Is there any difference physically between brake and shifter cable?
The cable itself looks about the same, the end crimps are obviously
of different shape, do they differ in strength or construction?
I substituted a shifter cable for rear brake cable simply because
it was handy and seemed to fit the brake lever quite well. The lever
is an old DiaCompe. The little metal "pill" rests nicely in the
yoke of the lever and doesn't look like it's applying any undue side
forces that might cause fatigue in the wire strands. The cable itself
is much stronger than my grip, so I certainly can't damage it.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska
Is there any difference physically between brake and shifter cable?
On 11/9/2026 10:04 AM, bp@www.zefox.net wrote:
Is there any difference physically between brake andProbably adequate but brake wires are thicker (more strands)
shifter cable?
The cable itself looks about the same, the end crimps are
obviously
of different shape, do they differ in strength or
construction?
I substituted a shifter cable for rear brake cable simply
because
it was handy and seemed to fit the brake lever quite well.
The lever
is an old DiaCompe. The little metal "pill" rests nicely
in the
yoke of the lever and doesn't look like it's applying any
undue side
forces that might cause fatigue in the wire strands. The
cable itself
is much stronger than my grip, so I certainly can't damage
it.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska
of the same material. And since braking forces are much
greater than shifting forces, the heads are larger as well.
Do ensure the head cannot pull through your lever's head stop!
The wires are formed before the head is cast on: https://www.yellowjersey.org/photosfromthepast/cablhead.jpg
so heads do not readily pull off, but on a gear wire all the
dimensions are much smaller.-a Perhaps near the limits of
what's required. I hope you do find yourself testing that
limit!
For the dollar or two expense of a brake wire, I would
change it ASAP.
On 11/9/2026 10:04 AM, bp@www.zefox.net wrote:
Is there any difference physically between brake and shifter cable?Probably adequate but brake wires are thicker (more strands)
The cable itself looks about the same, the end crimps are obviously
of different shape, do they differ in strength or construction?
I substituted a shifter cable for rear brake cable simply because
it was handy and seemed to fit the brake lever quite well. The lever
is an old DiaCompe. The little metal "pill" rests nicely in the
yoke of the lever and doesn't look like it's applying any undue side
forces that might cause fatigue in the wire strands. The cable itself
is much stronger than my grip, so I certainly can't damage it.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska
of the same material. And since braking forces are much
greater than shifting forces, the heads are larger as well.
Do ensure the head cannot pull through your lever's head stop!
The wires are formed before the head is cast on: https://www.yellowjersey.org/photosfromthepast/cablhead.jpg
so heads do not readily pull off, but on a gear wire all the
dimensions are much smaller. Perhaps near the limits of
what's required. I hope you do find yourself testing that limit!
For the dollar or two expense of a brake wire, I would
change it ASAP.
AMuzi <am@yellowjersey.org> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 10:04 AM, bp@www.zefox.net wrote:That seems the most plausible risk, though I don't think it can
Is there any difference physically between brake and shifter cable?Probably adequate but brake wires are thicker (more strands)
The cable itself looks about the same, the end crimps are obviously
of different shape, do they differ in strength or construction?
I substituted a shifter cable for rear brake cable simply because
it was handy and seemed to fit the brake lever quite well. The lever
is an old DiaCompe. The little metal "pill" rests nicely in the
yoke of the lever and doesn't look like it's applying any undue side
forces that might cause fatigue in the wire strands. The cable itself
is much stronger than my grip, so I certainly can't damage it.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska
of the same material. And since braking forces are much
greater than shifting forces, the heads are larger as well.
Do ensure the head cannot pull through your lever's head stop!
pull through. It's more likely to deform so a proper cable
won't fit.
The wires are formed before the head is cast on:
https://www.yellowjersey.org/photosfromthepast/cablhead.jpg
so heads do not readily pull off, but on a gear wire all the
dimensions are much smaller. Perhaps near the limits of
what's required. I hope you do find yourself testing that limit!
For the dollar or two expense of a brake wire, I would
change it ASAP.
Thanks for the prompt reply. Next time I'm in the LBS I'll
get a couple of brake cables. Does anybody offer numbers
for expected cable failure loads?
bob prohaska
AMuzi <am@yellowjersey.org> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 10:04 AM, bp@www.zefox.net wrote:That seems the most plausible risk, though I don't think it can
Is there any difference physically between brake and shifter cable?Probably adequate but brake wires are thicker (more strands)
The cable itself looks about the same, the end crimps are obviously
of different shape, do they differ in strength or construction?
I substituted a shifter cable for rear brake cable simply because
it was handy and seemed to fit the brake lever quite well. The lever
is an old DiaCompe. The little metal "pill" rests nicely in the
yoke of the lever and doesn't look like it's applying any undue side
forces that might cause fatigue in the wire strands. The cable itself
is much stronger than my grip, so I certainly can't damage it.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska
of the same material. And since braking forces are much
greater than shifting forces, the heads are larger as well.
Do ensure the head cannot pull through your lever's head stop!
pull through. It's more likely to deform so a proper cable
won't fit.
The wires are formed before the head is cast on:
https://www.yellowjersey.org/photosfromthepast/cablhead.jpg
so heads do not readily pull off, but on a gear wire all the
dimensions are much smaller. Perhaps near the limits of
what's required. I hope you do find yourself testing that limit!
For the dollar or two expense of a brake wire, I would
change it ASAP.
Thanks for the prompt reply. Next time I'm in the LBS I'll
get a couple of brake cables. Does anybody offer numbers
for expected cable failure loads?
bob prohaska
On 11/9/2026 11:39 AM, bp@www.zefox.net wrote:
AMuzi <am@yellowjersey.org> wrote:
On 11/9/2026 10:04 AM, bp@www.zefox.net wrote:That seems the most plausible risk, though I don't think it can
Is there any difference physically between brake and shifter cable?Probably adequate but brake wires are thicker (more strands)
The cable itself looks about the same, the end crimps are obviously
of different shape, do they differ in strength or construction?
I substituted a shifter cable for rear brake cable simply because
it was handy and seemed to fit the brake lever quite well. The lever
is an old DiaCompe. The little metal "pill" rests nicely in the
yoke of the lever and doesn't look like it's applying any undue side
forces that might cause fatigue in the wire strands. The cable itself
is much stronger than my grip, so I certainly can't damage it.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska
of the same material. And since braking forces are much
greater than shifting forces, the heads are larger as well.
Do ensure the head cannot pull through your lever's head stop!
pull through. It's more likely to deform so a proper cable
won't fit.
The wires are formed before the head is cast on:
https://www.yellowjersey.org/photosfromthepast/cablhead.jpg
so heads do not readily pull off, but on a gear wire all the
dimensions are much smaller. Perhaps near the limits of
what's required. I hope you do find yourself testing that limit!
For the dollar or two expense of a brake wire, I would
change it ASAP.
Thanks for the prompt reply. Next time I'm in the LBS I'll
get a couple of brake cables. Does anybody offer numbers
for expected cable failure loads?
bob prohaska
There are a lot of physics papers on bicycle gear rations
and on spoke tension but couldn't find anything on peak
tension loads for gear wires.
Does anybody offer numbers
for expected cable failure loads?
Is there any difference physically between brake and shifter cable?
The cable itself looks about the same, the end crimps are obviously
of different shape, do they differ in strength or construction?
I substituted a shifter cable for rear brake cable simply because
it was handy and seemed to fit the brake lever quite well. The lever
is an old DiaCompe. The little metal "pill" rests nicely in the
yoke of the lever and doesn't look like it's applying any undue side
forces that might cause fatigue in the wire strands. The cable itself
is much stronger than my grip, so I certainly can't damage it.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska
AMuzi <am@yellowjersey.org> wrote:Bob, please replace your cables as soon as possible. the head absolutely Will pull though on hard hraking and the wire itself will fray and brake at the brake lock. you may find it close to impossible to get the head out of the lever without removing the lever and holder. Individual shift wires and brake wires themselves are different diameters.
On 11/9/2026 10:04 AM, bp@www.zefox.net wrote:
Is there any difference physically between brake and shifter cable?Probably adequate but brake wires are thicker (more strands)
The cable itself looks about the same, the end crimps are obviously
of different shape, do they differ in strength or construction?
I substituted a shifter cable for rear brake cable simply because
it was handy and seemed to fit the brake lever quite well. The lever
is an old DiaCompe. The little metal "pill" rests nicely in the
yoke of the lever and doesn't look like it's applying any undue side
forces that might cause fatigue in the wire strands. The cable itself
is much stronger than my grip, so I certainly can't damage it.
Thanks for reading!
bob prohaska
of the same material. And since braking forces are much
greater than shifting forces, the heads are larger as well.
Do ensure the head cannot pull through your lever's head stop!
That seems the most plausible risk, though I don't think it can
pull through. It's more likely to deform so a proper cable
won't fit.
The wires are formed before the head is cast on: https://www.yellowjersey.org/photosfromthepast/cablhead.jpg
so heads do not readily pull off, but on a gear wire all the
dimensions are much smaller. Perhaps near the limits of
what's required. I hope you do find yourself testing that limit!
For the dollar or two expense of a brake wire, I would
change it ASAP.
Thanks for the prompt reply. Next time I'm in the LBS I'll
get a couple of brake cables. Does anybody offer numbers
for expected cable failure loads?
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:31:40 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |