There's a new version of Treasure Island starring David Oyelowo as Long
John Silver and Haley Atwell as Jim Hawkins mother produced by
Paramount+ and MGM+. It's a six part limited series and I'm two parts
into it.
I've never read the book but I'm pretty sure I saw at least part of the
1950 Disney version of the story when I was a kid. I've also skimmed the Wikipedia article about the book.
Several aspects of the new version struck me as completely unfamiliar
which is why I went to the Wikipedia article; it confirmed that these unfamiliar elements did NOT come from the book and they don't match my
very dim memory of the movie. This is my roundabout way of saying
they've taken a LOT of liberties with the story. The reviews at IMDB
echo this and note that there are many deviations from the book. It's probably why the IMDB rating for the new version is only 4.6 whereas the Disney version is 6.9.
So, the decision you need to make is whether you can watch this new
version and enjoy it as if it is not based on a familiar story or
whether the deviations would destroy your enjoyment. After two episodes,
I can say it's not horrible if you treat it as a separate story that
only coincidentally has things in common with the original story. If
you're a purist and wants a film adaptation that is very close to the original, you are likely to be disappointed by this version.
On 11/15/2026 6:19 PM, Rhino wrote:
There's a new version of Treasure Island starring David Oyelowo as Long
John Silver and Haley Atwell as Jim Hawkins mother produced by
Paramount+ and MGM+. It's a six part limited series and I'm two parts
into it.
I've never read the book but I'm pretty sure I saw at least part of the
1950 Disney version of the story when I was a kid. I've also skimmed
the Wikipedia article about the book.
Several aspects of the new version struck me as completely unfamiliar
which is why I went to the Wikipedia article; it confirmed that these
unfamiliar elements did NOT come from the book and they don't match my
very dim memory of the movie. This is my roundabout way of saying
they've taken a LOT of liberties with the story. The reviews at IMDB
echo this and note that there are many deviations from the book. It's
probably why the IMDB rating for the new version is only 4.6 whereas
the Disney version is 6.9.
So, the decision you need to make is whether you can watch this new
version and enjoy it as if it is not based on a familiar story or
whether the deviations would destroy your enjoyment. After two
episodes, I can say it's not horrible if you treat it as a separate
story that only coincidentally has things in common with the original
story. If you're a purist and wants a film adaptation that is very
close to the original, you are likely to be disappointed by this
version.
I've been watching it. I think it may be a continuation of the original story, of which I've only read an abridged version, and a long time
ago. In it Jim was very young, no older than 10, and possibly was taken
or a stowaway on the shiip. This seems like they're going back to find
the treasure because they didn't get it the first time.
There's a new version of Treasure Island starring David Oyelowo as Long
John Silver and Haley Atwell as Jim Hawkins mother produced by
Paramount+ and MGM+. It's a six part limited series and I'm two parts
into it.
I've never read the book
1950 Disney version of the story when I was a kid. I've also skimmed the Wikipedia article about the book.
Several aspects of the new version struck me as completely unfamiliar
which is why I went to the Wikipedia article; it confirmed that these unfamiliar elements did NOT come from the book and they don't match my
very dim memory of the movie. This is my roundabout way of saying
they've taken a LOT of liberties with the story. The reviews at IMDB
echo this and note that there are many deviations from the book. It's probably why the IMDB rating for the new version is only 4.6 whereas the Disney version is 6.9.
So, the decision you need to make is whether you can watch this new
version
whether the deviations would destroy your enjoyment. After two episodes,
I can say it's not horrible if you treat it as a separate story that
only coincidentally has things in common with the original story. If
you're a purist and wants a film adaptation that is very close to the original, you are likely to be disappointed by this version.
I had a bizarre conversation recently, with somebody who is of the opinion that you shouldnrCOt do a version without changing it wildly; that thererCOs no
point in being faithful.
I suppose I would endorse that more readily if faithful versions had been done before, but there are so few of those that I would think the main
point in redoing a classic is to do the first faithful version.
anim8rfsk <anim8rfsk@cox.net> wrote:
I had a bizarre conversation recently, with somebody who is of the
opinion that you shouldn't do a version without changing it wildly;
that there's no point in being faithful.
I suppose I would endorse that more readily if faithful versions had been >>done before, but there are so few of those that I would think the main >>point in redoing a classic is to do the first faithful version.
I think if I was a famous author like Stephen King or JK Rowling, I'd
require a clause in any adaptation rights contract that gave me final
script approval and maybe even some kind of casting approval to keep them >from wildly changing my story and to let me veto all the race and gender >swapping crap that Hollywood is obsessed with.
If they won't sign that contract then they can't use my book.
anim8rfsk <anim8rfsk@cox.net> wrote:
I had a bizarre conversation recently, with somebody who is of the opinion >> that you shouldnrCOt do a version without changing it wildly; that thererCOs no
point in being faithful.
I suppose I would endorse that more readily if faithful versions had been
done before, but there are so few of those that I would think the main
point in redoing a classic is to do the first faithful version.
I think if I was a famous author like Stephen King or JK Rowling, I'd
require a clause in any adaptation rights contract that gave me final
script approval and maybe even some kind of casting approval to keep them from wildly changing my story and to let me veto all the race and gender swapping crap that Hollywood is obsessed with.
If they won't sign that contract then they can't use my book.
BTR1701 <no_email@invalid.invalid> wrote:
anim8rfsk <anim8rfsk@cox.net> wrote:
I had a bizarre conversation recently, with somebody who is of the
opinion that you shouldn't do a version without changing it wildly;
that there's no point in being faithful.
I suppose I would endorse that more readily if faithful versions had been >>> done before, but there are so few of those that I would think the main
point in redoing a classic is to do the first faithful version.
I think if I was a famous author like Stephen King or JK Rowling, I'd
require a clause in any adaptation rights contract that gave me final
script approval and maybe even some kind of casting approval to keep them >>from wildly changing my story and to let me veto all the race and gender
swapping crap that Hollywood is obsessed with.
If they won't sign that contract then they can't use my book.
"If you go away, we'll let you supervise wardrobe of all the young
nubile supporting actresses."
The most faithful adaptation ever was The Manchurian Candidate. There
were still changes and entire major characters dropped. But the novel's
best dialogue ended up word for word in the shooting script.
The counter example is Hitchcock, who was never faithful to source
material. It's unlikely you have objections.
I'm not aware King ever had such a clause. The Lawnmower Man?
Rowling clearly supervised the movie scripts as she was still writing
the novels and couldn't afford divergence.
Here's another counter example. Ian Fleming objected to the casting of
Sean Connery; he envisioned David Niven. When Fleming, the consumate
English snob, saw the box office returns for Dr. No, suddenly, one of
the late novels had retconned Bond's backstory. He was now Scottish.
BTR1701 <no_email@invalid.invalid> wrote:
anim8rfsk <anim8rfsk@cox.net> wrote:
I had a bizarre conversation recently, with somebody who is of the
opinion that you shouldn't do a version without changing it wildly;
that there's no point in being faithful.
I suppose I would endorse that more readily if faithful versions had been >>> done before, but there are so few of those that I would think the main
point in redoing a classic is to do the first faithful version.
I think if I was a famous author like Stephen King or JK Rowling, I'd
require a clause in any adaptation rights contract that gave me final
script approval and maybe even some kind of casting approval to keep them
from wildly changing my story and to let me veto all the race and gender
swapping crap that Hollywood is obsessed with.
If they won't sign that contract then they can't use my book.
"If you go away, we'll let you supervise wardrobe of all the young
nubile supporting actresses."
The most faithful adaptation ever was The Manchurian Candidate. There
were still changes and entire major characters dropped. But the novel's
best dialogue ended up word for word in the shooting script.
The counter example is Hitchcock, who was never faithful to source
material. It's unlikely you have objections.
I'm not aware King ever had such a clause. The Lawnmower Man?
Rowling clearly supervised the movie scripts as she was still writing
the novels and couldn't afford divergence.
Here's another counter example. Ian Fleming objected to the casting of
Sean Connery; he envisioned David Niven. When Fleming, the consumate
English snob, saw the box office returns for Dr. No, suddenly, one of
the late novels had retconned Bond's backstory. He was now Scottish.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:34:19 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |