• RI recent times: Ciaphas Cain

    From ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan@tednolan to rec.arts.sf.written on Sat Nov 7 06:45:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.written

    Still don't have the energy to do catchup monthlies yet, but
    here's a series I quite enjoyed over the summer & fall.

    As usual, the links are Amazon affiliate ones which could in theory
    earn me something should you enter the store that way.

    =======
    Hero of the Imperium (Ciaphas Cain Book 1)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B07YW1Les

    Defender of the Imperium (Ciaphas Cain Book 2)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B0dCe0dcb

    Saviour of the Imperium (Ciaphas Cain)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B0hwVOXrx

    Vainglorious (Ciaphas Cain: Warhammer 40,000 Book 11)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B07qiha3O

    Ciaphas Cain: The Anthology (Ciaphas Cain: Warhammer 40,000)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B08Sn15CA

    It is the 41st millennium. For more than a hundred centuries
    the Emperor has sat immobile on the Golden Throne of Earth.
    He is the Master of Mankind by the will of the gods, and
    master of a million worlds by the might of His inexhaustible
    armies. He is a rotting carcass writhing invisibly with
    power from the Dark Age of Technology. He is the Carrion
    Lord of the Imperium for whom a thousand souls are sacrificed
    every day, so that He may never truly die.

    Yet even in His deathless state, the Emperor continues His
    eternal vigilance. Mighty battlefleets cross the daemon-infested
    miasma of the warp, the only route between distant stars,
    their way lit by the Astronomican, the psychic manifestation
    of the Emperor's will. Vast armies give battle in His name
    on uncounted worlds. Greatest amongst His soldiers are the
    Adeptus Astartes, the Space Marines, bio-engineered
    super-warriors. Their comrades in arms are legion: the Astra
    Militarum and countless planetary defense forces, the
    ever-vigilant Inquisition and the tech-priests of the Adeptus
    Mechanicus to name only a few. But for all their multitudes,
    they are barely enough to hold off the ever-present threat
    from aliens, heretics, mutants -- and worse.

    To be a man in such times is to be one amongst untold
    billions. It is to live in the cruellest and most bloody
    regime imaginable. These are the tales of those times.
    Forget the power of technology and science, for so much has
    been forgotten, never to be re-learned. Forget the promise
    of progress and understanding, for in the grim dark future
    there is only war. There is no peace amongst the stars,
    only an eternity of carnage and slaughter, and the laughter
    of thirsting gods.

    So, let's have a lighthearted adventure series!

    To make Ciaphas Cain, Sandy Mitchell (a pen name for Alex Stewart)
    has taken a bit of Flashman, dollops of Black Adder, "The Spectre
    General", "Retief", "Judge Dredd", "Flandry" & a pinch of _Dune_
    (for spice) and shaken them together to make one of the more unlikely
    heroes of milsf...Not that Cain would agree with that designation.
    At all.

    Ciaphas Cain is a man of somewhat enigmatic origins. We know he
    grew up a Hiveworlder, a native of one of those teaming Trantoresque
    planets where uncounted billions live burrowed from the surface to
    miles deep in layer upon layer descending from as-good-as-it-gets
    into total squalor. Or at least that's what he says, and it seems
    to be so, but he's careful never to actually name the world, and
    as his editor points out, certain other details that he gives us just
    can't be true.

    Whatever his exact circumstances, we know the Imperium reached out
    for him, placed him in a state Schola and trained him as a Commissar,
    something not at all to his liking, but in the more-or-less fascist
    Warhammer 40K setting, there is no "I would prefer not" when the Emperor
    calls.

    As a Commissar, Cain is part of the military, but outside of the
    chain of command. He's a political officer present to ensure loyalty
    to the state (not a big problem with his units) and discipline the
    troops when necessary (a bit more of one, soldiers being soldiers).
    Technically he doesn't actually have the authority to lead troops,
    but since he *does* have the authority to shoot whoever he wants,
    the former kind of comes as a corollary to the later. (He *is*
    deeply conscious that Commissars who ride the troops too hard tend
    to die heroically as the only casualties of unexpected battles with
    no official video...)

    Not that he *wants* to lead troops. As far as Ciaphas Cain is
    concerned, he is a rank coward, and would much rather sit in a swank
    hotel well behind the lines, playing cards, surrounded by young
    women (or later one woman) & old whiskey. But as mentioned, Cain
    is not a fully reliable narrator, and that's not entirely true.
    Well, it certainly *is* true that Cain would much rather avoid
    trouble, but when he is forced into the field, and he inevitably
    is, his constant need to assign base motives to his every action
    rings hollow after a while, and you come to realize that the measure
    of a man is not what he thinks, or why he does something, but *what*
    he does, and Ciaphas Cain, however much he would laugh at the idea,
    is a Hero of the Imperium.

    The Warhammer 40K setting, at least as reflected in the Cain stories,
    is kind of an ongoing, permanent Third Century Crisis with the
    Imperium besieged on all sides by Tyranids, Gene Stealers, Chaos
    Cults, Orks, Eldar, Necrons & The Tau. The point of view that
    Mitchell adapts is that the Imperium is strict, but that it has to
    be because falling away from the Emperor always results in disaster,
    as we see time and again. Cain and his troops aren't exactly the
    Good Guys (the only really good guys are the Tau), but for the
    citizenry, they are Orwell's "rough men [who] stand ready to do
    violence on their behalf". While Cain (in his very English manner)
    has no use for the Emperor Botherers who abound in the power
    structure, he is pious in his own way (and pretty sure the Emperor
    has a nasty sense of humor), and believes in his society even while
    we would look askance at a good bit of it.

    These novels (and short stories) are told in the first person by
    Cain, writing for his own amusement during his retirement, well
    after publishing his *official* memoirs, and represent his (sometimes
    flawed) idea of "what really happened". They tell (not in order)
    of his first days in the field with the Valhallan Artillery ("If I
    arrange to join an Artillery corps, I'll be well behind the lines..."),
    with a new Valhallan regiment (whose winning culture he shapes
    mostly by accident), operating as a Commissariat troubleshooter, as
    General's liaison, and in his semi-retirement teaching the next
    generation of Commissars at an Imperial Schola (closing the circle
    more or less). These secret histories are edited by his longtime
    lover, Inquisitor Amberley, whose acerbic footnotes dot the pages,
    pointing out when Cain is lying, wrong, or just too hard on himself,
    detailing what was happening across the field in other places during
    Cain's adventures, and occasionally just being catty.

    As author, Mitchell is not afraid to throw in movie references,
    obscure jokes you only get hours later (*Who* files Amberley's
    ship!?), and the occasional "Aside From That Mrs. Lincoln..", while
    keeping the action moving right along. I called it milsf, but
    really as Warhammer 40K tech is not much advanced from ours, and
    it's not really that much about strategy & tactics anyway, you could
    just call it (often comic) adventure and he does keep Cain & Jurgen
    moving right along.

    The typical Cain adventure starts with Cain congratulating himself
    on how he has definitely arranged to be well away from trouble
    on this mission, him immediately being proved spectacularly wrong,
    (often by the Cogboys poking at something they oughtn't..)
    and then he and his indispensable (if malodorous) batman Jurgen,
    blasting, chain-swording (a ridiculous weapon if there ever was one),
    and lasing their way through hordes of inexplicably appearing enemies
    while somehow rallying the troops to victory.

    What happens to Cain? Well, Amberley strongly implies he is dead,
    but we have also seen her lie whenever she felt it expedient, and
    she takes pains to mention that Cain was declared dead so many
    times that the Imperium has forbidden his death ever to be recorded
    again, so who knows? At any rate, we know she is still arranging
    his archives, and that he has dropped hints of stories not yet told.

    I believe these are the only books I have read due to seeing youtube
    filk videos on the overnight open-thread of a site I frequent. The
    first of these:

    "This Is Not A Plan" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BlW0FK8cPyE&pp=ygUSVGhpcyBpcyBub3QgYSBwbGFu

    drew me in, and I found these two from Amberley's point of view
    rather succinctly point out the contradictions of the man:

    "That's Not Quite What Happened, Commissar Cain" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nh2gc7vX0wM

    "A Great Man"
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lce_mKQQ1_A

    You will see differing counts of how many books are in the series.
    The first three I list here are omnibus volumes comprising several
    novels (and assorted short stories) in each. The next is the
    latest stand-alone novel, and the final one is an anthology of
    various short stories. I read these all at a sitting, but you might
    want to space them out some, as there is some repetition in the setups, introduction of Jurgen etc though it never rises to Dumarest levels.

    Anyway, I quite enjoyed these, and look forward to more of Cain's saga, including what he was doing on Holy Terra.
    --
    columbiaclosings.com
    What's not in Columbia anymore..
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Lynn McGuire@lynnmcguire5@gmail.com to rec.arts.sf.written on Sat Nov 7 00:55:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.written

    On 11/7/2026 12:45 AM, Ted Nolan <tednolan> wrote:
    Still don't have the energy to do catchup monthlies yet, but
    here's a series I quite enjoyed over the summer & fall.

    As usual, the links are Amazon affiliate ones which could in theory
    earn me something should you enter the store that way.

    =======
    Hero of the Imperium (Ciaphas Cain Book 1)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B07YW1Les

    Defender of the Imperium (Ciaphas Cain Book 2)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B0dCe0dcb

    Saviour of the Imperium (Ciaphas Cain)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B0hwVOXrx

    Vainglorious (Ciaphas Cain: Warhammer 40,000 Book 11)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B07qiha3O

    Ciaphas Cain: The Anthology (Ciaphas Cain: Warhammer 40,000)
    by Sandy Mitchell
    https://link.amazon/B08Sn15CA

    It is the 41st millennium. For more than a hundred centuries
    the Emperor has sat immobile on the Golden Throne of Earth.
    He is the Master of Mankind by the will of the gods, and
    master of a million worlds by the might of His inexhaustible
    armies. He is a rotting carcass writhing invisibly with
    power from the Dark Age of Technology. He is the Carrion
    Lord of the Imperium for whom a thousand souls are sacrificed
    every day, so that He may never truly die.

    Yet even in His deathless state, the Emperor continues His
    eternal vigilance. Mighty battlefleets cross the daemon-infested
    miasma of the warp, the only route between distant stars,
    their way lit by the Astronomican, the psychic manifestation
    of the Emperor's will. Vast armies give battle in His name
    on uncounted worlds. Greatest amongst His soldiers are the
    Adeptus Astartes, the Space Marines, bio-engineered
    super-warriors. Their comrades in arms are legion: the Astra
    Militarum and countless planetary defense forces, the
    ever-vigilant Inquisition and the tech-priests of the Adeptus
    Mechanicus to name only a few. But for all their multitudes,
    they are barely enough to hold off the ever-present threat
    from aliens, heretics, mutants -- and worse.

    To be a man in such times is to be one amongst untold
    billions. It is to live in the cruellest and most bloody
    regime imaginable. These are the tales of those times.
    Forget the power of technology and science, for so much has
    been forgotten, never to be re-learned. Forget the promise
    of progress and understanding, for in the grim dark future
    there is only war. There is no peace amongst the stars,
    only an eternity of carnage and slaughter, and the laughter
    of thirsting gods.

    So, let's have a lighthearted adventure series!

    To make Ciaphas Cain, Sandy Mitchell (a pen name for Alex Stewart)
    has taken a bit of Flashman, dollops of Black Adder, "The Spectre
    General", "Retief", "Judge Dredd", "Flandry" & a pinch of _Dune_
    (for spice) and shaken them together to make one of the more unlikely
    heroes of milsf...Not that Cain would agree with that designation.
    At all.

    Ciaphas Cain is a man of somewhat enigmatic origins. We know he
    grew up a Hiveworlder, a native of one of those teaming Trantoresque
    planets where uncounted billions live burrowed from the surface to
    miles deep in layer upon layer descending from as-good-as-it-gets
    into total squalor. Or at least that's what he says, and it seems
    to be so, but he's careful never to actually name the world, and
    as his editor points out, certain other details that he gives us just
    can't be true.

    Whatever his exact circumstances, we know the Imperium reached out
    for him, placed him in a state Schola and trained him as a Commissar, something not at all to his liking, but in the more-or-less fascist
    Warhammer 40K setting, there is no "I would prefer not" when the Emperor calls.

    As a Commissar, Cain is part of the military, but outside of the
    chain of command. He's a political officer present to ensure loyalty
    to the state (not a big problem with his units) and discipline the
    troops when necessary (a bit more of one, soldiers being soldiers). Technically he doesn't actually have the authority to lead troops,
    but since he *does* have the authority to shoot whoever he wants,
    the former kind of comes as a corollary to the later. (He *is*
    deeply conscious that Commissars who ride the troops too hard tend
    to die heroically as the only casualties of unexpected battles with
    no official video...)

    Not that he *wants* to lead troops. As far as Ciaphas Cain is
    concerned, he is a rank coward, and would much rather sit in a swank
    hotel well behind the lines, playing cards, surrounded by young
    women (or later one woman) & old whiskey. But as mentioned, Cain
    is not a fully reliable narrator, and that's not entirely true.
    Well, it certainly *is* true that Cain would much rather avoid
    trouble, but when he is forced into the field, and he inevitably
    is, his constant need to assign base motives to his every action
    rings hollow after a while, and you come to realize that the measure
    of a man is not what he thinks, or why he does something, but *what*
    he does, and Ciaphas Cain, however much he would laugh at the idea,
    is a Hero of the Imperium.

    The Warhammer 40K setting, at least as reflected in the Cain stories,
    is kind of an ongoing, permanent Third Century Crisis with the
    Imperium besieged on all sides by Tyranids, Gene Stealers, Chaos
    Cults, Orks, Eldar, Necrons & The Tau. The point of view that
    Mitchell adapts is that the Imperium is strict, but that it has to
    be because falling away from the Emperor always results in disaster,
    as we see time and again. Cain and his troops aren't exactly the
    Good Guys (the only really good guys are the Tau), but for the
    citizenry, they are Orwell's "rough men [who] stand ready to do
    violence on their behalf". While Cain (in his very English manner)
    has no use for the Emperor Botherers who abound in the power
    structure, he is pious in his own way (and pretty sure the Emperor
    has a nasty sense of humor), and believes in his society even while
    we would look askance at a good bit of it.

    These novels (and short stories) are told in the first person by
    Cain, writing for his own amusement during his retirement, well
    after publishing his *official* memoirs, and represent his (sometimes
    flawed) idea of "what really happened". They tell (not in order)
    of his first days in the field with the Valhallan Artillery ("If I
    arrange to join an Artillery corps, I'll be well behind the lines..."),
    with a new Valhallan regiment (whose winning culture he shapes
    mostly by accident), operating as a Commissariat troubleshooter, as
    General's liaison, and in his semi-retirement teaching the next
    generation of Commissars at an Imperial Schola (closing the circle
    more or less). These secret histories are edited by his longtime
    lover, Inquisitor Amberley, whose acerbic footnotes dot the pages,
    pointing out when Cain is lying, wrong, or just too hard on himself, detailing what was happening across the field in other places during
    Cain's adventures, and occasionally just being catty.

    As author, Mitchell is not afraid to throw in movie references,
    obscure jokes you only get hours later (*Who* files Amberley's
    ship!?), and the occasional "Aside From That Mrs. Lincoln..", while
    keeping the action moving right along. I called it milsf, but
    really as Warhammer 40K tech is not much advanced from ours, and
    it's not really that much about strategy & tactics anyway, you could
    just call it (often comic) adventure and he does keep Cain & Jurgen
    moving right along.

    The typical Cain adventure starts with Cain congratulating himself
    on how he has definitely arranged to be well away from trouble
    on this mission, him immediately being proved spectacularly wrong,
    (often by the Cogboys poking at something they oughtn't..)
    and then he and his indispensable (if malodorous) batman Jurgen,
    blasting, chain-swording (a ridiculous weapon if there ever was one),
    and lasing their way through hordes of inexplicably appearing enemies
    while somehow rallying the troops to victory.

    What happens to Cain? Well, Amberley strongly implies he is dead,
    but we have also seen her lie whenever she felt it expedient, and
    she takes pains to mention that Cain was declared dead so many
    times that the Imperium has forbidden his death ever to be recorded
    again, so who knows? At any rate, we know she is still arranging
    his archives, and that he has dropped hints of stories not yet told.

    I believe these are the only books I have read due to seeing youtube
    filk videos on the overnight open-thread of a site I frequent. The
    first of these:

    "This Is Not A Plan" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BlW0FK8cPyE&pp=ygUSVGhpcyBpcyBub3QgYSBwbGFu

    drew me in, and I found these two from Amberley's point of view
    rather succinctly point out the contradictions of the man:

    "That's Not Quite What Happened, Commissar Cain" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nh2gc7vX0wM

    "A Great Man"
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lce_mKQQ1_A

    You will see differing counts of how many books are in the series.
    The first three I list here are omnibus volumes comprising several
    novels (and assorted short stories) in each. The next is the
    latest stand-alone novel, and the final one is an anthology of
    various short stories. I read these all at a sitting, but you might
    want to space them out some, as there is some repetition in the setups, introduction of Jurgen etc though it never rises to Dumarest levels.

    Anyway, I quite enjoyed these, and look forward to more of Cain's saga, including what he was doing on Holy Terra.

    Sounds like this might be a little bit inspired by "The Forever Hero:
    Dawn for a Distant Earth, The Silent Warrior, In Endless Twilight" by L.
    E. Modesitt Jr.

    https://www.amazon.com/Forever-Hero-Distant-Warrior-Twilight/dp/0312868383

    "Thousands of years in the future, Earth is a desolate ruin. The first
    human ship to return in millennia discovers an abandoned wasteland
    inhabited only by a few degenerate or mutated human outcasts. But among
    them is a boy of immense native intelligence and determination who is captured, taken in, and educated, and disappears--to grow up to become
    the force behind a plan to make Earth flower again. He is, if not
    immortal, at least very long-lived, and he plans to build an independent
    power base out in the galaxy and force the galactic empire to devote
    centuries and immense resources to the restoration of the ecology of Earth."

    Lynn

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alexander Schreiber@als@usenet.thangorodrim.de to rec.arts.sf.written on Sat Nov 7 12:56:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.written

    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    Still don't have the energy to do catchup monthlies yet, but
    here's a series I quite enjoyed over the summer & fall.

    As usual, the links are Amazon affiliate ones which could in theory
    earn me something should you enter the store that way.

    Note: I've just finished the series.

    So, let's have a lighthearted adventure series!

    To make Ciaphas Cain, Sandy Mitchell (a pen name for Alex Stewart)
    has taken a bit of Flashman, dollops of Black Adder, "The Spectre
    General", "Retief", "Judge Dredd", "Flandry" & a pinch of _Dune_
    (for spice) and shaken them together to make one of the more unlikely
    heroes of milsf...Not that Cain would agree with that designation.
    At all.

    Of course not.

    Ciaphas Cain is a man of somewhat enigmatic origins. We know he
    grew up a Hiveworlder, a native of one of those teaming Trantoresque
    planets where uncounted billions live burrowed from the surface to
    miles deep in layer upon layer descending from as-good-as-it-gets
    into total squalor. Or at least that's what he says, and it seems
    to be so, but he's careful never to actually name the world, and
    as his editor points out, certain other details that he gives us just
    can't be true.

    Whatever his exact circumstances, we know the Imperium reached out
    for him, placed him in a state Schola and trained him as a Commissar, something not at all to his liking, but in the more-or-less fascist

    Well, the Empire of Man in WH40K is pretty much fascism dialed up to 11. Remember: "Only in death does duty end." Case in point: Even when Cain "retires", he doesn't end up sitting on the bench enjoying the sunshine,
    he serves training the next commissar candidates and every once in a
    while gets called out to serve in action until he (presumably) dies.

    Warhammer 40K setting, there is no "I would prefer not" when the Emperor calls.

    As a Commissar, Cain is part of the military, but outside of the
    chain of command. He's a political officer present to ensure loyalty
    to the state (not a big problem with his units) and discipline the
    troops when necessary (a bit more of one, soldiers being soldiers). Technically he doesn't actually have the authority to lead troops,
    but since he *does* have the authority to shoot whoever he wants,

    As Cain says:
    "In my experience, being allowed to shoot anyone who disagrees with you
    tends to persuade them of the validity of your viewpoint with remarkably
    little difficulty."

    the former kind of comes as a corollary to the later. (He *is*
    deeply conscious that Commissars who ride the troops too hard tend
    to die heroically as the only casualties of unexpected battles with
    no official video...)

    Or die as regrettable results of accidential friendly fire incidents, as
    Cain points out more than once.

    Thus Cain displaying his firm grasp of reality in the Imperial Guard
    and his strong survival instinct ;-)

    Not that he *wants* to lead troops. As far as Ciaphas Cain is
    concerned, he is a rank coward, and would much rather sit in a swank
    hotel well behind the lines, playing cards, surrounded by young
    women (or later one woman) & old whiskey. But as mentioned, Cain
    is not a fully reliable narrator, and that's not entirely true.
    Well, it certainly *is* true that Cain would much rather avoid
    trouble, but when he is forced into the field, and he inevitably
    is, his constant need to assign base motives to his every action
    rings hollow after a while, and you come to realize that the measure
    of a man is not what he thinks, or why he does something, but *what*
    he does, and Ciaphas Cain, however much he would laugh at the idea,
    is a Hero of the Imperium.

    Cain does play the "reluctant hero" very well.

    The Warhammer 40K setting, at least as reflected in the Cain stories,
    is kind of an ongoing, permanent Third Century Crisis with the
    Imperium besieged on all sides by Tyranids, Gene Stealers, Chaos
    Cults, Orks, Eldar, Necrons & The Tau. The point of view that
    Mitchell adapts is that the Imperium is strict, but that it has to
    be because falling away from the Emperor always results in disaster,
    as we see time and again. Cain and his troops aren't exactly the
    Good Guys (the only really good guys are the Tau), but for the

    The Tau are _not_ the good guys. As pointed out in the narrative, their "Greater Good" translates mostly to "The Greater Good of the Tau race and
    the Warp take anyone else". And the Tau caste system makes the Indian
    caste system look like a shining example of social mobility.

    While there might be individuals that are "good guys (or gals)", the WH40K universe is set up so that none of the factions could be called good guys.

    citizenry, they are Orwell's "rough men [who] stand ready to do
    violence on their behalf".

    To quote the in-universe lore: "The Imperial Guard Holds The Line".

    While Cain (in his very English manner)
    has no use for the Emperor Botherers who abound in the power
    structure, he is pious in his own way (and pretty sure the Emperor
    has a nasty sense of humor), and believes in his society even while
    we would look askance at a good bit of it.

    These novels (and short stories) are told in the first person by
    Cain, writing for his own amusement during his retirement, well
    after publishing his *official* memoirs, and represent his (sometimes
    flawed) idea of "what really happened". They tell (not in order)
    of his first days in the field with the Valhallan Artillery ("If I
    arrange to join an Artillery corps, I'll be well behind the lines..."),
    with a new Valhallan regiment (whose winning culture he shapes
    mostly by accident), operating as a Commissariat troubleshooter, as
    General's liaison, and in his semi-retirement teaching the next
    generation of Commissars at an Imperial Schola (closing the circle
    more or less). These secret histories are edited by his longtime
    lover, Inquisitor Amberley, whose acerbic footnotes dot the pages,
    pointing out when Cain is lying, wrong, or just too hard on himself, detailing what was happening across the field in other places during
    Cain's adventures, and occasionally just being catty.

    As author, Mitchell is not afraid to throw in movie references,
    obscure jokes you only get hours later (*Who* files Amberley's
    ship!?), and the occasional "Aside From That Mrs. Lincoln..", while
    keeping the action moving right along.

    Including interesting place names, such as Helengon, Simia Orichalcae
    and the like.

    I called it milsf, but
    really as Warhammer 40K tech is not much advanced from ours,

    The tech tree in WH40K is set up a bit weird, but I guess a lot of that
    comes from the board game background (which explains the hilariously
    short range of some weaponry) and starting out as satire (hence some of
    the over-the-top stuff and the "nobody understands the tech, so we
    run rituals and burn incense" bits). Adherence to the board game back-
    ground varies widely between authors and the better ones shift things
    a bit more towards reality (yes, artillery can reach out further than
    just a few kilometers) - as Sandy Mitchell does.

    The typical Cain adventure starts with Cain congratulating himself
    on how he has definitely arranged to be well away from trouble
    on this mission, him immediately being proved spectacularly wrong,

    His own reputation as a Hero of the Empire (which he cheerfully deploys tactically whenever convenient) doesn't help, in his own words:
    "The trouble with everybody thinking you're a hero is that they tend
    to assume you like being in mortal danger and go out of their way to
    provide some."


    (often by the Cogboys poking at something they oughtn't..)
    and then he and his indispensable (if malodorous) batman Jurgen,
    blasting, chain-swording (a ridiculous weapon if there ever was one),
    and lasing their way through hordes of inexplicably appearing enemies
    while somehow rallying the troops to victory.

    While that basic pattern quickly becomes predictable, each story is
    written well enough that all this does is assure you that our hero will
    somehow prevail, drawing you in further to discover exactly how he's
    going to duck under the reaper scythe this time.

    What happens to Cain? Well, Amberley strongly implies he is dead,
    but we have also seen her lie whenever she felt it expedient, and
    she takes pains to mention that Cain was declared dead so many
    times that the Imperium has forbidden his death ever to be recorded
    again, so who knows? At any rate, we know she is still arranging
    his archives, and that he has dropped hints of stories not yet told.

    All in all, I found Ciaphas Cain to be a very likable character. He
    is a deep pragmatist with cynic strain, a very competent fighter (as
    Amberley Vail points out: well known to be an exceptional marksman and
    sword fighter) with some serious impostor syndrome going. His stated
    strong selfishness results in him treating "his" troops well (so not
    only will they not shoot him, but in fact protect him), saving planets
    (because he is on the planet, and if the 'nids eat the planet, they'll
    eat him too) and more along those lines.

    I believe these are the only books I have read due to seeing youtube
    filk videos on the overnight open-thread of a site I frequent. The
    first of these:

    I never knew of the YouTube videos, but I've been reading WH40K fiction
    for quite some time and eventually stumbled over Ciaphas Cain.

    You will see differing counts of how many books are in the series.

    Goodreads seems to have a pretty good overview:
    https://www.goodreads.com/series/42531-ciaphas-cain

    Anyway, I quite enjoyed these, and look forward to more of Cain's saga, including what he was doing on Holy Terra.

    I enjoyed the series very much. Cain as a self-styled selfish rogue and reluctant hero cames across as very pragmatic and firmly grounded.

    Have fun reading the remainder of the stories.

    Thank you very much for the nice writeup!

    Kind regards,
    Alex.
    --
    "Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and
    looks like work." -- Thomas A. Edison
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan@tednolan to rec.arts.sf.written on Sat Nov 7 19:21:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.written

    In article <slrn11eu4f3.1bksm.als@mordor.angband.thangorodrim.de>,
    Alexander Schreiber <als@usenet.thangorodrim.de> wrote:
    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    Still don't have the energy to do catchup monthlies yet, but
    here's a series I quite enjoyed over the summer & fall.

    As usual, the links are Amazon affiliate ones which could in theory
    earn me something should you enter the store that way.

    Note: I've just finished the series.

    So, let's have a lighthearted adventure series!

    To make Ciaphas Cain, Sandy Mitchell (a pen name for Alex Stewart)
    has taken a bit of Flashman, dollops of Black Adder, "The Spectre
    General", "Retief", "Judge Dredd", "Flandry" & a pinch of _Dune_
    (for spice) and shaken them together to make one of the more unlikely
    heroes of milsf...Not that Cain would agree with that designation.
    At all.

    Of course not.

    Ciaphas Cain is a man of somewhat enigmatic origins. We know he
    grew up a Hiveworlder, a native of one of those teaming Trantoresque
    planets where uncounted billions live burrowed from the surface to
    miles deep in layer upon layer descending from as-good-as-it-gets
    into total squalor. Or at least that's what he says, and it seems
    to be so, but he's careful never to actually name the world, and
    as his editor points out, certain other details that he gives us just
    can't be true.

    Whatever his exact circumstances, we know the Imperium reached out
    for him, placed him in a state Schola and trained him as a Commissar,
    something not at all to his liking, but in the more-or-less fascist

    Well, the Empire of Man in WH40K is pretty much fascism dialed up to 11. >Remember: "Only in death does duty end." Case in point: Even when Cain >"retires", he doesn't end up sitting on the bench enjoying the sunshine,
    he serves training the next commissar candidates and every once in a
    while gets called out to serve in action until he (presumably) dies.

    Yes, but in the Cain books (the only WH40K I have read) we see that
    citizens do have private lives, and that in general the fascism is
    necessary because as soon as anyone goes off the reservation, it's
    tyranids or chaos cults all the way down.


    Warhammer 40K setting, there is no "I would prefer not" when the Emperor
    calls.

    As a Commissar, Cain is part of the military, but outside of the
    chain of command. He's a political officer present to ensure loyalty
    to the state (not a big problem with his units) and discipline the
    troops when necessary (a bit more of one, soldiers being soldiers).
    Technically he doesn't actually have the authority to lead troops,
    but since he *does* have the authority to shoot whoever he wants,

    As Cain says:
    "In my experience, being allowed to shoot anyone who disagrees with you
    tends to persuade them of the validity of your viewpoint with remarkably little difficulty."

    the former kind of comes as a corollary to the later. (He *is*
    deeply conscious that Commissars who ride the troops too hard tend
    to die heroically as the only casualties of unexpected battles with
    no official video...)

    Or die as regrettable results of accidential friendly fire incidents, as
    Cain points out more than once.

    Yes that was my implication.

    Thus Cain displaying his firm grasp of reality in the Imperial Guard
    and his strong survival instinct ;-)

    Not that he *wants* to lead troops. As far as Ciaphas Cain is
    concerned, he is a rank coward, and would much rather sit in a swank
    hotel well behind the lines, playing cards, surrounded by young
    women (or later one woman) & old whiskey. But as mentioned, Cain
    is not a fully reliable narrator, and that's not entirely true.
    Well, it certainly *is* true that Cain would much rather avoid
    trouble, but when he is forced into the field, and he inevitably
    is, his constant need to assign base motives to his every action
    rings hollow after a while, and you come to realize that the measure
    of a man is not what he thinks, or why he does something, but *what*
    he does, and Ciaphas Cain, however much he would laugh at the idea,
    is a Hero of the Imperium.

    Cain does play the "reluctant hero" very well.

    The Warhammer 40K setting, at least as reflected in the Cain stories,
    is kind of an ongoing, permanent Third Century Crisis with the
    Imperium besieged on all sides by Tyranids, Gene Stealers, Chaos
    Cults, Orks, Eldar, Necrons & The Tau. The point of view that
    Mitchell adapts is that the Imperium is strict, but that it has to
    be because falling away from the Emperor always results in disaster,
    as we see time and again. Cain and his troops aren't exactly the
    Good Guys (the only really good guys are the Tau), but for the

    The Tau are _not_ the good guys. As pointed out in the narrative, their >"Greater Good" translates mostly to "The Greater Good of the Tau race and
    the Warp take anyone else". And the Tau caste system makes the Indian
    caste system look like a shining example of social mobility.


    That may be true in the broader context. Just reading the Cain
    books, which is the only WH40K knowledge I have, they do come across
    as the good guys and humans living on Tau worlds tend to do better
    than those in the Imperium. (Of course humans living on Tau
    "influenced" Imperial worlds tend to go off the rails like Gravlax
    and you end up with gene-stealers and chaos).

    While there might be individuals that are "good guys (or gals)", the WH40K >universe is set up so that none of the factions could be called good guys.

    citizenry, they are Orwell's "rough men [who] stand ready to do
    violence on their behalf".

    To quote the in-universe lore: "The Imperial Guard Holds The Line".

    While Cain (in his very English manner)
    has no use for the Emperor Botherers who abound in the power
    structure, he is pious in his own way (and pretty sure the Emperor
    has a nasty sense of humor), and believes in his society even while
    we would look askance at a good bit of it.

    These novels (and short stories) are told in the first person by
    Cain, writing for his own amusement during his retirement, well
    after publishing his *official* memoirs, and represent his (sometimes
    flawed) idea of "what really happened". They tell (not in order)
    of his first days in the field with the Valhallan Artillery ("If I
    arrange to join an Artillery corps, I'll be well behind the lines..."),
    with a new Valhallan regiment (whose winning culture he shapes
    mostly by accident), operating as a Commissariat troubleshooter, as
    General's liaison, and in his semi-retirement teaching the next
    generation of Commissars at an Imperial Schola (closing the circle
    more or less). These secret histories are edited by his longtime
    lover, Inquisitor Amberley, whose acerbic footnotes dot the pages,
    pointing out when Cain is lying, wrong, or just too hard on himself,
    detailing what was happening across the field in other places during
    Cain's adventures, and occasionally just being catty.

    As author, Mitchell is not afraid to throw in movie references,
    obscure jokes you only get hours later (*Who* files Amberley's
    ship!?), and the occasional "Aside From That Mrs. Lincoln..", while
    keeping the action moving right along.

    Including interesting place names, such as Helengon, Simia Orichalcae
    and the like.

    And foods like soylens viridiens...

    I called it milsf, but
    really as Warhammer 40K tech is not much advanced from ours,

    The tech tree in WH40K is set up a bit weird, but I guess a lot of that
    comes from the board game background (which explains the hilariously
    short range of some weaponry) and starting out as satire (hence some of
    the over-the-top stuff and the "nobody understands the tech, so we
    run rituals and burn incense" bits). Adherence to the board game back-
    ground varies widely between authors and the better ones shift things
    a bit more towards reality (yes, artillery can reach out further than
    just a few kilometers) - as Sandy Mitchell does.

    "Promethium" sounds powerful & mysterious, but you gradually realize it's
    just gas/petrol and that they are roaring around on IC engines. The
    "Spectre General" fallen tech stuff is well sustained. The old Imperial
    ship Cain finds while exploring the "hulk" works better than current ones,
    and the Cogboys can't figure out how the Tau use tech without propriating
    the machine spirits...


    The typical Cain adventure starts with Cain congratulating himself
    on how he has definitely arranged to be well away from trouble
    on this mission, him immediately being proved spectacularly wrong,

    His own reputation as a Hero of the Empire (which he cheerfully deploys >tactically whenever convenient) doesn't help, in his own words:
    "The trouble with everybody thinking you're a hero is that they tend
    to assume you like being in mortal danger and go out of their way to
    provide some."


    (often by the Cogboys poking at something they oughtn't..)
    and then he and his indispensable (if malodorous) batman Jurgen,
    blasting, chain-swording (a ridiculous weapon if there ever was one),
    and lasing their way through hordes of inexplicably appearing enemies
    while somehow rallying the troops to victory.

    While that basic pattern quickly becomes predictable, each story is
    written well enough that all this does is assure you that our hero will >somehow prevail, drawing you in further to discover exactly how he's
    going to duck under the reaper scythe this time.

    What happens to Cain? Well, Amberley strongly implies he is dead,
    but we have also seen her lie whenever she felt it expedient, and
    she takes pains to mention that Cain was declared dead so many
    times that the Imperium has forbidden his death ever to be recorded
    again, so who knows? At any rate, we know she is still arranging
    his archives, and that he has dropped hints of stories not yet told.

    All in all, I found Ciaphas Cain to be a very likable character. He
    is a deep pragmatist with cynic strain, a very competent fighter (as
    Amberley Vail points out: well known to be an exceptional marksman and
    sword fighter) with some serious impostor syndrome going. His stated
    strong selfishness results in him treating "his" troops well (so not
    only will they not shoot him, but in fact protect him), saving planets >(because he is on the planet, and if the 'nids eat the planet, they'll
    eat him too) and more along those lines.

    I believe these are the only books I have read due to seeing youtube
    filk videos on the overnight open-thread of a site I frequent. The
    first of these:

    I never knew of the YouTube videos, but I've been reading WH40K fiction
    for quite some time and eventually stumbled over Ciaphas Cain.

    You will see differing counts of how many books are in the series.

    Goodreads seems to have a pretty good overview:
    https://www.goodreads.com/series/42531-ciaphas-cain

    Anyway, I quite enjoyed these, and look forward to more of Cain's saga,
    including what he was doing on Holy Terra.

    I enjoyed the series very much. Cain as a self-styled selfish rogue and >reluctant hero cames across as very pragmatic and firmly grounded.

    Have fun reading the remainder of the stories.

    Looking forward to more stories...


    Thank you very much for the nice writeup!

    Thank you for actually reading it!

    Kind regards,
    Alex.
    --
    columbiaclosings.com
    What's not in Columbia anymore..
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alexander Schreiber@als@usenet.thangorodrim.de to rec.arts.sf.written on Sat Nov 7 23:55:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.written

    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    In article <slrn11eu4f3.1bksm.als@mordor.angband.thangorodrim.de>,
    Alexander Schreiber <als@usenet.thangorodrim.de> wrote:
    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    Still don't have the energy to do catchup monthlies yet, but
    here's a series I quite enjoyed over the summer & fall.

    As usual, the links are Amazon affiliate ones which could in theory
    earn me something should you enter the store that way.

    Note: I've just finished the series.

    So, let's have a lighthearted adventure series!

    To make Ciaphas Cain, Sandy Mitchell (a pen name for Alex Stewart)
    has taken a bit of Flashman, dollops of Black Adder, "The Spectre
    General", "Retief", "Judge Dredd", "Flandry" & a pinch of _Dune_
    (for spice) and shaken them together to make one of the more unlikely
    heroes of milsf...Not that Cain would agree with that designation.
    At all.

    Of course not.

    Ciaphas Cain is a man of somewhat enigmatic origins. We know he
    grew up a Hiveworlder, a native of one of those teaming Trantoresque
    planets where uncounted billions live burrowed from the surface to
    miles deep in layer upon layer descending from as-good-as-it-gets
    into total squalor. Or at least that's what he says, and it seems
    to be so, but he's careful never to actually name the world, and
    as his editor points out, certain other details that he gives us just
    can't be true.

    Whatever his exact circumstances, we know the Imperium reached out
    for him, placed him in a state Schola and trained him as a Commissar,
    something not at all to his liking, but in the more-or-less fascist

    Well, the Empire of Man in WH40K is pretty much fascism dialed up to 11. >>Remember: "Only in death does duty end." Case in point: Even when Cain >>"retires", he doesn't end up sitting on the bench enjoying the sunshine,
    he serves training the next commissar candidates and every once in a
    while gets called out to serve in action until he (presumably) dies.

    Yes, but in the Cain books (the only WH40K I have read) we see that

    The Cain books are pretty much written in a way that one can enjoy them
    without needing to know any of the WH40K in-universe lore and thus work
    very well stand-alone.

    citizens do have private lives, and that in general the fascism is
    necessary because as soon as anyone goes off the reservation, it's
    tyranids or chaos cults all the way down.

    Well, the Imperial Guard tends not to show up fully ready for war to
    planets that are peaceful under Imperial Rule - only to places were
    trouble is visibly brewing or already erupting, so that does skew the perception in the Cain books a bit.

    The Warhammer 40K setting, at least as reflected in the Cain stories,
    is kind of an ongoing, permanent Third Century Crisis with the
    Imperium besieged on all sides by Tyranids, Gene Stealers, Chaos
    Cults, Orks, Eldar, Necrons & The Tau. The point of view that
    Mitchell adapts is that the Imperium is strict, but that it has to
    be because falling away from the Emperor always results in disaster,
    as we see time and again. Cain and his troops aren't exactly the
    Good Guys (the only really good guys are the Tau), but for the

    The Tau are _not_ the good guys. As pointed out in the narrative, their >>"Greater Good" translates mostly to "The Greater Good of the Tau race and >>the Warp take anyone else". And the Tau caste system makes the Indian
    caste system look like a shining example of social mobility.


    That may be true in the broader context. Just reading the Cain
    books, which is the only WH40K knowledge I have, they do come across
    as the good guys and humans living on Tau worlds tend to do better
    than those in the Imperium.

    Right until they are fully integrated and the caste system drops on them ;-)

    (Of course humans living on Tau
    "influenced" Imperial worlds tend to go off the rails like Gravlax
    and you end up with gene-stealers and chaos).

    Because 1) the Tau don't have Psykers (which has logistical implications,
    such as no Warp travel (because no navigators) and no superluminal comms (because no astropaths) 2) once the Imperial Rule is gone, there is no one
    who really understands - and stomps upon - threats of Chaos, although the
    Tau do seem to be quite aware of the hungry nature of the Tyranids, even
    though their worlds are just by-catch on the way to the Astronomican (the psychic navigational beacon projected into the Warp from the Golden Throne
    on Terra).

    I called it milsf, but
    really as Warhammer 40K tech is not much advanced from ours,

    The tech tree in WH40K is set up a bit weird, but I guess a lot of that >>comes from the board game background (which explains the hilariously
    short range of some weaponry) and starting out as satire (hence some of
    the over-the-top stuff and the "nobody understands the tech, so we
    run rituals and burn incense" bits). Adherence to the board game back- >>ground varies widely between authors and the better ones shift things
    a bit more towards reality (yes, artillery can reach out further than
    just a few kilometers) - as Sandy Mitchell does.

    "Promethium" sounds powerful & mysterious, but you gradually realize it's just gas/petrol and that they are roaring around on IC engines.

    Worse. In WH40K, "Promethium" is the catch-all for any kind of liquid
    fuel, all the way from crude oil (hence "promethium wells") to gasoline, diesel, kerosene and whatever mix goes into flamethrowers. And yes, that
    reeks of table top gaming mechanics ;-)

    The
    "Spectre General" fallen tech stuff is well sustained. The old Imperial
    ship Cain finds while exploring the "hulk" works better than current ones,

    In the Imperium of Man, much about technology has been forgotten. What is
    still around, is often not well understood even by those maintaining it,
    thus they do rituals and prayer as part of maintenance. Most of the Cult Mechanicus (the science & engineering division of the Imperium) runs on
    pure rote following of rituals, with little understanding. Only a very
    small fraction of the cog boys (and those mostly at the higher levels)
    have any real understanding and even they are steeped in the mysticism.

    and the Cogboys can't figure out how the Tau use tech without propriating
    the machine spirits...

    Because the Tau just run a straight up modern (for them) tech tree, no mysticism, just science and engineering. And while several branches of
    Imperial tech are closed to the Tau (anything related to the Warp), in
    general their stuff is way ahead of the Imperium which lost so much tech
    and knowledge in millenia of wars (e.g. the Age of Strife). Plus the
    Imperium remembers technology going very badly wrong: the Dark Age of Technologie, which included fully independent AI systems running havoc
    (hence the harsh rules against intelligent machines, a.k.a. Abominable Intelligence).

    Kind regards,
    Alex.
    --
    "Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and
    looks like work." -- Thomas A. Edison
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan@tednolan to rec.arts.sf.written on Sat Nov 7 23:26:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.written

    In article <slrn11evb39.1k8n6.als@mordor.angband.thangorodrim.de>,
    Alexander Schreiber <als@usenet.thangorodrim.de> wrote:
    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    In article <slrn11eu4f3.1bksm.als@mordor.angband.thangorodrim.de>,
    Alexander Schreiber <als@usenet.thangorodrim.de> wrote:
    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    Still don't have the energy to do catchup monthlies yet, but
    here's a series I quite enjoyed over the summer & fall.

    As usual, the links are Amazon affiliate ones which could in theory
    earn me something should you enter the store that way.

    Note: I've just finished the series.

    So, let's have a lighthearted adventure series!

    To make Ciaphas Cain, Sandy Mitchell (a pen name for Alex Stewart)
    has taken a bit of Flashman, dollops of Black Adder, "The Spectre
    General", "Retief", "Judge Dredd", "Flandry" & a pinch of _Dune_
    (for spice) and shaken them together to make one of the more unlikely
    heroes of milsf...Not that Cain would agree with that designation.
    At all.

    Of course not.

    Ciaphas Cain is a man of somewhat enigmatic origins. We know he
    grew up a Hiveworlder, a native of one of those teaming Trantoresque
    planets where uncounted billions live burrowed from the surface to
    miles deep in layer upon layer descending from as-good-as-it-gets
    into total squalor. Or at least that's what he says, and it seems
    to be so, but he's careful never to actually name the world, and
    as his editor points out, certain other details that he gives us just
    can't be true.

    Whatever his exact circumstances, we know the Imperium reached out
    for him, placed him in a state Schola and trained him as a Commissar,
    something not at all to his liking, but in the more-or-less fascist

    Well, the Empire of Man in WH40K is pretty much fascism dialed up to 11. >>>Remember: "Only in death does duty end." Case in point: Even when Cain >>>"retires", he doesn't end up sitting on the bench enjoying the sunshine, >>>he serves training the next commissar candidates and every once in a >>>while gets called out to serve in action until he (presumably) dies.

    Yes, but in the Cain books (the only WH40K I have read) we see that

    The Cain books are pretty much written in a way that one can enjoy them >without needing to know any of the WH40K in-universe lore and thus work
    very well stand-alone.

    citizens do have private lives, and that in general the fascism is
    necessary because as soon as anyone goes off the reservation, it's
    tyranids or chaos cults all the way down.

    Well, the Imperial Guard tends not to show up fully ready for war to
    planets that are peaceful under Imperial Rule - only to places were
    trouble is visibly brewing or already erupting, so that does skew the >perception in the Cain books a bit.

    The Warhammer 40K setting, at least as reflected in the Cain stories,
    is kind of an ongoing, permanent Third Century Crisis with the
    Imperium besieged on all sides by Tyranids, Gene Stealers, Chaos
    Cults, Orks, Eldar, Necrons & The Tau. The point of view that
    Mitchell adapts is that the Imperium is strict, but that it has to
    be because falling away from the Emperor always results in disaster,
    as we see time and again. Cain and his troops aren't exactly the
    Good Guys (the only really good guys are the Tau), but for the

    The Tau are _not_ the good guys. As pointed out in the narrative, their >>>"Greater Good" translates mostly to "The Greater Good of the Tau race and >>>the Warp take anyone else". And the Tau caste system makes the Indian >>>caste system look like a shining example of social mobility.


    That may be true in the broader context. Just reading the Cain
    books, which is the only WH40K knowledge I have, they do come across
    as the good guys and humans living on Tau worlds tend to do better
    than those in the Imperium.

    Right until they are fully integrated and the caste system drops on them ;-)

    (Of course humans living on Tau
    "influenced" Imperial worlds tend to go off the rails like Gravlax
    and you end up with gene-stealers and chaos).

    Because 1) the Tau don't have Psykers (which has logistical implications, >such as no Warp travel (because no navigators) and no superluminal comms >(because no astropaths) 2) once the Imperial Rule is gone, there is no one

    I got that they had no FTL comm, but I was under the impression
    they did have FTL travel somehow. Is that incorrect?

    who really understands - and stomps upon - threats of Chaos, although the
    Tau do seem to be quite aware of the hungry nature of the Tyranids, even >though their worlds are just by-catch on the way to the Astronomican (the >psychic navigational beacon projected into the Warp from the Golden Throne
    on Terra).

    I called it milsf, but
    really as Warhammer 40K tech is not much advanced from ours,

    The tech tree in WH40K is set up a bit weird, but I guess a lot of that >>>comes from the board game background (which explains the hilariously >>>short range of some weaponry) and starting out as satire (hence some of >>>the over-the-top stuff and the "nobody understands the tech, so we
    run rituals and burn incense" bits). Adherence to the board game back- >>>ground varies widely between authors and the better ones shift things
    a bit more towards reality (yes, artillery can reach out further than >>>just a few kilometers) - as Sandy Mitchell does.

    "Promethium" sounds powerful & mysterious, but you gradually realize it's
    just gas/petrol and that they are roaring around on IC engines.

    Worse. In WH40K, "Promethium" is the catch-all for any kind of liquid
    fuel, all the way from crude oil (hence "promethium wells") to gasoline, >diesel, kerosene and whatever mix goes into flamethrowers. And yes, that >reeks of table top gaming mechanics ;-)

    The
    "Spectre General" fallen tech stuff is well sustained. The old Imperial
    ship Cain finds while exploring the "hulk" works better than current ones,

    In the Imperium of Man, much about technology has been forgotten. What is >still around, is often not well understood even by those maintaining it,
    thus they do rituals and prayer as part of maintenance. Most of the Cult >Mechanicus (the science & engineering division of the Imperium) runs on
    pure rote following of rituals, with little understanding. Only a very
    small fraction of the cog boys (and those mostly at the higher levels)
    have any real understanding and even they are steeped in the mysticism.

    and the Cogboys can't figure out how the Tau use tech without propriating
    the machine spirits...

    Because the Tau just run a straight up modern (for them) tech tree, no >mysticism, just science and engineering. And while several branches of >Imperial tech are closed to the Tau (anything related to the Warp), in >general their stuff is way ahead of the Imperium which lost so much tech
    and knowledge in millenia of wars (e.g. the Age of Strife). Plus the
    Imperium remembers technology going very badly wrong: the Dark Age of >Technologie, which included fully independent AI systems running havoc
    (hence the harsh rules against intelligent machines, a.k.a. Abominable >Intelligence).

    Yes, that was the "pinch of Dune" I mentioned. Cain in particular seems
    to have no idea that AI is even possible. And the general xenophobia
    of the Imperium blinds them to a lot.
    --
    columbiaclosings.com
    What's not in Columbia anymore..
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alexander Schreiber@als@usenet.thangorodrim.de to rec.arts.sf.written on Sun Nov 8 09:46:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.written

    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    In article <slrn11evb39.1k8n6.als@mordor.angband.thangorodrim.de>,
    Alexander Schreiber <als@usenet.thangorodrim.de> wrote:
    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    In article <slrn11eu4f3.1bksm.als@mordor.angband.thangorodrim.de>,
    Alexander Schreiber <als@usenet.thangorodrim.de> wrote:
    Ted Nolan <tednolan> <ted@loft.tnolan.com> wrote:
    Still don't have the energy to do catchup monthlies yet, but
    here's a series I quite enjoyed over the summer & fall.

    That may be true in the broader context. Just reading the Cain
    books, which is the only WH40K knowledge I have, they do come across
    as the good guys and humans living on Tau worlds tend to do better
    than those in the Imperium.

    Right until they are fully integrated and the caste system drops on them ;-) >>
    (Of course humans living on Tau
    "influenced" Imperial worlds tend to go off the rails like Gravlax
    and you end up with gene-stealers and chaos).

    Because 1) the Tau don't have Psykers (which has logistical implications, >>such as no Warp travel (because no navigators) and no superluminal comms >>(because no astropaths) 2) once the Imperial Rule is gone, there is no one

    I got that they had no FTL comm, but I was under the impression
    they did have FTL travel somehow. Is that incorrect?

    They do have FTL travel (no other way to have a stable multi-planet
    empire otherwise). They don't travel the "Sea of Souls" (the Warp)
    like humans do, but - according to in-universe lore - their FTL
    (called Ether or Gravitic) drives "skip" along the interface between
    the Warp and Realspace. It is much slower, though.

    and the Cogboys can't figure out how the Tau use tech without propriating >>> the machine spirits...

    Because the Tau just run a straight up modern (for them) tech tree, no >>mysticism, just science and engineering. And while several branches of >>Imperial tech are closed to the Tau (anything related to the Warp), in >>general their stuff is way ahead of the Imperium which lost so much tech >>and knowledge in millenia of wars (e.g. the Age of Strife). Plus the >>Imperium remembers technology going very badly wrong: the Dark Age of >>Technologie, which included fully independent AI systems running havoc >>(hence the harsh rules against intelligent machines, a.k.a. Abominable >>Intelligence).

    Yes, that was the "pinch of Dune" I mentioned. Cain in particular seems
    to have no idea that AI is even possible. And the general xenophobia
    of the Imperium blinds them to a lot.

    To be fair, the "sentient machines bad, mkay?" trope does show up in SF in various places. In WH40K the Mechanicus has a deeply ingrained religious aversion to intelligent machines for brutal historical reasons (yes, echoes
    of Dune). They do show up every once in a while when someone digs up some archeotech cache and promptly cause havok until destroyed. And of course,
    every once in a while a Heretek (cog boy straying from the straight and
    narrow) cooks one of those up as well ... with predictable results.

    The reason WH40K uses servitors (which are another gruesome aspect of the
    WH40K grim dark atmosphere) in places we would use computerized control
    (not even AI, just computers) systems is based in this deep aversion to
    any machine smarter than a simple clock.

    Kind regards,
    Alex.
    --
    "Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and
    looks like work." -- Thomas A. Edison
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2