• Re: Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 30 14:14:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 30 18:31:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be
    enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.


    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.


    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Fri Oct 30 20:45:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be
    enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 07:06:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be >>>>> enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much
    about the early Bronze Age.


    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule,
    and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.


    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a "spiral-space-filling-curve"
    as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar
    with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with
    a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little
    circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.


    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of"
    being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association
    to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions
    of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question
    of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing".
    (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.)

    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.


    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling curve,
    which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 07:37:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/31/2026 07:06 AM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be >>>>>> enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable, >>>> and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much
    about the early Bronze Age.


    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule,
    and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.


    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a "spiral-space-filling-curve"
    as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar
    with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with
    a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little
    circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.


    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of"
    being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association
    to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions
    of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question
    of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing".
    (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.)

    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.


    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling curve,
    which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.





    "Nobody likes a quitter", ....


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 11:49:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    That is an old number..(you probbly found that number on old websites.)

    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    You probbly need permission to change the number from 13.6 billion to
    26.7 billion. Do you know who to ask for permission??


    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be >>>>> enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable, >>> and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much
    about the early Bronze Age.

    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule,
    and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.

    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a "spiral-space-filling-curve"
    as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar
    with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with
    a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little
    circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.

    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of"
    being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association
    to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions
    of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question
    of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing".
    (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.)

    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.

    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling curve,
    which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 13:48:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/31/2026 11:49 AM, The Starmaker wrote:
    That is an old number..(you probbly found that number on old websites.)

    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    You probbly need permission to change the number from 13.6 billion to
    26.7 billion. Do you know who to ask for permission??


    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be >>>>>>> enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable, >>>>> and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much
    about the early Bronze Age.

    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule,
    and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.

    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a "spiral-space-filling-curve"
    as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar
    with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with
    a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little
    circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.

    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of"
    being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association
    to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions
    of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question
    of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing".
    (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.)

    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.

    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling curve,
    which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.


    "If you have to ask, ...", then perhaps it helps to have
    some key terms to help broaden the perspective from usual
    inductive accounts of the invincible ignorance of inductive
    inference the impasses, crevasses, and chasms, about why
    somebody like Mirimanoff or Skolem long ago broke open the
    ordinary set theory.


    Hm, you appear to have learned something.

    Perhaps if you put my video essays on random and let
    them background-noise a few hours or days you'll wise up a bit.


    Zeno crosses Zeno's bridge every day,
    Aristotle won't be made a fool,
    and Hegel won't be made a liar.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 14:06:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/31/2026 01:48 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 11:49 AM, The Starmaker wrote:
    That is an old number..(you probbly found that number on old websites.)

    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    You probbly need permission to change the number from 13.6 billion to
    26.7 billion. Do you know who to ask for permission??


    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears >>>>>>>> to be
    enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable, >>>>>> to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the
    unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much
    about the early Bronze Age.

    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule,
    and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.

    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a "spiral-space-filling-curve"
    as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar
    with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with
    a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little
    circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.

    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of"
    being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association
    to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions
    of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question
    of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing".
    (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.)

    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.

    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling curve,
    which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.


    "If you have to ask, ...", then perhaps it helps to have
    some key terms to help broaden the perspective from usual
    inductive accounts of the invincible ignorance of inductive
    inference the impasses, crevasses, and chasms, about why
    somebody like Mirimanoff or Skolem long ago broke open the
    ordinary set theory.


    Hm, you appear to have learned something.

    Perhaps if you put my video essays on random and let
    them background-noise a few hours or days you'll wise up a bit.


    Zeno crosses Zeno's bridge every day,
    Aristotle won't be made a fool,
    and Hegel won't be made a liar.



    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_du_Bois-Reymond


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Oct 31 21:28:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The Starmaker wrote:

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be >>> enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable, and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.

    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?


    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    yous guys gots to get your maths right...
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 07:17:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/31/2026 09:28 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be >>>>>> enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable, >>>> and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.

    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?


    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    yous guys gots to get your maths right...




    Check back later, it'll change again.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 11:39:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/31/2026 09:28 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be >>>>>> enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable, >>>> and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.

    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?


    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    yous guys gots to get your maths right...



    Check back later, it'll change again.

    I was hoping you had permission to change it by now...


    ok, here's a easy one for you..it's about clocks!


    If you have one clock here and
    another clock there..

    Which clock has the true time?
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 15:36:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 09:28 PM, The Starmaker wrote:

    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?


    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    yous guys gots to get your maths right...




    Check back later, it'll change again.


    Do you guys have some cites about this? Last I heard was around 14
    billion years or so.
    --
    Sometimes I just feel like I need to get away
    A place where I can be by myself, all alone
    I kinda lay down in the back yard
    Watch the leaves fall down on my face
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 15:44:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 01:48 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 11:49 AM, The Starmaker wrote:
    That is an old number..(you probbly found that number on old websites.)

    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    You probbly need permission to change the number from 13.6 billion to
    26.7 billion. Do you know who to ask for permission??


    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    aaaaaaa expressing the situation of something that is or appears >>>>>>>>> to be
    enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable, >>>>>>> to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the
    unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, .... >>>>>>
    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much
    about the early Bronze Age.

    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule,
    and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.

    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a "spiral-space-filling-curve" >>>> as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar
    with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with
    a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little
    circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.

    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of"
    being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association
    to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions
    of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question
    of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing".
    (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.)

    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.

    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling curve,
    which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.


    "If you have to ask, ...", then perhaps it helps to have
    some key terms to help broaden the perspective from usual
    inductive accounts of the invincible ignorance of inductive
    inference the impasses, crevasses, and chasms, about why
    somebody like Mirimanoff or Skolem long ago broke open the
    ordinary set theory.


    Hm, you appear to have learned something.

    Perhaps if you put my video essays on random and let
    them background-noise a few hours or days you'll wise up a bit.


    Zeno crosses Zeno's bridge every day,
    Aristotle won't be made a fool,
    and Hegel won't be made a liar.



    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_du_Bois-Reymond

    Most of my peers avoided anything computer-programming. I avoid anything Fourier transform. It's probably because the science of Fourier totally discards what your 'gut' feeling can tell you. As I understand it, it's
    like sampling some sequence every 1,000 units.

    While Fourier has nothing to do with 'gut' feeling, the difficult
    science of magnetics and electro-magnetics on the other hand does. I
    think if I ever go back to school this should be my focus. While my
    peers flunked out here & there & all over, I got a perfect score on the
    final. What this stuff is about is a so-called threshold quantity or
    ratio that talks about the strength and actions of the fields.

    Electromagnetism has "levels" much like water. A small amount causes
    static cling. More causes magnets to lift objects. More heats materials.
    More creates sparks and plasma. More still rearranges chemistry,
    penetrates atoms, and eventually accelerates particles to near light
    speed. The underlying force is the same in every case; only the energy
    scale changes.

    Ionization threshold

    This is one of the most important thresholds in nature.

    Add enough energy and electrons are stripped from atoms.

    Examples:

    Neon signs
    Lightning
    Welding arcs
    Plasma globes

    Now matter behaves very differently because some electrons are free
    rather than bound to atoms.

    You have crossed from ordinary gas into plasma.
    --
    Sometimes I just feel like I need to get away
    A place where I can be by myself, all alone
    I kinda lay down in the back yard
    Watch the leaves fall down on my face
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 17:06:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 11/01/2026 02:44 PM, Blaine wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 01:48 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 11:49 AM, The Starmaker wrote:
    That is an old number..(you probbly found that number on old websites.) >>>>
    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    You probbly need permission to change the number from 13.6 billion to
    26.7 billion. Do you know who to ask for permission??


    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears >>>>>>>>>> to be
    enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity, >>>>>>>>> and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable, >>>>>>>> to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the
    unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, .... >>>>>>>
    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured >>>>>>> out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much
    about the early Bronze Age.

    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule,
    and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.

    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a
    "spiral-space-filling-curve"
    as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar
    with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with
    a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little
    circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.

    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of"
    being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association >>>>> to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions
    of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question
    of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing".
    (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.)

    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.

    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling curve, >>>>> which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.


    "If you have to ask, ...", then perhaps it helps to have
    some key terms to help broaden the perspective from usual
    inductive accounts of the invincible ignorance of inductive
    inference the impasses, crevasses, and chasms, about why
    somebody like Mirimanoff or Skolem long ago broke open the
    ordinary set theory.


    Hm, you appear to have learned something.

    Perhaps if you put my video essays on random and let
    them background-noise a few hours or days you'll wise up a bit.


    Zeno crosses Zeno's bridge every day,
    Aristotle won't be made a fool,
    and Hegel won't be made a liar.



    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_du_Bois-Reymond

    Most of my peers avoided anything computer-programming. I avoid anything Fourier transform. It's probably because the science of Fourier totally discards what your 'gut' feeling can tell you. As I understand it, it's
    like sampling some sequence every 1,000 units.

    While Fourier has nothing to do with 'gut' feeling, the difficult
    science of magnetics and electro-magnetics on the other hand does. I
    think if I ever go back to school this should be my focus. While my
    peers flunked out here & there & all over, I got a perfect score on the final. What this stuff is about is a so-called threshold quantity or
    ratio that talks about the strength and actions of the fields.

    Electromagnetism has "levels" much like water. A small amount causes
    static cling. More causes magnets to lift objects. More heats materials.
    More creates sparks and plasma. More still rearranges chemistry,
    penetrates atoms, and eventually accelerates particles to near light
    speed. The underlying force is the same in every case; only the energy
    scale changes.

    Ionization threshold

    This is one of the most important thresholds in nature.

    Add enough energy and electrons are stripped from atoms.

    Examples:

    Neon signs
    Lightning
    Welding arcs
    Plasma globes

    Now matter behaves very differently because some electrons are free
    rather than bound to atoms.

    You have crossed from ordinary gas into plasma.


    Hm.

    "Criticality": is a concept, sort of like mathematical "emergence"
    after mathematical "convergence", where one expects convergence to
    always approach and never get farther away "the limit". Then,
    emergence is a sort of account of where "the limit" exists that
    it doesn't appear that "convergence" "converges".


    If you take a circle and draw two circles in it, sharing a diameter
    and of half the radius each, then drawing the orthogonal diameter,
    divides the circle C_0 into two semi-circles, then proceeding apace,
    the radius is halved ad infinitum until it reaches zero.

    Then, the sum of the area outside the circles, is pi r_0 ^2 / 2 - pi
    (r_0/2) ^2, so, there's the infinite series.

    Sum_i=1^oo pi (r/(2^i-1))^2 - pi (r/(2^i))^2 = pi r^2

    pi Sum_i=1^oo (r/(2^i-1))^2 - (r/(2^i))^2 = pi r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo (r/(2^i-1))^2 - (r^2/(2^i))^2 = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo r^2/(2^(2i-2)) - r^2/(2^2i) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo (r^2 2^2i - r^2 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo r^2 ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / 2^(4i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 2^2i ((1 - 2^(0-2) ) / 2^2i 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo ((1 - 2^(0-2) ) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 - 2^(0-2)) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 - 1/4) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 3/4 / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 3/ 2^(2i) = 1



    Hm.

    Compare this.

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 / 2^i) = 1

    Yet, the circumference of the outer circle and its contained circles,
    is a constant, since circumference C = pi D, and the contained circles
    with D_0 = D have that D_1 = D_0 / 2 and there are two of them, thusly
    the circumference is a constant, since the isoperimetric property.

    So, the limit of the circumference is a constant, while,
    the limit of the subtracted area is the entire area.

    Then, what emerges is that what results after all the bumps go to
    smooth, is that pi D -> 2 D (or D, whether the diameter's measure
    is counted on both sides).

    pi-ratio space / pi-ratio measure



    These sorts of things, where the infinite series adds up wrong,
    have been known since Zeno as "Zeno's moving rows" or "the
    windsprinters" I call it, then about Vitali's "split a unit line
    segment into infinitesimal bits: now it adds back up to length 2",
    then Hausdorff's "I made one for a 3-D ball instead of a 2-D line
    segment", then Banach-Tarski re-wrote that in algebra instead of
    geometry, while just saying Vitalie's was "non-measurable".



    So, these are the sorts of things, that happen in the infinite,
    the emergence, where the usual measure theory where the reals have
    measure 1 and the rationals have measure 0, can't say, while yet
    the accounts of Vitali's and Hausdorff's and since Zeno's, do say.


    "re-Vitali-ize measure theory", sometimes these days
    called "quasi-invariant measure theory".


    Otherwise physics these days has a well-known "crisis"
    called "the measure problem", which is at least three
    kinds of problems.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sun Nov 1 17:20:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 11/01/2026 05:06 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 11/01/2026 02:44 PM, Blaine wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 01:48 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 11:49 AM, The Starmaker wrote:
    That is an old number..(you probbly found that number on old
    websites.)

    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    You probbly need permission to change the number from 13.6 billion to >>>>> 26.7 billion. Do you know who to ask for permission??


    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe? >>>>>>>>>>>>
    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears >>>>>>>>>>> to be
    enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity, >>>>>>>>>> and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the
    unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the >>>>>>>>> unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, .... >>>>>>>>
    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples >>>>>>>> about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured >>>>>>>> out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that >>>>>>>> the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much
    about the early Bronze Age.

    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule,
    and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.

    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a
    "spiral-space-filling-curve"
    as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar >>>>>> with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with
    a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little
    circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.

    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of"
    being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association >>>>>> to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions >>>>>> of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question >>>>>> of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing".
    (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.)

    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.

    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling curve, >>>>>> which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.


    "If you have to ask, ...", then perhaps it helps to have
    some key terms to help broaden the perspective from usual
    inductive accounts of the invincible ignorance of inductive
    inference the impasses, crevasses, and chasms, about why
    somebody like Mirimanoff or Skolem long ago broke open the
    ordinary set theory.


    Hm, you appear to have learned something.

    Perhaps if you put my video essays on random and let
    them background-noise a few hours or days you'll wise up a bit.


    Zeno crosses Zeno's bridge every day,
    Aristotle won't be made a fool,
    and Hegel won't be made a liar.



    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_du_Bois-Reymond

    Most of my peers avoided anything computer-programming. I avoid anything
    Fourier transform. It's probably because the science of Fourier totally
    discards what your 'gut' feeling can tell you. As I understand it, it's
    like sampling some sequence every 1,000 units.

    While Fourier has nothing to do with 'gut' feeling, the difficult
    science of magnetics and electro-magnetics on the other hand does. I
    think if I ever go back to school this should be my focus. While my
    peers flunked out here & there & all over, I got a perfect score on the
    final. What this stuff is about is a so-called threshold quantity or
    ratio that talks about the strength and actions of the fields.

    Electromagnetism has "levels" much like water. A small amount causes
    static cling. More causes magnets to lift objects. More heats materials.
    More creates sparks and plasma. More still rearranges chemistry,
    penetrates atoms, and eventually accelerates particles to near light
    speed. The underlying force is the same in every case; only the energy
    scale changes.

    Ionization threshold

    This is one of the most important thresholds in nature.

    Add enough energy and electrons are stripped from atoms.

    Examples:

    Neon signs
    Lightning
    Welding arcs
    Plasma globes

    Now matter behaves very differently because some electrons are free
    rather than bound to atoms.

    You have crossed from ordinary gas into plasma.


    Hm.

    "Criticality": is a concept, sort of like mathematical "emergence"
    after mathematical "convergence", where one expects convergence to
    always approach and never get farther away "the limit". Then,
    emergence is a sort of account of where "the limit" exists that
    it doesn't appear that "convergence" "converges".


    If you take a circle and draw two circles in it, sharing a diameter
    and of half the radius each, then drawing the orthogonal diameter,
    divides the circle C_0 into two semi-circles, then proceeding apace,
    the radius is halved ad infinitum until it reaches zero.

    Then, the sum of the area outside the circles, is pi r_0 ^2 / 2 - pi
    (r_0/2) ^2, so, there's the infinite series.

    Sum_i=1^oo pi (r/(2^i-1))^2 - pi (r/(2^i))^2 = pi r^2

    pi Sum_i=1^oo (r/(2^i-1))^2 - (r/(2^i))^2 = pi r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo (r/(2^i-1))^2 - (r^2/(2^i))^2 = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo r^2/(2^(2i-2)) - r^2/(2^2i) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo (r^2 2^2i - r^2 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo r^2 ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / 2^(4i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 2^2i ((1 - 2^(0-2) ) / 2^2i 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo ((1 - 2^(0-2) ) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 - 2^(0-2)) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 - 1/4) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 3/4 / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 3/ 2^(2i) = 1



    Hm.

    Compare this.

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 / 2^i) = 1

    Yet, the circumference of the outer circle and its contained circles,
    is a constant, since circumference C = pi D, and the contained circles
    with D_0 = D have that D_1 = D_0 / 2 and there are two of them, thusly
    the circumference is a constant, since the isoperimetric property.

    So, the limit of the circumference is a constant, while,
    the limit of the subtracted area is the entire area.

    Then, what emerges is that what results after all the bumps go to
    smooth, is that pi D -> 2 D (or D, whether the diameter's measure
    is counted on both sides).

    pi-ratio space / pi-ratio measure



    These sorts of things, where the infinite series adds up wrong,
    have been known since Zeno as "Zeno's moving rows" or "the
    windsprinters" I call it, then about Vitali's "split a unit line
    segment into infinitesimal bits: now it adds back up to length 2",
    then Hausdorff's "I made one for a 3-D ball instead of a 2-D line
    segment", then Banach-Tarski re-wrote that in algebra instead of
    geometry, while just saying Vitalie's was "non-measurable".



    So, these are the sorts of things, that happen in the infinite,
    the emergence, where the usual measure theory where the reals have
    measure 1 and the rationals have measure 0, can't say, while yet
    the accounts of Vitali's and Hausdorff's and since Zeno's, do say.


    "re-Vitali-ize measure theory", sometimes these days
    called "quasi-invariant measure theory".


    Otherwise physics these days has a well-known "crisis"
    called "the measure problem", which is at least three
    kinds of problems.



    It's like the one where you're on a ski-trip with pseudo-Einstein,
    and you get to the top of the mountain, and survey the course.
    "How are we getting down, pseudo-Einstein?" "Gravity." "Which
    way are we going?" "Straight down."

    Then there's the one where pseudo-Einstein's playing marbles and dice.
    He puts a marble up to his eye, and says "I see a die", it's a "cube-wall".

    Then he notices the On High rolls a die, and it never stops rolling.

    Pseudo-Einstein rounds dice.



    How much is this 2i in this infinite series, pseudo-Einstein?
    Oh, it's "double infinity".


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Mon Nov 2 01:25:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 11/01/2026 05:20 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 11/01/2026 05:06 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 11/01/2026 02:44 PM, Blaine wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 01:48 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/31/2026 11:49 AM, The Starmaker wrote:
    That is an old number..(you probbly found that number on old
    websites.)

    It is my understanding the new number is 26.7 billion years.


    You probbly need permission to change the number from 13.6 billion to >>>>>> 26.7 billion. Do you know who to ask for permission??


    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 08:45 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe? >>>>>>>>>>>>>
    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or >>>>>>>>>>>> appears
    to be
    enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity, >>>>>>>>>>> and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the
    unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the >>>>>>>>>> unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, >>>>>>>>> ....

    Count toward the middle.

    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal >>>>>>>>> analysis for hundreds of years.

    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_, >>>>>>>>> then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples >>>>>>>>> about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise >>>>>>>>> the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's >>>>>>>>> a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured >>>>>>>>> out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that >>>>>>>>> the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.


    Is 13.6 billion the age of the universe?




    That's an estimate, like half-life carbon-dating doesn't say much >>>>>>> about the early Bronze Age.

    Shirley you had geometry in school, where points and lines were
    two different things yet define each other how they relate.

    Then in pre-calculus class there was given Zeno's "paradoxes"
    before learning about the limit.

    Then you learned the FTC's after the IVT and the trapezoid rule, >>>>>>> and then after various accounts of particular infinite series
    their limits (sums) like the geometric series, learned various
    derivatives and anti-derivatives of smooth functions, after
    learning about functions and smooth functions.

    Then about whether aliens who never heard of Euclid could
    arrive at geometry the mathematics after a
    "spiral-space-filling-curve"
    as a natural continuum, has at least that most people are familiar >>>>>>> with "drawing a line" as extending a point to another point with >>>>>>> a line in the middle, and "scribbling a dot" as drawing a little >>>>>>> circle with at least once putting pencil to paper.

    Then, for example, at some point somebody told you what a "set"
    was, as a collection of things, then with regards to "element-of" >>>>>>> being the relation of a set, that "contains" is the relation of
    a class, that "in" is probably your most usual geometric association >>>>>>> to association of relation, Venn diagrams and the like.

    Zeno, though, first of all makes for that there's the infinite,
    and for the continuous, all such accounts of "classical expositions >>>>>>> of the super-classical", being an example.

    Then of course that goes a bit further to "the fundamental question >>>>>>> of metaphysics" and "why is there something rather than nothing". >>>>>>> (The Bible starts that way, twice, in Genesis 1:1 and John 1:1.) >>>>>>>
    Then the Atman and Brahman of the Vedas gives accounts of
    perspective & projection.

    Before Wallis' lemniscate was the usual sign for "infinity"
    and "mathematics", it was a spiral like a spiral space-filling
    curve,
    which shows up in cave drawings since before recorded history.

    Anyways continuity and infinity are real.


    "If you have to ask, ...", then perhaps it helps to have
    some key terms to help broaden the perspective from usual
    inductive accounts of the invincible ignorance of inductive
    inference the impasses, crevasses, and chasms, about why
    somebody like Mirimanoff or Skolem long ago broke open the
    ordinary set theory.


    Hm, you appear to have learned something.

    Perhaps if you put my video essays on random and let
    them background-noise a few hours or days you'll wise up a bit.


    Zeno crosses Zeno's bridge every day,
    Aristotle won't be made a fool,
    and Hegel won't be made a liar.



    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_du_Bois-Reymond

    Most of my peers avoided anything computer-programming. I avoid anything >>> Fourier transform. It's probably because the science of Fourier totally
    discards what your 'gut' feeling can tell you. As I understand it, it's
    like sampling some sequence every 1,000 units.

    While Fourier has nothing to do with 'gut' feeling, the difficult
    science of magnetics and electro-magnetics on the other hand does. I
    think if I ever go back to school this should be my focus. While my
    peers flunked out here & there & all over, I got a perfect score on the
    final. What this stuff is about is a so-called threshold quantity or
    ratio that talks about the strength and actions of the fields.

    Electromagnetism has "levels" much like water. A small amount causes
    static cling. More causes magnets to lift objects. More heats materials. >>> More creates sparks and plasma. More still rearranges chemistry,
    penetrates atoms, and eventually accelerates particles to near light
    speed. The underlying force is the same in every case; only the energy
    scale changes.

    Ionization threshold

    This is one of the most important thresholds in nature.

    Add enough energy and electrons are stripped from atoms.

    Examples:

    Neon signs
    Lightning
    Welding arcs
    Plasma globes

    Now matter behaves very differently because some electrons are free
    rather than bound to atoms.

    You have crossed from ordinary gas into plasma.


    Hm.

    "Criticality": is a concept, sort of like mathematical "emergence"
    after mathematical "convergence", where one expects convergence to
    always approach and never get farther away "the limit". Then,
    emergence is a sort of account of where "the limit" exists that
    it doesn't appear that "convergence" "converges".


    If you take a circle and draw two circles in it, sharing a diameter
    and of half the radius each, then drawing the orthogonal diameter,
    divides the circle C_0 into two semi-circles, then proceeding apace,
    the radius is halved ad infinitum until it reaches zero.

    Then, the sum of the area outside the circles, is pi r_0 ^2 / 2 - pi
    (r_0/2) ^2, so, there's the infinite series.

    Sum_i=1^oo pi (r/(2^i-1))^2 - pi (r/(2^i))^2 = pi r^2

    pi Sum_i=1^oo (r/(2^i-1))^2 - (r/(2^i))^2 = pi r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo (r/(2^i-1))^2 - (r^2/(2^i))^2 = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo r^2/(2^(2i-2)) - r^2/(2^2i) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo (r^2 2^2i - r^2 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo r^2 ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = r^2

    Sum_i=1^oo ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / ( 2^(2i-2) 2^(2i) ) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo ((2^2i - 2^(2i-2) ) / 2^(4i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 2^2i ((1 - 2^(0-2) ) / 2^2i 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo ((1 - 2^(0-2) ) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 - 2^(0-2)) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 - 1/4) / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 3/4 / 2^(2i-2) = 1

    Sum_i=1^oo 3/ 2^(2i) = 1



    Hm.

    Compare this.

    Sum_i=1^oo (1 / 2^i) = 1

    Yet, the circumference of the outer circle and its contained circles,
    is a constant, since circumference C = pi D, and the contained circles
    with D_0 = D have that D_1 = D_0 / 2 and there are two of them, thusly
    the circumference is a constant, since the isoperimetric property.

    So, the limit of the circumference is a constant, while,
    the limit of the subtracted area is the entire area.

    Then, what emerges is that what results after all the bumps go to
    smooth, is that pi D -> 2 D (or D, whether the diameter's measure
    is counted on both sides).

    pi-ratio space / pi-ratio measure



    These sorts of things, where the infinite series adds up wrong,
    have been known since Zeno as "Zeno's moving rows" or "the
    windsprinters" I call it, then about Vitali's "split a unit line
    segment into infinitesimal bits: now it adds back up to length 2",
    then Hausdorff's "I made one for a 3-D ball instead of a 2-D line
    segment", then Banach-Tarski re-wrote that in algebra instead of
    geometry, while just saying Vitalie's was "non-measurable".



    So, these are the sorts of things, that happen in the infinite,
    the emergence, where the usual measure theory where the reals have
    measure 1 and the rationals have measure 0, can't say, while yet
    the accounts of Vitali's and Hausdorff's and since Zeno's, do say.


    "re-Vitali-ize measure theory", sometimes these days
    called "quasi-invariant measure theory".


    Otherwise physics these days has a well-known "crisis"
    called "the measure problem", which is at least three
    kinds of problems.



    It's like the one where you're on a ski-trip with pseudo-Einstein,
    and you get to the top of the mountain, and survey the course.
    "How are we getting down, pseudo-Einstein?" "Gravity." "Which
    way are we going?" "Straight down."

    Then there's the one where pseudo-Einstein's playing marbles and dice.
    He puts a marble up to his eye, and says "I see a die", it's a "cube-wall".

    Then he notices the On High rolls a die, and it never stops rolling.

    Pseudo-Einstein rounds dice.



    How much is this 2i in this infinite series, pseudo-Einstein?
    Oh, it's "double infinity".




    I have a very good opinion of pseudo-Einstein.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Sat Nov 14 09:20:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/30/2026 06:31 PM, Ross Finlayson wrote:
    On 10/30/2026 02:14 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 09:44 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    amirjf wrote:

    Which makes more sense: a finite or infinite universe?

    Cheers


    'In the beginning,.."

    "In"

    in
    /in/
    preposition

    expressing the situation of something that is or appears to be
    enclosed or surrounded by something else.


    Beginning


    to start


    infinite has no beginning or end.


    So, most likely your universe is finite.






    Eternity since forever.

    A few hundreds years ago, Earth was 6,000 years old.

    By a hundred years ago, the dinosaurs lived millions
    of years ago.

    In the 1960's, the Universe was 3 billion years old.
    In the '80's, it was 6-10.
    By the Y2K, it was more than 13.6 billion years old,
    and it got 200 million years older every year.
    Then, JWST at least doubled that.

    At this rate, it will be arbitrarily old, soon enough.

    Also "particles" get an order of magnitude smaller
    every few years, with "NIST PDG CODATA" and
    "running constants".

    So, according to science, its age/size is going to infinity,
    and its grain is going to smooth.

    Most likely you are afraid of infinity and continuity.


    Okay, let's start at 'the beginning'...

    I count 1,2,3,4,5,6------13.6 billion



    Infinity has no beginning.


    How can I start a count???

    Do I start counting before the beginning??


    i'm not good at math...

    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.


    0 + 0, infinity - 0, 0 + 1, infinity - 1, 0 + 2, infinity - 2, ....

    Count toward the middle.


    Shirley you must have heard of Zeno's arguments,
    showing that your finite counting can never achieve
    completion, then Polly you had pre-calculus and learned
    the definition of the inductive limit, after being told
    that the "atoms" of the unit line segment didn't exist,
    the infinitesimals, though calculus was called infinitesimal
    analysis for hundreds of years.


    Then, when induction _fails_, and only deduction _suffices_,
    then it's related to particular templates of geometric examples
    about the geometric series here or Zeno's arrow, or otherwise
    the geometric series, when deduction _completes_ then that's
    a "super-classical" reasoning, that anybody has, who ever figured
    out that finite arguments may _fail_ in the infinite, and that
    the _infinite_ for the _continuous_ lives in the numbers,
    and the geometry, and the physics.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2