• Re: Books Will Survive. The Harder Question Is Whether Reading Will.

    From Steve Hayes@hayesstw@telkomsa.net to alt.literature,alt.books,rec.arts.books on Sat Oct 31 06:35:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.books

    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 00:16:24 +0800, Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson <johann@myrkraverk.invalid> wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 3:53 AM, George J. Dance wrote:

    I read copiously, but I haven't read a book in over a decade. I still
    have some books, which I use for reference, and books of poetry, which I
    use to read individual poems, but I haven't even unpacked them since my
    last move. I think
    McLuhan was right, though ahead of his time; books have become obsolete.
    They're no longer the place people read for information or for
    entertainment.

    The primary value of books nowadays is as a keepsake; people buy books
    to keep them in their bookshelves or on their coffee tables, to show
    guests and visitors (or even themselves) how well-read they are.


    I disagree. Physical books still have value. Just, not the same value
    as before. I mostly read professional books in physical form, for a
    variety of reasons. The one I'm going to mention here is that I like to
    be able to learn things without being constantly in front of a screen.

    Fiction I can deal with in audiobook format, and that has some advantag-
    es over physical books. One of which is the space in the bookshelves.

    I prefer to read books in hard copy, because in electronic form
    (whether video or audio) they are primarily serial access. To refer to
    an earlier page or chapter it is much easier to find it in a printed
    book.

    I get most of my books in second-hand bookshops nowadays, partly
    because they are cheaper, and partly because I'm more likely to find
    something that I actually want to read and haven't read -- eg
    classics.

    For example, the last books my wife and I bought (over the last 3
    months) are:

    Amis, Kingsley. 1961 [1954] Lucky Jim.
    Braine, John. 1981 [1957] Room at the Top.
    George, Elizabeth. 2012. The Edge of Nowhere.
    MacBride, Stuart. 2018. A Dark so Deadly.
    McLachlan, G.R.; Liversidge, R. 1982 [1940] Roberts Birds of South
    Africa.
    Penny, Louise. 2011. The Murder Stone.
    Updike, John. 1978 [1963] The Centaur.

    All second hand; all, except the Roberts, paperback.

    Since buying them I have read the Amis, the Braine and the Updike and
    am now reading the MacBride.

    A lot of people read e-books. That is merely a /technical difference/, >between physical books on paper and the e-reader screen.

    I read ebooks only when hard copy is unobtainable, or too expensive,
    and it must be a book that I really want to read, but cannot get
    elsewhere.

    These are usually scholarly books, which are expensive anyway, and
    hard to find. The only ebook I have read this year is:

    Salter, G. Connor. 2026. The Other Inklings.

    To get hard copy I would have had to order it from overseas, and the
    cost of sending it, and the customs duties etc, would have been as
    much as, if not more than, the cost of the book itself.

    I don't know who McLuhan was, nor why he thought books would become ob- >solete, but he was wrong.

    Marshall McLuhan was a Canadian who studied the sociology of
    communication, and is best known for his study of the effects of the
    medium of communication on the message. His book "The Medium is the
    Massage" is short and readable (and copiously illustrated). He didn't
    actually say that books were obsolete, but he did say wthat printing
    was the first instance of mass production, and that the advent of
    printed books changed they way people saw the world.

    He said that broadcast TV changed the way people saw the world in a
    different way -- events that people read about in newspapers weeks
    after they had happened (a battle won or lost, an earthquake that
    killed thousands, etc) could now be seen around the world in real
    time.

    But we are now in the age of the podcast, and I don't think he foresaw
    that (I *hate* podcasts), and the age of the podcast is itself rapidly
    giving way to the age of the LLM.








    Best wishes, and happy reading!
    --
    Steve Hayes from Tshwane, South Africa
    Web: http://www.khanya.org.za/stevesig.htm
    Blog: http://methodius.blogspot.com
    E-mail - see web page, or parse: shayes at dunelm full stop org full stop uk --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson@johann@myrkraverk.invalid to alt.literature,alt.books,rec.arts.books on Sat Oct 31 16:13:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.books

    On 10/31/2026 12:35 PM, Steve Hayes wrote:
    On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 00:16:24 +0800, Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson <johann@myrkraverk.invalid> wrote:

    On 10/29/2026 3:53 AM, George J. Dance wrote:

    I read copiously, but I haven't read a book in over a decade. I still
    have some books, which I use for reference, and books of poetry, which I >>> use to read individual poems, but I haven't even unpacked them since my
    last move. I think
    McLuhan was right, though ahead of his time; books have become obsolete. >>> They're no longer the place people read for information or for
    entertainment.

    The primary value of books nowadays is as a keepsake; people buy books
    to keep them in their bookshelves or on their coffee tables, to show
    guests and visitors (or even themselves) how well-read they are.


    I disagree. Physical books still have value. Just, not the same value
    as before. I mostly read professional books in physical form, for a
    variety of reasons. The one I'm going to mention here is that I like to
    be able to learn things without being constantly in front of a screen.

    Fiction I can deal with in audiobook format, and that has some advantag-
    es over physical books. One of which is the space in the bookshelves.

    I prefer to read books in hard copy, because in electronic form
    (whether video or audio) they are primarily serial access. To refer to
    an earlier page or chapter it is much easier to find it in a printed
    book.

    Yes, this is something I've noticed also. In addition, I can think of
    several additions to an e-book reader, audio, or video player to make
    referring to material easier -- note the timestamped YouTube videos help
    when we want to make a point -- but there's no such thing as a built in reference systems in these. Nothing like an author or editor supplied
    index. [Though YT can be said to have a table of contents now.]

    Maybe it's the /youth/ of the medium, and people have not put serious scholarship to the study of videos, nor audio recordings yet? I don't
    know.

    Side note: some people may think that auto-transcripts are sufficient to
    refer to these things, but I disagree.

    I get most of my books in second-hand bookshops nowadays, partly
    because they are cheaper, and partly because I'm more likely to find something that I actually want to read and haven't read -- eg
    classics.

    I also buy second hand books, both professionally, and fictionally.
    And do so from abroad as well. I am lucky enough to live in a country
    without any additional customs duties on books, so it's merely the book
    and shipping. [Something you remarked on below.]

    At the end, it's a matter of my budget once I discover a book I want to
    buy.

    For example, the last books my wife and I bought (over the last 3
    months) are:

    Amis, Kingsley. 1961 [1954] Lucky Jim.
    Braine, John. 1981 [1957] Room at the Top.
    George, Elizabeth. 2012. The Edge of Nowhere.
    MacBride, Stuart. 2018. A Dark so Deadly.
    McLachlan, G.R.; Liversidge, R. 1982 [1940] Roberts Birds of South
    Africa.
    Penny, Louise. 2011. The Murder Stone.
    Updike, John. 1978 [1963] The Centaur.

    All second hand; all, except the Roberts, paperback.

    I'll just add that I like to read on the move -- I believe I've mention-
    ed that elsewhere -- for which the only reasonable medium is audiobooks.


    Since buying them I have read the Amis, the Braine and the Updike and
    am now reading the MacBride.

    A lot of people read e-books. That is merely a /technical difference/,
    between physical books on paper and the e-reader screen.

    I read ebooks only when hard copy is unobtainable, or too expensive,
    and it must be a book that I really want to read, but cannot get
    elsewhere.

    These are usually scholarly books, which are expensive anyway, and
    hard to find. The only ebook I have read this year is:

    Salter, G. Connor. 2026. The Other Inklings.

    To get hard copy I would have had to order it from overseas, and the
    cost of sending it, and the customs duties etc, would have been as
    much as, if not more than, the cost of the book itself.

    I don't know who McLuhan was, nor why he thought books would become ob-
    solete, but he was wrong.

    Marshall McLuhan was a Canadian who studied the sociology of
    communication, and is best known for his study of the effects of the
    medium of communication on the message. His book "The Medium is the
    Massage" is short and readable (and copiously illustrated). He didn't actually say that books were obsolete, but he did say wthat printing
    was the first instance of mass production, and that the advent of
    printed books changed they way people saw the world.

    He said that broadcast TV changed the way people saw the world in a
    different way -- events that people read about in newspapers weeks
    after they had happened (a battle won or lost, an earthquake that
    killed thousands, etc) could now be seen around the world in real
    time.

    But we are now in the age of the podcast, and I don't think he foresaw
    that (I *hate* podcasts), and the age of the podcast is itself rapidly
    giving way to the age of the LLM.

    Well, I have not delved deeply into podcasts yet. I've dipped my toes
    in one or two, but don't listen habitually. For some people, it has re-
    placed /talk radio/ while driving around, or otherwise commuting.

    So the phenomenon has been around for a while, people phoning radio sta-
    tions and talking about this and that, and -- I believe in the previous
    century -- most listeners were professional drivers or the like, people
    who could listen while working, but maybe not participating in the dis- cussion.

    I admit I was never much a fan of talk radio, and have therefore not
    moved my listening habits into podcasts instead. I remember having to
    listen to some of it while working because I did not control the radio
    at the time, but that was some time in the 90s.

    So, while I have not yet read the book you mentioned, I would have ex
    pected a chapter on talk radio. I'll see if can get a copy soon-ish but
    make no promises when I'll put it in my active reading pile.

    [I added it to my /saved for later/ basket at Abebooks, but I may as
    well see if I can find a copy in a used book store locally first.]

    On the L.L.M. front, I view that as a /lossy compression/. Somewhat
    similar to mp3s vs. CDs -- in concept if not experience.

    A lot of people are now using them to /write stories/, or even news ar-
    ticles, and such; but I take the view that if a human didn't write it
    for humans to read, I have no business reading it. Especially for fic-
    tion or entertainment.

    They are convenient to find things online, or find out about well known
    things; and that's partly because search engines have gotten worse in
    the last two decades. They are not convenient if you want to research
    anything /outside of human knowledge/. For that, people still need to
    put in the hard work. I believe Sam Altman is not very keen on adver-
    tising that fact.

    And no L.L.M. will ever interject itself into a Usenet discussion, and
    point out that some part of the discussion is in fact not some universal
    rule based on a lived experience, because the L.L.M. isn't alive and do-
    esn't have experience outside of what's in it's training set.

    Unlike say, an insufferable human know-it-all.

    Nor can it offer its own opinion on the entertainment value of podcasts
    vs. talk radio. [I don't have one myself.]


    I'll let that be it for this alt.literature monologue. Best wishes, and
    happy reading!
    --
    Johann | email: invalid -> com | http://www.myrkraverk.com/blog/
    I'm not from the Internet, I just work there. | via Easynews.com https://bsky.app/profile/myrkraverk.bsky.social | for ( ;; ) _:;
    Federated at https://fed.brid.gy/bsky/myrkraverk.bsky.social
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2