Adric might be the most hated companion in Doctor Who history. And
look, I get it. The kid could be an insufferable little pain in the....
But after more than forty years of making him the punchline, I started >wondering if we've been getting something wrong about him. So I went
back through his stories, and I think there's a lot more going on here
than we give him credit for.
And no, this is NOT an Adric defense video.
https://youtu.be/l_38fu7aFzY?si=SQUae8hpb9BJhT79
--
Democrats and the liberal media hate President Trump more than they
love this country.
Adric might be the most hated companion in Doctor Who history. And
look, I get it. The kid could be an insufferable little pain in the....
But after more than forty years of making him the punchline, I started wondering if we've been getting something wrong about him. So I went
back through his stories, and I think there's a lot more going on here
than we give him credit for.
And no, this is NOT an Adric defense video.
https://youtu.be/l_38fu7aFzY?si=SQUae8hpb9BJhT79
Ubiquitous wrote in article <11d2klh$3cfo6$3@dont-email.me>:
Adric might be the most hated companion in Doctor Who history. And
look, I get it. The kid could be an insufferable little pain in the....
But after more than forty years of making him the punchline, I started
wondering if we've been getting something wrong about him. So I went
back through his stories, and I think there's a lot more going on here
than we give him credit for.
And no, this is NOT an Adric defense video.
https://youtu.be/l_38fu7aFzY?si=SQUae8hpb9BJhT79
This video certainly takes a long time to get to its points. When
it does, it makes good ones.
Too many people simply judge Adric for acting like a kid,
forgetting that he was a kid.
----
The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
United States of America - North America - Earth
Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
Adric might be the most hated companion in Doctor Who history.
And look, I get it. The kid could be an insufferable little
pain in the....
But after more than forty years of making him the punchline, I
started wondering if we've been getting something wrong about
him.
So I went back through his stories, and I think there's a lot
more going on here than we give him credit for.
And no, this is NOT an Adric defense video.
https://youtu.be/l_38fu7aFzY?si=SQUae8hpb9BJhT79
So I went back through his stories, and I think there's a lot
more going on here than we give him credit for.
Don't think so. Bad acting is bad acting. A plank of wood would
have had more charisma.
Blueshirt wrote:
Don't think so. Bad acting is bad acting. A plank of
wood would have had more charisma.
That's one of the video's points, actually. Tom Baker's Doctor
also complained and frequently pouted or behaved petulantly.
Tom Baker sells it and makes it charming, but Mathew
Waterhouse was a kid.
Ubiquitous wrote:
Adric might be the most hated companion in Doctor Who history.
And look, I get it. The kid could be an insufferable little
pain in the....
arse.
But after more than forty years of making him the punchline, I
started wondering if we've been getting something wrong about
him.
After seeing Adric with an older and wiser head as part of our
current RADW rewatch, I don't think so. In "Full Circle" Adric
wasn't too bad... tolerable. But in "State of Decay" he was
starting to show the traits that would earn him the status he
has as a companion. He can only get better of course... but I
don't think he does.
So I went back through his stories, and I think there's a lot
more going on here than we give him credit for.
Don't think so. Bad acting is bad acting. A plank of wood would
have had more charisma.
And no, this is NOT an Adric defense video.
https://youtu.be/l_38fu7aFzY?si=SQUae8hpb9BJhT79
23 minutes of Adric?! No thanks.
Blueshirt wrote in article <xn0px6jdzd2ehwx001@news.eternal-
september.org>:
So I went back through his stories, and I think there's a lot
more going on here than we give him credit for.
Don't think so. Bad acting is bad acting. A plank of wood would
have had more charisma.
That's one of the video's points, actually. Tom Baker's Doctor
also complained and frequently pouted or behaved petulantly. Tom
Baker sells it and makes it charming, but Mathew Waterhouse was a
kid.
----
The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
United States of America - North America - Earth
Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
The True Melissa wrote:
Blueshirt wrote:
Don't think so. Bad acting is bad acting. A plank of
wood would have had more charisma.
That's one of the video's points, actually. Tom Baker's Doctor
also complained and frequently pouted or behaved petulantly.
Tom Baker sells it and makes it charming, but Mathew
Waterhouse was a kid.
Matthew Waterhouse was 18 and working full-time at the BBC
before he got the role of Adric. So not a kid as such... at 18
you're classed as an adult in the UK. He didn't have a lot of
acting experience though, and it showed. I suppose as JNT wanted
a companion who was a bit out of sorts, the inexperience could
have been seen as a plus point. (Either that or JNT fancied him!)
However, Matthew Waterhouse only acted how the director told him
to act and read the words typed in the script, so the
characterisation of Adric is not all on Matthew Waterhouse.
There are stories about him giving advice to Tom Baker, Peter
Davison and Richard Todd off-screen... but even if they are not
urban legends, they could be put down to youthful enthusiasm.
It's the way the character came across that I never took to. I
never got that misunderstood teenager thing. As a person though,
Matthew Waterhouse always comes across well on the DVD / Blu-ray
commentaries and the various behind the scenes features.
The True Melissa wrote:
Tom Baker's Doctor also complained and frequently pouted
or behaved petulantly. Tom Baker sells it and makes it
charming, but Mathew Waterhouse was a kid.
In comparison.
The Doctor wrote:
The True Melissa wrote:
Tom Baker's Doctor also complained and frequently pouted
or behaved petulantly. Tom Baker sells it and makes it
charming, but Mathew Waterhouse was a kid.
In comparison.
Comparing Matthew Waterhouse's acting abilities to Tom
Baker's is like comparing a mouse eating some cheese to
a Tiger with a man's head between its jaws.
Blueshirt wrote:
The Doctor wrote:
The True Melissa wrote:
Tom Baker's Doctor also complained and frequently pouted
or behaved petulantly. Tom Baker sells it and makes it
charming, but Mathew Waterhouse was a kid.
In comparison.
Comparing Matthew Waterhouse's acting abilities to Tom
Baker's is like comparing a mouse eating some cheese to
a Tiger with a man's head between its jaws.
That's a pretty unfair comparison due to Waterhouse's age at
the time. That's my point.
Ever notice how John Schneider was a much better actor on
Smallville than he was on The Dukes of Hazzard? He got better
at his craft over time.
The Doctor wrote:
The True Melissa wrote:
Tom Baker's Doctor also complained and frequently pouted
or behaved petulantly. Tom Baker sells it and makes it
charming, but Mathew Waterhouse was a kid.
In comparison.
Comparing Matthew Waterhouse's acting abilities to Tom
Baker's is like comparing a mouse eating some cheese to
a Tiger with a man's head between its jaws.
Blueshirt wrote in article <xn0px7stkeaucdz002@post.eweka.nl>:
The Doctor wrote:
The True Melissa wrote:
Tom Baker's Doctor also complained and frequently pouted
or behaved petulantly. Tom Baker sells it and makes it
charming, but Mathew Waterhouse was a kid.
In comparison.
Comparing Matthew Waterhouse's acting abilities to Tom
Baker's is like comparing a mouse eating some cheese to
a Tiger with a man's head between its jaws.
That's a pretty unfair comparison due to Waterhouse's age at the
time. That's my point.
Ever notice how John Schneider was a much better actor on
Smallville than he was on The Dukes of Hazzard? He got better at
his craft over time.
----
The True Melissa - Canal Winchester - Ohio
United States of America - North America - Earth
Solar System - Milky Way - Local Group
Virgo Cluster - Laniakea Supercluster - Cosmos
The True Melissa wrote:
Blueshirt wrote:
The Doctor wrote:
The True Melissa wrote:
Tom Baker's Doctor also complained and frequently pouted
or behaved petulantly. Tom Baker sells it and makes it
charming, but Mathew Waterhouse was a kid.
In comparison.
Comparing Matthew Waterhouse's acting abilities to Tom
Baker's is like comparing a mouse eating some cheese to
a Tiger with a man's head between its jaws.
That's a pretty unfair comparison due to Waterhouse's age at
the time. That's my point.
Ever notice how John Schneider was a much better actor on
Smallville than he was on The Dukes of Hazzard? He got better
at his craft over time.
They are not comparable was my point.
So because the Fourth Doctor could be petulant at times, that
isn't a legitimate defence of Adric being petulant. That's
whataboutery.
Adric's character was meant to be annoying and the actor playing
him was inexperienced, but that doesn't change how poor Adric
came across on screen. The fact Matthew Waterhouse might have
become a better actor in time as he got older is irrelevant to
what we see in 1980/81. There is no redemption for Adric as a
companion, he was an awful character and a bad addition to the
team. For that, I point the finger at JNT.
Fans of Adric can of course have their own opinions...
In article <MPG.4560c35e1bf3a92598a6ac@news.eternal-september.org>,
The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> wrote:
Ever notice how John Schneider was a much better actor on
Smallville than he was on The Dukes of Hazzard? He got better at
his craft over time.
And Waterhouse now?
The Doctor wrote in article <11d79ku$u83$11@gallifrey.nk.ca>:
In article <MPG.4560c35e1bf3a92598a6ac@news.eternal-september.org>,
The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> wrote:
Ever notice how John Schneider was a much better actor on
Smallville than he was on The Dukes of Hazzard? He got better at
his craft over time.
And Waterhouse now?
I haven't seen him in anything recent. I'll check something out
and report back.
On 14/11/2026 4:02 am, The True Melissa wrote:
The Doctor wrote in article <11d79ku$u83$11@gallifrey.nk.ca>:Checking IMDB, it seems Matthew is still active .... at least largely in
In article <MPG.4560c35e1bf3a92598a6ac@news.eternal-september.org>,
The True Melissa <thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM> wrote:
Ever notice how John Schneider was a much better actor on
Smallville than he was on The Dukes of Hazzard? He got better at
his craft over time.
And Waterhouse now?
I haven't seen him in anything recent. I'll check something out
and report back.
the "Doctor Who" Podcast world ....
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0913964/?ref_=fn_t_1
----
Daniel70
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 58:20:07 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,959 |