From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom
THE MT VOID
11/06/26 -- Vol. 45, No. 19, Whole Number 2457
Editor: Evelyn Leeper,
evelynchimelisleeper@gmail.com
All material is the opinion of the author and is copyrighted by
the author unless otherwise noted.
All comments sent or posted will be assumed authorized for
inclusion unless otherwise noted.
To subscribe or unsubscribe, send mail to
evelynchimelisleeper@gmail.com
The latest issue is at <
http://www.leepers.us/mtvoid/latest.htm>.
An index with links to the issues of the MT VOID since 1986 is at <
http://leepers.us/mtvoid/back_issues.htm>.
Topics:
2010: ODYSSEY TWO (correction)
Mini Reviews, Part 27 (55 DAYS AT PEKING, DUNKIRK (2017),
DARKEST HOUR (2017), KEN BURNS'S NATIONAL PARKS)
(film reviews by Evelyn C. Leeper)
More November Recommendations (NYC Area) (comments
by Evelyn C. Leeper)
Hercule Poirot (comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
A.I. Documentaries (letter of comment by Richie Bielak)
Facebook (letter of comment by Pete Rubinstein)
This Week's Reading (ROME, BLOOD, AND POLITICS)
(book comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
===================================================================
TOPIC: 2010: ODYSSEY TWO (correction)
In response to my crediting the letter of comment on 2010: ODYSSEY
TWO in the 10/30/26 issue of the MT VOID to Hal Heydt, Steve
Coltrin writes:
Purely for the matter of the record and with no slight having been
taken, the LoC is from me, not Hal. [-sc]
Mea culpa. Sometimes my cut-and-paste gets away from me. [-ecl]
===================================================================
TOPIC: Mini Reviews, Part 27 (film reviews by Evelyn C. Leeper)
55 DAYS AT PEKING (1963): This is yet another film that hasn't
aged well. It is typical Orientalism of the time, with all the
major Chinese characters played by white actors in yellow-face.
The Boxers are, not surprisingly, portrayed as total villains,
even though the Empress does present the Chinese point of
view--that European countries have seized land and ignored Chinese
laws and customs.with impunity. In general, the historians' view
of them is far more nuanced, but war films of the 1950s did not
tend to nuance.
The Baroness in the film does call out the hypocrisy of the
Westerners in having no problem with Western men taking Chinese
women as wives (or concubines), but shun her as beyond the pale
because she had an affair with a Chinese general. It also talks
about how the mixed-race daughter of one of his soldiers would be
treated as a freak back in the United States of 1900 if he were to
take her home (her mother having died).
And I have to ask, why would a four-foot pile of sandbags, each
smaller than a ten-pound sack of flour, seem at all sufficient to
stop an angry charging mob? Maybe if they were big fifty-pond
sandbags, and piled higher...
I think we're supposed to side with the Westerners in this film,
but as with the idea of the Soviets in RED DAWN showing ALEXANDER
NEVSKY in the movie theater, the message gets a little confused.
DUNKIRK (2017): Rewatching this, I naturally was reminded of the
story I have related before. During Dunkirk when Titanic Second
Officer Charles Lightoller was 66 years old, the Royal Navy
requested the use of his yacht for the evacuation. He insisted on
sailing it there himself (with the assistance of one of his sons
and two crew members). In spite of the fact that the yacht had
never held more than twenty-one people before, Lightoller loaded
130 soldiers on it and managed to dodge German shelling and get
them safely back to England. I have said that I was sure in my own
mind that when he was loading the yacht at Dunkirk, he remembered
all the half-filled lifeboats of Titanic, and how many people died
because of that, and loaded as many men as he possibly could. This
time I actually looked up what happened with his lifeboat from the
Titanic. The boat was rated to carry 65 people, but Lightoller
actually got 75 people onto it, all of whom survived. So Dunkirk
wasn't correcting an earlier mistake by him, but just another
example of how he operated. (But I still think he was haunted by
those half-empty boats from three decades earlier.)
DARKEST HOUR (2017): After watching DUNKIRK (2017), I naturally
had to watch DARKEST HOUR (2017). I give the year for both of them
because there is also a 2003 BBC documentary titled "Dunkirk"
which uses a lot of re-creations. and there is a 2011 science
fiction film titled "The Darkest Hour", which has nothing to do
with the evacuation of Dunkirk and serves only to confuse viewers.
KEN BURNS'S NATIONAL PARKS: This should be uplifting and
inspiring, but currently it is depressing as I keep reading about
the destruction of parts of Big Bend National Park, Yellowstone
National Park, and many others being targeted for drilling or
mining or building a wall.
[-ecl]
===================================================================
TOPIC: More November Recommendations (NYC Area) (comments by
Evelyn C. Leeper)
I see that not only TCM, but also WNET (Channel 13) is running
NETWORK this month. WNET is running it Saturday, November 14, at
9PM.
WNET is also running a film that Mark gave 9/10 to back in 2007:
AWAY FROM HER. Mark's capsule at the time:
"CAPSULE: A woman develops a new personality in the twilight
stages as Alzheimer's Disease robs her of her memories and her old
nature, but has not yet robbed her of mechanical function. Her
affectionate husband is bewildered by the initial loss, by the new
personality, and by choices she is making. Based on the story
"The Bear Came Over the Mountain" by Alice Munro, this very
personal film is a deeply affecting work from Sarah Polley, a good
actress becoming an even better writer and director. Rating: +3
(-4 to +4) or 9/10" [-mrl]
AWAY FROM HER is running on WNET Saturday, November 14, at 9PM.
[-ecl]
===================================================================
TOPIC: Hercule Poirot (comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
Yes, I'm still bingeing, and still commenting.
In EVIL UNDER SUN, the daughter became a son(*), one character was
given a new back story that gave her an additional motive for
murder, a suicide attempt was dropped, Poirot's method for testing
his solution was omitted, but another character was involved in
their proof instead, and while some characters were eliminated,
two suspicious bird watchers were added. There's also a totally
new framing story about Hastings's new Argentinian restaurant,
including a new justification for Poirot's stay at the Jolly
Roger, now also a health spa, along with a bunch of extra
"humorous" scenes of the health spa aspect. Oh, and there was
gunfire.
* After I wrote that the daughter became a son, I realize that
these days that is ambiguous. What I mean is that the character
that was written as a daughter in the book, was written as a son
in the adaptation.
Again, in FIVE LITTLE PIGS there is a gun drawn at a key moment.
In DEATH ON THE NILE, the series continues its downward slide. In
the first five minutes we have a sex scene--not the sort of thing
you would find in Christie's novel--and a drug-taking scene. Yes,
Christie had reference to sex and to drugs, but she never had them
front and center, as it were. And they also made one of the
characters gay (even though he was clearly straight in the book).
[SPOILERS] MYSTERY ON THE BLUE TRAIN has major plot changes,
including a total restructuring of Van Aldin's family and
relationships, and the changing of the personality of one of the
characters. It also has the problem that one of the clues works
when it is read in a book, but not when it is heard spoken on
television (or on radio, for that matter). (It's like the reverse
of those jokes that rely on word ambiguities that don't work in
print: "Now is the winter of our discontent / Made glorious summer
by this sun of York;" has to commit to either "son" or "sun"--it
can't have it both ways. [END SPOILERS]
And by the time we get to CARDS ON THE TABLE, the series keeps the
characters but changes *every* person's background (even Poirot
has moved to a new apartment), and personality, and motive, and
ultimately changes both the murderer and the method. The same is
true of TAKEN AT THE FLOOD.
This may be obvious, but there are two types of Agatha Christie
murder mysteries: those in which the victim(s) are blameless, and
those in which you can't wait to see them bumped off. For example,
the dentist and the lady from India in ONE, TWO, BUCKLE MY SHOE
are blameless (the Greek perhaps not so much), while the mother in
APPOINTMENT WITH DEATH is so despicable that you can't wait to see
her dead.
Even Christie realized the distinction, because on occasion,
Poirot lets the murderer(s) go.
And I forgot to mention that first they changed the pace of the
theme music to something much slower and sadder (a minor key
rather than a major? I'm no musician), and then they dropped it
entirely for different music for each episode. [-ecl]
===================================================================
TOPIC: A.I. Documentaries (letter of comment by Richie Bielak)
In response to Paul S. R. Chisholm's comments on A.I.
documentaries in the 11/30/26 issue of the MT VOID, Richie Bielak
writes:
There is another documentary, that I think is more realistic about
current state of AI industry is called GHOST IN THE MACHINE. You
can see it on PBS:
https://www.pbs.org/independentlens/documentaries/
ghost-in-the-machine/
[-rb]
===================================================================
TOPIC: Facebook (letter of comment by Pete Rubinstein)
[The Facebook symbol of the lower-case 'f' in a circle has been
rendered here as [f], and other symbols in obvious fashions.)
In response to Evelyn's comments on Facebook in the 11/30/26 issue
of the MT VOID, Pete Rubinstein writes:
With respect to the Facebook issue:
According to Dom McMillan
[f] = Friends + updates + ads
But updates seem to get very trivial, so friends drop out, leaving
[f] = ads
We know that ads = Time * Money
Therefore, [f] = Time * Money
But in business Time = Money
Therefore, [f] = Money^2
But Money = sqrt(evil)
Therefore, Money^2 = evil
Therefore, [f] = evil
[-pr]
===================================================================
TOPIC: This Week's Reading (book comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
ROME, BLOOD, AND POLITICS: REFORM, MURDER AND POPULAR POLITICS IN
THE LATE REPUBLIC 133-70 BC by Gareth C. Sampson (Pen & Sword
Books, ISBN 978-1-473-88732-9) is another one of those books that
reminds one all too frequently of current politics. For starters,
one of the main issues in the late Roman Republic was citizenship,
in particular, whether non-Roman, Latinate and Italianate groups
should have Roman citizenship or not. Complicating this was what
is an early version of gerrymandering: citizens voted by "tribes",
with each tribe having an equal vote. The proposal in 90 B.C.E.
was that the current thirty-five tribes of Roman citizens would be
supplemented by ten tribes of the newer Latinate and Italianate
citizens. The result was that the tens of thousands of Roman
voters controlled 35 votes, while the several million new voters
controlled only 10 votes. (Actually, I suppose it's less like
gerrymandering and more like the situation in the United States
Senate, where 26 states with a total population of only 18 million
out of over 200 million can control the Senate. With the Electoral
College, it is possible for someone to be elected President with
less than 23% of the popular vote; see <
https://vividmaps.com/ how-to-become-u-s-president-with-less-than-23-of-the-votes/>.)
And since votes had to be cast in person, this further diluted
their power, meaning only the wealthiest among them could afford
to go to Rome to vote. (Again, there seem to be parallels with
absentee and mail-in ballots today.)
Apparently there was concern that even before this proposal that
since many men of Italian ancestry had been granted Roman
citizenship, how could you tell who was a Roman citizen? There was
no form of identification, and the citizen registers used for army
recruitment were no update very often. As Sampson phrases it,
among Roman citizens there was "the fear of 'immigrants' sharing
the spoils of their 'hard work'."
Another major issue was effectively term limits, with
(unsuccessful) attempts to prevent various officials from serving
consecutive terms, or from serving before having achieved the
necessary qualifications.
It is clear that these parallels do not escape Sampson, since he
will occasionally refer to them, such as when he says, "It is
useful to think of today's politicians and whether they are all
striving to address social and economic ills that genuinely exist
or whether a product is manufactured to fit their solution? For
Tiberius and his allies, it was merely enough that there was the
belief that this was true, that Italy was being overrun by hordes
of barbarous slaves and that the 'virtuous' Roman peasant was
being thrown off his land by unscrupulous aristocrats."
As usual, this book has plenty of misspellings and typos, enough
that other reviewers have commented on it. At one point Samson
writes, "Marius returned home a hero, hailed as the 'savour' of
the Republic'." On one page, he twice quotes a source as saying,
"When the Latins were going to kill the Consul Philippus on the
Alban Mount, Drusus warned him to be on his gourd." These are
signs of the unverified use of a spell-checker, which only flags
*non*-words, not the *wrong* words.
Sampson also scorns commas, writing, "No one was ever tried for
the murder of Drusus and the identity of the murderer or more
importantly, who ordered the death is lost to history." (This
needs a comma either after "or" or after "death".) Also, he
writes, "Here he seems to have allied himself, albeit temporarily
with Saturninus and Glaucia, forming a triumverate..." (Again,
this either needs a comma after "temporarily", or no comma before
"albeit", though the two commas are preferable.)
He also writes, "We know a number of measures that Saturninus
passed this year, but as is common, not the order in which they
were passed in." (I am reminded of the lyrics to "Live and Let
Die", which are often heard as, "In this ever-changing world in
which we live in", although apparently it is claimed to be "If
this ever-changing world in which we're livin'". The published
sheet music splits the difference: "If this ever-changing world in
which we live in".) [-ecl]
===================================================================
Evelyn C. Leeper
evelynchimelisleeper@gmail.com
Many alligators will be slain, but the swamp will
remain.
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2