• MT VOID, 11/13/26 -- Vol. 45, No. 20, Whole Number 2458

    From Evelyn C. Leeper@evelynchimelisleeper@gmail.com to rec.arts.sf.fandom on Sun Nov 15 08:29:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    THE MT VOID
    11/13/26 -- Vol. 45, No. 20, Whole Number 2458

    Editor: Evelyn Leeper, evelynchimelisleeper@gmail.com
    All material is the opinion of the author and is copyrighted by
    the author unless otherwise noted.
    All comments sent or posted will be assumed authorized for
    inclusion unless otherwise noted.

    To subscribe or unsubscribe, send mail to
    evelynchimelisleeper@gmail.com
    The latest issue is at <http://www.leepers.us/mtvoid/latest.htm>.
    An index with links to the issues of the MT VOID since 1986 is at <http://leepers.us/mtvoid/back_issues.htm>.

    Topics:
    Mini Reviews, Part 28 (IMAGINING THE INDIAN,
    THE PRIMEVALS, M. Night Shyamalan) (film reviews
    by Evelyn C. Leeper)
    THE DEATH AND BIRTH OF ILIANA MAREK by David Liss
    (book review by Joe Karpierz)
    Griffin 1 Mission to the South Pole of the Moon (comments
    by Gregory Frederick)
    This Week's Reading (YESTERYEAR)
    (book comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)

    ===================================================================

    TOPIC: Mini Reviews, Part 28 (film reviews by Evelyn C. Leeper)

    IMAGINING THE INDIAN: THE FIGHT AGAINST NATIVE AMERICAN MASCOTING
    (2022): This has been on my "to-watch" list since it came out, but
    it took this long to become available. Finally it showed up on
    Kanopy.

    The first half covers the image of Native Americans in general in
    the media. Then the focus turns to sports teams names, mascots,
    and performances (e.g., the "Tomahawk Chop").

    The claim is often made that these names are "honoring" the people
    named. So one commentator suggested that we need to also have the
    Miami Yids, the Cleveland Bohunks, and the Boston Lace Irish. (For
    whatever reason, he didn't go the whole way and suggest the
    Oakland N*****s--though someone did similarly suggest the
    "Darkies" as a team name.)

    In particular, it covers the suit(s) against the Washington
    football team over its "Redskins" name. (This name is considered
    the most racist of all the various team names and mascots.)
    Eventually (right about when the film was being made) the
    Washington team management announced that they were going to
    change the name and the mascot. I'm sure that FedEx saying they
    would withdraw their financial support if they did not change the
    name had nothing to do with it. :-) (As noted in the film, of
    course, FedEx came to that decision in large part because of the
    pressure from people of all ethnicities.)

    It's not just teams. In 2021, Squaw Valley renamed itself
    Palisades Tahoe.

    The film ends with the information that the Cleveland Indians
    became the Cleveland Guardians in 2021. The Chicago Blackhawks
    have kept their name, but have banned headdresses in the park. The
    Kansas City Chiefs also have kept their name and the "chop",
    thought they did ban headdresses and face paint. The Atlanta
    Braves also kept their name and the "chop". (The film showed a
    clip of Seth Meyers, who showed a clip of Trump and Melania at an
    Atlanta game doing the "Tomahawk Chop", and then said that Trump
    had been hesitant about doing it until he was assured that it was
    definitely racist.)

    As of the time of the film, two thousand schools in the United
    States still used Native Americans as mascots. California schools
    are forbidden from using derogatory Native American names for team
    names or mascots, effective January of this year.

    (I will add that another long-time offensive practice is putting
    Native American artifacts in natural history museums rather than
    art museums.)


    THE PRIMEVALS (2023) was directed by David Allen, whose
    stop-motion work dates back to EQUINOX (1970). He was also known
    for films such as WHEN DINOSAURS RULED THE EARTH (1970), FLESH
    GORDON (1974), THE HOWLING (1981), Q: THE WINGED SERPENT (1982),
    and WILLOW (1988).

    THE PRIMEVALS had a rocky history, though. It started as an Edgar
    Rice Burroughs pastiche in the 1960s with David Allen, Dennis
    Muren, and Jim Danforth. In the 1970s, Allen gave it another try,
    and then again in the 1980s with Full Moon Entertainment. All the
    live-action sequences and most of the stop-motion animation was
    filmed in 1994, but then temporarily shelved due to the studio's
    financial problems. Allen died in 1999, and it wasn't until 2018,
    when producer Charles Band started an Indiegogo campaign that
    enough money was raised for Allen's colleague Chris Endicott to
    finish the visual effects with the storyboards, stop-motion
    puppets, and equipment left to him by Allen.

    The result is that the stop-motion has the classic look of many
    Ray Harryhausen films, having been conceived and started in that
    era. Unlike the standard structure of most "creature" movies, this
    one shows you the creature (or at least one of them) at the
    beginning, rather than teasing you until halfway or more through
    the film.

    The first shot of the film reminded me of BLACK NARCISSUS.
    although the building is just typical Nepalese architecture. And
    the people at the beginning seem remarkably lightly dressed for a
    Himalayan snowstorm. Later they are lying in a tent in another
    snowstorm with bare arms outside sleeping bags that don't seem
    designed for the Himalayas. They also manage to build a raft very
    quickly later on. And one character claims that if the environment
    doesn't change for million of years, species won't change either
    (assuming that environment, in this case climate, is the sole
    driver of evolution). All of this makes the film even more like a
    Harryhausen film, from an era when strict accuracy was what this
    sort of film was know for.

    The creature is described as a yeti, but turns out to be something
    more complicated than that, and the film takes some bizarre turns.

    It's basically Doyle's LOST WORLD with a bit of KING KONG, and a
    dash of FORBIDDEN PLANET, and a bit of nostalgia for those of us
    who watched the films of Harryhausen, Danforth, Allen back in the
    1960s through the 1980s. (For even more nostalgia, look for Robert Cornthwaite--from THE THING FROM ANOTHER WORLD (1951)--in a small
    role as D. Lloyd Trent. THE THING FROM ANOTHER WORLD was his first
    screen credit; THE PRIMEVALS was his last.)


    M. Night Shyamalan has written a lot of movies with interesting
    premises, but you have to wonder a bit at why he has been accused
    of plagiarism regarding at least four of them: THE VILLAGE, THE
    SHAPE OF WATER, OLD, and the Apple+ series "Servant". In all four
    cases, he was either cleared or the suit withdrawn. Mark was
    certainly one of the earliest reviewers to comment on the
    similarities between THE SHAPE OF WATER and "Let Me Hear You
    Whisper" by David Zindel, and I have to say that the claim that
    all of these are coincidences strikes me as ... unlikely.


    [-ecl]

    ===================================================================

    TOPIC: THE DEATH AND BIRTH OF ILIANA MAREK by David Liss
    (copyright 2026, Tachyon Publications, 363pp, ISBN-13:
    978-1616964702) (book review by Joe Karpierz)

    They say that in a small town, everyone knows your name. Everyone
    knows who you are. Everyone knows what you did and what you're
    doing. And everyone has an interest in having their version of the
    facts be the one that is right, the one that everyone believes.
    So, welcome to Tylor, Florida. Where everything I just said is
    true, and that's just the beginning of it all.

    Dan Gibson is a sad, pathetic man, the town pariah. Seven years
    ago, he murdered young Faye Kristic, a troubled, brilliant girl.
    The town, ruled by (and that's really the best way to put it)
    police chief Bryce Hilliard and his step-daughter and former
    classmate of Dan Gibson, Iliana Marek, have the residents of Tylor
    convinced of Gibson's guilt. The problem is that he doesn't
    remember how it happened. He only knows that Faye is dead, and he
    was the cause of it.

    Bryce and Iliana run the town with an iron fist; no one wants to
    cross either one of them, so they pretty much have their way. One
    night, Dan is summoned by one of the local police officers to a
    site that is a local famous location for many suicides. When he
    gets there, he finds the officer and Iliana digging a grave to
    bury a couple of bodies (the reader can work out where the bodies
    are from and how they got into the state they're in). They enlist
    Dan's help, although to be fair it's more like forcing him to
    help. He's reluctant, and the next thing you know Iliana, who has
    bullied him all the time she's known him, attempts to kill him.
    Until a one-armed woman--the other arm torn in half, revealing it
    to be metallic--saves him by killing Iliana and the cop. Yeah,
    we're into Terminator territory here, and we really don't know
    where this is headed next.

    Thing is, Iliana shows up later, alive and changed. She no longer
    wants to torment Dan; she wants to protect him. Then things get
    weird.

    And yet maybe they're not as weird as the reader might think,
    because this is a small town, and everybody...well, you get the
    idea. The story turns into a small town crime thriller with a
    couple of hundred (well, maybe not that many) different elements
    that kept me turning the pages and reading later in the evening
    than I normally do. The town's police force is corrupt. An
    outsider reporter is in town to get the real story about the
    wealthy tech investor who got off - yeah, he's dead by the time
    the novel starts--on spying on young girls. Faye Kristic is a lot
    more than the troubled youth she appeared to be. Dan lives in
    essentially an outbuilding apartment on his parents' property. His
    father really doesn't like him, and neither does his boss at the
    convenience store who took pity on him and gave him a job when no
    one else would. The wife of the dead cop doesn't know he's dead
    and thinks Dan knows where he is. And yes, you can't have a story
    like this without money. Oodles and oodles of money.

    And yet, the real mystery is the new Iliana Marek. She's changed.
    She's a friend to Dan and is trying to protect him as well as find
    out what's really happening in the town. And she certainly
    believes that there's more to Dan's story than anyone in the small
    town is letting on. And it's no longer a science fiction cyborg
    Terminator story. It's a criminal investigation with enough twists
    to make the reader dizzy.

    THE DEATH AND BIRTH OF ILIANA MAREK is a terrifically written
    novel by David Liss, known in part for his historical fiction
    novels. This certainly isn't historical fiction, and it only uses
    the cyborg trappings at the beginning to set up the rest of the
    story. The corrupt cops and other baddies in the town just know
    that Iliana is bad and they can't understand why she's helping
    Dan. That cyborg start to the book is left behind as Liss explores
    the change in Iliana and her relationship with Dan. The events of
    the novel move along that growth and change, and at the end the
    genre elements come back into play to explain just what Iliana is,
    where she came from, and where she might be going. It's a mystery
    to her, and it's a mystery to the reader. And if you like that
    sort of thing, this book is definitely for you. [-jak]

    ===================================================================

    TOPIC: Griffin 1 Mission to the South Pole of the Moon (comments
    by Gregory Frederick)

    There is a important new mission to the south pole of the Moon
    coming possibly this month, but more likely by 2027, that most
    people do not know about. The most important sites on the Moon are
    around the craters at the south pole. The deeper craters at the
    south pole have water at the bottom. Water is an extremely
    important resource on the Moon. Also, there are locations at the
    south pole where solar panels can access almost non-stop Solar
    energy. This mission will give NASA a claim to one of the best
    sites possibly before China gets there. A rover will be sent with
    this mission's lander. The You Tube video can be found at:

    <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=64ZgzunmPOU>

    [-gf]

    ===================================================================

    TOPIC: This Week's Reading (book comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)

    YESTERYEAR by Caro Claire Burke (Knopf, ISBN 978-0-593-80421-6)
    has many aspects that one could talk about. Natalie is a tradwife
    influencer who extols traditional gender roles, Christianity, and
    authentic farm life. She doesn't have modern appliances. She and
    her husband Caleb grow all their food organically, home-school
    their five children, and have burgeoning business selling cutting
    boards and aprons.

    Natalie is also a tradwife influencer who runs the farm with the
    help of two nannies, a producer, and a crew of Mexican laborers.
    Her dishwasher, microwave ovens, and massive refrigerator are
    hidden behind secret doors. Her husband is there mostly as
    window-dressing; she runs the farm. The Mexican laborers need to
    be constantly reminded to hide the pesticide containers where they
    won't be accidentally filmed. The nannies and the producers have
    to peel the "Made in China" labels off the "hand-crafted" cutting
    boards and aprons.

    Two things happen. One, the masquerade is revealed, and two, she
    wakes up in an 1855 farmhouse that seems to be hers in the sense
    of the same layout, but without all the secret "helpers". She has
    four children, not five, but they look different, and they are
    grimy and dressed in old clothes, not the picture-perfect ones
    from "before".

    So one could talk about the whole "tradwife" cult. One could talk
    about the pernicious effect of social influencers. Or a
    combination of those: how social influencers try to sell people on
    a lifestyle that is impossible. Or how people think they want to
    go back to the "good old days" (but with all the modern
    conveniences)--and in fact may fool themselves that they have gone
    back to a traditional lifestyle.. (One is reminded of "Frontier
    House" and "Colonial House" where in each case families were
    chosen that had no intention of living in an 1880s house or a
    1620s New England colony, and constantly smuggled modern items in,
    or just refused to follow the rules.) And of course there's the
    standard time travel plot of someone going back to the past.

    Or you could do all of them.

    This was published as a mainstream novel, so even though a
    decreasing number of people buy books in physical bookstores these
    days, a reminder to look in the mainstream fiction section for
    this is probably called for.

    As I'm writing this, I still haven't decided whether to mention
    similar works, as this would be spoilers for the two books and the
    three movies, and if I even tell you what they are, that will
    probably be spoiler enough (unless you are totally unfamiliar with
    any of them--which is unlikely). So I will use that
    oh-so-traditional dodge: rot-13. Gur obbxf ner LRFGRELRNE ol Pneb
    Pynver Ohexr naq GUR TYBEL GUNG JNF ol Y. Fcenthr qr Pnzc; gur
    zbivrf ner GUR IVYYNTR (2004), NAGRORYYHZ (2020), naq NYVPR
    (2022). [-ecl]

    ===================================================================

    Evelyn C. Leeper
    evelynchimelisleeper@gmail.com


    Loyalty to petrified opinion never broke a chain
    or freed a human soul.
    --Mark Twain
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From kludge@kludge@panix.com (Scott Dorsey) to rec.arts.sf.fandom on Sun Nov 15 09:18:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    Evelyn C. Leeper <evelynchimelisleeper@gmail.com> wrote:
    In particular, it covers the suit(s) against the Washington
    football team over its "Redskins" name. (This name is considered
    the most racist of all the various team names and mascots.)
    Eventually (right about when the film was being made) the
    Washington team management announced that they were going to
    change the name and the mascot. I'm sure that FedEx saying they
    would withdraw their financial support if they did not change the
    name had nothing to do with it. :-) (As noted in the film, of
    course, FedEx came to that decision in large part because of the
    pressure from people of all ethnicities.)

    It made no sense to me. Change the logo and change the mascot to a
    red skin potato, and keep the name. Everybody loves potatoes.
    --scott
    --
    "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Gary McGath@garym@mcgath.com to rec.arts.sf.fandom on Sun Nov 15 11:31:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    On 11/15/26 8:29 AM, Evelyn C. Leeper wrote:

    The claim is often made that these names are "honoring" the people
    named. So one commentator suggested that we need to also have the
    Miami Yids, the Cleveland Bohunks, and the Boston Lace Irish. (For
    whatever reason, he didn't go the whole way and suggest the
    Oakland N*****s--though someone did similarly suggest the
    "Darkies" as a team name.)

    Boston does have the Celtics (pronounced "sell tix," as was the usual pronunciation when the name as adopted), with distinctly Irish imagery
    to go with the name.
    --
    Gary McGath http://www.mcgath.com
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tim Merrigan@tppm@ca.rr.com to rec.arts.sf.fandom on Sun Nov 15 09:53:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    On 11/15/2026 8:31 AM, Gary McGath wrote:
    On 11/15/26 8:29 AM, Evelyn C. Leeper wrote:

    The claim is often made that these names are "honoring" the people
    named. So one commentator suggested that we need to also have the
    Miami Yids, the Cleveland Bohunks, and the Boston Lace Irish. (For
    whatever reason, he didn't go the whole way and suggest the
    Oakland N*****s--though someone did similarly suggest the
    "Darkies" as a team name.)

    Boston does have the Celtics (pronounced "sell tix," as was the usual pronunciation when the name as adopted), with distinctly Irish imagery
    to go with the name.


    Then there are the Minnesota Vikings. This is collage rather than pro,
    but there's also Notre Dame and the Fighting Irish.
    --

    Qualified immunity = virtual impunity.

    Tim Merrigan

    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Joshua Kreitzer@gromit82@hotmail.com to rec.arts.sf.fandom on Sun Nov 15 15:23:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    On 11/15/2026 7:29 AM, Evelyn C. Leeper wrote:

    M. Night Shyamalan has written a lot of movies with interesting
    premises, but you have to wonder a bit at why he has been accused
    of plagiarism regarding at least four of them: THE VILLAGE, THE
    SHAPE OF WATER, OLD, and the Apple+ series "Servant". In all four
    cases, he was either cleared or the suit withdrawn. Mark was
    certainly one of the earliest reviewers to comment on the
    similarities between THE SHAPE OF WATER and "Let Me Hear You
    Whisper" by David Zindel, and I have to say that the claim that
    all of these are coincidences strikes me as ... unlikely.

    M. Night Shyamalan wasn't involved with THE SHAPE OF WATER, as far as I
    can tell. That was directed and co-written by Guillermo del Toro.

    I found Mark's review of THE SHAPE OF WATER, in which he said the plot
    was very similar to the play "Let Me Hear You Whisper" by Paul (not
    David) Zindel. Mark wrote, "I am sorry to see del Toro resorting to
    uncredited near-remakes of other people's stories." http://leepers.us/mtvoid/2017/VOID1208.htm

    Shyamalan wrote and directed LADY IN THE WATER, but I couldn't find a
    review of that by you or Mark.

    In any event, I was under the impression that pretty much any successful
    movie attracts plagiarism lawsuits, albeit most of them non-meritorious.

    --
    Joshua Kreitzer
    gromit82@hotmail.com
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From prd@prd@pauldormer.cix.co.uk (Paul Dormer) to rec.arts.sf.fandom on Sun Nov 15 22:23:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    In article <11dcri7$2usip$1@dont-email.me>, tppm@ca.rr.com (Tim Merrigan) wrote:

    This is collage rather than pro,
    but there's also Notre Dame and the Fighting Irish.

    They are an art work?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jay Morris@morrisj@epsilon3.me to rec.arts.sf.fandom on Sun Nov 15 17:23:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    On 11/15/2026 7:29 AM, Evelyn C. Leeper wrote:

    IMAGINING THE INDIAN: THE FIGHT AGAINST NATIVE AMERICAN MASCOTING
    (2022): This has been on my "to-watch" list since it came out, but
    it took this long to become available. Finally it showed up on
    Kanopy.

    The first half covers the image of Native Americans in general in
    the media. Then the focus turns to sports teams names, mascots,
    and performances (e.g., the "Tomahawk Chop").

    The claim is often made that these names are "honoring" the people
    named. So one commentator suggested that we need to also have the
    Miami Yids, the Cleveland Bohunks, and the Boston Lace Irish. (For
    whatever reason, he didn't go the whole way and suggest the
    Oakland N*****s--though someone did similarly suggest the
    "Darkies" as a team name.)

    In particular, it covers the suit(s) against the Washington
    football team over its "Redskins" name. (This name is considered
    the most racist of all the various team names and mascots.)
    Eventually (right about when the film was being made) the
    Washington team management announced that they were going to
    change the name and the mascot. I'm sure that FedEx saying they
    would withdraw their financial support if they did not change the
    name had nothing to do with it. EfOe (As noted in the film, of
    course, FedEx came to that decision in large part because of the
    pressure from people of all ethnicities.)

    It's not just teams. In 2021, Squaw Valley renamed itself
    Palisades Tahoe.

    The film ends with the information that the Cleveland Indians
    became the Cleveland Guardians in 2021. The Chicago Blackhawks
    have kept their name, but have banned headdresses in the park. The
    Kansas City Chiefs also have kept their name and the "chop",
    thought they did ban headdresses and-a-a face paint. The Atlanta
    Braves also kept their name and the "chop". (The film showed a
    clip of Seth Meyers, who showed a clip of Trump and Melania at an
    Atlanta game doing the "Tomahawk Chop", and then said that Trump
    had been hesitant about doing it until he was assured that it was
    definitely racist.)

    As of the time of the film, two thousand schools in the United
    States still used Native Americans as mascots. California schools
    are forbidden from using derogatory Native American names for team
    names or mascots, effective January of this year.

    And yet...

    Descendants of Chief John Two Guns White Calf and the Native American Guardians Association (NAGA) are actively campaigning and pursuing legal action to restore the Washington Redskins name and logo.

    Key Details of the Campaign

    rCo The Family and Estate: The direct descendants of Blackfeet Chief John
    Two Guns White CalfrCowhose likeness inspired the 1971 logo created by
    Walter "Blackie" WetzelrCostate they were never consulted when the team dropped the name in 2020. Led by state Representative Morningstar Gopher
    and estate representatives, the family argues that removing the identity erased their heritage rather than honoring it.
    rCo Proposed Goals: The estate wants the team name and logo restored,
    hopes to meet with political leaders including President Donald Trump,
    and advocates for naming a future stadium John Two Guns White Calf
    Memorial Stadium.
    rCo Native American Guardians Association (NAGA): NAGA filed a lawsuit
    against the Washington Commanders and the National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) seeking $1.6 million and a seat to share Native history, arguing that dropping the name suppressed Native history. They also
    maintain an online petition pushing for the franchise to reinstate the branding.
    rCo Team Stance: Current Washington Commanders ownership, including Josh Harris, has rejected returning to the old name, reaffirming the
    Commanders identity.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2