• Ali-MIG test-welds pics - diagnose?

    From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Wed Oct 7 22:22:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    Hello all

    I know previous comments, but - does anyone have any ideas here?

    http://www.weldsmith.co.uk/greet/cs411/260724_testwelds/261007_alimig_1p2_1p6.html
    "CS411-CV alimig test welds w5356 20mm-p5083"

    I have done Ali-MIG welds considered "top level".
    I am aware that in those cases I was an agency worker walking up to a
    fully set-up machine. Maybe the "troubleshooting" is obvious to folk
    here used to having to do everything about the task?

    The arc is "fiery" and "fierce".
    The effect is particulary seen with
    "Bead-on-plate (w-1.6mm)"
    and
    "Pad-weld "2" (w-1.6mm)"
    It as if, whatever depth penetrated to, something got in and made the
    molten metal separate from and be repelled from what should be the
    fusion boundary...?
    There's a lot of "soot" - usually evaporation of Magnesium (Mg).
    I mean, you will get at least *some* sooting - about 3mm from the
    weld, where the shielding gas is "running out" - and it will be like a pencilled-on line. But this...

    I'm hit by so much at once here...


    It seems clear the machine does better with 1.2mm wire rather than
    1.6mm wire.
    However the duty-cycle of the torch is much higher with 1.6mm wire.
    So I want to succeed with 1.6mm wire.


    The machine will run 6mm (1/4-inch) "7018" SMAW rods on my
    single-phase supply in its Constant Current (CC) mode - promising!
    But something is "out-of-kilter" here.

    Ideas welcome...

    Best wishes, Rich S
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Leon Fisk@lfiskgr@gmail.invalid to rec.crafts.metalworking on Thu Oct 8 07:36:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On Wed, 07 Oct 2026 22:22:51 +0100
    Richard Smith <null@void.com> wrote:
    Hello all

    I know previous comments, but - does anyone have any ideas here?

    http://www.weldsmith.co.uk/greet/cs411/260724_testwelds/261007_alimig_1p2_1p6.html
    "CS411-CV alimig test welds w5356 20mm-p5083"

    I have done Ali-MIG welds considered "top level".
    I am aware that in those cases I was an agency worker walking up to a
    fully set-up machine. Maybe the "troubleshooting" is obvious to folk
    here used to having to do everything about the task?
    <snip>
    I would suspect your losing the shielding gas. Maybe you're moving
    faster and out running it. Or it's been turned up higher causing
    turbulence.
    I'd try putting something along the weld area on each side, like an
    angle iron or even aluminum foil. The idea being to make a trough to
    trap the gas in so it lingers over the weld longer while it cools Efn+
    I'm just a hack, but have seen similar when I lost gas coverage on odd
    shaped pieces. Or lost gas coverage before the weld area had cooled
    enough...
    --
    Leon Fisk
    Grand Rapids MI
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 9 11:22:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    Leon Fisk <lfiskgr@gmail.invalid> writes:

    On Wed, 07 Oct 2026 22:22:51 +0100
    Richard Smith <null@void.com> wrote:

    Hello all

    I know previous comments, but - does anyone have any ideas here?
    http://www.weldsmith.co.uk/greet/cs411/260724_testwelds/261007_alimig_1p2_1p6.html
    "CS411-CV alimig test welds w5356 20mm-p5083"

    I have done Ali-MIG welds considered "top level".
    I am aware that in those cases I was an agency worker walking up to a
    fully set-up machine. Maybe the "troubleshooting" is obvious to folk
    here used to having to do everything about the task?
    <snip>

    I would suspect your losing the shielding gas. Maybe you're moving
    faster and out running it. Or it's been turned up higher causing
    turbulence.

    I'd try putting something along the weld area on each side, like an
    angle iron or even aluminum foil. The idea being to make a trough to
    trap the gas in so it lingers over the weld longer while it cools Efn+

    I'm just a hack, but have seen similar when I lost gas coverage on odd
    shaped pieces. Or lost gas coverage before the weld area had cooled
    enough...

    Hi there
    Massive thanks for coming-in on this.
    One of many thoughts was "shielding gas coverage?".
    The arc is all wrong and sounds all wrong. Plus the sooting is
    "something else!".
    Sheilding gas is Argon; flowrate 20L/min (40cu-ft/hr(?)) - which is "not
    too little; not too much"?
    Those tests would make a great diagnostic.

    Are leaks possible?
    The answer would superficially seem "no" because it was running quite
    well with 1.2mm wire - but in changing the liner, etc. to 1.6mm I could
    have done "something" to make it wrong.
    What I am thinking is - is there a diagnostic to check that?.

    More thinking - it was suggested cut the liner so it doesn't quite touch
    the contactor-tip ("because it will melt and stick") - have a just
    "goofed" doing that? I left about 2mm short.
    The liner is "Teflon" and surely shouldn't melt anyway (I have used HDPE
    liners too on 5000-series Ali., and they seem to work well).

    Anyway - thanks again. I wasn't "leading" at all (?), and you came in
    on "shielding/shielding-gas". Appreciated.

    Rich Smith
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Bob La Londe@none@none.com99 to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 9 14:29:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 10/7/2026 2:22 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    Hello all

    I know previous comments, but - does anyone have any ideas here?

    http://www.weldsmith.co.uk/greet/cs411/260724_testwelds/261007_alimig_1p2_1p6.html
    "CS411-CV alimig test welds w5356 20mm-p5083"

    I have done Ali-MIG welds considered "top level".
    I am aware that in those cases I was an agency worker walking up to a
    fully set-up machine. Maybe the "troubleshooting" is obvious to folk
    here used to having to do everything about the task?

    The arc is "fiery" and "fierce".
    The effect is particulary seen with
    "Bead-on-plate (w-1.6mm)"
    and
    "Pad-weld "2" (w-1.6mm)"
    It as if, whatever depth penetrated to, something got in and made the
    molten metal separate from and be repelled from what should be the
    fusion boundary...?
    There's a lot of "soot" - usually evaporation of Magnesium (Mg).
    I mean, you will get at least *some* sooting - about 3mm from the
    weld, where the shielding gas is "running out" - and it will be like a pencilled-on line. But this...

    I'm hit by so much at once here...


    It seems clear the machine does better with 1.2mm wire rather than
    1.6mm wire.
    However the duty-cycle of the torch is much higher with 1.6mm wire.
    So I want to succeed with 1.6mm wire.


    The machine will run 6mm (1/4-inch) "7018" SMAW rods on my
    single-phase supply in its Constant Current (CC) mode - promising!
    But something is "out-of-kilter" here.

    Ideas welcome...

    Best wishes, Rich S

    I wish I could help. but I've long since shared with you everything I
    know about aluminum welding. My approach when I hit a wall (if
    possible) is to get some test coupons, get some internet advice, and try
    some things.
    --
    Bob La Londe
    CNC Molds N Stuff
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Snag@Snag_one@msn.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 9 23:17:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 10/9/2026 4:29 PM, Bob La Londe wrote:
    On 10/7/2026 2:22 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    Hello all

    I know previous comments, but - does anyone have any ideas here?

    http://www.weldsmith.co.uk/greet/cs411/260724_testwelds/261007_alimig_1p2_1p6.html

    "CS411-CV alimig test welds w5356 20mm-p5083"

    I have done Ali-MIG welds considered "top level".
    I am aware that in those cases I was an agency worker walking up to a
    fully set-up machine.-a Maybe the "troubleshooting" is obvious to folk
    here used to having to do everything about the task?

    The arc is "fiery" and "fierce".
    The effect is particulary seen with
    "Bead-on-plate (w-1.6mm)"
    and
    "Pad-weld "2" (w-1.6mm)"
    It as if, whatever depth penetrated to, something got in and made the
    molten metal separate from and be repelled from what should be the
    fusion boundary...?
    There's a lot of "soot" - usually evaporation of Magnesium (Mg).
    I mean, you will get at least *some* sooting - about 3mm from the
    weld, where the shielding gas is "running out" - and it will be like a
    pencilled-on line.-a But this...

    I'm hit by so much at once here...


    It seems clear the machine does better with 1.2mm wire rather than
    1.6mm wire.
    However the duty-cycle of the torch is much higher with 1.6mm wire.
    So I want to succeed with 1.6mm wire.


    The machine will run 6mm (1/4-inch) "7018" SMAW rods on my
    single-phase supply in its Constant Current (CC) mode - promising!
    But something is "out-of-kilter" here.

    Ideas welcome...

    Best wishes, Rich S

    I wish I could help. but I've long since shared with you everything I
    know about aluminum welding.-a My approach when I hit a wall (if
    possible) is to get some test coupons, get some internet advice, and try some things.



    Pretty much every problem I've had with welding aluminum has been
    caused by not having my material clean enough - including the filler .
    Cast is the worst , especially if it's been oil soaked . Sometimes I
    wish I had a vapor degreaser .
    --
    Snag
    Muslims hate dogs because they
    protect women , children, and goats .
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Oct 12 07:41:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    Bob La Londe <none@none.com99> writes:

    On 10/7/2026 2:22 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    ..
    Best wishes, Rich S

    I wish I could help. but I've long since shared with you everything I
    know about aluminum welding. My approach when I hit a wall (if
    possible) is to get some test coupons, get some internet advice, and
    try some things.

    Appreciated.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Oct 12 07:45:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    Snag <Snag_one@msn.com> writes:

    On 10/9/2026 4:29 PM, Bob La Londe wrote:
    On 10/7/2026 2:22 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    Hello all

    I know previous comments, but - does anyone have any ideas here?

    http://www.weldsmith.co.uk/greet/cs411/260724_testwelds/261007_alimig_1p2_1p6.html
    "CS411-CV alimig test welds w5356 20mm-p5083"

    I have done Ali-MIG welds considered "top level".
    I am aware that in those cases I was an agency worker walking up to a
    fully set-up machine.-a Maybe the "troubleshooting" is obvious to folk
    here used to having to do everything about the task?

    The arc is "fiery" and "fierce".
    The effect is particulary seen with
    "Bead-on-plate (w-1.6mm)"
    and
    "Pad-weld "2" (w-1.6mm)"
    It as if, whatever depth penetrated to, something got in and made the
    molten metal separate from and be repelled from what should be the
    fusion boundary...?
    There's a lot of "soot" - usually evaporation of Magnesium (Mg).
    I mean, you will get at least *some* sooting - about 3mm from the
    weld, where the shielding gas is "running out" - and it will be like a
    pencilled-on line.-a But this...

    I'm hit by so much at once here...


    It seems clear the machine does better with 1.2mm wire rather than
    1.6mm wire.
    However the duty-cycle of the torch is much higher with 1.6mm wire.
    So I want to succeed with 1.6mm wire.


    The machine will run 6mm (1/4-inch) "7018" SMAW rods on my
    single-phase supply in its Constant Current (CC) mode - promising!
    But something is "out-of-kilter" here.

    Ideas welcome...

    Best wishes, Rich S
    I wish I could help. but I've long since shared with you everything
    I know about aluminum welding.-a My approach when I hit a wall (if
    possible) is to get some test coupons, get some internet advice, and
    try some things.


    Pretty much every problem I've had with welding aluminum has been
    caused by not having my material clean enough - including the filler
    . Cast is the worst , especially if it's been oil soaked . Sometimes
    I wish I had a vapor degreaser .

    I was wondering if it is possible to get air contamination into the
    shielding gas...?
    Will have to search for if there is a ready test for that...

    I have stainless steel wire brushes.
    I am at the cleanness of what gave probably my best welds.
    I have welded on less clean than this (?) without obvious problems (in commercial jobs, if you are the welder and the job is presented as ready
    to weld, if you want to keep your job you weld...).

    Thanks, Rich S
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Bob La Londe@none@none.com99 to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Oct 12 14:10:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 10/11/2026 11:45 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    Snag <Snag_one@msn.com> writes:

    On 10/9/2026 4:29 PM, Bob La Londe wrote:
    On 10/7/2026 2:22 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    Hello all

    I know previous comments, but - does anyone have any ideas here?

    http://www.weldsmith.co.uk/greet/cs411/260724_testwelds/261007_alimig_1p2_1p6.html
    "CS411-CV alimig test welds w5356 20mm-p5083"

    I have done Ali-MIG welds considered "top level".
    I am aware that in those cases I was an agency worker walking up to a
    fully set-up machine.-a Maybe the "troubleshooting" is obvious to folk >>>> here used to having to do everything about the task?

    The arc is "fiery" and "fierce".
    The effect is particulary seen with
    "Bead-on-plate (w-1.6mm)"
    and
    "Pad-weld "2" (w-1.6mm)"
    It as if, whatever depth penetrated to, something got in and made the
    molten metal separate from and be repelled from what should be the
    fusion boundary...?
    There's a lot of "soot" - usually evaporation of Magnesium (Mg).
    I mean, you will get at least *some* sooting - about 3mm from the
    weld, where the shielding gas is "running out" - and it will be like a >>>> pencilled-on line.-a But this...

    I'm hit by so much at once here...


    It seems clear the machine does better with 1.2mm wire rather than
    1.6mm wire.
    However the duty-cycle of the torch is much higher with 1.6mm wire.
    So I want to succeed with 1.6mm wire.


    The machine will run 6mm (1/4-inch) "7018" SMAW rods on my
    single-phase supply in its Constant Current (CC) mode - promising!
    But something is "out-of-kilter" here.

    Ideas welcome...

    Best wishes, Rich S
    I wish I could help. but I've long since shared with you everything
    I know about aluminum welding.-a My approach when I hit a wall (if
    possible) is to get some test coupons, get some internet advice, and
    try some things.


    Pretty much every problem I've had with welding aluminum has been
    caused by not having my material clean enough - including the filler
    . Cast is the worst , especially if it's been oil soaked . Sometimes
    I wish I had a vapor degreaser .

    I was wondering if it is possible to get air contamination into the
    shielding gas...?

    Absolutely, although I expect that was not exactly what you were saying.
    Many people think a small leak doesn't matter because pressure forces
    gas OUT all holes, but direct experience should tell you that if you
    have a leak in a shielding gas hose your welds suffer even if it feels
    like you are getting adequate flow. This alone should indicate air is
    also getting mixed in some how. I'll leave it to the more technically
    capable to explain why (or how I am wrong).


    Will have to search for if there is a ready test for that...

    I have stainless steel wire brushes.
    I am at the cleanness of what gave probably my best welds.
    I have welded on less clean than this (?) without obvious problems (in commercial jobs, if you are the welder and the job is presented as ready
    to weld, if you want to keep your job you weld...).

    Thanks, Rich S
    --
    Bob La Londe
    CNC Molds N Stuff
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Snag@Snag_one@msn.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Oct 12 22:19:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 10/12/2026 4:10 PM, Bob La Londe wrote:
    On 10/11/2026 11:45 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    Snag <Snag_one@msn.com> writes:

    On 10/9/2026 4:29 PM, Bob La Londe wrote:
    On 10/7/2026 2:22 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    Hello all

    I know previous comments, but - does anyone have any ideas here?

    http://www.weldsmith.co.uk/greet/cs411/260724_testwelds/261007_alimig_1p2_1p6.html

    "CS411-CV alimig test welds w5356 20mm-p5083"

    I have done Ali-MIG welds considered "top level".
    I am aware that in those cases I was an agency worker walking up to a >>>>> fully set-up machine.-a Maybe the "troubleshooting" is obvious to folk >>>>> here used to having to do everything about the task?

    The arc is "fiery" and "fierce".
    The effect is particulary seen with
    "Bead-on-plate (w-1.6mm)"
    and
    "Pad-weld "2" (w-1.6mm)"
    It as if, whatever depth penetrated to, something got in and made the >>>>> molten metal separate from and be repelled from what should be the
    fusion boundary...?
    There's a lot of "soot" - usually evaporation of Magnesium (Mg).
    I mean, you will get at least *some* sooting - about 3mm from the
    weld, where the shielding gas is "running out" - and it will be like a >>>>> pencilled-on line.-a But this...

    I'm hit by so much at once here...


    It seems clear the machine does better with 1.2mm wire rather than
    1.6mm wire.
    However the duty-cycle of the torch is much higher with 1.6mm wire.
    So I want to succeed with 1.6mm wire.


    The machine will run 6mm (1/4-inch) "7018" SMAW rods on my
    single-phase supply in its Constant Current (CC) mode - promising!
    But something is "out-of-kilter" here.

    Ideas welcome...

    Best wishes, Rich S
    I wish I could help. but I've long since shared with you everything
    I know about aluminum welding.-a My approach when I hit a wall (if
    possible) is to get some test coupons, get some internet advice, and
    try some things.


    -a-a Pretty much every problem I've had with welding aluminum has been
    -a-a caused by not having my material clean enough - including the filler >>> -a-a . Cast is the worst , especially if it's been oil soaked . Sometimes >>> -a-a I wish I had a vapor degreaser .

    I was wondering if it is possible to get air contamination into the
    shielding gas...?

    Absolutely, although I expect that was not exactly what you were saying.
    -aMany people think a small leak doesn't matter because pressure forces
    gas OUT all holes, but direct experience should tell you that if you
    have a leak in a shielding gas hose your welds suffer even if it feels
    like you are getting adequate flow.-a This alone should indicate air is
    also getting mixed in some how.-a I'll leave it to the more technically capable to explain why (or how I am wrong).


    Will have to search for if there is a ready test for that...

    I have stainless steel wire brushes.
    I am at the cleanness of what gave probably my best welds.
    I have welded on less clean than this (?) without obvious problems (in
    commercial jobs, if you are the welder and the job is presented as ready
    to weld, if you want to keep your job you weld...).

    Thanks, Rich S



    Venturi effect . If you have a small hole in your shield gas supply
    it can sometimes act as a venturi , sucking in ambient air . Richard's
    problem doesn't sound like that's his problem - to me , and God knows
    I've been wrong before .
    --
    Snag
    Muslims hate dogs because they
    protect women , children, and goats .
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Thu Oct 15 11:59:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    Bob - thanks again for responding.
    I'll tell you something I did / met...

    Boatyard - on a river - making river barges.
    On the slipway - making a pontoon. Welding machine on the levels beside
    the inclined slipway - so about 15m to 20m away.
    On one setting of the machine, which I never went to, I got both
    dip-transfer and spray-transfer.

    For fillets for stiffeners on the hull-plates I could turn up the wire-feed-speed on the "local" wire-feeder and be in "dip" at about
    270A (and something like 22V (?)).
    Joining stiffeners which needed full-penetration welds, I wound-down the wire-feed-speed so the condition jumped to "spray" at about 240A (and
    around 29V).

    The torch would only take seconds at "spray" - but that was enough to
    full-pen. end-to-end stiffeners.
    Then back to a lot of "dip" to bind the stiffeners to the hull-plates.

    With a copper-and-iron machine you could do that.
    Same transformer setting, but two totally different welding conditions -
    "dip" and "spray".

    Hope you like this recounting.

    Regards,
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2