• Watched tank running day at Bovington (UK) FWIW

    From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Sep 28 07:45:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    For what it's worth...
    went 2 days ago to Bovington camp tank museum for "running" day - of
    mainly WW2 armoured vehicles.

    I can cite what I have studied about tanks. First time ever seeing
    tanks running. I set myself the goal of watching and absorbing...

    Someone from the museum explained the cost in fuel (petrol/gasoline,
    diesel) runs into 5 figures GBPpounds (close to US$) *each day* - the
    admission cost from thousands of people barely covers.

    Petrol/gasoline fueled tanks (the most) popping and banging away.
    Name of day heavily distorted by the only running WW2 German Tiger
    tank in the World (?) appearing. Heat-haze of gasoline being burned...

    The amazing Soviet / Russian T34 (a T34/85) - one of very few
    diesel-engined tanks - blatantly displaying its crudity yet brilliance.

    You folk are in the main experts. I will only comment - I am glad I
    saw. Seeing is understanding a lot...

    Best wishes
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Sep 28 09:04:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1a4p1swlt.fsf@Admins-Air.Home...

    For what it's worth...
    went 2 days ago to Bovington camp tank museum for "running" day - of
    mainly WW2 armoured vehicles.

    I can cite what I have studied about tanks. First time ever seeing
    tanks running. I set myself the goal of watching and absorbing...

    Someone from the museum explained the cost in fuel (petrol/gasoline,
    diesel) runs into 5 figures GBPpounds (close to US$) *each day* - the
    admission cost from thousands of people barely covers.

    Petrol/gasoline fueled tanks (the most) popping and banging away.
    Name of day heavily distorted by the only running WW2 German Tiger
    tank in the World (?) appearing. Heat-haze of gasoline being burned...

    The amazing Soviet / Russian T34 (a T34/85) - one of very few
    diesel-engined tanks - blatantly displaying its crudity yet brilliance.

    You folk are in the main experts. I will only comment - I am glad I
    saw. Seeing is understanding a lot...

    Best wishes

    ---------------------------------------

    There are two tank museums about an hour from here in opposite directions.
    The operations manager of this one is a friend. https://www.americanheritagemuseum.org/jml/panther/
    They have a live demo October 10 & 11.

    I haven't visited this one yet.
    https://wrightmuseum.org/

    Tank driving was expensive and I hadn't been well coordinated driving a
    clutch and brake bulldozer so I settled for a half-track ride in the woods, which was like a roller coaster without seatbelts.

    Being a motorhead I'd love to see the inner workings, some of which are visible in the tank repair shop demo. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_R-975_Whirlwind

    Their machine shop contained large, old, simple machine tools appropriate to WW2 tasks.

    Bovington has a functional Tiger I and broken Tiger II, there's a running Tiger II in Saumur, France. As the war progressed bombing and lack of
    alloying metals cost German industry the ability to make adequately strong tank transmission gears, as well as stressed aero engine components. https://www.reddit.com/r/history/comments/jx6uiu/why_did_germanys_biggest_wwii_tanks_always_have/

    This was my usual ride in the Army because it had a safe to contain
    classified material. It was not much fun to drive, slow on the Autobahn and too wide for back roads. https://www.nf6x.net/1999/10/m109a3-2-5-ton-6x6-shop-van/
    We had Army versions of civilian vehicles such as the Suburban but no money for repairs when they broke. US forces in Europe were starved to support Vietnam. At least we could order Jeep parts privately from J.C.Whitney. Performance parts to make them faster also made them more likely to flip.

    On a narrow winding back road in the Black Forest I had to drive my VW into the woods to avoid an oncoming convoy of British tanks. I took maximum advantage of knowing some German and being able to navigate my way around.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Sep 28 12:11:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Jim Wilkins" wrote in message news:119doj7$2bq1k$1@dont-email.me...

    Tank driving was expensive and I hadn't been well coordinated maneuvering a >clutch and brake bulldozer so I settled for a half-track ride in the woods, >which was like a roller coaster without seatbelts.

    I also can't steer a tail-dragger plane with toe brakes, or leave a straight wake behind a sailboat. Maybe with more practice. I did learn to operate the four controls separately on a sliding dirt bike.

    https://www.americanheritagemuseum.org/tank-driving-experiences-and-tank-rides/m4-sherman-wwii-tank-driving-experience/

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Sep 28 13:29:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1a4p1swlt.fsf@Admins-Air.Home...

    For what it's worth...
    went 2 days ago to Bovington camp tank museum for "running" day - of
    mainly WW2 armoured vehicles.

    -----------------------------------

    In case you heard the argument that we were wrong to not adopt the Firefly modification, this explores the reasons. Mainly the Firefly was less
    accurate and less effective against infantry, the more common threat. https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/us-firefly-17-pounder-vs-90mm-vs-76mm.285284/
    "Where is the practical advantage to the capability to puch through at extended range if you can't get the shell to hit to begin with? By the time Firefly gets close enough to hit the target, [US Sherman] 76mm would be punching through as well anyway."

    90mm refers to the larger gun on US tank destroyers.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Bob La Londe@none@none.com99 to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Sep 28 11:18:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 9/27/2026 11:45 PM, Richard Smith wrote:
    For what it's worth...
    went 2 days ago to Bovington camp tank museum for "running" day - of
    mainly WW2 armoured vehicles.

    I can cite what I have studied about tanks. First time ever seeing
    tanks running. I set myself the goal of watching and absorbing...

    Someone from the museum explained the cost in fuel (petrol/gasoline,
    diesel) runs into 5 figures GBPpounds (close to US$) *each day* - the admission cost from thousands of people barely covers.

    Petrol/gasoline fueled tanks (the most) popping and banging away.
    Name of day heavily distorted by the only running WW2 German Tiger
    tank in the World (?) appearing. Heat-haze of gasoline being burned...

    The amazing Soviet / Russian T34 (a T34/85) - one of very few
    diesel-engined tanks - blatantly displaying its crudity yet brilliance.

    You folk are in the main experts. I will only comment - I am glad I
    saw. Seeing is understanding a lot...

    Best wishes

    I don't know how enthused you are, but there is a place here in the
    states where you can drive and even shoot tanks.


    "DriveTanks.com
    https://www.drivetanks.com
    Drive and shoot real tanks! The World's premier living military history adventure. Experience the historic and rate anti-tank guns and machine
    guns."
    --
    Bob La Londe
    CNC Molds N Stuff
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Mon Sep 28 18:01:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Jim Wilkins" wrote in message news:119doj7$2bq1k$1@dont-email.me...

    Bovington has a functional Tiger I and broken Tiger II, there's a running Tiger II in Saumur, France. As the war progressed bombing and lack of
    alloying metals cost German industry the ability to make adequately strong
    tank transmission gears, as well as stressed aero engine components. https://www.reddit.com/r/history/comments/jx6uiu/why_did_germanys_biggest_wwii_tanks_always_have/

    --------------------------------

    https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5d1810846e4b69000116772f/t/628c00db380dc66f9a261a85/1653342427999/Tanks+and+Tungsten+-+Germany%27s+Little+Big+Problem.pdf

    Straight cut spur gears can be made on simple milling machines like mine
    while more complex geometries require rotating the gear blank in exact synchronization with the motion of the cutting tool. I've read that US daylight bombing that targeted vital factories significantly hurt German machine tool and war production manufacturing capability, as did the
    hydrogen peroxide aircraft and U-boot propulsion programs that robbed the
    rest of industry of already scarce nickel and other alloying metals. This
    book mentions the problem. https://www.calum-douglas.com/current-book-the-secret-horsepower-race/

    A measure of the difference is that German aero engines needed half again
    the displacement to match the power of Allied engines.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Tue Sep 29 12:26:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Jim Wilkins" wrote in message news:119eo2i$2ofnn$1@dont-email.me...

    I've read that US daylight bombing that targeted vital factories >significantly hurt German machine tool and war production manufacturing >capability,

    That's actually a complex and controversial subject with each combatant
    having a different viewpoint that favors their capabilities and accomplishments.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Richard Smith@null@void.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Tue Sep 29 19:33:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    https://www.nf6x.net/1999/10/m109a3-2-5-ton-6x6-shop-van/
    Good run-around to have :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Wed Sep 30 07:15:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Richard Smith" wrote in message news:m1bj9faovs.fsf@void.com...

    https://www.nf6x.net/1999/10/m109a3-2-5-ton-6x6-shop-van/
    Good run-around to have :-)
    -------------------------------

    Impossible to park in civilian spaces, as at Autobahn rest stops. I liked
    the internal and external size of the 1970's VW camper van, but couldn't
    keep up with its road salt rust. That's why I've improved my ability to form sheet metal into repair panels and mig weld them.

    The rivnuts are more trouble than expected because their heads space the
    patch outward on curves and shift the alignment of other holes. The Hardell tool doesn't reliably clinch 1/4-20 stainless rivnuts tight enough to not spin. Tightening a Gr8 bolt in them bottoms them out tight enough. I turned
    a sleeve bushing with a Vise-Grip handle to isolate the rivnut head from the rotational friction of the bolt head, then clean up the slightly deformed threads with a tap.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Bob La Londe@none@none.com99 to rec.crafts.metalworking on Wed Sep 30 14:01:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 9/30/2026 4:15 AM, Jim Wilkins wrote:
    "Richard Smith"-a wrote in message news:m1bj9faovs.fsf@void.com...

    https://www.nf6x.net/1999/10/m109a3-2-5-ton-6x6-shop-van/
    Good run-around to have :-)
    -------------------------------

    Impossible to park in civilian spaces, as at Autobahn rest stops. I
    liked the internal and external size of the 1970's VW camper van, but couldn't keep up with its road salt rust. That's why I've improved my ability to form sheet metal into repair panels and mig weld them.

    The rivnuts are more trouble than expected because their heads space the patch outward on curves and shift the alignment of other holes. The
    Hardell tool doesn't reliably clinch 1/4-20 stainless rivnuts tight
    enough to not spin. Tightening a Gr8 bolt in them bottoms them out tight enough. I turned a sleeve bushing with a Vise-Grip handle to isolate the rivnut head from the rotational friction of the bolt head, then clean up
    the slightly deformed threads with a tap.



    There are two styles of tools I am familiar with for setting rivet nuts.
    One that operates like a pop rivet tool, but it incorporates a
    threaded mandrel. Of those there ARE two sub types. A regular right
    angle fist grip tool of which most of us are familiar and a compound
    crimp tool with leverage more like a bolt cutter.

    The other is simpler, may be cheaper (except at an industrial bolt
    supplier), and can be shop made. It is basically a GR8 bolt, a heavy
    washer, and a clearance fit hex fitting with a coarse knurl more like
    the bucking spikes on a chainsaw. You use a wrench on the hex with the spikes/knurl against the rivet nut, and tighten the bolt with a suitable wrench, socket, impact, or whatever. When the rivet nut is compressed
    in place you just back out the bolt.

    I expect that one of these tools may work better than the others for
    your use. Some type or retaining compound might help. I don't know. I
    would also suggest if you are still enamored of the idea of rivet nuts,
    check to see if there are flush head countersunk versions available.

    If a recessed or counter sunk head rivet nut is available some sort of
    dimple die might just be the ticket to make everything work the way you
    want.

    Depending on how you punch the hole and dimple the sheet metal you may
    also be able to create increased engagement surface for knurling on the
    rivet nut itself.
    --
    Bob La Londe
    CNC Molds N Stuff
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Wed Sep 30 18:44:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Bob La Londe" wrote in message news:119jtb6$jpru$1@dont-email.me...

    On 9/30/2026 4:15 AM, Jim Wilkins wrote:
    The rivnuts ...

    There are two styles of tools I am familiar with for setting rivet nuts.
    One that operates like a pop rivet tool, but it incorporates a
    threaded mandrel. Of those there ARE two sub types. A regular right
    angle fist grip tool of which most of us are familiar and a compound
    crimp tool with leverage more like a bolt cutter.

    The other is simpler, may be cheaper (except at an industrial bolt
    supplier), and can be shop made. It is basically a GR8 bolt, a heavy
    washer, and a clearance fit hex fitting with a coarse knurl more like
    the bucking spikes on a chainsaw. You use a wrench on the hex with the spikes/knurl against the rivet nut, and tighten the bolt with a suitable wrench, socket, impact, or whatever. When the rivet nut is compressed
    in place you just back out the bolt.

    I expect that one of these tools may work better than the others for
    your use. Some type or retaining compound might help. I don't know. I
    would also suggest if you are still enamored of the idea of rivet nuts,
    check to see if there are flush head countersunk versions available.

    If a recessed or counter sunk head rivet nut is available some sort of
    dimple die might just be the ticket to make everything work the way you
    want.

    Depending on how you punch the hole and dimple the sheet metal you may
    also be able to create increased engagement surface for knurling on the
    rivet nut itself.
    --
    Bob La Londe
    CNC Molds N Stuff

    ---------------------------------

    The Hardell tool is of the bolt cutter handle type which initially sets the rivnut without rotating it. I used my shop made bolt and wrench tool afterwards to pull the rivnut tighter, until I felt it bottom out. The
    initial set and the friction of the stationary sleeve bushing against the
    head were enough to keep the knurled stainless rivnut from turning from
    thread friction.

    In this case the patch doesn't need to fit flush, a drainage gap may be
    better than sealing in high speed tire spray, which the original box channel design appears to have done on the V shaped and spotwelded bottom edge. I considered making a screw-together die set to form a shallow well around the rivnut head, but don't think it's appropriate or necessary on curved
    surfaces that it will distort, and 18 gauge galvy steel is difficult to
    simply shear or bend with a hammer. I've made such die sets for easier tasks like setting brass grommets in hanging tarps.

    A more adjustable approach would be to fold the outer edges of the patch
    down to form a seal with some spring. I've found that with curved metal I
    need each forming operation to solve one problem without worsening another elsewhere.

    Everything finally fits. I took it apart and sprayed LPS-3 inside the remaining box channel. The factory paint is still intact on exposed areas
    that I sprayed 20+ years ago.

    Does anyone else take auto body repair to this level? I can buy repair
    panels for my 91 Ranger but not this 2000 Honda. I made the Ranger floor repair only because the available floor panel has the same drain hole where mine rusted around the rubber plug.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Thu Oct 1 07:37:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Jim Wilkins" wrote in message news:119k3bl$lqav$1@dont-email.me...

    If a recessed or counter sunk head rivet nut is available some sort of
    dimple die might just be the ticket to make everything work the way you
    want.
    --
    Bob La Londe
    --------------------------

    I made a dimpling die set for my #5 Junior punch. The limitation is access
    to the back side which a small rust hole or internal structure may not
    permit. My rust repairs to the truck and car have included Mig butt and plug welding when the back side is accessible to grind and spray, stainless pop rivets and auto body sealant, rivnuts for blind assembly and U clip nuts at edges. The non-welded patches are galvanized, the hardware stainless. The threads gall and stick together if not lubricated, LPS-3 which dries to a
    wax seems adequate so far. It's too thick to be a good grease for moving
    parts but it keeps them from seizing.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Lesher@wb8foz@panix.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Thu Oct 29 18:46:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Jim Wilkins" <muratlanne@gmail.com> writes:


    As the war progressed bombing and lack of alloying metals cost
    German industry the ability to make adequately strong tank
    transmission gears, as well as stressed aero engine components.

    From my reading, the issue was lack of to harden
    the transmission ring gears, made worse by them broaching vs.
    milling them.

    There was an edict against towing another tank because soon
    you had two dead tanks.

    Allied knowledge of this lead to pre-D Day emphasis on taking
    out railroad lines along the Channel. This forced the Heer to
    road-march their armour instead. And on the later, heavier,
    tanks, roughly a third would have a transmission failure within
    50 miles. It also consumed large quantities of gasoline; an
    always short critical resource.
    --
    A host is a host from coast to coast...............wb8foz@panix.com
    & no one will talk to a host that's close..........................
    Unless the host (that isn't close).........................pob 1433
    is busy, hung or dead....................................20915-1433
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Thu Oct 29 18:51:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "David Lesher" wrote in message news:11c04a9$cc1$1@reader2.panix.com...

    "Jim Wilkins" <muratlanne@gmail.com> writes:


    As the war progressed bombing and lack of alloying metals cost
    German industry the ability to make adequately strong tank
    transmission gears, as well as stressed aero engine components.

    From my reading, the issue was lack of to harden
    the transmission ring gears, made worse by them broaching vs.
    milling them.

    There was an edict against towing another tank because soon
    you had two dead tanks.

    Allied knowledge of this lead to pre-D Day emphasis on taking
    out railroad lines along the Channel. This forced the Heer to
    road-march their armour instead. And on the later, heavier,
    tanks, roughly a third would have a transmission failure within
    50 miles. It also consumed large quantities of gasoline; an
    always short critical resource.
    -------------------------------------- https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5d1810846e4b69000116772f/t/628c00db380dc66f9a261a85/1653342427999/Tanks+and+Tungsten+-+Germany%27s+Little+Big+Problem.pdf

    rCLIt is interesting that the American Sherman tank used double-herringbone gears in the final
    drives, which provides more torque capability for a given width of a final drive,rCY said Jacques
    Littlefield, founder of the Military Vehicle Technology Foundation, ...

    His magnificent tank collection has passed to the American Heritage Museum.

    Although gears require a slight clearance between mating teeth, on a herringbone gear the contact is continuous and moves across the faces. Straight cut spur gears jump and impact due to the clearance as the pressure passes between successive tooth pairs, adding to the force on them. Some
    older cars had straight cut reverse gears that were plainly louder due to
    the impacts than the more expensive herringbone forward gears.

    Generally with angled teeth both the cutter and the blank have to rotate in synchronization on dedicated gear cutting machines.

    Cutting straight across is much simpler, standard milling machines can do it with the addition of an indexer accessory to rotate the gear blank and hold
    it in each position. The cutter for both types is somewhat tricky to make
    but easy to sharpen by grinding the radial faces, which for an all steel
    gear cutter are where the yellow tungsten carbide inserts are in the
    picture. Tungsten carbide retains its sharp edge much longer than hardened tool steel.
    https://www.manufacturingguide.com/en/gear-milling

    I've cut a custom gear for a repair by grinding the shape of one tooth space on the end of a lathe bit and rotating it like a fly cutter.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Billington@djb@invalid.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Thu Oct 29 23:52:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 29/10/2026 22:51, Jim Wilkins wrote:
    "David Lesher"-a wrote in message news:11c04a9$cc1$1@reader2.panix.com...

    "Jim Wilkins" <muratlanne@gmail.com> writes:


    As the war progressed bombing and lack of alloying metals cost
    German industry the ability to make adequately strong tank
    transmission gears, as well as stressed aero engine components.

    From my reading, the issue was lack of-a to harden
    the transmission ring gears, made worse by them broaching vs.
    milling them.

    There was an edict against towing another tank because soon
    you had two dead tanks.

    Allied knowledge of this lead to pre-D Day emphasis on taking
    out railroad lines along the Channel. This forced the Heer to
    road-march their armour instead. And on the later, heavier,
    tanks, roughly a third would have a transmission failure within
    50 miles. It also consumed large quantities of gasoline; an
    always short critical resource.
    -------------------------------------- https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5d1810846e4b69000116772f/t/628c00db380dc66f9a261a85/1653342427999/Tanks+and+Tungsten+-+Germany%27s+Little+Big+Problem.pdf


    rCLIt is interesting that the American Sherman tank used
    double-herringbone gears in the final
    drives, which provides more torque capability for a given width of a
    final drive,rCY said Jacques
    Littlefield, founder of the Military Vehicle Technology Foundation, ...

    His magnificent tank collection has passed to the American Heritage
    Museum.

    Although gears require a slight clearance between mating teeth, on a herringbone gear the contact is continuous and moves across the faces. Straight cut spur gears jump and impact due to the clearance as the
    pressure passes between successive tooth pairs, adding to the force on
    them. Some older cars had straight cut reverse gears that were plainly louder due to the impacts than the more expensive herringbone forward
    gears.

    A few years ago on the local news they had an item about the energy
    crisis and showed a specialist gear cutter near Bristol UK cutting
    herringbone gears something similar to this https://youtu.be/d4OIcYHzpr4?t=1425 , an energy intensive process so electricity prices effect them, IIRC our rate here is around 3x the US.
    I had never seen one in action before and didn't know how herringbone
    gears were made. I used to know a machinist that specialised in gear and spline cutting and had various Fellows gear shapers and other hobbing equipment so had seen the cutting of normal spur gears done on a Fellows shaper.


    Generally with angled teeth both the cutter and the blank have to
    rotate in synchronization on dedicated gear cutting machines.

    Cutting straight across is much simpler, standard milling machines can
    do it with the addition of an indexer accessory to rotate the gear
    blank and hold it in each position. The cutter for both types is
    somewhat tricky to make but easy to sharpen by grinding the radial
    faces, which for an all steel gear cutter are where the yellow
    tungsten carbide inserts are in the picture. Tungsten carbide retains
    its sharp edge much longer than hardened tool steel. https://www.manufacturingguide.com/en/gear-milling

    I've cut a custom gear for a repair by grinding the shape of one tooth
    space on the end of a lathe bit and rotating it like a fly cutter.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 30 07:07:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "David Billington" wrote in message news:11c0m72$3r0ds$1@dont-email.me...

    A few years ago on the local news they had an item about the energy
    crisis and showed a specialist gear cutter near Bristol UK cutting
    herringbone gears something similar to this
    https://youtu.be/d4OIcYHzpr4?t=1425 , an energy intensive process so electricity prices effect them, IIRC our rate here is around 3x the US.
    I had never seen one in action before and didn't know how herringbone
    gears were made. I used to know a machinist that specialised in gear and
    spline cutting and had various Fellows gear shapers and other hobbing
    equipment so had seen the cutting of normal spur gears done on a Fellows shaper.

    ------------------------------
    Thanks, I'd never seen that either. The gear cutting processes I looked into were older and suited to simpler general purpose machine tools like mine. https://archive.org/details/Workshop_Practice_Series_Volume_17_Gears_Gear_Cutting

    The hard part is generating the cutting tool geometry, which is based on string unwinding from a spool at a constant speed. The contact between teeth duplicates the steady linear motion of a spot on the string. When translated to the string unwinding outward from a fixed spool that spot defines the
    tooth face curve.

    There are shortcuts, for instance a gear of infinite diameter, a rack, has easily machined flat tooth faces. A cylindrical cutter shaped like an Acme thread can cut the correct tooth shape on a gear blank if angled so its
    teeth cut straight across while the blank rotates, either freely or synchronized. https://www.motorgearengineer.com/blog/gear-hobbing-introduction-working-advantages-applications/

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Snag@Snag_one@msn.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 30 07:17:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 10/29/2026 5:51 PM, Jim Wilkins wrote:
    "David Lesher"-a wrote in message news:11c04a9$cc1$1@reader2.panix.com...

    "Jim Wilkins" <muratlanne@gmail.com> writes:


    As the war progressed bombing and lack of alloying metals cost
    German industry the ability to make adequately strong tank
    transmission gears, as well as stressed aero engine components.

    From my reading, the issue was lack of-a to harden
    the transmission ring gears, made worse by them broaching vs.
    milling them.

    There was an edict against towing another tank because soon
    you had two dead tanks.

    Allied knowledge of this lead to pre-D Day emphasis on taking
    out railroad lines along the Channel. This forced the Heer to
    road-march their armour instead. And on the later, heavier,
    tanks, roughly a third would have a transmission failure within
    50 miles. It also consumed large quantities of gasoline; an
    always short critical resource.
    -------------------------------------- https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5d1810846e4b69000116772f/t/628c00db380dc66f9a261a85/1653342427999/Tanks+and+Tungsten+-+Germany%27s+Little+Big+Problem.pdf


    rCLIt is interesting that the American Sherman tank used
    double-herringbone gears in the final
    drives, which provides more torque capability for a given width of a
    final drive,rCY said Jacques
    Littlefield, founder of the Military Vehicle Technology Foundation, ...

    His magnificent tank collection has passed to the American Heritage Museum.

    Although gears require a slight clearance between mating teeth, on a herringbone gear the contact is continuous and moves across the faces. Straight cut spur gears jump and impact due to the clearance as the
    pressure passes between successive tooth pairs, adding to the force on
    them. Some older cars had straight cut reverse gears that were plainly louder due to the impacts than the more expensive herringbone forward
    gears.

    Generally with angled teeth both the cutter and the blank have to rotate
    in synchronization on dedicated gear cutting machines.

    Cutting straight across is much simpler, standard milling machines can
    do it with the addition of an indexer accessory to rotate the gear blank
    and hold it in each position. The cutter for both types is somewhat
    tricky to make but easy to sharpen by grinding the radial faces, which
    for an all steel gear cutter are where the yellow tungsten carbide
    inserts are in the picture. Tungsten carbide retains its sharp edge much longer than hardened tool steel. https://www.manufacturingguide.com/en/gear-milling

    I've cut a custom gear for a repair by grinding the shape of one tooth
    space on the end of a lathe bit and rotating it like a fly cutter.


    I've done the same to recut splines . Made an adapter to hold lathe
    cutters in my boring head ...
    --
    Snag
    Muslims hate dogs because they
    protect women , children, and goats .
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Billington@djb@invalid.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 30 13:14:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    On 30/10/2026 11:07, Jim Wilkins wrote:
    "David Billington"-a wrote in message
    news:11c0m72$3r0ds$1@dont-email.me...

    A few years ago on the local news they had an item about the energy
    crisis and showed a specialist gear cutter near Bristol UK cutting herringbone gears something similar to this https://youtu.be/d4OIcYHzpr4?t=1425 , an energy intensive process so electricity prices effect them, IIRC our rate here is around 3x the US.
    I had never seen one in action before and didn't know how herringbone
    gears were made. I used to know a machinist that specialised in gear and spline cutting and had various Fellows gear shapers and other hobbing equipment so had seen the cutting of normal spur gears done on a Fellows shaper.

    ------------------------------
    Thanks, I'd never seen that either. The gear cutting processes I
    looked into were older and suited to simpler general purpose machine
    tools like mine. https://archive.org/details/Workshop_Practice_Series_Volume_17_Gears_Gear_Cutting


    The hard part is generating the cutting tool geometry, which is based
    on string unwinding from a spool at a constant speed. The contact
    between teeth duplicates the steady linear motion of a spot on the
    string. When translated to the string unwinding outward from a fixed
    spool that spot defines the tooth face curve.

    There are shortcuts, for instance a gear of infinite diameter, a rack,
    has easily machined flat tooth faces. A cylindrical cutter shaped like
    an Acme thread can cut the correct tooth shape on a gear blank if
    angled so its teeth cut straight across while the blank rotates,
    either freely or synchronized. https://www.motorgearengineer.com/blog/gear-hobbing-introduction-working-advantages-applications/


    It looked like the cutter used to produce that herringbone gear was a
    rack profile so simple to produce. The Fellows cutters look like gears themselves so maybe a search is on for later to see how those are
    generated.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 30 10:13:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "David Billington" wrote in message news:11c2570$8uog$1@dont-email.me...

    It looked like the cutter used to produce that herringbone gear was a
    rack profile so simple to produce. The Fellows cutters look like gears themselves so maybe a search is on for later to see how those are
    generated.

    ----------------------------------

    One pre-CNC method I read of replaces the string on the spool with a
    flexible metal band that guides the cutting edge.

    https://drivetrainhub.com/notebooks/gears/geometry/Chapter%201%20-%20Involute.html


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Lesher@wb8foz@panix.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 30 15:24:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Jim Wilkins" <muratlanne@gmail.com> writes:

    It is interesting that the American Sherman tank used
    double-herringbone gears in the final drives, which provides
    more torque capability for a given width of a final drive, said
    Jacques Littlefield, founder of the Military Vehicle Technology
    Foundation, ...


    I forgot to include the other impediment mentioned. Germany was
    broaching, not milling, the aforementioned gears. From the above statement
    I gather that's less than optimum.
    --
    A host is a host from coast to coast...............wb8foz@panix.com
    & no one will talk to a host that's close..........................
    Unless the host (that isn't close).........................pob 1433
    is busy, hung or dead....................................20915-1433
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 30 11:54:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "David Lesher" wrote in message news:11c2cr1$jqe$1@reader2.panix.com...

    "Jim Wilkins" <muratlanne@gmail.com> writes:

    It is interesting that the American Sherman tank used
    double-herringbone gears in the final drives, which provides
    more torque capability for a given width of a final drive, said
    Jacques Littlefield, founder of the Military Vehicle Technology
    Foundation, ...


    I forgot to include the other impediment mentioned. Germany was
    broaching, not milling, the aforementioned gears. From the above statement
    I gather that's less than optimum.

    -----------------------------------

    I believe that depends on how much the final tooth surface has been deformed and possibly cracked by the cutting force. Milling removes thin chips
    rapidly with little effect on the uncut metal while broaching may be a more brute force bulldozer approach, depending on the tooling and depth of cut. Drilling vs punching illustrate the difference. Milling is like drilling, broaching like punching.

    https://xtdsteel.com/steel-structure-fabrication/drilling-vs-punching-steel/ "The edge quality of holes also differs between drilling vs punching steel. Drilled holes typically have smooth edges and minimal burr formation. Punching, however, can produce rough edges and deformation zones around the hole perimeter."

    Germany was doing whatever they could with the machine tools that hadn't
    been destroyed. I have a late war "Last Ditch" Mauser rifle bolt with all
    the machining marks clearly visible, showing how it was made.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Fri Oct 30 13:06:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "Jim Wilkins" wrote in message news:11c2eig$cn6s$1@dont-email.me...

    "David Lesher" wrote in message news:11c2cr1$jqe$1@reader2.panix.com...

    "I forgot to include the other impediment mentioned. Germany was
    broaching, not milling, the aforementioned gears. From the above statement
    I gather that's less than optimum.

    -----------------------------------

    I believe that depends on how much the final tooth surface has been deformed and possibly cracked by the cutting force. Milling removes thin chips
    rapidly with little effect on the uncut metal while broaching may be a more brute force bulldozer approach, depending on the tooling and depth of cut.

    ----------------------------

    Broaching isn't inherently worse, and may be a good choice for slots or splines within a hole. This is a broach set for cutting drive key slots in gear and pulley hub holes.
    https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0F3TMYMB3?

    The step height between cutting edges is small and not damaging. I bought a few individual broaches for much less $$ and machine the round guide
    bushings as needed.

    https://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?t=288654
    "Gear design and materials: The PantherrCOs final-drive consisted of two cascaded spur-gear reduction sets driving the sprockets. This simple design (used because gear-cutting capacity for complex planetary gears was lacking) subjected gear teeth to very high contact stresses. German steel shortages meant gears had lower core strength and often lacked case hardening. Dr. P|+schel (MAN) reported that fatigue of the intermediate gear rCo rCLdue to the
    low-core strength of the material and the absence of case hardeningrCY rCo caused most failures."

    The original design specified planetary reduction gears which distribute the force among several gears. https://www.chamolgear.com/a-complete-guide-to-planetary-transmission-gear/


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jim Wilkins@muratlanne@gmail.com to rec.crafts.metalworking on Sat Oct 31 16:51:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.crafts.metalworking

    "David Lesher" wrote in message news:11c04a9$cc1$1@reader2.panix.com...
    ...
    Allied knowledge of this lead to pre-D Day emphasis on taking
    out railroad lines along the Channel. This forced the Heer to
    road-march their armour instead. And on the later, heavier,
    tanks, roughly a third would have a transmission failure within
    50 miles. It also consumed large quantities of gasoline; an
    always short critical resource.

    ---------------------------------

    Additionally the British SOE sent an abrasive powder to sabotage the wheel bearings of the flatcars intended to transport the very dangerous 2nd SS Panzer Division to Normandy from central France, where they could move to oppose either a northern or southern invasion.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2nd_SS_Panzer_Division_Das_Reich
    See March of Das Reich. Along the way they reacted to the Resistance the
    same way they had in Russia, weekly massacres. Germany sought needed cooperation from France and those responsible were scheduled for court-martial, though they died in the Normandy battles first.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oradour-sur-Glane

    https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16115490-das-reich

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2