Hello,
This is prompted by a comment in The True Melissa's recent post about deities.
Fellow DMs, when a player can't make it to a game, what do you do with
their characters?
I tried a few options. NPCing the character just doesn't work for me; I
have enough to handle already as a DM, adding an always-present NPC is
just too much, I will forget the character is even here half the
time. Letting another player run the character has part of the same
issue, plus the problem Melissa ran into: what happens when the fill-in player gets the character killed? Finally I opted to just let the
character fade into the background: when the player is absent, the
character is just not here, continuity be damned.
I tend to run a picaresque game, not one where the characters'
background matters much, so this works for me for D&D; I probably
wouldn't choose the same option in a character-centered game.
What about you and your games?
Hello,
This is prompted by a comment in The True Melissa's recent post about >deities.
Fellow DMs, when a player can't make it to a game, what do you do with
their characters?
I tried a few options. NPCing the character just doesn't work for me; I
have enough to handle already as a DM, adding an always-present NPC is
just too much, I will forget the character is even here half the
time. Letting another player run the character has part of the same
issue, plus the problem Melissa ran into: what happens when the fill-in >player gets the character killed? Finally I opted to just let the
character fade into the background: when the player is absent, the
character is just not here, continuity be damned.
I tend to run a picaresque game, not one where the characters'
background matters much, so this works for me for D&D; I probably
wouldn't choose the same option in a character-centered game.
What about you and your games?
I tried a few options. NPCing the character just doesn't work for me; I
have enough to handle already as a DM, adding an always-present NPC is
just too much, I will forget the character is even here half the
time. Letting another player run the character has part of the same
issue, plus the problem Melissa ran into: what happens when the fill-in player gets the character killed? Finally I opted to just let the
character fade into the background: when the player is absent, the
character is just not here, continuity be damned.
Arnaud Gomes wrote in article <8733v58okf.fsf@moka.glou.org>:
I tried a few options. NPCing the character just doesn't work for me; I
have enough to handle already as a DM, adding an always-present NPC is
just too much, I will forget the character is even here half the
time. Letting another player run the character has part of the same
issue, plus the problem Melissa ran into: what happens when the fill-in
player gets the character killed? Finally I opted to just let the
character fade into the background: when the player is absent, the
character is just not here, continuity be damned.
My players beg me not to play without them because everyone else
would be earning XP they won't get.
That never was too much of an issue with us, largely because I was
fairly loose with keeping track/ awarding XP. My general 'rule' was
level = # of adventures required to level-up. (I still awarded XP, but
in amounts that just happened to advance the group at the
aforementioned pace).
So long as you particpated in the bulk of the adventure, you were
usually assured of getting enough XP that you wouldn't fall too far
behind. And, anyway, we usually 'retired' PCs after 8 to 10 levels and replaced them with new ones. I'm of the general opinion that 1E/2E
works best within that level range anyway.
My players are third level, and they're already setting up an
outpost and a guild. One of them even sent me elaborate bylaws.
:D I think they have eight henchmen right now, as well as some
retainers on loan from the city, so a base of operations does
make sense.
On 9/21/2026 12:52 PM, The True Melissa wrote:
My players are third level, and they're already setting up an
outpost and a guild. One of them even sent me elaborate bylaws.
:D I think they have eight henchmen right now, as well as some
retainers on loan from the city, so a base of operations does
make sense.
Mine recently took over a village from some bandits and are trying to
build something there. So far they only have stationed some archers there.
What about you and your games?
On Sat, 19 Sep 2026 13:31:44 +0200, Arnaud Gomes <arnaud+rgfd@carrosse.frmug.org> said this thing:
What about you and your games?
As an aside:
It's not quite the same, but when one player left our group we had a
similar problem: what to do with his character? Just vanish him? Have
me (the DM) play him as an NPC? Have the PC suddenly find some reason
to not be there ("Oh, sorry, gotta go, I just remembered I left some
bacon frying on the hob"). What to do with the character? It didn't
help that the player left right in the middle of a dungeon crawl
either, so finding an excuse for him to no longer be involved with the adventure was sort of difficult.
So we put it up to a vote, and well... let's just say neither the
player nor his character were particularly well liked by the rest of
the group. So the results of the vote were not too surprising. I was instructed to play him as an NPC, and then further instructed to walk
him to his death at the next opportunity... a death that /may/ have
been *just a little bit* expedited by the other characters. If I
recall, he was used to trigger a trap the characters had a hard time
figuring a way around. I walked the PC into the room to 'investigate'
the trap, and the other players triggered the trap. Two problems
solved at once, and we never talked about that character again. ;-)
(All this despite the PC being the group's only healer and everyone
knew how much more difficult this would make the rest of the
adventure. But it was a sacrifice they were happy to make. The
character was /really/ obnoxious ;-)
It's not quite the same, but when one player left our group we had a
similar problem: what to do with his character?
As you say, not quite the same. This happened once with my current
group. The rest of the group did not know the player was leaving. The
player killed his character in a non-obvious way (walked into a weird transparent wall that happened to be a gelatinous cube) then created a
new one that he played only once; the character was revealed to be a
traitor at the end of the game. Both the player and I had a lot of fun
when the rest of the group understood. :-)
Arnaud Gomes wrote in article <87a4oig3sk.fsf@moka.glou.org>:
As you say, not quite the same. This happened once with my current
group. The rest of the group did not know the player was leaving. The
player killed his character in a non-obvious way (walked into a weird
transparent wall that happened to be a gelatinous cube) then created a
new one that he played only once; the character was revealed to be a
traitor at the end of the game. Both the player and I had a lot of fun
when the rest of the group understood. :-)
Oh, that sounds like tremendous fun. :-)
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 56:55:18 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,828 |