• Re: fwiw - rod-mill project start

    From sinotece@112ce605cdf05ce68f4a2b2f2f9f1966dd8fd8fc0a997f5891271c9f657cff29@example.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Nov 9 17:00:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    Richard, have you had a chance to sieve the rod mill discharge yet? If itrCOs going to feed a ball mill, comparing the coarse fraction and fines at two grind times would help show whether the extra time is still breaking down oversize particles or mostly producing more fines. ThatrCOs a check werCOd start with when evaluating a grinding circuit at SINOTECE (https://sinotece.com/).
    --
    For full context, visit https://www.polytechforum.com/metalworking/fwiw-rod-mill-project-start-1622742-.htm

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Tue Nov 10 13:58:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    sinotece <112ce605cdf05ce68f4a2b2f2f9f1966dd8fd8fc0a997f5891271c9f657cff29@example.com> writes:

    Richard, have you had a chance to sieve the rod mill discharge yet? If
    it's going to feed a ball mill, comparing the coarse fraction and
    fines at two grind times would help show whether the extra time is
    still breaking down oversize particles or mostly producing more
    fines. That's a check we'd start with when evaluating a grinding
    circuit at SINOTECE (https://sinotece.com/).

    Thank-you for your response.

    Yes and no.

    * Sieve analysis:

    I have done sieve analysis on the rod-mill's output.
    I have a halving series of sieves.
    (I want to get a "square-root 2" series of sieves from about 1200microns
    to about 40microns - that would be 13 sieves(?) - but have not yet found
    a good supplier - I know most are in Anping, but I have not found one
    yet which repeats back what my order is and what the price agreed is)
    Seen on the Web at my own hosted website

    "Particle Size Analysis rod-mill comminute 10mm granite chippings 23July2025" http://weldsmith.co.uk/tech/minerals/250723_sa_rm10gran/250723_sa_rm10gran.html The idea of grinding granite chippings sold in builders' merchants was
    to "calibrate" the rod-mill. Have a cheap consistent starting feed so
    you are free to do a lot of tests...
    I intended to do tests including exactly the test you suggest
    "> ... comparing the coarse fraction and
    fines at two grind times would help show whether the extra time is
    still breaking down oversize particles or mostly producing more
    fines. ..."
    Getting such a mass fraction of very fines, I "developed a suspicion"
    and went back to the builders merchant, and a story emerges - the
    granite chippings come from the kaolin quarries (we in england call
    kaolin "china-clay" but everyone with geological knowledge knows we mean kaolin) near St Austell. It is likely that even the granite which seems
    hard is part kaolinised.
    Hence I realised my "test program with a consistent feed" while having
    worthy intentions isn't going to work...

    * Rod-mill:

    Another problem - the rod-mill I was able to quickly make has its drive
    through a centre of the rear end-plate of the shell. This makes loading
    and unloading the mill very hard work - because you cannot tip down the
    shell to unload comminute then tip up the shell to put the rods and new
    feed back in...

    I need to acquire a lathe so I cna make machine components.
    Then I hope to sort-out the rod-mill and make a ball-mill.
    I have the steel tube - all "mild steel" - essentially S275 or S355 - to
    make more shells. I hope to make a machine with a pair of parallel
    rollers onto which the shells sit in gravity and spin on the rollers.
    With nothing on the end-plates I could look to have continuous ore and
    water feed...

    * more...

    I did this. You can readily see the cassiterite in the ore... "Particle-Size-Analysis of fine-comminuted tin ore" http://weldsmith.co.uk/tech/minerals/260315_rm_sn_ore_sa/260315_rm_sn_ore4p5kg_sa.html
    Our tin ore is cassiterite (tin oxide ore), usually "contaminated",
    thought to be by "over-printing" by a later sulphide mineral deposition
    of arsenopyrite.
    But nothing else : quartz; cassiterite; arsenopyrite.
    The cassiterite is fine - you only see gleaming specks of it even a good
    ore.

    * final note:

    You can get open contact with me using the
    Contact Form
    http://weldsmith.co.uk/contactform/contact.html
    on my website.

    Thanks for your suggestions.
    I hope to do trials of mineral processing during our winter here,
    arriving now, with short hours of daylight, low temperatures in Celsius,
    and a lot of rain blown by the wind. Hence - be indoors...

    Regards, Rich Smith

    PS - are you able to recommend a sieves supplier - in Anping ?
    You must use stacks of sieves at Sinotece...
    I am looking for 200mm or 8-inch sieves
    Root-2 series from 1.18mm down to 38 microns
    Given transport cost is significant part of the cost, might as well go
    for 316 stainless steel.

    Which means, in microns:
    1180
    850
    600
    425
    300
    212
    150
    106
    75
    53
    38
    Then lid/cover-plate and catch-pan
    So 11 sieves plus the lid and pan, so 13 items.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Tue Nov 10 13:09:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1pkwciy9g.fsf@void.com...
    I need to acquire a lathe so I cna make machine components.

    A lathe makes round moving components, you will likely also need a milling machine to accurately cut flat rectilinear surfaces on the frame such as multiple closely aligned pillow block mounts and drill matching hole
    patterns, and perhaps a horizontal bandsaw to cut stock to size and rough
    out odd shapes such as large disks.

    Your expert local contacts can give better advice on what is suited to
    meeting your designs' needs than I can from over here.

    Good machines may become investments rather than expenses, I paid $1200 for
    a lathe like this:
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/358913435946?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Tue Nov 10 19:21:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Jim Wilkins" <muratlanne@gmail.com> writes:

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1pkwciy9g.fsf@void.com...
    I need to acquire a lathe so I cna make machine components.

    A lathe makes round moving components, you will likely also need a
    milling machine to accurately cut flat rectilinear surfaces on the
    frame such as multiple closely aligned pillow block mounts and drill
    matching hole patterns, and perhaps a horizontal bandsaw to cut stock
    to size and rough out odd shapes such as large disks.

    Your expert local contacts can give better advice on what is suited to meeting your designs' needs than I can from over here.

    Good machines may become investments rather than expenses, I paid
    $1200 for a lathe like this:
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/358913435946?

    I have used a mill - quite a lot. For sure I would like one.
    Lathe - cylindrical surfaces (in the main)
    Mill - flat surfaces
    I could have got a good Myford lathe. However it would be bigger and
    use more space in the outbuilding. It is seeming that I have much
    reduced the dampness in the outbuilding - however, don't conclude until
    deep into the winter. I wanted a lathe which I can move on a trolley so
    it can come back to the house to keep dry.
    Best wishes
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Tue Nov 10 18:49:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1zevgbig8.fsf@void.com...

    I have used a mill - quite a lot. For sure I would like one.
    Lathe - cylindrical surfaces (in the main)
    Mill - flat surfaces
    I could have got a good Myford lathe. However it would be bigger and
    use more space in the outbuilding. It is seeming that I have much
    reduced the dampness in the outbuilding - however, don't conclude until
    deep into the winter. I wanted a lathe which I can move on a trolley so
    it can come back to the house to keep dry.
    Best wishes

    ------------------------------

    Lathes need their ways very straight and parallel to turn long cylinders properly. Usually this means that the ways are accurately leveled crosswise
    at both ends by shimming under the feet to remove any twist, since a level
    or plumb bob are the only easy indicators of the direction of gravity.

    In practice I think this means you would need a way to hoist the top-heavy machine off the trolley before using it, and check for and correct bed
    twist. I have more jobs for the lathe in summer but more free time to play with it in winter.

    My South Bend is an exception, there may be others. It's on a relatively
    light sheet metal cabinet and has a pivot between the ways and foot under
    the tailstock that lets the bed mostly straighten itself when the
    restraining screws are loosened. It isn't quite level front to back (or end
    to end) but it's close enough that I could match the bubble offsets on the headstock and tailstock ends.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Wed Nov 11 12:46:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1zevgbig8.fsf@void.com...

    I wanted a lathe which I can move on a trolley so
    it can come back to the house to keep dry.

    I've used wheeled trailer tongue jacks as landing gear to lift and move things. An advantage is that they let the load rest on its normal feet or a thin flange below them, disadvantages are their high mounting bolt holes and poor castering on uneven ground, which the top heaviness of a lathe will
    make dangerous if the wheels have to pass through a narrow doorway.

    https://www.myteeproducts.com/marine-swivel-swing-down-trailer-jack-2000-lbs-capacity.html?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Billington@djb@invalid.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Wed Nov 11 21:00:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 10/11/2026 19:21, Richard Smith wrote:
    "Jim Wilkins" <muratlanne@gmail.com> writes:

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1pkwciy9g.fsf@void.com...
    I need to acquire a lathe so I cna make machine components.
    A lathe makes round moving components, you will likely also need a
    milling machine to accurately cut flat rectilinear surfaces on the
    frame such as multiple closely aligned pillow block mounts and drill
    matching hole patterns, and perhaps a horizontal bandsaw to cut stock
    to size and rough out odd shapes such as large disks.

    Your expert local contacts can give better advice on what is suited to
    meeting your designs' needs than I can from over here.

    Good machines may become investments rather than expenses, I paid
    $1200 for a lathe like this:
    https://www.ebay.com/itm/358913435946?
    I have used a mill - quite a lot. For sure I would like one.
    Lathe - cylindrical surfaces (in the main)
    Mill - flat surfaces
    I could have got a good Myford lathe. However it would be bigger and
    use more space in the outbuilding. It is seeming that I have much
    reduced the dampness in the outbuilding - however, don't conclude until
    deep into the winter. I wanted a lathe which I can move on a trolley so
    it can come back to the house to keep dry.
    Best wishes

    What about making a cover for it so when not in use it's covered and you
    can use a desiccant to keep it dry. It's something I'm looking at
    currently with a piece of equipment I'm building and moving it into the
    house is impractical. I could arrange to move it into the rear of my
    workshop where I have a dehumidifier to keep the main machines rust free.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Wed Nov 11 17:11:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "David Billington" wrote in message news:11d2l0o$3d3fo$1@dont-email.me...

    What about making a cover for it so when not in use it's covered and you
    can use a desiccant to keep it dry. It's something I'm looking at
    currently with a piece of equipment I'm building and moving it into the
    house is impractical. I could arrange to move it into the rear of my
    workshop where I have a dehumidifier to keep the main machines rust free. -----------------------------------

    I bought this and later a similar one to dry my small bathroom after taking
    a shower when the weather is too hot or cold for a window fan. https://eva-dry.com/products/edv-1100-petite-dehumidifier?

    The second one keeps basement shop humidity below rusting level during midsummer. Their power draw measures about 25W each. I don't know if they
    will handle cold that frosts the chill side.

    I leave less vulnerable machinery in a covered space outdoors year round, protected by a spray of LPS-3. The top of the beam of the log splitter would be the first to rust but doesn't, or only lightly. The only real rust hazard is a warm humid spell in spring when shed roofs are still snow covered, and drip condensation.

    A piece of ground bare steel could be left in the shed this winter to test these suggestions.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Thu Nov 12 06:51:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1zevgbig8.fsf@void.com...

    I have used a mill - quite a lot. For sure I would like one.
    Lathe - cylindrical surfaces (in the main)
    Mill - flat surfaces
    I could have got a good Myford lathe. However it would be bigger and
    use more space in the outbuilding. It is seeming that I have much
    reduced the dampness in the outbuilding - however, don't conclude until
    deep into the winter. I wanted a lathe which I can move on a trolley so
    it can come back to the house to keep dry.
    Best wishes

    ---------------------------------------

    A possible alternative if you lack the room is a Maker Space. https://creativelivesinprogress.com/articles/creative-co-working-maker-spaces https://www.hackspace.org.uk/

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2