The group had a blowup last week. One of our members is an
assassin, true neutral with a dark streak, who resists the appeal
of evil with the support of his chaotic good twin brother. During
play, this character angrily killed a captive. Another member, a
chaotic good elf mage, was horrified and walked away from the
party, with the support of two others.
The branches re-merged when one had a random encounter shortly
afterward. The characters argued again, and somehow this became
the players arguing.
The mage player said that her character would be unwilling to
adventure with someone like that. Okay, fine. The assassin
offered to switch to a character less dark. The mage offered to
switch to a character less principled. There was talk of a party
code of conduct to which all would adhere. It seemed like
everything was being worked out, but then things flared up again.
The mage player thought the assassin player was taking up too
much space in the room.
Three of the players left the group. They joined together, so I
wasn't shocked that the other two left in support of her.
We four remain. We're going to let the group restabilize before
we take on any more people.
I've never seen that happen at D&D before.
They both took roleplaying seriously, but in different ways. He
saw it as a chance to be a very different person, while she saw
it as truly experiencing the scenario and so needing to apply
morality.
The assassin character, while definitely in the dark and edgy
category, isn't grimdark just to be grimdark. He has a backstory
that makes sense.
He did do a lot of the talking. I didn't realize anyone else was
unhappy.
The previous time, everyone seemed fine with each other. *shrug*
I would go where my heart leads me. I feel very strongly that the player characters are there to entertain us, the players. That's why I don't
care about backstory or alignment of player characters if they annoy
me, the player or DM. Unfortunately for all players of evil characters,
that usually means that I don't feel particularly entertained by evil characters doing evil things and whereas a player might argue that they
use role-playing games to explore different personalities and all that,
I would counter by saying that this is my entertainment and I'm not
offering therapy sessions. Their exploration of different personalities
still has to contribute to the entertainment of everybody else at the
table. I suspect that I'd follow the mage player.
Sadly, this isn't the first time I've seen something
like this happen. Here's an example from 2007: https://alexschroeder.ch/view/2007-09-10_It%e2%80%99s_called_%e2%80%9cEntertainment%e2%80%9d
In the example above, the ranger and monk player that had shouted
at each other left nice comments and it all looks like some sort of misunderstanding but I was shocked at what I had seen. I expect the
people sitting down at the same time as I to behave. Shouting at each
other is not acceptable conflict resolution for adults, not even as a
result of a misunderstanding.
Evil in a party of goods doesn't ever work, I've seen it time and time again. Even those on the border of evil (CN.) The only time I've seen
evil work was with a party of all evil, but I've also seen that not work.
On 8/20/2026 12:22 PM, The True Melissa wrote:
Evil in a party of goods doesn't ever work, I've seen it time and time >again. Even those on the border of evil (CN.) The only time I've seen
evil work was with a party of all evil, but I've also seen that not work.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 55:58:10 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,718 |