• Munchkin or cheater? (Alt title: Am I the DM or the mommy?)

    From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to alt.games.adnd,rec.games.frp.dnd on Fri Oct 30 07:33:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    I apologize in advance for the length.

    I onboarded two new players to my game, making four. They both
    rolled reasonable characters, a magic-user and a ranger. Both had
    solid stats with prime requisites of 15 and other decent numbers.
    I use an extremely generous method of character creation, so this
    was no surprise.

    My munchkin apparently cornered them in the parking lot to tell
    them their characters sucked. He texted me to complain that they
    hated their weak, terrible, underpowered characters and he was
    worried new people wouldn't advocate hard enough for themselves
    and he was afraid they would quit. I pointed out that the new
    characters were fine, and he insisted that they had to have stat
    bonuses or else I was letting them play "weak" characters, which
    he would never do.

    This player has two characters, one with two 18s and one with one
    18, as well as other very high rolls. The other established
    player also has two characters with 18s. I accepted this without
    question because I use a generous creation method, but at this
    point I sat down and did some math. Even with my generous method,
    the odds of those four characters emerging are about one in 17
    million.

    I gently pointed this out. It came out that both he and his
    brother felt free to reroll without consulting me. Even with
    acknowledged rerolling, their odds of those characters still work
    out to about one in a thousand.

    Something hinky is going on. I asked that player for his primary
    character's stats and was told the dex was 16. I've heard "My dex
    is 18" from him at least twice, to justify automatically having
    some proficiency he'd never learned.

    I guess I need a policy that new characters are rolled in front
    of me. That seems too authoritarian. We're supposed to be friends
    having fun together. I guess I also need my own copy of character
    sheets, or at least of their stats and basic derived features
    like hit points. I don't like that at all.

    Maybe he just made a mistake. It's been several weeks since he
    claimed to have a dex of 18. I'd rather believe he's a munchkin
    who made a mistake on his stats and assumed rerolling privileges
    than believe he is deliberately cheating. Either way, it's
    becoming a real pain in the neck, and I don't like this business
    of complaining that the new characters are "garbage covered in
    shit" because they're not superhuman.

    I messaged the two new players to ask if they had fun, just in
    case they really did hate their "weak" characters and want to
    quit. One said he had a great time and is planning to return. The
    other hasn't responded yet.

    I don't want a game of superpowered superheroes striding easily
    through pseudochallenges and having treasure thrown at them from
    all directions. That's not D&D. That's not even a game any more,
    just narcissistic daydreaming. We can imagine ourselves as gods
    without the bother of rolling all those dice; the dice aren't
    supposed to roll 20 every time.

    This same player has other problems. One harmless but annoying
    trait is announcing "nat 20" or "crit" when he rolls a 20. This
    roll has no special magic at my table, but he wants it to mean a
    critical hit for extra damage, so he keeps announcing it that
    way. Another annoying trait is that he constantly wants to retool
    his character to be more powerful -- he started as a magic-
    user/assassin and converted to a paladin/assassin, and that was
    just the start. He wanted to have a special power of turning
    invisible, and when I said no to that, he wanted a special power
    of stealing life force in combat while his eyes glowed. He said
    he was "thinking of" trading some intelligence points for more
    strength, as if that were just a thing he could decide to do. He
    also tried to talk me into letting him invent the guitar, write
    "strange, mesmerizing tunes" (rock music) and become famous,
    which would be "just roleplay" but would also improve everyone's
    reactions to his rude character.

    The worst thing is that he recently accused me of cheating.
    According to him, he was shooting at the dragon's wings and thus
    should have downed it. He heavily implied that I had cheated,
    then deleted all the messages because "it looked like we were
    arguing" to cover his tracks. This tells me that he does have
    deceptive tendencies and makes it more likely that he
    deliberately lied to me about Quintus' stats.

    I guess I have to tell him to stop programming the new players
    with this "trashcan stats" nonsense. One of them is new to the
    game and might actually think his character is bad. I don't like
    this at all. I don't care for the modern idea that the DM is
    supposed to be the adult of the table. We're all supposed to be
    adults.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Spalls Hurgenson@spallshurgenson@gmail.com to rec.games.frp.dnd on Fri Oct 30 22:52:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 07:33:54 -0400, The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:

    I apologize in advance for the length.

    I onboarded two new players to my game, making four. They both
    rolled reasonable characters, a magic-user and a ranger. Both had
    solid stats with prime requisites of 15 and other decent numbers.
    I use an extremely generous method of character creation, so this
    was no surprise.

    My munchkin apparently cornered them in the parking lot to tell
    them their characters sucked. He texted me to complain that they
    hated their weak, terrible, underpowered characters and he was
    worried new people wouldn't advocate hard enough for themselves
    and he was afraid they would quit. I pointed out that the new
    characters were fine, and he insisted that they had to have stat
    bonuses or else I was letting them play "weak" characters, which
    he would never do.

    This player has two characters, one with two 18s and one with one
    18, as well as other very high rolls. The other established
    player also has two characters with 18s. I accepted this without
    question because I use a generous creation method, but at this
    point I sat down and did some math. Even with my generous method,
    the odds of those four characters emerging are about one in 17
    million.

    I gently pointed this out. It came out that both he and his
    brother felt free to reroll without consulting me. Even with
    acknowledged rerolling, their odds of those characters still work
    out to about one in a thousand.

    Something hinky is going on. I asked that player for his primary
    character's stats and was told the dex was 16. I've heard "My dex
    is 18" from him at least twice, to justify automatically having
    some proficiency he'd never learned.

    I guess I need a policy that new characters are rolled in front
    of me. That seems too authoritarian. We're supposed to be friends
    having fun together. I guess I also need my own copy of character
    sheets, or at least of their stats and basic derived features
    like hit points. I don't like that at all.

    Maybe he just made a mistake. It's been several weeks since he
    claimed to have a dex of 18. I'd rather believe he's a munchkin
    who made a mistake on his stats and assumed rerolling privileges
    than believe he is deliberately cheating. Either way, it's
    becoming a real pain in the neck, and I don't like this business
    of complaining that the new characters are "garbage covered in
    shit" because they're not superhuman.

    I messaged the two new players to ask if they had fun, just in
    case they really did hate their "weak" characters and want to
    quit. One said he had a great time and is planning to return. The
    other hasn't responded yet.

    I don't want a game of superpowered superheroes striding easily
    through pseudochallenges and having treasure thrown at them from
    all directions. That's not D&D. That's not even a game any more,
    just narcissistic daydreaming. We can imagine ourselves as gods
    without the bother of rolling all those dice; the dice aren't
    supposed to roll 20 every time.

    This same player has other problems. One harmless but annoying
    trait is announcing "nat 20" or "crit" when he rolls a 20. This
    roll has no special magic at my table, but he wants it to mean a
    critical hit for extra damage, so he keeps announcing it that
    way. Another annoying trait is that he constantly wants to retool
    his character to be more powerful -- he started as a magic-
    user/assassin and converted to a paladin/assassin, and that was
    just the start. He wanted to have a special power of turning
    invisible, and when I said no to that, he wanted a special power
    of stealing life force in combat while his eyes glowed. He said
    he was "thinking of" trading some intelligence points for more
    strength, as if that were just a thing he could decide to do. He
    also tried to talk me into letting him invent the guitar, write
    "strange, mesmerizing tunes" (rock music) and become famous,
    which would be "just roleplay" but would also improve everyone's
    reactions to his rude character.

    The worst thing is that he recently accused me of cheating.
    According to him, he was shooting at the dragon's wings and thus
    should have downed it. He heavily implied that I had cheated,
    then deleted all the messages because "it looked like we were
    arguing" to cover his tracks. This tells me that he does have
    deceptive tendencies and makes it more likely that he
    deliberately lied to me about Quintus' stats.

    I guess I have to tell him to stop programming the new players
    with this "trashcan stats" nonsense. One of them is new to the
    game and might actually think his character is bad. I don't like
    this at all. I don't care for the modern idea that the DM is
    supposed to be the adult of the table. We're all supposed to be
    adults.


    People play D&D for different reasons. Some like the 'competition' of
    'beating' the DM at the game (whether honestly or otherwise). Others
    like figuring out all the tricks and loopholes to min-max their
    characters. Some enjoy the power-fantasy of being a super-powered hero
    who can easily stride through any obstacle. A few like to play a
    character who is the 'main character' that other PCs look up to and
    follow (another sort of power-fantasy, I suppose). I hesitate to say
    any of these are wrong ways to play, especially if he and othes in the
    group are having fun. The problem comes up when you have players with distinctly different types of ideas of what the game is about.

    Min-maxers/munchkins were never that much of a problem for me,
    although mostly because we just didn't have that many players who went
    for that style in our group (or, if they did, they recognized their incompatibility with the rest of our 'core' group and left quickly
    because they weren't having fun).

    But also, I don't think their tricks would work well against me. It's
    /never/ been stats or knowledge of the rules that have been the key to
    success in my adventures. My style of DMing is... well, I'll be
    honest: adventures in my campaigns can be grueling. Your PC will be
    put through the wringer. Magic is rare, NPCs are distrustful, and
    monsters are clever. A party's success is more often than not their
    ability to observe, think, work together, and convince allies to help
    them... and rarely will I let a simple attribute-check be the end-all
    of deciding if any of that happens. So that PC with 18 in all stats
    isn't going to have all that much more advantage over the rest. And
    like all vengeful gods, the proudest characters often attract the most
    wrathful punishments... so the player who thinks they're the Main
    Character of the group usually gets the brunt of my cruelty while the
    more humble gets my pity and assistance ;-)

    (I'm really not that mean as a DM... but the more a player has to
    lose, the less reluctant I'll be about taking stuff from them. And a
    character with extra-high stats is just /asking/ to be visited by an attribute-draining monster ;-)

    I did have a few players who were... let's say extra-creative about
    what their stats were. Which is why I often kept copies of their PC
    sheets (or at least, their more important stats) available to me. Not
    just them, of course; I did it for all the players. But it was because
    of the cheaters that I made sure to know what those stats were, and
    with them I often reinforced the idea that I KNEW what those stats
    were. "Oh, time for a STR check; let's see, you have a strength of 15
    so you need to roll under that..."

    #

    TL;DR: make the proud less proud by taking away their toys, and guide
    the others to your way of thinking by rewarding them for role-playing
    rather roll-playing. If that's the way you want the game to go, that
    is.

    #

    For another example, read up on Tucker's Kobolds (google it if you're unfamiliar). I've never gone quite so far, but it's a good example of
    teaching players that think they have stats and rules on their side
    that they ain't got nothin' on a well-prepared DM.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sat Oct 31 06:42:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article <n8kaelpaid0hubmgu2triqkcs6gu8g2h10@4ax.com>:
    But also, I don't think their tricks would work well against me. It's
    /never/ been stats or knowledge of the rules that have been the key to success in my adventures. My style of DMing is... well, I'll be
    honest: adventures in my campaigns can be grueling. Your PC will be
    put through the wringer. Magic is rare, NPCs are distrustful, and
    monsters are clever.

    This is similar to my initial goal. I've started handing out more
    treasure to cut down on the complaining, but overall, I want to
    play some actual D&D. You *make* your character successful and
    powerful and important.

    The NPCs aren't all going to treat you as the main character just
    because you've arrived. That's something I think the party failed
    to understand about the OS. They were acting demanding and
    entitled to the lords of the city.

    The other day, I saw someone comment that many D&D players don't
    actually like D&D. I think there's something to it.

    I've noticed that modern D&D doesn't provide the occasional
    moments of real wonder that the OSR does. When I'm roleplaying a
    stripling girl from a humble farming hamlet, my first sight of a
    gnome village or dwarven mine will amaze me. If I come from a
    multiracial city and have several special abilities and also
    carry around a curse and/or a destiny, those places are just some
    places.


    A party's success is more often than not their
    ability to observe, think, work together, and convince allies to help
    them... and rarely will I let a simple attribute-check be the end-all
    of deciding if any of that happens. So that PC with 18 in all stats
    isn't going to have all that much more advantage over the rest. And
    like all vengeful gods, the proudest characters often attract the most wrathful punishments... so the player who thinks they're the Main
    Character of the group usually gets the brunt of my cruelty while the
    more humble gets my pity and assistance ;-)

    My munchkin doesn't seem to want to outshine the others exactly.
    I think he wants to stroll through the wilderness, stabbing
    monsters and vacuuming treasure, while the NPCs shower him with
    rewards and praise.

    I think things might have gone better if I'd known that at the
    beginning. I would have chosen some "save the frightened
    villagers from the ooky thing" adventure, and I would have made
    it short enough that rewards came quickly.

    Today's D&D day. I hope it goes well. I had very little sleep
    last night, but I'll do my best and hope everyone has a good
    time.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Arnaud Gomes@arnaud+rgfd@carrosse.frmug.org to alt.games.adnd,rec.games.frp.dnd on Sat Oct 31 13:14:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> writes:

    My munchkin apparently cornered them in the parking lot to tell
    them their characters sucked. He texted me to complain that they
    hated their weak, terrible, underpowered characters and he was
    worried new people wouldn't advocate hard enough for themselves
    .../...
    I gently pointed this out. It came out that both he and his
    brother felt free to reroll without consulting me. Even with
    .../...
    just the start. He wanted to have a special power of turning
    invisible, and when I said no to that, he wanted a special power
    of stealing life force in combat while his eyes glowed. He said
    he was "thinking of" trading some intelligence points for more
    strength, as if that were just a thing he could decide to do. He
    .../....
    The worst thing is that he recently accused me of cheating.
    According to him, he was shooting at the dragon's wings and thus
    should have downed it. He heavily implied that I had cheated,
    then deleted all the messages because "it looked like we were

    Sorry to be blunt, but this guy is toxic. Get rid of him.
    --
    Arnaud
    https://the-dm.oook.fr/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to alt.games.adnd,rec.games.frp.dnd on Sat Oct 31 11:36:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    Arnaud Gomes wrote in article <874ie2dq3f.fsf@moka.glou.org>:
    Sorry to be blunt, but this guy is toxic. Get rid of him.


    I'm afraid you're right. I'm pretty done with his crap, and I'll
    probably tell him not to come back the next time he pulls
    something major.

    His brother will probably leave out of loyalty. He griped that he
    was getting frustrated by some of the situation, but he'll
    probably choose blood in the end. I guess I'll just live with it.
    Maybe I can train up the new guy to be an actual D&D player.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alex Schroeder@alex@alexschroeder.ch to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sat Oct 31 17:07:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comnospam> wrote:
    Arnaud Gomes wrote in article <874ie2dq3f.fsf@moka.glou.org>:
    Sorry to be blunt, but this guy is toxic. Get rid of him.

    I'm afraid you're right. I'm pretty done with his crap, and I'll
    probably tell him not to come back the next time he pulls
    something major.

    His brother will probably leave out of loyalty. He griped that he
    was getting frustrated by some of the situation, but he'll
    probably choose blood in the end. I guess I'll just live with it.
    Maybe I can train up the new guy to be an actual D&D player.

    I agree. I think you need to tell this player to find a new group.

    This would be the kind of player that would make me want to leave.
    And you know how it is: if you don't make the aggravating players
    leave, then the nice players leave and you're left with a table
    full of aggravating ones.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Spalls Hurgenson@spallshurgenson@gmail.com to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sat Oct 31 20:44:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:36:23 -0400, The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:

    Arnaud Gomes wrote in article <874ie2dq3f.fsf@moka.glou.org>:
    Sorry to be blunt, but this guy is toxic. Get rid of him.


    I'm afraid you're right. I'm pretty done with his crap, and I'll
    probably tell him not to come back the next time he pulls
    something major.

    His brother will probably leave out of loyalty. He griped that he
    was getting frustrated by some of the situation, but he'll
    probably choose blood in the end. I guess I'll just live with it.
    Maybe I can train up the new guy to be an actual D&D player.


    I wouldn't be quite so blunt but I do agree that increasingly it
    sounds like this person's preferred method of gameplay is incompatible
    with yours. As I said in an earlier thread, you have to look at what
    you want from the game (and what the others want from the game) and
    decide if he's still a good fit. And then you have to make a hard
    choice about what to do.

    I'm still tempted to say the player can be potentially salvaged,* and
    my preferred method is to 'break' the character (see earlier post on
    some ideas on how to do that). It's a risky method, though; such a
    hard-assed technique can put off the other players too. But usually
    one of two things will happen: either the player will learn to play in
    a different way, or they will stop having fun and leave. But it's
    often a hard, argumentative method and often asking the player to
    leave is the easier (sometimes safer) alternative.

    Asking a player to leave is always difficult (well, unless they are
    truly loathsome, and it doesn't seem like this player is that). Even
    though other players may, ultimately, agree with your decision, rarely
    do they speak out in support of you, and it often feels --to both
    yourself and perhaps to the others-- as if you are being unfairly mean
    and selfish. But from what you've told us, you've discussed things
    with the player before, so it's not as if this is coming out of left
    field. Just try to remain calm and rational, and keep it as short as
    possible.

    It's especially hard to ask a player to leave if you have a small
    group and that player has a relationship with the others; the loss of
    the one can lead to the defection of others.

    Still, sometimes asking the player to leave is the only reasonable
    thing to do. You can't salvage everybody and ultimately --even if as
    DM it's a huge part of your job ensuring that your players have a good
    time-- you too should be enjoying the experience as well. So sometimes
    you just have to grit your teeth and do the hard thing.

    I'm sorry, though, that you have to face these problems (what seems to
    be so) early into you DMing career. But think of it as a useful
    learning experience, not only for gaming but life. ;-)









    * I can't help it; I was infected with the ideals of Randy Pausch's
    "Last Lecture" and helping others enable their own goals. Admittedly,
    my recommended methodology differs from Pausch's though




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sun Nov 1 14:51:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    Alex Schroeder wrote in article <11c577r$378du$1 @paraelectrobombus.campaignwiki>:
    I agree. I think you need to tell this player to find a new group.

    This would be the kind of player that would make me want to leave.
    And you know how it is: if you don't make the aggravating players
    leave, then the nice players leave and you're left with a table
    full of aggravating ones.


    I will if there's another major problem, but everything's calm at
    the moment.

    Neither of the two players who left were bad people.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sun Nov 1 14:59:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article <jo0deldd1g5qseluv6718kh762u2se6m5v@4ax.com>:
    I'm still tempted to say the player can be potentially salvaged,* and
    my preferred method is to 'break' the character (see earlier post on
    some ideas on how to do that). It's a risky method, though; such a
    hard-assed technique can put off the other players too.

    I got a message from him in which he apologized and mentioned a
    serious personal trauma which probably relates. He volunteered
    that there was nothing really wrong with the other players'
    characters. I like the guy, despite everything. I will keep
    working with him for now.

    I offered him a one-player one-shot in which he is a huge,
    ancient red dragon taking out humans who come for his hoard. It
    doesn't get much more overpowered than that. He loves the idea,
    and it sounds like a fun way to spend a few hours. It'll give him
    a chance to have the kind of experience he's seeking, without
    blemish for the main campaign.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alex Schroeder@alex@alexschroeder.ch to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sun Nov 1 20:29:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comnospam> wrote:
    I offered him a one-player one-shot in which he is a huge,
    ancient red dragon taking out humans who come for his hoard. It
    doesn't get much more overpowered than that. He loves the idea,
    and it sounds like a fun way to spend a few hours. It'll give him
    a chance to have the kind of experience he's seeking, without
    blemish for the main campaign.

    You are a more gracious referee than I am.

    *meme of somebody bowing respectfully*

    Good luck and it hope it all goes well.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Spalls Hurgenson@spallshurgenson@gmail.com to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sun Nov 1 17:31:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 20:29:05 -0000 (UTC), Alex Schroeder
    <alex@alexschroeder.ch> said this thing:

    The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comnospam> wrote:
    I offered him a one-player one-shot in which he is a huge,
    ancient red dragon taking out humans who come for his hoard. It
    doesn't get much more overpowered than that. He loves the idea,
    and it sounds like a fun way to spend a few hours. It'll give him
    a chance to have the kind of experience he's seeking, without
    blemish for the main campaign.

    You are a more gracious referee than I am.

    *meme of somebody bowing respectfully*

    Good luck and it hope it all goes well.


    I'm not entirely against the idea. Another thing to do would be to
    offer to let HIM 'master a game for the others (and yourself). Not
    only does it let him see the other side of things, but it may give you
    a better idea of what he sees as important in the game.

    But you may just be postponing the inevitable (which I totally get the
    impulse to do). It's not that the player is a bad person, or trying to
    be troublesome, but their idea of fun differs from yours (and,
    possibly, the others). And as earnest as their promises to change may
    be, it's probably an innate and irreconcilable difference.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2