From Newsgroup: rec.aviation.piloting
It took about 90 seconds for a routine report of ice and turbulence to be replaced by a desperate oMayday, mayday!o and then silence, as a private
jet plunged more than 27,000 feet over the course of one minute toward a Florida roadway.
Inside, a pilot and promising young co-pilot desperately tried to avert disaster for all on board, including a couple with two young children, a family caregiver and two others u all en route from Texas to the Bahamas.
oWeAre gonna crash into the ground!o copilot Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras
cried out to air traffic controllers.
Before the plane struck the ground, killing all nine inside, the pilot
sent a final transmission.
oWeAre out of time.o
Key pieces of the jet began breaking off as it got closer and closer to
the ground.
The aircraft slammed nose-first like a missile into a busy Palm Beach
County road, before erupting into flames and sending thick black smoke
into the sky, dashcam video shows. Bystander video showed a fiery crater gouged into Military Trail, a major highway, with the pavement buckled and shattered around the wreckage.
Residents of a nearby mobile home park ran outside to see what caused the explosion that rattled their homes.
oI heard and felt the boom,o said Andrew Mannino, a Palm Beach County resident. oThe power immediately went out.o Then came the smell of smoke,
he said, and a large black cloud rising into the sky.
Investigators are now working to determine what caused the aircraft, a
Learjet 60, to plunge from about 35,000 feet.
In an update Tuesday, NTSB board member Tom Chapman said pieces of the aircraft were still being collected.
oYesterday, the majority of the aircraftAs left elevator was located in
three pieces within a range about 1.3 to 3.8 miles away from the accident site. Those items are being retained for analysis.o Chapman said.
oSome pieces of the aircraft,o he added, oimportant pieces of the
aircraft, separated before the impact.o
oFinding that piece is a very significant bit of evidence,o Chapman said.
Investigators will determine if the aircraft breakup was the cause or a
result of the catastrophic dive.
But the early finding by investigators is key, underscoring that the
Learjet 60 began breaking apart during its minute-long blistering descent
from 35,000 feet.
While authorities have yet to identify those on board, their families have named eight of the nine victims as tech entrepreneur Adam Robinson and
Helen Sharp, as well as their two children, Emma and Charlie; caretaker
Anita Maria Cetina; Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr. Filgueiras and pilot
Jeff Gregory were also killed.
HereAs what we know about the crash and the final moments of those on
board.
A sudden amayday!A
The passengers of the Learjet 60 were traveling from Austin, Texas, to the Bahamas on Sunday, a route that took them over South Florida.
Scattered storms were passing through the area at the time of the crash,
and the plane passed through a strong cell just before it began suddenly descending.
Though it is unclear if the storm contributed to the crash, federal investigators have said it will be part of their investigation.
Minutes before the crash, Filgueiras, the pilot speaking to air traffic control, reported ice accumulating on the aircraft, an outside air
temperature of -47 degrees Celsius (-53 degrees Fahrenheit), and moderate turbulence, bouncing the plane by up to 700 feet, according to a recording
of radio calls captured by LiveATC.net.
Audio captures moments before Learjet crash
Minutes before the crash, the pilot of the plane reported ice accumulating
on the aircraft, an outside air temperature of -47 degrees Celsius, and moderate turbulence.
Source: LiveATC.com
oWe have light, clear ice that is manageable and moderate turbulence,o Filgueiras radioed the Miami Air Route Traffic Control Center.
But moments later, after reporting precipitation and requesting to climb,
she declared an emergency.
oMayday, mayday!o Filgueiras said.
oWeAre descending 10,000 feet per minute!o she told air traffic
controllers.
oWe are in an overspeed condition descending 20,000 feet per minute,o Filgueiras cried. oWeAre going to crash into the ground!o
A timeline of the learjet's final moments
9:37 a.m. CT / 10:37 a.m. ET: The plane takes off from Austin-Bergstrom International Airport in Texas.
12:47 p.m. ET: The plane is flying over Palm Beach County, Florida, when
it turns right to fly toward Freeport, Bahamas. The pilot says the
temperature is -47C (-52F) and reports olight, clear ice that is
manageable and moderate turbulence.o
12:48:00 p.m. ET: The pilot reports precipitation and asks to climb to
37,000 feet. Air traffic control grants the request.
12:48:28 p.m. ET: The pilot declares omaydayo as the plane starts dropping 8,000 feet per minute, then 10,000 feet per minute.
12:48:36 p.m. ET: The plane is plummeting 20,000 feet per minute (333 feet
per second), which the pilot says exceeds the aircraftAs limits.
12:48:54 p.m. ET: oWeAre going to crash into the ground!o the pilot tells
air traffic control.
12:49:01 p.m. ET: The pilot says the plane is falling at a rate of 22,000
feet per minute (367 feet per second).
12:49:17 p.m. ET: In the planeAs final transmission, the pilot says,
oWeAre out of time.o
Sources: LiveATC.net audio and FlightRadar24
Ultimately, the jet plunged 27,000 feet in one minute, before flight
tracking data was cut off, the website ADS-B Exchange shows.
The plane crashed just before 1 p.m. on Military Trail, between Cresthaven Boulevard and 10th Avenue North, the Palm Beach County SheriffAs Office
said.
Florida jet plunged to ground at high speed
A Bahamas-bound Learjet 60 departing from Texas crashed in Palm Beach
County on November 1 at 12:49 p.m. local time. The plane suddenly lost altitude while travelling at 500mph, dropping around 27,000 feet in one
minute before flight tracking data stopped.
Altitude and ground speed of the Learjet
The National Transportation Safety Board said on Monday that one person on
the ground sustained a leg injury. Officials initially said no injuries
were reported on the ground.
The crash is the second deadliest in the United States this year,
according to NTSB records, following JuneAs skydiving plane crash in
Butler, Missouri, which killed 12. It is also the deadliest crash
involving a Learjet 60, according to data from the Flight Safety
Foundation.
Devoted parents, children and caregiver among the dead
Robinson, Sharp, and their two children, Emma and Charlie, were identified
by family members as being victims, according to a family statement.
Emma, 4, and Charlie, 2, owere the light of their lives,o the statement
said.
oHelen and Adam were the love affair that will last forever. Their warmth, generosity and gift for making people feel welcome touched so many lives,o
the statement reads. oTheir loss will be felt deeply by all those who
loved them and who they loved in return.o
The couple split their time between Aspen, Colorado, and Austin. Robinson
was a tech entrepreneur who co-founded Retention.com, an e-commerce data company. Sharp had worked in public relations and was also a gifted
ceramics artist who created minimalistic vases and softly sloping bowls.
oItAs quite a blow,o Dudley Sharp, Helen SharpAs father, told The Palm
Beach Post by phone on Monday. oWe had a daughter, her husband and two grandchildren on the plane.o
Traveling with them on the plane was Anita Maria Cetina, who was
identified in the familyAs statement as the childrenAs caretaker.
oAnita Maria cared for Emma and Charlie with tenderness and devotion, and
she was truly part of the family,o the statement said, adding she leaves a olegacy of unconditional love and devotion.o
Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr, two people ofull of joy and adventureo were
also on board, the family statement said.
oFrom the moment they met, (Reed and Fehr) were all in on each other and
the life they were building,o the statement said.
Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras, the young co-pilot, was just 20 years old,
her family told CNN Brasil.
oShe was a very good girl u responsible, hardworking,o her mother, Camila Gadelha Corteleti, told CNN Brasil. Her family, who are Brazilian, live in Florida, where Filgueiras was raised, her mother said.
Before Filgueiras even had her driverAs license, she had gotten her hands
on a pilotAs license at age 17, her stepfather, Thiago Corteleti, told CNN Brasil. Though some people were taken aback by her eagerness to be in the
sky, Filgueiras was excited by it.
oI like being different than everyone, so to me, I think itAs, like,
cool,o Filgueiras told CNN affiliate WPEC in 2023. oSome people think that itAs, like, weird because I can fly planes, but I canAt drive a car. I
mean, I can, but a lot of people think itAs funny.o
She had graduated from American Flyers, one of the most prestigious
aviation schools in the United States and had already accumulated more
than 1,300 flight hours, her family said.
East Coast Jets, a private jet charter and aircraft management company in Allentown, Pennsylvania, said in a statement on their website that Gregory worked with their team in 2016 and 2017.
oOur prayers go out to JeffAs family, his fellow crew member, the
passengers and everyone affected by this heart breaking tragedy,o the statement read.
Gregory had a wife and young daughters, according to a GoFundMe set up for
the family.
oJeff was also a personal friend, and knowing him has made me a better person,o Thomas Noetzel wrote in the fundraiser.
Noetzel also serves as director of operations at Upper Jets, the company
that operated the flight.
Upper Jets offered condolences oto everyone affected by the catastrophic evento and said it was ocommitted to supporting the families of all those
who lost a loved one.o
In its statement to CNN, the company said it was cooperating with
authorities oto ensure an objective understanding of what occurredo and
noted information about the crash will be shared by authorities.
A crater scattered with evidence
A team of NTSB investigators has begun piecing together what could have
caused such a catastrophic crash, but they will have to navigate difficult challenges as they meticulously document the site over the next several
days.
About 20 investigators were at the scene Sunday and more have arrived
since.
oThe biggest obstacle that weAre going to have is recovering the major wreckage from the impacted crater on the roadway,o NTSB Senior Air Safety Investigator Tim Monville said.
Bad weather has hampered the investigation, Chapman, the NTSB member,
said.
The crater was filled with murky water, and more rounds of rain are
expected to sweep through the area until Tuesday, possibly lingering into Wednesday morning.
oWe expect to find critical airplane components within the crater,o
Chapman said.
ItAs a big puzzle to try to put together, he said, with oelements of the aircraft that are in the crater are going to be very likely in smaller
pieceso
Pieces of the aircraftAs left elevator was olocated in three pieces within
a range about 1.3 to 3.8 miles away from the accident site,o Chapman said Tuesday.
The elevator is a critical control surface of an airplane controlling
whatAs called pitch, or the up-and-down motion of the nose about a planeAs lateral axis.
Determining whether the plane was equipped with a cockpit voice recorder
will also be essential. Aircraft maintenance records show one was
installed on the plane, but it is unclear whether it was still on board, Chapman said.
oWeAll be better off with it,o Chapman said when asked whether
investigators would be stymied without the recorder. But even without it,
he said, oOur folks are very, very good. WeAre still able to do some incredible detective work and determine how things transpired.o
Weather and asupercooledA water
Determining how weather may have contributed to the crash will be a major focus of the investigation, Chapman said.
The plane had been flying around 35,000 feet when the pilot reported one
of the biggest hazards in aviation: icing.
In January 2024, the NTSB published a safety alert emphasizing the risks
of in-flight icing conditions, which can cause pilots to lose control.
Icing can cause an increase in a planeAs weight, a reduction in lift, a decrease in thrust and an increase in drag, according to the Federal
Aviation Administration. In other words, icing can slow an aircraft or
force it downward.
All clouds at heights where temperatures dip below freezing have the
potential to create icing conditions, according to the FAA, and icing can happen any time of year if the conditions are right.
Even in warm weather, thunderstorms generate powerful updrafts, or columns
of rising air that cool rapidly. The higher the altitude, the colder the
air gets. And temperatures in these updrafts can drop to as low as -100 degrees Fahrenheit at the altitudes where planes fly.
Blocked with Video Blocker
Click here to allow this video
How ice can down a plane
1:07
Filgueiras told air traffic controllers the temperature outside the plane
as -47 degrees Celsius. Ice cannot typically form in air below -40 degrees Celsius, as any liquid at that temperature has already frozen.
But thunderstorms can carry violent internal updrafts, thrusting
supercooled water droplets upward even in air colder than -40 degrees
Celsius.
The water can remain liquid and freeze on contact with the surfaces of an airplane u much like freezing rain falls as liquid and freezes on cars and roads on contact.
Hundreds of residents displaced
Hundreds of residents of a mobile home park have also been displaced by
the crash, the scene of which is blocking the entrance, according to Joel Flores, Palm Beach County commissioner for District 3.
Those residents are advised to stay with relatives or are being housed in
two shelters while the site is under investigation, though authorities are looking for alternative temporary housing, he said.
Several residents had left their homes to look at the scene of the crash
and were unable to re-enter once police established a perimeter around the crater, Flores said. Some have expressed concern that they have been
unable to access their belongings or vehicles, which they need to get to
work.
The county is considering it a state of emergency, said county
administrator Joseph Abruzzo, who is acting as incident commander. The
move would allow officials to unlock emergency funds to help the
displaced.
Local officials are also considering how to assist businesses that may be impacted by extended closures in the area, including a strip mall not far
from the crash site, Abruzzo said.
The NTSB is aware that the longer its investigation takes, the longer
these people will be uprooted.
oWe understand the challenges for those folks and we want to do our work
as quickly as we can so that the access to the neighborhood can be reestablished,o Monville said Monday.
https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/03/us/florida-plane-crash-learjet
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2