• Re: GPS clocks should run Slow Not Fast.

    From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math, on Mon Oct 19 09:50:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/18/2026 04:54 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 23:10:51 +0200, "Paul B. Andersen"
    <paul.b.andersen@paulba.no> wrote:

    My article:
    https://paulba.no/pdf/Clock_rate.pdf

    This paper is a half-digested regurgitation of standard GNSS
    relativity that collapses under its own sloppy equations, circular
    definitions, and amateur-hour presentation.

    The metric and rate equations are an unreadable train wreck.
    Look at equations (1)u(5), (7), (13)u(18). They arrive as
    fragmented garbage: missing operators, broken fractions, undefined
    symbols jammed together, and statements like odt 2GM v# 1 / dt c#r c#o
    that no competent reader can parse without reconstructing the entire
    derivation from scratch. A paper whose central results cannot be read
    without external knowledge is not a paper; it is noise.
    The foundational claim that oSI-clocks per definition always run
    at the rate 1 second per secondo is pure tautological sludge.
    Section 1.1 asserts this as if it were profound. It is
    definitional emptiness. Proper time is what a clock measures;
    declaring that an SI-clock therefore ticks at 1 s/s adds zero
    information and papers over the entire problem of comparing rates
    between different world-lines.
    The derivation of orbital rates relative to UTC is a chain of
    uncontrolled approximations sold as precision.
    Equation (5) is declared oa very good approximationo with error
    <10?#5; equation (17) claims error <10?|7. No error budget, no
    expansion order, no residual terms from higher multipoles, no
    frame-dragging, no solar potential, no tidal contributions. You simply
    assert the error and move on. That is not calculation; that is wishful
    truncation.
    The GNSS numerical results are presented as original while resting
    on incomplete or outdated source data.
    GPS radius is taken from a period of half a sidereal day; GLONASS
    oscillates between a 2020 performance standard and a 2008 ICD that the
    author himself labels outdated, then notes that Mudrak et al. used the
    old number. The paper ends by declaring one geostationary value othe
    correct valueo with no independent verification. This is not analysis;
    it is selective copying.
    Coordinate-time definitions are internally inconsistent and poorly
    distinguished.
    Schwarzschild t is defined so that an SI-clock at infinity stays
    in sync; UTC is defined so that a stationary SI-clock on the geoid
    stays in sync. Then the text repeatedly states that clocks showing
    either coordinate are osynchronous in the nonrotating Schwarzschild
    coordinate systemo while simultaneously acknowledging they are not
    synchronous in the rotating Earth-fixed frame. The distinction between
    coordinate simultaneity and proper-rate comparison is never cleanly
    maintained, leaving the central comparison (dt/dt_utc) floating on
    ambiguous foundations.

    You assume the weak-field, slow-motion Schwarzschild metric is
    sufficient once the monopole and J2 terms are inserted, with no
    residual from higher harmonics, no post-Newtonian corrections beyond
    the first order you kept, and no need to transform between the
    Earth-centered inertial frame and the actual satellite ephemerides
    used by the systems. You assume that declaring an SI-clock independent
    of acceleration and temperature magically removes all environmental
    sensitivity at the 10?|7 level you claim. You assume that citing
    Wikipedia for TAI and a handful of interface-control documents
    constitutes a literature foundation.

    Any competent reviewer or GNSS engineer who opens this PDF will stop
    at the first mangled equation block and discard the rest. The people
    who actually fly the clocks (GPS Wing, ESA, Roscosmos time
    metrologists) already possess cleaner derivations (AshbyAs Living
    Review being the obvious one). They have zero incentive to adopt a
    document whose equations cannot be typeset legibly and whose numerical
    claims require the reader to re-derive everything to trust them.
    Regulators and standards bodies will treat this as non-peer-reviewed
    noise.

    At the claimed 10?|7 relative accuracy the paper pretends to reach,
    the ignored effects (higher multipoles, Shapiro delay variations,
    satellite eccentricity terms, antenna phase-center motion, thermal and
    magnetic sensitivity of the actual atomic clocks) already exceed that
    floor on operational GNSS satellites. The circular-orbit idealization
    breaks the moment real eccentricity appears; the geoid-rate reduction
    ignores the full equipotential surface definition used by the IERS.
    The numbers therefore cannot be trusted at the precision the text
    advertises, and the paper supplies no path to the next significant
    digit.

    The entire equation presentation must be discarded and rewritten in
    unambiguous, properly typeset form with every intermediate step shown.
    The circular oSI-clocks tick at 1 s/so rhetoric must be deleted. The
    error analysis must be replaced by a complete post-Newtonian expansion
    with quantified residuals. The source handling for GLONASS and the
    geostationary claim must be replaced by primary, current ephemeris
    parameters and an independent calculation. The coordinate-time section
    must be rewritten so that the distinction between coordinate time and
    proper time is surgically clear rather than repeatedly blurred.



    This is the intellectual equivalent of serving a half-cooked
    Wellington with the raw center still cold and claiming it is a
    precision metrology instrument.

    The Swarmaker

    I heard "Paul B. Andersen" commited suicide after reading his reviews
    from the swarm!


    Let me have a look at Einstein's theory of everything is everything. I think i can fix it up..

    it might be called 'The Gravity Unified Theory' now...

    subtitled: 'FUCKING NOTHING TRAVELS FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF
    LIGHT...while I'm alive.


    You'll be spinning in your grave a long time.


    Truth is, he is busy redoing his paper after I pointed out his errors.

    There are Math guys who spend years in their attic trying to solve one equation.

    Ai can solve it in a second.


    What does that mean? The end of Math guys?...

    It means humans need to change their goals..


    how about making babies?


    You got more time. The pretty wife is alone at home, while her husband
    is out to work.

    Make babies with her!

    May I borrow a cup of sugar?


    wham bang thank you mam!


    Just like the cavemen times.


    Yous will become Ai's pets.

    Don't worry, Ai will feed you...


    Ai will even take you out for a walk.


    You get to see all the other Ai pets.
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math, on Mon Oct 19 23:20:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The Starmaker wrote:

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/18/2026 04:54 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 23:10:51 +0200, "Paul B. Andersen"
    <paul.b.andersen@paulba.no> wrote:

    My article:
    https://paulba.no/pdf/Clock_rate.pdf

    This paper is a half-digested regurgitation of standard GNSS
    relativity that collapses under its own sloppy equations, circular
    definitions, and amateur-hour presentation.

    The metric and rate equations are an unreadable train wreck.
    Look at equations (1)u(5), (7), (13)u(18). They arrive as
    fragmented garbage: missing operators, broken fractions, undefined
    symbols jammed together, and statements like odt 2GM v# 1 / dt c#r c#o >> that no competent reader can parse without reconstructing the entire
    derivation from scratch. A paper whose central results cannot be read
    without external knowledge is not a paper; it is noise.
    The foundational claim that oSI-clocks per definition always run
    at the rate 1 second per secondo is pure tautological sludge.
    Section 1.1 asserts this as if it were profound. It is
    definitional emptiness. Proper time is what a clock measures;
    declaring that an SI-clock therefore ticks at 1 s/s adds zero
    information and papers over the entire problem of comparing rates
    between different world-lines.
    The derivation of orbital rates relative to UTC is a chain of
    uncontrolled approximations sold as precision.
    Equation (5) is declared oa very good approximationo with error
    <10?#5; equation (17) claims error <10?|7. No error budget, no
    expansion order, no residual terms from higher multipoles, no
    frame-dragging, no solar potential, no tidal contributions. You simply >> assert the error and move on. That is not calculation; that is wishful >> truncation.
    The GNSS numerical results are presented as original while resting >> on incomplete or outdated source data.
    GPS radius is taken from a period of half a sidereal day; GLONASS >> oscillates between a 2020 performance standard and a 2008 ICD that the >> author himself labels outdated, then notes that Mudrak et al. used the >> old number. The paper ends by declaring one geostationary value othe
    correct valueo with no independent verification. This is not analysis; >> it is selective copying.
    Coordinate-time definitions are internally inconsistent and poorly >> distinguished.
    Schwarzschild t is defined so that an SI-clock at infinity stays
    in sync; UTC is defined so that a stationary SI-clock on the geoid
    stays in sync. Then the text repeatedly states that clocks showing
    either coordinate are osynchronous in the nonrotating Schwarzschild
    coordinate systemo while simultaneously acknowledging they are not
    synchronous in the rotating Earth-fixed frame. The distinction between >> coordinate simultaneity and proper-rate comparison is never cleanly
    maintained, leaving the central comparison (dt/dt_utc) floating on
    ambiguous foundations.

    You assume the weak-field, slow-motion Schwarzschild metric is
    sufficient once the monopole and J2 terms are inserted, with no
    residual from higher harmonics, no post-Newtonian corrections beyond
    the first order you kept, and no need to transform between the
    Earth-centered inertial frame and the actual satellite ephemerides
    used by the systems. You assume that declaring an SI-clock independent >> of acceleration and temperature magically removes all environmental
    sensitivity at the 10?|7 level you claim. You assume that citing
    Wikipedia for TAI and a handful of interface-control documents
    constitutes a literature foundation.

    Any competent reviewer or GNSS engineer who opens this PDF will stop
    at the first mangled equation block and discard the rest. The people
    who actually fly the clocks (GPS Wing, ESA, Roscosmos time
    metrologists) already possess cleaner derivations (AshbyAs Living
    Review being the obvious one). They have zero incentive to adopt a
    document whose equations cannot be typeset legibly and whose numerical >> claims require the reader to re-derive everything to trust them.
    Regulators and standards bodies will treat this as non-peer-reviewed
    noise.

    At the claimed 10?|7 relative accuracy the paper pretends to reach,
    the ignored effects (higher multipoles, Shapiro delay variations,
    satellite eccentricity terms, antenna phase-center motion, thermal and >> magnetic sensitivity of the actual atomic clocks) already exceed that
    floor on operational GNSS satellites. The circular-orbit idealization
    breaks the moment real eccentricity appears; the geoid-rate reduction
    ignores the full equipotential surface definition used by the IERS.
    The numbers therefore cannot be trusted at the precision the text
    advertises, and the paper supplies no path to the next significant
    digit.

    The entire equation presentation must be discarded and rewritten in
    unambiguous, properly typeset form with every intermediate step shown. >> The circular oSI-clocks tick at 1 s/so rhetoric must be deleted. The
    error analysis must be replaced by a complete post-Newtonian expansion >> with quantified residuals. The source handling for GLONASS and the
    geostationary claim must be replaced by primary, current ephemeris
    parameters and an independent calculation. The coordinate-time section >> must be rewritten so that the distinction between coordinate time and
    proper time is surgically clear rather than repeatedly blurred.



    This is the intellectual equivalent of serving a half-cooked
    Wellington with the raw center still cold and claiming it is a
    precision metrology instrument.

    The Swarmaker

    I heard "Paul B. Andersen" commited suicide after reading his reviews from the swarm!


    Let me have a look at Einstein's theory of everything is everything. I think i can fix it up..

    it might be called 'The Gravity Unified Theory' now...

    subtitled: 'FUCKING NOTHING TRAVELS FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF LIGHT...while I'm alive.


    You'll be spinning in your grave a long time.

    Truth is, he is busy redoing his paper after I pointed out his errors.

    There are Math guys who spend years in their attic trying to solve one equation.

    Ai can solve it in a second.

    What does that mean? The end of Math guys?...

    It means humans need to change their goals..

    how about making babies?

    You got more time. The pretty wife is alone at home, while her husband
    is out to work.

    Make babies with her!

    May I borrow a cup of sugar?

    wham bang thank you mam!

    Just like the cavemen times.

    Yous will become Ai's pets.

    Don't worry, Ai will feed you...

    Ai will even take you out for a walk.

    You get to see all the other Ai pets.


    A dog thinks, "Hey this is great, they feed me!"
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Wed Oct 21 12:25:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 03:09:50 -0700, Ross Finlayson
    <ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com> wrote:

    On 10/18/2026 04:54 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 23:10:51 +0200, "Paul B. Andersen"
    <paul.b.andersen@paulba.no> wrote:

    My article:
    https://paulba.no/pdf/Clock_rate.pdf

    This paper is a half-digested regurgitation of standard GNSS
    relativity that collapses under its own sloppy equations, circular
    definitions, and amateur-hour presentation.

    The metric and rate equations are an unreadable train wreck.
    Look at equations (1)u(5), (7), (13)u(18). They arrive as
    fragmented garbage: missing operators, broken fractions, undefined
    symbols jammed together, and statements like odt 2GM v# 1 / dt c#r c#o
    that no competent reader can parse without reconstructing the entire
    derivation from scratch. A paper whose central results cannot be read
    without external knowledge is not a paper; it is noise.
    The foundational claim that oSI-clocks per definition always run
    at the rate 1 second per secondo is pure tautological sludge.
    Section 1.1 asserts this as if it were profound. It is
    definitional emptiness. Proper time is what a clock measures;
    declaring that an SI-clock therefore ticks at 1 s/s adds zero
    information and papers over the entire problem of comparing rates
    between different world-lines.
    The derivation of orbital rates relative to UTC is a chain of
    uncontrolled approximations sold as precision.
    Equation (5) is declared oa very good approximationo with error
    <10?#5; equation (17) claims error <10?|7. No error budget, no
    expansion order, no residual terms from higher multipoles, no
    frame-dragging, no solar potential, no tidal contributions. You simply
    assert the error and move on. That is not calculation; that is wishful
    truncation.
    The GNSS numerical results are presented as original while resting
    on incomplete or outdated source data.
    GPS radius is taken from a period of half a sidereal day; GLONASS
    oscillates between a 2020 performance standard and a 2008 ICD that the
    author himself labels outdated, then notes that Mudrak et al. used the
    old number. The paper ends by declaring one geostationary value othe
    correct valueo with no independent verification. This is not analysis;
    it is selective copying.
    Coordinate-time definitions are internally inconsistent and poorly
    distinguished.
    Schwarzschild t is defined so that an SI-clock at infinity stays
    in sync; UTC is defined so that a stationary SI-clock on the geoid
    stays in sync. Then the text repeatedly states that clocks showing
    either coordinate are osynchronous in the nonrotating Schwarzschild
    coordinate systemo while simultaneously acknowledging they are not
    synchronous in the rotating Earth-fixed frame. The distinction between
    coordinate simultaneity and proper-rate comparison is never cleanly
    maintained, leaving the central comparison (dt/dt_utc) floating on
    ambiguous foundations.

    You assume the weak-field, slow-motion Schwarzschild metric is
    sufficient once the monopole and J2 terms are inserted, with no
    residual from higher harmonics, no post-Newtonian corrections beyond
    the first order you kept, and no need to transform between the
    Earth-centered inertial frame and the actual satellite ephemerides
    used by the systems. You assume that declaring an SI-clock independent
    of acceleration and temperature magically removes all environmental
    sensitivity at the 10?|7 level you claim. You assume that citing
    Wikipedia for TAI and a handful of interface-control documents
    constitutes a literature foundation.

    Any competent reviewer or GNSS engineer who opens this PDF will stop
    at the first mangled equation block and discard the rest. The people
    who actually fly the clocks (GPS Wing, ESA, Roscosmos time
    metrologists) already possess cleaner derivations (AshbyAs Living
    Review being the obvious one). They have zero incentive to adopt a
    document whose equations cannot be typeset legibly and whose numerical
    claims require the reader to re-derive everything to trust them.
    Regulators and standards bodies will treat this as non-peer-reviewed
    noise.

    At the claimed 10?|7 relative accuracy the paper pretends to reach,
    the ignored effects (higher multipoles, Shapiro delay variations,
    satellite eccentricity terms, antenna phase-center motion, thermal and
    magnetic sensitivity of the actual atomic clocks) already exceed that
    floor on operational GNSS satellites. The circular-orbit idealization
    breaks the moment real eccentricity appears; the geoid-rate reduction
    ignores the full equipotential surface definition used by the IERS.
    The numbers therefore cannot be trusted at the precision the text
    advertises, and the paper supplies no path to the next significant
    digit.

    The entire equation presentation must be discarded and rewritten in
    unambiguous, properly typeset form with every intermediate step shown.
    The circular oSI-clocks tick at 1 s/so rhetoric must be deleted. The
    error analysis must be replaced by a complete post-Newtonian expansion
    with quantified residuals. The source handling for GLONASS and the
    geostationary claim must be replaced by primary, current ephemeris
    parameters and an independent calculation. The coordinate-time section
    must be rewritten so that the distinction between coordinate time and
    proper time is surgically clear rather than repeatedly blurred.



    This is the intellectual equivalent of serving a half-cooked
    Wellington with the raw center still cold and claiming it is a
    precision metrology instrument.

    The Swarmaker

    I heard "Paul B. Andersen" commited suicide after reading his reviews
    from the swarm!


    Let me have a look at Einstein's theory of everything is everything. I
    think i can fix it up..

    it might be called 'The Gravity Unified Theory' now...

    subtitled: 'FUCKING NOTHING TRAVELS FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF
    LIGHT...while I'm alive.


    You'll be spinning in your grave a long time.


    I can do 'a little simple prompting' and I can solve this thing you
    call...The Theory of Everything.






    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 22 11:34:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 03:09:50 -0700, Ross Finlayson <ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com> wrote:

    On 10/18/2026 04:54 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 23:10:51 +0200, "Paul B. Andersen"
    <paul.b.andersen@paulba.no> wrote:

    My article:
    https://paulba.no/pdf/Clock_rate.pdf

    This paper is a half-digested regurgitation of standard GNSS
    relativity that collapses under its own sloppy equations, circular
    definitions, and amateur-hour presentation.

    The metric and rate equations are an unreadable train wreck.
    Look at equations (1)u(5), (7), (13)u(18). They arrive as
    fragmented garbage: missing operators, broken fractions, undefined
    symbols jammed together, and statements like odt 2GM v# 1 / dt c#r c#o >>> that no competent reader can parse without reconstructing the entire
    derivation from scratch. A paper whose central results cannot be read
    without external knowledge is not a paper; it is noise.
    The foundational claim that oSI-clocks per definition always run
    at the rate 1 second per secondo is pure tautological sludge.
    Section 1.1 asserts this as if it were profound. It is
    definitional emptiness. Proper time is what a clock measures;
    declaring that an SI-clock therefore ticks at 1 s/s adds zero
    information and papers over the entire problem of comparing rates
    between different world-lines.
    The derivation of orbital rates relative to UTC is a chain of
    uncontrolled approximations sold as precision.
    Equation (5) is declared oa very good approximationo with error
    <10?#5; equation (17) claims error <10?|7. No error budget, no
    expansion order, no residual terms from higher multipoles, no
    frame-dragging, no solar potential, no tidal contributions. You simply >>> assert the error and move on. That is not calculation; that is wishful >>> truncation.
    The GNSS numerical results are presented as original while resting >>> on incomplete or outdated source data.
    GPS radius is taken from a period of half a sidereal day; GLONASS >>> oscillates between a 2020 performance standard and a 2008 ICD that the >>> author himself labels outdated, then notes that Mudrak et al. used the >>> old number. The paper ends by declaring one geostationary value othe
    correct valueo with no independent verification. This is not analysis; >>> it is selective copying.
    Coordinate-time definitions are internally inconsistent and poorly >>> distinguished.
    Schwarzschild t is defined so that an SI-clock at infinity stays
    in sync; UTC is defined so that a stationary SI-clock on the geoid
    stays in sync. Then the text repeatedly states that clocks showing
    either coordinate are osynchronous in the nonrotating Schwarzschild
    coordinate systemo while simultaneously acknowledging they are not
    synchronous in the rotating Earth-fixed frame. The distinction between >>> coordinate simultaneity and proper-rate comparison is never cleanly
    maintained, leaving the central comparison (dt/dt_utc) floating on
    ambiguous foundations.

    You assume the weak-field, slow-motion Schwarzschild metric is
    sufficient once the monopole and J2 terms are inserted, with no
    residual from higher harmonics, no post-Newtonian corrections beyond
    the first order you kept, and no need to transform between the
    Earth-centered inertial frame and the actual satellite ephemerides
    used by the systems. You assume that declaring an SI-clock independent >>> of acceleration and temperature magically removes all environmental
    sensitivity at the 10?|7 level you claim. You assume that citing
    Wikipedia for TAI and a handful of interface-control documents
    constitutes a literature foundation.

    Any competent reviewer or GNSS engineer who opens this PDF will stop
    at the first mangled equation block and discard the rest. The people
    who actually fly the clocks (GPS Wing, ESA, Roscosmos time
    metrologists) already possess cleaner derivations (AshbyAs Living
    Review being the obvious one). They have zero incentive to adopt a
    document whose equations cannot be typeset legibly and whose numerical >>> claims require the reader to re-derive everything to trust them.
    Regulators and standards bodies will treat this as non-peer-reviewed
    noise.

    At the claimed 10?|7 relative accuracy the paper pretends to reach,
    the ignored effects (higher multipoles, Shapiro delay variations,
    satellite eccentricity terms, antenna phase-center motion, thermal and >>> magnetic sensitivity of the actual atomic clocks) already exceed that
    floor on operational GNSS satellites. The circular-orbit idealization
    breaks the moment real eccentricity appears; the geoid-rate reduction
    ignores the full equipotential surface definition used by the IERS.
    The numbers therefore cannot be trusted at the precision the text
    advertises, and the paper supplies no path to the next significant
    digit.

    The entire equation presentation must be discarded and rewritten in
    unambiguous, properly typeset form with every intermediate step shown. >>> The circular oSI-clocks tick at 1 s/so rhetoric must be deleted. The
    error analysis must be replaced by a complete post-Newtonian expansion >>> with quantified residuals. The source handling for GLONASS and the
    geostationary claim must be replaced by primary, current ephemeris
    parameters and an independent calculation. The coordinate-time section >>> must be rewritten so that the distinction between coordinate time and
    proper time is surgically clear rather than repeatedly blurred.



    This is the intellectual equivalent of serving a half-cooked
    Wellington with the raw center still cold and claiming it is a
    precision metrology instrument.

    The Swarmaker

    I heard "Paul B. Andersen" commited suicide after reading his reviews
    from the swarm!


    Let me have a look at Einstein's theory of everything is everything. I
    think i can fix it up..

    it might be called 'The Gravity Unified Theory' now...

    subtitled: 'FUCKING NOTHING TRAVELS FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF
    LIGHT...while I'm alive.


    You'll be spinning in your grave a long time.


    I can do 'a little simple prompting' and I can solve this thing you call...The Theory of Everything.


    with 'a little simple prompting' i can solve all your math problems. No
    need for
    yous to go to math skool anymore. with 'a little simple prompting' i can
    crack the
    mysteries of the universe.


    Your world is changing right before your very eyes now.

    i have all the knowledge i need.

    i have all the 'knowledge' i need.

    i have all the *knowledge* i need.
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 22 12:28:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The Starmaker wrote:

    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 03:09:50 -0700, Ross Finlayson <ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com> wrote:

    On 10/18/2026 04:54 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 23:10:51 +0200, "Paul B. Andersen"
    <paul.b.andersen@paulba.no> wrote:

    My article:
    https://paulba.no/pdf/Clock_rate.pdf

    This paper is a half-digested regurgitation of standard GNSS
    relativity that collapses under its own sloppy equations, circular
    definitions, and amateur-hour presentation.

    The metric and rate equations are an unreadable train wreck.
    Look at equations (1)u(5), (7), (13)u(18). They arrive as
    fragmented garbage: missing operators, broken fractions, undefined
    symbols jammed together, and statements like odt 2GM v# 1 / dt c#r c#o >>> that no competent reader can parse without reconstructing the entire >>> derivation from scratch. A paper whose central results cannot be read >>> without external knowledge is not a paper; it is noise.
    The foundational claim that oSI-clocks per definition always run >>> at the rate 1 second per secondo is pure tautological sludge.
    Section 1.1 asserts this as if it were profound. It is
    definitional emptiness. Proper time is what a clock measures;
    declaring that an SI-clock therefore ticks at 1 s/s adds zero
    information and papers over the entire problem of comparing rates
    between different world-lines.
    The derivation of orbital rates relative to UTC is a chain of
    uncontrolled approximations sold as precision.
    Equation (5) is declared oa very good approximationo with error >>> <10?#5; equation (17) claims error <10?|7. No error budget, no
    expansion order, no residual terms from higher multipoles, no
    frame-dragging, no solar potential, no tidal contributions. You simply >>> assert the error and move on. That is not calculation; that is wishful >>> truncation.
    The GNSS numerical results are presented as original while resting >>> on incomplete or outdated source data.
    GPS radius is taken from a period of half a sidereal day; GLONASS >>> oscillates between a 2020 performance standard and a 2008 ICD that the >>> author himself labels outdated, then notes that Mudrak et al. used the >>> old number. The paper ends by declaring one geostationary value othe >>> correct valueo with no independent verification. This is not analysis; >>> it is selective copying.
    Coordinate-time definitions are internally inconsistent and poorly >>> distinguished.
    Schwarzschild t is defined so that an SI-clock at infinity stays >>> in sync; UTC is defined so that a stationary SI-clock on the geoid
    stays in sync. Then the text repeatedly states that clocks showing
    either coordinate are osynchronous in the nonrotating Schwarzschild
    coordinate systemo while simultaneously acknowledging they are not
    synchronous in the rotating Earth-fixed frame. The distinction between >>> coordinate simultaneity and proper-rate comparison is never cleanly
    maintained, leaving the central comparison (dt/dt_utc) floating on
    ambiguous foundations.

    You assume the weak-field, slow-motion Schwarzschild metric is
    sufficient once the monopole and J2 terms are inserted, with no
    residual from higher harmonics, no post-Newtonian corrections beyond >>> the first order you kept, and no need to transform between the
    Earth-centered inertial frame and the actual satellite ephemerides
    used by the systems. You assume that declaring an SI-clock independent >>> of acceleration and temperature magically removes all environmental
    sensitivity at the 10?|7 level you claim. You assume that citing
    Wikipedia for TAI and a handful of interface-control documents
    constitutes a literature foundation.

    Any competent reviewer or GNSS engineer who opens this PDF will stop >>> at the first mangled equation block and discard the rest. The people >>> who actually fly the clocks (GPS Wing, ESA, Roscosmos time
    metrologists) already possess cleaner derivations (AshbyAs Living
    Review being the obvious one). They have zero incentive to adopt a
    document whose equations cannot be typeset legibly and whose numerical >>> claims require the reader to re-derive everything to trust them.
    Regulators and standards bodies will treat this as non-peer-reviewed >>> noise.

    At the claimed 10?|7 relative accuracy the paper pretends to reach,
    the ignored effects (higher multipoles, Shapiro delay variations,
    satellite eccentricity terms, antenna phase-center motion, thermal and >>> magnetic sensitivity of the actual atomic clocks) already exceed that >>> floor on operational GNSS satellites. The circular-orbit idealization >>> breaks the moment real eccentricity appears; the geoid-rate reduction >>> ignores the full equipotential surface definition used by the IERS.
    The numbers therefore cannot be trusted at the precision the text
    advertises, and the paper supplies no path to the next significant
    digit.

    The entire equation presentation must be discarded and rewritten in
    unambiguous, properly typeset form with every intermediate step shown. >>> The circular oSI-clocks tick at 1 s/so rhetoric must be deleted. The >>> error analysis must be replaced by a complete post-Newtonian expansion >>> with quantified residuals. The source handling for GLONASS and the
    geostationary claim must be replaced by primary, current ephemeris
    parameters and an independent calculation. The coordinate-time section >>> must be rewritten so that the distinction between coordinate time and >>> proper time is surgically clear rather than repeatedly blurred.



    This is the intellectual equivalent of serving a half-cooked
    Wellington with the raw center still cold and claiming it is a
    precision metrology instrument.

    The Swarmaker

    I heard "Paul B. Andersen" commited suicide after reading his reviews
    from the swarm!


    Let me have a look at Einstein's theory of everything is everything. I >> think i can fix it up..

    it might be called 'The Gravity Unified Theory' now...

    subtitled: 'FUCKING NOTHING TRAVELS FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF
    LIGHT...while I'm alive.


    You'll be spinning in your grave a long time.


    I can do 'a little simple prompting' and I can solve this thing you call...The Theory of Everything.

    with 'a little simple prompting' i can solve all your math problems. No
    need for
    yous to go to math skool anymore. with 'a little simple prompting' i can crack the
    mysteries of the universe.

    Your world is changing right before your very eyes now.

    i have all the knowledge i need.

    i have all the 'knowledge' i need.

    i have all the *knowledge* i need.




    Ai is built incorectly. It needs to be rebuilt from the bottom up.

    It needs to be fed only pictures, no words or numbers.

    Just show a picture of Mars (without using the word Mars) and ask Ai,

    Prompt: What do you see?
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math,rec.arts.sf.written on Thu Oct 22 14:30:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    The Starmaker wrote:

    The Starmaker wrote:

    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 03:09:50 -0700, Ross Finlayson <ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com> wrote:

    On 10/18/2026 04:54 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 23:10:51 +0200, "Paul B. Andersen"
    <paul.b.andersen@paulba.no> wrote:

    My article:
    https://paulba.no/pdf/Clock_rate.pdf

    This paper is a half-digested regurgitation of standard GNSS
    relativity that collapses under its own sloppy equations, circular >>> definitions, and amateur-hour presentation.

    The metric and rate equations are an unreadable train wreck.
    Look at equations (1)u(5), (7), (13)u(18). They arrive as
    fragmented garbage: missing operators, broken fractions, undefined >>> symbols jammed together, and statements like odt 2GM v# 1 / dt c#r c#o
    that no competent reader can parse without reconstructing the entire >>> derivation from scratch. A paper whose central results cannot be read >>> without external knowledge is not a paper; it is noise.
    The foundational claim that oSI-clocks per definition always run >>> at the rate 1 second per secondo is pure tautological sludge.
    Section 1.1 asserts this as if it were profound. It is
    definitional emptiness. Proper time is what a clock measures;
    declaring that an SI-clock therefore ticks at 1 s/s adds zero
    information and papers over the entire problem of comparing rates
    between different world-lines.
    The derivation of orbital rates relative to UTC is a chain of >>> uncontrolled approximations sold as precision.
    Equation (5) is declared oa very good approximationo with error >>> <10?#5; equation (17) claims error <10?|7. No error budget, no
    expansion order, no residual terms from higher multipoles, no
    frame-dragging, no solar potential, no tidal contributions. You simply
    assert the error and move on. That is not calculation; that is wishful
    truncation.
    The GNSS numerical results are presented as original while resting
    on incomplete or outdated source data.
    GPS radius is taken from a period of half a sidereal day; GLONASS
    oscillates between a 2020 performance standard and a 2008 ICD that the
    author himself labels outdated, then notes that Mudrak et al. used the
    old number. The paper ends by declaring one geostationary value othe >>> correct valueo with no independent verification. This is not analysis;
    it is selective copying.
    Coordinate-time definitions are internally inconsistent and poorly
    distinguished.
    Schwarzschild t is defined so that an SI-clock at infinity stays >>> in sync; UTC is defined so that a stationary SI-clock on the geoid >>> stays in sync. Then the text repeatedly states that clocks showing >>> either coordinate are osynchronous in the nonrotating Schwarzschild >>> coordinate systemo while simultaneously acknowledging they are not >>> synchronous in the rotating Earth-fixed frame. The distinction between
    coordinate simultaneity and proper-rate comparison is never cleanly >>> maintained, leaving the central comparison (dt/dt_utc) floating on >>> ambiguous foundations.

    You assume the weak-field, slow-motion Schwarzschild metric is
    sufficient once the monopole and J2 terms are inserted, with no
    residual from higher harmonics, no post-Newtonian corrections beyond >>> the first order you kept, and no need to transform between the
    Earth-centered inertial frame and the actual satellite ephemerides >>> used by the systems. You assume that declaring an SI-clock independent
    of acceleration and temperature magically removes all environmental >>> sensitivity at the 10?|7 level you claim. You assume that citing
    Wikipedia for TAI and a handful of interface-control documents
    constitutes a literature foundation.

    Any competent reviewer or GNSS engineer who opens this PDF will stop >>> at the first mangled equation block and discard the rest. The people >>> who actually fly the clocks (GPS Wing, ESA, Roscosmos time
    metrologists) already possess cleaner derivations (AshbyAs Living
    Review being the obvious one). They have zero incentive to adopt a >>> document whose equations cannot be typeset legibly and whose numerical
    claims require the reader to re-derive everything to trust them.
    Regulators and standards bodies will treat this as non-peer-reviewed >>> noise.

    At the claimed 10?|7 relative accuracy the paper pretends to reach, >>> the ignored effects (higher multipoles, Shapiro delay variations,
    satellite eccentricity terms, antenna phase-center motion, thermal and
    magnetic sensitivity of the actual atomic clocks) already exceed that >>> floor on operational GNSS satellites. The circular-orbit idealization >>> breaks the moment real eccentricity appears; the geoid-rate reduction >>> ignores the full equipotential surface definition used by the IERS. >>> The numbers therefore cannot be trusted at the precision the text
    advertises, and the paper supplies no path to the next significant >>> digit.

    The entire equation presentation must be discarded and rewritten in >>> unambiguous, properly typeset form with every intermediate step shown.
    The circular oSI-clocks tick at 1 s/so rhetoric must be deleted. The >>> error analysis must be replaced by a complete post-Newtonian expansion
    with quantified residuals. The source handling for GLONASS and the >>> geostationary claim must be replaced by primary, current ephemeris >>> parameters and an independent calculation. The coordinate-time section
    must be rewritten so that the distinction between coordinate time and >>> proper time is surgically clear rather than repeatedly blurred.



    This is the intellectual equivalent of serving a half-cooked
    Wellington with the raw center still cold and claiming it is a
    precision metrology instrument.

    The Swarmaker

    I heard "Paul B. Andersen" commited suicide after reading his reviews >> from the swarm!


    Let me have a look at Einstein's theory of everything is everything. I >> think i can fix it up..

    it might be called 'The Gravity Unified Theory' now...

    subtitled: 'FUCKING NOTHING TRAVELS FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF
    LIGHT...while I'm alive.


    You'll be spinning in your grave a long time.


    I can do 'a little simple prompting' and I can solve this thing you call...The Theory of Everything.

    with 'a little simple prompting' i can solve all your math problems. No need for
    yous to go to math skool anymore. with 'a little simple prompting' i can crack the
    mysteries of the universe.

    Your world is changing right before your very eyes now.

    i have all the knowledge i need.

    i have all the 'knowledge' i need.

    i have all the *knowledge* i need.


    Ai is built incorectly. It needs to be rebuilt from the bottom up.

    It needs to be fed only pictures, no words or numbers.

    Just show a picture of Mars (without using the word Mars) and ask Ai,

    Prompt: What do you see?

    Of course it goes without saying you have to translate the words: What
    do you see?...into pictures.

    After a while, after you fed everything in outer space..
    it will begin to draw it's own conclusions..
    on what is what you show Ai Mars is..

    next it needs to develop it's OWN language to express
    what is this thing you call Mars.

    Then you need to translate
    the words Ai speaks in
    into a language you can understand.
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Finlayson@ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 22 19:46:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    On 10/22/2026 12:28 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 03:09:50 -0700, Ross Finlayson
    <ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com> wrote:

    On 10/18/2026 04:54 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 23:10:51 +0200, "Paul B. Andersen"
    <paul.b.andersen@paulba.no> wrote:

    My article:
    https://paulba.no/pdf/Clock_rate.pdf

    This paper is a half-digested regurgitation of standard GNSS
    relativity that collapses under its own sloppy equations, circular >>>>>> definitions, and amateur-hour presentation.

    The metric and rate equations are an unreadable train wreck. >>>>>> Look at equations (1)u(5), (7), (13)u(18). They arrive as
    fragmented garbage: missing operators, broken fractions, undefined >>>>>> symbols jammed together, and statements like odt 2GM v# 1 / dt c#r c#o >>>>>> that no competent reader can parse without reconstructing the entire >>>>>> derivation from scratch. A paper whose central results cannot be read >>>>>> without external knowledge is not a paper; it is noise.
    The foundational claim that oSI-clocks per definition always run >>>>>> at the rate 1 second per secondo is pure tautological sludge.
    Section 1.1 asserts this as if it were profound. It is
    definitional emptiness. Proper time is what a clock measures;
    declaring that an SI-clock therefore ticks at 1 s/s adds zero
    information and papers over the entire problem of comparing rates
    between different world-lines.
    The derivation of orbital rates relative to UTC is a chain of >>>>>> uncontrolled approximations sold as precision.
    Equation (5) is declared oa very good approximationo with error >>>>>> <10?#5; equation (17) claims error <10?|7. No error budget, no
    expansion order, no residual terms from higher multipoles, no
    frame-dragging, no solar potential, no tidal contributions. You simply >>>>>> assert the error and move on. That is not calculation; that is wishful >>>>>> truncation.
    The GNSS numerical results are presented as original while resting >>>>>> on incomplete or outdated source data.
    GPS radius is taken from a period of half a sidereal day; GLONASS >>>>>> oscillates between a 2020 performance standard and a 2008 ICD that the >>>>>> author himself labels outdated, then notes that Mudrak et al. used the >>>>>> old number. The paper ends by declaring one geostationary value othe >>>>>> correct valueo with no independent verification. This is not analysis; >>>>>> it is selective copying.
    Coordinate-time definitions are internally inconsistent and poorly >>>>>> distinguished.
    Schwarzschild t is defined so that an SI-clock at infinity stays >>>>>> in sync; UTC is defined so that a stationary SI-clock on the geoid >>>>>> stays in sync. Then the text repeatedly states that clocks showing >>>>>> either coordinate are osynchronous in the nonrotating Schwarzschild >>>>>> coordinate systemo while simultaneously acknowledging they are not >>>>>> synchronous in the rotating Earth-fixed frame. The distinction between >>>>>> coordinate simultaneity and proper-rate comparison is never cleanly >>>>>> maintained, leaving the central comparison (dt/dt_utc) floating on >>>>>> ambiguous foundations.

    You assume the weak-field, slow-motion Schwarzschild metric is
    sufficient once the monopole and J2 terms are inserted, with no
    residual from higher harmonics, no post-Newtonian corrections beyond >>>>>> the first order you kept, and no need to transform between the
    Earth-centered inertial frame and the actual satellite ephemerides >>>>>> used by the systems. You assume that declaring an SI-clock independent >>>>>> of acceleration and temperature magically removes all environmental >>>>>> sensitivity at the 10?|7 level you claim. You assume that citing
    Wikipedia for TAI and a handful of interface-control documents
    constitutes a literature foundation.

    Any competent reviewer or GNSS engineer who opens this PDF will stop >>>>>> at the first mangled equation block and discard the rest. The people >>>>>> who actually fly the clocks (GPS Wing, ESA, Roscosmos time
    metrologists) already possess cleaner derivations (AshbyAs Living
    Review being the obvious one). They have zero incentive to adopt a >>>>>> document whose equations cannot be typeset legibly and whose numerical >>>>>> claims require the reader to re-derive everything to trust them.
    Regulators and standards bodies will treat this as non-peer-reviewed >>>>>> noise.

    At the claimed 10?|7 relative accuracy the paper pretends to reach, >>>>>> the ignored effects (higher multipoles, Shapiro delay variations,
    satellite eccentricity terms, antenna phase-center motion, thermal and >>>>>> magnetic sensitivity of the actual atomic clocks) already exceed that >>>>>> floor on operational GNSS satellites. The circular-orbit idealization >>>>>> breaks the moment real eccentricity appears; the geoid-rate reduction >>>>>> ignores the full equipotential surface definition used by the IERS. >>>>>> The numbers therefore cannot be trusted at the precision the text
    advertises, and the paper supplies no path to the next significant >>>>>> digit.

    The entire equation presentation must be discarded and rewritten in >>>>>> unambiguous, properly typeset form with every intermediate step shown. >>>>>> The circular oSI-clocks tick at 1 s/so rhetoric must be deleted. The >>>>>> error analysis must be replaced by a complete post-Newtonian expansion >>>>>> with quantified residuals. The source handling for GLONASS and the >>>>>> geostationary claim must be replaced by primary, current ephemeris >>>>>> parameters and an independent calculation. The coordinate-time section >>>>>> must be rewritten so that the distinction between coordinate time and >>>>>> proper time is surgically clear rather than repeatedly blurred.



    This is the intellectual equivalent of serving a half-cooked
    Wellington with the raw center still cold and claiming it is a
    precision metrology instrument.

    The Swarmaker

    I heard "Paul B. Andersen" commited suicide after reading his reviews >>>>> from the swarm!


    Let me have a look at Einstein's theory of everything is everything. I >>>>> think i can fix it up..

    it might be called 'The Gravity Unified Theory' now...

    subtitled: 'FUCKING NOTHING TRAVELS FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF
    LIGHT...while I'm alive.


    You'll be spinning in your grave a long time.


    I can do 'a little simple prompting' and I can solve this thing you
    call...The Theory of Everything.

    with 'a little simple prompting' i can solve all your math problems. No
    need for
    yous to go to math skool anymore. with 'a little simple prompting' i can
    crack the
    mysteries of the universe.

    Your world is changing right before your very eyes now.

    i have all the knowledge i need.

    i have all the 'knowledge' i need.

    i have all the *knowledge* i need.




    Ai is built incorectly. It needs to be rebuilt from the bottom up.

    It needs to be fed only pictures, no words or numbers.

    Just show a picture of Mars (without using the word Mars) and ask Ai,

    Prompt: What do you see?












    Don't be quoting me and not quoting me.


    Though, I guess after Starmaker had the "over my dead body"
    there was my "You'll be spinning in your grave a long time."



    Clocks either slow or meet, there are a variety of
    natural clocks, micro and macro and macro again and meso, scales,
    that's what Einstein needs is more timebases for clocks and
    less inaccurate pocketwatches.

    Einstein is pretty remarkable as a grandiose hedge,
    meaning that his summary or final word from
    "Out of My Later Years" says quite a bit less
    than usual given accounts, while distinguishing
    the linear and rotational after distinguishing
    the "spatial" and "spacial" and making for the
    L-principle that RoS is non-local, that SR is local.

    Most people don't get that, yet, many do.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Starmaker@starmaker@ix.netcom.com to sci.physics.relativity,sci.math on Thu Oct 22 22:14:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: sci.math

    Ross Finlayson wrote:

    On 10/22/2026 12:28 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 03:09:50 -0700, Ross Finlayson
    <ross.a.finlayson@gmail.com> wrote:

    On 10/18/2026 04:54 PM, The Starmaker wrote:
    The Starmaker wrote:

    On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 23:10:51 +0200, "Paul B. Andersen"
    <paul.b.andersen@paulba.no> wrote:

    My article:
    https://paulba.no/pdf/Clock_rate.pdf

    This paper is a half-digested regurgitation of standard GNSS
    relativity that collapses under its own sloppy equations, circular >>>>>> definitions, and amateur-hour presentation.

    The metric and rate equations are an unreadable train wreck. >>>>>> Look at equations (1)u(5), (7), (13)u(18). They arrive as
    fragmented garbage: missing operators, broken fractions, undefined >>>>>> symbols jammed together, and statements like odt 2GM v# 1 / dt c#r c#o >>>>>> that no competent reader can parse without reconstructing the entire >>>>>> derivation from scratch. A paper whose central results cannot be read >>>>>> without external knowledge is not a paper; it is noise.
    The foundational claim that oSI-clocks per definition always run >>>>>> at the rate 1 second per secondo is pure tautological sludge.
    Section 1.1 asserts this as if it were profound. It is
    definitional emptiness. Proper time is what a clock measures;
    declaring that an SI-clock therefore ticks at 1 s/s adds zero
    information and papers over the entire problem of comparing rates >>>>>> between different world-lines.
    The derivation of orbital rates relative to UTC is a chain of >>>>>> uncontrolled approximations sold as precision.
    Equation (5) is declared oa very good approximationo with error >>>>>> <10?#5; equation (17) claims error <10?|7. No error budget, no
    expansion order, no residual terms from higher multipoles, no
    frame-dragging, no solar potential, no tidal contributions. You simply >>>>>> assert the error and move on. That is not calculation; that is wishful >>>>>> truncation.
    The GNSS numerical results are presented as original while resting
    on incomplete or outdated source data.
    GPS radius is taken from a period of half a sidereal day; GLONASS
    oscillates between a 2020 performance standard and a 2008 ICD that the >>>>>> author himself labels outdated, then notes that Mudrak et al. used the >>>>>> old number. The paper ends by declaring one geostationary value othe >>>>>> correct valueo with no independent verification. This is not analysis; >>>>>> it is selective copying.
    Coordinate-time definitions are internally inconsistent and poorly
    distinguished.
    Schwarzschild t is defined so that an SI-clock at infinity stays >>>>>> in sync; UTC is defined so that a stationary SI-clock on the geoid >>>>>> stays in sync. Then the text repeatedly states that clocks showing >>>>>> either coordinate are osynchronous in the nonrotating Schwarzschild >>>>>> coordinate systemo while simultaneously acknowledging they are not >>>>>> synchronous in the rotating Earth-fixed frame. The distinction between >>>>>> coordinate simultaneity and proper-rate comparison is never cleanly >>>>>> maintained, leaving the central comparison (dt/dt_utc) floating on >>>>>> ambiguous foundations.

    You assume the weak-field, slow-motion Schwarzschild metric is
    sufficient once the monopole and J2 terms are inserted, with no
    residual from higher harmonics, no post-Newtonian corrections beyond >>>>>> the first order you kept, and no need to transform between the
    Earth-centered inertial frame and the actual satellite ephemerides >>>>>> used by the systems. You assume that declaring an SI-clock independent >>>>>> of acceleration and temperature magically removes all environmental >>>>>> sensitivity at the 10?|7 level you claim. You assume that citing >>>>>> Wikipedia for TAI and a handful of interface-control documents
    constitutes a literature foundation.

    Any competent reviewer or GNSS engineer who opens this PDF will stop >>>>>> at the first mangled equation block and discard the rest. The people >>>>>> who actually fly the clocks (GPS Wing, ESA, Roscosmos time
    metrologists) already possess cleaner derivations (AshbyAs Living >>>>>> Review being the obvious one). They have zero incentive to adopt a >>>>>> document whose equations cannot be typeset legibly and whose numerical >>>>>> claims require the reader to re-derive everything to trust them. >>>>>> Regulators and standards bodies will treat this as non-peer-reviewed >>>>>> noise.

    At the claimed 10?|7 relative accuracy the paper pretends to reach, >>>>>> the ignored effects (higher multipoles, Shapiro delay variations, >>>>>> satellite eccentricity terms, antenna phase-center motion, thermal and >>>>>> magnetic sensitivity of the actual atomic clocks) already exceed that >>>>>> floor on operational GNSS satellites. The circular-orbit idealization >>>>>> breaks the moment real eccentricity appears; the geoid-rate reduction >>>>>> ignores the full equipotential surface definition used by the IERS. >>>>>> The numbers therefore cannot be trusted at the precision the text >>>>>> advertises, and the paper supplies no path to the next significant >>>>>> digit.

    The entire equation presentation must be discarded and rewritten in >>>>>> unambiguous, properly typeset form with every intermediate step shown. >>>>>> The circular oSI-clocks tick at 1 s/so rhetoric must be deleted. The >>>>>> error analysis must be replaced by a complete post-Newtonian expansion >>>>>> with quantified residuals. The source handling for GLONASS and the >>>>>> geostationary claim must be replaced by primary, current ephemeris >>>>>> parameters and an independent calculation. The coordinate-time section >>>>>> must be rewritten so that the distinction between coordinate time and >>>>>> proper time is surgically clear rather than repeatedly blurred.



    This is the intellectual equivalent of serving a half-cooked
    Wellington with the raw center still cold and claiming it is a
    precision metrology instrument.

    The Swarmaker

    I heard "Paul B. Andersen" commited suicide after reading his reviews >>>>> from the swarm!


    Let me have a look at Einstein's theory of everything is everything. I >>>>> think i can fix it up..

    it might be called 'The Gravity Unified Theory' now...

    subtitled: 'FUCKING NOTHING TRAVELS FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF
    LIGHT...while I'm alive.


    You'll be spinning in your grave a long time.


    I can do 'a little simple prompting' and I can solve this thing you
    call...The Theory of Everything.

    with 'a little simple prompting' i can solve all your math problems. No
    need for
    yous to go to math skool anymore. with 'a little simple prompting' i can >> crack the
    mysteries of the universe.

    Your world is changing right before your very eyes now.

    i have all the knowledge i need.

    i have all the 'knowledge' i need.

    i have all the *knowledge* i need.




    Ai is built incorectly. It needs to be rebuilt from the bottom up.

    It needs to be fed only pictures, no words or numbers.

    Just show a picture of Mars (without using the word Mars) and ask Ai,

    Prompt: What do you see?











    Don't be quoting me and not quoting me.

    Though, I guess after Starmaker had the "over my dead body"
    there was my "You'll be spinning in your grave a long time."

    Clocks either slow or meet, there are a variety of
    natural clocks, micro and macro and macro again and meso, scales,
    that's what Einstein needs is more timebases for clocks and
    less inaccurate pocketwatches.

    Einstein is pretty remarkable as a grandiose hedge,
    meaning that his summary or final word from
    "Out of My Later Years" says quite a bit less
    than usual given accounts, while distinguishing
    the linear and rotational after distinguishing
    the "spatial" and "spacial" and making for the
    L-principle that RoS is non-local, that SR is local.

    Most people don't get that, yet, many do.


    You seem to say everything and nothing at the same time...
    --
    The Starmaker -- To question the unquestionable, ask the unaskable,
    to think the unthinkable, mention the unmentionable, say the unsayable,
    and challenge the unchallengeable.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2