• helix shifting

    From Roger Merriman@roger@sarlet.com to rec.bicycles.tech on Mon Oct 19 16:21:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.bicycles.tech

    <https://youtu.be/qpsRDuD2mZA?is=bZLGXpZRz48s3zKh>

    Mechanical auto shifting between chainrings via a helix, itrCOs claimed to shift under load, but IrCOm not sure how the jump in gearing is coped with?

    As obviously you actively shift the chain ring, on the roadie I often need
    to shift on the cassette just after, on the MTB/Gravel that there is a
    large shift I use coming up to a steep ramp, and likewise once over and
    going down ie I choose the point of my shifting quite deliberately.

    I do have a 1by system and lots of friends bikes are as itrCOs very common on Gravel and MTB IrCOm a bit of outlier for having a front mech! But IrCOve not noticed any difference between them wear wise, itrCOs off road itrCOs muddy one gets mileages that would horrify Mark!

    Only thing I notice is my Gravel bike has a wider range having lower and
    higher than 1by but itrCOs fairly marginal.

    I think itrCOs interesting but IrCOm not sure itrCOs not a solution looking for a
    problem?

    Roger Merriman


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From AMuzi@am@yellowjersey.org to rec.bicycles.tech on Mon Oct 19 11:44:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.bicycles.tech

    On 10/19/2026 11:21 AM, Roger Merriman wrote:
    <https://youtu.be/qpsRDuD2mZA?is=bZLGXpZRz48s3zKh>

    Mechanical auto shifting between chainrings via a helix, itrCOs claimed to shift under load, but IrCOm not sure how the jump in gearing is coped with?

    As obviously you actively shift the chain ring, on the roadie I often need
    to shift on the cassette just after, on the MTB/Gravel that there is a
    large shift I use coming up to a steep ramp, and likewise once over and
    going down ie I choose the point of my shifting quite deliberately.

    I do have a 1by system and lots of friends bikes are as itrCOs very common on Gravel and MTB IrCOm a bit of outlier for having a front mech! But IrCOve not noticed any difference between them wear wise, itrCOs off road itrCOs muddy one
    gets mileages that would horrify Mark!

    Only thing I notice is my Gravel bike has a wider range having lower and higher than 1by but itrCOs fairly marginal.

    I think itrCOs interesting but IrCOm not sure itrCOs not a solution looking for a
    problem?

    Roger Merriman



    Functional in theory but those never sell.

    https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikeforums.net-vbulletin/820x1090/bicycling_aug_1972_tokheim_transmission_p14_50pct_9d08e2bc83bce5ea16e01919eb0b9645512db174.jpg
    --
    Andrew Muzi
    am@yellowjersey.org
    Open every day since 1 April, 1971
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Merriman@roger@sarlet.com to rec.bicycles.tech on Mon Oct 19 21:44:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.bicycles.tech

    AMuzi <am@yellowjersey.org> wrote:
    On 10/19/2026 11:21 AM, Roger Merriman wrote:
    <https://youtu.be/qpsRDuD2mZA?is=bZLGXpZRz48s3zKh>

    Mechanical auto shifting between chainrings via a helix, itrCOs claimed to >> shift under load, but IrCOm not sure how the jump in gearing is coped with? >>
    As obviously you actively shift the chain ring, on the roadie I often need >> to shift on the cassette just after, on the MTB/Gravel that there is a
    large shift I use coming up to a steep ramp, and likewise once over and
    going down ie I choose the point of my shifting quite deliberately.

    I do have a 1by system and lots of friends bikes are as itrCOs very common on
    Gravel and MTB IrCOm a bit of outlier for having a front mech! But IrCOve not
    noticed any difference between them wear wise, itrCOs off road itrCOs muddy one
    gets mileages that would horrify Mark!

    Only thing I notice is my Gravel bike has a wider range having lower and
    higher than 1by but itrCOs fairly marginal.

    I think itrCOs interesting but IrCOm not sure itrCOs not a solution looking for a
    problem?

    Roger Merriman



    Functional in theory but those never sell.

    https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikeforums.net-vbulletin/820x1090/bicycling_aug_1972_tokheim_transmission_p14_50pct_9d08e2bc83bce5ea16e01919eb0b9645512db174.jpg

    ItrCOs to be fair a different design ie has a feeder half chainring than the expanding cog, but likely to end up likewise as curiosity.

    Roger Merriman

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2