• Abdul El-Sayed Is a Socialist in All but Name

    From Comey Club@86comey@trump.org to talk.politics.guns,talk.politics.misc,rec.sport.tennis on Sun Nov 1 18:08:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.sport.tennis

    When Abdul El-Sayed ran for governor of Michigan in 2018, progressive
    media hailed him as the next Barack Obama. El-Sayed did not appreciate
    the comparison. "I get compared to Obama because my name is funny, and
    I'm brown, and my politics are about inspiring us to believe in each
    other again," he told Vox at the time.

    In El-Sayed's telling, Obama was a "fairly centrist, middle-of-the-road" Democrat. He did not intend that as a compliment. El-Sayed believed the administration's policies were not nearly progressive enoughrCoindeed, he believed Obama had betrayed the agenda he ran on. The far-reaching
    financial, environmental, and labor regulations that Obama pushed
    through were not nearly enough for El-Sayed.

    El-Sayed ultimately fell short in the 2018 Democratic gubernatorial
    primary. Eight years later, he's a much savvier political operative; now running for the U.S. Senate, he has welcomed Obama's support this time.
    Yet El-Sayed's commitment to a left-wing agenda has hardly diminished.
    If he defeats his opponent, former Rep. Mike Rogers (RrCoMich.), he will
    be one of the most far-left politicians to win a statewide election in
    recent memoryrCoand in a purple-ish swing state that President Donald
    Trump won twice.

    Like his friend and mentor Sen. Bernie Sanders (IrCoVt.), El-Sayed is not
    a member of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA); unlike Sanders, El-Sayed maintains that he is a capitalist rather than a socialist. Yet
    his political project has much in common with the DSA, and he has given
    every indication that he will align himself with DSA-affiliated members
    of CongressrCoveterans such as Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (DrCoN.Y.) and likely newcomers such as Darializa Avila Chevalier and Claire Valdez,
    both of New York, who rode similar waves of populist resentment to
    victory over establishment Democrats.

    El-Sayed's left-wing bona fides were evident during his debate with
    Rogers on October 8. The Democrat proposed giving the federal government
    vast new powers: up to 50 percent control over AI companies, a
    socialized health insurance program along the lines of Medicare for All,
    and price controls on the domestic oil industry. Asked what he would do
    to bring down the national debt and pay for all the new spending he
    wants, he had a simple, three-word answer: "Tax. Billionaire. Wealth."

    El-Sayed's support for higher taxes exempts one important constituency: seniors. Like many DemocratsrCoand Republicans such as Rep. Nancy Mace (RrCoS.C.)rCoEl-Sayed wants to exempt retirees from property tax increases,
    a policy that critics have branded "total boomer luxury communism"
    because it forces younger, less wealthy Americans to shoulder ever more
    of the social burden. The new wave of leftist Democrats think that
    higher taxes on the 1 percent, combined with cuts to the military
    budget, would be sufficient to pay down the debt while vastly expanding
    the social safety net.

    In fact, El-Sayed has proposed tying Pentagon spending to education,
    such that an increase in money for the military would necessitate more
    funding toward schools. Don't expect this to work the other way around:
    Under El-Sayed's plan, a decrease in Pentagon spending would not force
    the government to stop throwing so much money at failing schools.

    Ann Arbor and Onward
    El-Sayed was born on Halloween in 1984. He grew up in Bloomfield Hills,
    an affluent, predominantly white suburb north of Detroit. His parents
    divorced when he was young, and El-Sayed lived with his Egyptian father
    and white stepmother. In high school, he was captain of the football, wrestling, and lacrosse teams. He continued to play on a club lacrosse
    team at the University of Michigan, which he attended from 2003 to 2007.
    (We overlapped briefly, though I never met him: I attended Michigan from
    2006 to 2010.)

    That meant going to Ann Arbor, a progressive college town with a long
    history of radical activism. Students for a Democratic Society (SDS),
    the prototypical '60s New Left student activist group, was founded in
    Ann Arbor in 1960; its first president, Alan Haber, still lives there.
    The White Panther Party, a sort of hippie counterpart to the Black
    Panthers, was based in Ann Arbor for a while; in the 1970s, the
    socialist Human Rights Party won multiple seats on city council.
    Liberalism, as well as radicalism, has thrived in Ann Arbor: The same
    year the SDS was born, future President John F. Kennedy came to the town
    to propose the international volunteer organization that eventually
    emerged as the Peace Corps. In the 2008 Democratic presidential
    primaries, the student-run Michigan Daily naturally endorsed the
    inspirational liberal candidate, Obama, over the establishment favorite, Hillary Clinton.

    Over the course of the next decaderCoas left-wing enthusiasm for the Obama project faded and was replaced by bitter disappointmentrCoEl-Sayed
    enrolled in Oxford University and then Columbia University, pursuing a
    career in public health. (He never completed a residency, which has led
    to some scrutiny, even from friendly media figures, regarding his
    decision to describe himself as a physician.) In 2015, the mayor of
    Detroit appointed him the city's executive health officer. He resigned
    that position in 2017 to run for governor. That pattern repeated itself
    a few years later: He was appointed health director of Wayne County,
    which includes Detroit, in 2022, and resigned in 2025 to run for Senate.

    Unlike in 2018, El-Sayed's hard-left politics and contempt for the
    Democratic establishment were now well-calibrated to prevail in the
    primaries. He defeated a more moderate candidate, Rep. Haley Stevens (DrCoMich.), in part due to her support for IsraelrCoan issue that El-Sayed frequently discusses. The same phenomenon has played out all over the
    country, with establishment Democratic figures paying a huge price when perceived as indifferent to voter outrage over Israel.

    What works in the Democratic primaries does not always do as well in the general election. But while El-Sayed's politics are well to the left of
    the state he seeks to represent, the president's unpopularity may be
    enough to push him over the finish line. El-Sayed is narrowly ahead of
    Rogers in the latest polling. The Republican has finally resorted to
    breaking with the president on key policy issuesrCohe has said that he
    wishes to end some of Trump's tariffs, conceding that "Canada is not our enemy"rCobut it may be too little too late.

    Moreover, El-Sayed's left-wing foreign policy positions, which are not necessarily antithetical to libertarian views, count for more in
    Michigan than in other places. The state has a significant Arab-American population that politicians have ignored at their peril. In 2024, dissatisfaction with President Joe Biden's failure to curtail Israel's
    war on Gaza prompted many Arabs in Michigan to cast ballots for Green
    Party candidate Jill Stein, or even Trump, over Democratic nominee
    Kamala Harris. Republicans have sought to portray El-Sayed as
    insufficiently supportive of Israel, but that doesn't always play well
    in MichiganrCoparticularly at a time when dissatisfaction with Trump's blunders in the Middle East is strong among Democrats, independents, and
    even many Republicans.

    El-Sayed does have a possible Achilles heel on foreign policy: His
    association with the far-left Twitch streamer Hasan Piker. To many
    outside observers, the candidate's courting of Piker reads as a huge
    unforced error. Not only did El-Sayed seek the approval of an internet personality best known for praising authoritarian governments and
    evincing sympathy for terrorist groups, but he brought Piker to
    Michigan, put him in front of a camera, and made him a de facto
    representative of the campaign. For everyone except the toxically
    online, Piker is a bizarre and marginal shock jock, a man who says
    things like "America deserved 9/11." Piker is what happens when you pay
    too much attention to podcasts. He is also a reminder that while the
    insurgent left often claims to speak for ordinary, blue-collar working
    people, its agenda tends to be most popular with the affluent and elite-educated. In El-Sayed's showdown with Stevens, polls had her up 22 points with noncollege voters and 46 points with black voters. (Stevens herself is white.)

    Yet El-Sayed prevailed, and he dealt with the Piker issue by shunting
    him to the sidelines. When asked about Piker, El-Sayed dutifully recites
    that a Twitch streamer from California has nothing to do with a Senate
    race in Michigan. (The obvious retort is Well, you brought him here.) He
    has also adopted right-coded language to explain why he should not be
    held responsible for Piker's inflammatory comments, telling Politico
    that he was over "this whole gotcha game, platform policing, cancel
    culture."

    The GOP, meanwhile, may have gone overboard in the other direction.
    Rogers, a traditional Republican more in the George W. Bush mold than
    the Trump mold, is not exactly a right-wing firebrand, yet he could not
    stop himself from suggesting that El-Sayed has some sort of connection
    to Islamic terrorists. Just as Democrats should genuinely worry that
    linking up with people like Piker will cost them Jewish votes,
    Republicans should think more about whether reflexively calling Muslims terrorists is a bad strategy to win in Michigan.

    After all, the form of radicalism that El-Sayed typifies is not really Islamic. It's not even foreign. It's the radicalism of left-wing
    economics, of making the federal government larger and more robust. He
    wants to prohibit corporations from buying houses and to punish
    companies like Airbnb over "housing dislocation." He wants to raise the capital gains tax, the inheritance tax, and the top marginal tax rates.
    He wants to give the Federal Trade Commission expansive new powers. He
    thinks higher education should be free for everyone. If he makes it to
    the Senate, El-Sayed will be a reliable vote for the Sanders agenda,
    including moratoriums on new data center construction, a much stronger Environmental Protection Agency, and, of course, Medicare for All.
    Indeed, one of El-Sayed's most frequent criticisms of Obama over the
    years has been that the Affordable Care Act did not go nearly far
    enough, and that it may have even been counterproductive to the mission
    of building a socialist health system.

    Obama appeared alongside El-Sayed in Detroit on October 24. The
    candidate was savvy enough not to bring up his thoughts about Obamacare.

    https://reason.com/2026/10/29/abdul-el-sayed-is-a-socialist-in-all-but-name/ --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2