From Newsgroup: rec.aviation.military
from
https://www.thestreet.com/retirement/fidelity-and-vanguard-issue-a-sobering-outlook-for-retirees
Fidelity and Vanguard issue a sobering outlook for retirees
The number both firms landed on should change how yourCOre planning for retirement.
Nov 9, 2026 8:07 AM EST
By Hillary Remy
Edited by Aparajita Chatterjee
Follow
A Fidelity Investments office in Washington, DC, US.
Bloomberg / Getty Images
2 Comments
Related Articles
View post: Democrats inherit a retirement threat in Congress
Retirement
Democrats inherit a retirement threat in Congress
Damilola Esebame
7 hours ago
0
comments
View post: It's the Prices, Stupid: Why Americans Pay 3x More for the
Same Healthcare
Retirement
It's the Prices, Stupid: Why Americans Pay 3x More for the Same Healthcare
Jeffrey H. Snyder
11 hours ago
1
comment
View post: Self-directed IRA pitfalls: one mistake can blow up your
retirement
Retirement
Self-directed IRA pitfalls: one mistake can blow up your retirement
Roger Wohlner
23 hours ago
0
comments
View post: Dave Ramsey sends strong warning on 401(k) investment options Retirement
Dave Ramsey sends strong warning on 401(k) investment options
Jeffrey Quiggle
Nov 8, 2026
0
comments
Recommended on TheStreet Pro
View post: Windows for AI Debt, IPOs & Data Center Permits Appear to Be Closing
PRO
Market Commentary
Windows for AI Debt, IPOs & Data Center Permits Appear to Be Closing
Bret Jensen
6 hours ago
View post: ConsumersrCO Inflation Expectations Remain at Multi-Year Highs, Straining Household Finances
PRO
Market Commentary
ConsumersrCO Inflation Expectations Remain at Multi-Year Highs, Straining Household Finances
Neil Sethi
7 hours ago
View post: Why CoreWeaverCOs Earnings Call Will Be Important to Watch
PRO
Portfolio
Why CoreWeaverCOs Earnings Call Will Be Important to Watch
Chris Versace
7 hours ago
Most retirement calculators default to 10%. That is what the S&P 500 has averaged annually since 1957, and it has become the backbone of nearly
every retirement plan built in the last few decades. Run that number,
and $500,000 becomes roughly $1.3 million in ten years.
That 10% is not a forecast. It is a rearview mirror. And the two firms managing more retirement money than almost anyone else in America have
clearly said they donrCOt expect the next decade to look like the last one.
Fidelity and Vanguard arenrCOt predicting a crash. What theyrCOre saying is almost more unsettling: plan for about half of what your calculator assumes.
What Fidelity and Vanguard are forecasting
VanguardrCOs latest market outlook, updated through September, puts U.S.
stock returns between 4.8% and 6.8% per year over the next decade. The midpoint of that range is 5.8%.
Also read: Social Security just changed for anyone nearing retirement
FidelityrCOs capital market assumptions use a 20-year horizon rather than
a decade, and its expected annual return for U.S. stocks comes in at
5.8% as well. The two firms use fundamentally different methodologies
and model different time periods, yet arrived at the same projection.
ThatrCOs the kind of agreement between independent forecasts thatrCOs hard
to explain away.
Vanguard and Fidelity arenrCOt niche forecasters. Between them, they
manage retirement savings for a substantial portion of American
households. When two institutions that size independently come out with
the same number, itrCOs not something you read once and then go back to assuming 10%.
What lower stock returns cost your retirement
At 10% a year, $500,000 grows to roughly $1.3 million over ten years. At
5%, it reaches about $814,000. ThatrCOs nearly $480,000 less from the same starting amount, over the same time period, just because the return
assumption is different.
If your retirement plan is built on 10% growth and you get 5%, you donrCOt just retire with less. You retire with a plan that never accounted for
what actually happened to your money.
And the closer you are to retirement, the less room you have to course-correct. At 10 to 15 years out, you can save more, work longer,
or reset the target. At five years out, those options narrow fast.
Senior Couple Reviewing Retirement Plan on Tablet
Neither Vanguard nor Fidelity is telling you to sell your stocks. Both
still expect equities to outperform bonds over the long run.
Anchiy / Getty Images
Why experts expect below-average stock returns
U.S. stocks are expensive by most historical measures. When valuations
are elevated, forward returns tend to be lower. ThererCOs less room for
prices to run when buyers have already paid a premium. ThatrCOs not a prediction. ItrCOs just how the math has worked consistently in long-run market data, and both Vanguard and Fidelity build it into their models.
Earnings growth has also moderated from the pace of the 2010s. That
decade produced an unusual combination of cheap borrowing, expanding
profit margins and aggressive share buybacks that pushed corporate
earnings well above their long-run trend. That backdrop is harder to
repeat in the current environment.
Interest rates are part of the picture too. For most of the past 15
years, near-zero rates pushed investors into equities because bonds
offered almost nothing in return. ThatrCOs no longer the case. Bonds now compete with stocks for capital in ways they havenrCOt in over a decade,
and that competition limits how aggressively equity prices need to run
to attract buyers.
How to adjust your retirement plan now
Neither Vanguard nor Fidelity is telling you to sell your stocks. Both
still expect equities to outperform bonds over the long run. But the
return gap between the two has narrowed, and that changes some of the
planning assumptions that may have governed your portfolio for years.
Start with what yourCOre taking out each year. The 4% withdrawal rule was designed for a world where stocks averaged around 10%. At 5% or 6%,
pulling 4% out every year, no matter what, is a good way to run short
before you expected to. Most financial planners have shifted toward a
flexible withdrawal strategy, somewhere in the 2% to 5% range, adjusted
based on what markets are actually doing rather than a rate you
committed to on day one of retirement.
More Retirement:
Annuities can be a retirement safety net to prevent outliving savings
Vanguard flags a retirement fear built into 401(k) plans
Suze Orman has a serious retirement warning for 2027
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2