• CBS Daytime Is Remembering the Most Valuable Thing a Soap Can Have: Women With History

    From mummycullen@mummycullen@gmail-dot-com.no-spam.invalid (MummyChunk) to rec.arts.tv.soaps.cbs on Tue Oct 20 12:33:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.tv.soaps.cbs

    CBS Daytime Is Remembering the Most Valuable Thing a Soap Can Have: Women With History

    The Young and the Restless, The Bold and the Beautiful and Beyond the Gates are very different soaps, but all three are demonstrating the same useful truth: a woman does not become less interesting after twenty, thirty or forty. On a soap opera, everything she has already survived should make her more interesting.

    rCo rCo rCo

    There is an advantage soap operas possess that almost no other form of television can duplicate.

    Time.

    Not a two-hour movie. Not eight episodes released on a streaming service and forgotten eighteen months later. Daytime can let a character accumulate a life in front of us, sometimes for decades, until a single look across a room carries more information than another program could fit into an entire flashback.

    CBS currently has three daytime dramas using that advantage in noticeably different ways.

    On The Young and the Restless, Sharon, Nikki, Phyllis and Victoria are still making decisions that reshape families and reopen history rather than simply advising the generation behind them. On The Bold and the Beautiful, Brooke and Katie are discovering that decades of sisterhood do not guarantee they will always understand each other, while Steffy is making choices in her marriage that cannot be separated from everything she has learned about family and control.

    Then there is Beyond the Gates, the newest soap of the three, which did something interesting from its beginning. It did not construct a new daytime world around twenty-somethings and then wait twenty years for them to acquire history. Anita, Dani, Nicole and the other Dupree women arrived with marriages, careers, children, mistakes, grudges and memories already behind them.

    That matters because one of the peculiar strengths of a soap opera is that history does not have to be an obstacle to new story.

    History is story.

    The best soap characters do not outgrow drama. They accumulate reasons for the next drama to hurt more.

    rCo rCo rCo

    Sharon Newman is more interesting now because we remember 1994

    Consider what The Young and the Restless is currently asking Sharon to do.

    Matt Clark has been pulled back into her life, and Sharon has been placed in the extraordinary position of deciding how much compassion, professional responsibility and personal risk she is willing to extend toward a man connected to one of the darkest periods of her youth.

    For a newer viewer, Matt can simply function as a dangerous man from Sharon's past.

    For somebody who remembers the history, there is another layer entirely.

    Matt was part of Sharon's life when she was a teenager. He sexually assaulted her, tormented her relationship with Nick, weaponized secrets from her past and later returned under another identity to cause still more damage. The current story therefore does not need to manufacture a reason for Sharon to be conflicted. The reason has been sitting inside the character for more than thirty years.

    That is a tremendous dramatic resource.

    The CBS episode guide has recently described Sharon as being forced to make a difficult decision while the Matt story continues:

    https://www.cbs.com/shows/the_young_and_the_restless/episodes/

    What makes the situation interesting is not simply whether Matt can be trusted. I am not particularly eager to trust him with the silverware.

    The more interesting question belongs to Sharon.

    After everything she has survived, who does she believe herself to be now?

    Is compassion evidence of strength, or can compassion become a way of putting herself back in danger? Does becoming a therapist change the way she responds to somebody who traumatized her before she had the tools she possesses today? Can she acknowledge whatever has happened to Matt without allowing his problems to consume her life again?

    A thirty-year history gives those questions weight.

    The younger Sharon could only react to Matt.

    The woman she has become can decide what access he gets to her now.

    That is character development in the most literal sense. The same people can stand in a room decades later, but they are no longer having the same scene.

    rCo rCo rCo

    Phyllis and Nikki have not been converted into furniture either

    This is equally important.

    Long-running soaps have sometimes fallen into the habit of moving veteran women into a vaguely ceremonial position. They become mothers who worry, grandmothers who dispense advice, or familiar faces brought out for weddings and holidays so the audience can say how nice it is to see them.

    There is nothing wrong with any of those functions occasionally.

    The problem comes when that is all they are permitted to do.

    Phyllis Summers has fortunately never shown much interest in becoming decorative.

    She is still taking risks, interfering where she should probably not interfere, forming alliances other people regard as questionable and making decisions that may prove brilliant, disastrous or both at once.

    That is exactly what Phyllis should be doing.

    The value of a character such as Phyllis is not that viewers always approve of her. Half the entertainment lies in watching her explain why whatever alarming thing she is doing is completely reasonable if everyone else would simply stop being idiots for five minutes.

    Nikki has a different energy, but she too remains part of the machinery of the Newman family rather than merely its portrait on the wall. Her history with Victor, her children, addiction, illness and the battles that have accumulated around that family give her authority, but they also give her vulnerabilities that can still be used dramatically.

    Victoria occupies yet another position. She has been daughter, wife, mother, executive, rival and Newman heir for so long that almost every major decision she makes carries echoes of an earlier version of herself.

    That is the reward for keeping characters alive instead of constantly replacing them.

    A twenty-five-year-old can make a terrible decision.

    A character we have watched for thirty years can make a terrible decision and cause us to remember six previous terrible decisions, the lesson she supposedly learned from each one and the reason she is somehow doing it again.

    That is soap opera.

    rCo rCo rCo

    The Logan sisters are more interesting when loving each other does not solve everything

    Over on The Bold and the Beautiful, Brooke and Katie are currently providing another version of the same idea.

    Their relationship has survived an absurd amount of history.

    Men have passed through the Logan family in configurations that would require a whiteboard to explain safely. Brooke and Katie have hurt one another, forgiven one another, supported one another and spent years believing that whatever happened, the identity of being Logan sisters would eventually pull them back together.

    Now the show is allowing that assumption to become less comfortable.

    Katie has changed.

    That does not necessarily mean she has become a villain, and I hope the story resists the temptation to flatten her into one. She has spent much of her life being viewed in relation to Brooke, Bill, Ridge, Donna, her son or whichever larger personality happened to be occupying the center of the room.

    A Katie who finally decides she is finished accepting that position is potentially fascinating.

    Brooke, meanwhile, can genuinely love her sister and still fail to understand why Katie no longer wants the arrangement Brooke believes should satisfy her.

    CBS's October 19 description put the emotional distance plainly: Brooke feels more disconnected from Katie than ever.

    https://www.cbs.com/shows/the_bold_and_the_beautiful/episodes/

    That is much richer than manufacturing another argument between sisters who met last year.

    When Brooke and Katie hurt each other, decades come into the room with them.

    They remember who was there during illnesses, betrayals, marriages, births and disasters. They know each other's weaknesses, and sometimes they know those weaknesses well enough to use them.

    Forgiveness can become harder, not easier, after people have forgiven each other repeatedly.

    At some point somebody asks whether the same pattern is being repaired or merely restarted.

    That is a very adult question for a soap to ask.

    rCo rCo rCo

    Steffy is old enough now to become the person she once argued with

    Steffy's current story offers another benefit of long-form storytelling.

    Characters eventually move into roles once occupied by the generation above them.

    Steffy began as the younger Forrester woman pushing against parents and grandparents whose decisions governed her world. She now has children, a marriage, enormous family responsibilities and enough authority that her own choices can destabilize the people around her.

    That transition is one of the things soaps can do beautifully when they allow it to happen gradually.

    A character who once complained about being controlled eventually discovers herself keeping secrets because she believes she knows what is best for everybody.

    A daughter becomes the mother.

    A rebel becomes the person protecting the institution.

    The interesting part is not pointing at the hypocrisy and shouting, "Gotcha."

    People actually do this.

    We spend our youth recognizing every mistake our parents make and part of adulthood discovering why they made some of them.

    Steffy's present difficulty with Finn works better when viewed through that accumulation. She is not simply a wife who made a questionable decision. She is somebody who has spent years watching secrecy, control and family loyalty collide, yet can still convince herself that this secret or this decision is different because she understands the stakes better than everybody else.

    Perhaps she does.

    That uncertainty is where the story lives.

    rCo rCo rCo

    Beyond the Gates understood something important from its first episode

    The most interesting comparison may be with Beyond the Gates because that show cannot rely on fifty years of audience memory.

    It premiered in 2025.

    It has had to manufacture emotional depth much faster than Y&R or B&B.

    Its solution was smart: begin with people who already had lives.

    Anita and Vernon Dupree did not arrive as newlyweds discovering adulthood. They arrived as the heads of a family that already had expectations, tensions, adult children and a public identity.

    Dani did not enter Fairmont Crest waiting for her first romance. She brought a marriage that had collapsed, daughters with opinions, a public past and enough emotional debris to furnish several houses.

    Nicole was already accomplished, already married, already a mother and already carrying assumptions about the life she thought she had built.

    Leslie arrived carrying an entirely different kind of history.

    Because of that structure, Beyond the Gates was able to feel like a soap with a past before viewers had actually watched that past happen.

    Creator Michele Val Jean recently explained that she prefers to let character lead her plotting, asking what makes sense for a particular character and what might shake up that person's world.

    That interview is worth reading because it describes much of what the show does well:

    https://www.tvinsider.com/1295846/beyond-the-gates-fall-2026-preview-storylines-spoilers/

    You can see the approach in the current episodes.

    Nicole is not simply being assigned a new romantic complication because the script needs romance on Tuesday. What happens with Ted, Shanice and Kial matters because it collides with the life Nicole thought she understood.

    Dani's story works because Bill is not simply an ex-husband. He is part of the architecture of her adult life, including the family they created and the humiliation that came when that marriage exploded.

    Anita can worry about her daughters, but she has her own emotional existence too.

    That last part is especially important.

    A matriarch should not become a customer-service desk for everyone else's plots.

    She should still be capable of having a bad day of her own.

    rCo rCo rCo

    This may be the thing streaming television still cannot manufacture

    Modern television is very good at creating instantly compelling characters.

    What it cannot easily create is the strange intimacy that develops when an audience has watched somebody for thousands of episodes.

    You remember hairstyles.

    Husbands.

    Enemies.

    Children who somehow became thirty while you were making lunch.

    You remember the terrible house they lived in before they became rich, the affair they swore would never happen, the illness everybody thought would kill them, and the person they insisted they had finally stopped loving.

    That accumulation changes how we watch.

    When Brooke says something to Katie, longtime viewers are not merely processing the sentence being spoken that afternoon. They are unconsciously comparing it with hundreds of earlier conversations between the sisters.

    When Sharon has to look at Matt, people who watched them in the 1990s bring something to the scene that no recap can completely reproduce.

    Even Beyond the Gates, despite its youth, understands the principle. Give the audience enough detail about who these people were before we met them, then allow that past to exert pressure on the present.

    Soap opera history works almost like compound interest.

    The longer a character remains viable, the more dramatic value the show can draw from what has already happened.

    Throwing that away simply because a character reaches some arbitrary age makes no sense.

    rCo rCo rCo

    There is a difference between honoring a veteran and actually writing for her

    Soap fans are understandably sentimental about familiar faces.

    A beloved performer can return for a wedding, receive applause online and disappear after saying three lines.

    That can be pleasant.

    It is not the same as story.

    Real respect for a veteran character means allowing her to be difficult again.

    Let her make the wrong choice.

    Let her want something inconvenient.

    Let her be selfish, romantic, jealous, ambitious, frightened, sexual, ridiculous, insightful and occasionally infuriating.

    Do not turn her into the person who appears whenever somebody younger requires advice.

    That is why the current CBS lineup is interesting to compare.

    Sharon's judgment can be questioned.

    Phyllis can still make everybody nervous.

    Brooke can be wrong about Katie.

    Katie can become harder than Brooke expected.

    Steffy can make a decision Finn hates.

    Dani can be gloriously messy.

    Nicole can discover that knowing exactly what everybody else should do is much easier than deciding what she wants for herself.

    Anita can remain a mother without ceasing to be Anita.

    None of these women needs to become perfect in order to become important.

    Actually, perfection would ruin most of them.

    rCo rCo rCo

    The next generation benefits when the previous one refuses to disappear

    There is sometimes a false choice in soap discussions between using veteran characters and developing younger ones.

    The best soaps have never required that choice.

    You develop younger characters by putting them into meaningful relationships with people who have history.

    A child rebelling against a mother means more when the mother has flaws we already understand.

    A young executive challenging a family institution becomes richer when viewers remember who built the institution and what it cost.

    A new romance gains complexity when one of the people involved comes with relatives who have spent thirty years remembering everything.

    Generations require one another.

    Otherwise a soap becomes a collection of people who happen to be the same age having interchangeable problems in adjacent rooms.

    CBS currently has the rare advantage of three dramas at three completely different stages of life.

    The Young and the Restless has been accumulating history since 1973.

    The Bold and the Beautiful has been doing it since 1987.

    Beyond the Gates is still writing the memories its viewers may be arguing about thirty years from now.

    Watching all three at once makes the lesson unusually visible.

    The veteran shows demonstrate what happens when characters are allowed to accumulate enormous emotional histories.

    The new show demonstrates how important it is to begin accumulating them immediately.

    rCo rCo rCo

    That may be daytime television's greatest surviving advantage

    Soap operas have lost networks, time slots, magazines and millions of viewers over the decades. They have been declared dead often enough that the obituary itself has become a daytime tradition.

    Yet there remains something the format can do extraordinarily well.

    It can let a person have a life.

    Not merely a character arc with a beginning, middle and finale, but an untidy life in which old wounds reopen, former enemies become friends, lovers become strangers, children become parents and the person we thought we understood surprises us because another ten years have passed.

    The women at the center of CBS daytime right now illustrate why that is worth preserving.

    Their histories are not burdens the writers need to explain away before getting to the new story.

    Their histories are what make the new story possible.

    A younger Sharon could be frightened of Matt Clark.

    The Sharon who has lived thirty additional years has to decide what that frightened young woman means to the person she is now.

    Brooke and Katie can argue about today's problem while carrying every previous version of their sisterhood into the room.

    Anita, Dani and Nicole are already showing Beyond the Gates how quickly a new soap can feel inhabited when its women are allowed to arrive as fully formed adults rather than blank pages.

    That is why I hope all three shows keep leaning into this.

    Not nostalgia for nostalgia's sake, and not veteran appearances designed only to make longtime viewers clap.

    Use the history.

    Complicate it.

    Let people change without pretending they never were who we remember them being.

    A soap character should not become less valuable because she has been around long enough to have a past.

    The past is the most valuable thing she owns.


    View the attachments for this post at: http://www.jlaforums.com/viewtopic.php?p=712633930#712633930
    --
    Via JLA Forums web gateway for rec.arts.tv.soaps.cbs
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2