From Newsgroup: rec.arts.startrek.misc

AI/LLM Reviews of Star Trek - Deep Space Nine - Progress

Google Gemini

The episode centers on Major Kira Nerys being assigned a difficult task by the Provisional Bajoran Government: convincing three elderly Bajoran farmers, led by the stubborn Mullibok, to evacuate their remote valley on the moon Andros. The government needs to convert the moon's atmosphere into a stable geothermal energy source to alleviate Bajor's severe power crisis, but the conversion process will make the valley uninhabitable.

Kira, a former Resistance fighter, finds herself uncomfortably positioned as the enforcer of the state against her own people, who remind her of her past fight against Cardassian oppression. Mullibok refuses all offers of relocation, viewing his connection to the land and his independence as non-negotiable.

The conflict forces Kira to confront the difference between fighting for Bajor's freedom (the Resistance) and governing Bajor (the Provisional Government). When her attempts to persuade Mullibok fail and the government insists the project must proceed, Kira makes a dramatic choice, demonstrating where her loyalties ultimately lie: with the individual's right to self-determination over the cold needs of state "progress."

The subplot features a light-hearted diversion where Quark attempts to turn a profit by secretly cleaning out and subletting an old cargo bay, enlisting the reluctant help of Chief O'Brien and Doctor Bashir.

Strengths

Kira's Defining Conflict: This episode is a brilliant character study for Kira. She sees her own past defiance mirrored in Mullibok's stubborn independence. Her internal struggle is intense as she must choose between her sworn duty to the new government and her deeply held principles of justice for the common people.

Thematic Depth: "Progress" masterfully explores the moral tightrope of post-war nation-building. It asks fundamental questions about the price of progress, the concept of eminent domain, and whether the needs of the many truly outweigh the rights of the few. The Bajoran government is portrayed realistically as flawed but necessity-driven, not simply evil.

Mullibok's Character: Mullibok is a powerful adversary because he argues from a position of moral and historical legitimacy. His interactions with Kira create a deep, generational tension.

The Climax: KirarCOs choice to destroy the power generator rather than betray Mullibok (and her own history) is one of the most memorable moments of DS9's early seasons, cementing her as a fiercely principled character.

Weaknesses

Disconnected Subplot: While the B-plot with Quark, O'Brien, and Bashir is humorous, it serves only as comic relief and provides no real thematic connection to KirarCOs intense ethical dilemma.

Overall Impression

"Progress" is a cornerstone episode of Deep Space Nine, defining the show's willingness to engage with morally ambiguous political issues. It showcases the messy reality of governing and the personal toll it takes on a former revolutionary like Kira Nerys. The emotional weight and ethical complexity make this a superb piece of television.

Rating: 8.2/10

ChatGPT

HererCOs a full review of ***Star Trek: Deep Space Nine rCo rCLProgressrCY***, based on the episode transcript at [chakoteya.net/DS9/415.htm](http://www.chakoteya.net/DS9/415.htm).

---

## Ef-E Summary

In *rCLProgressrCY*, Major **Kira Nerys** is sent to the moon of **Jeraddo**, where a Bajoran government project plans to tap geothermal energy by evacuating the small remaining population. ThererCOs only one holdout: **Mullibok**, an old, stubborn farmer who refuses to leave the home he built with his own hands during the Cardassian Occupation.

As Kira tries to convince him to evacuate peacefully, she finds herself drawn to his quiet defiance rCo a mirror of her own rebellious spirit. Meanwhile, **Nog** and **Jake** run a side story about trading **yamok sauce** (a Cardassian delicacy) for profit, a lighthearted counterbalance to KirarCOs emotional conflict.

When diplomacy fails, Kira ultimately takes a wrenching moral stand: she **destroys MullibokrCOs home** to force him to leave, realizing that progress sometimes means painful loss.

---

## EfA! Analysis

### 1. **A Deeply Human Story About Change and Identity**

rCLProgressrCY is one of *DS9*rCOs first truly **character-driven moral dramas**, and it hits home because it confronts a question Star Trek rarely explores so directly: *what happens after the revolution?*

Mullibok represents the **old Bajor** rCo proud, independent, and scarred by occupation. Kira, once a guerrilla fighter, now serves that same government, tasked with enforcing its decisions. The episode becomes a meditation on **moral compromise**, as Kira faces what it means to trade resistance for responsibility.

rCLI spent most of my life fighting people like me rCo and now IrCOve become one of them.rCY
rCo Kira

That line captures the tragic irony of postwar change.

---

### 2. **KirarCOs Best Episode (So Far)**

Nana Visitor delivers a **superb performance**, layering anger, empathy, and sorrow. Kira isnrCOt written as a hero here; sherCOs torn, self-contradictory, and painfully human.

Her scenes with Mullibok are intimate and beautifully acted. What begins as frustration grows into quiet affection rCo not romantic, but **spiritual kinship**. She sees her own past reflected in him, which makes her ultimate decision all the more devastating.

This episode **cements Kira as one of Star TrekrCOs richest characters**, moving her from fiery resistance fighter to morally complex leader.

---

### 3. **Mullibok rCo A Perfect Foil**

Mullibok (played with gruff charm by **Brian Keith**) is both sympathetic and infuriating. HerCOs a proud man, refusing to be displaced again after surviving the Occupation. His stubbornness borders on foolishness, yet itrCOs rooted in dignity and trauma.

He doesnrCOt hate Kira rCo he *understands* her. Their conversations about home, purpose, and freedom are among *DS9*rCOs most emotionally honest exchanges.

rCLYou can burn my home, girl. But you canrCOt burn me.rCY

That line hits like a gut punch.

---

### 4. **The Jake and Nog Subplot rCo Light but Thematically Relevant**

The boysrCO **yamok sauce** subplot is comic relief, yet it fits neatly into the larger theme: the art of **adaptation**. Jake and Nog learn to navigate commerce, trade, and Ferengi-style opportunism rCo the **next generation adjusting to a changing Bajor**.

ItrCOs one of the early hints that **Nog** has an entrepreneurial spark that will one day make him StarfleetrCOs first Ferengi officer.

---

### 5. **Direction and Atmosphere**

Director **David Carson** gives the episode a moody, grounded tone. The Jeraddo sets feel earthy and lived-in, with subdued lighting that matches the melancholy subject matter.

The episode doesnrCOt rely on action or effects rCo itrCOs **quiet Star Trek**, driven by dialogue and moral tension.

---

## rUaN+A Weak Points

* The **evacuation premise** (a moon being destroyed for energy extraction) feels a bit forced and underexplained.
* Some viewers may find the **slow pacing** overly contemplative.
* The **Jake/Nog** story, while pleasant, slightly undercuts the emotional weight of the main plot near the midpoint.

Still, these are minor issues in an otherwise emotionally mature episode.

---

## Efo! Themes

* **Progress vs. Tradition** rCo What is sacrificed in the name of advancement? * **Personal freedom vs. collective responsibility** rCo When does stubbornness become self-destruction?
* **Post-war identity** rCo How do you redefine yourself after your cause is gone?
* **Empathy and moral duty** rCo Kira must act against her heart to do whatrCOs right for her people.

---

## Efif Standout Moments

* Kira quietly eating with Mullibok by candlelight rCo a perfect blend of warmth and tension.
* MullibokrCOs final defiant lines as his home burns.
* KirarCOs tearful decision to torch the house rCo one of *DS9*rCOs most powerful early emotional climaxes.
* The closing scene, where she stays with Mullibok in silence, wordlessly accepting her guilt and duty.

---

## Efuu Final Rating: **9 / 10**

**Verdict:**
*rCLProgressrCY* is a **masterful early DS9 episode**, balancing moral complexity, character development, and emotional realism. It deepens KirarCOs character, challenges idealistic notions of progress, and captures the heart of what makes *Deep Space Nine* distinct from other Trek series rCo its willingness to dwell in moral grayness.

**In short:**
EfoN *Kira learns that duty sometimes means destruction.*
EfAo *Emotionally raw, morally complex, and beautifully acted.*
r!E **Rating:** **9 / 10** rCo *A quiet classic and an essential Kira episode.* --
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant
--- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2