Hi all,
Starting to think more seriously about a new tow vehicle for our
Lance 1475 (GVWR ~4000 lbs). We currently use a 2023 GMC Acadia
Denali and have been happy with it, but it is closing in on 90k
miles and starting to show its age. I expect it won't be long
until it starts needing some bigger ticket repairs.
I do NOT want a pickup, an SUV is just right for hauling our
tandem bicycle and luggage in the back when we travel without the
trailer--or when we schlep to a remote ride start with just the
bike. I also don't want the bigger SUVs (e.g., Yukon) because the
mid sizes have enough towning capacity and being slightly smaller
fit the garage better and are a bit more driveable. So probably a
3-row model, though a larger 2-row could also work.
I've put together a table with 14 possibilities based on towing
capacity, engine hp, mileage, weight, and length/width. Cost is
also there, though it's not an importnt factor. Here are a few
options with comments...
Mazda CX-90 3.3 Turbo Premium Plus
I like its hp and mileage and that Edmunds describes it as sporty.
It's 7 inches longer than my 23 Acadia, which is prolly ok. On
the other hand, some reviews are not favorable on handling and responsiveness, and it's a hybrid (which reportedly increases
repair costs greatly).
Ford Explorer AT 6 cylinder
Great power (400 hp) and nothing to criticize.
Nissan Pathfinder Rock Creek Edition
A little on the heavy side and slightly less engine power (295 hp
as compared to my current 310). Otherwise seems worth considering
Dodge Durango R/T 392 Premium
Mileage is poor, but with a V8 it has hp and towing capacity in
abundance.
Toyota 4Runner TRD Off-Road Premium
It's only 4 cylinder, but being a hybrid has ample power and
decent mileage. It reportedly has a high load in for cargo, which
could be a hassle with the bike in and out.
I'd consider a newer Acadia, but they are all bigger than my
current model by a good bit (and described as "ponderous" in the
Edmunds review. Ew).
Another option is the Lexus GS Premium Plus, but it's described as
having "noticeable body roll" (again, ew), and its mileage stinks.
I did consider cargo capacity and all seem fine given what I know
about our tongue weight needs.
There were a few I ruled out because the rated hp was too much
lower than what we have now (Toyota Grand Highlander Platinum, Kia
Telluride SX-Prestige, and Honda Passport or Pilot). Maybe I'm
putting too much stock in horsepower, I suppose I could consider
torque too.
I do intend to dig in deeper on the leading candidates and of
course see and drive the top several. Any other thoughts for me?
On 11/1/2026 9:38 AM, Ted Heise wrote:
Hi all,
Starting to think more seriously about a new tow vehicle for
our Lance 1475 (GVWR ~4000 lbs). We currently use a 2023 GMC
Acadia Denali and have been happy with it, but it is closing
in on 90k miles and starting to show its age. I expect it
won't be long until it starts needing some bigger ticket
repairs.
That model also has only a 4,000 lb towing capacity so you're
right at the limit.
I'd consider a newer Acadia, but they are all bigger than my
current model by a good bit (and described as "ponderous" in
the Edmunds review. Ew).
The new on does add 10" to the back, but also goes to 5,000 lb.
towing capacity.
Google really likes this one:
Hyundai Palisade: The Premium Substitute: If you want to match
or exceed the luxury and feature density of your Denali trim,
the Palisade is a top-tier contender. It features a robust
5,000 to 5,500 lbs towing capacity (depending on the exact
model year) alongside a highly customizable, flat cargo space
and advanced trailering tech like auto-leveling rear
suspension.
But, you have to stick with the naturally aspirated 3.5L Gas
V6, and not the hybrid they offer.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:48:33 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Calls today: | 2 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
5 files (9,643K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,375 |