There's been a lot of material written for D&D in its various
iterations, both official and unofficial. Some of them have been
great, some of them have been terrible; most fall somewhere in
between. Of all the books you may have read for the game, which one do
you think is both well-written, useful and often overlooked?
On 13/04/2026 21.47, Spalls Hurgenson wrote:
There's been a lot of material written for D&D in its various
iterations, both official and unofficial. Some of them have been
great, some of them have been terrible; most fall somewhere in
between. Of all the books you may have read for the game, which one do
you think is both well-written, useful and often overlooked?
Never played D&D, always just AD&D, mainly 2.0, some 2.5. One that we
used to get more details regarding weapons we had "The Compendium of >Weapons, Armour & Castles" (ISBN: 0-916211-38-X), good source for
example for how different weapons were actually used.
There's been a lot of material written for D&D in its various
iterations, both official and unofficial. Some of them have been
great, some of them have been terrible; most fall somewhere in
between. Of all the books you may have read for the game, which one do
you think is both well-written, useful and often overlooked?
I've got three. You'll note all three are old-school TSR-era books,
but that's mostly because that's what I still use but that's not to
exclude more modern stuff (and I think even the old stuff I mention
may have some value to users of more recent editions)
#
For me, the one that immediately comes to mind is "REF3: Book of
Lairs" (TSR9177),
Next, the "Aurora's Whole Realms Catalogue". (TSR 9358) Not so muchThat was fun, but a little too useful in some regards. I rather like AC
for the writing but its pictures. Written as if it were a
fantasy-themed 'Sears Catalogue' sort of thing
What about you? What book do you think is something that isPrimal Order. Wonderful and fun book on a system of how to deal with
particularly memorable to you and probably would benefit others by
reading it, even if it may not be directly useful to a modern gamer?
Is it one of the classic rulebooks? An especially memorable adventure?
A reference guidebook? Some third-party campaign supplement? What
hidden gem do you think needs to be uncovered by more D&D gamers?
On 4/13/2026 12:47 PM, Spalls Hurgenson wrote:
For me, the one that immediately comes to mind is "REF3: Book of
Lairs" (TSR9177),
In much the same vein, 4e's Dungeon Delves is a collection of '5-room >dungeons' from 1 each from level 1-30 (equivilent to 1-20 since each
level was about .75 of a level elsewhere.) Admittedly not quite as
useful since no one plays 4e, but still easy enough to take and convert
to anything.
Next, the "Aurora's Whole Realms Catalogue". (TSR 9358) Not so muchThat was fun, but a little too useful in some regards. I rather like AC
for the writing but its pictures. Written as if it were a
fantasy-themed 'Sears Catalogue' sort of thing
4 The Book of Marvelous Magic, which has a bunch of rather silly magic >items, and isn't presented as something the PCs can just buy from.
What
hidden gem do you think needs to be uncovered by more D&D gamers?
Primal Order. Wonderful and fun book on a system of how to deal with
god's powers, possibly even playing gods.
There's been a lot of material written for D&D in its various
iterations, both official and unofficial. Some of them have been
great, some of them have been terrible; most fall somewhere in
between. Of all the books you may have read for the game, which one do
you think is both well-written, useful and often overlooked?
I've got three. You'll note all three are old-school TSR-era books,
but that's mostly because that's what I still use but that's not to
exclude more modern stuff (and I think even the old stuff I mention
may have some value to users of more recent editions)
#
For me, the one that immediately comes to mind is "REF3: Book of
Lairs" (TSR9177), a 1st Ed. AD&D supplement that included 60+ >mini-adventures, sorted by monster and terrain, that were intended to
be placed as encounters or side-quests during campaigns. Not all the >adventures were great or --at least for my campaigns-- useful but I
always found them to be great stepping-off points that helped me
create my own adventures. In fact, I only used a few of the encounters
in my own campaigns (and even then, not without major modifications).
But often when I was writing up an adventure and couldn't think up
what to do next, I'd pick one of the encounters from the book. I
wouldn't use it and rarely would even slip any of the ideas into my
own writings, but the book was great for getting me into the right
state of mind.
Next, the "Aurora's Whole Realms Catalogue". (TSR 9358) Not so much
for the writing but its pictures. Written as if it were a
fantasy-themed 'Sears Catalogue' sort of thing, it lists a bunch of
equipment that PCs might find useful in their adventures. Some of it
is absolutely silly and worthless but you can't imagine how many times
I've let players thumb through it and it spurred them onto some wild
ideas that made our campaigns more exciting and imaginative. (also, a
quick shout out to "DMGR3 Arms And Equipment Guide" for similar
reasons: it's great to have pictures of commonly used gear)
Finally, "DMGR1 Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide" (TSR 2112).
Not the entirety of the book, and it may not be something everyone
agrees with. But its early chapters on how to actually DM a game were >something I found inordinately useful when I first started a long-term >campaign. It gave me an idea of how to handle different players and
add life to my campaigns. Up until that point I was more or less
playing it all by ear; that book made me stop and think about how I
could improve my skills at a DM. I don't agree with everything it says
but in many ways it was the first time I had any real advice on how to
play itself beyond just being given a bunch of rules to adjudicate.
There are probably a lot better guides for that sort of thing these
days (and maybe even back in 1990 when it was first published) but it
was the first such book I had read, and as such it holds a special
place in my heart.
#
What about you? What book do you think is something that is
particularly memorable to you and probably would benefit others by
reading it, even if it may not be directly useful to a modern gamer?
Is it one of the classic rulebooks? An especially memorable adventure?
A reference guidebook? Some third-party campaign supplement? What
hidden gem do you think needs to be uncovered by more D&D gamers?
Justisaur <justisaur@yahoo.com> said this thing:
Primal Order. Wonderful and fun book on a system of how to deal with >>god's powers, possibly even playing gods.
I wasn't familiar with this one. Apparently it's a generic FRPG
supplement published by WOTC (back in 1992, before they owned D&D)
that helped DM role-play gods, whether as powers the PCs interact with
or if the PCs themselves achieve (or try to achieve) that sort of
prominence. In form, it reminds me a bit of the old RoleAids
supplements, although I suspect its probably better written.
On 4/13/2026 12:47 PM, Spalls Hurgenson wrote:
There's been a lot of material written for D&D in its various
iterations, both official and unofficial. Some of them have been
great, some of them have been terrible; most fall somewhere in
between. Of all the books you may have read for the game, which one do
you think is both well-written, useful and often overlooked?
I've got three. You'll note all three are old-school TSR-era books,
but that's mostly because that's what I still use but that's not to
exclude more modern stuff (and I think even the old stuff I mention
may have some value to users of more recent editions)
#
For me, the one that immediately comes to mind is "REF3: Book of
Lairs" (TSR9177),
In much the same vein, 4e's Dungeon Delves is a collection of '5-room dungeons' from 1 each from level 1-30 (equivilent to 1-20 since each
level was about .75 of a level elsewhere.) Admittedly not quite as
useful since no one plays 4e, but still easy enough to take and convert
to anything.
That was fun, but a little too useful in some regards. I rather like AC
Next, the "Aurora's Whole Realms Catalogue". (TSR 9358) Not so much
for the writing but its pictures. Written as if it were a
fantasy-themed 'Sears Catalogue' sort of thing
4 The Book of Marvelous Magic, which has a bunch of rather silly magic items, and isn't presented as something the PCs can just buy from.
Primal Order. Wonderful and fun book on a system of how to deal with
What about you? What book do you think is something that is
particularly memorable to you and probably would benefit others by
reading it, even if it may not be directly useful to a modern gamer?
Is it one of the classic rulebooks? An especially memorable adventure?
A reference guidebook? Some third-party campaign supplement? What
hidden gem do you think needs to be uncovered by more D&D gamers?
god's powers, possibly even playing gods.
I like your picks. I'd add:
* DMGR2: The Castle Guide. I really, really enjoyed reading through it,
back in the day;
* PHBR2: The Complete Thief's Handbook. I liked the guidelines for
putting together a thieves' guild based on the size of the city.
* PHBR3: The Complete Priest's Handbook. The sample faiths were useful.
I remember creating my own faiths by picking two or three of the
portfolios listed. It also drove home to me how kits aren't (or
shouldn't) be just a new set of bonuses but have a strong roleplaying
component.
On Wed, 09 Sep 2026 13:20:38 -0300, Punga
<punga!nospam!@great-atuin.net> said this thing:
I like your picks. I'd add:
* DMGR2: The Castle Guide. I really, really enjoyed reading through it,
back in the day;
I remember being quite disappointed by DMGR2 Castle Guide, largely
because it didn't give a lot of examples of actual castles. Especially
since it came out around the same time as Paladium's "Compendium of
Weapons, Armor & Castles", which had lots of pictures and diagrams
that could easily be transplanted into an existing campaign world.
* PHBR2: The Complete Thief's Handbook. I liked the guidelines for
putting together a thieves' guild based on the size of the city.
* PHBR3: The Complete Priest's Handbook. The sample faiths were useful.
I remember creating my own faiths by picking two or three of the
portfolios listed. It also drove home to me how kits aren't (or
shouldn't) be just a new set of bonuses but have a strong roleplaying
component.
The PHBR splat-books were really hit and miss in their quality. Even
within the book, some kits were really cool, and others much less so.
I was more impressed with PHBR1 Fighters Handbook, but mostly because
it had more use to our low-magic, non-evil campaign adventures which
limited the use of thieves, wizards and priests. But in general, while
I enjoyed a lot of the ideas in the PHBR series, I found them of less utility... especially since they were so bound to 2E rules anyway.
IMHO, YMMV, OOAEV, etc.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 57:20:36 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,926 |