Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Savoy
Dudnakov":
Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote::-D
e 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Dinanaththat has nothing to do with the acceleration, [hysterical fit]
Bakuroff":
HenryWilson wrote:Apropos basics: Does
On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 07:47:30 -0000 (UTC), Phillup Tsarakov wrote:[...] not even knowing the kindergarten basics. Forces has nothing to >>>>> do with acceleration, cretin
[...] Why would an object accelerate in free fall if it didn't have >>>>>> a force on it?
F = m a
"F" means "force". "m" means "mass". What might "a" mean? Hmmm. :-D
that's relating everything to anything,
correleated in this universe,
[...] but has nothing to do with acceleration.
Write down the definition of acceleration,
[...] irrelevant fritzkarte [...]
[...] under a wheel of a train, where the acceleration is zero,
and see what force you got
that's relating everything to anything,
No.
correleated in this universe,
Word salad.
[...] but has nothing to do with acceleration.
:-D
"a" _means_ "acceleration" there.
Write down the definition of acceleration,
Acceleration is the change of velocity per unit time.
[...] irrelevant fritzkarte [...]
Do you even know what a Fritz!Card /is/?
<https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/AVM_Fritz!Card>
[...] under a wheel of a train, where the acceleration is zero,
Word salad.
and see what force you got
The acceleration of a train is not always zero.
Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
"a" _means_ "acceleration" there.
that's a correlation, [...] made to define the
unit named Newton
Write down the definition of acceleration,Acceleration is the change of velocity per unit time.
[so] there is no force there
and see what force you got
The acceleration of a train is not always zero.
it is when it stops on your foot, cretin;
"a" _means_ "acceleration" there.
that's a correlation, [...] made to define the unit named Newton
Pseudoscientific word salad. Once again: In F = m a, "a" is the symbol
for the physical quantity "acceleration".
dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.
Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.
idiot
dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.
idiot
dx(s, t)/dy = reex/rees ds/dy + reex/reet dt/dy.
Le 23/10/2026 |a 13:44, Jett Baklanov a |-crit :
Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.
idiot
dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.
Jett,
idiot
dx(s, t)/dy = reex/rees ds/dy + reex/reet dt/dy.
You have "corrected"
A + B
into
B + A.
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved space is the cause.
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
space is
the cause.
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
the acceleration is zero?
On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
space is
the cause.
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
the acceleration is zero?
<snip incoherent babble>--
Den 23.10.2026 14:17, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
space is
the cause.
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
the acceleration is zero?
Since you are responding it must be because
you will try to answer the question.
So what is your answer?
On 10/23/2026 2:33 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 14:17, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is >>>>> clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
space is
the cause.
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
the acceleration is zero?
Since you are responding it must be because
you will try to answer the question.
So what is your answer?
<snip incoherent babble>--
Den 23.10.2026 14:34, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 2:33 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 14:17, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is >>>>>> clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved >>>>>> space is
the cause.
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
the acceleration is zero?
Since you are responding it must be because
you will try to answer the question.
So what is your answer?
OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.
On 10/23/2026 2:45 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
the acceleration is zero?
OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.
A lie, of course, as expected from
a piece of relativistic shit. The
answer was written clearly and 2 times.
Den 23.10.2026 15:37, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 2:45 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
the acceleration is zero?
OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.
A lie, of course, as expected from
a piece of relativistic shit. The
answer was written clearly and 2 times.
OK. According to Maciej Wo+|niak:
An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration
is zero because mad, brainwashing-a ideologies are using
misnaming as a common practice; The Shit of Einstein is
not an exception.
I take your clear answer to mean that an accelerometer
is shit of Einstein that does not show the correct acceleration.
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved space
is the cause.
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that the acceleration is
zero?
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
(together with others).
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 15:37, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 2:45 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
On 10/23/2026 2:14 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
the acceleration is zero?
OK. Got it. You will not try to answer the question.
A lie, of course, as expected from
a piece of relativistic shit. The
answer was written clearly and 2 times.
OK. According to Maciej Wo+|niak:
An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration
is zero because mad, brainwashing-a ideologies are using
misnaming as a common practice; The Shit of Einstein is
not an exception.
I take your clear answer to mean that an accelerometer
is shit of Einstein that does not show the correct acceleration.
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
(together with others).
free falling radar can register d2y/dt^2
Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.
Ralph,
free falling radar can register d2y/dt^2
Yes.
And the accelerometer falling with it reads:
-a-a 0
Maciej,
Excellent.
So an accelerometer is "junk" precisely when it correctly measures
proper acceleration.
Maciej,
Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:
-a-a a = dv/dt.
And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.
On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
Maciej,
Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:
-a-a a = dv/dt.
And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.
No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
be proper sharks.
Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
Maciej,
Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:
-a-a-a a = dv/dt.
And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.
No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
be proper sharks.
Maciej,
This doesn't even require Einstein.
A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.
Why?
On 10/24/2026 12:29 PM, Python wrote:
Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
Maciej,
Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:
-a-a-a a = dv/dt.
And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.
No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
be proper sharks.
Maciej,
This doesn't even require Einstein.
A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.
Why?
For the same reason that Orwell's Ministry of
Love kidnaps, tortures and kills.
Because misnaming is a common practice in
mad, brainwashing ideologies, and The Shit
of Einstein is no way an exception.
Le 24/10/2026 |a 12:45, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
On 10/24/2026 12:29 PM, Python wrote:
Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
Maciej,
Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:
-a-a-a a = dv/dt.
And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.
No surprise, since an insane crazie announced
sharks to eat grass - ordinary sharks can no longer
be proper sharks.
Maciej,
This doesn't even require Einstein.
A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.
Why?
For the same reason that Orwell's Ministry of
Love kidnaps, tortures and kills.
Because misnaming is a common practice in
mad, brainwashing ideologies, and The Shit
of Einstein is no way an exception.
This is beyond parody.
The accelerometer contains a test mass.
On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use?
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
is known.
Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
of the airplane is also known.
The latitude must be input.
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
when the airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lyingRight!
shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use? >>>>
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
is known.
Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
of the airplane is also known.
The latitude must be input.
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
when the airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
Right!
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.
On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:Right!
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use? >>>>>
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
is known.
Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
of the airplane is also known.
The latitude must be input.
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
when the airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.
Neither the fact that when a plane is
standing still in airport - the output
of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.
Maciej Wo+|niak wrote:
On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:Right!
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc., >>>>>>> has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems >>>>>>> use?
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
is known.
Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
of the airplane is also known.
The latitude must be input.
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
when the airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.
Neither the fact that when a plane is
standing still in airport - the output
of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.
Call me a stupid idiot and talk about how I don't know which way sharks swim.
And, usually, measures no acceleration.
It became "accelerometer" only for the sake of "confirming"
that mad mumble of your mad guru.
On 10/24/2026 1:09 PM, Python wrote:
Le 24/10/2026 |a 12:45, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
On 10/24/2026 12:29 PM, Python wrote:
Le 24/10/2026 |a 11:51, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
On 10/24/2026 11:44 AM, Python wrote:
Maciej,
Yes. That's coordinate acceleration:
-a-a-a a = dv/dt.
And an accelerometer measures proper acceleration.
No surprise, since an insane crazie announced sharks to eat grass -
ordinary sharks can no longer be proper sharks.
Maciej,
This doesn't even require Einstein.
A Newtonian accelerometer in free fall reads zero.
Why?
For the same reason that Orwell's Ministry of Love kidnaps, tortures
and kills.
Because misnaming is a common practice in mad, brainwashing
ideologies, and The Shit of Einstein is no way an exception.
This is beyond parody.
The accelerometer contains a test mass.
And, usually, measures no acceleration. It became "accelerometer" only
for the sake of "confirming"
that mad mumble of your mad guru.
Maciej,
And, usually, measures no acceleration.
It measures the force on its test mass relative to its case.
It has no more in common with accelerations that
Ministry of Love with love.
Maciej,
It has no more in common with accelerations that
Ministry of Love with love.
Then explain this without Einstein:
-a-a accelerometer on table:-a 1 g
-a-a same accelerometer dropped: 0 g
Newtonian mechanics explains it immediately.
On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 14:14:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved space
is the cause.
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that the acceleration is
zero?
HAHAHAHAHAAHA! How can I give up this NG when I get so many laughs? Let's rename it 'sci.physics.comedy'
Paul, our expert radio engineer, does not even know that free falling
radar can register d2y/dt^2 as well as dy/dt.
He thinks that a massive
force accelerates the Earth towards a skydiver at g.
Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.
On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:Right!
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc.,
has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems use? >>>>>
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
is known.
Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
of the airplane is also known.
The latitude must be input.
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
when the airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.
Neither the fact that when a plane is
standing still in airport - the output
of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.
Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:Right!
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc., >>>>>>> has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems >>>>>>> use?
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
is known.
Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
of the airplane is also known.
The latitude must be input.
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
when the airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.
Neither the fact that when a plane is
standing still in airport - the output
of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.
Give it up, Maciej.
It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground
show that the acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.
(The exact value will depend on the latitude.)
And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration
or inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.
---------------
Newton's definition of acceleration is:
-aa = F/m
where F is the force acting on an object with mass m
and a is the acceleration of the object.
An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
definition.
Think of this, Maciej:
Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.
You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts
an upwards force on you, F = 786 N.
According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.
Do you claim that Newton is wrong?
the values 1g on the table,
0 during freefall are NOT any acceleration,
none of them.
Maciej,
For once, there is a point here on which you are right.
In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:
coordinate acceleration = g downward
Paul's statement
F = ma
needs "F" to mean the NET force.
So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:
gravity: 786 N downward
scale: 786 N upward
net force: 0
Newtonian a: 0
The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.
Drop it:
Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
accelerometer reading: about 0
And none of this requires Einstein.
The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
(or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
to the Earth.
So yes: if somebody says an accelerometer directly measures Newton's coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# in a gravitational field, that is
wrong.
But your conclusion
"therefore it measures no acceleration"
doesn't follow.
It measures a different, perfectly well-defined physical quantity,
which is precisely why inertial navigation can use it.
You seem remarkably fond of arguments about labels:
"That's not acceleration!"
"That's not time!"
"That's not a proper clock!"
Fine. Call the accelerometer output Fred again.
sitting on runway: Fred ree 1 g
free fall: Fred ree 0
The aircraft's navigation system does not care what Maciej permits us
to call Fred.
Maciej,
the values 1g on the table,
0 during freefall are NOT any acceleration,
none of them.
Fine. Then forget the word "accelerometer".
Maciej,
For once, there is a point here on which you are right.
In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:
-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward
Paul's statement
-a-a F = ma
needs "F" to mean the NET force.
So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:
-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward
-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward
-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
-a-a Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.
Drop it:
-a-a Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
-a-a accelerometer reading:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a about 0
And none of this requires Einstein.
The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
(or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
to the Earth.
So yes: if somebody says an accelerometer directly measures Newton's coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# in a gravitational field, that is
wrong.
But your conclusion
-a-a "therefore it measures no acceleration"
doesn't follow.
It measures a different, perfectly well-defined physical quantity,
which is precisely why inertial navigation can use it.
You seem remarkably fond of arguments about labels:
On 10/24/2026 8:23 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:Right!
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc., >>>>>>>> has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation systems >>>>>>>> use?
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards),
while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
is known.
Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
of the airplane is also known.
The latitude must be input.
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
when the airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.
Neither the fact that when a plane is
standing still in airport - the output
of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.
Give it up, Maciej.
It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground
show that the acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.
Give it up, poor piece of shit - no it is not.
(The exact value will depend on the latitude.)
And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration
or inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.
---------------
Newton's definition of acceleration is:
-a-aa = F/m
where F is the force acting on an object with mass m
and a is the acceleration of the object.
An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
definition.
Even such an ignorant idiot should know that
the acceleration of Newton's definition-a is
not 0 for a free falling object. But he doesn't
know, and-a what can I do.
Anyway, it is not, what your toy measures
is not any acceleration. The Shit has lied
to you.
Think of this, Maciej:
Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.
You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts
an upwards force on you, F = 786 N.
According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.
Do you claim that Newton is wrong?
Den 24.10.2026 21:04, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/24/2026 8:23 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 9:50 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:Right!
Den 23.10.2026 20:00, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/23/2026 7:46 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
A knowledgeable person like you will obviously know that
a modern commercial airplane, in addition to GPS, WAAS, ILS etc., >>>>>>>>> has an inertial navigation system.
Can you tell me what kind of sensors inertial navigation
systems use?
Sensors showing the real acceleration, I guess
(together with others).
Right. Well done.
They are using three accelerometers, one along each of
the plane's three axes, and three ring laser gyroscopes
measuring the rotation around the three axes.
The axes are:
Yaw axis-a-a - the vertical axis
Roll axis-a - the longitudinal axis (nose-tail)
Pitch axis - the lateral axis (wingtip - wingtip)
Do you think such system
will show the pilot 0 acceleration when the plane
is falling down like a rock? Just because some
mad idiot imagined it would be proper? Somehow I
doubt it.
Airplanes are not in free fall, so let's see what real
sensors in real airplanes show.
When the inertial navigation systems is switched on
the airplane has to stand at the airfield for 20 minutes.
Then the three gyros will have measured the rotation of
the airplane. This rotation is obvious equal to the rotation
of the Earth, and parallel to Earth's north-south axis.
The yaw-axis accelerometer will show areC = ~9.8 m/s-# (upwards), >>>>>>> while the other two accelerometers will show a = 0.
Since the angle between the yaw-axis and the planes
rotation axis now is known, the latitude of the plane
is known.
Since the rotation around each axis is known, the heading
of the airplane is also known.
The latitude must be input.
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating
the accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration
to integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown
by the vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration
when the airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying
shit is asserting - it just has to be true.
Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit
does not change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.
Neither the fact that when a plane is
standing still in airport - the output
of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.
Give it up, Maciej.
It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground
show that the acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.
Give it up, poor piece of shit - no it is not.
(The exact value will depend on the latitude.)
And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration
or inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.
---------------
Newton's definition of acceleration is:
-a-aa = F/m
where F is the force acting on an object with mass m
and a is the acceleration of the object.
An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
definition.
The above is correct, nothing more to discuss.
Even such an ignorant idiot should know that
the acceleration of Newton's definition-a is
not 0 for a free falling object. But he doesn't
know, and-a what can I do.
Anyway, it is not, what your toy measures
is not any acceleration. The Shit has lied
to you.
Think of this, Maciej:
Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.
You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts
an upwards force on you, F = 786 N.
According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.
Do you claim that Newton is wrong?
Do you claim that Newton is wrong?
Maciej,
For once, there is a point here on which you are right.
In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:
-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward
Paul's statement
-a-a F = ma
needs "F" to mean the NET force.
So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:
-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward
-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward
-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
-a-a Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.
Drop it:
-a-a Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
-a-a accelerometer reading:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a about 0
And none of this requires Einstein.
The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
(or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
to the Earth.
So yes: if somebody says an accelerometer directly measures Newton's coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# in a gravitational field, that is--
wrong.
But your conclusion
-a-a "therefore it measures no acceleration"
doesn't follow.
It measures a different, perfectly well-defined physical quantity,
which is precisely why inertial navigation can use it.
You seem remarkably fond of arguments about labels:
-a-a "That's not acceleration!"
-a-a "That's not time!"
-a-a "That's not a proper clock!"
Fine. Call the accelerometer output Fred again.
-a-a sitting on runway: Fred ree 1 g
-a-a free fall:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a Fred ree 0
The aircraft's navigation system does not care what Maciej permits us
to call Fred.
Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
Maciej,
For once, there is a point here on which you are right.
In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:
-a-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward
.. when the coordinate system is the ECI-frame.
This is the coordinate acceleration according to Newton, SR and GR.
Paul's statement
-a-a-a F = ma
needs "F" to mean the NET force.
F is the net force that is acting on the body with mass m.
So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:
-a-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward
No! There is no force acting downwards on the man.
-a-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward
Right.
That means that the net force acting on the man is 786 N upward.
-a-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
If the net force acting on the man were 0, then the scale
would show 0 N.
The fact that the scale shows 786 N upward _proves_ that
the only force acting on the man is 786 N upward.
Newton's gravitation is a fictitious force.
According to Newton's second law of motion
the acceleration a = 786N/80kg = 9.825 m/s-# upward
Den 24.10.2026 21:04, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/24/2026 8:23 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 24.10.2026 15:55, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
On 10/24/2026 1:58 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 22:15, skrev Maciej Wo+|niak:
The position of the airplane can now be found by integrating the >>>>>>> accelerations and rotations. The vertical acceleration to
integrate is a-areC where a is the a acceleration shown by the
vertical accelerometer, and areC is the acceleration when the
airplane was stationary on the ground.
inertial navigation systems works.
Do you think accelerometers measure acceleration correctly?
If a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit is asserting - itRight!
just has to be true.
Calling me a piece of brainwashed, fanatic, lying shit does not
change the fact that inertial navigation systems works.
Neither the fact that when a plane is standing still in airport - the
output of an accelerometer is 0. Not 9.81 up.
Give it up, Maciej.
It is a fact that an accelerometer on the ground show that the
acceleration is ~9.8 m/s-# upwards.
Give it up, poor piece of shit - no it is not.
(The exact value will depend on the latitude.)
And as you now know, accelerometers measures the acceleration or
inertial navigation systems wouldn't work.
---------------
Newton's definition of acceleration is:
-a-aa = F/m
where F is the force acting on an object with mass m and a is the
acceleration of the object.
An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
definition.
The above is correct, nothing more to discuss.
Even such an ignorant idiot should know that the acceleration ofDo you claim that Newton is wrong?
Newton's definition-a is not 0 for a free falling object. But he doesn't
know, and-a what can I do.
Anyway, it is not, what your toy measures is not any acceleration. The
Shit has lied to you.
Think of this, Maciej:
Let us in the following assume that your mass is 80 kg.
You sit on a spring scale which show that it exerts an upwards force
on you, F = 786 N.
According to Newton's definition, your acceleration is:
a = F/m = 9.825 m/s-# upwards.
Do you claim that Newton is wrong?
On 10/25/2026 3:31 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
Maciej,
For once, there is a point here on which you are right.
In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:
-a-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward
.. when the coordinate system is the ECI-frame.
This is the coordinate acceleration according to Newton, SR and GR.
Paul's statement
-a-a-a F = ma
needs "F" to mean the NET force.
F is the net force that is acting on the body with mass m.
So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:
-a-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward
No! There is no force acting downwards on the man.
-a-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward
Right.
That means that the net force acting on the man is 786 N upward.
-a-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
If the net force acting on the man were 0, then the scale would show 0
N.
The fact that the scale shows 786 N upward _proves_ that the only force
acting on the man is 786 N upward.
Newton's gravitation is a fictitious force.
According to Newton's second law of motion the acceleration a =
786N/80kg = 9.825 m/s-# upward
It's indeed amazing what The Shit of Einstein is doing with poor brains
of its unfortunate victims.
Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 14:14:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
an object can be observed to accelerate during free fall. A force is
clearly still acting on it. Only an idiot would claim that curved
space is the cause.
Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that the acceleration is
zero?
HAHAHAHAHAAHA! How can I give up this NG when I get so many laughs?
Let's rename it 'sci.physics.comedy'
Paul, our expert radio engineer, does not even know that free falling
radar can register d2y/dt^2 as well as dy/dt.
A free falling radar can only measure the acceleration of the
y-coordinate in its own rest frame. So it will measure its own
coordinate acceleration to be zero, of course.
y = 0, dy/dt = 0, d-#y/dt-#.
But it can measure the coordinate acceleration of the Earth (or other objects) in its rest frame.
If the radar is stationary on Earth, it can measure a free falling
object's coordinate acceleration in Earth's rest frame.
If the radar is on the moon, it can measure the same free falling
object's coordinate acceleration in the moon's rest frame.
The two coordinate accelerations are not equal.
He thinks that a massive force accelerates the Earth towards a skydiver
at g.
Paul thinks that an object can have several different coordinate accelerations depending on in which coordinate system the coordinate acceleration is measured.
Did you really not know that, Ralph? :-D
-----------
Newton's definition of acceleration is:
a = F/m
where F is the force acting on an object with mass m.
This acceleration is what we call the object's proper acceleration. An
object has but one proper acceleration.
An accelerometer is in principle a body with known mass fixed to theNo, your spring accelerometer is not what its name suggests. It is really
casing via a spring. When the casing is accelerated by a force, the
casing will via the spring make the body accelerate along with the
casing.
The acceleration of the body is now a = F/m where m is the body's known mass, and F is the force the spring exert on the body. The compression
of the spring is measured and a = F/m.
(The "spring" may be a piezoelectric crystal so
the output of the accelerometer is a voltage.)
An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's definition.
Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.
Right!
Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by an
accelerometer.
An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration is zero
because the proper acceleration is zero.
Even no acceleration is measurable.
Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
Maciej,
For once, there is a point here on which you are right.
In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:
-a-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward
.. when the coordinate system is the ECI-frame.
This is the coordinate acceleration according to Newton, SR and GR.
Paul's statement
-a-a-a F = ma
needs "F" to mean the NET force.
F is the net force that is acting on the body with mass m.
So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:
-a-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward
No! There is no force acting downwards on the man.
-a-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward
Right.
That means that the net force acting on the man is 786 N upward.
-a-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
If the net force acting on the man were 0, then the scale
would show 0 N.
The fact that the scale shows 786 N upward _proves_ that
the only force acting on the man is 786 N upward.
Newton's gravitation is a fictitious force.
According to Newton's second law of motion
the acceleration a = 786N/80kg = 9.825 m/s-# upward
The acceleration in Newton's second law of motion
is what we now call the proper acceleration.
If you stand on the ground at the position y = 0,
(or any other constant), then your speed dy/dt = 0,
your coordinate acceleration is-a d-#y/dt-# = 0.
Note that d-#y/dt-# is a coordinate acceleration by definition!
This thread started with my question:
"Why does an accelerometer in free fall show that
-athe acceleration is zero?"
The answer is that it is because the proper acceleration is zero.
My point was simply that an accelerometer measures proper
acceleration, and the proper acceleration of a body on the ground
is ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
-a-a-a Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
The accelerometer nevertheless reads about 1 g.
Drop it:
-a-a-a Newtonian coordinate acceleration: about 1 g downward
-a-a-a accelerometer reading:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a about 0
And none of this requires Einstein.
The accelerometer measures the non-gravitational force per unit mass
(or, in modern terminology, proper acceleration), not d-#x/dt-# relative
to the Earth.
The accelerometer measures the only real force that is acting
on a body with known mass within it.
Proper acceleration is the only acceleration that can be measured
with no external reference to a coordinate system.
Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 14:14:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 20.09.2026 01:10, skrev HenryWilson:
An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's definition.
Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.
Right!
Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by an
accelerometer.
An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration is zero
because the proper acceleration is zero.
Even no acceleration is measurable.
Maciej,
For once, there is a point here on which you are right.
In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:
-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward
Paul's statement
-a-a F = ma
needs "F" to mean the NET force.
So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:
-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward
-a-a scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward
-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
-a-a Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
On Sat, 24 Oct 2026 19:32:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:
An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's definition.
Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.
Right!
Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by an
accelerometer.
An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration is zero
because the proper acceleration is zero.
Even no acceleration is measurable.
I missed that classic...
When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer...which is not really what its name suggests but is a 'forceometer' or 'spring tension- meter'...correctly indicates that a downward gravitational force of 9.8 m/ s/s is acting on every unit mass there, for reasons unknown. This directly implies that any object in free fall will accelerate at that rate. A
spring tension-meter falling down a hole has zero spring tension because
the same force is now operating on both ends, which are
known to be accelerating at that rate, 9.8. The apparatus is not designed
to directly indicate acceleration under such conditions but indirectly
does so by way of its zero reading. Even Marcel told you that.
Read what you snipped:
Newton's definition of acceleration is:
-aa = F/m
Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.
And F=a*m is in Netonian physics a definition of mass.
Maciej,
Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.
Yes.
Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of acceleration.
But then you write:
And F=a*m is in Netonian physics a definition of mass.
Not so fast.
In elementary Newtonian mechanics we have distinct concepts:
-a-a acceleration:-a a = dv/dt
-a-a net force:-a-a-a-a F
-a-a inertial mass: m
When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer [...]
correctly indicates that a downward gravitational force of 9.8 m/s/s
is acting on every unit mass there
The apparatus is not designed to directly indicate acceleration
under such conditions but indirectly does so by way of its zero
reading.
Den 24.10.2026 22:41, skrev Python:
In Newtonian mechanics, a freely falling body near Earth has:
-a-a coordinate acceleration = g downward
Paul's statement
-a-a F = ma
needs "F" to mean the NET force.
So for an 80 kg man sitting motionless on a scale:
-a-a gravity:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N downward scale:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 786 N upward net
-a-a force:-a-a-a-a-a-a-a 0 Newtonian a:-a-a-a-a-a-a 0
The above is correct.
According to Newton the gravitational force above the ground is F =
GMm/r-#. In free fall close to the ground this will give the acceleration
a = F/m = GM/r-# ree 9.81 m/s-# downward.
Maciej,
Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.
Yes.
Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of acceleration.
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
FORCES.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The apparatus
is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.
A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat road
after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force that is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring. The spring
extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient to provide the
mass with the same acceleration as the car.
Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free
fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
FORCES.
An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.
-a________________
|-a-a-a-a ______-a-a-a-a |
|-a-a-a |-a m-a-a |-a-a-a |
|-a-a-a |______|-a-a-a |
|-a-a-a-a-a-a-a \-a-a-a-a-a-a |
|-a-a-a-a-a-a-a /-a-a-a-a-a-a |
|________\_______|
-a-a m = 1 kg
1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
-a-a What is the tension T in the string?
2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
-a-a What is the tension T in the string?
(Tensile stress is positive, compressive stress is negative.)
There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The apparatus
is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.
3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
-a-a of the box?
So the accelerometer works correctly.
Acceleration is the tension multiplied by the mass, a = Triam
Den 26.10.2026 15:55, skrev Python:
Maciej,
Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.
Yes.
dv/dt, or d-#x/dt-#, is the definition of acceleration in
mathematics and calculus. x and t are coordinates so this
is a coordinate acceleration.
Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of
acceleration.
Newton's definition of acceleration is found in his second
law of motion. It can be expressed a = F/m.
Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free
fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
FORCES.
An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.
________________
| ______ |
| | m | |
| |______| |
| \ |
| / |
|________\_______|
m = 1 kg
1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
What is the tension T in the string?
2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
What is the tension T in the string?There certainly is. You don't understand very basic Physics.
(Tensile stress is positive, compressive stress is negative.)
There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The
apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.
3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
of the box?
There is but one rather obvious correct answer to this question.
A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat road
after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force that
is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring. The
spring extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient to
provide the mass with the same acceleration as the car.
Right.
So the accelerometer works correctly.
Acceleration is the tension multiplied by the mass, a = Triam
Do you think the accelerometer would cease to work correctly if the orientation is different from horizontal?
Den 26.10.2026 15:55, skrev Python:
Maciej,
Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.
Yes.
dv/dt, or d-#x/dt-#, is the definition of acceleration in mathematics and calculus. x and t are coordinates so this is a coordinate acceleration.
Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of
acceleration.
Newton's definition of acceleration is found in his second law of
motion. It can be expressed a = F/m.
"Acceleration is directly proportional to the net force and
inversely proportional to the object's mass."
This is _physics_, it relates force, mass and acceleration.
If I say:
"The force on an object is F, the mass of the object is m.
Please find the acceleration defined by a = dv/dt."
What would you do?
Wouldn't it be better id a said:
"Please find the acceleration defined by a = F/m"?
Newton didn't use the word "proper", but a = F/m is the proper
acceleration which can have but one value for a given force and mass. It
is invariant, the same in all frames of reference.
The coordinate acceleration d-#x/dt-# can have different values in
different frames of reference.
On 10/26/2026 11:06 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 26.10.2026 15:55, skrev Python:
Maciej,
Newton's definition of acceleration is - dv/dt.
Yes.
dv/dt, or d-#x/dt-#, is the definition of acceleration in mathematics and
calculus. x and t are coordinates so this is a coordinate acceleration.
Paul was imprecise there: Newton's second law is not the definition of
acceleration.
Newton's definition of acceleration is found in his second law of
motion. It can be expressed a = F/m.
No, poor ignorant idiot. Newton's definition of acceleration can be
found elsewhere, and it is dv/dt. F=a*m was Newton's definition of mass.
Your mad Shit has lied to you.
Den 26.10.2026 08:25, skrev HenryWilson:
On Sat, 24 Oct 2026 19:32:28 +0200, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 23.10.2026 20:56, skrev HenryWilson:
An accelerometer measures acceleration according to Newton's
definition.
Like rotation, Acceleration is absolute and always detectable.
Right!
Proper acceleration is absolute and always measurable by an
accelerometer.
An accelerometer in free fall shows that the acceleration is zero
because the proper acceleration is zero.
Even no acceleration is measurable.
I missed that classic...
When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer...which is
not really what its name suggests but is a 'forceometer' or 'spring
tension- meter'...correctly indicates that a downward gravitational
force of 9.8 m/
s/s is acting on every unit mass there, for reasons unknown. This
directly implies that any object in free fall will accelerate at that
rate. A spring tension-meter falling down a hole has zero spring
tension because the same force is now operating on both ends, which are
known to be accelerating at that rate, 9.8. The apparatus is not
designed to directly indicate acceleration under such conditions but
indirectly does so by way of its zero reading. Even Marcel told you
that.
There is no such thing as an "Einsteinian accelerometer".
Read what you snipped:
Newton's definition of acceleration is:
a = F/m
where F is the force acting on an object with mass m.
This acceleration is what we call the object's proper acceleration. An
object has but one proper acceleration.
An accelerometer is in principle a body with known mass fixed to the
casing via a spring.
When the casing is accelerated by a force, the
casing will via the spring make the body accelerate along with the
casing.
The acceleration of the body is now a = F/m where m is the body's known mass, and F is the force the spring exert on the body. The compression
of the spring is measured and a = F/m.
(The "spring" may be a piezoelectric crystal so
the output of the accelerometer is a voltage.)
Note:
The force the spring exert on the body with known mass is upwards.
upward.
Ralph,
When on the ground, your juvenile Einsteinian accelerometer [...]
correctly indicates that a downward gravitational force of 9.8 m/s/s is
acting on every unit mass there
No.
And your very next paragraph demonstrates why.
In Newtonian terms, gravity acts on the accelerometer's components
whether the instrument is:
sitting on the ground
or
falling down the hole.
If its reading were simply a measurement of the gravitational force per
unit mass, then it should read approximately g in BOTH cases.
It doesn't.
On the ground:
gravity acts on the proof mass the case is prevented from falling by
the ground -> relative force/displacement -> accelerometer reads ~1
g.
In free fall:
gravity acts on case and proof mass both fall together -> no
relative force/displacement -> accelerometer reads ~0
No Einstein is required to describe that in Newtonian mechanics.
The apparatus is not designed to directly indicate acceleration under
such conditions but indirectly does so by way of its zero reading.
This is the particularly entertaining part.
You have just conceded the complete physical behaviour of the
accelerometer:
stationary on Earth: ~1 g free fall: 0
You merely want to reinterpret the zero as secretly meaning:
"0, therefore the REAL acceleration is g."
But the instrument has no knowledge of Earth.
Put the same ideal accelerometer in a sealed freely falling box and its
local reading is zero. From that reading alone it cannot tell whether
the box is falling toward Earth, orbiting Earth, or coasting far from gravitation.
To obtain acceleration relative to Earth, you need additional
information defining Earth as your reference and, in an inertial
navigation system, an appropriate gravity model.
So the accelerometer is not "indirectly indicating g by indicating
zero".
YOU are inferring g from its zero reading plus external knowledge about
the gravitational field and the chosen reference frame.
Those are rather different things.
And calling it a "forceometer" doesn't hurt relativity in the slightest.
In fact, that is remarkably close to the point:
an accelerometer measures specific force, equivalently proper
acceleration.
After several paragraphs attacking the terminology, you have described
almost exactly why the distinction exists.
Don't use the word 'proper'. Its just part of you religious jargon.
Coordinates are the same in all frames.
Ralph,
Don't use the word 'proper'. Its just part of you religious jargon.
Fine. Let's remove the word entirely.
Engineers have another perfectly ordinary term:
-a-a specific force
That is what an accelerometer measures.
Yes, Maciej.
Except the sheep was called "specific force" by engineers all along.
And "acceleration" by some religious maniacs
Maciej,
And "acceleration" by some religious maniacs
Yes.
Because "proper acceleration" is a technical term for a perfectly well-defined physical quantity.
Maciej,
No prophecy is needed.
Take a box, a mass and a spring.
Put the box on the ground:
-a-a spring deflected.
Drop the box:
-a-a spring not deflected.
Exactly.
Congratulations, Maciej: you have finally discovered the distinction.
-a-a box on ground:
-a-a-a-a-a-a coordinate acceleration = 0
-a-a-a-a-a-a accelerometer reading-a-a = ~1 g
-a-a box in free fall:
-a-a-a-a-a-a coordinate acceleration = ~g
-a-a-a-a-a-a accelerometer reading-a-a = 0
Maciej,
Then your complaint is purely about terminology.
You won't because the terminology IS important.
You won't because the terminology IS important.
Exactly.
Which is precisely why I don't let YOU define it.
Exactly.
And that's why science doesn't settle terminology by asking either you
or me.
It uses definitions shared by the scientific and engineering
communities.
GPS/engineering second remains -
9 192 631 770 on Earth, 9 192 631 774
on a satellite.
Maciej,
GPS/engineering second remains -
9 192 631 770 on Earth, 9 192 631 774
on a satellite.
No.
That is simply false.
There is no GPS definition saying:
-a-a GPS second on Earth-a-a-a-a-a = 9,192,631,770 Cs periods
-a-a GPS second on satellite-a = 9,192,631,774 Cs periods
GPS does not have two different seconds depending on altitude.
it has just one, and it is equivalent to
9,192,631,770 Cs periods on the ground and
9,192,631,774 on a satellite.
Just read its clocks
On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can be
used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in free
fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
FORCES.
An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.
________________
| ______ |
| | m | |
| |______| |
| \ |
| / |
|________\_______|
m = 1 kg
That can measure acceleration.
1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
What is the tension T in the string?
The spring extends until the its tension is sufficient to precisely accelerate the mass at the same rate as the box. In other words, the force accelerating the box is transmited to the mas via the stretching of the spring.
2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
...Hahahah! .but you said there is no acceleration in free fall. Now you
are admitting that the box is accelerating in free fall. Make up your mind Paul.
What is the tension T in the string?
There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.
There certainly is. You don't understand very basic Physics.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
tension...(except a very small on due to gravity gradient). The
apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.
3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
of the box?
The box is accelerating at 9.8, which was the force on it as measured when
it was not falling. Marcel told you that.
There is but one rather obvious correct answer to this question.
Yes. Same as above.
A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat road
after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force that
is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring. The
spring extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient to
provide the mass with the same acceleration as the car.
Right.
So the accelerometer works correctly.
Acceleration is the tension divided by the mass, a = T/m
That would be the numerical answer. Yes.
Do you think the accelerometer would cease to work correctly if the
orientation is different from horizontal?
Of course. The car's acceleration acts directly on the box, not the mass.
The spring tension, after a delay while it stretches, acts on the mass. Gravity acts equally on both immediately..so no stretching is needed.
We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,
Maciej,
it has just one, and it is equivalent to
9,192,631,770 Cs periods on the ground and
9,192,631,774 on a satellite.
Good. Now notice what you have just said.
The SAME GPS-time interval corresponds, according to you, to different amounts of local Cs evolution:
-a-a ground:-a-a-a-a ~9,192,631,770 periods
-a-a satellite:-a ~9,192,631,774 periods
That is a rate difference.
You can call the common GPS interval "the real second" until the Sun explodes. It doesn't make those two numbers equal.
And:
Just read its clocks
We did.
NTS-2 was specifically operated with the relativistic frequency
correction OFF.
The delicious part is that you are now reproducing the same rate
difference yourself with your 9,192,631,770 versus 9,192,631,774.
You read the clocks, obtain the relativistic effect
Some clocks may fit any nonsense.
I read the clocks, obtain t'=t.
And a second of 9,192,631,770 on the
ground and 9,192,631,774 on a satellite.
Some clocks may fit any nonsense.
That's not an explanation. That's an escape hatch.
NTS-2:
-a-a predicted:-a +446.5 x 10^-12
-a-a measured:-a-a +442.5 x 10^-12
Your answer:
-a-a bad clock.
Unfortunately, other clocks kept committing the same crime.
Pendulums would never,
pulsar clocks would never, Cs clocks hasn't been
for 50 years.
Maciej,
Pendulums would never,
pulsar clocks would never, Cs clocks hasn't been
for 50 years.
Wonderful.
We have progressed from:
-a-a "Some clocks may fit any nonsense"
to:
-a-a "Yes, but not the clocks I have just selected."
Unfortunately, clocks have been stubbornly committing this same
"error" for decades.
in satellites, rockets and laboratories, over scales ranging from
thousands of kilometres down to millimetres.
As for pendulums: nobody expects an ordinary pendulum to provide the precision required for these tests.
It becomes a method for making your claim experimentally unfalsifiable.
And in serious measurement system correctly
calibrated - not anymore.
I've told you - serious models always
are [unfalsifiable].
Have your bunch of idiots falsified
Euclidean geometry?
Maciej,
And in serious measurement system correctly
calibrated - not anymore.
You keep accidentally explaining the point.
YES.
Once correctly calibrated
Yes, Python.I've told you - serious models always
are [unfalsifiable].
No, Maciej.
A model protected from every possible experimental result is not
"serious".
Have the idiots from your bunch of idiots
"falsified" Euclidean geometry?
you simply have no clue about the subject.
Maciej,
Have the idiots from your bunch of idiots
"falsified" Euclidean geometry?
You are repeating the same category error.
Euclidean geometry is an axiomatic mathematical theory.
Nobody "falsifies" Euclidean geometry by experiment.
from its axioms.
What experiment can test is whether Euclidean geometry is an adequate
MODEL of some physical situation.
Those are two completely different statements:
-a-a Euclidean geometry is mathematically valid.
and:
-a-a physical spacetime is globally Euclidean.
The first is mathematics.
The second is an empirical claim.
It's completely different things than
theorems following postulates, sure.
"Euclidean geometry is mathematically valid" is
some very cheap philosophy.
you simply have no clue about the subject.
Maciej,
It's completely different things than
theorems following postulates, sure.
Oh dear.
You have now discovered another distinction without a difference.
In an axiomatic theory, theorems are derived from the assumptions of
the theory, traditionally called axioms and, especially in Euclid, postulates.
Calling one of them a "postulate" does not magically turn the
mathematical system into experimental physics.
Pythagoras remains a theorem of Euclidean geometry whether the physical surface on which you perform measurements is Euclidean or not.
I'm far from claiming that EG is physics,
it's a serious model.
real clocks measure t'=t.
Maciej,
I'm far from claiming that EG is physics,
it's a serious model.
Exactly. Mathematics gives the model; experiment tells us whether it describes physical reality.
real clocks measure t'=t.
After compensation.
The interesting measurement is BEFORE compensation.
Explaining why measurement don't fit your
idiocies doesn't change the fact they don't
fit your idiocies.
your opinion of "what is interesting" is
worthless.
Maciej,
Explaining why measurement don't fit your
idiocies doesn't change the fact they don't
fit your idiocies.
But they DO fit the prediction.
your opinion of "what is interesting" is
worthless.
It's not an opinion.
Prediction - 38us a day.
Measurement - 0.
Maciej,
Prediction - 38us a day.
Measurement - 0.
You keep omitting two words:
-a-a AFTER COMPENSATION.
Ralph,
Don't use the word 'proper'. Its just part of you religious jargon.
Fine. Let's remove the word entirely.
Engineers have another perfectly ordinary term:
specific force
That is what an accelerometer measures.
Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can
be used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in
free fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting
FORCES.
An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a string inside.
________________
| ______ |
| | m | |
| |______| |
| \ |
| / |
|________\_______|
m = 1 kg
^
| upward | downward
v
'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure, it
has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated relative to
the Earth.
I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.
That can measure acceleration.
1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
What is the tension T in the string?
We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, so
the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.
The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward.
2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
What is the tension T in the string?
We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,
so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.
The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward
Generally:
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the
figure.
If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on the figure.
This is always true!
====================
It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.
There is but one rather obvious correct answer to each question.
There certainly is. You don't understand very basic Physics.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The
apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.
3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
of the box?
a = T/m = 0
The box is accelerating at 9.8, which was the force on it as measured
when it was not falling. Marcel told you that.
You are babbling again.
There is but one rather obvious correct answer to this question.
Yes. Same as above.An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
A horizontal accelerometer in a car will work correctly on a flat
road after a small reaction delay due to the time taken for the force
that is accelerating the car to be transmitted through the spring.
The spring extends until its tensional force is precisely sufficient
to provide the mass with the same acceleration as the car.
Right.
So the accelerometer works correctly.
Acceleration is the tension divided by the mass, a = T/m
That would be the numerical answer. Yes.
Do you think the accelerometer would cease to work correctly if the
orientation is different from horizontal?
Of course. The car's acceleration acts directly on the box, not the
mass. The spring tension, after a delay while it stretches, acts on the
mass. Gravity acts equally on both immediately..so no stretching is
needed.
When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
You can wonder why, but it is a fact.
The following may give you a hint:
Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The proper acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An accelerometer
onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#
Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
hovering 10 m above the ground.
The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8 m/s-#!
This is a fact whether you like it or not.
Of course it is gravitation at play.
It seems like GR is right:
Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.
So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it can >>>>> be used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration in
free fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely acting >>>>> FORCES.
An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a spring inside.
________________
| ______ |
| | m | |
| |______| |
| \ |
| / |
|________\_______|
m = 1 kg
^
| upward | downward
v
'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure, it
has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated relative to
the Earth.
I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.
That can measure acceleration.
1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
What is the tension T in the spring?
We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, so
the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.
The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)
yes
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward.
2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
What is the tension T in the spring?
We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,
so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.
That is correct.
The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward
Generally:
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the
figure.
If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on the
figure.
This is always true!
====================
It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The
apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.
3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration
of the box?
a = T/m = 0
No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that a(mass)- a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
Get it?
If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you deliberately
intend to confuse.
An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
You can wonder why, but it is a fact.
The following may give you a hint:
Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The proper
acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An accelerometer
onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#
No Paul. It show F = 9.8 m/s/s.
Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
hovering 10 m above the ground.
The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8 m/s-#!
The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is not transmitted to the body.
This is a fact whether you like it or not.
Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the body, even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.
Of course it is gravitation at play.
It seems like GR is right:
Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.
So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!
The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force
and 9.8 m/s-# upward acceleration.
Of course it is gravitation at play.
But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.
Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.
*facepalm*dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.
Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Savoy
Dudnakov":
Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote::-D
e 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their ignorance as "Dinanath
Bakuroff":
HenryWilson wrote:
On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 07:47:30 -0000 (UTC), Phillup Tsarakov wrote:
[...] Why would an object accelerate in free fall if it didn't have >>>>>> a force on it?
[...] not even knowing the kindergarten basics. Forces has nothing to >>>>> do with acceleration, cretin
Apropos basics: Does
F = m a
that has nothing to do with the acceleration, [hysterical fit]
"F" means "force". "m" means "mass". What might "a" mean? Hmmm. :-D
that's relating everything to anything, correleated in this universe, you stinking sack of half german subhuman excrement; but has nothing to do
with acceleration. Write down the definition of acceleration, you fucking irrelevant fritzkarte inbreed excrement
put your foot under a wheel of a train, where the acceleration is zero,
and see what force you got
there are no forces applied in freefall, only by opposing it; [...]
You know of course that an accelerometer works equally
well in both directions.
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
-a-a the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
-a-a the figure. (spring stretched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)
Why is this confusing?
--Paul
Wrt the everlasting field, everything knows about everything.
Den 27.10.2026 23:31, skrev HenryWilson:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:It seems that we agree about this:
Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it
can be used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration >>>>>> in free fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely
acting FORCES.
An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a spring inside.
________________
| ______ |
| | m | |
| |______| |
| \ |
| / |
|________\_______|
m = 1 kg
^
| upward | downward
v
'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure, it
has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated relative to
the Earth.
I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.
That can measure acceleration.We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, so
1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
What is the tension T in the spring?
the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.
The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)
yes
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward.
2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
What is the tension T in the spring?
We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward,
so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.
That is correct.
The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward
Generally:
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the
figure.
If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on the
figure.
This is always true!
====================
It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The
apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero.
3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration >>>>> of the box?
a = T/m = 0
No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that
a(mass)-
a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
Get it?
Don't be ridiculous!
a(mass) - a(box) = 0 always!
a(box) = a(mass) = T/m = 0 only in free fall.
If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass
hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you
deliberately intend to confuse.
You know of course that an accelerometer works equally well in both directions.
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
the figure. (spring streched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)
Why is this confusing?
An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
You can wonder why, but it is a fact.
The following may give you a hint:
Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The proper
acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An accelerometer
onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#
No Paul. It shows Force = 9.8 m/s/s.
Is this meant to be a joke?
Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
hovering 10 m above the ground.
The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8
m/s-#!
The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself
but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is not
transmitted to the body.
Don't be ridiculous. :-D
The accelerometer will show the same as if it was stationary on the
ground, which is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
The fact that the output from the accelerometer shows that the
acceleration of the 1kg body is a = 9.8 m/s-# _proves_ that the _only_
force acting on the 1kg body is the upwards force from the compressed
spring: F = 9.8 N.
So whether the spaceship is far from gravitating masses,
or is stationary relative to the Earth 10 m above the ground,
the only force that acts on the 1kg body is the 9.8 N force from
compressed spring, and the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
This is a fact whether you like it or not.
Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the
body,
even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.
Don't be ridiculous!
The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force and 9.8 m/s-# upward acceleration.
Of course it is gravitation at play.
But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.
It seems like GR is right:
Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.
So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!
The 'nym-shifting troll trolled as "Parker Zholudev":
there are no forces applied in freefall, only by opposing it; [...]
That is exactly what general relativity states 8-)
Objects follow spacetime geodesics unless a force is acting on them.
See also my public playlist:
The 'nym-shifting troll demonstrated their foolishness as "Jett
Baklanov":
Thomas 'PointedEars' Lahn wrote:
dx(s, t)/dy = reexreoreet dtreody + reexreorees dsreody.
Yes, I did write that '
> idiot
*facepalm*dx(s, t)/dy = reexreorees dsreody + reexreoreet dtreody.
Ever heard of the commutative law?
On Wed, 28 Oct 2026 20:11:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 27.10.2026 23:31, skrev HenryWilson:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it >>>>>>> can be used in that way. It is not designed to measure acceleration >>>>>>> in free fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely
acting FORCES.
An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a spring inside. >>>>>>
________________
| ______ |
| | m | |
| |______| |
| \ |
| / |
|________\_______|
m = 1 kg
^
| upward | downward
v
'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure, it >>>> has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated relative to >>>> the Earth.
I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.
That can measure acceleration.We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, so >>>> the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.
1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
What is the tension T in the spring?
The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)
yes
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward.
2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
What is the tension T in the spring?
We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# downward, >>>> so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N downward.
That is correct.
The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward
Generally:
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the
figure.
If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on the >>>> figure.
This is always true!
====================
It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.
It seems that we agree about this:
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The >>>>>>> apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension correctly...zero. >>>>>>
3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the acceleration >>>>>> of the box?
a = T/m = 0
No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that
a(mass)-
a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
Get it?
Don't be ridiculous!
a(mass) - a(box) = 0 always!
Wrong again...when the box accelerates there is an important time lag
before the body catches up..but I was talking about during free fall
anyway.
a(box) = a(mass) = T/m = 0 only in free fall.
You just said above that it is zero ALWAYS. Make up your mind Paul,
That's what I said. That is the general solution in free fall when there
is acceleration but so tension.
If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass
hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you
deliberately intend to confuse.
You know of course that an accelerometer works equally well in both
directions.
Only over a small range. Compressing a spring is limited...
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
the figure. (spring streched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)
Why is this confusing?
Springs are flexible. Have you never used I coil spring? If a large mass
is fixed to the top it will lean over. Maybe you only know of the
cantilever type.
Normally, the body would be hanging downwards, for obvious reasons.
An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
You can wonder why, but it is a fact.
The following may give you a hint:
Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The proper
acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An accelerometer
onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#
No Paul. It shows Force = 9.8 m/s/s.
Is this meant to be a joke?
You are the joke Paul...along with your friend Einstein.
Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
hovering 10 m above the ground.
The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8
m/s-#!
The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself
but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is not
transmitted to the body.
Don't be ridiculous. :-D
The accelerometer will show the same as if it was stationary on the
ground, which is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
That's right. The engine thrust is not transmitted to the body.
The only
change is that the upward force that was exerted by the ground on the
rocket is now exerted by the reaction to the momentum increase of the propellant. The hanging body is not affected by the firing of the engine.
The fact that the output from the accelerometer shows that the
acceleration of the 1kg body is a = 9.8 m/s-# _proves_ that the _only_
force acting on the 1kg body is the upwards force from the compressed
spring: F = 9.8 N.
Paul, will you please act normally and turn you box upside down.
...but whichever way it hangs, TWO forces act on it when siting on the ground. The spring tension and gravity. It has NO acceleration. Only
idiots like Einstein believe it does. In free fall the tension becomes
zero + minuscule gravity gradient
So whether the spaceship is far from gravitating masses,
or is stationary relative to the Earth 10 m above the ground,
the only force that acts on the 1kg body is the 9.8 N force from
compressed spring, and the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
No Paul, you have been badly indoctrinated. Gravity is a force, not an acceleration. Newton's law say it all. Einstein thought he was greater
than Newton and stuffed up the whole of Physics for 120 years.
This is a fact whether you like it or not.
Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the
body,
even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.
Don't be ridiculous!
The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force and 9.8 m/s-# upward
acceleration.
where is your dv/dt Paul? Where is your dx/dt?
Of course it is gravitation at play.
But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.
Like I said, you have been badly indoctrinated. There is no d2x/dt2.
Tell me Paul, when two bar magnets are stuck firmly together, do you
really think they accelerating towards each other?
You can see them ACCELERATING very rapidly while they are coming together...and that acceleration ceases when they do. Surely you wont
argue about that.
The same applies to a +ve and -ve charge coming together..precisely in
line with gravity.
It seems like GR is right:
Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.
Paul, they don't even have the same dimensions.
So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!
Yes! That one reason Physics has gone completely off the rails.
Den 29.10.2026 16:22, skrev HenryWilson:
On Wed, 28 Oct 2026 20:11:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 27.10.2026 23:31, skrev HenryWilson:
On Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:17 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 27.10.2026 10:08, skrev HenryWilson:
On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:13:56 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 26.10.2026 06:58, skrev HenryWilson:
A spring accelerometer does not measure acceleration although it >>>>>>>> can be used in that way. It is not designed to measure
acceleration in free fall.
It measures the tension in the spring caused by two oppositely >>>>>>>> acting FORCES.
An accelerometer is a box with a body attached to a spring inside. >>>>>>>
________________
| ______ |
| | m | |
| |______| |
| \ |
| / |
|________\_______|
m = 1 kg
^
| upward | downward
v
'downward' and 'upward' only refers to the direction on the figure,
it has nothing to do with how the accelerometer is orientated
relative to the Earth.
I will use the symbol T for both tension and compression.
If T is positive it is tension. If T is negative it is compression.
That can measure acceleration.We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-# upward, >>>>> so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N upward.
1: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# upwards.
What is the tension T in the spring?
The tension in the string is T = -10 N (compression)
yes
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = -10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# upward. >>>>
2: The acceleration of the box is 10 m/s-# downward.
What is the tension T in the spring?
We know the acceleration of body with mass m is a = 10 m/s-#
downward, so the force acting on the body is F = mriaa = 10 N
downward.
That is correct.
The tension in the string is T = 10 N (tension)
This works both ways.
If the tension is T = 10N, then the acceleration is 10 m/s-# downward >>>>>
Generally:
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on the >>>>> figure.
If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
the figure.
This is always true!
====================
It is an inevitable consequence of Newton's second law of motion.
Note this: According to Newton!
It seems that we agree about this:
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
In free fall, the same force acts on both ends so there is no
tension...(except a very small one due to gravity gradient). The >>>>>>>> apparatus is accelerating and is reading tension
correctly...zero.
3: If the tension T in the spring is T = 0, what is the
acceleration
of the box?
a = T/m = 0
No Paul. That is only one solution. The general solution is that
a(mass)-
a(box) = 0. That is the situation in free fall.
Get it?
Don't be ridiculous!
a(mass) - a(box) = 0 always!
This means: a(mass) = a(box) always.
Wrong again...when the box accelerates there is an important time lag
before the body catches up..but I was talking about during free fall
anyway.
So in free fall it is a delay before the acceleration of the body with acceleration zero becomes zero? :-D
I find it rather amazing that you seem to believe that real
accelerometers are 1 kg masses hanging in a long steel spring. My accelerometer is obviously only meant to illustrate the principle of an accelerometer.
Real accelerometers are electronic devices and the most used 'spring' is
a piezoelectric crystal (like quartz). The delay is in the ms range or faster. The data of an accelerometer will vary depending on what use it
is built for.
Even you must understand that when for example cars are crash-tested a
lot of accelerometers are used. Testing shocks demands fast
accelerometers.
a(box) = a(mass) = T/m = 0 only in free fall.
You just said above that it is zero ALWAYS. Make up your mind Paul,
Did I say: a(box) = a(mass) = 0 always? :-D
Only in free fall is a(box) = a(mass) = 0.
That's what I said. That is the general solution in free fall when
there is acceleration but so tension.
So according to Henry Wilson a = T/m rea 0 when T = 0
Ralph, it is a fact that an accelerometer in an orbiting satellite show
zero acceleration.
Why do you keep disputing what you must know is true?
If your diagram was more realistic you would have shown the mass
hanging downward. Whatever made you draw it upside down? Did you
deliberately intend to confuse.
You know of course that an accelerometer works equally well in both
directions.
Only over a small range. Compressing a spring is limited...
The acceleration of the box is a = T/m.
1: If a is positive, the direction of the acceleration is upward on
the figure. (spring compressed, pushing the 1kg body upwards)
2: If a is negative, the direction of the acceleration is downward on
the figure. (spring streched, pulling the 1kg body downwards)
Why is this confusing?
Springs are flexible. Have you never used I coil spring? If a large
mass is fixed to the top it will lean over. Maybe you only know of the
cantilever type.
Normally, the body would be hanging downwards, for obvious reasons.
Normally accelerometers aren't 1kg bodies hanging in a spring.
Now you know better, or don't you?
An accelerometer always measure the proper acceleration.
When an accelerometer is stationary on the ground,
it shows the proper acceleration a ree 9.8 m/s-# upward.
You can wonder why, but it is a fact.
The following may give you a hint:
Given a spaceship with mass m = 10000 kg.
This spaceship has a rocket engine with thrust F = 98000 N The
proper acceleration of the spaceship is a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-# An
accelerometer onboard will show a = 9.8 m/s-#
No Paul. It shows Force = 9.8 m/s/s.
Is this meant to be a joke?
You are the joke Paul...along with your friend Einstein.
Now we place the spaceship vertically 10m above the ground.
The ship will be stationary relative to the ground, it will stay
hovering 10 m above the ground.
The accelerometer will still show the proper acceleration a = 9.8
m/s-#!
The engine thrust neutralizes the gravity force on the rocket itself
but because the top of the spring remains stationary, that force is
not transmitted to the body.
Don't be ridiculous. :-D
The accelerometer will show the same as if it was stationary on the
ground, which is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
That's right. The engine thrust is not transmitted to the body.
This is too idiotic even for you.
It is the acceleration of the body that is measured.
That acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
That means that the force on the body is 9.8 N.
From where do you think this force comes?
The only change is that the upward force that was exerted by the ground
on the rocket is now exerted by the reaction to the momentum increase
of the propellant. The hanging body is not affected by the firing of
the engine.
The fact that the output from the accelerometer shows that the
acceleration of the 1kg body is a = 9.8 m/s-# _proves_ that the _only_
force acting on the 1kg body is the upwards force from the compressed
spring: F = 9.8 N.
Paul, will you please act normally and turn you box upside down.
...but whichever way it hangs, TWO forces act on it when siting on the
ground. The spring tension and gravity. It has NO acceleration. Only
idiots like Einstein believe it does. In free fall the tension becomes
zero + minuscule gravity gradient
So whether the spaceship is far from gravitating masses,
or is stationary relative to the Earth 10 m above the ground,
the only force that acts on the 1kg body is the 9.8 N force from
compressed spring, and the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
No Paul, you have been badly indoctrinated. Gravity is a force, not an
acceleration. Newton's law say it all. Einstein thought he was greater
than Newton and stuffed up the whole of Physics for 120 years.
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that
the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
This is a fact whether you like it or not.
Yes. The device still measures the downward force of gravity on the
body,
even though the rocket is now experiencing zero force.
Don't be ridiculous!
The rocket is "experiencing" 98000 N upward force and 9.8 m/s-# upward
acceleration.
where is your dv/dt Paul? Where is your dx/dt?
Does the fact that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut in the
rocket is zero make him weightless?
No, he can feel his seat pushing him upwards with the force F = m*(9.8 m/s-#)N where m is his mass.
Interesting.Of course it is gravitation at play.
But there is no "gravitatinal force" that can be measured.
What can be measured is the acceleration caused by gravitation.
The acceleration _is_ the gravitation.
Like I said, you have been badly indoctrinated. There is no d2x/dt2.
Tell me Paul, when two bar magnets are stuck firmly together, do you
really think they accelerating towards each other?
You can see them ACCELERATING very rapidly while they are coming
together...and that acceleration ceases when they do. Surely you wont
argue about that.
The same applies to a +ve and -ve charge coming together..precisely in
line with gravity.
It seems like GR is right:
Acceleration and gravitation are the same phenomena.
Paul, they don't even have the same dimensions.
So we measure the gravitation as an acceleration!
Yes! That one reason Physics has gone completely off the rails.
The fact that an accelerometer at the ground show that acceleration is
9.8 m/s-# upward has made Physics go completely off the rails.
Whose Physics has gone off the rail because an accelerometer works
according to Newton's second law of motion?
Newton's second law of motion, F = dp/dt, is valid in SR/GR and NM.
Real accelerometers are electronic devices and the most used 'spring'
is a piezoelectric crystal (like quartz). The delay is in the ms range
or faster. The data of an accelerometer will vary depending on what use
it is built for.
Paul. You don't have a clue. The delay, whether it is ten seconds or a nanosecond is fundamental to the whole operation. ..and it doesn't
matter if the spring is steel or crystal, the same principles apply. If
an acceleration is not horizontal, the FORCE of gravity will affect the operation.
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that
the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
gawd! Paul has changed religion. He is now an 'Earth Expansionist'. He
thinks the reason we don't fall off the Earth is because its surface is continually accelerating outwards.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity is
a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the
ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body is
not accelerating.
Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that
the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
gawd! Paul has changed religion. He is now an 'Earth Expansionist'. He
thinks the reason we don't fall off the Earth is because its surface is
continually accelerating outwards.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity
is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the
ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body
is not accelerating.
I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.
And then you can explain why real accelerometers do not show what Newton
say they should show. What are the alternative laws of nature that an accelerometer obey?
HenryWilson wrote:
Real accelerometers are electronic devices and the most used 'spring'
is a piezoelectric crystal (like quartz). The delay is in the ms range
or faster. The data of an accelerometer will vary depending on what
use it is built for.
Paul. You don't have a clue. The delay, whether it is ten seconds or a
nanosecond is fundamental to the whole operation. ..and it doesn't
matter if the spring is steel or crystal, the same principles apply. If
an acceleration is not horizontal, the FORCE of gravity will affect the
operation.
the most today are cheap 3D force accelerometer, and you are correct,
you need a closesd to no mass accelerometer, ie optical, laser based accelerometers
also, just take 2 shots of an object fixed as stationary reference, then calculate based on the zoom factor, or a table.
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that >>>> the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity
is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the
ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body
is not accelerating.
I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.
Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised that your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining to you that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration. It is calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o course, zero.
If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring has contracted. Get it now?
Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that >>>>> the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
Of course-a I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity >>>> is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the >>>> ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body
is not accelerating.
I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.
And this is your answer:
Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised
that
your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining to
you
that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration. It is
calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring
tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of
gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o
course, zero.
If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring has
contracted. Get it now?
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to
the spring is the force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
force -F acting on the body.
So we can sum it up thus:
Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion doesn't apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#
Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows
that the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
Of course I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says
gravity is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local
compression of the ground is pushing the object up. There is no
residual force. The body is not accelerating.
I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.
And this is your answer:
Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised
that your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep
explaining to you that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure
acceleration. It is calibrated according to spring extension and
therefore measures spring tension directly...a force. When on the
ground, it measure the force of gravity acting on the hanging mass,
nothing else. Its acceleration is o course, zero.
If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring
has contracted. Get it now?
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is the
force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration a
= F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration
is 9.8 m/s-#.
The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is a = 9.8 m/s-#
upward, because the spring is still exerting the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
because the upward force from the spring doesn't make the body
accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward force -F acting on
the body.
So we can sum it up thus:
Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer on
the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion doesn't apply
on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#
Is it possible to make an accelerometer which correctly can measure a
static horizontal acceleration and, when turned 90 degrees, will show
the static vertical acceleration is zero?
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is the
force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration a
= F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration
is 9.8 m/s-#.
Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its tension
is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body with that force.
On 11/1/2026 2:53 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows that >>>>>> the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
Of course-a I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says gravity >>>>> is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression of the >>>>> ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body >>>>> is not accelerating.
I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.
And this is your answer:
Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm surprised
that
your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining to
you
that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration. It is >>> calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring
tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of
gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o
course, zero.
If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the spring has >>> contracted. Get it now?
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to
the spring is the force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
force -F acting on the body.
So we can sum it up thus:
Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion doesn't
apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#
And poor idiot Paul B.Andersen claims that since
his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
sharks eating fishes are improper.
his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
sharks eating fishes are improper.
Le 01/11/2026 |a 17:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
On 11/1/2026 2:53 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows >>>>>>> that
the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
Of course-a I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says
gravity
is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression
of the
ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body >>>>>> is not accelerating.
I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.
And this is your answer:
Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm
surprised that
your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining
to you
that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration.
It is
calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring >>>> tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of >>>> gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o >>>> course, zero.
If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the
spring has
contracted. Get it now?
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to
the spring is the force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
force -F acting on the body.
So we can sum it up thus:
Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion
doesn't apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#
And poor idiot Paul B.Andersen claims that since
his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
sharks eating fishes are improper.
Maciej,
his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
sharks eating fishes are improper.
No.
Once again you are trying to extract ordinary English from a technical
term.
"Proper acceleration" does not mean:
-a-a good acceleration
-a-a correct acceleration
-a-a morally appropriate acceleration
any more than "proper time" means "perfect time".
And no guru is required here. A spring and Newton are enough.
Drop the accelerometer:
-a-a case and test mass both fall
-a-a spring extension -> 0
-a-a accelerometer reading -> 0
Support it on the ground:
-a-a case is supported
-a-a test mass is pulled downward by gravity
-a-a spring is extended
-a-a accelerometer reading -> g
Put it in a rocket accelerating at g far from gravity:
-a-a case pushes the test mass
-a-a spring is extended
-a-a accelerometer reading -> g
Those are physical predictions about an actual instrument.
Calling one of them "sharks eating grass" changes neither the spring extension nor the reading.
Le 01/11/2026 |a 17:35, Maciej Wo+|niak a |-crit :
On 11/1/2026 2:53 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 01.11.2026 05:18, skrev HenryWilson:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:29:59 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Den 31.10.2026 17:54, skrev HenryWilson:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:25:37 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
You know perfectly well that an accelerometer on the ground shows >>>>>>> that
the acceleration is 9.8 m/s-# upward.
And that is exactly what Newton says it should show.
Or do you claim otherwise? :-D
Of course-a I do. You don't even understand Newton. Newton says
gravity
is a force is pulling the body down. The equal local compression
of the
ground is pushing the object up. There is no residual force. The body >>>>>> is not accelerating.
I challenge you to explain what Newton say an accelerometer on the
ground should show the vertical acceleration to be.
And this is your answer:
Paul, I know you must be getting on a bit in years but, I'm
surprised that
your knowledge of Physics has all but evaporated. I keep explaining
to you
that a spring accelerometer does not actually measure acceleration.
It is
calibrated according to spring extension and therefore measures spring >>>> tension directly...a force. When on the ground, it measure the force of >>>> gravity acting on the hanging mass, nothing else. Its acceleration is o >>>> course, zero.
If you lift the box up and then drop it, the box will accelerate
immediately. The body will also accelerate downwards after the
spring has
contracted. Get it now?
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating
at 9.8 m/s-# somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to
the spring is the force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper
acceleration a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows
that the proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground
so the rocket is stationary relative to the ground.
The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is
a = 9.8 m/s-# upward, because the spring is still exerting
the upward force F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m on the body.
But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
because the upward force from the spring doesn't make
the body accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward
force -F acting on the body.
So we can sum it up thus:
Ralph Malcolm Rabbidge aka Henry Wilson knows that an accelerometer
on the ground shows that its proper acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#, but he
claims that this is wrong because Newton's second law of motion
doesn't apply on the ground. The correct proper acceleration is 0 m/s-#
And poor idiot Paul B.Andersen claims that since
his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
sharks eating fishes are improper.
Maciej,
his mad guru announced sharks to Eat grass -
sharks eating fishes are improper.
No.
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is the
force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration a
= F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration
is 9.8 m/s-#.
Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its tension
is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body with that force.
The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground so the rocket is
stationary relative to the ground.
The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is a = 9.8 m/s-#
upward, because the spring is still exerting the upward force F = (9.8
m/s-#)*m on the body.
But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
because the upward force from the spring doesn't make the body
accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward force -F acting on
the body.
Paul, I can only feel sorry for you. All you have done is replace the
upward force on the rocket (and box) exerted by the local compression of
the ground with the upward reaction (pressure) to the propellant's
continuous change in momentum. Neither the body nor its position are
affected in any way. The box is still effectively fixed to the ground and
the spring extension is still a measure of the downward force of gravity acting on the body.
Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference
between coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.
HenryWilson wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is
the force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration
a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper
acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its
tension is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body
with that force.
idiot, a peiezo electric film or shaped material is usually triggered by
an electric frequency from 40 kHz (ultrasound) to 4 MHz; kiss my ass
On 11/2/2026 10:40 PM, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference between
coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.
Yeah, we should study hard to understand the difference between proper
sharks eating grass and improper sharks eating fishes.
Den 01.11.2026 19:38, skrev HenryWilson:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 14:53:49 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
An accelerometer is in a rocket that is accelerating at 9.8 m/s-#
somewhere in intergalactic space.
The only force that is acting on the body attached to the spring is
the force accelerating the body,
F = (9.8 m/s-#)*m where m is the mass of the body.
According to Newton's second law of motion is the proper acceleration
a = F/m = 9.8 m/s-#. The accelerometer shows that the proper
acceleration is 9.8 m/s-#.
Absolutely correct. After the spring has finished extending, its
tension is 9.8 Newtons (per unit mass) and it is accelerating the body
with that force.
The rocket is now hovering ten metres above the ground so the rocket
is stationary relative to the ground.
The accelerometer shows that the proper acceleration is a = 9.8 m/s-#
upward, because the spring is still exerting the upward force F = (9.8
m/s-#)*m on the body.
According to Henry:
But now Newton's second law of motions doesn't apply,
because the upward force from the spring doesn't make the body
accelerate upwards, because now there is a downward force -F acting on
the body.
Paul, I can only feel sorry for you. All you have done is replace the
upward force on the rocket (and box) exerted by the local compression
of the ground with the upward reaction (pressure) to the propellant's
continuous change in momentum. Neither the body nor its position are
affected in any way. The box is still effectively fixed to the ground
and the spring extension is still a measure of the downward force of
gravity acting on the body.
Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference between coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.
Example 1:
A centrifuge for testing astronauts has a r = 16m long arm and the speed
of the astronaut is v = 40 m/s.
This means that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut is a = v-#/r
= 100 m/s-# (ree 10.2 g).
The mass of the astronaut and his spacesuit is m = 100kg.
According to Newton's second law of motion the inward (toward the centre
of the centrifuge) force the backrest of the astronaut's chair will
exert on him will be
F = mriaa = 10000 N.
This means that the proper acceleration of the astronaut is a = 100 m/s-#
.
An accelerometer in the astronaut's chair would show a = 100 m/s-#.
In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are equal.
Example 2:
The astronaut is in a space vehicle (SV, satellite) orbiting the Earth
at an altitude h = 680500 m (slightly higher than the ISS). This is equivalent to an orbital radius r = 7058637 m.
The orbital period is p = reU(4-C-#r-|/GM) = 5901.9 s.
where G is the gravitational constant and M is the mass of Earth.
The orbital speed is v = 2-Criar/p = 7514.6 m/s.
The coordinate acceleration of the SV is a = v-#/r = 8.000 m/s-#
According to Newton's law of gravitation the acceleration is:
a = F/m = GM/r-# = 8.000 m/s-#
where F is Newton's gravitational force and m is the mass of the SV
including the astronaut.
The question is now if this is the proper acceleration of the SV.
We know that the astronaut in the SV is weightless. He can feel that no
force is acting on him. That means that his proper acceleration is 0
m/s-#.
An accelerometer in the SV would show a = 0 m/s-#.
In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are different.
This shows that that "Newton's gravitational force" doesn't exist,
and F/m is a coordinate acceleration.
However, when orbits are calculated, it is the coordinate acceleration
that is used.
The "gravitational acceleration" is a coordinate acceleration.
I have made a program which simulates satellites orbiting the Earth.
See:
https://paulba.no/Satellites.html I have used the post-Newtonian approximation of the gravitational acceleration predicted by GR, see the equation shown on this page: https://paulba.no/PerihelionAdvance.html I
have also tried to use the Newtonian gravitational acceleration a =
GM/r-#, and I must admit that in the satellite simulation I can see no difference between the GR-acceleration and the Newton acceleration.
In stimulations of planet orbits it is a significant difference, though.
I already have a very good programs for simulating elliptical orbits and saving their important details, using Newton's equation. The orbit shapes
are as close to those produced by equation as the computer will resolve. I have also simulated precession, which I found could be largely dependent
on the speed of gravity...which, purely by accident, might be represented
by the very small computer iteration error. If you simulate the capture of
a passing object, you will notice that its orbit will precess for an indefinite time afterwards..but again that could be just an iteration
error. Simulating three body situations is even more fascinating.
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 22:40:01 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference between
coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.
Acceleration is absolute...it has the same magnitude in all frames but its direction is naturally relative. I gather that's what you mean by 'coordinate' ... because centripetal force acts normally to the velocity vector.
Example 1:
A centrifuge for testing astronauts has a r = 16m long arm and the speed
of the astronaut is v = 40 m/s.
This means that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut is a = v-#/r
= 100 m/s-# (ree 10.2 g).
The mass of the astronaut and his spacesuit is m = 100kg.
According to Newton's second law of motion the inward (toward the centre
of the centrifuge) force the backrest of the astronaut's chair will
exert on him will be
F = mriaa = 10000 N.
This means that the proper acceleration of the astronaut is a = 100 m/s-#
.
An accelerometer in the astronaut's chair would show a = 100 m/s-#.
In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are
equal.
Naturally...since they are consequent to the same force.
Example 2:
The astronaut is in a space vehicle (SV, satellite) orbiting the Earth
at an altitude h = 680500 m (slightly higher than the ISS). This is
equivalent to an orbital radius r = 7058637 m.
The orbital period is p = reU(4-C-#r-|/GM) = 5901.9 s.
where G is the gravitational constant and M is the mass of Earth.
The orbital speed is v = 2-Criar/p = 7514.6 m/s.
The coordinate acceleration of the SV is a = v-#/r = 8.000 m/s-#
According to Newton's law of gravitation the acceleration is:
a = F/m = GM/r-# = 8.000 m/s-#
where F is Newton's gravitational force and m is the mass of the SV
including the astronaut.
The question is now if this is the proper acceleration of the SV.
We know that the astronaut in the SV is weightless. He can feel that no
force is acting on him. That means that his proper acceleration is 0
m/s-#.
An accelerometer in the SV would show a = 0 m/s-#.
In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are
different.
This shows that that "Newton's gravitational force" doesn't exist,
and F/m is a coordinate acceleration.
Paul, while I had a few spare moments, I invented a very useful device
called a nonsometer. I tested it by feeding in some of your posts and
guess what happened, It blew up...went right off scale...but not before it announced, 'DEFINITELY PROPER NONSENSE...COORDINATES WITH NO ASPECT OF REALITY'.
However, when orbits are calculated, it is the coordinate acceleration
that is used.
The "gravitational acceleration" is a coordinate acceleration.
Paul, the force of gravity acts identically to the force exerted by the
chair on the astronaut's back. Both act normally to his velocity. They can
be considered identical in concept.
Den 03.11.2026 04:36, skrev HenryWilson:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 22:40:01 +0100, Paul B. Andersen wrote:
Let's study Newton's gravitational force and the difference between
coordinate acceleration and proper acceleration.
Acceleration is absolute...it has the same magnitude in all frames but
its
direction is naturally relative. I gather that's what you mean by
'coordinate' ... because centripetal force acts normally to the velocity
vector.
Example 1:
A centrifuge for testing astronauts has a r = 16m long arm and the speed >>> of the astronaut is v = 40 m/s.
This means that the coordinate acceleration of the astronaut is a = v-#/r >>> = 100 m/s-# (ree 10.2 g).
The mass of the astronaut and his spacesuit is m = 100kg.
According to Newton's second law of motion the inward (toward the centre >>> of the centrifuge) force the backrest of the astronaut's chair will
exert on him will be
-a-a F = mriaa = 10000 N.
This means that the proper acceleration of the astronaut is a = 100 m/s-# >>> .
An accelerometer in the astronaut's chair would show a = 100 m/s-#.
In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are >>> equal.
Naturally...since they are consequent to the same force.
Example 2:
The astronaut is in a space vehicle (SV, satellite) orbiting the Earth
at an altitude h = 680500 m (slightly higher than the ISS). This is
equivalent to an orbital radius r = 7058637 m.
The orbital period is p = reU(4-C-#r-|/GM) = 5901.9 s.
where G is the gravitational constant and M is the mass of Earth.
The orbital speed is v = 2-Criar/p = 7514.6 m/s.
The coordinate acceleration of the SV is a = v-#/r = 8.000 m/s-#
According to Newton's law of gravitation the acceleration is:
a = F/m = GM/r-# = 8.000 m/s-#
-a-a-a where F is Newton's gravitational force and m is the mass of the SV >>> -a-a-a including the astronaut.
The question is now if this is the proper acceleration of the SV.
We know that the astronaut in the SV is weightless. He can feel that no
force is acting on him. That means that his proper acceleration is 0
m/s-#.
An accelerometer in the SV would show a = 0 m/s-#.
In this case the coordinate acceleration and the proper acceleration are >>> different.
This shows that that "Newton's gravitational force" doesn't exist,
and F/m is a coordinate acceleration.
Paul, while I had a few spare moments, I invented a very useful device
called a nonsometer. I tested it by feeding in some of your posts and
guess what happened, It blew up...went right off scale...but not
before it
announced, 'DEFINITELY PROPER NONSENSE...COORDINATES WITH NO ASPECT OF
REALITY'.
Your well formulated explanation of why I am wrong noted.
However, when orbits are calculated, it is the coordinate acceleration
that is used.
The "gravitational acceleration" is a coordinate acceleration.
An example:
The orbital radius of a GPS SV is r = 26561763 m.
According to Newton the gravitational acceleration is:
-aa = F/m = GM/r-# = 0.5650 m/s-#
where F is the gravitational force, m is the mass of the SV,
and GM = 3.986004418e14 m-|/s-# is the geocentric gravitational constant.
The coordinate acceleration of the SV is:
-a a = v-#/r where v is the orbital speed of the SV.
-a v = reU(ariar) = 3873.8 m/s
Period: p = 2-Criar/v = 43082.045 s
which is half a sidereal day as specified in
the Interface Specification Document.
So from the gravitational acceleration we now know the exact orbit
of the GPS SV.
Paul, the force of gravity acts identically to the force exerted by the
chair on the astronaut's back. Both act normally to his velocity. They
can
be considered identical in concept.
No "gravitational force" is acting on a satellite in orbit,
its proper acceleration is zero as shown by accelerometers.
This is a fact, and nothing more to discuss.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 55:41:01 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,687 |