• Arthropod phylogeny

    From x@x@x.org to sci.bio.paleontology on Mon Jun 2 10:58:21 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.bio.paleontology

    So there is the tadpole shrimp, the horseshoe crab, and the trilobite.

    There is Chelicerata and Mandibulata.

    There is Decapoda and Hexapoda.

    So basic questions.

    Are exoskeletons monophyletic?

    Is the trilobite more closely related to the tadpole shrimp,
    the horseshoe crab, or are the tadpole shrimp and horseshoe
    crab more closely related to each other than to the trilobite?

    Are sea spiders closely related to land spiders? Do they have
    too many joints in their legs to be closely related? Are they
    a crown group of the arthropods and they have eight legs by
    coincidence? Or are they actually pretty closely related to
    land spiders?
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From erik simpson@eastside.erik@gmail.com to sci.bio.paleontology on Mon Jun 2 13:55:13 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.bio.paleontology

    On 6/2/25 10:58 AM, x wrote:
    So there is the tadpole shrimp, the horseshoe crab, and the trilobite.

    There is Chelicerata and Mandibulata.

    There is Decapoda and Hexapoda.

    So basic questions.

    Are exoskeletons monophyletic?

    Is the trilobite more closely related to the tadpole shrimp,
    the horseshoe crab, or are the tadpole shrimp and horseshoe
    crab more closely related to each other than to the trilobite?

    Are sea spiders closely related to land spiders?-a Do they have
    too many joints in their legs to be closely related?-a Are they
    a crown group of the arthropods and they have eight legs by
    coincidence?-a Or are they actually pretty closely related to
    land spiders?
    If by exoskeletons you mean ecdysozoa, they are indeed a huge clade (see Wikipedia).

    Trilobites are believed to be members of Artiopoda, a group of extinct critters, whose placement within Arthropoda is somewhat uncertain since
    the best way to order organisms in clades is genomic analysis, and for anything extinct that long (250 My) that isn't available.

    Everything you mention specifically is a member of Arthropoda, and
    Wikipedia is your friend. Tadpole shrimp (Notostraca) have been
    separated from all other arthropods since the Devonian (360 MYa), and
    they look it.
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Harshman@john.harshman@gmail.com to sci.bio.paleontology on Mon Jun 2 15:18:51 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.bio.paleontology

    On 6/2/25 10:58 AM, x wrote:
    So there is the tadpole shrimp, the horseshoe crab, and the trilobite.

    There is Chelicerata and Mandibulata.

    There is Decapoda and Hexapoda.

    So basic questions.

    Are exoskeletons monophyletic?

    Yes; synapomorphy of Ecdysozoa.

    Is the trilobite more closely related to the tadpole shrimp,
    the horseshoe crab, or are the tadpole shrimp and horseshoe
    crab more closely related to each other than to the trilobite?

    Current thinking is that trilobites are arachnomorphs and so more
    closely related to horseshoe crabs.

    Are sea spiders closely related to land spiders?

    No. But both are probably arachnomorphs.

    Do they have
    too many joints in their legs to be closely related?-a Are they
    a crown group of the arthropods and they have eight legs by
    coincidence?

    All "crown group" means is a clade bounded by living representatives.
    Not sure just how 8 legs maps onto the tree.

    -aOr are they actually pretty closely related to
    land spiders?

    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2