I doubt that I'll see "The Magician's Nephew", mainly because it
seems that they are going to treat it as the first in the series, and
also because I've heard that they are moving it to the 1950s. If
you're going to interfere with the story that much, why use someone
else's story and mess with it? Why not be creative and do your own.
I'll avoid it for the same reason I avoid remakes of movies where the original was good. Rather tell your own story than mess with someone
else's.
On Tue, 13 Oct 2026 22:19:56 +0200
Steve Hayes <hayesstw@telkomsa.net> wrote:
I doubt that I'll see "The Magician's Nephew", mainly because it
seems that they are going to treat it as the first in the series, and
also because I've heard that they are moving it to the 1950s. If
you're going to interfere with the story that much, why use someone
else's story and mess with it? Why not be creative and do your own.
I'll avoid it for the same reason I avoid remakes of movies where the
original was good. Rather tell your own story than mess with someone
else's.
I can sympathize; it is true that *effectively* adapting a story from
one medium to another necessitates changes, but I do rankle a bit at
the ones that seem unnecessary to me.
That said, there was no chance Corporate Hollywood was *ever* going to
do this one unless some Very Eccentric Director dragged them into it
kicking and screaming - and it's a basic fact that when you have a
strong creative personality tackling an adaptation of an existing work, you're going to get at least some of their own personal stamp on the
result. Peter Jackson's LOTR films are a good example - they're a very earnest attempt to do right by the story, but there are still aspects
that have Jackson written all over them. Some of those I may enjoy,
some I definitely don't, but even if it's not the version of LOTR that
lives in my head, I do feel that it's the best version we were ever
*going* to get out of 2000s Hollywood.
So, at least 'til the film's out and I can draw my own conclusions,
I'll cross my fingers and hope that this ends up being the best version
of the story that 2020s Hollywood was ever *going* to do, especially considering I've been waiting for them to do it *at all* since I first
heard the story as a child and for most of my life it's seemed wholly unlikely that they ever *would.* Gerwig is certainly not the type of
director who's merely a hired hand taking notes from a boardroom full
of suits attempting to calculate for maximum marketability; I may not
get the version of the story *I* want, but I'm at least interested to
see a self-assuredly Weird take from an interesting creator.
(And I *do* have to respect a fellow lover of the '70s prog aesthetic.)
And I feel reasonably hopeful that, whatever my quibbles with the
result, she'll make a good-faith effort at capturing the core of
the story; God knows that a fable about a child learning to choose
decency and empathy over the temptations of domineering sociopaths
presenting themselves in the guise of Rational Self-Interest and
Manifest Destiny feels unsettlingly timely as of the last 10-20 years.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:59:00 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |