During all of this, he admitted that
he had cheated during character rollup, with a laughing emoji.
The True Melissa wrote in article ><MPG.455d64f62d4bfd2698a68d@news.eternal-september.org>:
During all of this, he admitted that
he had cheated during character rollup, with a laughing emoji.
This is astonishing, given how generous my method is. Roll 4d6
and keep three, twelve times, then pick any six and arrange them
as you like. Isn't that generous? It's hard to roll a truly
hopeless character that way.
The toxic guy and his brother each had characters with extremely
high stats (an 18 and other high rolls). I didn't think anything
of this, since I set such a generous method. A few weeks ago, two
new players joined and rolled up, and their stats were merely
good. The toxic player began to deluge me with complaints about
their "garbage covered in shit" characters who were so "weak"
that their players must hate them, though the players seemed
engaged and weren't complaining.
I did some math and realized that the odds of those two rolling
their four characters in four tries, even with my method, were
about one in seventeen million. I gently inquired, and was told
that his brother had rerolled twice, which along with some stat
adjustments lowered the odds to about one in a thousand -- lucky,
but no reason not to believe it.
Then, in Discord discussion, this guy happily volunteered that he
rerolled three times until he got an 18. He added a laughing
emoji.
He had to go, but I'm still sad and upset.
The True Melissa wrote in article <MPG.455d64f62d4bfd2698a68d@news.eternal-september.org>:
During all of this, he admitted that
he had cheated during character rollup, with a laughing emoji.
This is astonishing, given how generous my method is. Roll 4d6
and keep three, twelve times, then pick any six and arrange them
as you like. Isn't that generous? It's hard to roll a truly
hopeless character that way.
Then, in Discord discussion, this guy happily volunteered that heWhen I played online last (it's a long ago), we had a bot on out IRC
rerolled three times until he got an 18. He added a laughing
emoji.
Then, in Discord discussion, this guy happily volunteered that heWhen I played online last (it's a long ago), we had a bot on out IRC
rerolled three times until he got an 18. He added a laughing
emoji.
channel which rolled dices and it was how we rolled /roll 3d6+1
Not much space for cheating there, maybe this is something for you: https://www.clrn.org/how-to-roll-dice-in-discord/
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 18:10:05 -0500, The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:
It was a tough decision on your part, and I respect that you made it.
But apparently the player was making you uncomfortable --both in their behavior and their play-style-- and that rarely leads to a fun time.
While it is an important part of a DM's job to make sure the other
players are having fun, it's almost as important that the DM has fun
too. Grumpy DMs can bring down a whole adventure.* I hope it all works
out and doesn't cause any further issues with the party. But it sounds
like it will.**
I won't be too judgmental against the player, though, if only because
I don't know things from his side.
Nonetheless, it did seem he was a
poor fit for your group and I've long maintained that finding
like-minded players is probably the most important part of having a
good, long-term D&D experience. It's nice sometimes to play with
people who have other styles and expectations, but usually only for
one-off games. But more than rules, more than setting, more even than
skill of the players, it's having a bunch of players all working
together to the same goal --whatever that goal may is, be it
mindlessly killing monsters, roleplaying a character, or amassing loot
and power in the best munchkin fashion-- that makes for a good game.
I've never been too fashed about some (minor) creative license with
character creation / attributes. Not that it really came up that much;
if you wanted to make a new character, you did it in front of me
before the session started. I might not pay attention to every roll
while you did that, but if you got more than one 17 or 18 I'd probably
take a closer interest in what your next rolls were.*** But at the
same time, if you came to me with a good idea as to what your
character was intended to be, I might let you have those rolls anyway.
Having PCs with above-average stats wasn't that unusual in our group. Especially since I was never afraid to sap PCs attributes through one
means or another.**** ;-)
At the same time, I never had issue with players using PCs with
sub-optimum scores in (some of their) attributes (although I probably
voiced concerns if a PC had poor scores in ALL their attributes. It
might be fun for the player to use a character like that, but would
put unfair burden on the others in the group. I don't recall that ever happening though).
Still, if a player admits to cheating with their character creation,
they'd definitely be on my 'watch-list' while playing the game because
they'd marked themselves as untrustworthy. I'd make sure I had copies
of their player sheet, and any rolls they made I'd make sure were
under observation (or sometimes I'd just roll for them). But mostly it
wasn't that much of an issue. I had a fairly honest bunch, and they
were more interested in the role-playing than the gaming aspect of D&D anyway.
* A sin I have been guilty of more than once. Sometimes I was just
having a bad day, or maybe I had an issue with another player and it
made for less-than-stellar adventure. Other times it was a bad time of
my life and this was reflected in the overall tone and design of the adventure. Not all my DMing was perfect! I'm fortunate that my players
were forgiving of my faults and seemed to think that my good sessions outweighed the poor ones.
** I'd recommend having a brief discussion with your remaining
players, if you haven't already, letting them know that the player's
removal from the group wasn't a spur of the moment thing; that you had
given it some thought and given the other player warnings and attempts
to correct their behavior. Just so they know that you aren't being
spurious and vindictive, which might cause uncertainty amongst the
survivors. And if you haven't had the discussion yet, you may also at
some point (not necessarily at the same time) discuss with your
players what your expectations are of them and of the group.
** Our group's preferred method was roll 4d6, drop the lowest. Roll 7
times, drop the lowest. Assign the surviving six numbers where you
will. Then whine at DM for permission to tinker with your stats, which
may or may not be granted. Mostly this was allowed by removing points
from a higher attribute to raise a lower; rarely the other way around.
*** for example, a custom monster I used was a 'greater shadow', who
drained STR just like regular shadows, but there was a chance that the
drain was permanent. Alternately, if a player was badly hurt (either
forced into negative HP, or took a huge amount of damage in a single
attack) I might penalize with a permanent disability penalty to one of
their attributes. Adventuring is a tough life, after all, and throwing yourself into all those death-defying situations takes a toll on the
body and mind. And if characters with 18 stats tended to get targeted
a bit more often, it was only because I knew those PCs could afford
the hit more easily. ;-)
I don't know what method I'll use for the Big Reboot this Sunday.
Normally I would take player input and decide on what would be
the most fun for everyone, but at the moment I am terrified to
invite player input. Someone might snatch the game from me and
start beating me on the head with it. :-\
The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> writes:
I don't know what method I'll use for the Big Reboot this Sunday.
Normally I would take player input and decide on what would be
the most fun for everyone, but at the moment I am terrified to
invite player input. Someone might snatch the game from me and
start beating me on the head with it. :-\
Doesn't sound fun. :-/ But from the tone of your posts, I trust this
should go much better without him. Maybe try to present a few options to
your players, not for everything but at leat give them a few choices and
see how things go?
Out of curiosity, do you intend to try to continue your campaign more or
less as is, or to start anew?
Arnaud Gomes wrote in article <87y0aztsui.fsf@moka.glou.org>:
The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> writes:
I don't know what method I'll use for the Big Reboot this Sunday.
Normally I would take player input and decide on what would be
the most fun for everyone, but at the moment I am terrified to
invite player input. Someone might snatch the game from me and
start beating me on the head with it. :-\
Doesn't sound fun. :-/ But from the tone of your posts, I trust this
should go much better without him. Maybe try to present a few options to
your players, not for everything but at leat give them a few choices and
see how things go?
Out of curiosity, do you intend to try to continue your campaign more or
less as is, or to start anew?
I will probably at least revise.
Right now the religion system is
a basic sun god and moon goddess, but I have what I think is a
cool alignment system. What if there are four main gods? There's
a god of law, a god of chaos, a goddess of good, and a goddess of
evil. Their alliances and oppositions become ours.
Of course, this would make paladins a little hard to handle.
Would they be dedicated to both law and good? They're supposed to
be a bit fanatical.
I could also use new maps. I'm terrible with outdoor maps.
J.O. Aho wrote in article <nliifsFnfe2U1@mid.individual.net>:
Then, in Discord discussion, this guy happily volunteered that heWhen I played online last (it's a long ago), we had a bot on out IRC
rerolled three times until he got an 18. He added a laughing
emoji.
channel which rolled dices and it was how we rolled /roll 3d6+1
Not much space for cheating there, maybe this is something for you:
https://www.clrn.org/how-to-roll-dice-in-discord/
We were playing in real life. Four people were sitting there
rolling a bunch of dice, and I didn't realize I had to stare at
them and count the rolls.
Before the final ejection, I switched us to a point-assignment
system to cut down on arguing (and cheating). You get 70 points;
put them where you want them. If your stats don't sum to 70, you
made a mistake. Okay, *now* do race and age adjustments. If
you've exceeded or missed a racial limit, you can sacrifice
points to go down but you don't get free points to go up.
It's certainly fair. On the other hand, it doesn't feel very D&D.
Working around a strength of 6 or roleplaying a wisdom of 4 can
be part of the fun.
I don't know what method I'll use for the Big Reboot this Sunday.
Normally I would take player input and decide on what would be
the most fun for everyone, but at the moment I am terrified to
invite player input. Someone might snatch the game from me and
start beating me on the head with it. :-\
I've always enjoyed starting new in an existing campaign world
(usually mine ;-). It allows some continuity that existing players
will enjoy, and cuts down on a lot of the work for me as DM.
It does sometimes to lead to soap opera-ish plot twists at times
("Paladin was Cleric's half-cousin by way of his father's marriage to
Ranger from three parties back!" ;-) but that adds some
tongue-in-cheek fun to the experience. And if it all gets too silly,
we just recon it later on so it never happened. ;-)
It's not to everybody's taste, but it works for us.
Of course, this would make paladins a little hard to handle.
Would they be dedicated to both law and good? They're supposed to
be a bit fanatical.
I've never stuck singly with Lawful Good paladins. For me, the paladin
was just a chosen holy warrior who was granted extra powers (and
duties) by his deity. Those duties usually being of the 'you go on
quests for your god when they ask' sort of thing. So fanaticism (at
least in the sense of pushing their beliefs on others) was never a necessity... although give them a quest and they'd stick to it or face consequences. But evil gods could have paladins too.
I could also use new maps. I'm terrible with outdoor maps.
Outdoor maps are always my favorite! Although I still make them the
old fashioned way, on paper, with pen and pencils. I've dabbled with
making maps electronically, but it's never quite as satisfying to me.
I love the classic AD&D maps (not so much the hex-maps of BECMI),
although I don't always use that style.
Drawing the region map is always my favorite part of starting a new
campaign.
saw you mention discord, so that why I mentioned this, but yeahsome
people are like that, if you don't stare at them all the time then they cheat. As we always don't things like filling in the form was done by
the DM, so it was tradition you rolled the dice in front of the DM and
the DM filled your stats in the form.
Before the final ejection, I switched us to a point-assignment
system to cut down on arguing (and cheating). You get 70 points;
put them where you want them. If your stats don't sum to 70, you
made a mistake. Okay, *now* do race and age adjustments. If
you've exceeded or missed a racial limit, you can sacrifice
points to go down but you don't get free points to go up.
It's certainly fair. On the other hand, it doesn't feel very D&D.
You could have a little bit of random and have 60 points + d12
If you increase the number of point you could have a system with
1-11: 1 point per step
12-15: 2 points per step
16-18: 3 points per step
Sure more to calculate, but it would make things more balance IMHO,
I don't know what method I'll use for the Big Reboot this Sunday.
Normally I would take player input and decide on what would be
the most fun for everyone, but at the moment I am terrified to
invite player input. Someone might snatch the game from me and
start beating me on the head with it. :-\
Just have a bowl of chips and ask, do you want some? Tend to make people more relaxed ;)
I had some game where you only played "action" scenes, like in a move,
you cut away all the "boring" parts like the long travel, never got the
time to play it and I don't have the books left, did a swap with one of
the other in the group, got his AD&D books I had in exchange for it.
I'm sure you will have a great reboot game night, don't worry too much.
I hope so, but I'm a little afraid only one person will show up.
There were two new players when I finally had to eject the toxic
one, and they don't know what he was doing behind the scenes, so
one of them is going to the toxic guy's table. I think he'll be
all right; he's a guy, and a lot of the toxic guy's toxicity
seems to be rooted in misogyny.
Yeah, antipaladins have always been a thing. I regret allowing
the neutral paladin, though I still think it might have been cool
if it had gone as pitched.
I don't want to allow any evil characters, and I also plan to
reject any allegedly neutral characters who are struggling with
the dark side. If any sneak in, the alignment will flip to evil
as soon as the character does something evil, regardless of >rationalizations.
Drawing the region map is always my favorite part of starting a new
campaign.
Are you available? :-) I just sit there plopping things around
in Wonderdraft, and then I realize how awful it looks compared to
everyone else's maps.
I never developed any drawing skill, though. I can't draw by
hand, either. We never needed maps in the old days; we mapped
dungeons and mazes on graph paper when needed, but outdoors was
100% theater of the mind.
On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 09:04:30 -0500, The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:
Yeah, antipaladins have always been a thing. I regret allowing
the neutral paladin, though I still think it might have been cool
if it had gone as pitched.
I sort of have a problem with neutral paladins too. I mean, if your
whole belief is sort of not taking a stance, having a fanatical
warrior doesn't really fit the mode. Paladins by nature are not chill
;-)
Assuming they aren't just doing it just to be dicks, playerswith evil
characters can be fun. Unfortunately, by nature of their alignment,
they tend to be disruptive to the other players and to the story.
With a good player, they add a certain spice to an adventure... but
they're a bad fit (IMHO) for long-running campaigns.
Are you available? :-) I just sit there plopping things around
in Wonderdraft, and then I realize how awful it looks compared to
everyone else's maps.
Heh; you wouldn't want my stuff anyway. I said I enjoyed making maps.
I never made any claim to quality.
(I don't think I'm terrible, but they look like what they are:
hand-drawn maps made by an amateur ;-)
I tend to draw far fewer indoor maps. Overland maps have wonderful
natural curves and jags that I've gotten quite good at. Indoor maps
require me to do the impossible: draw a straight line!
Since I tend to do a lot of world-building, having an largeoutdoor
map was always helpful. Especially since a core tenet of the gameworld
was that its history was dependent on geography and politics, and not
the whims of gods and wizards. So knowing where the coast lay and
which way the rains were likely to come from was essential. ;-)
On 12/11/2026 15.12, The True Melissa wrote:
I hope so, but I'm a little afraid only one person will show up.
There were two new players when I finally had to eject the toxic
one, and they don't know what he was doing behind the scenes, so
one of them is going to the toxic guy's table. I think he'll be
all right; he's a guy, and a lot of the toxic guy's toxicity
seems to be rooted in misogyny.
I rather DM one player than have a toxic gang who may talk shit about
you behind your back.
Have your adventure ready, have a good time with those who appears, I
would if I didn't have to swim so far to be there and don't think I can manage in time, the Atlantic is wide ;)
Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article <4ar7fldlmnd0com8fosm514bbhrb0h5l75@4ax.com>:
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 18:10:05 -0500, The True Melissa
<thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:
** Our group's preferred method was roll 4d6, drop the lowest. Roll 7
times, drop the lowest. Assign the surviving six numbers where you
will. Then whine at DM for permission to tinker with your stats, which
may or may not be granted. Mostly this was allowed by removing points
from a higher attribute to raise a lower; rarely the other way around.
In the 80s, we did 4d6k3 straight down, then whined for
permission to swap stats if we wanted. That and your method both
sound fine to me. The 12 tries weren't really needed, but I
thought it would prevent someone getting stuck with an unwanted
low score... though low scores can be fun to manage.
I do think I should apply a stronger penalty at zero. I've been
skipping the prescribed coma and letting characters bounce right
back up, like a video game. This is the sort of thing I'd like to
see a whole group decide on together, but it has to be a group
consisting largely of non-toxic non-abusive non-narcissists.
Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article <vjpcfl1mhji8h3pcam1j4hi6dd5jfgcksj@4ax.com>:
On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 09:04:30 -0500, The True Melissa
<thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:
Yeah, antipaladins have always been a thing. I regret allowing
the neutral paladin, though I still think it might have been cool
if it had gone as pitched.
I sort of have a problem with neutral paladins too. I mean, if your
whole belief is sort of not taking a stance, having a fanatical
warrior doesn't really fit the mode. Paladins by nature are not chill
;-)
I wondered about that too, but as it was originally pitched, it
could have worked. The idea was not the classic preserve-the-
balance but that the paladin was an agent of karma. He was
charged with making sure people got what they had coming, whether
that was aid or mercy or instant death. Allegedly, this god
valued fair dealing above all else, so that bargains made either
by or with the god's agent could potentially be enforced by the
god himself.
After the god was admitted and the paladinhood bestowed, I was
informed that in fact the paladins are allowed to make false
bargains and cheat others, even flat-out betraying them, if they
judge that the other party deserved it. It was a mistake to allow
any homebrew from this guy, because 100% of it tends toward MOAR
POWER.
During the final drama, he admitted that his character was
supposed to "challenge the players' morals" or some such, to
which no one agreed.
Assuming they aren't just doing it just to be dicks, playerswith evil
characters can be fun. Unfortunately, by nature of their alignment,
they tend to be disruptive to the other players and to the story.
With a good player, they add a certain spice to an adventure... but
they're a bad fit (IMHO) for long-running campaigns.
I learned recently that the reason there are so many evil
characters in the original campaigns is that the DMs
recategorized them based on their actions.
Are you available? :-) I just sit there plopping things around
in Wonderdraft, and then I realize how awful it looks compared to
everyone else's maps.
Heh; you wouldn't want my stuff anyway. I said I enjoyed making maps.
I never made any claim to quality.
(I don't think I'm terrible, but they look like what they are:
hand-drawn maps made by an amateur ;-)
I tend to draw far fewer indoor maps. Overland maps have wonderful
natural curves and jags that I've gotten quite good at. Indoor maps
require me to do the impossible: draw a straight line!
I use architecture software for indoor maps. They don't even have
to render well, only be usable in 3D, so it's easy-peasy.
Sometimes I think I should just snarf one of those entire-world
Wonderdraft models and use that. Maybe I will.
On 11/11/2026 12.11, The True Melissa wrote:
J.O. Aho wrote in article <nliifsFnfe2U1@mid.individual.net>:
Then, in Discord discussion, this guy happily volunteered that heWhen I played online last (it's a long ago), we had a bot on out IRC
rerolled three times until he got an 18. He added a laughing
emoji.
channel which rolled dices and it was how we rolled /roll 3d6+1
Not much space for cheating there, maybe this is something for you:
https://www.clrn.org/how-to-roll-dice-in-discord/
We were playing in real life. Four people were sitting there
rolling a bunch of dice, and I didn't realize I had to stare at
them and count the rolls.
saw you mention discord, so that why I mentioned this, but yeah some
people are like that, if you don't stare at them all the time then they cheat. As we always don't things like filling in the form was done by
the DM, so it was tradition you rolled the dice in front of the DM and
the DM filled your stats in the form.
Before the final ejection, I switched us to a point-assignment
system to cut down on arguing (and cheating). You get 70 points;
put them where you want them. If your stats don't sum to 70, you
made a mistake. Okay, *now* do race and age adjustments. If
you've exceeded or missed a racial limit, you can sacrifice
points to go down but you don't get free points to go up.
It's certainly fair. On the other hand, it doesn't feel very D&D.
You could have a little bit of random and have 60 points + d12
If you increase the number of point you could have a system with
1-11: 1 point per step
12-15: 2 points per step
16-18: 3 points per step
Sure more to calculate, but it would make things more balance IMHO,
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 57:39:33 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,926 |