• State of Decay REWATCH and REVIEW

    From The True Doctor@agamemnon@hello.to.NO_SPAM to rec.arts.drwho on Sat Nov 7 04:10:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.drwho

    The title of the story State of Decay perfectly sums up the JN-T era
    from start to finish.

    Just like with The Horns of Nimon, the roles and characters in State of
    Decay were not taken seriously and the story was turned into a
    pantomime, full of deliberate overacting and melodramatic caricatures
    from every actor except Tom Baker, Lalla Ward, and John Leeson.

    During this era the British film industry totally collapsed bringing
    British television down with it. Every actor who could actually act and
    play a role naturally left for the United States because they knew they
    could never build a career in this country outside of repertory theatre
    and the annual Christmas pantomime. The actors and directors that were
    left behind, were either too old, had no talent, or were young kids who couldn't handle the roles they aspired to, and once they gained
    experience and became any good would leave for the US as well. The same
    went for all the best writers. They all left the country and very little talent remained that could perform or write outside of theatre which is
    a style unsuited to television or film.

    Here is the plot, which, once again, only contains enough material for
    45 minutes.

    The Doctor and Romana try to find a habitable planet to visit which is complicated by the fact that not many planets exist in E-Space, but
    eventually they find one that they believe to posses a high level of technology. When the TARDIS lands and they step outside, the planet
    appears to host a society from the middle ages.

    The society is ruled by the overlords, a group of aristocrats who have
    somehow become vampires.

    The overloads regularly seek out tribute from the common people of the village, the only settlement on the planet, who are either recruited and trained as guards, or more likely, like with the vast majority of those
    taken, are drained of their blood to feed the vampire overlords and
    their master the Great One.

    The vampires are actually the command crew of the Earth rocket Hydrax
    which disappeared from N-Space along with the last survivor of the Great Vampires who the Time Lords fought a war with and defeated in the time
    when Rassilon was still young, after which the Time Lords abandoned
    waging wars.

    The villagers are the descendents of the ship's ordinary crew members,
    who have been bred as food for the vampire oveloards and the Great One
    for over one thousand years, until the time when he will be healed of
    his injuries sustained during the war with the Time Lords and rise again
    to take power again, which happens to be right now.

    The Doctor and Romana discover the village while the Doctor is
    investigating why the TARDIS and K9 detected a high level of technology
    on this medieval like planet.

    An informant who is the village's head man, whose son has was taken away earlier in the day by the guards along with other young villagers to be drained of their blood for food, contacts the Rebels on a 1980s looking
    mobile phone, and the Doctor and Romana are captured and taken to the
    Rebels' lair where the Doctor gets the ship's computer working again and discovers images of the ship's commanders in the database, who the
    Rebels identify as looking like the current overlords, who they first
    believe are descended from them, but are to find out later from the
    Doctor that they are the command crew themselves.

    The Doctor learns that the ordinary people on the planet, which consists
    of only this small village, have been deliberately left uneducated by
    the overlords, but the Rebels hope that by developing and learning
    science again from basic principles they can build a new and better
    society redeveloping their original technology so they can return home
    to Earth, after deposing the overlords.

    Meanwhile Adric who has stowed away onboard the TARDIS gets K9, who the
    Doctor has put on guard, to allow him to leave and finds the village,
    where he is made to wear a flimsy disguise by the headman's wife to
    avoid being taken by the overloads, but is discovered and taken by them
    to become one of them.

    The Doctor and Romana visit the tower of the overloads which has been
    built from the remains of their rocket ship, and are soon captured by them.

    Eventually the Doctor and Romana are rescued by the Rebels trailing
    behind them and the Doctor goes back to the TARDIS to find out about the
    Great Vampires, while Romana remains in the tower to look for Adric and
    finds that he is in the process of being turned into a vampire.

    Adric seems to betray Romana to the overloards to be sacrificed to the
    the Great Lord, since she as a Time Lord she is his greatest enemy, but
    the attempted betrayal is in fact part of Adric's plan to free Romana
    from the overlords' grasp by gaining their confidence. He fails.

    After finding out the history of the war between the Time Lords and the
    Great Vampires, the Doctor makes a short jump with the TARDIS to the
    lair of the Rebels to enlist their help to destroy the overlord vampires
    and their Great Lord before he can return to N-Space and take the lives
    of billions of souls to feed on.

    K9 and the Rebels take out the guards and the Doctor programmes one of
    the scout ships attached to the main rocket to launch upwards and then
    turn around going down again like a metal spike to spear the Great
    Vampire through the heart. The Great Vampire is thus destroyed and the overlords whose lives were prolonged by him turn into dust.

    The Doctor, Romana, and K9 depart along with Adric who they take with
    them as their new companion.

    Once again there is only enough material in this story for 45 minutes
    and the rest is padding. The first two episodes were not even necessary
    to move the story along.

    Even though the script was written by Terrance Dicks it was originally supposed to be for Season 15 and would have featured Leela as the
    companion, but after it had been rejected as too complicated, in favour
    of Horror of Fang Rock, JN-T decided to resurrect it and force major
    changes by Dicks to incorporate Adric and rewrite the part of Leela,
    making Romana scream and run in the manner of Sarah Jane, which does not
    fit her character.

    The manner of the acting and directing is theatrical pantomime and does
    not belong in any kind of serious drama. Humour is also forced into the
    story where it does not belong and done very badly by script editor
    Christoph H Bidmead who was nowhere near par with either Douglas Adams
    or Robert Holmes would have handled this kind of story much better.

    8/10
    --
    The True Doctor https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCngrZwoS0n21IRcXpKO79Lw

    "To be woke is to be uninformed which is exactly the opposite of what it stands for." --William Shatner

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From doctor@doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca (The Doctor) to rec.arts.drwho on Sat Nov 7 04:54:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.drwho

    In article <11cm8b4$34mv6$1@dont-email.me>,
    The True Doctor <agamemnon@hello.to.NO_SPAM> wrote:
    The title of the story State of Decay perfectly sums up the JN-T era
    from start to finish.

    Just like with The Horns of Nimon, the roles and characters in State of >Decay were not taken seriously and the story was turned into a
    pantomime, full of deliberate overacting and melodramatic caricatures
    from every actor except Tom Baker, Lalla Ward, and John Leeson.

    During this era the British film industry totally collapsed bringing
    British television down with it. Every actor who could actually act and
    play a role naturally left for the United States because they knew they >could never build a career in this country outside of repertory theatre
    and the annual Christmas pantomime. The actors and directors that were
    left behind, were either too old, had no talent, or were young kids who >couldn't handle the roles they aspired to, and once they gained
    experience and became any good would leave for the US as well. The same
    went for all the best writers. They all left the country and very little >talent remained that could perform or write outside of theatre which is
    a style unsuited to television or film.

    Here is the plot, which, once again, only contains enough material for
    45 minutes.

    The Doctor and Romana try to find a habitable planet to visit which is >complicated by the fact that not many planets exist in E-Space, but >eventually they find one that they believe to posses a high level of >technology. When the TARDIS lands and they step outside, the planet
    appears to host a society from the middle ages.

    The society is ruled by the overlords, a group of aristocrats who have >somehow become vampires.

    The overloads regularly seek out tribute from the common people of the >village, the only settlement on the planet, who are either recruited and >trained as guards, or more likely, like with the vast majority of those >taken, are drained of their blood to feed the vampire overlords and
    their master the Great One.

    The vampires are actually the command crew of the Earth rocket Hydrax
    which disappeared from N-Space along with the last survivor of the Great >Vampires who the Time Lords fought a war with and defeated in the time
    when Rassilon was still young, after which the Time Lords abandoned
    waging wars.

    The villagers are the descendents of the ship's ordinary crew members,
    who have been bred as food for the vampire oveloards and the Great One
    for over one thousand years, until the time when he will be healed of
    his injuries sustained during the war with the Time Lords and rise again
    to take power again, which happens to be right now.

    The Doctor and Romana discover the village while the Doctor is
    investigating why the TARDIS and K9 detected a high level of technology
    on this medieval like planet.

    An informant who is the village's head man, whose son has was taken away >earlier in the day by the guards along with other young villagers to be >drained of their blood for food, contacts the Rebels on a 1980s looking >mobile phone, and the Doctor and Romana are captured and taken to the >Rebels' lair where the Doctor gets the ship's computer working again and >discovers images of the ship's commanders in the database, who the
    Rebels identify as looking like the current overlords, who they first >believe are descended from them, but are to find out later from the
    Doctor that they are the command crew themselves.

    The Doctor learns that the ordinary people on the planet, which consists
    of only this small village, have been deliberately left uneducated by
    the overlords, but the Rebels hope that by developing and learning
    science again from basic principles they can build a new and better
    society redeveloping their original technology so they can return home
    to Earth, after deposing the overlords.

    Meanwhile Adric who has stowed away onboard the TARDIS gets K9, who the >Doctor has put on guard, to allow him to leave and finds the village,
    where he is made to wear a flimsy disguise by the headman's wife to
    avoid being taken by the overloads, but is discovered and taken by them
    to become one of them.

    The Doctor and Romana visit the tower of the overloads which has been
    built from the remains of their rocket ship, and are soon captured by them.

    Eventually the Doctor and Romana are rescued by the Rebels trailing
    behind them and the Doctor goes back to the TARDIS to find out about the >Great Vampires, while Romana remains in the tower to look for Adric and >finds that he is in the process of being turned into a vampire.

    Adric seems to betray Romana to the overloards to be sacrificed to the
    the Great Lord, since she as a Time Lord she is his greatest enemy, but
    the attempted betrayal is in fact part of Adric's plan to free Romana
    from the overlords' grasp by gaining their confidence. He fails.

    After finding out the history of the war between the Time Lords and the >Great Vampires, the Doctor makes a short jump with the TARDIS to the
    lair of the Rebels to enlist their help to destroy the overlord vampires
    and their Great Lord before he can return to N-Space and take the lives
    of billions of souls to feed on.

    K9 and the Rebels take out the guards and the Doctor programmes one of
    the scout ships attached to the main rocket to launch upwards and then
    turn around going down again like a metal spike to spear the Great
    Vampire through the heart. The Great Vampire is thus destroyed and the >overlords whose lives were prolonged by him turn into dust.

    The Doctor, Romana, and K9 depart along with Adric who they take with
    them as their new companion.

    Once again there is only enough material in this story for 45 minutes
    and the rest is padding. The first two episodes were not even necessary
    to move the story along.

    Even though the script was written by Terrance Dicks it was originally >supposed to be for Season 15 and would have featured Leela as the
    companion, but after it had been rejected as too complicated, in favour
    of Horror of Fang Rock, JN-T decided to resurrect it and force major
    changes by Dicks to incorporate Adric and rewrite the part of Leela,
    making Romana scream and run in the manner of Sarah Jane, which does not
    fit her character.

    The manner of the acting and directing is theatrical pantomime and does
    not belong in any kind of serious drama. Humour is also forced into the >story where it does not belong and done very badly by script editor >Christoph H Bidmead who was nowhere near par with either Douglas Adams
    or Robert Holmes would have handled this kind of story much better.

    8/10


    8 + 8 + 3.5

    19.5 /3

    6.5

    --
    The True Doctor https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCngrZwoS0n21IRcXpKO79Lw

    "To be woke is to be uninformed which is exactly the opposite of what it >stands for." --William Shatner

    --
    Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
    Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ; 31 years in the ISP business!
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2