From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.movies
s|b <
me@privacy.invalid> wrote:
On Fri, 3 Apr 2026 22:27:44 -0500, Lynn McGuire wrote:
Number one son and I went to see the Project Hail Mary movie today. 4.5
stars out of 5 stars. Now I need to reread the book. And yes, the book
is on my six star list. And Rocky was just the way I envisioned him.
Adriaaaaaaaan!
Loved the old movie references (which my 25yo godchild didn't catch :-).
I read the book PROJECT HAIL MARY a year or more ago and I loved it. Our
sun is dying and humanity places all its hopes in a last-ditch one-shot scientific endeavor. What a terrific adventure it was! As I recall, I knew nothing about it beforehand other than that it was good and that it was by
Andy Weir, the guy who had written THE MARTIAN. Of course I gave it a
chance and I became enthusiastically caught up in the story as it unfolded across the galaxy. I never knew what was going to happen next and I reveled
in every unexpected twist and turn and breathtaking revelation. The book
was great fun.
So of course, I looked forward to the movie. My big regret is that I did
not rush to see it in IMAX at the first opportunity because all too soon MemphisrCys only IMAX screen gave way to the Super Mario Brothers. But thatrCOs OK rCo it was still showing on a reasonably big screen near me and on Sunday afternoon when I could find nobody who was interested in going with me, I
saw it by myself. Sad, I know, but there was no way I was going to end up watching this thing on a TV screen. I knew it was going to be just that
good.
Should I have been surprised when I found myself dozing off? Probably not.
I mean, I knew everything that was going to happen because I had already luxuriated in the enjoyment of a well written book-length tale. And here
was this movie condensing all the great parts and skipping over many of the others. Should I have admitted to myself that I was bored? Should I have wondered why I kept looking at my watch?
The movie has received high praise and I understand why. The stakes involve
the survival of humanity, itrCOs tense, itrCOs amusing, and it is nicely cast and uniformly well acted. It is very well done and amazing to look at in places. I wasnrCOt totally disappointed. But still.
As I was leaving the theater, I asked some of the others in the audience if they thought the movie was as good as the book and they told me that they
had never read the book and they thought the movie was terrific. Well there
you go. ItrCOs a wonderful movie. See it by all means. But for me, as with
THE PRINCESS BRIDE, the movie is just a pale shadow of the book.
--
rCo
Bill Anderson
I am the Mighty Favog
--- Synchronet 3.21f-Linux NewsLink 1.2