• Munchkins

    From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to alt.games.adnd,rec.games.frp.dnd on Wed Sep 30 09:32:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    My munchkin player is at it again. At setup, he created a
    ridiculously dramatic backstory and successfully talked me into
    trading some charisma points for ambidexterity. Since then, he
    retooled his character into a paladin and gave himself dice which
    can read people's souls (I didn't realize he thought the dice
    were that powerful). He insists that this god wears a Gucci suit,
    though I've said no to the anachronism.

    Most recently, he wanted to invent the guitar and introduce
    "strange, entrancing tunes." Essentially, he wanted to invent
    rock-n-roll and become a medieval Elvis, hoping that fame would
    offset the charisma hit he chose. Um, no? I have told him that he
    can seek work as a bard, but he'll be using a lute or zither and
    should look into folk music.

    I like the guy overall. He's a good player. His creative ideas
    often liven things up. I just wish he could get the hang of being
    a regular guy in this world.

    IMO that's one of the main differences between 1e and 5e. In 5e,
    we start exceptional. In 1e, we start out as ordinary people and
    try to become exceptional.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Spalls Hurgenson@spallshurgenson@gmail.com to rec.games.frp.dnd on Wed Sep 30 13:23:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    On Wed, 30 Sep 2026 09:32:56 -0400, The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:

    My munchkin player is at it again. At setup, he created a
    ridiculously dramatic backstory and successfully talked me into
    trading some charisma points for ambidexterity. Since then, he
    retooled his character into a paladin and gave himself dice which
    can read people's souls (I didn't realize he thought the dice
    were that powerful). He insists that this god wears a Gucci suit,
    though I've said no to the anachronism.


    Yeah, you definitely have to put your foot down on his trying to
    roleplay his character's deity. He can say what he BELIEVES his god is
    like but ultimately the DM is in control of that sort of thing.

    It does introduce some fun role-playing opportunities, where the PC
    says "this is what my god looks like" and either the god itself (or
    the church) smacks him down for his heresy. Similarly, he might
    BELIEVE his dice have these all-seeing powers, but it's all just in
    his head. Let him roll the dice, tell people "This man has a dark
    stain on his soul" and be found out to be a fraud. It makes for some
    great storytelling opportunities, and he either learns from it... or
    not.

    But definitely you need to take the player aside and (re-) explain to
    him that he controls his character and his character alone. The
    effects of magical items, gods, and whatever else he thinks he has
    influence over are actually in the purview of the DM. Just so he
    understands ahead of time that you aren't 'changing the deal' on him
    unfairly; that's just how the game works.


    Most recently, he wanted to invent the guitar and introduce
    "strange, entrancing tunes." Essentially, he wanted to invent
    rock-n-roll and become a medieval Elvis, hoping that fame would
    offset the charisma hit he chose. Um, no? I have told him that he
    can seek work as a bard, but he'll be using a lute or zither and
    should look into folk music.


    I always hesitate to say to players that they can't do something. I
    just put realistic obstacles in their way (and maybe give them some
    warning about possible consequences). Your PC thinks he can fly? Let
    them leap off a cliff, flap their arms and see what happens. Who
    knows; maybe they're right and they'll soar into the atmosphere! I
    wouldn't bet on it, but I won't tell them they can't try. ;-)

    So the player wants his character to invent the guitar? Let him try.
    But creating a new instrument isn't easy. Does he have carpentry or
    musical skills? Is he spending the months and years to experiment and
    build? Researching and buying special materials for strings and frame?
    No? Then he's gonna end up with something akin to a rubber-band
    strapped to a popsicle stick.

    And just because he introduces a new style of music and dancing,
    doesn't mean any of the NPCs will care for it. Elvis was castigated
    for his 'wanton' gyrations and 'uncivilized' rhythms even in the
    1950s. A thousand years earlier he might have been burned at the
    stake. All the moreso since the lack of mass communication in the
    medieval era means your Paladin's new ideas won't be comminicated far,
    so he'll have to re-fight the same battles over and over to get his
    musical stylings accepted in every single town and hamlet.

    So let the Paladin try. It might work out the way he wants; it
    probably won't. Either way, it'll be fun to see what happens.


    IMO that's one of the main differences between 1e and 5e. In 5e,
    we start exceptional. In 1e, we start out as ordinary people and
    try to become exceptional.


    I often describe the difference between the systems as playing heroes
    vs. super-heroes but your description is catchier. ;-)



    <Digression mode=on>

    The thing is, I don't think 3E (and later) intended to be like that.
    It's just that --by making every possible option a learnable skill
    with fixed rules and benefits-- that was the result.

    I often point to "Bulls Rush" as an example. It used to be that if a
    player wanted their character to rush into battle, it was up to the DM
    to determine the outcome: the penalties/bonuses, how the monsters are
    affected, etc. Nothing was fixed and any character could do stuff like
    that at any time. But when "Bulls Rush" became a learnable skill, it
    became a 'power' that made the PCs seem exceptional in comparison to
    other characters. It -and similar skills- led to a feeling of
    continual power creep.

    Again, I don't think that was the idea when WOTC redesigned the game
    for 3E and later. I think they just wanted to standardize the rules
    and put more ideas into the hands of players (especially with combat,
    which too many DMs let devolve into opposing lines of foes just
    whacking at one another until HP reached zero). The new skills, I
    think, were made to enliven the game (and combat specifically).

    But they also turned the PCs into superheroes.


    </digression>


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to rec.games.frp.dnd on Wed Sep 30 15:20:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article <cnfqbldcdji6vo9ht54fqh71fl1d72052m@4ax.com>:
    But definitely you need to take the player aside and (re-) explain to
    him that he controls his character and his character alone. The
    effects of magical items, gods, and whatever else he thinks he has
    influence over are actually in the purview of the DM. Just so he
    understands ahead of time that you aren't 'changing the deal' on him unfairly; that's just how the game works.

    Yeah, I think that's the path forward. In particular, we need to
    get clear on the holy dice. Yes, they are sacred to that deity.
    No, other characters won't automatically believe you're a deity's
    chosen one, believe the dice are from the deity, believe you
    always interpret them correctly, rank that deity above their own
    chosen deity, and treat that one deity's pronouncements as
    overriding their own morals and ethics. If you kill people you
    promised you'd release safely, people will disapprove whether you
    mention the dice or not.

    The part that weirded me out a little was that both he and his
    brother (playing his character's brother) seemed genuinely
    confused by other characters not just accepting "but dice" as a
    reason to ignore the law and normal ethics/morality.

    The medieval Elvis thing was out of left field. At the same time,
    he also wanted to trade some intelligence points for more
    strength points. The next time he asks for a major upgrade, I
    think I'll say that since he constantly wants to retool this
    character, he might be happier refocusing on his other character.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Arnaud Gomes@arnaud+rgfd@carrosse.frmug.org to rec.games.frp.dnd on Wed Sep 30 22:40:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> writes:

    The medieval Elvis thing was out of left field. At the same time,
    he also wanted to trade some intelligence points for more
    strength points. The next time he asks for a major upgrade, I
    think I'll say that since he constantly wants to retool this
    character, he might be happier refocusing on his other character.

    Well, this one is easy: if he wants to play a different character, let
    him create another and play the character from level 1. Nobody said he
    was stuck with his initial choice forever.

    Actually this is one area 5e is not too bad at, at least for the lower
    levels, say up to level 6 to 8; if you handle experience by the book and
    the current characters are not above this level range, his new character
    will catch up reasonably fast and stay at most 1 or 2 levels below, so
    not an unreasonable difference.
    --
    Arnaud
    https://the-dm.oook.fr/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Spalls Hurgenson@spallshurgenson@gmail.com to rec.games.frp.dnd on Thu Oct 1 13:29:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    On Wed, 30 Sep 2026 22:40:35 +0200, Arnaud Gomes <arnaud+rgfd@carrosse.frmug.org> said this thing:

    The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> writes:

    The medieval Elvis thing was out of left field. At the same time,
    he also wanted to trade some intelligence points for more
    strength points. The next time he asks for a major upgrade, I
    think I'll say that since he constantly wants to retool this
    character, he might be happier refocusing on his other character.

    Well, this one is easy: if he wants to play a different character, let
    him create another and play the character from level 1. Nobody said he
    was stuck with his initial choice forever.


    You know, I can't recall if I ever let a player respec his character after-the-fact. During character creation I was fairly lenient (4d6,
    drop the worst, assign where you will, then argue with the DM why
    maybe you should have a +1 here or there to better match your vision
    of what the character was). But once the player was actually in use,
    you just used those stats.

    To be sure, if a player was truly unhappy with their character, I'd
    allow them to create a new one (and usually make it close to the same
    level as the PC they were retiring). Although that was as much for the
    benefit of the other players; adding a 1st level PC to a group of 6th
    level heroes makes things harder on the group.

    Not to say the other way is wrong --whatever works best for your
    campaign and players-- but it just never *occured* to me to even
    consider allowing a mid-game respec.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to rec.games.frp.dnd on Thu Oct 1 15:44:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article <lb5tbl1b1n8euud66k5v8qaoa7qmnek2o3@4ax.com>:

    On Wed, 30 Sep 2026 22:40:35 +0200, Arnaud Gomes <arnaud+rgfd@carrosse.frmug.org> said this thing:

    The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> writes:

    Well, this one is easy: if he wants to play a different
    character, let
    him create another and play the character from level 1. Nobody said he
    was stuck with his initial choice forever.

    Yeah, I don't like how this character has turned into the main
    character of the campaign. Other players left over it. If I had
    it to do over, I'd handle that differently.


    You know, I can't recall if I ever let a player respec his character after-the-fact. During character creation I was fairly lenient (4d6,
    drop the worst, assign where you will, then argue with the DM why
    maybe you should have a +1 here or there to better match your vision
    of what the character was). But once the player was actually in use,
    you just used those stats.

    I never have so far. I let him trade charisma points for
    ambidexterity during creation, but I'm saying no to trading
    intelligence for strength.

    Reclassing is built into the game, so I figure it should
    generally be allowed. I'm not liking the neutral paladin thing
    now that I've seen it in action, though.


    To be sure, if a player was truly unhappy with their character, I'd
    allow them to create a new one (and usually make it close to the same
    level as the PC they were retiring). Although that was as much for the benefit of the other players; adding a 1st level PC to a group of 6th
    level heroes makes things harder on the group.

    Ages ago, my character died at 7th level or so, and I had to roll
    back in at 1st level. I wanted my new character's background to
    be minor nobility, and the DM suggested we go big and make me a
    princess.

    This worked out well for roleplaying. I thought I was incognito,
    but the rest of the party had been warned that I'd better come
    back alive or else, so they had to babysit me. I genuinely
    believed I was pulling my weight, leading me to take risks more
    appropriate to the other characters. It was the only way my 1st-
    level self could have survived, and it also let the DM pile on
    some extra rewards at the end.

    We were exiting that campaign anyway, so there were no worries
    about future repercussions. It was a lot of fun.


    Not to say the other way is wrong --whatever works best for your
    campaign and players-- but it just never *occured* to me to even
    consider allowing a mid-game respec.

    I've never had a player request such a thing before. I do want my
    players to enjoy the game, of course, and I thought the neutral
    paladin was worth a try, but it's not going well for me. I'm
    hoping to onboard a couple of new players, so I can't let this
    one dominate the game.

    I like the guy overall, though, and he does take no for an answer
    after several repetitions. I won't boot him unless his desire for
    the spotlight starts to outweigh the liveliness and creativity he
    brings to the table.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Spalls Hurgenson@spallshurgenson@gmail.com to rec.games.frp.dnd on Fri Oct 2 13:13:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    On Thu, 1 Oct 2026 15:44:45 -0400, The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:
    Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article ><lb5tbl1b1n8euud66k5v8qaoa7qmnek2o3@4ax.com>:
    On Wed, 30 Sep 2026 22:40:35 +0200, Arnaud Gomes
    <arnaud+rgfd@carrosse.frmug.org> said this thing:


    Well, this one is easy: if he wants to play a different
    character, let
    him create another and play the character from level 1. Nobody said he
    was stuck with his initial choice forever.


    Yeah, I don't like how this character has turned into the main
    character of the campaign. Other players left over it. If I had
    it to do over, I'd handle that differently.


    Yeah, it sounds like you're in a bit of a pickle. My first instinct is
    simply to say, "ask him to leave," but of course it's never that easy.
    But it does sound like there's a mismatch between what player
    expectations; what this player wants out of the game and what you (and
    at least some of the other players) want from it. And that can often
    be disastrous to a campaign and gaming group.

    You need to start asking the hard questions: is this player good for
    the group? How many other players agree with his play-style? If I ask
    him to leave, will this cause more harm (cause more people to leave)
    than if he stays? How will this effect our (outside-the-game)
    interpersonal relations? And what do I personally want from the game?

    If you decide that the bulk of the (remaining) party are happy (or at
    least not too unhappy) with his gaming style, then it may be that YOU
    are the problem, and either need to step down as DM, leave the group,
    or adjust your own expectations. It's not that you're in the wrong,
    but (IMHO) there needs to be a general consensus in what sort of game
    you are all playing, and sometimes we have to realize we're the ones
    out of sorts with the particular group and we're the ones who have to
    make the sacrifice.

    But more likely, it's the player who is at fault, and you have to
    figure out how to deal with it. From everything you've said before, it
    doesn't seem like he's trying to be obnoxious and is, in fact, trying
    to become a better fit for the group, which only makes it harder.

    I don't envy you your position. I've been there and it can be really
    hard knowing what to do. You don't necessarily need to do something immediately, but you do need to start considering your options.

    Me, I'd still try to redeem the player. They think they're the main
    hero? I'd knock 'em down a peg or three. Start taking away the
    crutches that they think make them special. Paladins are especially
    vulnerable to this, since they are so heavily dependent on the favor
    of their god. Start sending him warnings, perhaps in the form of
    dreams, or scoldings from the church's hierarchy, that his behavior is untenable (and put an immediate stop to the player telling you, the
    DM, what his character's god would or wouldn't do). His precious dice
    need to be nerfed (and if he pushes, have them go up in a puff of
    smoke because God is just that upset with his behavior). Start putting
    him in situations where his skill-set isn't that useful, and the
    restrictions on his behavior start causing problems. Get him to depend
    more on the other PCs to get him out of jams. Humility is one of the
    primary virtues of the paladin class, after all.

    You don't have to be a dick about it. Just run an adventure where his
    character can't dominate the action. Something where combat and magic
    aren't emphasised, and his contacts with church hierarchy aren't
    useful. Meanwhile, other characters can take up the slack.

    It's not only a learning experience, but it can open up the player's
    eyes as to how teamwork can be fun. Even if he does maybe spend half
    the adventure in a jail-cell waiting for the rest of the party to
    deliver the thief to unlock his shackles ;-)



    Ages ago, my character died at 7th level or so, and I had to roll
    back in at 1st level. I wanted my new character's background to
    be minor nobility, and the DM suggested we go big and make me a
    princess.

    This worked out well for roleplaying. I thought I was incognito,
    but the rest of the party had been warned that I'd better come
    back alive or else, so they had to babysit me. I genuinely
    believed I was pulling my weight, leading me to take risks more
    appropriate to the other characters. It was the only way my 1st-
    level self could have survived, and it also let the DM pile on
    some extra rewards at the end.

    We were exiting that campaign anyway, so there were no worries
    about future repercussions. It was a lot of fun.


    Sounds fun! I love that you yourself, as player, were as much in the
    dark as the character herself (at least for some of the adventure).
    That's some great role-playing from the other players.

    It's a shame your campaign ended. I'd have loved to hear about the arc
    of that princess character through further adventures.


    I've never had a player request such a thing before. I do want my
    players to enjoy the game, of course, and I thought the neutral
    paladin was worth a try, but it's not going well for me. I'm
    hoping to onboard a couple of new players, so I can't let this
    one dominate the game.


    I've no real issue with neutral paladins. But I've always played it
    that paladins need to epitomize the ethos of their god, and if they
    stray from that path, they suffer from that betrayal. At first it's
    warnings, then its loss of some (or all) their powers. Paladin
    characters are granted many abilities above and beyond the regular
    character; the cost of those powers is that they need to roleplay.

    True-neutral is hard to roleplay though. It too often is used as an
    excuse to "just do anything I want, good or evil, because it all evens
    out in the end". I try to discourage players from choosing that
    alignment, but if they do pick true neutral I keep close track of
    their actions (down to the point of counting good vs evil actions) and
    if that ratio strays too far, they're not true neutral anymore. This
    is not an issue for most characters; alignment is usually more of a
    suggestion in my campaigns. Usually if you shift alignment, it's just
    a mark on a paper and some of your erstwhile allies treating you
    different because 'you've changed, man!' But for characters tied to a
    Power (priests, paladins, maybe some mages), it is a real concern and
    can result in loss of abilities.

    But that's just how I do things. Other DMs may do it differently and
    that's cool too.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sat Oct 3 08:07:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article <ptnvbl1abo2cf9qbff0kioed3mgoc4ver8@4ax.com>:

    On Thu, 1 Oct 2026 15:44:45 -0400, The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> said this thing:
    Spalls Hurgenson wrote in article
    Yeah, it sounds like you're in a bit of a pickle. My first
    instinct is
    simply to say, "ask him to leave," but of course it's never that easy.
    But it does sound like there's a mismatch between what player
    expectations; what this player wants out of the game and what you (and
    at least some of the other players) want from it. And that can often
    be disastrous to a campaign and gaming group.

    You need to start asking the hard questions: is this player good for
    the group? How many other players agree with his play-style? If I ask
    him to leave, will this cause more harm (cause more people to leave)
    than if he stays? How will this effect our (outside-the-game)
    interpersonal relations? And what do I personally want from the game?

    Yeah, I think that's what I'm doing. Our third player had to be
    ejected for coming on to him. Since then, he and his brother are
    the only two players. I'm supposed to onboard two new people
    today. One is a newbie, but the other has played before. I plan
    to encourage them both to do plenty of roleplaying.

    I've told the two current players that I'm going to be
    downplaying the OTT stuff. There won't be any more pocket
    dimensions or personal god visits.


    But more likely, it's the player who is at fault, and you have
    to
    figure out how to deal with it. From everything you've said before, it doesn't seem like he's trying to be obnoxious and is, in fact, trying
    to become a better fit for the group, which only makes it harder.

    He can hear "no" after several repetitions. I do mostly like the
    guy overall, so I'll keep trying to work with him for now. My
    eyes are a little more open, though.


    Me, I'd still try to redeem the player. They think they're the main
    hero? I'd knock 'em down a peg or three. Start taking away the
    crutches that they think make them special. Paladins are especially vulnerable to this, since they are so heavily dependent on the favor
    of their god. Start sending him warnings, perhaps in the form of
    dreams, or scoldings from the church's hierarchy, that his behavior is untenable (and put an immediate stop to the player telling you, the
    DM, what his character's god would or wouldn't do). His precious dice
    need to be nerfed (and if he pushes, have them go up in a puff of
    smoke because God is just that upset with his behavior).

    I was thinking of turning them into blank cubes if he misuses
    them again.


    Start putting
    him in situations where his skill-set isn't that useful, and the
    restrictions on his behavior start causing problems. Get him to depend
    more on the other PCs to get him out of jams. Humility is one of the
    primary virtues of the paladin class, after all.

    Yes, that's a good idea. I'll come up with scenarios where
    neither of his two classes is useful -- heavy magic use, perhaps.

    I could also have a cleric succeed at turning him. That would
    happen mostly to the strongly aligned, though, so it could be
    misleading.


    You don't have to be a dick about it. Just run an adventure where his character can't dominate the action. Something where combat and magic
    aren't emphasised, and his contacts with church hierarchy aren't
    useful. Meanwhile, other characters can take up the slack.

    Heh, he has no church hierarchy. He was selected by the god
    somehow and put through thirty years of extradimensional trials,
    outside of normal time, while about half an our passed in our
    world.

    I didn't love that, but it was pitched both more mildly and as
    the character beginning to follow a code instead of just doing
    what he wants. The pitch wasn't that bad. In the pitch, deals and
    bargains are sacred, and any bargain made by or with an agent of
    Argomos must be honored or else. Turned out what he really had in
    mind was that others had to keep their word, but he could betray
    if he believed the other party deserved to be betrayed. The dice
    were used in this, and I should have had them go blank at that
    time.


    It's not only a learning experience, but it can open up the player's
    eyes as to how teamwork can be fun. Even if he does maybe spend half
    the adventure in a jail-cell waiting for the rest of the party to
    deliver the thief to unlock his shackles ;-)

    I hope that's not needed.


    I've no real issue with neutral paladins. But I've always
    played it
    that paladins need to epitomize the ethos of their god, and if they
    stray from that path, they suffer from that betrayal. At first it's
    warnings, then its loss of some (or all) their powers. Paladin
    characters are granted many abilities above and beyond the regular
    character; the cost of those powers is that they need to roleplay.

    Going forward, I will continue having NPCs respond appropriately,
    and if needed I'll send him a dream from Argomos.


    True-neutral is hard to roleplay though. It too often is used as an
    excuse to "just do anything I want, good or evil, because it all evens
    out in the end". I try to discourage players from choosing that
    alignment, but if they do pick true neutral I keep close track of
    their actions (down to the point of counting good vs evil actions) and
    if that ratio strays too far, they're not true neutral anymore. This
    is not an issue for most characters; alignment is usually more of a suggestion in my campaigns. Usually if you shift alignment, it's just
    a mark on a paper and some of your erstwhile allies treating you
    different because 'you've changed, man!' But for characters tied to a
    Power (priests, paladins, maybe some mages), it is a real concern and
    can result in loss of abilities.

    I liked the initial idea of being an agent of karma, dishing out
    good and bad. Unfortunately it didn't go that way, but the
    character has now decided that everyone should be given a chance
    at redemption, so the last few sessions have been better.

    I'm hoping the new people turn up and are good. Let's just play
    some D&D, FFS.
    --
    The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
    United States of America - North America - Earth
    Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
    Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2