What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive
Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by
Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to
swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the
power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if
Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would
have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there
are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could
last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
John Savard <quadibloc@invalid.com> wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive
Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by
Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to
swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the
power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if
Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would
have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there
are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could
last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
Bless you for asking, John.
AIPAC's clueless, congress critters enjoyed Speaker of the House Mike Johnson's mandatory "Epstein recess." But behind the scenes, Thomas
Massie, master maker of sausage in the style of Bismark, crossed the
aisle to cook up a piece de resistance with Democrats. Massie found
the votes to put the Epstein Coalition back on the agenda after Mike's mandatory midterm "Epstein recess" ends:
<https://democrats-judiciary.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/democrats-judiciary.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/2026-10.hjc-dems-staff-report-epstein-and-trump.pdf>
Massie will introduce a new bill that empowers all the fifty state
attorney generals to independently pursue justice for Epstein Coalition victims, regardless of what "the Feds" do.
Massie's last bill (to open the Epstein Coalition files) passed by unanimous consent before it reached the floor of the Senate. Because
even Mike Johnson isn't stupid enough to openly protect pedophiles.
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term >elections in the United States?The most likely is nothing but a lot of hot air, per the Flanders &
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term elections in the United States?
John Savard wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
Off topic political posts on this-a group. clearly.
William Hyde
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive
Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by
Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to
swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the
power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if
Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would
have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there
are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could
last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
John Savard
On Wed, 04 Nov 2026 12:27:00 GMT, John Savard wrote:In addition to being Chief Executive and CinC of the Armed Forces, the President is also the Head of State. This includes the power to
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive
Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by
Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to
swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the
power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if
Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would
have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there
are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could
last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
By this time there should have arisen public debate about the
structure of the presidency itself, such as why it should retain
royalist holdovers like the power to pardon. Isn't the silence
on this kind of odd?
On Wed, 04 Nov 2026 12:27:00 GMT, John Savard wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive
Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by
Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to
swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the
power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if
Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would
have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there
are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could
last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
John Savard
By this time there should have arisen public debate about the
structure of the presidency itself, such as why it should retain
royalist holdovers like the power to pardon. Isn't the silence
on this kind of odd?
On 11/5/2026 2:50 AM, Charles Packer wrote:To be fair-ish, that's just as arbitrary as winning a popularity con-
On Wed, 04 Nov 2026 12:27:00 GMT, John Savard wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive
Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by
Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to
swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the
power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if
Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would
have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there
are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could
last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
John Savard
By this time there should have arisen public debate about the
structure of the presidency itself, such as why it should retain
royalist holdovers like the power to pardon. Isn't the silence
on this kind of odd?
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every
4 to 8 years.-a Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son...
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every
4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their >son...
Lynn McGuire <lynnmcguire5@gmail.com> wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every
4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their
son...
This is the wonderful thing about the democratic process. Some people seem to want kings, and the problem with kings is that sometimes you get a good one and sometimes you get a bad one and it's hard to change them out when
you get a bad one. And sometimes you get a good one and his son turns out
to be not so good.
And this is why people in the international community are so terrified when an American president buddies-up to people like Mobutu Sese Seko, or to Vladimir Putin, and then speak in public about how they wish they could be "President for Life... doesn't that sound good?"
Thailand had for many years an amazing king who did a great job of keeping the country neutral when everything around his country was collapsing. He managed threading the needle between Axis and Allies in WWII and then east and west during the Cold War and to some extent even the Vietnam War. When
I was a kid, Thailand was a third-world country on the way up and today there is nothing third-world about it. But... King Bhumibol died in 2016 and his son has been having a hard time of it. He's doing better, but he's no Bhumibol.
When people talked to me about how they want a king who can just sweepingly fix everything himself, for years I agreed that this can work because I thought of Bhumibol. But now I'm not so sure, because nobody lives forever. --scott
On 11/4/26 12:42, William Hyde wrote:
John Savard wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
Off topic political posts on this-a group. clearly.
William Hyde
-a-a-a-aWe have those all the time election or no election.
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every
4 to 8 years.-a Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son...
bliss wrote:
On 11/4/26 12:42, William Hyde wrote:It's still worth mocking the perps.
John Savard wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
Off topic political posts on this-a group. clearly.
William Hyde
-a-a-a-aWe have those all the time election or no election.
If you must post something political, at least add an SF reference, such
as the elections in "Double Star".
I can't think of too many elections described in SF, which is odd as
Robert Bloch essentially ran a successful campaign for mayor of
Milwaukee as a young man.
Lynn McGuire wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out
every 4 to 8 years.-a Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son...
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in-a the days when they had power - managed to do this for more than three or four generations.
In England the Tudors lasted three generations, the Stuarts four - sort of.-a-a-a The longest successful dynasty in the Roman Empire may have been the adoptive dynasty of Nerva through Marcus Aurelius, at 82 years.
Constantine, for example, was succeeded by his sons, who killed one
another, and by no male-line grandsons. Maybe he shouldn't have killed
that eldest son if he wanted a long dynasty.
Rebellions, coups, simple murder, death by natural causes, lack of sons born, tend to end things pretty rapidly.
In SF long dynasties are generally due to effectively immortal monarchs
as in Hamilton's "Exodus", or cloning.
Various hints in "Foundation" show that Asimov was aware of this.
Dynasties in the Galactic Empire didn't seem to last long, nor did the Indbur dynasty on Terminus.
Then there's the constitutional monarch in Heinlein's "Double Star".
He's House of Orange, a very old dynasty indeed and I wonder how long they've held that position in this future.-a The impression I get is that it's been for a long time.-a But he doesn't have much power.
William Hyde
I can't think of too many elections described in SF, which is odd as
Robert Bloch essentially ran a successful campaign for mayor of
Milwaukee as a young man.
Lynn McGuire wrote:
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son...
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in the days when they had >power - managed to do this for more than three or four generations.
On 11/5/2026 2:50 AM, Charles Packer wrote:Don't be silly! We have had several Presidents for Life:
On Wed, 04 Nov 2026 12:27:00 GMT, John Savard wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive
Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by
Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to
swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the
power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if
Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would
have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there
are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could
last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
John Savard
By this time there should have arisen public debate about the
structure of the presidency itself, such as why it should retain
royalist holdovers like the power to pardon. Isn't the silence
on this kind of odd?
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every
4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their >son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son...
William Hyde <wthyde1953@gmail.com> wrote:
I can't think of too many elections described in SF, which is odd as
Robert Bloch essentially ran a successful campaign for mayor of
Milwaukee as a young man.
Isaac Asimov's _Franchise_. Absolutely one of the best.
And "The Lottery" was not exactly SF and it wasn't exactly an election... --scott
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 13:50:38 -0600, Lynn McGuire
<lynnmcguire5@gmail.com> wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every=20 >>4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their= >=20
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to=20 >>their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it=20 >>to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing=20 >>it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,=20 >>passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their=20 >>son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to=20 >>their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it=20 >>to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing=20 >>it to their son...
Don't be silly! We have had several Presidents for Life:
Tippecanoe (Harrison)
Taylor
Lincoln
Garfield
McKinley
Harding
=46DR
Kennedy
and Trump is free to join them any time he wants to, IMHO.
You are correct, however, that the office is not inheritable.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 13:50:38 -0600, Lynn McGuire
<lynnmcguire5@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/5/2026 2:50 AM, Charles Packer wrote:
On Wed, 04 Nov 2026 12:27:00 GMT, John Savard wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term
elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive
Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by
Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to >>> swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the
power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if >>> Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would >>> have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there >>> are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could >>> last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
John Savard
By this time there should have arisen public debate about the
structure of the presidency itself, such as why it should retain
royalist holdovers like the power to pardon. Isn't the silence
on this kind of odd?
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every
4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their >son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son...
Don't be silly! We have had several Presidents for Life:
Tippecanoe (Harrison)
Taylor
Lincoln
Garfield
McKinley
Harding
FDR
Kennedy
In article <r9urel125oh54lu90l82qkrh4udsr6cgip@4ax.com>,
Paul S Person <psperson@old.netcom.invalid> wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 13:50:38 -0600, Lynn McGuire
<lynnmcguire5@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/5/2026 2:50 AM, Charles Packer wrote:
On Wed, 04 Nov 2026 12:27:00 GMT, John Savard wrote:
What is the likely consequence of the results of yesterday's mid-term >>>>> elections in the United States?
There has been much speculation. Some have said nothing much would
change; Trump would go on ignoring Congress, and ruling by Executive >>>>> Order.
Others have been concerned about the possibility of a coup d'etat by >>>>> Trump. Perhaps Republicans in the House and Senate will attempt not to >>>>> swear in the incoming Democrats.
But something has occurred to me. As in other democratic systems, the >>>>> power of the purse rests in the legislative branch in the U.S.. So, if >>>>> Trump does something the Democrats don't like, one resource they would >>>>> have is to cut off the money for it.
And in a climate where more extreme actions may be at issue, and there >>>>> are fewer resources for a compromise, a government shutdown that could >>>>> last longer than any has lasted before it would be a realistic
possibility.
John Savard
By this time there should have arisen public debate about the
structure of the presidency itself, such as why it should retain
royalist holdovers like the power to pardon. Isn't the silence
on this kind of odd?
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every
4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their >>> son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son...
Don't be silly! We have had several Presidents for Life:
Tippecanoe (Harrison)
Taylor
Lincoln
Garfield
McKinley
Harding
FDR
Kennedy
I think only FDR deserves the epithet since he not only ran for a 3rd
term, but a 4th term as well when he should have known that he wouldn't
live to complete it.
Lynn McGuire wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out
every 4 to 8 years.-a Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son...
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in-a the days when they had power - managed to do this for more than three or four generations.
In England the Tudors lasted three generations, the Stuarts four - sort of.-a-a-a The longest successful dynasty in the Roman Empire may have been the adoptive dynasty of Nerva through Marcus Aurelius, at 82 years.
Constantine, for example, was succeeded by his sons, who killed one
another, and by no male-line grandsons. Maybe he shouldn't have killed
that eldest son if he wanted a long dynasty.
Rebellions, coups, simple murder, death by natural causes, lack of sons born, tend to end things pretty rapidly.
In SF long dynasties are generally due to effectively immortal monarchs
as in Hamilton's "Exodus", or cloning.
Various hints in "Foundation" show that Asimov was aware of this.
Dynasties in the Galactic Empire didn't seem to last long, nor did the Indbur dynasty on Terminus.
Then there's the constitutional monarch in Heinlein's "Double Star".
He's House of Orange, a very old dynasty indeed and I wonder how long they've held that position in this future.-a The impression I get is that it's been for a long time.-a But he doesn't have much power.
William Hyde
I'm not afraid of competition among the grand wizards, and am perfectly >capably of getting myself -- err, character -- elected as the head wiz-
ard, whatever the title may be.
On 11/5/2026 5:58 PM, William Hyde wrote:
Lynn McGuire wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out
every 4 to 8 years.-a Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son...
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in-a the days when they
had power - managed to do this for more than three or four generations.
In England the Tudors lasted three generations, the Stuarts four -
sort of.-a-a-a The longest successful dynasty in the Roman Empire may
have been the adoptive dynasty of Nerva through Marcus Aurelius, at 82
years.
Constantine, for example, was succeeded by his sons, who killed one
another, and by no male-line grandsons. Maybe he shouldn't have killed
that eldest son if he wanted a long dynasty.
Rebellions, coups, simple murder, death by natural causes, lack of
sons born, tend to end things pretty rapidly.
In SF long dynasties are generally due to effectively immortal
monarchs as in Hamilton's "Exodus", or cloning.
Various hints in "Foundation" show that Asimov was aware of this.
Dynasties in the Galactic Empire didn't seem to last long, nor did the
Indbur dynasty on Terminus.
Then there's the constitutional monarch in Heinlein's "Double Star".
He's House of Orange, a very old dynasty indeed and I wonder how long
they've held that position in this future.-a The impression I get is
that it's been for a long time.-a But he doesn't have much power.
William Hyde
Japan: (Yamato) 2680 years
India:-a (Pandyan) 1850 years
India: (Chola: 1580
CHina: (Zhou) 790
Ethiopia (Solomonic) 704
Ottoman: 623
pt
On 11/6/26 14:52, Cryptoengineer wrote:10: >>>> Nobody gets to be President for life,
On 11/5/2026 5:58 PM, William Hyde wrote:
Lynn McGuire wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out
every 4 to 8 years.-a
[...]
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in-a the days when
they had power - managed to do this for more than three or four
generations.
In England the Tudors lasted three generations, the Stuarts four -
sort of.-a-a-a The longest successful dynasty in the Roman Empire may
have been the adoptive dynasty of Nerva through Marcus Aurelius, at
82 years.
Japan: (Yamato) 2680 years
Sorry the first 1000 years are mythical.
India:-a (Pandyan) 1850 years
India: (Chola: 1580
CHina: (Zhou) 790
Ethiopia (Solomonic) 704
Ottoman: 623
Won't comment on the others as I have not studied
them as intensively as Japan but even in Japan relatives
overthrew an Emperor and assumed that dignity.
On 11/5/2026 5:58 PM, William Hyde wrote:
Lynn McGuire wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out
every 4 to 8 years.-a Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it
to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son...
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in-a the days when they
had power - managed to do this for more than three or four generations.
In England the Tudors lasted three generations, the Stuarts four -
sort of.-a-a-a The longest successful dynasty in the Roman Empire may
have been the adoptive dynasty of Nerva through Marcus Aurelius, at 82
years.
Constantine, for example, was succeeded by his sons, who killed one
another, and by no male-line grandsons. Maybe he shouldn't have killed
that eldest son if he wanted a long dynasty.
Rebellions, coups, simple murder, death by natural causes, lack of
sons born, tend to end things pretty rapidly.
In SF long dynasties are generally due to effectively immortal
monarchs as in Hamilton's "Exodus", or cloning.
Various hints in "Foundation" show that Asimov was aware of this.
Dynasties in the Galactic Empire didn't seem to last long, nor did the
Indbur dynasty on Terminus.
Then there's the constitutional monarch in Heinlein's "Double Star".
He's House of Orange, a very old dynasty indeed and I wonder how long
they've held that position in this future.-a The impression I get is
that it's been for a long time.-a But he doesn't have much power.
William Hyde
Japan: (Yamato) 2680 years
India:-a (Pandyan) 1850 years
India: (Chola: 1580
CHina: (Zhou) 790
Ethiopia (Solomonic) 704
Ottoman: 623
On 2026-11-07, bliss wrote:
On 11/6/26 14:52, Cryptoengineer wrote:10: >>>> Nobody gets to be President for life,
On 11/5/2026 5:58 PM, William Hyde wrote:
Lynn McGuire wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out
every 4 to 8 years.
20: >>>> passing it to their son,
GOTO 20
[...]
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in-a the days when
they had power - managed to do this for more than three or four
generations.
In England the Tudors lasted three generations, the Stuarts four -
sort of.-a-a-a The longest successful dynasty in the Roman Empire may
have been the adoptive dynasty of Nerva through Marcus Aurelius, at
82 years.
Japan: (Yamato) 2680 years
Sorry the first 1000 years are mythical.
India:-a (Pandyan) 1850 years
India: (Chola: 1580
CHina: (Zhou) 790
Ethiopia (Solomonic) 704
Ottoman: 623
Won't comment on the others as I have not studied
them as intensively as Japan but even in Japan relatives
overthrew an Emperor and assumed that dignity.
How much deviation within the same family does it take to consider it a different dynasty?
Paul S Person <psperson@old.netcom.invalid> writes:He won it on his own.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 13:50:38 -0600, Lynn McGuire
<lynnmcguire5@gmail.com> wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every=20 >>>4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their= >>=20
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to=20 >>>their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it=20 >>>to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing=20 >>>it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,=20 >>>passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their=20 >>>son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to=20 >>>their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it=20 >>>to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing=20 >>>it to their son...
Don't be silly! We have had several Presidents for Life:
Tippecanoe (Harrison)
Taylor
Lincoln
Garfield
McKinley
Harding
=46DR
Kennedy
and Trump is free to join them any time he wants to, IMHO.
You are correct, however, that the office is not inheritable.
Well, there was the Shrub...
On 11/6/26 10:05, Robert Woodward wrote:
In article <r9urel125oh54lu90l82qkrh4udsr6cgip@4ax.com>,
Paul S Person <psperson@old.netcom.invalid> wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 13:50:38 -0600, Lynn McGuire
<lynnmcguire5@gmail.com> wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every >>> 4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their >>> son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it >>> to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing >>> it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it >>> to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing >>> it to their son...
Don't be silly! We have had several Presidents for Life:
Tippecanoe (Harrison)
Taylor
Lincoln
Garfield
McKinley
Harding
FDR
Kennedy
I think only FDR deserves the epithet since he not only ran for a 3rd
term, but a 4th term as well when he should have known that he wouldn't live to complete it.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt was an optomist. And you may be overestimating the amount of medical information available to him
and to his physicians.
My Father died in 1939 at the age of 43 years. A few years
later and antibiotics became available and he might have survived periotonitis due to a ruptured appendix.
On Fri, 06 Nov 2026 17:38:35 GMT, scott@slp53.sl.home (Scott Lurndal)
wrote:
Paul S Person <psperson@old.netcom.invalid> writes:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 13:50:38 -0600, Lynn McGuire
<lynnmcguire5@gmail.com> wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out every=20 >>>>4 to 8 years. Nobody gets to be President for life, passing it to their= >>>=20
son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to=20 >>>>their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it=20 >>>>to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing=20 >>>>it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,=20 >>>>passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their=20 >>>>son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to=20 >>>>their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it=20 >>>>to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing=20 >>>>it to their son...
Don't be silly! We have had several Presidents for Life:
Tippecanoe (Harrison)
Taylor
Lincoln
Garfield
McKinley
Harding
=46DR
Kennedy
and Trump is free to join them any time he wants to, IMHO.
You are correct, however, that the office is not inheritable.
Well, there was the Shrub...
He won it on his own.
Well, with an assist from the Supreme Court, thanks to Florida.
That's for the first term. The second term he just plain won.--
William Hyde <wthyde1953@gmail.com> wrote:
I can't think of too many elections described in SF, which is odd as
Robert Bloch essentially ran a successful campaign for mayor of
Milwaukee as a young man.
Isaac Asimov's _Franchise_. Absolutely one of the best.
And "The Lottery" was not exactly SF and it wasn't exactly an election...
Cryptoengineer wrote:
On 11/5/2026 5:58 PM, William Hyde wrote:
Lynn McGuire wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out
every 4 to 8 years.-a Nobody gets to be President for life, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing
it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son...
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in-a the days when they
had power - managed to do this for more than three or four generations.
In England the Tudors lasted three generations, the Stuarts four -
sort of.-a-a-a The longest successful dynasty in the Roman Empire may
have been the adoptive dynasty of Nerva through Marcus Aurelius, at
82 years.
Constantine, for example, was succeeded by his sons, who killed one
another, and by no male-line grandsons. Maybe he shouldn't have
killed that eldest son if he wanted a long dynasty.
Rebellions, coups, simple murder, death by natural causes, lack of
sons born, tend to end things pretty rapidly.
In SF long dynasties are generally due to effectively immortal
monarchs as in Hamilton's "Exodus", or cloning.
Various hints in "Foundation" show that Asimov was aware of this.
Dynasties in the Galactic Empire didn't seem to last long, nor did
the Indbur dynasty on Terminus.
Then there's the constitutional monarch in Heinlein's "Double Star".
He's House of Orange, a very old dynasty indeed and I wonder how long
they've held that position in this future.-a The impression I get is
that it's been for a long time.-a But he doesn't have much power.
William Hyde
Japan: (Yamato) 2680 years
India:-a (Pandyan) 1850 years
India: (Chola: 1580
CHina: (Zhou) 790
Ethiopia (Solomonic) 704
Ottoman: 623
My western bias shows again!
How many of these were strictly father to son, though?-a Lynn insisted on sons.
The Ottomans seem to have done quite well at this. I don't see any case aside from the first where a sultan wasn't the son of a sultan.-a It
helps, I suppose, if you can have a couple of dozen or more children.I
was sure there was at least one dynastic overthrow there, but apparently not.
If Henry had been allowed to have six wives at a time instead of sequentially, perhaps the UK would still have a Tudor King.
The Duchy of Norfolk, England's senior non-royal dukedom, has passed
from father to son, IIRC, since the first Howard married the female
Mowbray heir some time in the late 1400s.-a Well, the Dukedom itself was suppressed for part of that time, but the line continued and the title
was twice restored, once due to Baron Howard's win at Flodden.
William Hyde
On 11/7/2026 11:47 AM, William Hyde wrote:
Cryptoengineer wrote:
On 11/5/2026 5:58 PM, William Hyde wrote:
Lynn McGuire wrote:
The nice about the Presidency of the USA is that we change it out
every 4 to 8 years.-a Nobody gets to be President for life, passing >>>>> it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son, passing it to their son, passing it to
their son, passing it to their son, passing it to their son,
passing it to their son...
That is a nice feature.
But it's surprising how few monarchies - back in-a the days when they >>>> had power - managed to do this for more than three or four generations. >>>>
In England the Tudors lasted three generations, the Stuarts four -
sort of.-a-a-a The longest successful dynasty in the Roman Empire may >>>> have been the adoptive dynasty of Nerva through Marcus Aurelius, at
82 years.
Constantine, for example, was succeeded by his sons, who killed one
another, and by no male-line grandsons. Maybe he shouldn't have
killed that eldest son if he wanted a long dynasty.
Rebellions, coups, simple murder, death by natural causes, lack of
sons born, tend to end things pretty rapidly.
In SF long dynasties are generally due to effectively immortal
monarchs as in Hamilton's "Exodus", or cloning.
Various hints in "Foundation" show that Asimov was aware of this.
Dynasties in the Galactic Empire didn't seem to last long, nor did
the Indbur dynasty on Terminus.
Then there's the constitutional monarch in Heinlein's "Double Star".
He's House of Orange, a very old dynasty indeed and I wonder how
long they've held that position in this future.-a The impression I
get is that it's been for a long time.-a But he doesn't have much power. >>>>
William Hyde
Japan: (Yamato) 2680 years
India:-a (Pandyan) 1850 years
India: (Chola: 1580
CHina: (Zhou) 790
Ethiopia (Solomonic) 704
Ottoman: 623
My western bias shows again!
How many of these were strictly father to son, though?-a Lynn insisted
on sons.
The Ottomans seem to have done quite well at this. I don't see any
case aside from the first where a sultan wasn't the son of a sultan.
It helps, I suppose, if you can have a couple of dozen or more
children.I was sure there was at least one dynastic overthrow there,
but apparently not.
If Henry had been allowed to have six wives at a time instead of
sequentially, perhaps the UK would still have a Tudor King.
The Duchy of Norfolk, England's senior non-royal dukedom, has passed
from father to son, IIRC, since the first Howard married the female
Mowbray heir some time in the late 1400s.-a Well, the Dukedom itself
was suppressed for part of that time, but the line continued and the
title was twice restored, once due to Baron Howard's win at Flodden.
William Hyde
The Ottomans, and for that matter the Japanese, made it easier to
keep the line going by the (male) leader having many partners,
whether wives, concubines, or others, whose son(s) were regarded
as potential heirs to the throne.
On top of that, before DNA paternity testing was available, any
of those women who became pregnant soon after being with the
leader, in the absence of other evidence, would be presumed
to be pregnant by him. Thus, the effects of both male and female
infertility could be mitigated, while keeping the appearance of an
unbroken male line.
In the Ottoman case, since there were sometimes several sons with
a potential claim to the throne, one of the first actions of a
new Sultan was to have his brothers and half-brothers killed.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:01:29 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,989 |