• best fantasy worlds?

    From David Chmelik@dchmelik@gmail.com to rec.games.frp.dnd on Sun Oct 20 11:09:50 2024
    From Newsgroup: rec.games.frp.dnd

    An Advanced Dungeons & Dragons (AD&D) second edition (2nd ed., 2e) Dungeon Master (DM) whose game I was in (hadn't run play-by-email a while so had trouble running one with chat room) asked me my top five favourite fantasy worlds. Besides my own, these are my top 20, though I'm unsure exact
    order. Some didn't influence my D&D; which influenced yours (any others)?

    1. Earth (some mythology is fantasy, AD&D 2e HR series)
    2. James Tolkien's Arda (in original D&D)
    4. Clive Lewis' Narnia (AD&D 2e Dungeon Masters Guide (DMG) appendix N)
    5. Lloyd Alexander's Prydain (AD&D 2e DMG appendix N list)
    6. Robert Howard's Hyborian Age (AD&D 2e DMG list)
    5. Wendy & Richard Pini's Abode (influenced my D&D)
    6. Dragonlance (broad appeal not just to gamers)
    7. Terry Brooks' Shannara (seems D&D-like... most my friends have read)
    8. Susan Cooper's The Dark Is Rising (Arthurian, pagan)
    9. Roger Zelazny's Amber (AD&D 2e DMG list)
    10. Highlander (film/television set ancient to modern age)
    11. He-man And The Masters of The Universe (MoTU, also She-ra)
    12. ThunderCats
    13. Robert Aspirin's MythAdventures
    14. Piers Anthony's Xanth
    15. Ursula Le Guin's Earthsea
    16. Mystara (with Blackmoor)
    17. Greyhawk
    18. Ravenloft
    19. Toril (Forgotten Realms)
    20. AD&D cosmology in general: /Manual of The Planes/ & Spelljammer

    My D&D retains some original (Arda) D&D creature names, and might make Narnia's Aslan a god, and might be remade as alternative Earth including Prydain map, and has non-player character (NPC, Conan) from Hyborian Age,
    and elves similar to Abode (not short with four fingers, but have telepathically bonded pets/steeds), and when I made my own role-playing
    game (before could afford D&D) it had a 'dragonlance' (am converting
    setting to D&D). Other worlds didn't influence me as much, except maybe unconsciously/subconsciously, though I might incorporate elements/ characters... of course, not modern like The Dark Is Rising, Amber, Highlander, MoTU, ThunderCats, Xanth, unless using D&D set modern age. I forgot which others (if any) are in DMG appendix N, but haven't read many from that list, nor its earlier version in /The Dragon/ magazine.

    Two I started reading were Michael Moorock's Elric and Fritz Leiber's Lankhmar, but not fan of some amoral/immoral characters; when a friend insisted bringing his Forgotten Realms evil monk to my D&D world, and
    praying to Cyric, I eventually had a deity say he can either go home or
    start over, so he started over as a druid. It was different when basic
    D&D allowed chaotic alignment (not necessarily evil) but I really disliked evil characters. Maybe DMG has a section on handling evil characters...?

    I never read Greyhawk nor Ravenloft novels, but enjoyed reading much about settings/worlds. I only read a few Mystara (Penhaligon, some Dragonlord)
    and Forgotten Realms (/Streams of Silver/, but not much fan of drow as
    much as Mystara shadow elves, though Drizzt's alignment is good) ones.
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2