accelerometer output Fred again.

    sitting on runway: Fred ree 1 g
    free fall: Fred ree 0

    The aircraft's navigation system does not care what Maciej permits us
    to call Fred.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 22:47:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 01:41 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    For once, there is a point here on which you are right.

    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    coordinate acceleration = g downward

    Paul's statement

    F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    gravity: 786 N downward
    scale: 786 N upward
    net force: 0
    Newtonian a: 0

    The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.

    Drop it:

    Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
    accelerometer reading: about 0

    And none of this requires Einstein.

    The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
    (or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
    to the Earth.

    So yes: if somebody says an accelerometer directly measures Newton's coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# in a gravitational field, that is
    wrong.

    But your conclusion

    "therefore it measures no acceleration"

    doesn't follow.

    It measures a different, perfectly well-defined physical quantity,
    which is precisely why inertial navigation can use it.

    You seem remarkably fond of arguments about labels:

    "That's not acceleration!"
    "That's not time!"
    "That's not a proper clock!"

    Fine. Call the accelerometer output Fred again.

    sitting on runway: Fred ree 1 g
    free fall: Fred ree 0

    The aircraft's navigation system does not care what Maciej permits us
    to call Fred.


    Hooke's law, then, another of Newton's inconvenient and uncomfortable adaptations, hypothesis non fingo, make for the spring balance and
    the lever, the account of the reductionism, then that later accounts
    besides of course Lagrange's great half-account, makes for that in
    a sense that Hooke's law is the king of half accounts, then for
    Clausius and Arrhenius and for Kelvin then for Planck, besides
    whoever made for partial in analysis or differential geometry,
    makes for the wider Mach-ian and wider Lagrange-ian an account
    of way gravity is always turning away.

    So, before even getting to Lagrange, you already have Hooke's law,
    implicit in all your derivations and a merely partial half-account.

    If Newton stands on these giants, it's a bit diminishing.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Oct 25 07:02:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 10:39 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    the values 1g on the table,
    0 during freefall are NOT any acceleration,
    none of them.

    Fine. Then forget the word "accelerometer".

    No, I won't.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Oct 25 07:07:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/24/2026 10:41 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    For once, there is a point here on which you are right.

    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    -a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward

    Paul's statement

    -a-a F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    -a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward
    -a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward
    -a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
    -a-a Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.

    Drop it:

    -a-a Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
    -a-a accelerometer reading:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a about 0

    And none of this requires Einstein.

    The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
    (or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
    to the Earth.

    So yes: if somebody says an accelerometer directly measures Newton's coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# in a gravitational field, that is
    wrong.

    But your conclusion

    -a-a "therefore it measures no acceleration"

    doesn't follow.

    Yes, it does.




    It measures a different, perfectly well-defined physical quantity,
    which is precisely why inertial navigation can use it.

    You seem remarkably fond of arguments about labels:

    This is NOT any Ministry of Love, this is
    security agency kidnapping, torturing, murdering.

    Labels make difference.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Oct 25 12:33:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 24.10.2026 21:04, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/24/2026 8:23 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc., >>>>>>>> has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems >>>>>>>> use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.


    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
    while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
    does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.


    Neither the fact that when a plane is
    standing still in airport - the output
    of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.

    Give it up, Maciej.
    It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground
    show that the acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.

    Give it up, poor piece of shit - no it is not.


    (The exact value will depend on the latitude.)

    And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration
    or inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.

    ---------------

    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    -a-aa = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m
    and a is the acceleration of the object.

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
    definition.

    The above is correct, nothing more to discuss.


    Even such an ignorant idiot should know that
    the acceleration of Newton's definition-a is
    not 0 for a free falling object. But he doesn't
    know, and-a what can I do.
    Anyway, it is not, what your toy measures
    is not any acceleration. The Shit has lied
    to you.


    Think of this, Maciej:

    Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.

    You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts
    an upwards force on you, F = 786 N.

    According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
    a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.

    Do you claim that Newton is wrong?



    Do you claim that Newton is wrong?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Oct 25 12:54:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/25/2026 12:33 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 24.10.2026 21:04, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/24/2026 8:23 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
    a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc., >>>>>>>>> has an inertial navigation system.

    Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation
    systems use?

    Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
    (together with others).

    Right. Well done.

    They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
    the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
    measuring the rotation around the three axes.
    The axes are:
    Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
    Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
    Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)

    Do you think such system
    will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
    is falling down like a rock? Just because some
    mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
    doubt it.

    Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
    sensors in real airplanes show.


    When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
    the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
    Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
    the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
    of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
    The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards), >>>>>>> while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
    Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
    rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
    is known.
    Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
    of the airplane is also known.
    The latitude must be input.

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
    the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
    to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
    by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
    when the airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
    shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
    does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.


    Neither the fact that when a plane is
    standing still in airport - the output
    of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.

    Give it up, Maciej.
    It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground
    show that the acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.

    Give it up, poor piece of shit - no it is not.


    (The exact value will depend on the latitude.)

    And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration
    or inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.

    ---------------

    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    -a-aa = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m
    and a is the acceleration of the object.

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
    definition.

    The above is correct, nothing more to discuss.


    Even such an ignorant idiot should know that
    the acceleration of Newton's definition-a is
    not 0 for a free falling object. But he doesn't
    know, and-a what can I do.
    Anyway, it is not, what your toy measures
    is not any acceleration. The Shit has lied
    to you.


    Think of this, Maciej:

    Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.

    You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts
    an upwards force on you, F = 786 N.

    According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
    a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.

    Do you claim that Newton is wrong?



    Do you claim that Newton is wrong?

    I claim you're an arrogant, ignorant idiot not
    knowing even Newton's basics.
    I can also claim that he was wrong about many
    things, if you wish.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Oct 25 15:31:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    For once, there is a point here on which you are right.

    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    -a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward

    .. when the coordinate system is the ECI-frame.

    This is the coordinate acceleration according to Newton, SR and GR.


    Paul's statement

    -a-a F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    F is the net force that is acting on the body with mass m.


    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    -a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward

    No! There is no force acting downwards on the man.

    -a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward

    Right.
    That means that the net force acting on the man is 786 N upward.

    -a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    If the net force acting on the man were 0, then the scale
    would show 0 N.
    The fact that the scale shows 786 N upward _proves_ that
    the only force acting on the man is 786 N upward.

    Newton's gravitation is a fictitious force.

    According to Newton's second law of motion
    the acceleration a = 786N/80kg = 9.825 m/s-# upward

    The acceleration in Newton's second law of motion
    is what we now call the proper acceleration.

    If you stand on the ground at the position y = 0,
    (or any other constant), then your speed dy/dt = 0,
    your coordinate acceleration is d-#y/dt-# = 0.

    Note that d-#y/dt-# is a coordinate acceleration by definition!

    This thread started with my question:
    "Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    the acceleration is zero?"

    The answer is that it is because the proper acceleration is zero.

    My point was simply that an accelerometer measures proper
    acceleration, and the proper acceleration of a body on the ground
    is ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.


    -a-a Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.

    Drop it:

    -a-a Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
    -a-a accelerometer reading:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a about 0

    And none of this requires Einstein.

    The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
    (or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
    to the Earth.

    The accelerometer measures the only real force that is acting
    on a body with known mass within it.

    Proper acceleration is the only acceleration that can be measured
    with no external reference to a coordinate system.


    So yes: if somebody says an accelerometer directly measures Newton's coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# in a gravitational field, that is
    wrong.

    But your conclusion

    -a-a "therefore it measures no acceleration"

    doesn't follow.

    It measures a different, perfectly well-defined physical quantity,
    which is precisely why inertial navigation can use it.

    You seem remarkably fond of arguments about labels:

    -a-a "That's not acceleration!"
    -a-a "That's not time!"
    -a-a "That's not a proper clock!"

    Fine. Call the accelerometer output Fred again.

    -a-a sitting on runway: Fred ree 1 g
    -a-a free fall:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a Fred ree 0

    The aircraft's navigation system does not care what Maciej permits us
    to call Fred.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Oct 25 16:45:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/25/2026 3:31 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    For once, there is a point here on which you are right.

    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    -a-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward

    .. when the coordinate system is the ECI-frame.

    This is the coordinate acceleration according to Newton, SR and GR.


    Paul's statement

    -a-a-a F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    F is the net force that is acting on the body with mass m.


    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    -a-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward

    No! There is no force acting downwards on the man.

    -a-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward

    Right.
    That means that the net force acting on the man is 786 N upward.

    -a-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    If the net force acting on the man were 0, then the scale
    would show 0 N.
    The fact that the scale shows 786 N upward _proves_ that
    the only force acting on the man is 786 N upward.

    Newton's gravitation is a fictitious force.


    According to Newton's second law of motion
    the acceleration a = 786N/80kg = 9.825 m/s-# upward

    It's indeed amazing what The Shit of Einstein
    is doing with poor brains of its unfortunate
    victims.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 05:58:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 12:33:55 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 24.10.2026 21:04, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/24/2026 8:23 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
    On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:

    The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating the >>>>>>> accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration to
    integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown by the
    vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration when the
    airplane was stationary on the ground.

    inertial navigation systems works.

    Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?


    If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit is asserting - it
    just has to be true.
    Right!

    Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit does not
    change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.


    Neither the fact that when a plane is standing still in airport - the
    output of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.

    Give it up, Maciej.
    It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground show that the
    acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.

    Give it up, poor piece of shit - no it is not.


    (The exact value will depend on the latitude.)

    And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration or
    inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.

    ---------------

    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    -a-aa = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m and a is the
    acceleration of the object.

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
    definition.

    The above is correct, nothing more to discuss.

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
    used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
    FORCES. In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The apparatus
    is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.
    A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat road
    after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force that is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring. The spring
    extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient to provide the
    mass with the same acceleration as the car.

    Even such an ignorant idiot should know that the acceleration of
    Newton's definition-a is not 0 for a free falling object. But he doesn't
    know, and-a what can I do.
    Anyway, it is not, what your toy measures is not any acceleration. The
    Shit has lied to you.


    Think of this, Maciej:

    Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.

    You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts an upwards force
    on you, F = 786 N.

    According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
    a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.

    Do you claim that Newton is wrong?



    Do you claim that Newton is wrong?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 06:09:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 16:45:43 +0100, Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 10/25/2026 3:31 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    For once, there is a point here on which you are right.

    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    -a-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward

    .. when the coordinate system is the ECI-frame.

    This is the coordinate acceleration according to Newton, SR and GR.


    Paul's statement

    -a-a-a F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    F is the net force that is acting on the body with mass m.


    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    -a-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward

    No! There is no force acting downwards on the man.

    -a-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward

    Right.
    That means that the net force acting on the man is 786 N upward.

    -a-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    If the net force acting on the man were 0, then the scale would show 0
    N.
    The fact that the scale shows 786 N upward _proves_ that the only force
    acting on the man is 786 N upward.

    Newton's gravitation is a fictitious force.


    According to Newton's second law of motion the acceleration a =
    786N/80kg = 9.825 m/s-# upward

    It's indeed amazing what The Shit of Einstein is doing with poor brains
    of its unfortunate victims.

    They deny forces exist without a causative acceleration. Einstein's magic
    glue holds two bar magnets together and makes an armature spin.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 06:34:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sat, 24 Oct 2026 19:32:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 14:14:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:

    an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
    clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
    space is the cause.

    Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that the acceleration is
    zero?

    HAHAHAHAHAAHA! How can I give up this NG when I get so many laughs?
    Let's rename it 'sci.physics.comedy'

    Paul, our expert radio engineer, does not even know that free falling
    radar can register d2y/dt^2 as well as dy/dt.

    A free falling radar can only measure the acceleration of the
    y-coordinate in its own rest frame. So it will measure its own
    coordinate acceleration to be zero, of course.
    y = 0, dy/dt = 0, d-#y/dt-#.

    But it can measure the coordinate acceleration of the Earth (or other objects) in its rest frame.

    If the radar is stationary on Earth, it can measure a free falling
    object's coordinate acceleration in Earth's rest frame.
    If the radar is on the moon, it can measure the same free falling
    object's coordinate acceleration in the moon's rest frame.
    The two coordinate accelerations are not equal.

    He thinks that a massive force accelerates the Earth towards a skydiver
    at g.

    Paul thinks that an object can have several different coordinate accelerations depending on in which coordinate system the coordinate acceleration is measured.

    Did you really not know that, Ralph? :-D

    Paul thinks wrongly. Acceleration is not frame dependent, it is absolute
    and always measurable...Coordinate systems are the same in all frames.

    -----------

    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    a = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m.

    This acceleration is what we call the object's proper acceleration. An
    object has but one proper acceleration.

    Who is this 'we'? Do you belong to a weird group of magicians?

    An accelerometer is in principle a body with known mass fixed to the
    casing via a spring. When the casing is accelerated by a force, the
    casing will via the spring make the body accelerate along with the
    casing.
    The acceleration of the body is now a = F/m where m is the body's known mass, and F is the force the spring exert on the body. The compression
    of the spring is measured and a = F/m.
    (The "spring" may be a piezoelectric crystal so
    the output of the accelerometer is a voltage.)

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's definition.
    No, your spring accelerometer is not what its name suggests. It is really
    a tension-ometer that can be adapted to measure acceleration. There is no tension in free fall for reasons that are obvious to 'we' who are not
    members of your magic society..


    Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.

    Right!
    Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by an
    accelerometer.
    An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration is zero
    because the proper acceleration is zero.
    Even no acceleration is measurable.

    Doppler radar will indicate the absolute acceleration of a free falling object.
    Einstein whole theory is based on his ignorance of basic physics...but it
    made him rich and famous because it temporarily
    saved the reputations of many equally ignorant academics whose own silly theories were demolished by the MMX.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 07:54:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/25/2026 3:31 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    For once, there is a point here on which you are right.

    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    -a-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward

    .. when the coordinate system is the ECI-frame.

    This is the coordinate acceleration according to Newton, SR and GR.


    Paul's statement

    -a-a-a F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    F is the net force that is acting on the body with mass m.


    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    -a-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward

    No! There is no force acting downwards on the man.

    -a-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward

    Right.
    That means that the net force acting on the man is 786 N upward.

    -a-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    If the net force acting on the man were 0, then the scale
    would show 0 N.
    The fact that the scale shows 786 N upward _proves_ that
    the only force acting on the man is 786 N upward.

    Newton's gravitation is a fictitious force.

    According to Newton's second law of motion
    the acceleration a = 786N/80kg = 9.825 m/s-# upward

    The acceleration in Newton's second law of motion
    is what we now call the proper acceleration.

    If you stand on the ground at the position y = 0,
    (or any other constant), then your speed dy/dt = 0,
    your coordinate acceleration is-a d-#y/dt-# = 0.

    Note that d-#y/dt-# is a coordinate acceleration by definition!

    This thread started with my question:
    "Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
    -athe acceleration is zero?"

    The answer is that it is because the proper acceleration is zero.

    My point was simply that an accelerometer measures proper
    acceleration, and the proper acceleration of a body on the ground
    is ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.


    -a-a-a Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.

    Drop it:

    -a-a-a Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
    -a-a-a accelerometer reading:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a about 0

    And none of this requires Einstein.

    The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
    (or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
    to the Earth.

    The accelerometer measures the only real force that is acting
    on a body with known mass within it.

    Proper acceleration is the only acceleration that can be measured
    with no external reference to a coordinate system.

    Paul, poor piece of shit, THIS is
    Newton's definition of acceleration:
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acceleration
    And this is still the official definition
    accepted by your moronic church.

    If you can't measure it with no external
    reference - then you have to measure it WITH
    some external reference.


    https://www.britannica.com/science/inertial-mass
    F=a*m worked in Newtonian physics as the
    definition of mass, not as the definition
    of the acceleration.


    And your wild assertion that gravity is
    pseudoforce, abstracting of its sense - is
    no way any part of Newtonian definition system.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 07:25:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sat, 24 Oct 2026 19:32:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 14:14:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:



    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's definition.


    Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.

    Right!
    Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by an
    accelerometer.
    An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration is zero
    because the proper acceleration is zero.
    Even no acceleration is measurable.

    I missed that classic...

    When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer...which is not really what its name suggests but is a 'forceometer' or 'spring tension- meter'...correctly indicates that a downward gravitational force of 9.8 m/
    s/s is acting on every unit mass there, for reasons unknown. This directly implies that any object in free fall will accelerate at that rate. A
    spring tension-meter falling down a hole has zero spring tension because
    the same force is now operating on both ends, which are
    known to be accelerating at that rate, 9.8. The apparatus is not designed
    to directly indicate acceleration under such conditions but indirectly
    does so by way of its zero reading. Even Marcel told you that.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 15:08:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    For once, there is a point here on which you are right.

    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    -a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward

    Paul's statement

    -a-a F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    -a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward
    -a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward
    -a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
    -a-a Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    The above is correct.

    According to Newton the gravitational force above the ground
    is F = GMm/r-#. In free fall close to the ground this will
    give the acceleration a = F/m = GM/r-# ree 9.81 m/s-# downward.
    When the 80 kg man is sitting on a scale, the downward force
    on the man is ~785 N and the upward force from the scale
    is the reaction force (Newton's third law of motion),
    the net force is 0 and the acceleration is 0.

    My point with my other response to Python's post was not
    that Python was wrong about what Newton say, but that
    what Newton say is factually wrong.

    Accelerometers measure proper acceleration correctly.
    The proper acceleration of an object on the ground
    is ree 9.81 m/s-# upward, it is not zero.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 15:31:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 26.10.2026 08:25, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sat, 24 Oct 2026 19:32:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's definition.


    Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.

    Right!
    Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by an
    accelerometer.
    An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration is zero
    because the proper acceleration is zero.
    Even no acceleration is measurable.

    I missed that classic...

    When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer...which is not really what its name suggests but is a 'forceometer' or 'spring tension- meter'...correctly indicates that a downward gravitational force of 9.8 m/ s/s is acting on every unit mass there, for reasons unknown. This directly implies that any object in free fall will accelerate at that rate. A
    spring tension-meter falling down a hole has zero spring tension because
    the same force is now operating on both ends, which are
    known to be accelerating at that rate, 9.8. The apparatus is not designed
    to directly indicate acceleration under such conditions but indirectly
    does so by way of its zero reading. Even Marcel told you that.

    There is no such thing as an "Einsteinian accelerometer".

    Read what you snipped:
    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    a = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m.

    This acceleration is what we call the object's proper
    acceleration. An object has but one proper acceleration.

    An accelerometer is in principle a body with known mass
    fixed to the casing via a spring. When the casing is
    accelerated by a force, the casing will via the spring
    make the body accelerate along with the casing.
    The acceleration of the body is now a = F/m where
    m is the body's known mass, and F is the force the spring
    exert on the body. The compression of the spring is measured
    and a = F/m.
    (The "spring" may be a piezoelectric crystal so
    the output of the accelerometer is a voltage.)

    Note:
    The force the spring exert on the body with known mass
    is upwards. The reaction force from the body is downward
    _because_ the acceleration is upward.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 15:37:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/26/2026 3:31 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Read what you snipped:
    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    -aa = F/m

    No, poor ignorant idiot, Newton's definition of
    acceleration is - dv/dt.
    And F=a*m is in Netonian physics a definition of
    mass.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 14:55:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.

    Yes.

    Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of acceleration.

    But then you write:

    And F=a*m is in Netonian physics a definition of mass.

    Not so fast.

    In elementary Newtonian mechanics we have distinct concepts:

    acceleration: a = dv/dt

    net force: F

    inertial mass: m

    related by

    F = ma

    You don't get to win an argument about definitions merely by moving
    the word "definition" from Paul's sentence into yours.

    And none of this rescues your accelerometer argument.

    In Newtonian mechanics, for a freely falling body near Earth:

    dv/dt ree g

    while an ideal spring-mass accelerometer falls together with its proof
    mass and therefore reads approximately zero.

    On the ground:

    dv/dt = 0

    while the accelerometer reads approximately g.

    That distinction follows perfectly well from Newtonian mechanics.

    So Paul made a terminological mistake.

    You have been making a physical category mistake for several days.

    I wouldn't celebrate the exchange rate.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 16:12:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/26/2026 3:55 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.

    Yes.

    Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of acceleration.

    But then you write:

    And F=a*m is in Netonian physics a definition of mass.

    Not so fast.

    In elementary Newtonian mechanics we have distinct concepts:

    -a-a acceleration:-a a = dv/dt

    -a-a net force:-a-a-a-a F

    -a-a inertial mass: m

    https://www.britannica.com/science/inertial-mass
    Quick Summary
    Inertial mass is a fundamental concept in physics that quantifies an
    object's resistance to changes in its state of motion. It is defined by
    how much acceleration an object experiences when a force is applied to it.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 15:14:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Yes. This time your reference supports the point you are making:

    inertial mass can be defined operationally by m = F/a,

    given an independently specified procedure for comparing/applied
    forces.

    So my previous wording was too categorical if you understood it as
    saying that F = ma cannot be used to define inertial mass.

    Fine.

    Notice how easy that was.

    You supplied a relevant reference, it supported your point, and I
    corrected the statement.

    No "Shit", no "mad guru", no conspiracy required.

    It still changes absolutely nothing about our accelerometer discussion.

    We still have, in Newtonian mechanics:

    free fall:
    dv/dt relative to Earth ree g
    accelerometer reading ree 0

    resting on Earth:
    dv/dt relative to Earth = 0
    accelerometer reading ree g

    So congratulations: you have scored a perfectly legitimate point about
    the operational definition of inertial mass.

    Now perhaps we can return to the two columns you have spent several
    days trying to turn into one by arguing about the word "acceleration".
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 15:26:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ralph,

    When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer [...]
    correctly indicates that a downward gravitational force of 9.8 m/s/s
    is acting on every unit mass there

    No.

    And your very next paragraph demonstrates why.

    In Newtonian terms, gravity acts on the accelerometer's components
    whether the instrument is:

    sitting on the ground

    or

    falling down the hole.

    If its reading were simply a measurement of the gravitational force
    per unit mass, then it should read approximately g in BOTH cases.

    It doesn't.

    On the ground:

    gravity acts on the proof mass
    the case is prevented from falling by the ground
    -> relative force/displacement
    -> accelerometer reads ~1 g

    In free fall:

    gravity acts on case and proof mass
    both fall together
    -> no relative force/displacement
    -> accelerometer reads ~0

    No Einstein is required to describe that in Newtonian mechanics.

    The apparatus is not designed to directly indicate acceleration
    under such conditions but indirectly does so by way of its zero
    reading.

    This is the particularly entertaining part.

    You have just conceded the complete physical behaviour of the
    accelerometer:

    stationary on Earth: ~1 g
    free fall: 0

    You merely want to reinterpret the zero as secretly meaning:

    "0, therefore the REAL acceleration is g."

    But the instrument has no knowledge of Earth.

    Put the same ideal accelerometer in a sealed freely falling box and its
    local reading is zero. From that reading alone it cannot tell whether
    the box is falling toward Earth, orbiting Earth, or coasting far from gravitation.

    To obtain acceleration relative to Earth, you need additional
    information defining Earth as your reference and, in an inertial
    navigation system, an appropriate gravity model.

    So the accelerometer is not "indirectly indicating g by indicating
    zero".

    YOU are inferring g from its zero reading plus external knowledge about
    the gravitational field and the chosen reference frame.

    Those are rather different things.

    And calling it a "forceometer" doesn't hurt relativity in the slightest.

    In fact, that is remarkably close to the point:

    an accelerometer measures specific force, equivalently proper
    acceleration.

    After several paragraphs attacking the terminology, you have described
    almost exactly why the distinction exists.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brendon Rujnikov@nnun@onon.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 15:31:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
    In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:

    -a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward

    Paul's statement

    -a-a F = ma

    needs "F" to mean the NET force.

    So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:

    -a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward net
    -a-a force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0 Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0

    The above is correct.

    According to Newton the gravitational force above the ground is F =
    GMm/r-#. In free fall close to the ground this will give the acceleration
    a = F/m = GM/r-# ree 9.81 m/s-# downward.

    idiot, just crashes when accl is zero, how can that be correct
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 23:06:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 26.10.2026 15:55, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.

    Yes.

    dv/dt, or d-#x/dt-#, is the definition of acceleration in
    mathematics and calculus. x and t are coordinates so this
    is a coordinate acceleration.


    Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of acceleration.

    Newton's definition of acceleration is found in his second
    law of motion. It can be expressed a = F/m.

    "Acceleration is directly proportional to the net force and
    inversely proportional to the object's mass."

    This is _physics_, it relates force, mass and acceleration.

    If I say:
    "The force on an object is F, the mass of the object is m.
    Please find the acceleration defined by a = dv/dt."
    What would you do?

    Wouldn't it be better id a said:
    "Please find the acceleration defined by a = F/m"?

    Newton didn't use the word "proper", but a = F/m
    is the proper acceleration which can have but one value
    for a given force and mass. It is invariant, the same
    in all frames of reference.

    The coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# can have different values
    in different frames of reference.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Oct 26 23:13:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
    used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
    FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.

    ________________
    | ______ |
    | | m | |
    | |______| |
    | \ |
    | / |
    |________\_______|

    m = 1 kg

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    What is the tension T in the string?

    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
    What is the tension T in the string?

    (Tensile stress is positive, compressive stress is negative.)

    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.

    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The apparatus
    is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.


    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
    of the box?

    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to this question.

    A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat road
    after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force that is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring. The spring
    extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient to provide the
    mass with the same acceleration as the car.

    Right.

    So the accelerometer works correctly.
    Acceleration is the tension multiplied by the mass, a = Triam

    Do you think the accelerometer would cease to work correctly
    if the orientation is different from horizontal?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 07:43:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/26/2026 11:13 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
    used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free
    fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
    FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.

    -a________________
    |-a-a-a-a ______-a-a-a-a |
    |-a-a-a |-a m-a-a |-a-a-a |
    |-a-a-a |______|-a-a-a |
    |-a-a-a-a-a-a-a \-a-a-a-a-a-a |
    |-a-a-a-a-a-a-a /-a-a-a-a-a-a |
    |________\_______|

    -a-a m = 1 kg

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    -a-a What is the tension T in the string?

    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
    -a-a What is the tension T in the string?

    (Tensile stress is positive, compressive stress is negative.)

    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.

    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
    tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The apparatus
    is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.


    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
    -a-a of the box?


    It's depending where it is. If it's near the
    Earth surface is about 9.81m/s^2, poor ignorant
    idiot.

    So the accelerometer works correctly.
    Acceleration is the tension multiplied by the mass, a = Triam

    No, it is dv/dt. Your mad religion has lied to you.










    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 08:19:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/26/2026 11:06 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 26.10.2026 15:55, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.

    Yes.

    dv/dt, or d-#x/dt-#, is the definition of acceleration in
    mathematics and calculus. x and t are coordinates so this
    is a coordinate acceleration.


    Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of
    acceleration.

    Newton's definition of acceleration is found in his second
    law of motion. It can be expressed a = F/m.

    No, poor ignorant idiot. Newton's definition
    of acceleration can be found elsewhere, and it is
    dv/dt. F=a*m was Newton's definition of mass.
    Your mad Shit has lied to you.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 09:08:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
    used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free
    fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
    FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.

    ________________
    | ______ |
    | | m | |
    | |______| |
    | \ |
    | / |
    |________\_______|

    m = 1 kg

    That can measure acceleration.

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    What is the tension T in the string?

    The spring extends until the its tension is sufficient to precisely
    accelerate the mass at the same rate as the box. In other words, the force accelerating the box is transmited to the mas via the stretching of the spring.

    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.

    ...Hahahah! .but you said there is no acceleration in free fall. Now you
    are admitting that the box is accelerating in free fall. Make up your mind Paul.

    What is the tension T in the string?

    (Tensile stress is positive, compressive stress is negative.)

    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.
    There certainly is. You don't understand very basic Physics.

    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
    tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The
    apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.


    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
    of the box?

    The box is accelerating at 9.8, which was the force on it as measured when
    it was not falling. Marcel told you that.

    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to this question.

    Yes. Same as above.

    A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat road
    after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force that
    is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring. The
    spring extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient to
    provide the mass with the same acceleration as the car.

    Right.

    So the accelerometer works correctly.
    Acceleration is the tension multiplied by the mass, a = Triam

    That would be the numerical answer. Yes.

    Do you think the accelerometer would cease to work correctly if the orientation is different from horizontal?

    Of course. The car's acceleration acts directly on the box, not the mass.
    The spring tension, after a delay while it stretches, acts on the mass. Gravity acts equally on both immediately..so no stretching is needed.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 09:16:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:06:16 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 15:55, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.

    Yes.

    dv/dt, or d-#x/dt-#, is the definition of acceleration in mathematics and calculus. x and t are coordinates so this is a coordinate acceleration.


    Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of
    acceleration.

    Newton's definition of acceleration is found in his second law of
    motion. It can be expressed a = F/m.

    "Acceleration is directly proportional to the net force and
    inversely proportional to the object's mass."

    This is _physics_, it relates force, mass and acceleration.

    If I say:
    "The force on an object is F, the mass of the object is m.
    Please find the acceleration defined by a = dv/dt."
    What would you do?

    Wouldn't it be better id a said:
    "Please find the acceleration defined by a = F/m"?

    Newton didn't use the word "proper", but a = F/m is the proper
    acceleration which can have but one value for a given force and mass. It
    is invariant, the same in all frames of reference.

    The coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# can have different values in
    different frames of reference.

    Only in your ridiculous Einsteinian universe.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 09:21:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 08:19:38 +0100, Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 10/26/2026 11:06 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 26.10.2026 15:55, skrev Python:
    Maciej,

    Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.

    Yes.

    dv/dt, or d-#x/dt-#, is the definition of acceleration in mathematics and
    calculus. x and t are coordinates so this is a coordinate acceleration.


    Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of
    acceleration.

    Newton's definition of acceleration is found in his second law of
    motion. It can be expressed a = F/m.

    No, poor ignorant idiot. Newton's definition of acceleration can be
    found elsewhere, and it is dv/dt. F=a*m was Newton's definition of mass.
    Your mad Shit has lied to you.

    Hey ,Marcel, I'm on your side but you wont win any points by defining mass
    as mass x acceleration..even though Python missed it.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 09:37:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 15:31:42 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 08:25, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sat, 24 Oct 2026 19:32:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:

    An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
    definition.


    Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.

    Right!
    Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by an
    accelerometer.
    An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration is zero
    because the proper acceleration is zero.
    Even no acceleration is measurable.

    I missed that classic...

    When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer...which is
    not really what its name suggests but is a 'forceometer' or 'spring
    tension- meter'...correctly indicates that a downward gravitational
    force of 9.8 m/
    s/s is acting on every unit mass there, for reasons unknown. This
    directly implies that any object in free fall will accelerate at that
    rate. A spring tension-meter falling down a hole has zero spring
    tension because the same force is now operating on both ends, which are
    known to be accelerating at that rate, 9.8. The apparatus is not
    designed to directly indicate acceleration under such conditions but
    indirectly does so by way of its zero reading. Even Marcel told you
    that.

    There is no such thing as an "Einsteinian accelerometer".

    Read what you snipped:
    Newton's definition of acceleration is:
    a = F/m
    where F is the force acting on an object with mass m.

    Correct. A is the dependent variable. An 'a' will only occur if a force operates. Forces can exist without accelerations.

    This acceleration is what we call the object's proper acceleration. An
    object has but one proper acceleration.

    You are preaching Einsteiniana. There is only ONE type of acceleration and
    it is frame independent.



    An accelerometer is in principle a body with known mass fixed to the
    casing via a spring.

    Paul, that is one type of device that can detect acceleration. But it is really a device that transmits a force to the mass on the spring. The only reason a pring is used rather than a rope is that springs extend more than ropes do and can be easily calibrated.

    When the casing is accelerated by a force, the
    casing will via the spring make the body accelerate along with the
    casing.

    Yes. The spring transmits the exact force after it extends. A rope would
    do the same immediately.

    The acceleration of the body is now a = F/m where m is the body's known mass, and F is the force the spring exert on the body. The compression
    of the spring is measured and a = F/m.

    In free fall, the spring is not stretched and exerts no force on the mass.
    The same force is exerted on the box.


    (The "spring" may be a piezoelectric crystal so
    the output of the accelerometer is a voltage.)

    Note:
    The force the spring exert on the body with known mass is upwards.

    In free fall, the spring exerts NO force on the mass.

    The reaction force from the body is downward _because_ the acceleration is
    upward.

    There is no spring extension or reaction in free fall.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 10:06:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Mon, 26 Oct 26 15:26:44 +0000, Python wrote:

    Ralph,

    When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer [...]
    correctly indicates that a downward gravitational force of 9.8 m/s/s is
    acting on every unit mass there

    No.

    And your very next paragraph demonstrates why.

    In Newtonian terms, gravity acts on the accelerometer's components
    whether the instrument is:

    sitting on the ground

    or

    falling down the hole.

    If its reading were simply a measurement of the gravitational force per
    unit mass, then it should read approximately g in BOTH cases.

    Indeed it should if it was really an accelerometer. But it isn't even
    though it can be used as one on horizontal ground. It actually measures
    the tension in a spring.

    It doesn't.

    On the ground:

    gravity acts on the proof mass the case is prevented from falling by
    the ground -> relative force/displacement -> accelerometer reads ~1
    g.

    Correct. It indicate FORCE.

    In free fall:

    gravity acts on case and proof mass both fall together -> no
    relative force/displacement -> accelerometer reads ~0

    Correct. There is no tension in the spring....for obvious reasons. The box
    is now not prevented from falling.

    No Einstein is required to describe that in Newtonian mechanics.

    The apparatus is not designed to directly indicate acceleration under
    such conditions but indirectly does so by way of its zero reading.

    This is the particularly entertaining part.

    You have just conceded the complete physical behaviour of the
    accelerometer:

    stationary on Earth: ~1 g free fall: 0

    You merely want to reinterpret the zero as secretly meaning:

    "0, therefore the REAL acceleration is g."

    But the instrument has no knowledge of Earth.

    Put the same ideal accelerometer in a sealed freely falling box and its
    local reading is zero. From that reading alone it cannot tell whether
    the box is falling toward Earth, orbiting Earth, or coasting far from gravitation.

    Look! I feel sorry for you. You are terribly confused.
    When a spring accelerometer is use in a car, the force that accelerates
    the car and all its parts is virtually instantaneous throughout its whole
    body because of its rigidity. The use of a spring to transmit the
    accelerating force to a free mass is a clever idea because unlike the the
    cars teel frame, the spring's extension can be calibrated, That extension
    is a direct measure of the applied force/divided by the car's
    mass....which will be its subsequent acceleration.

    To obtain acceleration relative to Earth, you need additional
    information defining Earth as your reference and, in an inertial
    navigation system, an appropriate gravity model.

    So the accelerometer is not "indirectly indicating g by indicating
    zero".

    It measured g before it started to fall.

    YOU are inferring g from its zero reading plus external knowledge about
    the gravitational field and the chosen reference frame.

    Correct. Before falling, it measure g at its location.

    Those are rather different things.

    And calling it a "forceometer" doesn't hurt relativity in the slightest.

    In fact, that is remarkably close to the point:

    an accelerometer measures specific force, equivalently proper
    acceleration.

    Don't use the word 'proper'. Its just part of you religious jargon.

    After several paragraphs attacking the terminology, you have described
    almost exactly why the distinction exists.

    Coordinates are the same in all frames.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 11:39:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ralph,

    Don't use the word 'proper'. Its just part of you religious jargon.

    Fine. Let's remove the word entirely.

    Engineers have another perfectly ordinary term:

    specific force

    That is what an accelerometer measures.

    In the simple Newtonian case:

    coordinate acceleration = specific force + gravitational acceleration

    So:

    car accelerating horizontally:
    accelerometer measures the applied specific force

    car stationary on Earth:
    coordinate acceleration = 0
    accelerometer reads ~1 g

    freely falling box:
    coordinate acceleration = g
    accelerometer reads 0

    Your car example is therefore perfectly consistent with what I said.
    You have merely selected a situation where gravity has no component
    along the direction being discussed, so specific force and coordinate acceleration happen to coincide.

    Then comes this remarkable sentence:

    Coordinates are the same in all frames.

    No, Ralph.

    If coordinates were the same in all frames, there would be no point in
    having different frames.

    Take a car moving at constant velocity V relative to the road. Even in
    Galilean mechanics:

    x' = x - Vt

    The coordinates are NOT the same.

    What Newtonian mechanics gives you is that acceleration is invariant
    under transformations between inertial frames related by constant
    velocity:

    d-#x'/dt-# = d-#x/dt-#

    That is very different from saying that the coordinates are the same.

    So after accusing me of being "terribly confused", you have managed to:

    1. describe correctly how an accelerometer measures specific force;

    2. confirm that it reads 1 g on the ground and zero in free fall;

    3. explain why its reading can coincide with coordinate acceleration
    in your specially chosen car example;

    4. finish by getting the Galilean transformation wrong.

    And none of this required Einstein.

    Newton would already have been enough.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:01:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 12:39 PM, Python wrote:
    Ralph,

    Don't use the word 'proper'. Its just part of you religious jargon.

    Fine. Let's remove the word entirely.

    Engineers have another perfectly ordinary term:

    -a-a specific force

    That is what an accelerometer measures.

    And a sheep is again a sheep, no longer
    a shark. Isn't it, poor piece of shit?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 12:06:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Yes, Maciej.

    Except the sheep was called "specific force" by engineers all along.

    You were the one insisting that because it wasn't the shark you wanted,
    it couldn't possibly be a sheep.

    The accelerometer measures specific force.

    From that, plus gravity and reference-frame information, an INS
    computes coordinate acceleration, velocity and position.

    No sheep became a shark.

    You simply spent several days shouting at the label on the enclosure.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:12:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 1:06 PM, Python wrote:
    Yes, Maciej.

    Except the sheep was called "specific force" by engineers all along.

    And "acceleration" by some religious maniacs
    brainwashed by a mad, brainwashing religion.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 12:19:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    And "acceleration" by some religious maniacs

    Yes.

    Because "proper acceleration" is a technical term for a perfectly
    well-defined physical quantity.

    But since the word "acceleration" causes you such theological distress,
    we can call it what inertial-navigation engineers commonly call it:

    specific force.

    Nothing changes.

    on the table: ~1 g
    in free fall: 0

    And an INS combines that measured specific force with attitude, a
    gravity model and rotation terms to obtain coordinate acceleration.

    So your entire objection has now collapsed from physics to:

    "I don't like what this quantity is called."

    Fine.

    Call it "sheep" if you prefer.

    The sheep still reads zero in free fall.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:22:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 1:19 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    And "acceleration" by some religious maniacs

    Yes.

    Because "proper acceleration" is a technical term for a perfectly well-defined physical quantity.

    Rather - because some mad idiot has predicted
    sharks to eat grass and his prophecies had
    to be fulfilled.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 12:23:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    No prophecy is needed.

    Take a box, a mass and a spring.

    Put the box on the ground:

    spring deflected.

    Drop the box:

    spring not deflected.

    This was true before Einstein was born and remains true if every copy
    of his books is burned tomorrow.

    Engineers call the measured quantity "specific force".

    Relativists also describe it as "proper acceleration".

    Your entire "sharks eating grass" argument therefore amounts to being
    furious that one physical quantity has two names.

    The spring, regrettably, remains indifferent to your theological
    analysis.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:40:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 1:23 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    No prophecy is needed.

    Take a box, a mass and a spring.

    Put the box on the ground:

    -a-a spring deflected.

    And the box doesn't accelerate.


    Drop the box:

    -a-a spring not deflected.

    But the box accelerate.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 12:42:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Exactly.

    Congratulations, Maciej: you have finally discovered the distinction.

    box on ground:
    coordinate acceleration = 0
    accelerometer reading = ~1 g

    box in free fall:
    coordinate acceleration = ~g
    accelerometer reading = 0

    That is precisely why nobody competent claims that an accelerometer
    directly measures d-#x/dt-# relative to the Earth.

    It measures specific force.

    To obtain coordinate acceleration, an inertial navigation system
    combines that measurement with gravity, orientation and reference-frame information.

    You have now stated the experimental facts demonstrating the distinction
    I've been explaining to you.

    Again.

    This is becoming a remarkably efficient debate: I make the argument,
    you insult me, then you supply the evidence for it.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:44:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 1:42 PM, Python wrote:
    Exactly.

    Congratulations, Maciej: you have finally discovered the distinction.

    -a-a box on ground:
    -a-a-a-a-a-a coordinate acceleration = 0
    -a-a-a-a-a-a accelerometer reading-a-a = ~1 g

    -a-a box in free fall:
    -a-a-a-a-a-a coordinate acceleration = ~g
    -a-a-a-a-a-a accelerometer reading-a-a = 0

    Conclusion: so called "accelerometer"
    has no more in common with acceleration
    than Ministry of Love with love. Your
    mad, brainwashing religion is lying.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 12:52:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Then your complaint is purely about terminology.

    The instrument measures a quantity with dimensions of acceleration:

    force / mass = m/s-#

    It is exactly the quantity that determines the acceleration produced by non-gravitational forces.

    On Earth:

    supported box: specific force ~g, coordinate acceleration 0
    free fall: specific force 0, coordinate acceleration ~g

    Nobody is hiding this distinction. It is precisely WHY the two
    quantities have different names.

    And if "accelerometer" offends you, call it a specific-force meter.

    Nothing whatsoever changes in the physics.

    Your Ministry of Love analogy would work only if physicists claimed:

    accelerometer reading = d-#x/dt-# relative to Earth

    They don't.

    So after all the sharks, sheep, ministries, mad idiots and religions,
    your scientific objection reduces to:

    "I don't approve of the name of the instrument."

    Duly noted.

    The spring still does exactly what the equations say.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:01:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 1:52 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Then your complaint is purely about terminology.

    Yeah, and everybody knows - the
    terminology is not important.

    Since it is not - start calling The
    Shit - The Shit and the idiot - the
    idiot together with me. Why won't you,
    poor piece of Shit?

    Do you know why you won't? You won't
    because the terminology IS important.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:04:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    You won't because the terminology IS important.

    Exactly.

    Which is precisely why I don't let YOU define it.

    Physicists and engineers use established technical terms with defined
    meanings:

    acceleration
    proper acceleration
    specific force
    coordinate acceleration

    You, on the other hand, propose:

    relativity = "The Shit"
    Einstein = "the idiot"

    and apparently expect me to accept Maciej Wo+|niak as an authoritative standards body for scientific terminology.

    I decline.

    And yes, terminology IS important. That's why when two different
    physical quantities exist, giving them different names is useful.

    As for how I would describe the reliability of YOUR terminology...

    Well, guess.

    I suspect my answer would be shared by most sane readers of this
    thread.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:18:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 2:04 PM, Python wrote:
    You won't because the terminology IS important.

    Exactly.

    Which is precisely why I don't let YOU define it.

    And exactly why I don't let YOUR BUNCH
    OF MAD FANATICS define it.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:22:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Exactly.

    And that's why science doesn't settle terminology by asking either you
    or me.

    It uses definitions shared by the scientific and engineering
    communities.

    You are perfectly free to reject those definitions and invent your own:

    specific force -> "not acceleration"
    proper acceleration -> "religious nonsense"
    relativity -> "The Shit"
    Einstein -> "the idiot"

    But then you haven't refuted the physics.

    You've merely created the Maciej Dictionary and declared everyone using
    the standard dictionary a fanatic.

    Which is certainly convenient:

    Maciej is right by definition,
    because Maciej defines the definitions.

    Now THAT is circular.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:29:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 2:22 PM, Python wrote:
    Exactly.

    And that's why science doesn't settle terminology by asking either you
    or me.

    It uses definitions shared by the scientific and engineering
    communities.

    Thanks to your idiot guru, however, they're
    not shared anymore.
    And GPS/engineering second remains -
    9 192 631 770 on Earth, 9 192 631 774
    on a satellite.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:32:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    GPS/engineering second remains -
    9 192 631 770 on Earth, 9 192 631 774
    on a satellite.

    No.

    That is simply false.

    There is no GPS definition saying:

    GPS second on Earth = 9,192,631,770 Cs periods
    GPS second on satellite = 9,192,631,774 Cs periods

    GPS does not have two different seconds depending on altitude.

    The SI second is the unit used for GPS time.

    What changes is the RATE at which an uncorrected satellite atomic clock
    would accumulate time relative to GPS system time.

    That is precisely why the satellite clock is frequency-offset.

    You are taking approximately four extra Cs cycles resulting from the Earth/satellite rate comparison and turning them into a fictitious
    definition of a "satellite engineering second".

    So let's use the same test as before.

    You claim:

    "GPS/engineering second" =
    9,192,631,774 Cs periods on a satellite.

    Fine.

    Quote the GPS specification that defines the satellite second that way.

    Document.
    Section.
    Exact quotation.

    Not your interpretation.

    Not your arithmetic.

    The definition.

    I predict another very long wait.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:39:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 2:32 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    GPS/engineering second remains -
    9 192 631 770 on Earth, 9 192 631 774
    on a satellite.

    No.

    That is simply false.

    Yes. A brainwashed fanatic idiot screaming
    "NOOOOOOO!!!" won't change anything.




    There is no GPS definition saying:

    -a-a GPS second on Earth-a-a-a-a-a = 9,192,631,770 Cs periods
    -a-a GPS second on satellite-a = 9,192,631,774 Cs periods

    GPS does not have two different seconds depending on altitude.

    No, it has just one, and it is equivalent to
    9,192,631,770 Cs periods on the ground and
    9,192,631,774 on a satellite.

    Just read its clocks, trash, instead reading
    mystical mumble of your moronic gurus.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 13:41:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    it has just one, and it is equivalent to
    9,192,631,770 Cs periods on the ground and
    9,192,631,774 on a satellite.

    Good. Now notice what you have just said.

    The SAME GPS-time interval corresponds, according to you, to different
    amounts of local Cs evolution:

    ground: ~9,192,631,770 periods
    satellite: ~9,192,631,774 periods

    That is a rate difference.

    You can call the common GPS interval "the real second" until the Sun
    explodes. It doesn't make those two numbers equal.

    And:

    Just read its clocks

    We did.

    NTS-2 was specifically operated with the relativistic frequency
    correction OFF.

    It did not magically maintain t'=t.

    Its measured rate shift was:

    +442.5 x 10^-12

    against the relativistic prediction:

    +446.5 x 10^-12.

    THEN the correction was switched on.

    So "just read its clocks" is excellent advice.

    That's precisely how your claim was experimentally falsified in 1977.

    The delicious part is that you are now reproducing the same rate
    difference yourself with your 9,192,631,770 versus 9,192,631,774.

    You read the clocks, obtain the relativistic effect, rename one second
    "real", and announce that the effect disappeared.

    It didn't
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:46:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
    used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free
    fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
    FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.

    ________________
    | ______ |
    | | m | |
    | |______| |
    | \ |
    | / |
    |________\_______|

    m = 1 kg

    ^
    | upward | downward
    v

    'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure,
    it has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated
    relative to the Earth.

    I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
    If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.



    That can measure acceleration.

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    What is the tension T in the string?

    The spring extends until the its tension is sufficient to precisely accelerate the mass at the same rate as the box. In other words, the force accelerating the box is transmited to the mas via the stretching of the spring.

    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward,
    so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.

    The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward


    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.

    ...Hahahah! .but you said there is no acceleration in free fall. Now you
    are admitting that the box is accelerating in free fall. Make up your mind Paul.

    You are babbling.


    What is the tension T in the string?

    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,
    so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.

    The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward

    Generally:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
    If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward
    on the figure.
    If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward
    on the figure.

    This is always true!
    ====================
    It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.



    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.

    There certainly is. You don't understand very basic Physics.


    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
    tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The
    apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.


    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
    of the box?

    a = T/m = 0


    The box is accelerating at 9.8, which was the force on it as measured when
    it was not falling. Marcel told you that.

    You are babbling again.


    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to this question.


    Yes. Same as above.

    A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat road
    after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force that
    is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring. The
    spring extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient to
    provide the mass with the same acceleration as the car.

    Right.

    So the accelerometer works correctly.
    Acceleration is the tension divided by the mass, a = T/m

    That would be the numerical answer. Yes.

    Do you think the accelerometer would cease to work correctly if the
    orientation is different from horizontal?

    Of course. The car's acceleration acts directly on the box, not the mass.
    The spring tension, after a delay while it stretches, acts on the mass. Gravity acts equally on both immediately..so no stretching is needed.


    An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
    When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
    it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    You can wonder why, but it is a fact.

    The following may give you a hint:

    Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
    This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N
    The proper acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#
    An accelerometer onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#

    Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
    The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will
    stay hovering 10 m above the ground.
    The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration
    a = 9.8 m/s-#!

    This is a fact whether you like it or not.
    Of course it is gravitation at play.

    It seems like GR is right:
    Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.
    So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:46:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 2:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,

    Ignorant DK idiots know such things.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 15:01:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 2:41 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    it has just one, and it is equivalent to
    9,192,631,770 Cs periods on the ground and
    9,192,631,774 on a satellite.

    Good. Now notice what you have just said.

    The SAME GPS-time interval corresponds, according to you, to different amounts of local Cs evolution:

    -a-a ground:-a-a-a-a ~9,192,631,770 periods
    -a-a satellite:-a ~9,192,631,774 periods

    That is a rate difference.

    Or frequency difference.


    You can call the common GPS interval "the real second" until the Sun explodes. It doesn't make those two numbers equal.

    And:

    Just read its clocks

    We did.

    NTS-2 was specifically operated with the relativistic frequency
    correction OFF.

    Some clocks may fit any nonsense.


    The delicious part is that you are now reproducing the same rate
    difference yourself with your 9,192,631,770 versus 9,192,631,774.

    Of course. A clock error.

    You read the clocks, obtain the relativistic effect

    No. I read the clocks, obtain t'=t.
    And a second of 9,192,631,770 on the
    ground and 9,192,631,774 on a satellite.

    I'm not reading the draft. The draft
    is of no importance.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:11:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Some clocks may fit any nonsense.

    That's not an explanation. That's an escape hatch.

    NTS-2:

    predicted: +446.5 x 10^-12
    measured: +442.5 x 10^-12

    Your answer:

    bad clock.

    Unfortunately, other clocks kept committing the same crime.

    Gravity Probe A compared a hydrogen maser in a rocket with one on
    Earth and confirmed the predicted gravitational frequency shift to
    about 7 x 10^-5.

    Atomic-clock experiments later measured the same gravitational
    rate effect over height differences of:

    thousands of kilometres,
    33 centimetres,
    and eventually millimetres.

    Different clocks.
    Different experiments.
    Different decades.
    Different laboratories.
    Same relativistic dependence.

    So your theory now requires an impressive coincidence:

    every time physicists put sufficiently accurate clocks at different
    velocities or gravitational potentials, the clocks develop precisely
    the "errors" relativity predicted.

    And then you write:

    I read the clocks, obtain t'=t.
    And a second of 9,192,631,770 on the
    ground and 9,192,631,774 on a satellite.

    That's the funniest part.

    You obtain "t'=t" by allowing your supposedly identical "second" to
    contain different numbers of Cs periods at the two locations.

    In other words:

    observe the rate difference,
    absorb it into your definition,
    announce that there is no difference.

    And when an uncorrected clock directly displays the predicted
    difference:

    "Some clocks may fit any nonsense."

    This isn't a physical model anymore, Maciej.

    It's a machine for declaring every confirming experiment defective
    after you have seen its result.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 15:14:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 3:11 PM, Python wrote:
    Some clocks may fit any nonsense.

    That's not an explanation. That's an escape hatch.

    That's not explaination, that's just a fact.


    NTS-2:

    -a-a predicted:-a +446.5 x 10^-12
    -a-a measured:-a-a +442.5 x 10^-12

    Your answer:

    -a-a bad clock.

    Unfortunately, other clocks kept committing the same crime.

    Lie, poor piece of shit. Pendulums would never,
    pulsar clocks would never, Cs clocks hasn't been
    for 50 years.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:16:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Pendulums would never,
    pulsar clocks would never, Cs clocks hasn't been
    for 50 years.

    Wonderful.

    We have progressed from:

    "Some clocks may fit any nonsense"

    to:

    "Yes, but not the clocks I have just selected."

    Unfortunately, clocks have been stubbornly committing this same
    "error" for decades.

    Gravity Probe A:
    a hydrogen maser was flown through a changing gravitational potential
    and compared with hydrogen masers on Earth. The predicted
    gravitational frequency shift was observed.

    NIST, 2010:
    two independent Al+ atomic clocks separated vertically by only 33 cm
    measured the predicted difference in clock rates.

    JILA/NIST, 2022:
    the gravitational frequency shift was resolved across a millimetre-scale
    sample of strontium atoms.

    So now we have:

    cesium clocks,
    hydrogen masers,
    aluminium-ion clocks,
    strontium optical clocks,

    in satellites, rockets and laboratories, over scales ranging from
    thousands of kilometres down to millimetres.

    And whenever the measured rate follows relativity, your explanation is:

    clock error.

    That's quite a remarkable epidemic of clock errors:

    different atoms,
    different technologies,
    different laboratories,
    different decades,

    all mysteriously producing "errors" with the dependence on velocity
    and gravitational potential predicted by relativity.

    As for pendulums: nobody expects an ordinary pendulum to provide the
    precision required for these tests.

    And pulsars are astrophysical clocks, not magic devices exempt from relativistic timing. Pulsar timing is in fact full of relativistic
    corrections.

    At some point, Maciej, "every clock agreeing with the prediction is a
    bad clock" stops being an objection to the experiment.

    It becomes a method for making your claim experimentally unfalsifiable.

    Your rule is now beautifully simple:

    disagrees with relativity -> real clock
    agrees with relativity -> clock error

    With that methodology, you could experimentally prove absolutely
    anything.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 15:26:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 3:16 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Pendulums would never,
    pulsar clocks would never, Cs clocks hasn't been
    for 50 years.

    Wonderful.

    We have progressed from:

    -a-a "Some clocks may fit any nonsense"

    to:

    -a-a "Yes, but not the clocks I have just selected."

    Unfortunately, clocks have been stubbornly committing this same
    "error" for decades.

    Lie, of course, it's just one kind of clocks
    and in GPS they haven't been for 50 years.

    in satellites, rockets and laboratories, over scales ranging from
    thousands of kilometres down to millimetres.

    And in serious measurement system correctly
    calibrated - not anymore.


    As for pendulums: nobody expects an ordinary pendulum to provide the precision required for these tests.

    And as for your junk - nobody serious as well.

    It becomes a method for making your claim experimentally unfalsifiable.

    I've told you - serious models always
    are. Have your bunch of idiots falsified
    Euclidean geometry?




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 14:31:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    And in serious measurement system correctly
    calibrated - not anymore.

    You keep accidentally explaining the point.

    YES.

    Once correctly calibrated, the predicted effect is compensated.

    That is what calibration is FOR.

    Your argument has now become:

    uncorrected clock shows predicted relativistic shift:
    "junk clock"

    clock corrected for predicted relativistic shift:
    "See! No relativistic shift!"

    This is becoming magnificent.

    I've told you - serious models always
    are [unfalsifiable].

    No, Maciej.

    A model protected from every possible experimental result is not
    "serious".

    If:

    prediction confirmed -> irrelevant, bad clock
    prediction contradicted -> relativity wrong
    effect compensated -> effect never existed

    then you have constructed a game in which you cannot lose.

    That's theology, not experimental physics -- amusingly, exactly the
    accusation you have been throwing at everyone else.

    Have your bunch of idiots falsified
    Euclidean geometry?

    Euclidean geometry is a mathematical axiomatic system.

    It is not an empirical theory claiming that physical spacetime MUST be Euclidean.

    You cannot experimentally falsify the theorem of Pythagoras within
    Euclidean geometry.

    You can experimentally test whether Euclidean geometry accurately
    models a particular physical situation.

    After all these years fighting "religion", discovering the distinction
    between mathematics and empirical physics might be your most ambitious
    project yet.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 15:56:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 3:31 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    And in serious measurement system correctly
    calibrated - not anymore.

    You keep accidentally explaining the point.

    YES.

    Once correctly calibrated

    They measure the correct result, which is t'=t.
    Even such a piece of lying shit as you are
    is sometimes admitting that.
    And, of course, they measure with the real
    second instead of your SI ideological absurd.


    I've told you - serious models always
    are [unfalsifiable].

    No, Maciej.
    Yes, Python.
    A model protected from every possible experimental result is not
    "serious".

    Have the idiots from your bunch of idiots
    "falsified" Euclidean geometry?
    That's the quality, unapproachable by your
    primitive gurus.
    And don't bother yourself with repeating your
    ignorant babble, you simply have no clue
    about the subject.






    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 15:00:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Have the idiots from your bunch of idiots
    "falsified" Euclidean geometry?

    You are repeating the same category error.

    Euclidean geometry is an axiomatic mathematical theory.

    Nobody "falsifies" Euclidean geometry by experiment. Its theorems follow
    from its axioms.

    What experiment can test is whether Euclidean geometry is an adequate
    MODEL of some physical situation.

    Those are two completely different statements:

    Euclidean geometry is mathematically valid.

    and:

    physical spacetime is globally Euclidean.

    The first is mathematics.
    The second is an empirical claim.

    you simply have no clue about the subject.

    This is an especially entertaining thing to tell someone with a
    Master's degree in mathematics while confusing an axiomatic theory
    with an empirical model.

    You don't have one, as far as I know.

    Normally I wouldn't mention degrees at all -- arguments matter, not
    diplomas.

    But when YOU decide to lecture ME about what mathematics is, while
    presenting Euclidean geometry as an example of an experimentally
    unfalsifiable physical model...

    well, you rather asked for it.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 16:21:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 4:00 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Have the idiots from your bunch of idiots
    "falsified" Euclidean geometry?

    You are repeating the same category error.

    It's not any category error, you just still
    have no clue about the subject.

    Euclidean geometry is an axiomatic mathematical theory.

    In opposition to The Shit of your idiot
    guru, which is based on postulates (and
    is often also claimed to be a mathematical
    theory by its minions - you're such hopeless
    lying idiots...).

    Nobody "falsifies" Euclidean geometry by experiment.

    There is a story of poor idiot Riemann trying.
    But, sure, it's a serious model.


    Its theorems follow
    from its axioms.

    It's completely different things than
    theorems following postulates, sure.




    What experiment can test is whether Euclidean geometry is an adequate
    MODEL of some physical situation.

    You were already caught at this lie.



    Those are two completely different statements:

    -a-a Euclidean geometry is mathematically valid.

    and:

    -a-a physical spacetime is globally Euclidean.

    The first is mathematics.

    No, it is not.
    2+2=4 - this is mathematics.
    For any right triangle etc - this is mathematics.

    "Euclidean geometry is mathematically valid" is
    some very cheap philosophy.

    The second is an empirical claim.

    No way. You've already lied it is
    empirically verifiable and you had to
    run in shame, poor piece of shit.
    A pity your memory is as worthless
    as your "logic".

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 15:40:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    It's completely different things than
    theorems following postulates, sure.

    Oh dear.

    You have now discovered another distinction without a difference.

    In an axiomatic theory, theorems are derived from the assumptions of
    the theory, traditionally called axioms and, especially in Euclid,
    postulates.

    Calling one of them a "postulate" does not magically turn the
    mathematical system into experimental physics.

    For example, Euclid's parallel postulate can be replaced.

    Do that and you obtain non-Euclidean geometries.

    Nobody has thereby "falsified Euclidean geometry".

    What observation can test is a DIFFERENT proposition:

    physical spatial/spacetime geometry is adequately described
    by Euclidean geometry.

    That proposition most certainly has empirical content.

    You then write:

    "Euclidean geometry is mathematically valid" is
    some very cheap philosophy.

    Fine. Replace my informal phrase by the precise statement:

    If the Euclidean axioms/postulates hold, the theorems derived
    from them follow logically.

    Happy now?

    Pythagoras remains a theorem of Euclidean geometry whether the physical
    surface on which you perform measurements is Euclidean or not.

    On a sphere, for example, construct a geodesic triangle from the North
    Pole to two points on the equator separated by 90 degrees.

    Its angles sum to:

    90 + 90 + 90 = 270 degrees.

    This does not "falsify" Euclidean geometry.

    It demonstrates that Euclidean plane geometry is not the geometry of
    that physical surface.

    That's the distinction you keep missing:

    mathematics:
    what follows from specified assumptions?

    physics:
    which mathematical structure models observations?

    And this is particularly rich:

    you simply have no clue about the subject.

    Maciej, I have a Master's degree in mathematics.

    You don't, as far as I know.

    That does not make me right and you wrong -- the argument above does.

    But if you're going to replace mathematical arguments with claims about
    who "has no clue about the subject", choosing mathematics was a
    spectacularly unfortunate subject for you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 16:57:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 4:40 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    It's completely different things than
    theorems following postulates, sure.

    Oh dear.

    You have now discovered another distinction without a difference.

    In an axiomatic theory, theorems are derived from the assumptions of
    the theory, traditionally called axioms and, especially in Euclid, postulates.

    Calling one of them a "postulate" does not magically turn the
    mathematical system into experimental physics.

    Sorry, poor piece of shit, as anyobe can
    see in the case of your mad Shit - it
    does.
    Anyway, I'm far from claiming that EG
    is physics, it's a serious model.

    Pythagoras remains a theorem of Euclidean geometry whether the physical surface on which you perform measurements is Euclidean or not.

    Samely - the idiocies of The Shit remain
    idiocies of The Shit even when the real
    clocks measure t'=t.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 16:04:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    I'm far from claiming that EG is physics,
    it's a serious model.

    Exactly. Mathematics gives the model; experiment tells us whether it
    describes physical reality.

    real clocks measure t'=t.

    After compensation.

    The interesting measurement is BEFORE compensation. NTS-2 measured
    essentially the relativistic prediction.

    So give us your prediction for the uncorrected clock.

    A number, Maciej. Not another insult.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 17:16:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 5:04 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    I'm far from claiming that EG is physics,
    it's a serious model.

    Exactly. Mathematics gives the model; experiment tells us whether it describes physical reality.

    real clocks measure t'=t.

    After compensation.

    Explaining why measurement don't fit your
    idiocies doesn't change the fact they don't
    fit your idiocies.

    The interesting measurement is BEFORE compensation.

    You're a brainwashed, fanatic idiot, your
    opinion of "what is interesting" is
    worthless. Sorry, poor piece of shit.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 16:21:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Explaining why measurement don't fit your
    idiocies doesn't change the fact they don't
    fit your idiocies.

    But they DO fit the prediction.

    Before compensation: about +38 microseconds/day.

    After compensation: approximately zero accumulated difference.

    You point at the second measurement and carefully ignore the first.

    your opinion of "what is interesting" is
    worthless.

    It's not an opinion.

    If you want to know whether a correction compensates a predicted
    effect, you measure the system BEFORE applying the correction.

    Calling that "brainwashed fanaticism" is certainly easier than giving
    your own quantitative prediction.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 17:34:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 5:21 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Explaining why measurement don't fit your
    idiocies doesn't change the fact they don't
    fit your idiocies.

    But they DO fit the prediction.

    Prediction - 38us a day.
    Measurement - 0.
    Python - a piece of mindless,
    lying, fanatic shit.



    your opinion of "what is interesting" is
    worthless.

    It's not an opinion.

    Pfffff.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 16:36:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Maciej,

    Prediction - 38us a day.
    Measurement - 0.

    You keep omitting two words:

    AFTER COMPENSATION.

    Prediction before compensation: about +38 us/day.

    Measurement before compensation: about +38 us/day.

    Measurement after compensation: about 0.

    That's not a failure of the prediction.

    That's the compensation working.

    At this point your argument is literally:

    Prediction: X.
    Measure X.
    Correct X.
    Measure 0.
    Therefore prediction X was wrong.

    Pfffff indeed.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 17:41:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/27/2026 5:36 PM, Python wrote:
    Maciej,

    Prediction - 38us a day.
    Measurement - 0.

    You keep omitting two words:

    -a-a AFTER COMPENSATION.


    And you keep screaming that since you can
    explain why it is 0 instead your moronic
    prediction it is no longer 0 instead
    your moronic prediction.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Halsey Poroskov@sks@kop.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 19:07:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Python wrote:

    Ralph,

    Don't use the word 'proper'. Its just part of you religious jargon.

    Fine. Let's remove the word entirely.

    Engineers have another perfectly ordinary term:

    specific force

    That is what an accelerometer measures.

    idiot, you make shit up as you go; it depends on what device, physics or chemical implementation shows it, thus you are thinking the W shown in g's
    by a piezo material, that's a force, not acceleration. Fucking idiot.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Oct 27 22:31:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can
    be used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in
    free fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
    FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.

    ________________
    | ______ |
    | | m | |
    | |______| |
    | \ |
    | / |
    |________\_______|

    m = 1 kg

    ^
    | upward | downward
    v

    'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure, it
    has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated relative to
    the Earth.

    I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
    If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.



    That can measure acceleration.

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    What is the tension T in the string?


    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, so
    the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.

    The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)

    yes

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward.

    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
    What is the tension T in the string?

    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,
    so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.

    That is correct.

    The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward

    Generally:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
    If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the
    figure.
    If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on the figure.

    This is always true!
    ====================
    It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.



    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.

    There certainly is. You don't understand very basic Physics.


    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
    tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The
    apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.


    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
    of the box?

    a = T/m = 0

    No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that a(mass)- a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
    Get it?

    The box is accelerating at 9.8, which was the force on it as measured
    when it was not falling. Marcel told you that.

    You are babbling again.

    If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you deliberately
    intend to confuse.


    There is but one rather obvious correct answer to this question.


    Yes. Same as above.

    A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat
    road after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force
    that is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring.
    The spring extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient
    to provide the mass with the same acceleration as the car.

    Right.

    So the accelerometer works correctly.
    Acceleration is the tension divided by the mass, a = T/m

    That would be the numerical answer. Yes.

    Do you think the accelerometer would cease to work correctly if the
    orientation is different from horizontal?

    Of course. The car's acceleration acts directly on the box, not the
    mass. The spring tension, after a delay while it stretches, acts on the
    mass. Gravity acts equally on both immediately..so no stretching is
    needed.


    An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
    When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
    it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    You can wonder why, but it is a fact.

    The following may give you a hint:

    Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
    This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The proper acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An accelerometer
    onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#

    No Paul. It show F = 9.8 m/s/s.

    Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
    The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
    hovering 10 m above the ground.
    The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8 m/s-#!

    The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is not transmitted to the body.

    This is a fact whether you like it or not.

    Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the body,
    even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.

    Of course it is gravitation at play.



    It seems like GR is right:
    Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.
    So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Wed Oct 28 20:11:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 27.10.2026 23:31, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can >>>>> be used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in
    free fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting >>>>> FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a spring inside.

    ________________
    | ______ |
    | | m | |
    | |______| |
    | \ |
    | / |
    |________\_______|

    m = 1 kg

    ^
    | upward | downward
    v

    'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure, it
    has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated relative to
    the Earth.

    I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
    If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.


    That can measure acceleration.

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    What is the tension T in the spring?


    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, so
    the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.

    The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)

    yes

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward.

    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
    What is the tension T in the spring?

    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,
    so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.

    That is correct.

    The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward

    Generally:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
    If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the
    figure.
    If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on the
    figure.

    This is always true!
    ====================
    It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.


    It seems that we agree about this:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
    tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The
    apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.


    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
    of the box?

    a = T/m = 0

    No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that a(mass)- a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
    Get it?

    Don't be ridiculous!
    a(mass) - a(box) = 0 always!

    a(box) = a(mass) = T/m = 0 only in free fall.


    If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you deliberately
    intend to confuse.

    You know of course that an accelerometer works equally
    well in both directions.
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
    the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
    2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
    the figure. (spring streched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)

    Why is this confusing?

    An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
    When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
    it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    You can wonder why, but it is a fact.

    The following may give you a hint:

    Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
    This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The proper
    acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An accelerometer
    onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#

    No Paul. It show F = 9.8 m/s/s.

    Is this meant to be a joke?


    Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
    The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
    hovering 10 m above the ground.
    The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8 m/s-#!

    The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is not transmitted to the body.

    Don't be ridiculous. :-D

    The accelerometer will show the same as if it was stationary
    on the ground, which is 9.8 m/s-# upward.

    The fact that the output from the accelerometer shows
    that the acceleration of the 1kg body is a = 9.8 m/s-#
    _proves_ that the _only_ force acting on the 1kg body
    is the upwards force from the compressed spring: F = 9.8 N.

    So whether the spaceship is far from gravitating masses,
    or is stationary relative to the Earth 10 m above the ground,
    the only force that acts on the 1kg body is the 9.8 N force
    from compressed spring, and the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.


    This is a fact whether you like it or not.

    Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the body, even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.

    Don't be ridiculous!
    The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force
    and 9.8 m/s-# upward acceleration.


    Of course it is gravitation at play.

    But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
    What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
    The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.


    It seems like GR is right:
    Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.
    So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!

    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Wed Oct 28 22:10:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/28/2026 8:11 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force
    and 9.8 m/s-# upward acceleration.


    Of course it is gravitation at play.

    But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
    What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
    The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.

    So, gravitation is - 9.81 upward.
    It's indeed amazing what The Shit of Einstein
    does with the brain of its unfortunate
    victims.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 29 01:04:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their foolishness as "Jett Baklanov":
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.

    Yes, I did write that ':-)
    > idiot
    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.
    *facepalm*

    Ever heard of the commutative law?

    reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.

    While it would have been didactically more prudent to give the
    derivatives in the order of the arguments of the function (which is what
    I had intended, but apparently I was too tired, so I pasted the
    characters in a different order), my equation/total derivative is in no
    way wrong; it is equivalent to the equation posted by this 'nym-shifting
    troll.

    The important point was that with a total derivative there are in
    general _partial_ derivatives involved, not just total derivatives.

    F'up2 sci.math
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris M. Thomasson@chris.m.thomasson.1@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Wed Oct 28 18:37:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/15/2026 1:00 AM, Luke Adodurov wrote:
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Savoy
    Dudnakov":
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
    e 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Dinanath
    Bakuroff":
    HenryWilson wrote:
    On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 07:47:30 -0000 (UTC), Phillup Tsarakov wrote:
    [...] Why would an object accelerate in free fall if it didn't have >>>>>> a force on it?

    [...] not even knowing the kindergarten basics. Forces has nothing to >>>>> do with acceleration, cretin

    Apropos basics: Does

    F = m a

    that has nothing to do with the acceleration, [hysterical fit]
    :-D

    "F" means "force". "m" means "mass". What might "a" mean? Hmmm. :-D

    that's relating everything to anything, correleated in this universe, you stinking sack of half german subhuman excrement; but has nothing to do
    with acceleration. Write down the definition of acceleration, you fucking irrelevant fritzkarte inbreed excrement

    put your foot under a wheel of a train, where the acceleration is zero,
    and see what force you got

    Wrt the everlasting field, everything knows about everything.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 29 07:24:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The 'nym-shifting troll trolled as "Parker Zholudev":
    there are no forces applied in freefall, only by opposing it; [...]

    That is exactly what general relativity states 8-)

    Objects follow spacetime geodesics unless a force is acting on them.

    See also my public playlist: <https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL41EYJuJ5YuDn3d13ryZwpzGBXewXa9AH>
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 29 11:06:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 28.10.2026 20:11, skrev Paul B. Andersen:

    You know of course that an accelerometer works equally
    well in both directions.
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
    -a-a the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
    2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
    -a-a the figure. (spring stretched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)

    Why is this confusing?

    Well, it seems to be a bit confusing! :-D

    With my definition of the sign of T, it should be:
    (T and a have the same sign)

    1: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
    the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
    2: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
    the figure. (spring stretched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)


    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn@PointedEars@web.de to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 29 15:50:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Chris M. Thomasson wrote:
    Wrt the everlasting field, everything knows about everything.

    This does not appear to be mathematics or (relativistic) physics.

    What the heck are you talking about?

    F'up2 sci.physics.relativity
    --
    PointedEars

    Twitter: @PointedEars2
    Please do not cc me. / Bitte keine Kopien per E-Mail.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 29 15:22:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Wed, 28 Oct 2026 20:11:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 27.10.2026 23:31, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it
    can be used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration >>>>>> in free fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely
    acting FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a spring inside.

    ________________
    | ______ |
    | | m | |
    | |______| |
    | \ |
    | / |
    |________\_______|

    m = 1 kg

    ^
    | upward | downward
    v

    'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure, it
    has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated relative to
    the Earth.

    I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
    If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.


    That can measure acceleration.

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    What is the tension T in the spring?


    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, so
    the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.

    The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)

    yes

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward.

    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
    What is the tension T in the spring?

    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,
    so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.

    That is correct.

    The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward

    Generally:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
    If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the
    figure.
    If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on the
    figure.

    This is always true!
    ====================
    It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.


    It seems that we agree about this:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
    tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The
    apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.


    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration >>>>> of the box?

    a = T/m = 0

    No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that
    a(mass)-
    a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
    Get it?

    Don't be ridiculous!
    a(mass) - a(box) = 0 always!

    Wrong again...when the box accelerates there is an important time lag
    before the body catches up..but I was talking about during free fall
    anyway.

    a(box) = a(mass) = T/m = 0 only in free fall.

    You just said above that it is zero ALWAYS. Make up your mind Paul,

    That's what I said. That is the general solution in free fall when there
    is acceleration but so tension.

    If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass
    hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you
    deliberately intend to confuse.

    You know of course that an accelerometer works equally well in both directions.

    Only over a small range. Compressing a spring is limited...

    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
    the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
    2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
    the figure. (spring streched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)

    Why is this confusing?

    Springs are flexible. Have you never used I coil spring? If a large mass
    is fixed to the top it will lean over. Maybe you only know of the
    cantilever type.

    Normally, the body would be hanging downwards, for obvious reasons.

    An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
    When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
    it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    You can wonder why, but it is a fact.

    The following may give you a hint:

    Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
    This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The proper
    acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An accelerometer
    onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#

    No Paul. It shows Force = 9.8 m/s/s.

    Is this meant to be a joke?

    You are the joke Paul...along with your friend Einstein.

    Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
    The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
    hovering 10 m above the ground.
    The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8
    m/s-#!

    The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself
    but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is not
    transmitted to the body.

    Don't be ridiculous. :-D

    The accelerometer will show the same as if it was stationary on the
    ground, which is 9.8 m/s-# upward.

    That's right. The engine thrust is not transmitted to the body. The only change is that the upward force that was exerted by the ground on the
    rocket is now exerted by the reaction to the momentum increase of the propellant. The hanging body is not affected by the firing of the engine.

    The fact that the output from the accelerometer shows that the
    acceleration of the 1kg body is a = 9.8 m/s-# _proves_ that the _only_
    force acting on the 1kg body is the upwards force from the compressed
    spring: F = 9.8 N.

    Paul, will you please act normally and turn you box upside down.

    ...but whichever way it hangs, TWO forces act on it when siting on the
    ground. The spring tension and gravity. It has NO acceleration. Only
    idiots like Einstein believe it does. In free fall the tension becomes
    zero + minuscule gravity gradient

    So whether the spaceship is far from gravitating masses,
    or is stationary relative to the Earth 10 m above the ground,
    the only force that acts on the 1kg body is the 9.8 N force from
    compressed spring, and the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    No Paul, you have been badly indoctrinated. Gravity is a force, not an acceleration. Newton's law say it all. Einstein thought he was greater
    than Newton and stuffed up the whole of Physics for 120 years.

    This is a fact whether you like it or not.

    Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the
    body,
    even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.

    Don't be ridiculous!
    The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force and 9.8 m/s-# upward acceleration.

    where is your dv/dt Paul? Where is your dx/dt?

    Of course it is gravitation at play.

    But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
    What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
    The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.

    Like I said, you have been badly indoctrinated. There is no d2x/dt2.
    Tell me Paul, when two bar magnets are stuck firmly together, do you
    really think they accelerating towards each other?
    You can see them ACCELERATING very rapidly while they are coming together...and that acceleration ceases when they do. Surely you wont
    argue about that.
    The same applies to a +ve and -ve charge coming together..precisely in
    line with gravity.

    It seems like GR is right:
    Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.

    Paul, they don't even have the same dimensions.

    So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!

    Yes! That one reason Physics has gone completely off the rails.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Judd Tsarenkov@nt@nensnedd.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 29 21:53:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    The 'nym-shifting troll trolled as "Parker Zholudev":
    there are no forces applied in freefall, only by opposing it; [...]

    That is exactly what general relativity states 8-)

    Objects follow spacetime geodesics unless a force is acting on them.

    See also my public playlist:

    he rather shits on your grave, you stupid sack of shit; like yesterday you said exactly the opposite, you stinking subhuman excrement, half german
    half Russian; ask your mothers, historically
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Emiliano Baikowsky@ikwna@bkose.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 29 21:56:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their foolishness as "Jett
    Baklanov":
    Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:

    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.

    Yes, I did write that '
    > idiot
    dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.
    *facepalm*

    Ever heard of the commutative law?

    you stinking fucking uneducated imbecile, you put there the "commutative
    low" for no reason, you stinking sack of putrid excrement
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 30 22:25:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 29.10.2026 16:22, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Wed, 28 Oct 2026 20:11:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 27.10.2026 23:31, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it >>>>>>> can be used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration >>>>>>> in free fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely
    acting FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a spring inside. >>>>>>
    ________________
    | ______ |
    | | m | |
    | |______| |
    | \ |
    | / |
    |________\_______|

    m = 1 kg

    ^
    | upward | downward
    v

    'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure, it >>>> has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated relative to >>>> the Earth.

    I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
    If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.


    That can measure acceleration.

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    What is the tension T in the spring?


    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, so >>>> the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.

    The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)

    yes

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward.

    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
    What is the tension T in the spring?

    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward, >>>> so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.

    That is correct.

    The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward

    Generally:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
    If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the
    figure.
    If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on the >>>> figure.

    This is always true!
    ====================
    It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.

    Note this: According to Newton!



    It seems that we agree about this:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
    tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The >>>>>>> apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero. >>>>>>

    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration >>>>>> of the box?

    a = T/m = 0

    No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that
    a(mass)-
    a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
    Get it?

    Don't be ridiculous!
    a(mass) - a(box) = 0 always!

    This means: a(mass) = a(box) always.


    Wrong again...when the box accelerates there is an important time lag
    before the body catches up..but I was talking about during free fall
    anyway.

    So in free fall it is a delay before the acceleration of
    the body with acceleration zero becomes zero? :-D

    I find it rather amazing that you seem to believe that
    real accelerometers are 1 kg masses hanging in a long
    steel spring. My accelerometer is obviously only meant to
    illustrate the principle of an accelerometer.

    Real accelerometers are electronic devices and the most used
    'spring' is a piezoelectric crystal (like quartz). The delay is
    in the ms range or faster. The data of an accelerometer will
    vary depending on what use it is built for.

    Even you must understand that when for example cars are crash-tested
    a lot of accelerometers are used. Testing shocks demands fast
    accelerometers.



    a(box) = a(mass) = T/m = 0 only in free fall.

    You just said above that it is zero ALWAYS. Make up your mind Paul,

    Did I say: a(box) = a(mass) = 0 always? :-D

    Only in free fall is a(box) = a(mass) = 0.


    That's what I said. That is the general solution in free fall when there
    is acceleration but so tension.

    So according to Henry Wilson a = T/m rea 0 when T = 0

    Ralph, it is a fact that an accelerometer in an orbiting
    satellite show zero acceleration.

    Why do you keep disputing what you must know is true?


    If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass
    hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you
    deliberately intend to confuse.

    You know of course that an accelerometer works equally well in both
    directions.

    Only over a small range. Compressing a spring is limited...

    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
    the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
    2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
    the figure. (spring streched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)

    Why is this confusing?

    Springs are flexible. Have you never used I coil spring? If a large mass
    is fixed to the top it will lean over. Maybe you only know of the
    cantilever type.

    Normally, the body would be hanging downwards, for obvious reasons.

    Normally accelerometers aren't 1kg bodies hanging in a spring.

    Now you know better, or don't you?


    An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
    When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
    it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    You can wonder why, but it is a fact.

    The following may give you a hint:

    Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
    This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The proper
    acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An accelerometer
    onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#

    No Paul. It shows Force = 9.8 m/s/s.

    Is this meant to be a joke?

    You are the joke Paul...along with your friend Einstein.

    Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
    The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
    hovering 10 m above the ground.
    The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8
    m/s-#!

    The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself
    but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is not
    transmitted to the body.

    Don't be ridiculous. :-D

    The accelerometer will show the same as if it was stationary on the
    ground, which is 9.8 m/s-# upward.

    That's right. The engine thrust is not transmitted to the body.

    This is too idiotic even for you.
    It is the acceleration of the body that is measured.
    That acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    That means that the force on the body is 9.8 N.
    From where do you think this force comes?

    The only
    change is that the upward force that was exerted by the ground on the
    rocket is now exerted by the reaction to the momentum increase of the propellant. The hanging body is not affected by the firing of the engine.

    The fact that the output from the accelerometer shows that the
    acceleration of the 1kg body is a = 9.8 m/s-# _proves_ that the _only_
    force acting on the 1kg body is the upwards force from the compressed
    spring: F = 9.8 N.

    Paul, will you please act normally and turn you box upside down.

    ...but whichever way it hangs, TWO forces act on it when siting on the ground. The spring tension and gravity. It has NO acceleration. Only
    idiots like Einstein believe it does. In free fall the tension becomes
    zero + minuscule gravity gradient

    So whether the spaceship is far from gravitating masses,
    or is stationary relative to the Earth 10 m above the ground,
    the only force that acts on the 1kg body is the 9.8 N force from
    compressed spring, and the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    No Paul, you have been badly indoctrinated. Gravity is a force, not an acceleration. Newton's law say it all. Einstein thought he was greater
    than Newton and stuffed up the whole of Physics for 120 years.

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground
    shows that the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.

    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D


    This is a fact whether you like it or not.

    Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the
    body,
    even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.

    Don't be ridiculous!
    The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force and 9.8 m/s-# upward
    acceleration.

    where is your dv/dt Paul? Where is your dx/dt?

    Does the fact that the coordinate acceleration of
    the astronaut in the rocket is zero make him weightless?

    No, he can feel his seat pushing him upwards with the force
    F = m*(9.8 m/s-#)N where m is his mass.


    Of course it is gravitation at play.

    But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
    What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
    The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.

    Like I said, you have been badly indoctrinated. There is no d2x/dt2.
    Tell me Paul, when two bar magnets are stuck firmly together, do you
    really think they accelerating towards each other?
    You can see them ACCELERATING very rapidly while they are coming together...and that acceleration ceases when they do. Surely you wont
    argue about that.
    The same applies to a +ve and -ve charge coming together..precisely in
    line with gravity.

    It seems like GR is right:
    Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.

    Paul, they don't even have the same dimensions.

    So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!

    Yes! That one reason Physics has gone completely off the rails.


    Interesting.
    The fact that an accelerometer at the ground show that
    acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward has made Physics go
    completely off the rails.

    Whose Physics has gone off the rail because an accelerometer
    works according to Newton's second law of motion?

    Newton's second law of motion, F = dp/dt, is valid in SR/GR
    and NM.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 16:54:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 29.10.2026 16:22, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Wed, 28 Oct 2026 20:11:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 27.10.2026 23:31, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:

    A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it >>>>>>>> can be used in that way. It is not designed to measure
    acceleration in free fall.
    It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely >>>>>>>> acting FORCES.

    An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a spring inside. >>>>>>>
    ________________
    | ______ |
    | | m | |
    | |______| |
    | \ |
    | / |
    |________\_______|

    m = 1 kg

    ^
    | upward | downward
    v

    'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure,
    it has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated
    relative to the Earth.

    I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
    If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.


    That can measure acceleration.

    1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
    What is the tension T in the spring?


    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, >>>>> so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.

    The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)

    yes

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward. >>>>
    2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
    What is the tension T in the spring?

    We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-#
    downward, so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N
    downward.

    That is correct.

    The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)

    This works both ways.
    If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward >>>>>
    Generally:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
    If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the >>>>> figure.
    If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
    the figure.

    This is always true!
    ====================
    It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.

    Note this: According to Newton!



    It seems that we agree about this:
    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
    tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The >>>>>>>> apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension
    correctly...zero.


    3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the
    acceleration
    of the box?

    a = T/m = 0

    No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that
    a(mass)-
    a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
    Get it?

    Don't be ridiculous!
    a(mass) - a(box) = 0 always!

    This means: a(mass) = a(box) always.


    Wrong again...when the box accelerates there is an important time lag
    before the body catches up..but I was talking about during free fall
    anyway.

    So in free fall it is a delay before the acceleration of the body with acceleration zero becomes zero? :-D

    I find it rather amazing that you seem to believe that real
    accelerometers are 1 kg masses hanging in a long steel spring. My accelerometer is obviously only meant to illustrate the principle of an accelerometer.

    Real accelerometers are electronic devices and the most used 'spring' is
    a piezoelectric crystal (like quartz). The delay is in the ms range or faster. The data of an accelerometer will vary depending on what use it
    is built for.

    Paul. You don't have a clue. The delay, whether it is ten seconds or a nanosecond is fundamental to the whole operation. ..and it doesn't matter
    if the spring is steel or crystal, the same principles apply. If an acceleration is not horizontal, the FORCE of gravity will affect the operation.

    Even you must understand that when for example cars are crash-tested a
    lot of accelerometers are used. Testing shocks demands fast
    accelerometers.

    Yes Paul. So why did you draw your silly upside down box with a spring and
    a mass on it? That is what we are discussing.


    a(box) = a(mass) = T/m = 0 only in free fall.

    You just said above that it is zero ALWAYS. Make up your mind Paul,

    Did I say: a(box) = a(mass) = 0 always? :-D

    Only in free fall is a(box) = a(mass) = 0.

    Paul, you said "This means: a(mass) = a(box) always.".......(1)

    Can you not do simple maths any more? Can you not see that (1) means
    'a(mass) - a(box) = 0 always'


    That's what I said. That is the general solution in free fall when
    there is acceleration but so tension.

    So according to Henry Wilson a = T/m rea 0 when T = 0

    Ralph, it is a fact that an accelerometer in an orbiting satellite show
    zero acceleration.

    Why should it not? It wasn't designed to work in free fall. An
    'accelerometer' is not an accelerometer. It measures force. Whatever type
    of 'spring' is used it will have no tension in free fall.
    conditions...even though an orbiting object is constantly accelerating. I suppose your religion denies the existence of centripetal acceleration.
    Its 'curved spacetime crap' replaces it.

    Why do you keep disputing what you must know is true?

    I keep disputing what YOU, in your ignorance of basic Physics, think is
    true.

    If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass
    hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you
    deliberately intend to confuse.

    You know of course that an accelerometer works equally well in both
    directions.

    Only over a small range. Compressing a spring is limited...

    The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.

    1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
    the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
    2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
    the figure. (spring streched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)

    Why is this confusing?

    Springs are flexible. Have you never used I coil spring? If a large
    mass is fixed to the top it will lean over. Maybe you only know of the
    cantilever type.

    Normally, the body would be hanging downwards, for obvious reasons.

    Normally accelerometers aren't 1kg bodies hanging in a spring.

    Now you know better, or don't you?


    An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
    When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
    it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    You can wonder why, but it is a fact.

    The following may give you a hint:

    Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
    This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The
    proper acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An
    accelerometer onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#

    No Paul. It shows Force = 9.8 m/s/s.

    Is this meant to be a joke?

    You are the joke Paul...along with your friend Einstein.

    Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
    The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
    hovering 10 m above the ground.
    The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8
    m/s-#!

    The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself
    but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is
    not transmitted to the body.

    Don't be ridiculous. :-D

    The accelerometer will show the same as if it was stationary on the
    ground, which is 9.8 m/s-# upward.

    That's right. The engine thrust is not transmitted to the body.

    This is too idiotic even for you.
    It is the acceleration of the body that is measured.
    That acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    That means that the force on the body is 9.8 N.
    From where do you think this force comes?

    Paul, your knowledge of basic Physics is virtually no existent. There are
    TWO equal forces on the body...spring tension up and gravity down. That's
    why is does not accelerate.

    The only change is that the upward force that was exerted by the ground
    on the rocket is now exerted by the reaction to the momentum increase
    of the propellant. The hanging body is not affected by the firing of
    the engine.

    That's what I just told you.

    The fact that the output from the accelerometer shows that the
    acceleration of the 1kg body is a = 9.8 m/s-# _proves_ that the _only_
    force acting on the 1kg body is the upwards force from the compressed
    spring: F = 9.8 N.

    Paul, will you please act normally and turn you box upside down.

    ...but whichever way it hangs, TWO forces act on it when siting on the
    ground. The spring tension and gravity. It has NO acceleration. Only
    idiots like Einstein believe it does. In free fall the tension becomes
    zero + minuscule gravity gradient

    So whether the spaceship is far from gravitating masses,
    or is stationary relative to the Earth 10 m above the ground,
    the only force that acts on the 1kg body is the 9.8 N force from
    compressed spring, and the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    No Paul, you have been badly indoctrinated. Gravity is a force, not an
    acceleration. Newton's law say it all. Einstein thought he was greater
    than Newton and stuffed up the whole of Physics for 120 years.

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that
    the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.

    gawd! Paul has changed religion. He is now an 'Earth Expansionist'. He
    thinks the reason we don't fall off the Earth is because its surface is continually accelerating outwards.

    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity is
    a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the
    ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body is
    not accelerating.


    This is a fact whether you like it or not.

    Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the
    body,
    even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.

    Don't be ridiculous!
    The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force and 9.8 m/s-# upward
    acceleration.

    where is your dv/dt Paul? Where is your dx/dt?

    Does the fact that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut in the
    rocket is zero make him weightless?

    'Weight' is mass x force. There only one force on the astronaut, gravity...acting normally to his velocity vector. It causes him to
    continually change direction.


    No, he can feel his seat pushing him upwards with the force F = m*(9.8 m/s-#)N where m is his mass.


    Of course it is gravitation at play.

    But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
    What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
    The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.

    Like I said, you have been badly indoctrinated. There is no d2x/dt2.
    Tell me Paul, when two bar magnets are stuck firmly together, do you
    really think they accelerating towards each other?
    You can see them ACCELERATING very rapidly while they are coming
    together...and that acceleration ceases when they do. Surely you wont
    argue about that.
    The same applies to a +ve and -ve charge coming together..precisely in
    line with gravity.

    It seems like GR is right:
    Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.

    Paul, they don't even have the same dimensions.

    So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!

    Yes! That one reason Physics has gone completely off the rails.


    Interesting.
    The fact that an accelerometer at the ground show that acceleration is
    9.8 m/s-# upward has made Physics go completely off the rails.

    It shows gravity FORCE is acting downward on the body and the box and the upward ground compression is acting directly on the box but through the
    spring tension on the body.

    Whose Physics has gone off the rail because an accelerometer works
    according to Newton's second law of motion?

    Newton's second law of motion, F = dp/dt, is valid in SR/GR and NM.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Valery Katsepov@peae@akraes.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 18:03:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    HenryWilson wrote:

    Real accelerometers are electronic devices and the most used 'spring'
    is a piezoelectric crystal (like quartz). The delay is in the ms range
    or faster. The data of an accelerometer will vary depending on what use
    it is built for.

    Paul. You don't have a clue. The delay, whether it is ten seconds or a nanosecond is fundamental to the whole operation. ..and it doesn't
    matter if the spring is steel or crystal, the same principles apply. If
    an acceleration is not horizontal, the FORCE of gravity will affect the operation.

    the most today are cheap 3D force accelerometer, and you are correct, you
    need a closesd to no mass accelerometer, ie optical, laser based accelerometers

    also, just take 2 shots of an object fixed as stationary reference, then calculate based on the zoom factor, or a table
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 22:29:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that
    the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.

    gawd! Paul has changed religion. He is now an 'Earth Expansionist'. He
    thinks the reason we don't fall off the Earth is because its surface is continually accelerating outwards.

    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity is
    a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the
    ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body is
    not accelerating.

    I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer
    on the ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.

    And then you can explain why real accelerometers do not
    show what Newton say they should show. What are the alternative
    laws of nature that an accelerometer obey?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 04:18:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that
    the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.

    gawd! Paul has changed religion. He is now an 'Earth Expansionist'. He
    thinks the reason we don't fall off the Earth is because its surface is
    continually accelerating outwards.

    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity
    is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the
    ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body
    is not accelerating.

    I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
    ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.

    Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised that your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining to you that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration. It is calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring
    tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o course, zero.
    If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
    immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring has contracted. Get it now?

    And then you can explain why real accelerometers do not show what Newton
    say they should show. What are the alternative laws of nature that an accelerometer obey?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 04:24:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 18:03:04 -0000 (UTC), Valery Katsepov wrote:

    HenryWilson wrote:

    Real accelerometers are electronic devices and the most used 'spring'
    is a piezoelectric crystal (like quartz). The delay is in the ms range
    or faster. The data of an accelerometer will vary depending on what
    use it is built for.

    Paul. You don't have a clue. The delay, whether it is ten seconds or a
    nanosecond is fundamental to the whole operation. ..and it doesn't
    matter if the spring is steel or crystal, the same principles apply. If
    an acceleration is not horizontal, the FORCE of gravity will affect the
    operation.

    the most today are cheap 3D force accelerometer, and you are correct,
    you need a closesd to no mass accelerometer, ie optical, laser based accelerometers

    also, just take 2 shots of an object fixed as stationary reference, then calculate based on the zoom factor, or a table.

    Maybe you would need three shots.

    Yes. I don't know what they use in Aeroplanes...presumably radar or GPS
    but a cheap spring type would have to be corrected for gravity.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 14:53:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that >>>> the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity
    is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the
    ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body
    is not accelerating.


    I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
    ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.

    And this is your answer:

    Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised that your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining to you that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration. It is calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o course, zero.
    If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
    immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring has contracted. Get it now?

    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
    at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to
    the spring is the force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
    acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
    that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
    so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
    The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
    a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
    the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
    But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
    because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
    the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
    force -F acting on the body.

    So we can sum it up thus:
    Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
    on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
    claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion doesn't
    apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#

    Is it possible to make an accelerometer which
    correctly can measure a static horizontal acceleration
    and, when turned 90 degrees, will show the static vertical
    acceleration is zero?
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 17:35:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 11/1/2026 2:53 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that >>>>> the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course-a I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity >>>> is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the >>>> ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body
    is not accelerating.


    I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
    ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.

    And this is your answer:

    Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised
    that
    your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining to
    you
    that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration. It is
    calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring
    tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of
    gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o
    course, zero.
    If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
    immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring has
    contracted. Get it now?

    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
    at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to
    the spring is the force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
    acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
    that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
    so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
    The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
    a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
    the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
    But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
    because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
    the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
    force -F acting on the body.

    So we can sum it up thus:
    Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
    on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
    claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion doesn't apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#

    And poor idiot Paul B.Andersen claims that since
    his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
    sharks eating fishes are improper.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 18:38:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows
    that the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says
    gravity is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local
    compression of the ground is pushing the object up. There is no
    residual force. The body is not accelerating.


    I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
    ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.

    And this is your answer:

    Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised
    that your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep
    explaining to you that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure
    acceleration. It is calibrated according to spring extension and
    therefore measures spring tension directly...a force. When on the
    ground, it measure the force of gravity acting on the hanging mass,
    nothing else. Its acceleration is o course, zero.
    If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
    immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring
    has contracted. Get it now?

    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
    somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is the
    force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration a
    = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration
    is 9.8 m/s-#.

    Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its tension
    is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body with that force.

    The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
    The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is a = 9.8 m/s-#
    upward, because the spring is still exerting the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
    But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
    because the upward force from the spring doesn't make the body
    accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward force -F acting on
    the body.

    Paul, I can only feel sorry for you. All you have done is replace the
    upward force on the rocket (and box) exerted by the local compression of
    the ground with the upward reaction (pressure) to the propellant's
    continuous change in momentum. Neither the body nor its position are
    affected in any way. The box is still effectively fixed to the ground and
    the spring extension is still a measure of the downward force of gravity acting on the body.

    So we can sum it up thus:
    Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer on
    the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion doesn't apply
    on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#

    Paul, you have been indoctrinated with the belief that force does not
    exist. You are incapable of understanding that your 'accelerometer' is
    really a 'force meter'. It is calibrated according to spring extension, in other words 'the force on each end'. As therapy for your unfortunate
    mental condition I suggest you place a pair of strain gauges between two neodymium bar magnets that are trying to repel each other. I don't think
    you will find any acceleration...just lots of genuine force.

    Is it possible to make an accelerometer which correctly can measure a
    static horizontal acceleration and, when turned 90 degrees, will show
    the static vertical acceleration is zero?

    (...'static vertical acceleration' ain't goin' nowhere fast)

    Paul, your static vertical rocket is not accelerating. It has two equal
    and opposite forces acting on it...and so has the body.

    Paul, answer this. Why would a spring extend if it didn't have forces
    pulling on each end? Would Einstein's fairies be playing games again?

    ...and by the way, Paul, there's no god either...so if you ever muster the courage to admit Einstein was wrong about gravity you wont end up in hell!



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alston Bachmanov@mooam@ooc.ru to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 19:43:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    HenryWilson wrote:

    On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
    somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is the
    force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration a
    = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration
    is 9.8 m/s-#.

    Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its tension
    is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body with that force.

    idiot, a peiezo electric film or shaped material is usually triggered by
    an electric frequency from 40 kHz (ultrasound) to 4 MHz; kiss my ass
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Python@python@cccp.invalid to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 21:07:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Le 01/11/2026 |a 17:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/1/2026 2:53 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that >>>>>> the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course-a I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity >>>>> is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the >>>>> ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body >>>>> is not accelerating.


    I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
    ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.

    And this is your answer:

    Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised
    that
    your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining to
    you
    that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration. It is >>> calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring
    tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of
    gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o
    course, zero.
    If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
    immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring has >>> contracted. Get it now?

    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
    at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to
    the spring is the force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
    acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
    that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
    so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
    The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
    a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
    the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
    But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
    because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
    the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
    force -F acting on the body.

    So we can sum it up thus:
    Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
    on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
    claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion doesn't
    apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#

    And poor idiot Paul B.Andersen claims that since
    his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
    sharks eating fishes are improper.

    Maciej,

    his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
    sharks eating fishes are improper.

    No.

    Once again you are trying to extract ordinary English from a technical
    term.

    "Proper acceleration" does not mean:

    good acceleration
    correct acceleration
    morally appropriate acceleration

    any more than "proper time" means "perfect time".

    And no guru is required here. A spring and Newton are enough.

    Drop the accelerometer:

    case and test mass both fall
    spring extension -> 0
    accelerometer reading -> 0

    Support it on the ground:

    case is supported
    test mass is pulled downward by gravity
    spring is extended
    accelerometer reading -> g

    Put it in a rocket accelerating at g far from gravity:

    case pushes the test mass
    spring is extended
    accelerometer reading -> g

    Those are physical predictions about an actual instrument.

    Calling one of them "sharks eating grass" changes neither the spring
    extension nor the reading.

    You have now spent several days trying to derive physics from the ordinary-English meanings of technical adjectives.

    First:

    proper -> correct -> perfect

    Now:

    proper acceleration -> improper acceleration -> sharks.

    At this rate, discovering "proper fraction" in a mathematics textbook
    is going to be devastating.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 17:17:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Python wrote:
    Le 01/11/2026 |a 17:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/1/2026 2:53 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows >>>>>>> that
    the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course-a I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says
    gravity
    is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression
    of the
    ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body >>>>>> is not accelerating.


    I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
    ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.

    And this is your answer:

    Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm
    surprised that
    your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining
    to you
    that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration.
    It is
    calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring >>>> tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of >>>> gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o >>>> course, zero.
    If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
    immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the
    spring has
    contracted. Get it now?

    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
    at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to
    the spring is the force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
    acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
    that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
    so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
    The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
    a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
    the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
    But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
    because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
    the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
    force -F acting on the body.

    So we can sum it up thus:
    Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
    on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
    claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion
    doesn't apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#

    And poor idiot Paul B.Andersen claims that since
    his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
    sharks eating fishes are improper.

    Maciej,

    his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
    sharks eating fishes are improper.

    No.

    Once again you are trying to extract ordinary English from a technical
    term.

    "Proper acceleration" does not mean:

    -a-a good acceleration
    -a-a correct acceleration
    -a-a morally appropriate acceleration

    any more than "proper time" means "perfect time".

    And no guru is required here. A spring and Newton are enough.

    Drop the accelerometer:

    -a-a case and test mass both fall
    -a-a spring extension -> 0
    -a-a accelerometer reading -> 0

    Support it on the ground:

    -a-a case is supported
    -a-a test mass is pulled downward by gravity
    -a-a spring is extended
    -a-a accelerometer reading -> g

    Put it in a rocket accelerating at g far from gravity:

    -a-a case pushes the test mass
    -a-a spring is extended
    -a-a accelerometer reading -> g

    Those are physical predictions about an actual instrument.

    Calling one of them "sharks eating grass" changes neither the spring extension nor the reading.

    He is referring to shocks in his Volkswagen automobile. Whether or not
    it burns diesel, I did not ascertain. With all the talk of war in the
    Europes and Americas, he has painted his Volkswagen with typical sharks
    and flames detailing. Driving his Volvo is to him, no different than maneuvering a flying fortress through the Rhein. I got most of this from
    the AI watermark in his post a few back indicating 'Fahrvegnugen'.

    The technical physics term for what "shocks" do in a car.

    The general concept is damping.

    More specifically, shock absorbers provide a viscous damping force (approximately proportional to velocity), causing the suspension to
    behave like a damped harmonic oscillator. Three regimes of damping:

    Underdamped: too little shock absorption.
    Critically damped: ideal shock absorption.
    Overdamped: excessive shock absorption.

    The quantity being adjusted is the damping coefficient.
    --
    Sometimes I just feel like I need to get away
    A place where I can be by myself, all alone
    I kinda lay down in the back yard
    Watch the leaves fall down on my face
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Nov 2 08:00:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 11/1/2026 10:07 PM, Python wrote:
    Le 01/11/2026 |a 17:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
    On 11/1/2026 2:53 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows >>>>>>> that
    the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
    And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
    Or do you claim otherwise? :-D

    Of course-a I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says
    gravity
    is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression
    of the
    ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body >>>>>> is not accelerating.


    I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
    ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.

    And this is your answer:

    Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm
    surprised that
    your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining
    to you
    that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration.
    It is
    calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring >>>> tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of >>>> gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o >>>> course, zero.
    If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
    immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the
    spring has
    contracted. Get it now?

    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
    at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to
    the spring is the force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
    acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
    that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
    so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
    The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
    a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
    the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
    But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
    because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
    the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
    force -F acting on the body.

    So we can sum it up thus:
    Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
    on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
    claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion
    doesn't apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#

    And poor idiot Paul B.Andersen claims that since
    his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
    sharks eating fishes are improper.

    Maciej,

    his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
    sharks eating fishes are improper.

    No.


    Yes, poor piece of shit, yes.
    Your Shit doesn't come from any
    experiments, it comes from your mad,
    blind faith that your desynchronizing
    junk are perfectly good clocks - and
    so on.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Nov 2 22:40:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 01.11.2026 19:38, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
    somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is the
    force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration a
    = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration
    is 9.8 m/s-#.

    Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its tension
    is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body with that force.

    The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground so the rocket is
    stationary relative to the ground.
    The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is a = 9.8 m/s-#
    upward, because the spring is still exerting the upward force F = (9.8
    m/s-#)*m on the body.

    According to Henry:
    But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
    because the upward force from the spring doesn't make the body
    accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward force -F acting on
    the body.

    Paul, I can only feel sorry for you. All you have done is replace the
    upward force on the rocket (and box) exerted by the local compression of
    the ground with the upward reaction (pressure) to the propellant's
    continuous change in momentum. Neither the body nor its position are
    affected in any way. The box is still effectively fixed to the ground and
    the spring extension is still a measure of the downward force of gravity acting on the body.

    Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference
    between coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.

    Example 1:
    A centrifuge for testing astronauts has a r = 16m long arm
    and the speed of the astronaut is v = 40 m/s.
    This means that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut
    is a = v-#/r = 100 m/s-# (ree 10.2 g).
    The mass of the astronaut and his spacesuit is m = 100kg.
    According to Newton's second law of motion the inward
    (toward the centre of the centrifuge) force the backrest
    of the astronaut's chair will exert on him will be
    F = mriaa = 10000 N.
    This means that the proper acceleration of the astronaut
    is a = 100 m/s-# .
    An accelerometer in the astronaut's chair would show
    a = 100 m/s-#.
    In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper
    acceleration are equal.

    Example 2:
    The astronaut is in a space vehicle (SV, satellite) orbiting
    the Earth at an altitude h = 680500 m (slightly higher than the ISS).
    This is equivalent to an orbital radius r = 7058637 m.
    The orbital period is p = reU(4-C-#r-|/GM) = 5901.9 s.
    where G is the gravitational constant and M is the mass of Earth.
    The orbital speed is v = 2-Criar/p = 7514.6 m/s.

    The coordinate acceleration of the SV is a = v-#/r = 8.000 m/s-#

    According to Newton's law of gravitation the acceleration is:
    a = F/m = GM/r-# = 8.000 m/s-#
    where F is Newton's gravitational force
    and m is the mass of the SV including the astronaut.
    The question is now if this is the proper acceleration of the SV.

    We know that the astronaut in the SV is weightless. He can feel
    that no force is acting on him. That means that his proper
    acceleration is 0 m/s-#.
    An accelerometer in the SV would show a = 0 m/s-#.
    In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper
    acceleration are different.

    This shows that that "Newton's gravitational force" doesn't exist,
    and F/m is a coordinate acceleration.

    However, when orbits are calculated, it is the coordinate acceleration
    that is used.
    The "gravitational acceleration" is a coordinate acceleration.

    I have made a program which simulates satellites orbiting the Earth.
    See:
    https://paulba.no/Satellites.html
    I have used the post-Newtonian approximation of the gravitational
    acceleration predicted by GR, see the equation shown on this page: https://paulba.no/PerihelionAdvance.html
    I have also tried to use the Newtonian gravitational acceleration
    a = GM/r-#, and I must admit that in the satellite simulation I
    can see no difference between the GR-acceleration and
    the Newton acceleration.
    In stimulations of planet orbits it is a significant difference, though.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Nov 2 22:42:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 11/2/2026 10:40 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference
    between coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.


    Yeah, we should study hard to understand
    the difference between proper sharks eating
    grass and improper sharks eating fishes.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Nov 3 01:51:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 19:43:21 -0000 (UTC), Alston Bachmanov wrote:

    HenryWilson wrote:

    On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
    somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is
    the force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration
    a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper
    acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its
    tension is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body
    with that force.

    idiot, a peiezo electric film or shaped material is usually triggered by
    an electric frequency from 40 kHz (ultrasound) to 4 MHz; kiss my ass

    I'm sure plenty of men already have.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Nov 3 02:48:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 22:42:00 +0100, Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:

    On 11/2/2026 10:40 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference between
    coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.


    Yeah, we should study hard to understand the difference between proper
    sharks eating grass and improper sharks eating fishes.

    The amazing thing is that Einstein must have been just as ignorant as
    these fellows...and so are all the academics in the world's universities
    who still teach something that is trivially nonsensical.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From HenryWilson@Hgw@home.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Nov 3 03:36:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 22:40:01 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:

    Den 01.11.2026 19:38, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
    somewhere in intergalactic space.
    The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is
    the force accelerating the body,
    F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
    According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration
    a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper
    acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.

    Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its
    tension is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body
    with that force.

    The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground so the rocket
    is stationary relative to the ground.
    The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is a = 9.8 m/s-#
    upward, because the spring is still exerting the upward force F = (9.8
    m/s-#)*m on the body.

    According to Henry:
    But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
    because the upward force from the spring doesn't make the body
    accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward force -F acting on
    the body.

    Paul, I can only feel sorry for you. All you have done is replace the
    upward force on the rocket (and box) exerted by the local compression
    of the ground with the upward reaction (pressure) to the propellant's
    continuous change in momentum. Neither the body nor its position are
    affected in any way. The box is still effectively fixed to the ground
    and the spring extension is still a measure of the downward force of
    gravity acting on the body.

    Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference between coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.

    Acceleration is absolute...it has the same magnitude in all frames but its direction is naturally relative. I gather that's what you mean by
    'coordinate' ... because centripetal force acts normally to the velocity vector.

    Example 1:
    A centrifuge for testing astronauts has a r = 16m long arm and the speed
    of the astronaut is v = 40 m/s.
    This means that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut is a = v-#/r
    = 100 m/s-# (ree 10.2 g).
    The mass of the astronaut and his spacesuit is m = 100kg.
    According to Newton's second law of motion the inward (toward the centre
    of the centrifuge) force the backrest of the astronaut's chair will
    exert on him will be
    F = mriaa = 10000 N.
    This means that the proper acceleration of the astronaut is a = 100 m/s-#
    .
    An accelerometer in the astronaut's chair would show a = 100 m/s-#.
    In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are equal.

    Naturally...since they are consequent to the same force.

    Example 2:
    The astronaut is in a space vehicle (SV, satellite) orbiting the Earth
    at an altitude h = 680500 m (slightly higher than the ISS). This is equivalent to an orbital radius r = 7058637 m.
    The orbital period is p = reU(4-C-#r-|/GM) = 5901.9 s.
    where G is the gravitational constant and M is the mass of Earth.
    The orbital speed is v = 2-Criar/p = 7514.6 m/s.

    The coordinate acceleration of the SV is a = v-#/r = 8.000 m/s-#

    According to Newton's law of gravitation the acceleration is:
    a = F/m = GM/r-# = 8.000 m/s-#
    where F is Newton's gravitational force and m is the mass of the SV
    including the astronaut.
    The question is now if this is the proper acceleration of the SV.

    We know that the astronaut in the SV is weightless. He can feel that no
    force is acting on him. That means that his proper acceleration is 0
    m/s-#.
    An accelerometer in the SV would show a = 0 m/s-#.
    In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are different.

    This shows that that "Newton's gravitational force" doesn't exist,
    and F/m is a coordinate acceleration.

    Paul, while I had a few spare moments, I invented a very useful device
    called a nonsometer. I tested it by feeding in some of your posts and
    guess what happened, It blew up...went right off scale...but not before it announced, 'DEFINITELY PROPER NONSENSE...COORDINATES WITH NO ASPECT OF REALITY'.

    However, when orbits are calculated, it is the coordinate acceleration
    that is used.
    The "gravitational acceleration" is a coordinate acceleration.

    Paul, the force of gravity acts identically to the force exerted by the
    chair on the astronaut's back. Both act normally to his velocity. They can
    be considered identical in concept.

    I have made a program which simulates satellites orbiting the Earth.
    See:
    https://paulba.no/Satellites.html I have used the post-Newtonian approximation of the gravitational acceleration predicted by GR, see the equation shown on this page: https://paulba.no/PerihelionAdvance.html I
    have also tried to use the Newtonian gravitational acceleration a =
    GM/r-#, and I must admit that in the satellite simulation I can see no difference between the GR-acceleration and the Newton acceleration.
    In stimulations of planet orbits it is a significant difference, though.

    I already have a very good programs for simulating elliptical orbits and saving their important details, using Newton's equation. The orbit shapes
    are as close to those produced by equation as the computer will resolve. I have also simulated precession, which I found could be largely dependent
    on the speed of gravity...which, purely by accident, might be represented
    by the very small computer iteration error. If you simulate the capture of
    a passing object, you will notice that its orbit will precess for an indefinite time afterwards..but again that could be just an iteration
    error. Simulating three body situations is even more fascinating.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris M. Thomasson@chris.m.thomasson.1@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Nov 2 20:53:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 11/2/2026 7:36 PM, HenryWilson wrote:
    [...]
    I already have a very good programs for simulating elliptical orbits and saving their important details, using Newton's equation. The orbit shapes
    are as close to those produced by equation as the computer will resolve. I have also simulated precession, which I found could be largely dependent
    on the speed of gravity...which, purely by accident, might be represented
    by the very small computer iteration error. If you simulate the capture of
    a passing object, you will notice that its orbit will precess for an indefinite time afterwards..but again that could be just an iteration
    error. Simulating three body situations is even more fascinating.


    The "speed" of gravity is the speed of light?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul B. Andersen@paul.b.andersen@paulba.no to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Nov 3 20:42:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Den 03.11.2026 04:36, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 22:40:01 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference between
    coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.

    Acceleration is absolute...it has the same magnitude in all frames but its direction is naturally relative. I gather that's what you mean by 'coordinate' ... because centripetal force acts normally to the velocity vector.

    Example 1:
    A centrifuge for testing astronauts has a r = 16m long arm and the speed
    of the astronaut is v = 40 m/s.
    This means that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut is a = v-#/r
    = 100 m/s-# (ree 10.2 g).
    The mass of the astronaut and his spacesuit is m = 100kg.
    According to Newton's second law of motion the inward (toward the centre
    of the centrifuge) force the backrest of the astronaut's chair will
    exert on him will be
    F = mriaa = 10000 N.
    This means that the proper acceleration of the astronaut is a = 100 m/s-#
    .
    An accelerometer in the astronaut's chair would show a = 100 m/s-#.
    In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are
    equal.

    Naturally...since they are consequent to the same force.

    Example 2:
    The astronaut is in a space vehicle (SV, satellite) orbiting the Earth
    at an altitude h = 680500 m (slightly higher than the ISS). This is
    equivalent to an orbital radius r = 7058637 m.
    The orbital period is p = reU(4-C-#r-|/GM) = 5901.9 s.
    where G is the gravitational constant and M is the mass of Earth.
    The orbital speed is v = 2-Criar/p = 7514.6 m/s.

    The coordinate acceleration of the SV is a = v-#/r = 8.000 m/s-#

    According to Newton's law of gravitation the acceleration is:
    a = F/m = GM/r-# = 8.000 m/s-#
    where F is Newton's gravitational force and m is the mass of the SV
    including the astronaut.
    The question is now if this is the proper acceleration of the SV.

    We know that the astronaut in the SV is weightless. He can feel that no
    force is acting on him. That means that his proper acceleration is 0
    m/s-#.
    An accelerometer in the SV would show a = 0 m/s-#.
    In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are
    different.

    This shows that that "Newton's gravitational force" doesn't exist,
    and F/m is a coordinate acceleration.

    Paul, while I had a few spare moments, I invented a very useful device
    called a nonsometer. I tested it by feeding in some of your posts and
    guess what happened, It blew up...went right off scale...but not before it announced, 'DEFINITELY PROPER NONSENSE...COORDINATES WITH NO ASPECT OF REALITY'.

    Your well formulated explanation of why I am wrong noted.


    However, when orbits are calculated, it is the coordinate acceleration
    that is used.
    The "gravitational acceleration" is a coordinate acceleration.

    An example:
    The orbital radius of a GPS SV is r = 26561763 m.
    According to Newton the gravitational acceleration is:
    a = F/m = GM/r-# = 0.5650 m/s-#
    where F is the gravitational force, m is the mass of the SV,
    and GM = 3.986004418e14 m-|/s-# is the geocentric gravitational constant.

    The coordinate acceleration of the SV is:
    a = v-#/r where v is the orbital speed of the SV.
    v = reU(ariar) = 3873.8 m/s

    Period: p = 2-Criar/v = 43082.045 s
    which is half a sidereal day as specified in
    the Interface Specification Document.

    So from the gravitational acceleration we now know the exact orbit
    of the GPS SV.


    Paul, the force of gravity acts identically to the force exerted by the
    chair on the astronaut's back. Both act normally to his velocity. They can
    be considered identical in concept.

    No "gravitational force" is acting on a satellite in orbit,
    its proper acceleration is zero as shown by accelerometers.
    This is a fact, and nothing more to discuss.

    Case closed.
    --
    Paul

    https://paulba.no/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From =?UTF-8?Q?Maciej_Wo=C5=BAniak?=@mlwozniak@wp.pl to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Tue Nov 3 21:08:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 11/3/2026 8:42 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
    Den 03.11.2026 04:36, skrev HenryWilson:
    On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 22:40:01 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:


    Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference between
    coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.

    Acceleration is absolute...it has the same magnitude in all frames but
    its
    direction is naturally relative. I gather that's what you mean by
    'coordinate' ... because centripetal force acts normally to the velocity
    vector.

    Example 1:
    A centrifuge for testing astronauts has a r = 16m long arm and the speed >>> of the astronaut is v = 40 m/s.
    This means that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut is a = v-#/r >>> = 100 m/s-# (ree 10.2 g).
    The mass of the astronaut and his spacesuit is m = 100kg.
    According to Newton's second law of motion the inward (toward the centre >>> of the centrifuge) force the backrest of the astronaut's chair will
    exert on him will be
    -a-a F = mriaa = 10000 N.
    This means that the proper acceleration of the astronaut is a = 100 m/s-# >>> .
    An accelerometer in the astronaut's chair would show a = 100 m/s-#.
    In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are >>> equal.

    Naturally...since they are consequent to the same force.

    Example 2:
    The astronaut is in a space vehicle (SV, satellite) orbiting the Earth
    at an altitude h = 680500 m (slightly higher than the ISS). This is
    equivalent to an orbital radius r = 7058637 m.
    The orbital period is p = reU(4-C-#r-|/GM) = 5901.9 s.
    where G is the gravitational constant and M is the mass of Earth.
    The orbital speed is v = 2-Criar/p = 7514.6 m/s.

    The coordinate acceleration of the SV is a = v-#/r = 8.000 m/s-#

    According to Newton's law of gravitation the acceleration is:
    a = F/m = GM/r-# = 8.000 m/s-#
    -a-a-a where F is Newton's gravitational force and m is the mass of the SV >>> -a-a-a including the astronaut.
    The question is now if this is the proper acceleration of the SV.

    We know that the astronaut in the SV is weightless. He can feel that no
    force is acting on him. That means that his proper acceleration is 0
    m/s-#.
    An accelerometer in the SV would show a = 0 m/s-#.
    In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are >>> different.

    This shows that that "Newton's gravitational force" doesn't exist,
    and F/m is a coordinate acceleration.

    Paul, while I had a few spare moments, I invented a very useful device
    called a nonsometer. I tested it by feeding in some of your posts and
    guess what happened, It blew up...went right off scale...but not
    before it
    announced, 'DEFINITELY PROPER NONSENSE...COORDINATES WITH NO ASPECT OF
    REALITY'.

    Your well formulated explanation of why I am wrong noted.

    However, when orbits are calculated, it is the coordinate acceleration
    that is used.
    The "gravitational acceleration" is a coordinate acceleration.

    An example:
    The orbital radius of a GPS SV is r = 26561763 m.
    According to Newton the gravitational acceleration is:
    -aa = F/m = GM/r-# = 0.5650 m/s-#
    where F is the gravitational force, m is the mass of the SV,
    and GM = 3.986004418e14 m-|/s-# is the geocentric gravitational constant.

    The coordinate acceleration of the SV is:
    -a a = v-#/r where v is the orbital speed of the SV.
    -a v = reU(ariar) = 3873.8 m/s

    Period: p = 2-Criar/v = 43082.045 s
    which is half a sidereal day as specified in
    the Interface Specification Document.

    So from the gravitational acceleration we now know the exact orbit
    of the GPS SV.


    Paul, the force of gravity acts identically to the force exerted by the
    chair on the astronaut's back. Both act normally to his velocity. They
    can
    be considered identical in concept.

    No "gravitational force" is acting on a satellite in orbit,
    its proper acceleration is zero as shown by accelerometers.
    This is a fact, and nothing more to discuss.

    Sure. And another fact is that proper sharks eat
    grass; the sharks eating fishes are obviously
    improper.
    Case closed.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2