• IsraelAs New - and Terrifying - Security Doctrine

    From NefeshBarYochai@void@invalid.noy to soc.culture.israel,can.politics,nz.politics,alt.atheism,sci.math on Thu Oct 22 10:09:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    In a stunning piece published by the head of one of IsraelAs most
    prominent think tanks, Maj. Gen. Tamir Hayman describes the reality of
    IsraelAs new security doctrine:

    A few crucial principles he describes:

    1. The United States is a odeclining powero and, given its ongoing
    social and political shifts, will soon abandon Israel in any event.
    This is compelling Israel to move toward greater self-reliance in
    order to avoid oexcessive dependenceo on the US since it oexposes
    Israel to the influence of a progressive American value system that is incompatible with IsraelAs Jewish character.o

    Then he concludes: oSevering ties with the United States is therefore
    not only inevitable, but essential to IsraelAs independence and the
    resilience of its Jewish national identity.o

    2. Primacy of Jewish Identity over Democracy: The stateAs Jewish
    identity takes precedence over its democratic system of government.

    3. Peace as a Means Rather Than an End: oA meaningful peace agreement
    is unattainable in the Middle East, as peace agreements are merely
    technical and temporary arrangements requiring constant reassessment.
    According to this view, peace is not an intrinsic value that generates security, but a means of achieving other policy objectives.o

    4. oRejection of the Independent Existence of Arab States: The
    underlying premise is that most Arab states are not genuine
    nation-states, but collections of tribes and ethnic groups lacking a
    shared history and a foundational national vision. Consequently,
    undermining their stability is viewed as a natural process, one that
    Israel can manage more effectively than it can contend with strong nation-states, and one that it should even encourage.o

    5. oWar as a Foundational State: War is essential to national security
    and cannot be replaced by a state of peace, which, as noted, is merely
    a means rather than an end.... War is necessary, and preventive war is preferable because it secures a significant achievement at the
    outset.o

    6. oAbsolute Priority for Initiative and Offense over Defense:
    Preemptive, surprise strikes are viewed as the only way to achieve
    victory, giving offense precedence over defense.o

    And thereAs more.

    Important to note that Hayman does not advocate for this. Rather, he
    contends that this already is the new security doctrine of Israel.

    He is describing reality as he sees it. And that reality simply is not compatible with a US or Western alliance with Israel - unless the West transforms into a similar entity that treats war as a permanent and
    desirable state of being.

    Read the full piece here:

    https://www.inss.org.il/publication/new-concept/


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Dawn Flood@Dawn.Belle.Flood@gmail.com to soc.culture.israel,can.politics,nz.politics,alt.atheism,sci.math on Thu Oct 22 19:44:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/22/2026 9:09 AM, NefeshBarYochai wrote:
    In a stunning piece published by the head of one of IsraelrCOs most
    prominent think tanks, Maj. Gen. Tamir Hayman describes the reality of IsraelrCOs new security doctrine:

    A few crucial principles he describes:

    1. The United States is a rCLdeclining powerrCY and, given its ongoing
    social and political shifts, will soon abandon Israel in any event.
    This is compelling Israel to move toward greater self-reliance in
    order to avoid rCLexcessive dependencerCY on the US since it rCLexposes Israel to the influence of a progressive American value system that is incompatible with IsraelrCOs Jewish character.rCY

    Then he concludes: rCLSevering ties with the United States is therefore
    not only inevitable, but essential to IsraelrCOs independence and the resilience of its Jewish national identity.rCY

    2. Primacy of Jewish Identity over Democracy: The staterCOs Jewish
    identity takes precedence over its democratic system of government.

    3. Peace as a Means Rather Than an End: rCLA meaningful peace agreement
    is unattainable in the Middle East, as peace agreements are merely
    technical and temporary arrangements requiring constant reassessment. According to this view, peace is not an intrinsic value that generates security, but a means of achieving other policy objectives.rCY

    4. rCLRejection of the Independent Existence of Arab States: The
    underlying premise is that most Arab states are not genuine
    nation-states, but collections of tribes and ethnic groups lacking a
    shared history and a foundational national vision. Consequently,
    undermining their stability is viewed as a natural process, one that
    Israel can manage more effectively than it can contend with strong nation-states, and one that it should even encourage.rCY

    5. rCLWar as a Foundational State: War is essential to national security
    and cannot be replaced by a state of peace, which, as noted, is merely
    a means rather than an end.... War is necessary, and preventive war is preferable because it secures a significant achievement at the
    outset.rCY

    6. rCLAbsolute Priority for Initiative and Offense over Defense:
    Preemptive, surprise strikes are viewed as the only way to achieve
    victory, giving offense precedence over defense.rCY

    And thererCOs more.

    Important to note that Hayman does not advocate for this. Rather, he
    contends that this already is the new security doctrine of Israel.

    He is describing reality as he sees it. And that reality simply is not compatible with a US or Western alliance with Israel - unless the West transforms into a similar entity that treats war as a permanent and
    desirable state of being.

    Read the full piece here:

    https://www.inss.org.il/publication/new-concept/

    Remember Dr. Carl Sagan's Cosmos? In the last chapter, Dr. Sagan talks
    about the likelihood of WW III. (Answer: sometime in the next 1,000
    years.)

    Dawn
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mitchell Holman@noemail@aol.com to soc.culture.israel,can.politics,nz.politics,alt.atheism,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 02:23:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Dawn Flood <Dawn.Belle.Flood@gmail.com> wrote in news:11bealn$1bosl$1@dont- email.me:



    Remember Dr. Carl Sagan's Cosmos? In the last chapter, Dr. Sagan talks about the likelihood of WW III. (Answer: sometime in the next 1,000 years.)

    Dawn



    The Cosmos companion book is a marvel,
    it should be required reading in high schools.



    "Ten thousand years ago, there were no dairy
    cows, no ferret hounds, no large ears of corn.
    When we domesticated the ancestors of those
    plants and animals, we controlled their
    breeding. We made sure that certain properties,
    considered by us to be desireable, were
    preferentially reproduced. The enormous
    distended udders of dairy cattle are the
    result of human interest in milk and cheese.
    Our corn has been bred for ten thousand
    generations to more tasty and nutritious than
    its scrawny natural ancestor; indeed, it is so
    changed that it cannot even reproduce without
    human intervention. If artificial selection
    can make such major changes in so short a
    period of time, what can natural selection,
    working over billions of years, be capable of?
    The answer is all the beauty and diversity of
    the biological world.

    Evolution is fact, not theory."

    Carl Sagan, Cosmos, p 27




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Lawrence =?iso-8859-13?q?D=FFOliveiro?=@ldo@nz.invalid to can.politics,nz.politics,alt.atheism,sci.math on Sat Oct 24 05:00:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Sat, 24 Oct 2026 02:23:48 +0000, Mitchell Holman wrote:

    The Cosmos companion book is a marvel, it should be required reading
    in high schools.

    "Ten thousand years ago, there were no dairy cows, no ferret hounds,
    no large ears of corn. When we domesticated the ancestors of those
    plants and animals, we controlled their breeding. We made sure that
    certain properties, considered by us to be desireable, were
    preferentially reproduced. The enormous distended udders of dairy
    cattle are the result of human interest in milk and cheese. Our corn
    has been bred for ten thousand generations to more tasty and
    nutritious than its scrawny natural ancestor; indeed, it is so
    changed that it cannot even reproduce without human intervention. If artificial selection can make such major changes in so short a
    period of time, what can natural selection, working over billions of
    years, be capable of? The answer is all the beauty and diversity of
    the biological world.

    Evolution is fact, not theory."

    Carl Sagan, Cosmos, p 27

    Some people conflate (whether accidentally or deliberately) the
    *facts* of evolution with the various *theories* about *why* evolution
    takes place.

    The *facts* of evolution are these:

    * The gene-replication process is far from perfect. Mutations happen,
    and can get passed on to offspring (if they survive).
    * Some mutations are more beneficial than others.
    * The environment keeps changing (climate, geography, food sources,
    diseases, predation), so characteristics which are more suited to
    some earlier situation might be less suited to a later one.

    Put all these three facts together, and the reality of evolution is inescapable: species come and go over time; many from earlier eras
    disappear in later ones, and new ones appear that were not present
    before. That happens; itrCOs real. J.B.S. Haldane, asked what it would
    take to falsify the scientific acceptance of evolution, replied
    succinctly with an example: rabbit fossils in pre-Cambrian strata.
    There was no way evolution could explain such evidence.

    But as to the details of *why* it occurs -- thatrCOs another issue.
    Natural selection? Sexual selection? Kin selection? rCLSelfish generCY? Sometimes these explanations sound just like rCLjust-sorCY stories. For example: rCLSurvival of the fittestrCY -- fittest for what? Why, to
    survive, of course!
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2